Full text of "1948"
BETRAYAL BY INACTION
By WM. I. SIEGEL
ZEBULUN BUILDS A MERCHANT
MARINE
By LEO GLASSMAN
THE JEW'S MYSTIC FLIGHT
By JACOB S. MINKIN
LIFE IN PALESTINE THIS MINUTE
By MEYER LEVIN
THE DUBNER MAGGID
By LEON SPITZ
MARTYR TO THE A-BOMB
By PHIL GLANZER
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
ORUM LECTURES «* DISCUSSIONS
MONDAY EVENINGS AT 8:30
FEBRUARY 2nd
D E B A T E
"MUST WE FIGHT RUSSIA?"
•
Speakers
WM. HENRY
CHAMBERLAIN
Writer, former foreign correspon-
dent, author of "Russia's Iron Age,"
"The Russian Engima."
DR. EM!L LENGYEL
Feature writer and foreign corre-
spondent for the New York Times
since 19*27. Teacher of history and
economics at X. V. l T .
FEBRUARY 9th
Round Table Discussion Group
"WAS WALLACE JUSTIFIED
IN FORMING A THIRD
PARTY?"
Negative
MAX HERZFELD
Prominent attorney and member of the
Center Board of Trustees.
Affirmative
LESTER BLICKSTKIX
COURSE OF LECTURES
Every Wed. Evening in February
"THE PSYCHOLOGY OF
EFFECTIVE LIVING"
by
DR. LUTHER
E. WOODWARD
Noted Psychologist; Field
Consultant, National Com-
mittee of Mental Hygiene.
Formerly with the Bureau of
Child Guidance of the Board
of Education. Dr. Wood-
ward conducts the radio pro-
gram "Inquiring Parent"
over WMCA Sundays at
12:45 p.m.
February 4th
"What Makes for Peace
of Mind?"
February I Ith
"How Can Parents Adjust to
Their Children's Growth?"
February 18th
"How to Maintain Healthy
Family Relations?"
February 25th
"How to Age Successfully"
All Welcome
FEBRUARY 16th
PROF. SCOTT NEARING
Noted Sociologist, Educator and
Economist. Formerly connected
with Swathmore College and
Toledo University.
Subject
"IS WORLD WAR III
INEVITABLE?"
•
FEBRUARY 23rd
Washington's Birthday
NO FORUM
•
MARCH 1st
DEBATE ON
"DO WE HAVE A FREE PRESS
IN AMERICA?"
Speakers
TULLY NETTLETON
Associate Editor of the
"Christian Science Monitor"
IRVING GILMAN
Research Director of the
"American News Guide"
Admission to Forum Lectures (except when a special charge is made) is free to Center members.
All others are charged 40f (incl. tax).
DOORS TO THE AUDITORIUM WILL BE CLOSED PROMPTLY AT 9:15
AND NO ONE WILL BE ADMITTED AFTER THAT HOUR.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Vol. XXIX
THE decision of the United Nations
to partition Palestine resulted in a
moment of high moral exaltation
rare in the international annals of our
modern world. It was of transcendent
importance in its specific purpose in that
it proposed to mark the end of the two
thousand years of Jewish homelessness.
It was perhaps — if that be possible — of
even greater importance in that it was the
first agreement reached in the United
Nations on a problem of major conse-
quence, and thus gave foundation to the
hope that the United Nations could in
other problems dispel conflict and achieve
unity. All men of good will welcomed
the partition agreement as a significant
contribution to the building of a new
world order and as an augury of better
times to come in the lives of men and
nations.
•
There has, therefore, been a corres-
pondingly great feeling of loss and defeat
because of the subsequent failure of the
United Nations to bring to practical
realization the plan projected by the par-
tition decision. In a schedule where time
is of the essence, time has been frittered
away. In a condition where firmness to-
wards dissidence was the first considera-
tion, there has been an indecision nothing
short of cowardly. On a scene where
good faith among nations has been essen-
tial we have witnessed a chicanery which
even the past record of some of the ex-
hibitors has not led us to suspect. In
this role of dishonor certain nations are
conspicuous. They should be known.
Other nations, not excluding our own,
while subject to lesser criticism, are
JANUARY, 1948 — SHEBAT, 5708
nevertheless so much at fault as to com-
pel an admission of blame.
Here are the small, weak, backward,
despotic and semi-medieval countries of
the Arab League, themselves members of
the United Nations and thus pledged to
a faithful acquiescence in the decisions
of the majority, truculently refusing to
accept that will and that decision and
belligerently announcing their determina-
tion to bring about, if necessary to their
plans, the very destruction of the United
Nations itself. Can it be doubted that
in this program of violence, death and
destruction these countries are encour-
aged by the example of a greater, if less
open and shamelessly bare-faced, partici-
pant? Does any reasonable person be-
lieve that the Arab countries would dare
to risk the displeasure and punishment of
the major powers were they not insti-
gated by the direct, if hidden, command
and encouragement of the British power-
crats? Have they not had sufficient en-
couragement in the anti-Semitism of
Bevin as Prime Minister, and the subtle
dialectics of Cadogan in the Councils of
the United Nations? "The hands are
the hands of Esau but the voice is the
voice of Jacob." (With apologies not
alone to Jacob but even to Esau.)
That the British are partners in the
Arab reaction is so clear that even he
who runs rapidly can read readily. The
record is replete with proof which has
both the systolic and diastolic rhythm of
a single heartbeat of purpose. England
sends to Trans-Jordania and Iraq muni-
tions in the fulfillment of conveniently
made treaty obligations, but at the same
time disarms the Haganah. England re-
No. 20
fuses to inform the world of its plan for
departure from Palestine, but England
still hunts down displaced persons by its
mighty ships and its far-ranging air
fleets. England protests the inviolability
of its national honor, yet English officers
not only wink at the murder of Chalut-
zim and the destruction of kibbutzim,
but submit to the indignity of search and
identification by Arab marauders. The
English know their scriptures well indeed,
but they have learned to quote it with
devilish ingenuity for Satan's purposes.
•
Nor have we any particular reason to
be proud of the stand of our own gov-
ernment in this matter. It is true that,
after some backing and filling in the
wake of a hesitation which shamed many
citizens of the United Nations, our gov-
ernment finally took a stand in favor of
partition. It was a stand which would
have done greater honor to the men in
charge of our national policy had it been
more forthright and earlier in decision;
but at least and at last it was a stand
for right and justice. However, what
has followed has gone far to nullify the
warm feeling of admiration earned by the
original action. The United States has
treaty rights in Palestine by virtue of its
being a signatory to the Treaty of San
Remo. We are therefore vitally inter-
ested in the continued violation by the
British of their obligations as the manda-
tory. Nevertheless, we have said not one
word of protest to the British. We are
vocal in admonishing other governments
concerning actual and even alleged
breaches of treaty. We are not at all
hesitant in applying to these governments
strong and condemnatory characteriza-
BETRAYAL BY INACTION
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Greenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Goodstein, Treasurer Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthat, D.D., D.H.L, Rabbi Manuel Salhman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
4
"JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES"
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
FUTILE BASKETS FOR THE BEREAVED
tions. There appears however to be some-
thing sacrosanct in the minds of our
State Department about British actions.
There is an almost colonial dependence by
Washington on Downing Street. It is
as though the Revolution and the War
of 1812 had never been fought, and al-
most as if the British had saved us in
World Wars 1 and II instead of we hav-
ing rescued them from utter destruction.
Of course, there may be good consid-
erations of international policy involved,
too esoteric for ordinary minds to follow.
But certainly if this subservience is tested
on the basis of right and justice and on
the scale of the interests of the United
States, the policy of our State Depart-
ment remains mystifying on the one hand
and unjustifiable on the other.
No one knows better than our own
State Department the fact that the de-
fense of Jewish rights and Jewish lives
in Palestine rests ultimately on the
Haganah. The fiction of British protec-
tion is exploded by the day-to-day record
of British inaction. At the same time,
no one knows better than our State De-
partment the fact that the Pan-Arab
League countries and the British are ship-
ping arms eastward for the express and
known purpose of use by the Mufti's
hoodlums. To issue an arms embargo
against the Haganah at this point and
under these conditions as our State De-
partment has done is a stupidity too great
to be merely stupid, and one which com-
pels the conclusion that it is designed
first to cripple the Haganah, and, even-
tually, to destroy the Jewish State before
it has a chance to draw its first breath.
There must be an end — and an im-
mediate end — to this situation. The fol-
lowing steps must be taken without
further debate:
1. The Haganah must be armed by the
United Nations or by the United States,
whichever can do the job more quickly
and efficiently; 2. The British must be
compelled either to protect Palestine or
to leave Palestine long before the May
1st deadline; 3. The Arab League govern-
ments must, under penalty of economic
sanction and, if necessary, by military
force, be warned against a continuance
of their revolt against the United
Nations.
This must be done today and not to-
IHAVE unfortunately frequent occa-
sions to visit people during "Shivah,"
when they observe the week of
mourning. Again and again I am struck
by the sight of huge baskets of fruit,
candies and other delicacies, sent by good
friends to show their sympathy for these
sorrowing folk.
I wonder how many of these well-
meaning people ever give a thought to
the wastefulness of this gesture. In most
of the cases the people do not need these
delicacies, and certainly do not want to
derive any enjoyment from something
that is linked with their sorrow. Much
of these offerings usually go to waste,
and in many cases, they are sent to some
institution.
A nobler gesture could be made in such
circumstances, one that would have a far
greater meaning to the bereaved and
would be an effective way of perpetuat-
ing the name of the deceased. If these
friends were to plant a tree on Palestine
Jewish National Fund land in memory of
the departed one, how much finer, how
much more useful, this action would be.
Imagine the feeling of the mourners upon
receiving the certificate from the Jewish
National Fund with the name of their
dear departed inscribed upon it, and tell-
ing of a tree that will blossom in the
sacred soil of the new Judea and bear
the name of their beloved one. Certainly
the act would be far more appreciated
than the receipt of another basket of
food.
I do not mean to limit the suggestion
to the Jewish National Fund. The offer-
morrow, with sincere meaning and not
idle gesture, by friendly officials and not
by hardened enemies. Jews demand it;
all decent people demand it; the present
safety of the world demands it; and,
above all, any possibility for the emer-
ing may be a contribution to any worthy
cause, to any fine institution to which the
departed one was devoted in life. We
sometimes receive a gift in our Center
Library in memory of someone who died.
The family is notified of this act, and I
am confident that they experience a joy
in the midst of their sorrow that the
name of their beloved one will be blessed
by readers of these books for years to
come. I often see a request, included in
the death announcement published in the
press, that friends who wish to honor
the memory of the deceased should make
a contribution to some specified charity
that was close to the heart of the one
who has passed on. Such acts have mean-
ing. They are productive of good. They
help to keep alive the name of the dead.
It is high time that people of intelli-
gence drop this senseless practice of
wasteful spending now in vogue in order
to express a sacred feeling of sympathy
with one's loss. But let the motive which
prompted the rise of this custom be util-
ized in a manner worthy of the solemnity
of the occasion. Let us unite the name
of the dead with a cause that brings
blessedness to the living, and then in
truth will the name and memory of the
departed ones live on in the hearts of
grateful people.
gence of a decent international relation-
ship demands it. Woe upon us all in this
and in future generations if those in
power remain deaf to the call of these
demands.
WM. I. SlEGEL.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
LIFE IN PALESTINE THIS MINUTE
Meyer Levin, Jewish TelegrapJric
Agency war correspondent and a
well-known novelist, was arrested by
the British authorities recently when
he arrived at Haifa, Palestine, aboard
the blockade-runner, "Yon Can't
Frighten Us." He was later released
on bail of $4,000. This is his story
of life in Palestine as it is lived now.
From the comparatively safe vantage-
point of the Haifa jail, I have been assim-
ilating the Haifa situation. I was locked
up here by the British for arriving with a
film of the crew on an illegal ship. (The
vessel bore a Hebrew name meaning You
Can't Frighten Us.)
The jail is in the Jewish center, half-
way up Mount Carmel, amidst a strategic
area for Arab snipers. The British occupy
the surrounding rooftops, shooting into
the Arab section near the port area.
Therefore, rifle-firing and short bursts
from automatic weapons are going on all
around us night and day.
Nevertheless, the most cheerful atmos-
phere prevails in the jail. The friendly
police stop at my cell door and give the
latest news. A 20-year-old policeman
tells of his effort to enjoy a holiday last
night: "I went down to a cafe in the
port area with a pal. We settled down
for a third beer when the Armv mortars
began firing overhead into an Arab
snipers' post, so we pulled stakes, heading
for the Jewish section in Carmel.
"I knew a nice music spot in Hcrzl
Street, but no sooner had I opened the
door when I saw a girl whose ankle had
been messed up by a stray bullet. After
evacuating her, I again tried to find a
peaceful spot. But a tracer started across
the street so I gave up and headed for
the barracks."
Meanwhile, riflemen in a neighboring
building were firing. I asked how they
knew where the target was. They don't,
replied the police, they fire at random in
the air.
It is impossible to arrive at a wholly
accurate description of such a situation.
However, stray bullets yesterday killed
a woman hanging out the washing on the
roof block of our jail.
Other police explain that they are only
shooting down at the Arabs who are
shooting at the Army while Haganah
(the Jewish unofficial militia) is in the
middle shooting at both. This scarcely
illumines conditions. Haganah also as-
serts that their men have been shot at
by both Arabs and the British.
In our cell, two 17-year-old youths arc
awaiting trial on charges of carrying
arms. They are typical of the situation.
(At this moment, a passerby at the cell
door says that on Shapiro Street near here
a girl was just killed.) Our Haganah
youths raised their heads, muttered curses
and returned to their reading. They were
here because they had been stationed to
protect a Jewish house in a narrow street
bordering on the Arab quarter. For
three days the boys held out, until finally
the roof of their house was burning and
they ran out. On seeing the police, they
dropped their weapons. In the curious
Palestine tangle, these home-defenders
were arrested for carrying arms.
They are the perfect Sabra (Palestine-
born) type, six-footers with undisturbed
souls. By a coincidence, the father of one
of them was brought in the next day
charged with possession of a revolver
found in a truck in which he was riding
to help Jews move from an Arab area.
The father is a dock worker.
At noon the wife and mother arrived
for a visit, but not as the traditional
wailing Jewess. This Palestinian woman
was brisk and courageous, her face radi-
ant with pride in her sturdy son and the
brave, muscular father.
Under the regulations against terror-
ists, it would be possible to receive life
sentences, even execution, for conviction
of carrying arms, but the British Sum-
mary Court is at least appreciative of the
difference between these home-defenders
and the terrorists. The father, as a test
case, was fined JO pounds (about $200).
The youth, his son, is still awaiting trial.
The general complaint of Haganah is
that the British do not make an effort to
afford sufficient protection, while concen-
trating on self-protection. The situation
is doubtless most difficult for the British
soldiers, who are not to be blamed for a
dislike of risking their lives a few months
before their evacuation from Palestine.
A Dramatic and Poignant
Account of Violent History
By MEYER LEVIN
However, ugly talcs persist, such as the
report that a Sten gun was taken by the
Army from the Jews and recaptured a
few days later by the Jews from Arab
hands.
The Jews also tell how a special type
of grenade known to belong only to Jew-
ish forces had passed to Arab possession
after being confiscated by the British.
The Jews generally declare that they
are well able to take care of the situa-
tion, but "meantime we arc bleeding with
our arms tied. It is certain the British
hope to weaken us in the next few
months so that we will beg them to re-
main to protect us."
My own impression, from my cell, is
more depressing than that of the Pales-
tinians who seem to be exhilarated by the
crisis. I witnessed attacks of terror last
year, but when I arrived this time and
was jailed I read how a chap I knew,
named Robert Stern, who wrote for the
Palestine Post, was shot dead while walk-
ing 200 yards to his home from his office.
I felt cold.
Then I read an item about an attack
on the Negev colony of Revivim, the
founding of which I helped to film last
year for "My Father's House." Three of
the boys taking part have been killed.
The Palestinians are braver than I.
They say that naturally they must ex-
pect final blood payments, but at last
the Jews would have their own country.
The stretch of main road between Tel
Aviv and Jerusalem, which is normally
an hour's drive, gave me the most hair-
raising four hours since I accompanied
a United States Army advance-patrol into
German territory, seeking contact with
the Russian troops.
On that occasion, however, I rode in a
convoy of eight vehicles, six of which
were tanks, while yesterday I rode in a
seven-vehicle convoy of buses and auto-
mobiles, feeling utterly exposed.
I was compelled to risk my neck to
drive up to Jerusalem and try to retrieve
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
6
the films I took aboard the "You Can't
Frighten Us," together with my cameras,
which the British authorities confiscated.
The prize place in the convoy was a seat
in two armor-plated buses recently put
into service by the Jewish Line, while the
remainder of the convoy consisted of one
unarmored bus and ordinary automobiles.
The last passenger to climb aboard was
a girl who carried a string-tied box which
she carefully set down on the floor of the
bus, explaining that it contained cakes.
I sincerely hoped that she belonged in the
ranks of Haganah, and that her cakes
were not the inedible kind.
At certain points the convoy avoided
the main road, circling Arab areas and
sometimes crossing through fields and
down improvised lanes. Once we held
our breaths as we drove directly through
an Arab village and saw an idler with a
revolver butt sticking out of his pocket.
Arab children mimicked the chatter of
machine-guns as we passed.
At this juncture, a small truck con-
taining a few riflemen of the official Jew-
ish Settlement Police joined our party,
escorting the convoy as far as Latrun,
which is half the distance to the Holy
City. This area is ideal for snipers since
orange groves and high lanes of cactus
line the road.
From an isolated patch of woods we
were surprised to see a hooded lad hold-
ing a Sten gun merrily wave us on. The
bus driver explained that formerly the
woods hid Arab snipers.
Just as we reached Latrun, an Arab
bus overtook our convoy and halted
among our vehicles at the British barrier
where Tommies perfunctorily examined
the Jews and Arabs for arms. Here we
hit the main road and saw a huge British
Army convoy containing Bren carriers
and even cannon, and we wondered why
it could not spare a single vehicle for a
civilian convoy.
We now entered a hairpin road wind-
ing into the hills, every turn possibly
harboring an ambush. At each turn a
Haganah lad and the girl who were with
us recited tales of Jews killed here last
week or in the course of previous
troubles. Since this stretch of road is
the most dangerous of all, the transport
companies risk only their worst cars, and
there was an added hazard when one of
our machines broke down and the entire
convoy waited a half hour in an exposed
spot. We congratulated ourselves that
the day was drizzly, thus reducing the
snipers' visibility.
When the line of cars crawled into
Jerusalem, every head in the streets was
turned toward us and we could watch
the news travelling cheerfully that the
"convoy made it today!"
It is tragic to reflect that among Pal-
estine's main cities, where busloads used
LETTERS TO
A Neutrality Clause for the Jewish
Constitution?
Editor, Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
AN ARTICLE in the December
Review regarding the inclusion of
a neutrality clause in the constitution of
the projected Jewish State appears to have
been in error. This conclusion may be
reached as the result of some correspon-
dence carried on with the Jewish Agency
for Palestine.
Enclosed please find a copy of that
correspondence, which indicates that such
a clause was not included.
Mr. Moshe Shertok
% The Jewish Agency for Palestine
16 East 66th St.
New York City
Dear Sir: —
In a statement made by Dr. Nahum
Goldman and reported in the Brooklyn
Jewish Center Review for the month of
December it was indicated that the new
constitution would include a clause bind-
ing the Jewish state to permanent neu-
trality. This clause it was indicated
would be modelled after some portion of
the Swiss constitution.
As a member of the Zionist Organiza-
tion of America and as one who has spent
his life in the study and teaching of his-
tory as it relates to antiquity I feel called
upon to object very strongly with regard
to the promulgation of any clause such
as that described above. I have no knowl-
edge of the existence of such a clause in
the Swiss constitution which can be
taken as a model, for I believe that the
neutrality of Switzerland was guaranteed
at the Congress of Vienna. At any rate,
to depart every quarter hour, the traffic
is now reduced to two such tiny convoys
daily, plus a few convoys of food-trucks.
Jerusalem immediately produces the
grimmest effect of people apprehensive
over the food and fuel shortages. The
cafes and movies are nearly empty and
the streets are deserted after dark as com-
pletely as during the curfew. Haifa is
optimistic, and Tel Aviv is belligerent;
but the nerves of Jerusalem are frayed
by the war.
THE REVIEW
that action of the Swiss at the time of
the- Neuchatel disagreement with Prussia
is sufficient to indicate that this provi-
sion, if it does exist, is not operative. As
further proof of this the state of the
Army in Switzerland is worthy of note.
The practice of universal male conscrip-
tion there has been in force for many
years.
Such a clause, however, limiting the
action of the sovereign in a military sense,
is in existence in the latest Japanese Con-
stitution, with which I am quite familiar.
This clause was inserted into the Japan-
ese Constitution as a result of the recent
defeat suffered by Japanese arms. Since
I am quite familiar with the mood of the
Japanese and the applicability of this
clause I feel quite certain that not too
much weight should be given to it.
Because of these facts I feel called upon
to express my disapproval of the pro-
posed clause. It seems to indicate a lack
of foresight on the part of the drafters
of the new constitution. We must not
underrate our neighbors, and we cer-
tainly should not take the defeatist atti-
tude which was evidenced in the state-
ment of Dr. Goldman as reported. De-
spite the fact that Palestine in the past
has been a land in which the Jews as a
whole have very strong pacifist ten-
dencies, they — that is, the people and the
drafters of the new constitution — should
not be blinded into placing themselves
in an unfavorable position.
I hope that the viewpoint expressed
in this letter, which I believe is shared
by many others, will be given careful
consideration before definite action is
taken ' Howard L. Adelson
[Continued on next page]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
7
Reply from the Jewish Agency
Dear Mr. Adelson:
I am obliged to you for your letter
of December 26 with reference to the
report which appeared in the press some
days ago of an interview said to have
been given by Dr. Nahum Goldman in
London, suggesting international neutral-
ity for the Jewish State.
I think that there are many who will
agree with the criticism expressed by you,
and I would merely like, at this stage,
to assure you that no authoritative deci-
sion along the lines indicated has been
taken by any responsible Jewish body,
nor am I sure that Dr. Goldman's spec-
ulations on the subject were correctly
reported.
We are making further inquiry in this
connection.
Arthur Lurie, Director
The Jew No Different From
Other People
Editor, Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
I write this letter as a member of the
Center to protest against a common prac-
tice in Jewish circles.
In the article, "Heine as a Jew," which
appeared in the November Review, the
author overlooked the significance of the
psychological motives in Heine's life, but
nevertheless I thoroughly enjoyed read-
ing it.
But he writes "But in one way Heine
was 'Jewish' throughout his life ... in
his profound interest in the social strug-
gles of his days, in the attempts of the
oppressed to get rid of their oppres-
sors ..."
The point I wish to make is this:
There is nothing inherent in the Jew —
since he is no different than others —
which would make him fight oppressors
more so than other people.
Any people who have been oppressed
for generations are conscious of such
feelings. Heine's whole life consisted of
struggle.
But one can't say that Jews, as such,
are one way or another.
It's anti-Semitism from the reverse
side, so to speak — it's pro-Semitism,
which is just as dangerous when based
on bad thinking.
— A Reader
MARTYR TO
AT a recent ceremony in New
York an award was presented
to the family of Dr. Louis
Slotin, the 3 5 -year-old Canadian-born
physicist — and it bore this tribute:
"Martyr of Science in 1946."
Dr. Slotin gave his life and saved seven
fellow scientific workers from death after
a laboratory mishap at the Los Alamos
atomic bomb assembly centre in New
Mexico in May of 1946.
He lived only nine days after the ac-
cident, and was conscious for the first
seven. For his family's sake he kept
secret the grim fact that he must die.
He pretended that he confidently expect-
ed to recover. Even during his last two
days of coma and delirium that pretense
survived in his subconscious mind.
It was on the morning of May 21,
1946, that Slotin summoned his group
to finish a laboratory experiment entrust-
ed to his direction. That afternoon he
was to leave for Los Angeles. He was
bound for the atomic test at Bikini. His
bags and equipment were packed.
"Why not run along and let us attend
to this one ourselves?" a co-worker asked
him. "No," replied Slotin, "if anything
happened to the rest of you I would never
forgive myself. Your wives would never
forgive me. I've been too busy to find
a wife."
He knew that this was the crucial
point in the experiment. In a certain
quantity of either U-23 5 or plutonium,
they are harmless. It is when a mass is
increased to a definite point that it be-
comes the "hottest" explosive on earth.
(The clarifying details cannot be pub-
lished.)
The slip of an instrument in Slotin's
right hand caused such an increase and
the "explosion" of the fissionable mate-
rial. It was a silent blast but it flashed
with a horrible blue glow and terrific
heat.
Official U. S. army reports tell how
Slotin instantly threw himself in the path
of the Gamma rays to prevent his assis-
tants from absorbing thousands of times
the amount of radiation that the human
body can endure.
THE A-BOMB
By PHIL GLANZER
All raced for cover. Soon after this
Slotin summoned the seven to assume the
positions they had taken in the test. He
calculated their distances from the ex-
plosion centre and accurately estimated
the amount of radiation suffered by each.
After checking on this vital informa-
tion he called for doctors and ambulances.
"I am sorry you were hurt," he apolo-
gized to the group "If you say so," one
spoke up, "we'll go back and take an-
other whack at it."
"No. I would say that now your
chances of recovery are 10,000 to one in
your favor. That is how I wish to leave
it."
"And what about your chances, doc-
tor?"
"About 10,000 to one against."
Yet, despite this knowledge, Slotin
waited two days before he telephoned his
home in Winnipeg, Canada. His father,
Israel, a livestock commission agent, and
his mother, Sonia Slotin, had returned
from visiting friends about 10 o'clock
that Thursday night when the long-
distance operator reached them at home.
From 2,600 miles away the father
heard: "Hello, dad, hello . . . I'm glad
you both are well. There's been a slight
accident and I am afraid that Bikini trip
is off. I may be here for some time.
Could you and mother fly down to see
me?" Then with a laugh: "I have a
drag with the army and they will ar-
range a plane priority on one condition
— that you won't worry about me."
Next evening, telephoning his brother,
Sam, he said: "Glad dad and mother made
the plane. Listen to me, Sam, I am
okay. No, I wouldn't try to fool you
for the world."
Arriving Saturday noon at the Los
Alamos hospital the parents saw their
Lou, smiling and cheerful, his face glow-
ing with a tan from "that wonderful
sun down here."
The Gamma rays left no mark on his
body. He never looked healthier except
for his hands.
They lay limp in ice packs "The doc-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
8
DOES THE BIBLE FORBID ART?
tor says I must cool them off," he ex-
plained.
On their visits Sunday and Monday
he spoke about a couple of technical
books he wanted to write. "Perhaps I
can dictate them if my hands are sore,"
he said.
On her hospital visit Tuesday Mrs.
Slotin remonstrated. "Lou," she said, "I
am worried. You know yesterday 1
wanted to brush your hair. And I know
why you wouldn't let me. Your hair
is as stiff as wire. "Why, it was always
so soft and wavy."
"Purely a symptom of radiation,
mother. Give me time to work it off."
The same night he sank into the coma.
Wednesday he was delirious. At his bed-
side the parents heard him murmur. "I
wish they would let me out of here. I
could start on the books."
Those were the words by which they
will remember him. They were the last
coherent words he spoke. Thursday at
10 a.m. Lou Slotin died.
Then came the revelation of his death-
bed conspiracy.
For that casual call to his parents in
Winnipeg an army nurse held the tele-
phone to his mouth. His hands were
useless and ice-packed.
Slotin's seven co-workers recovered;
four after a two-week stay in hospital
and three after four and a half months.
One scientist lost a lot of hair. It is
growing in again.
One American writer suggested this
extract from the official army report as
a fitting epitaph for the martyr: "He
took affirmative action."
His brother, a couple of years younger,
said: "Lou would appreciate that. He
prided himself on being thorough, not
brilliant. He liked to do all kinds of
things. ... He did not have to work his
way through college but when 1 8 he took
a job as cook on a railway dining car.
He knew how to live — and how to die."
EDITORIAL BOARD
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Louis J. Gribetz, Chairman
Joseph Goldberg M. H. Lewittes
Joseph Kaye Manuel Saltzman
I. H. Levinthal William I. Siegel
The following is an excerpt from
an address delivered by Dr. Levinthal
at the opening of the Jewish
Museum.
THERE is a notion, prevalent among
many, that the Jew was opposed to
art, that his religion discouraged an
appreciation of beauty. We often hear
repeated Mathew Arnold's dictum that
the Jew revealed the beauty of holiness,
while the Greek revealed the holiness of
beauty. It is not as simple as that. The
Jew was wary of art for the sake of art
alone, for that meant the worship of the
external. The Jew insisted on inward
beauty, which, in essence, is the beauty
of holiness. But where art inspired that
inward beauty, when art served as a
means to a holy end, then it was very
precious in the sight of the Jew and in
the sight of God.
Zeh Eli V'anvehu, "This is my God
and I shall adorn Him," was the song
that came from the lips and heart of the
Jew as he crossed the waters of the Red
Sea, beginning his life as a free man. And
the Rabbis in the Talmud develop these
words into a whole philosophy of Art.
"Adorn thyself before Him in the ob-
servance of precepts. When you make
a Sukkah, make it beautiful; see to it
that your Lulav is beautiful; your Shofar,
your fringes. The Scroll of the Law
should be one of beauty, written beauti-
fully, with fine ink, fine reed pen, by an
artist penman, and wrap it about with
beautiful silks" (Shabbat 133b).
The Jew did appreciate the value of
Art, the importance of beauty as an aid
in the development of religious life. In
fact there is an important principle
known as Hiddur Mitzvah, the adorn-
ment of a Mitzvah, which is emphasized
again and again even in our legal codes.
With reference to the bringing of the
Bikknrim — the first fruits — to the Tem-
ple in Jerusalem, we are told in the
Mishnah (Bikknrim III. 10): "There were
three degrees in offering the first fruits."
There were those who observed the literal
injunction and merely brought the nor-
mal amount of the fruits enjoined by the
law. Others, with a higher sense of re-
ligious values, brought Tosefet Habik-
By DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
kurim, more than was expected of them.
But there was a third group that ful-
filled the injunction by Ittur Habik-
kurhn, by bedecking their gifts, by
adorning the baskets artistically, and
these, the Rabbis would have us under-
stand, fulfilled their religious duty in
highest perfection.
If the Jew could not always enact the
obligation of Hiddur Mitzvah — adorning
the religious rite — it was not because he
failed to understand and to appreciate
the great value of art, but because of the
cruelty of the world in which he lived,
a world that shut from his eyes all sight
of beauty, a world that surrounded him
with ugliness, and that did all in its
power to crush the very concept of ex-
ternal beauty from his life.
It is the most eloquent testimony to
the Jew's love of art that in the very be-
ginning of the Jew's return to Eretz Yis-
rael in our own day, before the com-
munal life was yet fully organized, the
Bezalel School for the promotion of every
phase of art was established, and that its
founder, Professor Boris Schatz, was able
to recreate and to refashion the artistic
spirit that ruled in Jewish life in the
classic eras of its history.
Many of our people in America have
learned this truth; but, alas, not enough.
Too many, we must admit, perform
Mitzvot without Hiddur — they fulfil re-
ligious duties in routine fashion, without
beauty, without soul, and therefore lose
the Simchah Shel Mitzvah, the joy of the
religious act that is the very purpose, the
essence of the act itself. And that is why
so many, alas, who see only such type of
religious observance, fail to see any value,
because they see no beauty, in our re-
ligion, and have become lost to our heri-
tage, spiritually dead to that faith that
gave meaning and purpose to the Jews
in the ages past.
We need a revival of the sense , of
beauty. "This is my God and I shall
adorn Him!" must again become the
slogan in our religious life if our religion
is to become a dynamic force and influ-
ence in our life and in the life of the gen-
erations that are to come after us.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
ZEBULUN BUILDS A MERCHANT
MARINE
THE forthcoming establishment of a
Jewish State, brings into focus the
movement of the Zebulun Seafaring
Society, which is dedicated to the revival
of seafaring among Jews and seeks to cre-
ate a Jewish Merchant Marine in Pales-
tine. It is clear that a strong and active
merchant marine will constitute one of
the basic elements of the future Jewish
State. Strangely enough, although the
Zebulun Society has been in existence
since 1929 and has to its credit a record
of important achievements, very little is
known about it in this country.
The Zebulun movement combines the
romance of Jewish history with the hard
practical realities of Jewish pioneering in
Palestine in our time. The organization
takes its name from the sixth tribe of
ancient Israel, which was engaged in sea-
faring activities. Today, when Palestine,
standing at the crossroads between East
and West, is emerging through Jewish
zeal and enterprise from its centuries-
old neglect and is assuming a crucial
position in the world, the revival of mari-
time endeavor is of vital concern not
only to the Jews, but to all nations.
With its long coast line on the Medi-
terranean, Palestine must have a mer-
chant marine as an essential part of a
healthy national economy. Prof. Joseph
Klausner, of the Hebrew University of
Jerusalem, has stated:
"Palestine must look to its economic
resources, not only to agriculture, indus-
try and commerce, but also to indepen-
dent seafaring, without which the Jews
in Palestine will not be able to keep in-
dustry and commerce in their hands."
The development of a seafaring in-
dustry in Palestine will provide tens of
thousands of Jews with employment as
officers, engineers, and crewmen on pas-
senger vessels and freighters, in all
branches of shipping administration on
land and on the sea, as architects and
laborers in ship-building and repair yards
and as stevedores on docks, as well as in
all fields of deep sea fishing. Mr. Israel
Rokach, Mayor of Tel-Aviv and one of
the original founders and leaders of
Zebulun, has given his authoritative opin-
ion that: "Seafaring and fishing activ-
ities in Palestine will provide employment
for 100,000 Jews."
Already, during the eighteen years of
its existence, Zebulun has made marked
progress in the maritime sphere, which
hitherto had been entirely in non-Jewish
hands. Zebulun has today a small but
efficient fleet, manned by its own fully
trained disciplined Jewish seamen. The
fleet consists of training ships equipped
with motors and sails, motor boats, cut-
ters, fishing vessels, life-boats and row
boats. Zebulun has its own training sta-
tions, workshops, boat-building repair
yards, and boat houses in Tel-Aviv,
Haifa, Herzlia, Hedera, Bat Yam, Ramat
Gan, Nathanya, Naharia, Karkur and
Tiberias. There is a Zebulun yacht club
and school rooms with nautical instru-
By LEO GLASSMAN
ments and library at Haifa, and also
yacht clubs in Tel-Aviv and Athlit.
At Karkur, near Hedera, Zebulun has
built a rest-house for Jewish seamen on
land provided by the Henrietta Diamond
Fund through the generosity of Mrs.
Henrietta Diamond, of Leeds, England,
whose tireless efforts and material support
have been a tremendous mainstay of the
Zebulun movement since its inception.
Zebulun, through the Henrietta Diamond
Fund, participated in the building of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
docks in Tel-Aviv, Herzlia and Hedera.
In 1936, when construction of the Tel-
Aviv Harbor began, the seamen trained
by Zebulun won high praise for handling
cargo and passenger boats under ex-
tremely difficult conditions. Zebulun
life-guards are on duty on all Palestine
beaches.
During Arab riots in 1936, the Jews
in Palestine found it necessary to build
the port of Tel-Aviv as an emergency
measure and also with a view to its future
place in the development of the Yishuv.
Because Zebulun had already trained a
large number of Jewish seamen and had
the experience and skill needed for this
type of effort, it was possible to carry
out this herculean project successfully
practically over-night. The late Mayor
Dizengoff, of Tel-Aviv, and one of the
outstanding pioneers of the Jewish renas-
cence in Palestine, declared in his in-
auguration speech as chief executive of
the all-Jewish City:
"Were it not for the readiness of an
active body of enthusiastic and fully
trained young men of Zebulun we would
not have dared to open and operate our
Port."
When the second world war broke out,
Zebulun stood ready to serve the cause of
the United Nations. Zebulun sailors in
small patrol ships hunted U-boats in the
Mediterranean and helped to get vital
supplies through to the Lybian forces.
Their courage and heroism evoked the
highest commendation from Admiral Sir
Andrew Cunningham, Commander in
Chief of the Mediterranean Fleet, and
other top-ranking officers of the British
Navy. Zebulun seamen have also been
Some of Zcbitlun's
Training Ships at
Anchor
cited for heroic action by the U. S. War
Shipping Administration.
These achievements acquire great sig-
nificance, when one remembers that the
major part of Palestine's passenger and
freight traffic is sea-borne. For this traf-
fic millions of pounds Sterling are paid
annually to foreign countries. Those
who are concerned with the future of
Palestine, will readily understand how
vital it is for the Jews to conquer the
sea and build up a great merchant marine
that will perform these services, thus
bringing additional strength and enrich-
ment to the Yishuv.
In pursuing its aim of broadening eco-
nomically and culturally the basis and
scope of national redemption in Palestine
through the revival of Jewish seafaring,
Zebulun has undertaken a diversified
long-range program which includes the
following major projects:
1. Enlargement of Zebulun's training
facilities by the acquisition of additional
vessels, equipped with sails and motors.
(At the present moment negotiations are
under way for the purchase of the first
such vessel in America. This craft, a
luxury yacht, was used by the Govern-
ment during the war, and would be suit-
able for training purposes.)
2. A fleet of cargo vessels, manned by
crews of Zebulun trained masters, mates,
engineers, engine room personnel and
deck hands, to ply between the ports of
Palestine and various ports of the Near
East, the Mediterranean and elsewhere.
3. Passenger vessels, manned by Zebu-
lun seamen, for tourist cruises between
Palestine and neighboring countries, this
service eventually to be expanded to
other parts of the world.
4. Extension and improvement of the
existing motor launch services of Zebu-
lun between the Yarkon River and the
beaches of Tel-Aviv, Tiberias, the Dead
Sea, and other points. The plan em-
braces the establishment, as part of Zeb-
ulun's network of activities, of floating
cafes and restaurants, at the various ports
of call. (The first Zebulun floating cafe
is already operating successfully at Tel-
Aviv.)
5. The expansion of Zebulun makes it
urgent to establish at once a large con-
struction and repair yard to supplement
the several smaller yards already in ex-
istence. The proposed yard will have
[Continued on page 231
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
II
TI IAT a book on such a learned and
highly-specialized subject as Major
Trends, in Jewish Mysticism should
live to see a second edition after only five
years of its first printing, is no less a
tribute to the maturing American Jew-
ish reading public than to its author,
Professor Gershom G. Scholem, whose
rare combination of gifts and qualities
make it possible for him to write on ob-
scure and little-known subjects with the
learning and authority of the expert and
the approach and feeling of the artist.
For twenty years Professor Scholem has
been roving through the dim and weird
corridors of Jewish mysticism and Kab-
balah, haunted by ghosts concealed in the
folds of faded and barely readable parch-
ments a thousand years old. He had lit-
tle or no help. He is a pioneer in the
field, with no ancestors or predecessors
to lean on. What voices were heard,
what opinions on the subject were re-
corded, were discouraging. For Jewish
scholars rejected mysticism as an ally of
forces and tendencies which, in their
pride and prejudice — and perhaps, ignor-
ance — they hoped Judaism had overcome.
Professor Scholem, therefore, had to
start from the beginning. Almost single-
handed he did the spade-work, erected the
scaffolding, cleared the road, and blasted
paths not trodden before. From the con-
fusing welter of facts and surmisals, from
the almost innumerable books and manu-
scripts he absorbed into himself with a
mystic passion, there emerged a book at
once profound and readable, learned and
fascinating, a rare blending of creative
scholarship and superb, almost exciting,
narrative. It is a unique and remarkable
achievement which, it is to be hoped,
Jewish scholars in other fields will
emulate.
Dr. Scholem covers the whole sweep
and whirl of the Jewish mystic flight.
Gently he escorts the enthralled reader
down the stream of Jewish mystic think-
ing and living through the Bible, the
Talmud, the medieval Kabbalah to Has-
sidism, and from the patriot-mystic
Rabbi Akiba to the poet-philosopher
Abraham Issac Kuk, the late mystical
Chief Rabbi of Palestine. And what
strange and fantastic procession of men
one meets en route! Saints and scholars,
dreamers and visionaries, seers, prophets,
and messianic pretenders. There are, too,
The Fascinating History of Spirit-Moved Men
THE JEW'S MYSTIC FLIGHT
bizarre figures and odd characters in that
picture — freaks, frauds and charlatans,
and men of vague and vagrant lives.
But, one and all, they helped to shed a
glow of light and warmth over the Jew-
ish scene, and cheered lives that were de-
pressed and downcast.
Dr. Scholem vindicates the Jewish
claim to the mystic life — a fundamental
experience of the inner self which enters
into immediate contact with God — as an
inherent quality of the Jewish soul, not
prompted by suffering, but part of a
spiritual current common to both Juda-
ism and Christianity, indeed, to all great
historic religions. The misfortunes that
befell the Jews during the Crusades, their
expulsion from Spain, and the Chmiel-
nicki massacres have no doubt sharpened
and deepened the Jew's mystic sense and
prepared the ground for a veritable satur-
nalia of the most fantastic apocalyptic
dreamers and visionaries, but they cannot
be said to have created it. For its roots
one must trace it to the earliest manifes-
tations of the Jewish spiritual life down
to the great souls of the present day.
Briefly, however, it may be said that
whenever there was danger that Judaism
might become sterile and barren, formal
and mechanical, there arose those mystic
yearnings and experiences which kept
Israel and his religion fresh and strong.
But while the mystic rapturous long-
ing for God, the revolt against the limi-
tations of sense and time, was already
present in the Bible, resounding most
audibly in the psalms, its crystallization
into a movement known as Kabbalah was
of considerably later date. Reduced to
its simplest form, Kabbalah may be said
to be a doctrine which proclaims the
Torah to be pulsating with life under-
neath the crust of its literal meaning.
To quote Dr. Scholem's own words, to
the Kabbalists, "the Torah does not con-
sist merely of chapters, phrases and
words; rather it is to be regarded as the
living incarnation of the Divine wisdom
which eternally sends out new rays of
light. It is not merely the historical law
of the Chosen People, although it is that
By JACOB S. MINKIN
too; it is rather the cosmic law of the
Universe as God's wisdom conceives it."
Although the mystic ideal is universal,
the author points to differences which
sharply divide Jews and mystics of other
faiths. Thus, while many of their
Christian kindred spirits were restive
under restraint and showed little respect
for authority, the Jewish mystics, with
rare exceptions, not only remained loyal
to Torah but continued their association
with every phase of their family and
community life. We therefore have the
familiar instances of Jewish mystics who
also figured as great legalists, of men of
deep ecstatic piety who at the same time
taught and interpreted the Law, of Rabbi
Joseph Caro, a man who walked with
God and had an angel for his mentor,
yet was the author of the Slmlhan Aruk,
a religious manual which regulates a
man's daily conduct down to the small-
est detail.
Although Dr. Scholem's book is a
model of scholarship, heavily brocaded
with learning and scientific precision, its
chapters move along with almost dra-
matic swiftness. Thus, what more en-
tertaining narrative than the story of
Abraham Abulafia, that hapless, restless,
philosopher-kabbalist with messianic il-
lusions, who roamed through Spain,
Greece and Italy and finally landed at
the court of the Pope, whom he tried to
convert to Judaism and where he almost
lost his life? But his roving tempera-
ment was not the only quality of his
eccentric genius. In reality, he was a
man of great learning, a philosopher,
mystic and admirer of Maimonides, who
devised a mystical technique with which
kabbalists are juggling to this day. He
developed the mystical contemplation of
the letters of the Torah; he pondered on
the liberation of the soul through the
ecstasy of prayer, or devekut; he coined
that memorable adage, "whoever is full
of himself has no room for God." He
was luckless in everything, even in his
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
writings, for of the numerous books he
composed only a few insignificant scraps
were rescued from oblivion.
Someone described medieval German
Jewry as the Great Inarticulate. But,
like all generalities, this is only partly
true. Unlike their Sephardic brethren,
the German Jews did not write great
poetry, great philosophy, or great tal-
mudic codes to compare with those of
Alfasi or Maimonides. Theirs was an
unhappy lot, and therefore they wrote in
terms of their experiences — lamentations,
dirges, and penitential hymns. But in
Sefer Hassidim, "Book of the Devout,"
by Judah, surnamed the Saint, they left
a literary monument unequaled in Jew-
ish history, mystical only in the sense
that it invented a new scale of values,
setting piety above learning and simple-
hearted devotion to God higher than in-
tellectual attainments. But in reality it
is a drama of the spiritual life of a
people condemned to the jungle of Ger-
man barbarism. The life of medieval
German Jewry is reflected in this volume
in all its spiritual greatness and purity
with almost artistic realism. That a peo-
ple suffering so cruelly, so bitterly, ex-
periencing every form of hurt and shame
could rise to such grandeur of holiness
that they lived and wrote without spite
of rancor is one of the miracles in history.
The two chapters that the writer de-
votes to Sefer haXohar, "Book of Splen-
dor," move in an atmosphere of color and
learning, literary artistry and almost
astounding scholarly craftsmanship, the
combined effect of which is enlightening
and enlivening. He subjects the book —
a "mystical novel" he graphically calls
it — to an almost microscopic examina-
tion, and comes to conclusions contrary
to those held by other scholars. While
he dismisses, of course, the previously
held spurious authorship of this strange
and mystical book and attributes its com-
position to the genius of Moses de Leon,
he is more kindly and charitable to the
author than was Graetz, who called him
a base and despicable swindler. Although
the Xohar is unquestionably a forgery,
its author was just as unquestionably one
of the rare geniuses of all time. To imi-
tate a style and dialect in vogue more
than fifteen hundred years before his
time to such perfection; to reflect and
describe an atmosphere of scenes, land-
scapes, towns, villages and people he had
never seen and which existed only in his
imagination; to write a book of talmudic
proportions which for nearly seven hun-
dred years rivalled both the Bible and the
Talmud in popularity and in the adora-
tion of millions of men, deserves some-
thing better than was accorded to its
author.
For 250 years after the appearance of
the Xohar, Kabbalah, or Jewish mysti-
cism, made little progress. No great
teacher arose, no celebrated book was
flashed upon the Jewish world. There
was no need for either. The Xohar oc-
cupied all minds, absorbed all attention,
claimed all love and devotion. It was
like a torch set to dry wood. The time
previously spent on the Bible and Tal-
mud was now given to this strange,
weird, and fantastic book. But in the
middle of the sixteenth century a kab-
balistic doctrine was formulated which
THE number of Jews working for na-
tional, state and local governments is
on the increase, but in few civil service
departments is the percentage of Jews as
large as in the postal service of New
York City. Out of 22,000 postal em-
ployees, 7,000 are Jews in the boroughs
of Manhattan and the Bronx — a total of
30 percent.
Around the turn of the century Louis
Blumberg became the first Jewish letter
carrier in lower Manhattan. The num-
ber of Jewish employees soon rose, and
reached a substantial amount by 1925.
At that time, Jewish employees had
one outstanding grievance — because of a
lack of planned schedules, most Jews
could not observe the High Holy Days.
Blumberg, an officer of the Letter Car-
riers Association, and nine other carriers,
decided that the time was ripe for an
organization of Jews in the Post Office,
particularly since a Catholic organiza-
tion had been formed earlier. So they
set up the Jewish Postal Workers Wel-
fare League, with Blumberg as its first
president. Blumberg retired from the de-
partment after 36 years service, but he is
still the president, a post he fills without
salary.
The struggle for recognition of the
High Holy Days took a long time, and
it was not until last year that it bore
full fruit. This was the first time that
made its conquest worldwide. It made
its appearance in the little town of Safed,
nestling peacefully in the wooded hills
of Upper Galilee.
Safed has its deservedly magnificent
place in Jewish history for its kabbalists,
mystics and prophets, but its fame
was never so great as when it became
the home of the little band of God-
intoxicated men whose spiritual images
Dr. Scholem etches with such consum-
mate skill in one of the superb chapters
of his book. They were Isaac Luria, sur-
named "ARI," who became a legend dur-
ing his brief lifetime; Chaim Vital, his
pupil and Boswell; Moses Cordovero, the
mystic and writer of whom Dr. Scholem
says that he "transformed everything in-
to literature"; Solomon Alkabez, the
liturgical poet and composer of the Sab-
bath hymn Lecho Dodi; and Joseph Caro,
[Continued on page 23]
every Jew who asked for time off during
that period was excused.
The League rapidly expanded to in-
clude social, charitable, religious and wel-
fare functions. It loans money, aids the
sick, provides convalescent facilities, owns
a cemetery plot. Its membership has now
risen to more than 5,000.
It is only during the past ten years
that so many Jews have joined the de-
partment. While the salary is not high,
there is a good deal of security attached
to working in the post office.
The postmaster, Albert Goldman, is
Jewish. He is an honorary member of
the League and interests himself in many
of its activities. More than 900 Jews
are postal supervisors.
For the past few years the League has
tried to expand nationally. It now has
branches in some ten cities, but organiza-
tion, except in the larger cities, is ham-
pered because of the small number of
Jewish postal employees in many regions.
The League takes an active part in Jew-
ish affairs, contributing to yeshivas, hos-
pitals and other worthy organizations, as
well as to non-Jewish institutions. It is
an unfailing contributor to the United
Jewish appeal, and last year raised
$33,900 for it. It is a member of the
American Jewish Congress.
— Harry Brown, through J.T.A.
THE MEN IN GREY
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
THE DUBNER MAGGID
THE glory of Rabbi Jacob ben Wolf
Krantz of Dubnow was that despite
his Talmudic erudition he chose to
be a maggid, a preacher to the populace.
But what a preacher he was!
Though born in a small town in the
county of Wilna, in 1740, he spent the
greater part of his career in Dubnow,
which he made famous in Israel by his
presence, and he in turn became known
far and wide as Der Dtitwer. Fully fifty
years had passed since his death in 1804
before his scrmonic parables were col-
lected, edited and published by an ad-
mirer in far away Cracow, Austria.
The maggid of yesterday was usually
the preacher for the masses, the Every-
Jew, and more often than not a gen-
tleman-schnorrer who wandered from
town to town and on each succeeding
Sabbath preached from a new pulpit. He
was not always possessed of much learn-
ing. His stock-in-trade was a store of
tales gathered from the Midrash, from
Holy "Writ, and from the ordinary life
about him.
Of such a maggid, who was a colos-
sally ignorant man, the story is told that
he knew but a single sermon, which de-
volved about the Biblical Korah who was
punished for his rebellion against Moses,
by being swallowed alive by the earth.
Synagogue usage demanded, and still does,
that a sermon be based on some text con-
tained or suggested by the Sidrah of the
week. This maggid was thus constrained
to attach his Korah-sermon to such a
text, and on a particular Sabbath he just
could not forge the missing link. While
standing in the pulpit and facing the
congregation, he was fussing with his
tobacco-/wsMe, which slipped out of his
hand and rolled out of sight Straight-
way a gleam lit up the maggid's counte-
nance. "Have you noticed, gentlemen,"
he announced, "how my snufi-pushke
rolled out of sight, as if the very earth
had swallowed it? Verily, this reminds
me of the memorable Biblical tale of how
the earth opened and swallowed Korah
and his associates alive. And now," he
continued with a beaming smile, "since
I have already mentioned this very in-
teresting episode, it behooves us to en-
large on it." And once again our maggid
found an outlet for his favorite sermon.
However, Rabbi Jacob Krantz was a
far different type, a Talmudist of renown.
It was his abounding love for the com-
mon people that moved him to become
a maggid. He stands out easily as the
master preacher of several centuries.
The key to his popularity was his use
of the parable to illustrate and explain
his comments on Holy Writ. When he
was asked why he employed this tech-
nique, he replied, "When you give a child
medicine you sugar-coat the pill to make
it more palatable." His message was di-
rected to the simple folk, and he spoke
to them in terms they could understand
and appreciate. He drew for his sermon
material on the experiences of the coach-
man and the artisan, the petty trader, the
ordinary householder, the housewife and
the child. And he brought to them sim-
ple truths, plain thoughts which they
could digest. In this way he taught them
a morality which touched their lives and
warmed their hearts with a glow of piety.
He did not love the rich. When some
one taunted him, "Why do you go to the
rich for alms for the needy, and they
(the rich) do not come to you for moral
instruction?" he replied, "I am aware
that I need money so I go to obtain it
from those who have it, but the rich
people do not know that they lack wis-
dom. Therefore they do not come to me
to obtain it."
At another time he spoke of the
ignorant-rich with undisguised contempt.
Why was it, he was asked, that a boorish
man of wealth readily gives alms to a
cripple or a blind beggar but shies away
from a scholarly poor man? And the
Dubner replied, "The boorish rich real-
izes that he himself might some day be-
come a cripple or be afflicted with blind-
ness. But he is quite sure that he will
never become a talmid chochem, a man
of learning."
It goes without saying that the Dubner
was a man of great moral courage. We
are told that when Elijah, the famous
Wilna Goan, convalesced from a serious
illness and was unable to pursue his
studies, he sent for the maggid to divert
him with his sermonic conversation. Once
he pressed the Dubner for a personal mes-
sage for himself. "You have something
to say to the most ignorant of the ig-
By RABBI LEON SPITZ
norant," the Goan insisted. "Surely, you
have a word of admonition for me as
well."
Rabbi Jacob accepted the challenge.
"You," he said, "the Goan of Wilna, are
renowned for your scholarship and for
your unblemished life, and you take
credit for these virtues. You were able
to achieve these because you have shut
yourself away from the world in your
Beth Hamidrash and have devoted your-
self to never-ceasing learning. But, had
you been compelled by circumstances to
go forth into the sinful world and to
earn your bread by the sweat of your
brow, who knows whether you would
have been such a renowned Saint in
Israel?"
Elijah Goan bowed his head, and on
the following day he took up the wan-
derer's staff and fared forth, obzurichten
gohis, to wander incognito from town
to town and from village to village, to
taste the bitterness and the temptations
of poverty.
When this maggid turned to the Books
of Moses, the Scrolls of the Law, the
Wisdom of Kohelet, the Songs of Songs
and the Book of Lamentations for the
materials for his preaching, he revealed
to his hearers a vista of spiritual treasure
which he illuminated by his simple
homilies, his homely parables, his peppery
turns of phrase. He delighted the people
and he instructed them. And they in
their turn loved him and were genuinely
happy to be instructed by him.
Why did God consult the Angels when
he was about to create Man, the Dubner
asked, and he gave this interpretation,
"Because He, God, knew by His fore-
vision that Man would sin and that the
Angels would then chide Him thus: we
warned you not to create Man! But
now that God had consulted the Angels
and had created Man despite their coun-
sel to the contrary He could say, It was
my own fault; you advised me not to
create him, you warned me that he would
sin, and I rejected your advice, and cre-
ated him. So now I must stick to my
[Continued on page 22]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
NEWS MONT
THE WAR IN PALESTINE
THE Palestine Government is "care-
fully considering" the situation cre-
ated by the Haganah's public
assumption of responsibility for the blast-
ing of the Semiramis Hotel in Jerusalem,
in which more than a dozen persons were
killed.
An official communique added that
"the government is satisfied that reports
allegedly from 'Jewish sources' that the
Semiramis Hotel was used as a base for
marauding Arab gangs and the headquar-
ters of the military Arab youth organiza-
tion Nejada and Futuwa are entirely
without foundation."
The Jewish Agency, however, declared
that it would stand by its statement of
Monday that the hotel was a center for
Arab gangs and military groups. It
pointed out that the murder of Jews had
elicited no such indignation from the
government.
A Haganah intelligence officer told the
Jewish Telegraphic Agency that the com-
mand staff of Jerusalem Arab bands was
meeting at the Semiramis Hotel two
hours before the Haganah blew it up.
Only a technical delay saved the Arab
leaders because the Jewish attack had
been planned to coincide with the Arab
parley.
The same source stated that one of the
rooms in the hotel was used as an arsenal.
It was also learned that the damages in
the blasting of the Arab National Com-
mittee's headquarters in Jaffa last week
were so severe because an ammunition and
explosives cache in the building's cellar
went off after the external explosion set
off by the Sternists.
It was learned that High Commissioner
Sir Alan G. Cunningham met with
Agency Chairman David Ben Gurion and
that sharp words were exchanged con-
cerning the Semiramis blast.
In an attempt to break a siege of some
4,000 Jews beleaguered in the Old City of
Jerusalem, the Irgun carried out its sec-
ond bomb attack on a group of Arabs
blocking off the gates to the Old City.
The attack was made against Arab posi-
tions at the Jaffa Gate, main portal to
the Old City, by five young Yemenite
Jews in an armored car which they had
stolen from the Jewish Settlement Police.
Fifteen Arabs were killed and 43 were
wounded. None of the raiders escaped;
LATE
U. N. COMMISSION APPOINTS
GROUP TO SET STATE BORDERS
THE United Nations Implementation
Commission appointed a three-man
group to set the boundaries of the Jew-
ish and Arab states in Palestine. All
three members will be non-Palestinians.
The Commission also appointed a
three-man group to act as a preparatory
economic body to lay the basis for the
continuity of public services in Palestine
after the expiration of the British Man-
date, as well as for the formation of a
Joint Economic Board provided for by
a decision of the General Assembly. The
names of the three members were not
made known, but it is learned that one
of them is an economist of world-wide
reputation, the second a non-British ex-
pert on Palestine and the third is a mem-
ber of the U. N. Secretariat.
The Commission, meanwhile, formu-
lated eleven questions concerning the se-
curity situation in Palestine for submis-
sion to the British Government The na-
ture of the questions was kept secret in
accordance with a British request. No
deadline has been set by the Commission
for a reply, but reasonable haste is ex-
pected.
The Commission also formulated 17
questions concerning the discharge of its
administrative duties in Palestine prior
to the complete withdrawal of the Brit-
ish troops.
The Palestine Arab Higher Committee
notified the Commission that it was re-
three were killed by the police and two
were wounded and captured.
Subsequently, the Irgun, in a daring
action, rescued one of the two injured
youths, Uri Cohen, who was lying in a
first aid station guarded by a heavy de-
tachment of police. Seven Jews arrived
in the area in a limousine and non-
chalantly walked in the back entrance of
the building. They took Cohen out of
his bed and placed him on a stretcher,
then walked out the front door past sev-
eral policemen and entered the car which
was waiting for them.
Later, the Haganah made an abortive
attempt to crash through the Arab road
blockade sealing off the Old City. The
NEWS
jecting an invitation to appear before the
Commission on a basis of equality with
the mandatory power and the Jewish
Agency. "The Arab Higher Committee
is determined to persist in rejecting the
partitioning of Palestine and in its re-
fusal to recognize the United Nations
solution in this respect and anything de-
riving therefrom," the reply said.
(United Nations Secretary General
Trygve Lie, at a press conference in Paris,
declared that to his knowledge, no "neu-
tral" country has been approached for
possible participation in an international
armed force for Palestine Mr. Lie re-
iterated that he may go to Palestine with
the Implementation Commission or even
earlier, if necessary.)
Moshe Shertok, head of the political de-
partment of the Jewish Agency, appeared
at a closed meeting of the U. N. work-
ing group which is drafting plans for a
governmental set-up and a constitution
for the proposed international city of
Jerusalem. He urged, among other
things, that business enterprises in Jeru-
salem should have the right to choose
registration either in the Jewish or in the
Arab state. He also reiterated his request
for a speedy appointment of a U. N. gov-
ernor for the city.
Dr. Mordecai Eliash, leader of the Jew-
ish Community of Jerusalem, asked the
group to provide for legal recognition of
all religious holidays by' the Jerusalem
administration. Daniel Auster, former
mayor of Jerusalem, also testified.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
15
attempt to run in a large convoy of sup-
plies to the area was spotted by Arab
snipers who opened fire. Jews from posi-
tions in a nearby Jewish quarter laid down
a withering cover fire, including mortar
shells, but it was not effective.
British troops soon entered the picture,
raking all entrenched positions, with par-
ticular emphasis on the Haganah. Jew-
ish and Arab casualties are believed to
have been heavy in the shooting which
broke out at spasmodic intervals all after-
noon, and at least one Briton is known
to have died from bullet wounds.
The siege of Safed was lifted by the
Haganah which broke through road
blocks and brought food, medicine and
fuel to the Jews of the Upper Galilee
town who had been virtually cut off from
the rest of the world for four days.
British police detachments have begun
evacuating those parts of Palestine which
have been designated as territory of the
Arab state, it was learned here. It is un-
known, however, whether the police will
be concentrated in the territory which
will be part of the Jewish state or
whether they will be confined to barracks
until they are evacuated from the coun-
try, possibly next month.
A British military court sentenced two
young Jewish women to a fine of $1,600
or three years in jail for illegal possession
of arms. The women, 16-year-old Ruth
Klinov, daughter of the Jewish Agency's
information officer, and Carmela Yaari,
were arrested on December 1, at the
height of one of the early Arab riots,
while defending a Jewish section of Jeru-
salem from attack.
The Palestine Government has asked
the International Red Cross to send a rep-
resentative to Palestine to investigate the
situation and offer aid because the many
casualties during the past five weeks have
filled the hospitals to capacity, it was
announced.
Reports from Beirut state that three
Arab guerrilla units destined to join the
Arab "armies" in Palestine have already
been completely equipped and will leave
for Syria shortly. No information is
available concerning the strength, equip-
ment or make-up of the units other than
that they are named for Arab chieftains.
The reports also revealed that the Farouk
Sharia College in the Lebanese capital has
been converted into a training camp for
Palestine volunteers.
A Sternist clandestine broadcast
claimed that the Arab guerrillas are
being assisted by "Serbian fascists from
FEBRUARY THE CRITICAL
MONTH
By Boris Smolar
FEBRUARY will be the decisive month
in Palestine. The Jewish position can
either be strengthened considerably or im-
measurably weakened during the month.
It all depends on whether Britain com-
plies with the U.N. decision and with-
draws in February from a port area in
the section of Palestine designated to be
a part of the Jewish State. If Britain
withdraws, the port area, presumably Tel
Aviv, would be opened for Jewish immi-
gration, thus bringing new manpower in-
to the country. Arms and munitions
could then also reach the Jews freely
through the Jewish-controlled port. The
question of "illegal" Jewish immigration
would cease to exist. On the other hand,
if Britain chooses not to comply with the
U.N. decision and continues to bottle up
the Tel Aviv port area even after Feb-
ruary 1st, the Jewish defense forces might
suffer greatly, and the Arabs will inter-
pret the British action as an encourage-
ment, in their fight against the United
Nations partition decision.
Some members of the U.N. Implemen-
tation Commission seem to display uncer-
tainty as to whether the partition decision
can be carried out if Arab-Jewish clashes
continue. At least one of the five mem-
bers — representing a European country —
did not hesitate to indicate his feelings.
He believes that one of the possibilities
is that in the coming months the Jews
and the Arabs will show themselves im-
mature and not ready for independence.
In this case, he thinks, it would be the
duty of the Implementation Committee
to report to the U.N. General Assembly
that the partition scheme is impracticable
and ask the Assembly to act accordingly.
(the late General) Mikhailovic's army,
soldiers of (General Wladislaw) Anders'
Second Polish Corps, and members of the
British Union of Fascists and escaped
German prisoners of war."
(The Sternists have been accused of an
alliance with Communists. — Editors, The
Revinv.)
■b
The bullet-ridden body of Simcha
Baumblatt, 26, was found in Ramath
Gan. The Irgun announced that it had
executed him after it had learned that
he had worked for the Gestapo in Europe
and later served the British as an informer
on the Irgun, of which he was a member.
His connection with the Gestapo was re-
vealed after he was recognized by recent
immigrants who were former neighbors
in Europe.
Michael Klitchon, a non-Jewish
Ukrainian who had fled Poland, was shot
and killed by three Jews while sitting in
a Jerusalem cafe. Later it was learned
that the Stern Group had "executed" him
because he was acting as an informer for
the Criminal Investigation Division and
because it had pictorial evidence proving
his collaboration with the Nazis in
Europe.
Plans for the creation of a provisional
Jewish government for the projected
Jewish state were discussed at a meeting
of the Jewish Agency executive in Tel
Aviv.
Final approval of the plans have been
held up pending the return of Eliezer
Kaplan with a report on his negotiations
in the United States for loans necessary
to finance the Jewish State. The mem-
bers of the executive also discussed the
formation of a Jewish militia and turned
the problem over to a group of military
experts who will hammer out details.
The ratification of an agreement for
the merger of the Haganah and the Irgun
Zvai Leumi into one Jewish defense force
is expected within the next few days.
The rightist Citizen's Bloc, which in-
cludes the Revisionists, is known to favor
the merger, as do the Laborites, including
allegedly Moshe Shertok and David
Remez. The left-wing Hashomer Hat-
zair, and the Tenua L'Achdut Avoda,
which are slated to merge, have expressed
vigorous opposition to including the
Irgun within the Jewish community's de-
fense organization.
Information from Arab circles indi-
cates that there is a great deal of con-
fusion among all sections of the Arab
population in relation to the present
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
"War" on the Jews. The moderates
maintain that there is a strong possibility
for peace between the Jews and the
Arabs if a neutral power were to govern
Palestine.
ft
Guarantee of the human rights of
American citizens is the first goal of the
United States, President Truman told a
joint session of Congress in his State of
the Union message.
The President attacked racial, religious
and national discrimination as "utterly
contrary to American ideals of democ-
racy" and announced that he would send
a special message to Congress calling for
"effective federal action" on civil rights.
He called for the immediate passage
of suitable legislation by Congress to ad-
mit "many thousands of displaced per-
sons still living in camps overseas." De-
claring that the United States should do
its share "in caring for homeless and suf-
fering refugees of all faiths," the Presi-
dent expressed his belief "that the admis-
sion of these persons will add to the
strength and energy of this nation."
Of the five goals outlined in his mes-
sage, the President declared "our first
goal is to secure fully the essential human
rights of our citizens. The United
States has always had a deep concern for
human rights. Religious freedom, free
speech and freedom of thought are cher-
ished realities in our land. Any denial of
human rights is a denial of the basic be-
liefs of democracy and of our regard for
the worth of each individual," he said.
Assailing employment and educational
discrimination, Mr. Truman stated that
"today some of our citizens are still de-
nied equal opportunity for education, for
jobs and economic advancement, and for
the expression of their views at the polls.
Most serious of all, some are denied equal
protection under our laws. Whether dis-
crimination is based on race, or creed, or
color, or land of origin, it is utterly con-
trary to American ideals of democracy."
Urging stronger educational, health
and social security programs, the Presi-
dent called for establishment of an execu-
tive department for their administration
and to provide "greater equality of op-
portunity to all our citizens for an edu-
cation. Only by so doing," he empha-
sized, "can we insure that our citizens
will be capable of understanding and
sharing the responsibilities of democracy."
ft
President Truman received Dr. Leo
Baeck, president of the World Union for
Progressive Judaism, in the company of
Dr. Maurice Eisendrath, president of the
Union of American Hebrew Congrega-
tions.
Dr. Baeck, former Chief Rabbi of Ber-
lin, congratulated the President on the
magnificence and social vision of the so-
cial program outlined in Mr. Truman's
State of the Union message. Rabbi
Baeck is in this country as a guest of
the U.A.H.C. and will tour the U. S.
on an extended speaking tour as part of
the organization's second annual Ameri-
can Jewish Cavalcade.
ft
The New York State Commission on
a State University has approved tenta-
tively a statement condemning the use
of racial and religious quotas by institu-
tions of higher learning and outlining
specific legislation to prevent such dis-
crimination in the future, it was reported,
although the Commission has made no
official announcement.
The Commission will recommend that
the State Legislature adopt the following
measures: bar public funds to any institu-
tion practicing discrimination and the
Commissioner of Education to investigate
complaints of discrimination and initiate
inquiry into discriminatory practices. If
discrimination were found the Commis-
sioner would have the authority to take
both persuasive and legal action to end
the practice. Denominational and sec-
tarian institutions would be exempt.
In a section of its statement which dis-
cusses anti-Semitic discrimination, the
Commission says: "Studies of the staff of
the commission reveal that some non-
sectarian educational institutions have
criteria of selection that appear to be dif-
ferent for Jewish and non-Jewish appli-
cants. This inequality of treatment is
indicated by the fact that a smaller pro-
portion of applications are accepted from
Jewish than from non-Jewish applicants
from the same geographical areas. Fur-
thermore, as the academic standing of the
applicant decreases, increased preference
is given to non-Jewish applicants."
Disallowing tax deductions for char-
itable purposes for gifts or contributions
to organizations and institutions which
practice racial or religious discrimination
was offered as a deterrent to discrimina-
tory practices in colleges and charitable
institutions by Morris L. Ernst, member
of President Truman's Committee on
Civil Rights. Ernst made the proposal
in an address before the New York Sec-
tion of the National Council of Jewish
Women.
Labor Department support for bills
that would establish a Fair Employment
Practices Commission and that would ad-
mit a number of displaced persons to the
United States is reaffirmed in the annual
report for 1947 of Secretary of Labor
Lewis Schwellenbach.
ft
Establishment of local Jewish com-
munity councils in cities throughout the
country to coordinate and give expression
to the viewpoints of the diverse groups
within the community was suggested here
by Dr. Mordecai M. Kaplan, founder of
the Reconstruction movement, speaking
at the annual conference of the group.
The local councils should in turn be co-
ordinated by a National Jewish Com-
munity Council, Dr. Kaplan added.
ft
A School of Education and Com-
munity Administration will be opened
at the Yeshiva University in September,
1948, Dr. Samuel Belkin, president, an-
nounced this week.
The school, which will be located in
buildings now being constructed adjoin-
ing the University's main building, is the
first to be opened under the University's
recently undertaken physical expansion
program. The courses at the new school
will be offered to full-time graduate stu-
dents as well as part-time students already
serving in the respective areas.
The expansion program will provide
for an adult education section, to expand
undergraduate facilities in arts and sci-
ences, extend mathematical studies and
provide additional training for teachers
and supervisors in Hebrew schools.
ft
Dr. Israel Goldstein was re-elected
to his 20th term as president of the Jew-
ish Conciliation Board of America, which
attempts to settle out of court legal and
moral problems.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
NEWS OF THE CENTER——
IN THE HEBREW SCHOOL
Rabbi Saltzman to Preach on "Is Prayer
Worthwhile" this Friday Night
This Friday night, January 30th,
Rabbi Manuel Saltzman will preach the
sermon at our late Friday Night Services.
He will take as his theme "Is Prayer
Worthwhile?" We hope that many of
our members, their families and their
friends will be with us to hear Rabbi
Saltzman's discussion of this very im-
portant subject.
Cantor Sauler will render a vocal selec-
tion and lead in the congregational
singing.
Advance Notice
Next Friday evening, February 6th,
at our late services, Rabbi Levinthal will
occupy the pulpit and he will preach on
"What Now in Eretz Israel?"
Successful Registration for Center
Institute of Jewish Studies for Adults
The members of our Brooklyn Jewish
Center will be happy and proud to learn
that this season's registration in our In-
stitute of Jewish Studies for Adults shows
a great increase over all former years.
We are grateful to the special commit-
tee of the Institute, headed by Dr.
Reuben Finkelstein, for much of this
success.
We are noting here the number of
students in each of the classes that we
have this year:
Hebrew A-l, Mrs. E. Zusman, 34;
Hebrew A-2, Mr. Samuel Edelheit, 19;
Hebrew B, Mrs. P. Weinreb, 20; Hebrew
C, Mrs. J. Serbin-Beder, 12; Advanced
Hebrew and Hebrew in Bible, Miss Lillie
Rubee, 20; Yiddish, Mr. Samuel Edel-
heit, 22; Talmud A, Dr. Michael Higger,
21; Talmud B (textual), Dr. Michael
Higger, 6; History, Mr. Leo Shpall, 26;
Religion, Rabbi Manuel Saltzman, 5 5;
Wednesday morning class in Bible, Dr.
Alexander J. Burnstein, 36; Monday
morning class in Prayer Book A, 20; B, 7.
Dinner to Rabbi Lewittes — Feb. 17th
Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Assistant
Rabbi in charge of our Hebrew and Sun-
day Schools, will be tendered a testimonial
dinner on Tuesday evening, Feb. 17th.
The dinner is arranged under the auspices
In an attempt to raise the standards
of the United Synagogue schools, an or-
ganization representing all United Syna-
gogue Hebrew schools in Brooklyn was
formed at a meeting held at the East
Mid wood Jewish Center, Monday, Jan-
uary 5, 1948. The Brooklyn Jewish
Center was represented by Rabbi Mor-
decai H. Lewittes, Mrs. Julius Kushner,
Mr. Julius Grossman and Mr. Leo Shpall.
The new organization will consider prob-
lems of registration, curriculum, high
school education, etc. The Brooklyn re-
gional group was formed on the initiative
of the Board of Education of the United
Synagogue for the Metropolitan area.
The G. O. of the Hebrew and Sunday
Schools arranged for talent assemblies on
Sunday, January 4, and Sunday, January
11, 1948. The programs were highly
successful. The following entertained:
Conrad Lefkowitz, Ruth Berman, Renee
Aranow, Barbara Kaplan, Dorothy Spin-
rad, Hannah Swirin, Lila Silverman, Jane
Amster, Carla Lefkowitz, Martin Heil-
braun and Alan Fried. The programs
were coached by Mr. Julius Grossman.
The Hebrew School G. O. is advised by
Mrs. Beder and the Sunday School G. O.
by Mrs. Tessler.
of the Hebrew Education Committee, the
Sisterhood the Parent-Teachers Associa-
tion and the school faculty, on the oc-
casion of Rabbi Lewittes' completion of
ten years of service to the Center.
Reservation at $5.00 per person may
be made with Mrs. Rabinowitz, in care
of the Center.
To Members Who Lost Sons or
Grandsons in Service
The Center is contemplating the erec-
tion in the near future of a tablet to
honor the memory of members of the
institution, sons or grandsons of Center
members who made the supreme sacrifice
in World War II. In order that this
tablet may be complete we would appre-
ciate receiving the names, both Hebrew
and English, as well as the Yahrzeit date
of those to be included in this tablet.
A Chamisha Asar Bishvat program was
presented by the students of Miss Lila
Marcus' 3rd grade class on January 18
and 2 5. Distribution of fruits for
Chamisha took place on Sunday, January
2 5, and Monday, January 26, 1948.
The Parent-Teachers Association ar-
ranged a "Meet-the-Faculty Night" on
Tuesday, January 27, 1948. Mrs. Beder,
Mr. Shpall, Mr. Grossman and Miss Mar-
cus spoke briefly on various aspects of
school curriculum. Arrangements were
under the direction of Mrs. Kushner,
President of the P.TA.
The Hebrew School collected $405.00
for the Jewish National Fund. Repre-
sentatives of the J.N.F. praised the work
of the school and stated that a garden
would be dedicated in Palestine in honor
of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Hebrew
School. Mr. Edelheit was in charge of
the collection.
Mrs. Evelyn Zusman addressed the
Faculty Conference of the Hebrew
School on December 3 0, 1947, and of the
Sunday School on January 11, 1948, on
"The Place of Arts and Crafts in Our
School." She described many worthwhile
holiday projects.
Please communicate this information to
our Mr. Goldberg (Pr. 4-1400).
Sabbath Services
Friday evening services at 4:45.
Kindling of candles at 4:50.
Sabbath services, Parsha "Yitro" —
Exodus 18.1-20.23: Prophets — Isaiah
6.1-7.6:9.5-6, will commence at 8:45
a.m.
Mincha services Saturday at 4:45 p.m.
Rabbi Levinthal will preach on the
weekly portion of the Torah.
Rabbi George Abelson will continue his
lectures in Yiddish this Saturday after-
noon at 3:45 p.m.
Daily Services
Morning services at 8:00 o'clock.
Mincha services at 4:45 p.m.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Baskix, Herbert
Res. 567 Sheffield Ave.
Bus. Merchant, 5 98 — 9th Ave.
Single
Vroposcd by Harold Gumcr,
Samuel Gitlin
BEREN, Lr.ONARD
Res. 621 Montgomery St.
Bus. Textiles, 375 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Edward Fuchs,
Michael Kahn
Bergman, Robert
Res. 501 Avenue R
Bus. Tax Dept., 80 Centre St.
Single
Proposed by Harry Evans, S. Katz
Berke, Ben R.
Res. 344 Osborne St.
Bus. Acc't, 344 Osborne St.
Single
Proposed by Abe Mann, Hy Rosen
Blum, Miss Hannah
Res. 2027 Pacific St.
Bonfield, Miss Florence
Res. 728 Driggs Ave.
Proposed by David Feit
Bosbi, Miss Clarice
Res. 2146— 77th St.
Proposed by Sylvia Lichtman,
Miriam Margolies
Brunner, Joseph
Res. 119 E. 3 8th St.
Bus. Salesman, 206 Lexington Ave.
Proposed by Lionel Brunner
Married
Cantor, Harold
Res. 240 Crown St.
Bus. Student, Columbia University
Single
Proposed by A. H. Zirn, Frank Sugar
Chornev, Miss Bernice
Res. 220 Kingston Ave.
Proposed by Leo Stam, Rhoda Kipness
Cohen, Irwin
Res. 92 Maujer St.
Bus. 116 E. 18th St.
Married
Proposed by Irving Schwartz,
Percy Schwartz
Ehrlich, Irving
Res. 372 Brooklyn Ave.
Bus. Real Estate, 1351 Flatbush Ave.
Single
Proposed by Abr. Hoffman,
Sidney Leonard
Engel, Harry
Res. 919 Park Pi.
Bus. Importer, 170 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Abraham Grossman,
Max Pressner
Engelhard, Miss Betty
Res. 400 Lincoln PI.
Proposed by Hy Rosen,
Jerome J. Weiner
Erler, Miss Anne Sara
Res. 480 Montgomery St.
Proposed by Abe Mann
Feinstein, Miss Mildred
Res. 479 Pennsylvania Ave.
Proposed by Vivian Walker,
Edna Herman
Franklin, Elliot
Res. 1122 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. C. P. A., 500 Fifth Ave.
Single
Proposed by Irwin Schecker,
Louis Kogan
Friedland, Ira M.
Res. 1096 President St.
Bus. Plastics, 95 Madison Ave.
Single
Proposed by Moe Levy,
Leonard Lebow
Friedman, Alex
Res. 12 54 Union St.
Bus. Patent Attorney, 10 E. 40th St.
Married
Proposed by K. Karl Klein,
Samuel Rottenberg
Friedman, Miss Corinne Barbara
Res. 3 50 Lefferts Ave.
Proposed by Emanuel Berlin
Friedman, William Louis
Res. 647 Barbey St.
Bus. Hairnet, 132 W. 21st St.
Single
Proposed by Joseph Leifer,
Bernard Pressner
Gelb, Mark
Res. 39 E. 54th St.
Bus. Live Poultry, 25 Withers St.
Married
Proposed by Harry Preston,
Morris Gelbtuch
Goldberger, Dr. Mortimer.
Res. 919 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Dentist, 919 Eastern Pkwy.
Married
Proposed by E. David, R. Kaplan
Grau, Benjamin
Res. 1245 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Interior Decorating, 484 Bro.id
St., N. J.
Single
Proposed by Seymour Kornweiss,
Rhoda Stern
Greenberg, Emil
Res. 240 Crown St.
Bus. Librarian, Brooklyn College
Married
Proposed by Wm. C. Smerling,
Harry H. Cohen
Haddad, Miss Rose
Res. 2058— 67th St.
Proposed by Wm. J. Driesen
Harris, Dr. Frank
Res. 175 5 Schenectady Ave.
Bus. Dentist, 141 Rockaway Ave.
Married
Proposed by Sidney Saffer
Held, Charles
Res. 451 Kingston Ave.
Bus. Window Cleaning, 169 E. 88th
St.
Married
Proposed by Meyer Hausner
Joseph, Miss Lena
Res. 1497 Carroll St.
Proposed by Florence Gallant,
Vivian Walker
Karen, Irwin
Res. 763 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Insurance, 116 John St.
Married
Proposed by Joseph Goldstein,
Mack Ronick
Kieval, Harry S.
Res. 921 Washington Ave.
Bus. Teacher, Brooklyn College
Single
Kolodner, Irving
Res. 210 E. 51st St.
Bus. Mfg., 324 Clarkson Ave.
Married
Proposed by M. Goldstein,
Milton Chasin
Lederman, Miss Toby
Res. 509 Belmont Ave.
Proposed by Albert S. JafTe,
Norman S. Ruchman
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
19
Leonard, Bernard S.
Res. 419 Jerome St.
Bus. Adv., 3 05 Bway.
Single
Proposed by Ira Brodsky,
Marvin Blickstein
Lusthaus, Miss Betty
Res. 3 08 Sterling St.
Proposed by Abe Mann
Mervis, Arthur W.
Res. 1634 Union St.
Bus. Securities, 60 Broad St.
Single
Proposed by Norman A. Schorr,
Rosalind Stashin
Ostreich, Mrs. Laura
Res. 2 55 Rogers Ave.
Proposed by Mrs. Philip Brenner,
Al Witty
Pester, Miss Shirley
Res. 657 E. 26th St.
Proposed by Edward M. Heller,
Sam Rettinger
Pollack, William
Res. 1053 E. 52nd St.
Bus. Lumber, 34-3 5 Steinway St.
Married
Proposed by Irving J. Gottlieb
Posner, Dr. Leonard
Res. 20 Plaza St.
Bus. Physician, 60 Plaza St.
Married
Proposed by Joseph Goldstein,
Joseph Goldberg
Rader, Morris
Res. 1618 Carroll St.
Bus. C. P. A., 565 Fifth Ave.
Married
Proposed by Abraham Mantell
Radwin, Michael
Res. 134 E. 56th St.
Bus. Real Estate, 8 50 Flatbush Ave.
Married
Rauch, Seymour
Res. 20 E. 18th St.
Bus. National Optical Plan, 51 E.
42nd St.
Single
Proposed by Stanley Levenson,
Estelle Beame
Roberts, Dr. David P.
Res. 8705 Avenue B
Bus. Physician, 3 304 Glenwood Rd.
Married
Proposed by Dr. David Appelman,
Dr. Morris Glick
ROTHENBIRG, MlSS RlTA
Res. 670 Shepherd Ave.
Proposed by Doris Klein
Rubin, Miss Thflma
Res. 572 Lincoln PI.
Proposed by Leo Stam,
Thelma Plafker
Schaum, Miss Pearl
Res. 1068 Park Pi.
Schlaier, Herbert
Res. 179 Tompkins Ave.
Proposed by Nathan Sapon,
Abe Mann
Sidorsky, Samuel
Res. 919 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Jewelry, 3122 — 47th St.
Married
Proposed by E. David,
Max R. Kaplan
Sif.gel, Miss Dorothy
Res. 156 Prospect PI.
Proposed by Hy Rosen,
Jerome J. Weiner
Silverman, Miss Della
Res. 43 6 Eastern Pkwy.
Proposed by Raymond Lipshutz,
Philip L. Lipshutz
Silverman, Miss Paula
Res. 436 Eastern Pkwy.
Proposed by Raymond Lipshutz,
Philip L. Lipshutz
Sotzman, Harry
Res. 92 5 Prospect PI.
Bus. Fat Rendering, 58-64 Townsend
St.
Married
Proposed by Samuel Edelheit,
Abr. Shapiro
Spice, Allan M.
Res. % Crown, 1227 Lincoln Pi.
Bus. Thread, 1123 Bway.
Single
Steinberg, Lester
Res. 264 E. 91st St.
Bus. Dresses, 498 — 7th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Edward Galler
Strumpf, Milton
Res. 214 Van Buren St.
Bus. Auto Finance, 26 Court St.
Married
Proposed by Alfred Orlin
Teicher, Aaron S.
Res. 15 Westminster Rd.
Bus. Jewelry, 1325 Bway.
Single
Proposed by Harold Frumkin,
Hyman Rosen
Wasserman, Lion
Res. 862 Schenectady Ave.
Bus. Real Estate, 8 50 Flatbush Ave.
Married
Weber, Louis
Res. 5 84 Hinsdale St.
Bus. Textiles, 64 W. 36th St.
Single
Proposed by Harold Gumer,
Samuel Gitlin
Weishar, Irving L.
Res. 718 Empire Blvd.
Bus. Lawyer, 215 Montague St.
Married
Proposed by Abe Mann,
A. J. Stelzer
Weisman, Miss Edith
Res. 69-09— 108th St., Forest Hills
Weissman, Dr. Abraham
Res. 766 Hopkinson Ave.
Bus. Dentist, 766 Hopkinson Ave.
Single
Proposed by David Appelman,
Benjamin Ain
Winick, Charles B.
Res. 701 Montgomery St.
Bus. Engineer, 711 Eighth Ave.
Married
Proposed by Albert Joley,
Ira T. Kraner
Wolk, Miss Sonia L.
Res. 860 Eastern Pkwy.
Proposed by Florence Gallant,
Vivian Walker
The following have applied for re-
instatement:
Krohn, Jacob
Res. 1334 St. Johns Pi.
Bus. Hides & Skins, 100 Gold St.
Single
Miller, Manny
R,es. 919 Park Pi.
Bus. Clothing, 1418 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Murray T. Fciden,
A. M. Lindcnbaum
Rothstein, Nathan
Res. 37 Dover St.
Bus. Attorney, 769 Rockaway Ave.
Married
Late Applications
Carr, Herbert
Res. 138 5 Carroll St.
Bus. Auto Sales, 4650 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Maurice Bernhardt
[Continued on page 22]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
YAHRZEITS— FEBRUARY, 1948
Harry A. Harrison
■)
behg Harrison
( Mother
February 2
l J. oiieDat
c , «„i t_r_„
bamuel Herman
Mother
February 3
o\ ^Vi^K-ii-
lj oneuai
Morris W. Haft
Father
February 4
24 Shebat
Morris Brukenfeld
Father
February 7
27 Shebat
Leo Kaufmann
Father
February 7
27 Shebat
Sol Sussman
Father
February 7
27 Shebat
Mrs. Leo D. Kunin
Husband
February 8
28 Shebat
Mrs. Samuel Fleischman
1
Mr. Abe Zirn
\- Mother
February 8
28 Shebat
Mr. Samuel Zirn
i
J
Isador S. Koeppel
Father
February 1 1
1 Adar I
Jacob Koeppel
Father
February 1 1
1 Adar I
Ira Kraner
Father
February 1 1
1 \
Lou Schockett
Father
February 1 1
1 Adar 1
Louis Daum
Brother
February 12
2 Adar I
Jacob Doner
Mother
February 12
2 Adar T
Mrs. Bernard Isacowitz
Father
February 12
2 Adar I
Manes Malz
Mother
February 12
2 Adar I
Samuel Nicoll
Father
February 12
2 Adar I
Philip Rosenblum
Mother
February 12
2 Adar T
Tra Rosen son
Mother
February 12
2 Adar I
Elias Burros
Mother
February 13
3 Adar I
S. J. Fishman
Father
February 13
3 Adar I
Irving Rosenfeld
)
Jacob Rosenfeld
( Mother
February 13
3 Adar I
Dr. Max Goldstein
Father-in-
law February 14
4 Adar I
Louis Gordon
Mother
February 14
4 Adar T
S. Reich
Father
February 14
4 Adar I
Mrs. Gertrude Horowitz
Mrs. Irving L. Cohen
Dr. Joseph Horowitz
Mrs. Max Lovett
Mrs. Larry Sobel
Oscar Kurshan
Samuel L. Kurshan
Al Radutsky
Harry Radutsky
Milton Radutsky
William Schutzer
Louis Brenner
Phillip Brenner
Murray Lipton
Moses Siegel
Mrs. Dora Zurich
Max Fabrikant (N. Y. C.)
Isador Lowenfeld
Irving Kramer (Carroll
Mrs. I. J. Riker
Mrs. Leo Kaufmann
I. Hoffman
Dr. Reuben Finkelstein
Husband ]
Father
( Sister
1
Mother
Father
February 15 5 Adar I
) Father
Father
Father
Husband
Brother
Mother
Mother
Father
Mother
Wife
Mother
[Continued on page 21]
St.)
February 15
February 15
February 1 5
February 1 6
February 16
February 16
February 16
February 17
February 17
February 18
February 18
February 19
February 20
February 21
5 Adar I
5 Adar I
5 Adar I
6 Adar I
6 Adar I
6 Adar I
6 Adar I
7 Adar I
7 Adar I
8 Adar I
8 Adar I
9 Adar I
10 Adar I
11 Adar I
Hebrew School Registrations
Parents are reminded that begin-
ning September, 1948, no boys be-
yond the age of ten will be admit-
ted to the beginners' class of the
Hebrew School. Thus, each boy
will be assured of at least three
years of preparation prior to Bar
Mitzvah. This, of course, is only
a minimum. Since we have a six-
year elementary Hebrew course, it
is advisable for the child to be reg-
istered before he is eight so that he
might complete the full course by
the time he is fourteen. A mini-
mum Hebrew education should be
the goal of every student.
Junior Clubs
The Junior Clubs are continuing to
maintain their high standards of pro-
grams. The Vivalets planned a social
meeting with the Shomrim which took
place on Saturday evening, January 24th.
Food or clothing to our brethren overseas
was the price of admission. Having con-
cluded their project in clay of topograph-
ical maps of Palestine, the Vivalets have
decided to build a miniature Kibbutz.
The Shomrim engaged the Yeshiva Tal-
mudic Academy in their first competitive
basketball game of the year. Our boys
emerged victorious by a score of 16 to
12. "The Shekel and Its Significance"
was the subject of another meeting. The
Candle-Lites have been working with
clay and soap and have been busy making
various articles of religious and national
significance. All the clubs are now pre-
paring for their Chamisa O'ser B'shvat
affairs. A gala music program of our
Inta-League clubs in celebration of Jew-
ish Music Month will take place on Sat-
urday evening, February 14th.
Post-Consecration Societies
The newly organized Junior group of
the Post-Consecration Society met for the
first time on Monday evening, January
5 th, at the Center. Janice Levine re-
viewed Jewish current events. Rabbi
Saltzman conducted a very interesting
discussion of "Will I Keep a Kosher
Home." Eleanor Zeldin led in the sing-
ing of Palestinian songs. The meeting
closed with refreshments by the Sister-
Broolclyn Jewish Center Review
21
hood. This group meets with Rabbi
Saltzman on the first Monday of every
month. The next meeting will take place
on Monday evening, February 2nd, at
8 o'clock in the Ladies Social Room.
Janice Glassman is Chairman and Phyllis
Glass is Secretary.
The Senior group of our Post-Consecra-
tion Society had its first meeting of the
year in the home of Clair Gumeiner, 481
Brooklyn Avenue, on Wednesday evening,
January 28th, at 8 o'clock. Rabbi Saltz-
man led in the discussion "What Are My
Religious Beliefs?" This group meets the
last Wednesday evening of every month
in the home of a Post-Consecrant. All
Post-Consecrants are invited to attend
these meetings.
Junior League
The programs of the Junior League
have been most interesting in cultural
work and very successful in the social
phase. Game Nights, Silent Movies and
timely lectures were featured during the
past few months.
The next meeting of the League which
is scheduled for Thursday evening, Feb-
ruary 5th, at 8:30 o'clock will include
a discussion of "Can Judaism Survive in
the Modern World?"
All Junior Leaguers are invited to at-
tend.
Young Folks League
The Young Folks League of the Cen-
ter sponsored a "March of Dimes" dance
on Tuesday evening, January 27th. The
music for this affair was furnished by an
orchestra. Refreshments were served.
The meeting of the Young Folks
League on Tuesday, February 3rd, will
begin promptly at 8:30 o'clock and will
be held in the Dining Room. A special
welcome for new members will be fea-
tured. The program will consist of part
of the "Eternal Light" program to com-
memorate the 100th anniversary of the
birth of Solomon Schechter. New mem-
bers of the Center are asked to come early
for a brief get-together before the general
meeting.
Acknowledgment of Gifts
We acknowledge with thanks receipt
of donations for the purchase of Prayer
Books, Taleisim and Books for our
Library:
Mr. and Mrs. Irving Kofsky in honor
of the Bar Mitzvah of their son; Barbara
Block; K. Karl Klein.
Personals
At a recent meeting of the Board of
Directors of the Beth-El Hospital, Dr.
Reuben Finkelstein was appointed as the
head Gastro-Enterologist of the hospital
in recognition of his long and faithful
service.
Mr. Morton S. Waxman of 313 Mont-
gomery Street was named head of the
Eastern Parkway Division of the Brook-
lyn Red Cross for the 1948 Drive.
Louis Lipsky at the Center Feb. 5th
The veteran Zionist Leader and orator
Louis Lipsky will be the guest speaker at
a Zionist mass rally to be held at the
Center on Thursday evening, February
5th, at 8:30 o'clock. He will speak on:
"The Struggle for a Jewish State." The
meeting is under the auspices of the E. P.
Zionist District No. 14, and all Center
members and their friends are cordially
invited to attend.
Congratulations
Heartiest congratulations and best
wishes are extended to the following:
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Bruman of 919
Mrs. Reuben Finkelstein
Father
February 21
11 Adar I
Harry Sankin
Irving Sankin
j Father
February 21
11 Adar I
Abe Schlusselberg
Father
February 21
11 Adar I
Isaac Levingson
Mother
February 22
12 Adar I
Mrs. John Sklar
Husband
February 26
16 Adar I
Samuel Nicoll
Mother
February 27
17 Adar I
Dr. Maurice Schnall
Sister
February 27
17 Adar I
David Levkoff
Brother
February 29
19 Adar I
Abe Mann ......
Brother
February 29
19 Adar I
Samuel Schwartz
Father
February 29
19 Adar I
* The Yahrzeit commences on the evening preceding this date.
Park Place on the marriage of their
daughter, Sunny, to Dr. Mordant Adler
on January 29th.
Mr. and Mrs. Harry Cooper of 146
Lincoln Road on the announcement of the
marriage of their daughter, Julia, to Mr.
Arthur P. Gould on January 23rd.
Mr. and Mrs. Emanuel Davis on the
celebration of their 17th wedding anni-
versary on January 24th.
Mr. and Mrs. Jacob Macklowe of. 30
Ocean Parkway on the marriage of their
daughter, Gladys to Mr. Leo Fisher on
January 23rd.
Mrs. Louis Posner of 20 Plaza Street
on the occasion of the birth of a daughter,
Lois Susan, to her children, Mr. and Mrs.
Charles H. Posner on December 31, 1947.
Mr. Jacob L. Holtzmann, member of
the Board of Trustees of the Center, was
elected a Director of the Title Guarantee
and Trust Company.
BROOKLYN JEWISH
CENTER
celebrates
"Jewish Music Festival"
January 24th to February 22nd
CALENDAR OF EVENTS
Sun., Feb. 1st — 1 1:15 a.m.
HEBREW SCHOOL JEWISH
MUSIC ASSEMBLY
Mon., Feb. 9th — 8:30 p.m.
SISTERHOOD MEETING
Program of Jewish Music
Tues., Feb. 10 — 8:30 pm.
"CENTER YOUTH MUSIC
FESTIVAL"
Co-sponsored by Young Folks League,
Junior League and Inta-League
A program of Jewish Music by
Professional Artists
Community Singing
Sat., Feb. 14th — 8:30 p.m.
Junior and Inta-Clubs
Jewish Music Celebration
Fri., Feb. 20th — 8:30 p.m.
Late Friday Night Services dedicated
to "Jewish Music Festival"
Sun., Feb. 22nd — 11:30 a.m.
Sunday School
Jewish Music Assembly
Tues., Feb. 24th — 8:30 p.m.
Membership Social
Jewish Music Concert
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
THE DUBNER MAGGED
[Continued from page 13]
creature, I must forgive him and teach
him to better his ways."
Why is a Synagogue, he once asked,
spoken of as a House of God? Hath not
the prophet, Isaiah, told us, "Holy, holy,
holy is the Lord of hosts, His glory filleth
the entire Universe"? The Dubner here
narrated a tale of a traveller who was
pointed out a Royal Palace, but when
he entered it, he was shown chamber
after chamber occupied by the king's
ministers and generals. Finally he was
led into the throne room. The entire
universe, explained the Dubner, is God's
but the Synagogue is his private cham-
ber set aside for His glorification, the
Throne Room in which he holds his
Royal Court.
When our maggid speaks in his com-
ments on Jeremiah's Lamentations, which
is part of the Tisha b'Av ritual, he be-
moans the "breach of my people," and
also the desolation of the Torah, which
had been shamefully neglected even in
his generation by many of his contem-
poraries who sought material gains at the
expense of the spiritual life.
The Song of Songs, on the other hand,
provides him with an atmosphere of
exultation. It held out to him the prom-
ise of Messianic glory, and he in his turn
transferred this joyous mood to his lis-
teners. The Purim story evoked in him
a healthy reaction to nekama, vengeful-
ness at the bloody machinations of a cruel
Rosbe.
And he has well chosen as the crown-
ing touch of his preaching the Words of
Koheleth, that gentle cynic. But the
Dubner is by no means the cynic the
Biblical author was reputed to be. Still,
he affords us a homely philosophy
grounded in the common sense of every-
day experience. His conclusion bears the
stamp of Koheleth: whatever he has
tasted of life, its bitters and its sweets,
the Quest of Everyjew must always re-
main, Torah, mifzvos and good deeds.
Applications
[Continued from page 19]
Ebner, Miss Dorothy
Res. 2818 West 23rd St.
Korn, Irving A.
Res. 1153 St. Johns PL
Bus. Watches, 608— 5th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Robert Krampner,
Morris Krampner
Lieberman, Norman
Res. 1505 President St.
Bus. Accountant, 90 Church St.
Married
Proposed by Max D. Zankel
Shapiro, Jay
Res. 339 New York Ave.
Bus. Jobbing, 72 Duane St.
Single
Proposed by George A. Shapiro
Shlakman, Martin J.
Res. 742 Montgomery St.
Bus. Dental Equip., 141 — 5 th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Saul A. Shlakman
Samuel H. Goldberg,
Chairman, Membership Committee.
Torah Scholarship Fund
All Center women are most cordially
asked that they please reserve the after-
noon of Wednesday, March 17th, for a
dessert luncheon for the benefit of the
Torah Scholarship Fund. The subscrip-
tion will be $6.1 1 for you and your guest.
Reservations may be made with the
Chairman, Mrs. Sarah I. Epstein, 701
Montgomery Street, SL 6 - 7413, or with
the Vice-Chairman, Mrs. Dorothy Wisner,
760 Montgomery Street, PR 3 - 6973.
Cantor Sauler Soloist
With Vinaver Chorus
Our Cantor, Rev. William Sauler, will
be the soloist with the Vinaver Chorus at
the Concerts to be given by that group
on Monday evening, February 2nd, and on
Saturday evening, February 21st, at
Times Hall, New York.
Basketball Game
Brooklyn Jewish Center
vs.
Hebrew Educational Society
(League Game)
Next Sunday Evening, February 8th
Preliminary Came at 8 P.M.
— — Admission — — —
Center Members — 75c (incl. tax)
Non-members — $1.20 (incl. tax)
Next Home Game
February 22nd
B.J.C. vs. Union Temple
HYMAN
SPITZ inc.
OUR ONLY STORE
Dickens 2-4000
1685 PITKIN AVENUE
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
THE JEW'S MYSTIC FLIGHT
[Continued from page 12]
author of the Shulhan Aruk. It was
from the midst of these men that a neo-
kabbalistic doctrine went forth which
started its victorious march through the
Jewish world.
The times and circumstances favored
its appearance. After the expulsion of
the Jews from Spain, Kabbalah ceased to
be theoretical and became "practical."
It no longer sufficed to implore the
Deity; His hands, so to say, had to be
forced by organized mystical action. For
the first time, the Kabbalah became mes-
sianic; the End was sought; the fiendish
reality of the galut was to be overcome
by ecstatic prayer, mortification of the
flesh and the practice of all sorts of magic
formulae and incantations. A new set
of mystical terms — kelipah, the shell of
sin, tikkun, restitution, gilgul, incarna-
tion, and dybbuk, possession — became the
kabbalistic stock-in-trade almost to this
very day. Surprising as it may seem, the
aberrations of the so-called Lurianic Kab-
balah initiated a mystical revival which,
more powerful than the Zohar, was of
the greatest influence among the Jews
in the Diaspora.
The Sabbatian heresy, the last and most
colorful messianic pageantry in Jewish
history, was the natural sequence to
the Lurianic Kabbalah. The so-called
Prophet-Messiah of Ismir but acted the
role prepared for him by the "Lion of
Safed." That man, by the exercise of kab-
balistic rites, may force the hands of
Providence and bring about Redemption
was one of Luria's delusions. And in the
case of Sabbatai Zevi, the delusion was
global in its effect for, according to Pro-
fessor Scholem, there was not a household
in the Jewish Diaspora that remained free
from it.
Professor Scholem dwells at length on
the Sabbatian paradox and comes to some
striking conclusions. That a man of
Sabbatai Zevi's physical and mental dis-
abilities, of learning so undistinguished
that at his death he left not even a sin-
gle memorable phrase or epigram, should
attract a following so large that even
after he committed the two crimes most
abominable to Jews, betrayal and apos-
tasy, thousands should still believe in his
role as a Messiah, is one of the riddles in
Jewish history. But the paradox can be
partially explained when it is remembered
that it was among the Sephardic Jews,
themselves victims of a double life for
a full hundred years, that the apostate
Messiah enjoyed his greatest following.
To quote Dr. Scholem, "That the Mes-
siah should by the very nature of his
mission be forced into the inescapable
tragedy of apostasy was a doctrine
ideally made to provide an emotional out-
let for the tormented conscience of the
Marranos."
After touching lightly on the corrupt
and hideous Frankist sect, which made
an orgiastic rite of the "fascinating" doc-
trine of the "holiness of sin," the author
concludes his long odyssey with a chap-
ter on Hassidism, all too brief for this
last and captivating phase of the Jew's
mystic flight. But it is a very intelli-
gent and highly informative chapter,
with fresh points of view on almost every
page.
Hassidism, in the opinion of the writer,
is neither a radical nor revolutionary
movement as some claimed it to have
been. In no single essential point has it
departed from the general framework of
traditional Judaism. It created no new
religious ideas nor set up a new scale of
Jewish values. But by the intensity of
the religious feeling it injected into Jew-
ish life it transformed everything. It
was this almost incredible intensity of
creative religious feeling, acting as a re-
bellion against the sterile and petrified
religious values of orthodox Judaism, that
gave rise to a fresh outburst of spiritual
energy and produced so many truly orig-
inal types of saints and sages, men not
surpassed even in the classical period of
the Safed mystics.
What made Hassidism a popular faith,
evoking the enthusiasm and devotion of
thousands, was not so much its theologi-
cal as its social doctrine. From the very
beginning, the Zaddik's court was a so-
cial center where the depressed, the de-
feated, and untutored met and received
comfort and encouragement. Their life
was dull and dreary; they needed some-
one to love and worship, and the Zaddik
offered them what their starved and
yearning hearts had longed for. This is
why the Zaddik's personality was of
higher importance to them than his
learning, and his friendship and intimacy
meant than his doctrine. This is why,
too, that while, in point of ideas it was
the least creative of Jewish sects, Has-
sidism marched quickly and steadily on
its victorious triumphant road.
Dr. Scholem has written a rich and
challenging volume, deserving of the
widest reading public. Profound scholar-
ship matched by popular presentation
have produced a memorable contribution
to one of the most fascinating subjects
of Jewish life and literature.
THE JEWISH MERCHANT MARINE
[Continued from page 10]
facilities for construction and repair of
larger craft, as well as for the building
and repair of such craft as lighters, pon-
toons, buoys, motor launches, trawlers
and tugboats.
6. Construction of additional Zebulun
marine training schools and mechanical
workshops, equipped with nautical in-
struments and marine libraries, at Haifa
and Tel-Aviv, to supplement the training
schools and workshops already in exist-
ence.
7. Construction at Haifa of a marine
salvage and ship supply center, which will
be a vital adjunct to the Zebulun enter-
prises.
8. The establishment of a series of sea-
faring settlements for fishermen on the
shore of the Mediterranean and on the
rivers of Palestine. These settlements
will include craft building and repair
yards, fish conserving factories, rest and
marine sport centers, and farms for the
use of the fishermen.
9. Organization of a floating exhibi-
tion of Palestine products.
These projects can be realized with the
support of influential individuals and
organizations in America.
The Zebulun movement opens up new
vistas for Jewish enterprise and achieve-
ment in a field from which Jews have,
perforce, been absent for 3,000 years.
Zebulun has laid the groundwork for
Palestine's re-entry into world trade, with
unbounded possibilities in passenger traf-
fic, cargo hauling, and deep sea fishing.
The seafaring activities initiated by Zeb-
ulun, besides providing Palestine with a
great vital industry, will give to the Jews
throughout the world that profound
sense of pride and dignity which all sea-
faring nations have enjoyed.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
m m
ABBOT-FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES— SERVICE
507 Flatbush Avenue
JESSE J. FINE Brooklyn, New York
J/^Q\^ ABBOT Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
— RIVERSIDE—
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2-6600
Far Rockaway, L 1.
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE
FAr Roclcaway 7-7100
Miami Beach, Florida
1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
Miami 5-7777
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle, we have arranged to
serve your Community. We have at our disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn.
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed
Sec. 562, P. L. & R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
MM
mm
m
M
THE JEWISH COMMUNITY OF
VIENNA TODAY
By ALFRED WERNER
CAUSE FOR ALARM-BUT NOT
DESPAIR
AN EDITORIAL
PAYING DUES IS NOT ENOUGH
By ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
HERMANN SHAPIRO-FOUNDER OF
THE JEWISH NATIONAL FUND
By LEO SHPALL
NEWS OF THE MONTH
F
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
ORUM LECTURES «"<* DISCUSSIONS
MONDAY EVENINGS AT 8:30
MARCH 1st
DEBATE
"DO WE HAVE A FREE PRESS
IN AMERICA?"
Speakers
TULLY NETTLETON
Associate Editor of the
"Christian Science Monitor"
Mr. Nettleton has been a member of the
"Monitor*' staff since 1926 as an editorial
writer and writer of special articles.
IRVING GILMAN
Research Director of the
Newspaper Guild
Mr. Oilman has been a newspaper man for
14 years and was formerly connected with
the X. Y. Times. He conducted a radio
program "The News and What to Do About
It." During the war he served as a mem-
ber of the National War Labor Board.
MARCH 8th
HOUND TABLE DISCUSSION
MR. DAVID ROSENSTEIN
Member, Reconstruction Committee of the
J. D. C. and one of the American leaders
of World ORT Union.
will speak on
"IS PALESTINE THE ONLY
SOLUTION OF THE D.P.
PROBLEM?"
The lecture will be illustrated with
colored slides of D.P. camps.
MARCH 15th
DR. L M. BIRKHEAD
Founder and Leader of
"Friends of Democracy".
Lecturer and author of "Can
Man Know God?" and "The
Religion of a Free Man". Dr.
Birkhead is in the vanguard
of those fighting all forms of
bigotry and oppression in this
country.
Subject
"SHALL WE JAIL THE
PROPAGANDIST?"
MARCH 22nd
Subject and Speaker to be
announced
MARCH 29th
Concluding Forum of the Season
JOHN HAYNES HOLMES
Famous liberal preacher, minis-
ter of Community Church. Dr.
Holmes has recently returned
from an extended trip to India
where he interviewed the late
Mahatma Gandhi.
Subject
"INDIA TODAY —
AS I SAW IT"
•
Concluding Lecture of Series
"THE PSYCHOLOGY OF
EFFECTIVE LIVING"
DR. LUTHER
E. WOODWARD
Noted Psychologist; Field Con-
sultant, National Committee of
Mental Hygiene. Formerly with
the Board of Education. Dr.
Woodward conducts the radio
program "Inquiring Parent" over
WMCA Sundays at 12:45 P. M.
WEDNESDAY EVENING, MARCH 10th
Subject
"WHAT MAKES FOR PEACE
OF MIND?"
Admission — Free to All
Admission to Forum Lectures (except when a special charge is made) is free to Center members.
All others are charged 40j (inch tax).
DOORS TO THE AUDITORIUM WILL BE CLOSED PROMPTLY AT 9:15
AND ISO ONE WILL BE ADMITTED AFTER THAT HOUR.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Vol. XXIX
ALTHOUGH the decision of the
United Nations Asseembly to es-
tablish a Jewish State in Pales-
tine seemed definite and unqualified, it
has become increasingly evident that the
approval of the Partition proposal by the
overwhelming majority of the nations of
the world was only the first phase in a
long and difficult battle for its imple-
mentation. Our hopes for a quick and
peaceful settlement of the difficulties in
Eretz Israel because of the anticipated
influence of the moral authority of the
United Nations must give way to the dis-
appointing realization that there are
mighty and evil forces arrayed against
us, forces which know not the meaning
of justice and morality. We hoped for
the best. Unfortunately, we must come
to grips with the worst.
There is cause for alarm, but no rea-
son to despair. In Palestine, where our
brethren are writing a new chapter of
Jewish heroism, all reports seem to indi-
cate that the Yishuv has more than held
its own. We have retreated from no posi-
tion, however small, however isolated.
The economic and social life of more than
two-thirds of the Palestinian Jewish com-
munity has not been disturbed by the
fighting. At the same time the Arabs
have suffered great losses, and the econ-
omy of most large Arab communities has
been seriously disrupted. In Haifa, for
example, more than 20,000 Arabs have
been forced to leave the city, and the
manufacturing center is practically dor-
mant. Jaffa is torn by starvation and
internal strife.
However vital and stirring the achieve-
ments of the Yishuv are, the main battle
FEBRUARY, 1948 — ADAR-I, 5708
for our Jewish state at present will not
be waged in the Hills of Judea or in
Northern Galilee but in the Security
Council of the United Nations at Lake
Success. It is on this diplomatic front
and in the propaganda war that our en-
emies have registered success. The great-
est blow to our cause and to the cause
of the United Nations has been the
"neutralization" of the United States.
Neutrality, in the King's English, means
actively abetting the Arabs to liquidate
the Yishuv, or forcing the Yishuv into a
position where it will have to compro-
mise even further with the Arabs and
England. But England's hypocrisy and
duplicity, although to be deplored, was
anticipated. Most disappointing and dis-
couraging has been the United States
stand. Our neutrality, e.g., arms-embargo,
means passive support of the English -
Arab policy by shutting the door to
the Yishuv's only source of armament
strength. •
It is no secret that it was only because
of the direct and active intervention by
the United States delegation in the
Assembly that the Partition plan was ac-
cepted. Only by continued pressure by
the United States will it have any chance
of survival. If the United States will
not assume active leadership in this im-
plementation, it will be tantamount to a
reversal in policy in spite of the vague
reassurances of the President and the Sec-
retary of State.
The key then to our future is Wash-
ington — and our enemies know it. The
aims of all their propaganda is to insure
the continued "neutrality" of the United
States by deceiving the American people
No. 24
into the belief that Jewish Palestinian
immigrants may be communist agents,
and that the active participation of the
United States in Palestine would alienate
the Arab world and jeopardize the supply
of oil which is necessary for our national
security. They would have us think that
a pro-Zion policy is anti-American and
pro-communist. We do not pretend to
possess the omniscience of so-called mili-
tary experts who are urging us to give
heed to these propagandists. Moshe Sher-
tok, in a speech made in this city, stated:
"The Arabs cannot drink their oil, and
they will not sell their oil for rubles.
They want to sell the oil for dollars."
Even if we were to concede (and we are
not ready to do so) that we may lose
some oil, let us ask wherein lies our se-
curity and the security of the world —
in an oil pipeline or in effective inter-
national agreements made by the United
Nations.
The second phase of the battle in the
Jewish State is reaching a climax. Noth-
ing less than the future of the United
Nations and our hopes for world peace
are at stake. When the stakes are that
high, the United States cannot remain
"neutral."
— Manuel Saltzman.
Prof. Alexander Marx Is 70
THIS month we celebrated the sev-
' entieth birthday of one of the most
revered and beloved teachers and scholars,
Professor Alexander Marx. Practically
every institution of higher Jewish learn-
ing in America, Palestine and those Euro-
pean lands where Jewish academies still
exist, and many non-Jewish universities
and academies, joined in a tribute of
gratitude and affection.
[Continued on page 4]
CAUSE FOR ALARM— BUT NOT DESPAIR
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Greenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Goodstein. Treasurer Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthal, D.D., D.H.L, Rabbi Manuel Saltiman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
4
Professor Marx is one of those rare
personalities who combine mastery in al-
most every field of Jewish learning with
spiritual fineness and nobility in charac-
ter. Hundreds of rabbis throughout the
land who, during the last forty-five years,
were his students at the Jewish Theologi-
cal Seminary are indebted to him for a
love of Jewish history, and for an appre-
ciation of painstaking research and scien-
tific methods in Jewish studies. His book
on Jewish history, which he wrote in col-
laboration with the sainted Professor
Max Margolies, is today one of the au-
thoritative and standard works in this
important field.
It is to him that we are indebted above
all for the library of the Jewish Theo-
logical Seminary, which, under his per-
sistent and devoted efforts, now houses
the largest collection of Jewish books and
manuscripts in the world. He is recog-
nized as the greatest Jewish bibliogra-
pher, and there is hardly an important
work on any Jewish subject published in
the last few decades whose author is not
indebted to Prof. Marx for aid in supply-
ing helpful material.
It has been well said that the real
teacher influences his pupils not only by
the words of his lips — important as they
may be — but by his personality. Prof.
Marx influenced thousands of students
through his lovable personality, as well
as by his knowledge.
The readers of the Center Review join
his many admirers in extending to him
and to Mrs. Marx their congratulations
and good wishes. It is their fervent
prayer that our Heavenly Father may
bless them with life, health and strength,
so that this great teacher may continue
to enrich Jewish spiritual and cultural
life for many, many more years to come.
— Israel H. Levinthal.
U. J. A. Campaign For
Palestine Defense Fund
THE United Jewish Appeal has recently
proclaimed an emergency campaign to
raise $10,000,000 for immediate and di-
rect aid for the defense of the Yishuv in
Eretz Israel. This money must be col-
lected by February 28 th. The special
campaign brings into sharp relief the
grave danger which confronts the Yishuv
and the importance of the success of the
[Continued on page 23]
JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
PAYING DUES IS NOT ENOUGH
I AM writing this just a few days after
the Annual Meeting of our Brooklyn
Jewish Center, which took place on
the evening of January 29th. Like
others who were present then, I, too,
wondered — and still wonder — why so
many of our Centerites were not with us.
It was indeed a very cold night, and we
did have a fairly representative gathering.
But when we consider that we have
around 2,500 members, and that this was
their opportunity to hear the detailed re-
ports of the work we are doing and the
progress we have made, we surely had a
right to expect that our large auditorium
would not be big enough to accommodate
all those who would show their interest
by their presence.
The disappointment is even greater
when we note that many of our monthly
membership meetings and social gather-
ings do crowd our halls to capacity.
I tried to explain this anomalous situa-
tion by the fact that the rank and file
of our membership know that we are
blessed with a splendid group of officers
and trustees, and that they have implicit
confidence in their leadership and guid-
ance. They are aware of the manifold
activities in which we are engaged, and
they read the frequent reports of our
progress in the pages of the Center
Review; they thus may feel that their
presence is not at all important at what
they must regard as a routine order of
business.
•
I agree wholeheartedly that our insti-
tution is singularly blessed with its lay
leadership and that we can rely upon
their wisdom and devotion.
But the officers themselves would feel
more strengthened in their purpose and
greatly encouraged in their efforts if they
could see that the entire membership
takes an active — not just a passive — in-
terest in what they are doing. The Presi-
dent and many of the other officers are
at their posts of duty almost daily. They
study and observe every phase of the
work that is being done. They con-
stantly strive to develop new plans, new
projects, in order to bring our people
closer to our faith, to our culture, to our
general welfare. They are working now
on a program of expansion for the Center.
They have a right to ask that the ma-
jority of the members should indicate
that they are strongly concerned with
these endeavors, and that they are active
participants in all that takes place and in
all that is being planned. They want to
hear the voice of approval or of disap-
proval, of suggestion or of criticism, from
those who placed them in office.
•
I want to hope that every member of
our Center who reads these lines will real-
ize the justification of this feeling on the
part of our officers, and that they will
resolve to show a personal interest in the
planning and accomplishment of the pro-
gram of our activities. To be a mem-
ber of an institution such as the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center should mean something
more than merely paying one's dues or
even taking advantage of what the insti-
tution offers. It should mean a co-
worker, a co-builder; it should mean
sharing the responsibility of all that the
institution symbolizes.
We are entering the 30th year of
the Center's existence. Ben Sbelosbim
La-ko-ach, at thirty one should reach the
age of strength and power. May this
year see our beloved Brooklyn Jewish
Center achieve the strength and power
to be an even greater source of blessed-
ness to our people, to our faith and to
our people's ideals.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
Doctors and Lawyers Get Along
in Vienna — Others Have a Difficult Time
THE JEWISH COMMUNITY IN
VIENNA TODAY
TEN years ago a tired statesman with
a look of profound worry drove
through the gray and foggy winter night
from Berchtesgaden towards the Austrian
frontier. He was Dr. Kurt von Schusch-
nigg, Chancellor of Austria, who had just
been forced by Hitler to sign an agree-
ment that virtually made little Austria
a tool of the Reich. Beside Schuschnigg
sat his trusted friend, Foreign Minister
Dr. Guido Schmidt. It was only much
later that Schuschnigg learned how he
had been betrayed by Schmidt, who had
engineered the Berchtesgaden pact in
the hope of replacing his friend as
Nazi-appointed Chancellor of a satellite
Austria.
Back in Vienna, Schuschnigg made the
grave mistake of concealing to his people
the seriousness of the situation. He
should have told them the truth: that
Hitler was determined to annex Austria,
one way or another. Perhaps the oppo-
sition to Hitlerism would have reached
such a height that the Fuehrer would not
have dared to attack his native country.
At least, Schuschnigg would have given
the leaders of the various anti-Nazi
groups a chance to prepare for the flight
instead of getting caught by the Gestapo.
At the same time the anti-Fascist forces
would have obtained a respite to enable
them to go underground. In particular,
Austria's 200,000 Jews, of whom 175,000
lived in the capital, could have trans-
ferred some of their property abroad and
prepared themselves for a quick exodus
in the case of Austria's surrender. But
Schuschnigg, still waiting for a miracle
to save Austria, feigned optimism; when
a deputation of Austrian Jews, led by
Dr. Desider Friedmann, head of Vienna's
Israelitische Kultusgemeinde, asked him
whether he thought that Austrian Jewry
was in danger, he gave them the ambigu-
ous answer: "As long as I shall remain
Chancellor, no Austrian Jew will be
harmed." A few weeks after that inter-
view he had to abdicate, and what fol-
lowed was a reign of Nazi terror.
•
While, fortunately, more than 100,000
Austrian Jews succeeded in saving them-
selves by reaching the U. S. A., Eng-
land, Palestine, and other countries, over
one-fourth of Austrian Jewry perished
in jails and concentration camps, or com-
mitted suicide. Today, ten years after
the Anschluss, and three years after Aus-
tria's liberation, the Jews of Austrian
citizenship living in the second Austrian
republic number only 7,834 individuals,
of whom all but a handful are in Vienna.
It is significant that of those survivors
only 748, or less than ten per cent, are
under eighteen, whereas 3,715, or nearly
fifty per cent, are over forty-five; males
by far outnumber the females. Its death
rate being infinitely higher than its birth
rate, Austrian Jewry is "biologically
dead" for all practical purposes.
But where did these 7,834 come from?
A few hundred Jews remained in Vienna
throughout the Nazi era; some of them
belonged to the skeleton staff of a Jew-
ish Community Council which the Nazis
permitted to function, and to be the butts
for abuse for whatever sinister purposes
they could invent; others were not mo-
lested because they were married to Gen-
tiles, while a third category lived the
hazardous lives of "Unterseeboote," thus
called in bitter jocularity because in 1938
they had "submerged" like submarines,
hiding their identity and posing as
Aryans. But the bulk of Viennese Jews
are men and women who, in the spring
of 1945, returned from slave labor and
concentration camps.
•
A special group are the so-called
Shanghai Jews. In 1938 the port of
Shanghai was the only place that could
be entered without a special visa. After
the large-scale pogroms of November,
1938, large numbers of Austrian Jews
were released from concentration camps
on condition that they leave Greater
Germany within a couple of weeks.
These had no other place to go than far-
away Shanghai. There the Japanese mas-
ters at first left them alone, but eventu-
ally, under German pressure, herded them
into a ghetto. These Austrians lived
there for years in ugly barracks, trying
to fight their hunger by establishing soup
kitchens, by borrowing money from
By ALFRED WERNER
abroad and by using food sent by the
American Red Cross. Last year an
American transport, built to carry G. I.'s
to Pacific battlefronts, was loaded at
Shanghai harbor with the first batch of
Austrian Jewish exiles anxious to return
to their homeland. They knew from let-
ters and newspaper accounts that postwar
Austria was no paradise, that in Vienna
one-fourth of the houses had been de-
stroyed during the last bombardments,
that except for the few who could afford
to pay the fantastic black-market prices,
everyone existed on scanty rations. But
they had friends in Austria, they could
talk with them in their native tongue,
and there were places that had been dear
to them from infancy.
It so happened that shortly before the
Shanghai Jews embarked for Europe, Ira
A. Hirschmann, then visiting Austria,
declared that a high-ranking Allied offi-
cer in Vienna had told him he wouldn't
give "a plugged nickel" for the life of an
Austrian Jew after the Occupation
Armies would be withdrawn. Simultane-
ously, Leland Stowe reported that the
Austrian provinces were ripe for a new
Hitler. But the Shanghai repatriates who
had been stateless for eight years seemed
to have implicit faith in their country,
to judge by the comments they made on
the above-quoted statements. They told
correspondents visiting them on their
ship: "We are Austrians and we can fight
back. Surely our government will help
us."
•
Jews returning to Austria must pos-
sess a fighting spirit, if they wish to sur-
vive. True, the present government is
not anti-Semitic, but, yielding to popu-
lar pressure, it frequently — too fre-
quently — treats notorious anti-Semites
and collaborators with kid-gloves, and
it is very slow in forcing the restitution
of stolen property to returning Jews in
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
6
order not to antagonize the countless
Nazi thieves now posing as law-abiding,
peaceful Austrian citizens.
Among the Jews, the intellectuals seem
to be far better off than any other group.
In fact, Dr. Geroe, Minister of Justice,
who is himself of partly Jewish descent,
appealed to Austrian lawyers residing in
England and the United States to return
to their homeland since there was a great
need for trained jurists. By now many
Jewish lawyers have opened offices in
Vienna and are overburdened with work
because many of their Christian col-
leagues who had collaborated with the
Nazis had had to be purged by the Aus-
trian Bar Association. Similarly, Jewish
physicians are much in demand — it should
be remembered that the famous "Wiener
Schule" owes its international fame largely
to Jewish medical men. Some outstand-
ing Jewish experts who had been force-
ably retired in 1938 are now serving again
in various government offices and in the
police department regardless of their ad-
vanced age. Finally, several Jews are
active as editors of newspapers and peri-
odicals, and in the field of education.
Jewish businessmen, however, have a
hard time in Vienna. With capitalism
in decline in Central Europe, the Jew as
a purveyor of goods, as a middleman, is
much less needed than he was a half cen-
tury ago, when capitalism was still vig-
orous and expanding. Besides, the Gen-
tiles who took over Jewish enterprises in
Germany and Austria in 1933 and in
1938, discovered that they could manage
business affairs as efficiently as the Jews.
•
The problem of Jewish commerce is
closely connected with the burning prob-
lem of the restitution of property. Un-
fortunately, a large portion of the Jew-
ish wealth in Austria that was expropri-
ated by the Nazis consisted of movables,
securities and monies. Inevitably, these
items were to the greatest extent either
carried away, consumed or in the posses-
sion of persons who cannot be traced or
are protected by existing legislation. In-
dustrial and commercial enterprises that
have been restored are, in most cases,
empty shells, the stocks and machines
having been sold, transported abroad or
vanished. Some of the improved real es-
tate, too — whose ownership is easiest to
trace — has been returned, yet much of it
had suffered damage or was dilapidated.
To be fair to the Austrian government
we must admit that the problem of prop-
erty restitution is not an easy one, par-
ticularly since some property changed
hands several times between 1938 and
194 J, and since though the first owner
during this period was undoubtedly a
Nazi thief, the last owner may have ob-
tained it bona fide for hard cash. Never-
in figures and much more influential, in-
cluding as they do persons associated with
large banks and insurance companies, and
politicians. Under these circumstances
it is tragically clear why, in many cases,
the Austrian authorities did not hurry to
theless, there is also a psychological fac-
tor contributing to the slowness of the
process of property restitution: Jews,
frightfully reduced in numbers, no longer
represent an important factor in political
life (as voters), while the beneficiaries
of the 1938 robberies are much stronger
issue certificates enabling a claimant to
prove his case, or why they have been
delaying court decisions favorable to
Jews.
Another psychological factor is play-
ing a sinister role in the relations between
Jewish and Gentile business — fear on the
part of the Gentiles lest Austria will
"again" become "dominated" by Jewish
capital. Actually, Jews never dominated
Austrian trade and commerce, and for
each well-to-do Jew there were at least
two or three who barely eked out a living.
But the nonsensical fear of Jewish com-
petition already caused the governments
of Dollfuss and Schuschnigg to refuse
the granting of trade licenses to Jews,
and Vienna's Vice Burgomaster Kresse,
who administered the public contracts
department, saw to it that Jews did not
receive public orders. Today the fear
that Jews might "get control of industry
and the economic life of the country"
is more ridiculous than it had been ever
before, yet it was voiced by no less a man
than Leopold Kunschak, President of the
National Assembly. The septuagenarian
Kunschak, one of the founders of the
conservative Christian Social Party, re-
cently had the audacity to state at a mass
meeting that Austria's political and eco-
nomic ills had been "caused by the Jews."
Later, he claimed that he had been mis-
quoted, and asserted that he was merely
opposed to special measures for restora-
tion of Jewish rights and property,
"since non-Jews also suffered at the hands
of the Nazis."
This kind of double-talk is not likely
to help anyone, at least not the Jews.
The latter gladly noted that Chancellor
Figl, head of the People's Party, as the
Christian Social Party has been renamed,
tried to appease public opinion in the
democratic countries by excusing Kun-
schak's anti-Semitism on the ground that
"he is an old man and has some fixed
ideas." But young and vigorous Chan-
cellor Figl failed to use his strength to
rush to the aid of his Jewish fellow-
citizens, who claim that they cannot exist
on empty expressions of friendship for
the jews. Three years have passed since
Austria's liberation, yet many Jews are
still forced to live like beggars, housed,
clothed and fed by the Israelitische Kult-
usgemeinde, though some of them were
well-to-do people before the Anschluss.
The denazification of the country is still
very slow; former Nazis are still in con-
trol of the allocation of apartments and
of granting licenses for traders and
artisans, thus making it difficult for Jews
to resume a normal existence. So great
is the dissatisfaction of our brethren in
Vienna that at a recent meeting of the
kehilla for the forthcoming elections to
the Jewish Community Council, one man
in the audience desperately shouted in
the presence of Austrian government offi-
cials: "We do not want wealth. We
want only bread and homes, and to be
treated as decent human beings."
While talking of Austria's Jews, we
must not forget the Jewish DP's, cur-
rently living in Austria. These are either
stateless people or citizens of Poland,
Roumania and other Eastern European
countries fleeing from a pogrom atmos-
phere to the relative security of the Aus-
trian capital, from where they wish to
emigrate to Palestine. One-third of them,
or about 12,000, live in special shelters
in Vienna, largely financed by the Joint
Distribution Committee. But their head-
quarters is the Rothschild Memorial Hos-
pital in the American sector of the city.
It was recently visited by the newspaper
[Continued on page 23]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
7
1™L n U MONTH
A DRAFT statute for the inter-
national regime of the city of
Jerusalem was submitted to the
U.N. Trusteeship Council.
The internationalized city will be a
"corpus separatum" under the administra-
tion of the United Nations, acting
through the Trusteeship Council and the
Governor, to be appointed by the Coun-
cil. Some of the main provisions of the
2 9 -page document are:
1. The United Nations would guar-
antee the territorial integrity of the city
and the maintenance of the special in-
ternational regime. In case of aggres-
sion, or a threat of aggression, "or any
other attempt to alter by force" the spe-
cial regime, the Security Council would
be informed.
2. The city itself would be demili-
tarized, with no "para-military" forma-
tions, exercises or activities permitted
within its borders. However, a special
police force would be organized — of such
size as the Governor deemed necessary —
"to assist in the maintenance of internal
law and order, and especially for the pro-
tection throughout the city of the Holy
Places, religious buildings and sites." This
special police force would be selected as
far as possible without regard to nation-
ality, except that no citizen of Jerusalem
or of the Arab or the Jewish state would
be eligible.
3. The Governor would be appointed
for a three-year term, which could be
extended if necessary, and would be eli-
gible for re-appointment. No resident of
the city, or the Arab or the Jewish state
would be eligible. He would have su-
preme executive authority, subject only
to the instructions of the Trusteeship
Council.
The Legislative Council would consist
of a single chamber, composed of citizens
of the city over 25 years of age. Citizens,
by definition of the statute, would not
include any persons who chose citizenship
in either the Arab or Jewish state.
Subject to "the requirement of public
order, security and public health, and
economic welfare," residents and citizens
of the Arab state and the Jewish state
would have free access to the city, as
would foreign pilgrims and visitors. Im-
migration would be controlled by the
Governor under instructions of the Trus-
teeship Council.
Arabic and Hebrew would be the offi-
cial languages of the city, with English
and French recognized as additional
working languages.
An "adequate" system of primary and
secondary education would be maintained
"on an equitable basis" for the Arab and
Jewish community in their respective
LATE
PROSPECTS for an international army
to implement U.N. decision to parti-
tion Palestine were bettered. As the
Review goes to press it was hoped that
Britain would at least give passive assis-
tance to the establishment of such a force,
since the British Colonial Secretary
Arthur Creech Jones, now in this country
to participate in U.N. discussions, said
that his government believed an interna-
tional force would be needed to enforce
partition. He emphasized that the U.N.
must "mean business." It was consid-
ered certain that Britain would not exer-
cise her veto against any plan to mili-
tarily enforce partition, and that Russia
would agree to it.
ft
The U.N. Palestine Commission made
public its report on the Palestine security
situation several hours after submitting
the document to the Security Council.
The Council was expected to commence
its discussion of the report early the fol-
lowing week.
The report warned the Security Coun-
cil that only the prompt establishment
of a "non-Palestinian" armed force can
prevent serious trouble in Palestine and
effectively implement the partition deci-
sion of the General Assembly. Such a
force, the report said, would assist law-
languages and in accordance with their
respective cultural traditions.
The city would be included within the
Economic Union of Palestine, but would
operate its own central bank, control its
own fiscal and credit policy, and conduct
international financial operations. Exist-
ing municipalities, and any that might be
created in the future, would have wide
powers of local autonomy.
ft
The Department of the Army flatly
denied an assertion by Rep. Noah Mason
of Illinois who told the House of reports
he had heard that 40,000 American
troops were to be sent to Palestine for
keeping the peace.
The office of Secretary of Defense,
James Forrestal, categorically stated that
there is absolutely no truth to a press
NEWS
abiding elements in both the Arab and
Jewish communities in maintaining an
atmosphere of law and order. The re-
port asked that the international force
enter Palestine simultaneously with the
Commission.
Only such a force can replace the Brit-
ish troops which are now the sole barrier
to a complete deterioration of the situa-
tion to "open warfare," the Commission
continued. Any alternative would be
"catastrophic," it emphasized, and would
involve "bloodshed and human suffering."
ft
Following the issuance of its report,
the Commission discussed the question
of how to get nations to lift arms em-
bargoes which are preventing the Jewish
defense forces in Palestine from getting
weapons. The five-member group de-
cided to leave the matter open until after
the Security Council acts on the recom-
mendations contained in the security
report.
ft
The English Foreign Office categori-
cally denied reports that Britain is pre-
pared to place troops at the disposal of
the international regime of the city of
Jerusalem, following partition.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
8
FOUNDER OF THE JEWISH
NATIONAL FUND
report that he is trying to sabotage
American policy on Palestine.
Jews throughout Palestine were aroused
and angered at the destruction of a syna-
gogue in the Manshieh quarter, on the
Tel Aviv- Jaffa border, by British troops.
A spokesman for the Army asserted that
shots had been fired at a nearby station
from the synagogue.
The demolition was bitterly protested
by a Jewish security officer heading a
small detachment of settlement police
assigned to guard it. He pointed out that
the building had never been used as a
strong point and categorically denied that
any shots had ever been fired from its
windows or roof.
Rabbi Isser Judah Unterman, Chief
Rabbi of Tel Aviv, declared that the deed
"might be compared with Nazi actions."
He also pointed out that while the British
blew up the synagogue they made no at-
tempt to molest snipers operating from
mosques on the edge of Jaffa. The Pal-
estine Chief Rabbinate has addressed mes-
sages of protest to all Jewish religious
centers throughout the world.
The British Army in Palestine has
stopped the sale to Jews of surplus stocks
of barbed wire and other defensive equip-
ment, the Jewish Agency disclosed. The
British are also withholding the delivery
of the last of 21 Auster training-planes
sold to Jews recently, although the crafts
have been paid for, the Jewish Agency
stated.
In line with this new restrictive policy
affecting the Jewish defense in the Man-
date was the British Army's refusal last
week of an escort, as previously agreed,
for a supply convoy to the Kfar Etzion
settlement. Part of the convoy — the first
since the big Arab attack on Kfar Etzion
last month — did not go because the
trucks contained barbed wire, corrugated
iron and cement. These items, the Brit-
ish Army ruled, were "military stores"
and accordingly could not be permitted
to go to the settlement.
Sternists blew up a three-story build-
ing in the center of Jerusalem which was
owned by Dr. Izzat Tannous, an Arab
leader, and which had been used as the
headquarters of an Arab gang. Many
[Continued on next page]
THE Jewish National Fund is unques-
tionably one of the most popular of
Zionist institutions. No other fund
makes such an appeal to the imagination
of the Jewish people or has so strong a
hold on its affections. The Jewish Na-
tional Fund is favored by all factions in
Zionism because all Zionists realize that
the strength of the Jewish position in
Palestine plays an important part in de-
termining the issues of our political strug-
gle. It is fitting that this institution,
whose achievements constitute an epic
of Jewish rehabilitation in Palestine,
should have been born in the mind of
Professor Hermann Shapiro, who died
fifty years ago.
At an early age, he manifested extra-
ordinary abilities in Jewish and secular
studies. He won fame as a "wonder
child," and at eight there was no longer
anyone in his home town who could be
his teacher. When the boy was thirteen
his mother died. The family then broke
up, each member going his separate way.
Hermann, too, parted with his father and
began his wanderings. He went to the
neighboring towns and studied at the
Yeshivas there, but the schools left him
dissatisfied. He finally returned home
and told his father he wished to go
abroad. The father urged him to con-
tinue his Hebrew studies locally, prom-
ising permission to travel when he had
given proof of his proficiency in Talmud.
Hermann agreed. At the age of twenty
he was an ordained rabbi. For two years
he was spiritual leader of a Jewish com-
munity in Courland, but this mode of
life did not satisfy him. He resigned his
post and set out to pursue his secular
studies.
Shapiro reached the city of Vienna,
then the seat of the Haskalah, and there
he set to work diligently to master the
German and Russian languages. Soon he
had learned that Vienna could offer him
very little and decided to go to Berlin.
There, though under the strain of priva-
tion and actual hunger, he kept up his
studies and was admitted to the univer-
sity. He attended the higher institution
By LEO SPHALL
of learning for three years, then his health
broke down and he returned to Russia.
Next Shapiro went to seek his fortune
in Odessa, at time already a center of
the Hebrew literati. During the Russo-
Turkish war he accumulated some money
and was able to resume his studies in
Germany. He obtained the degree of
Doctor of Philosophy and was appointed
Professor at the University of Heidelberg.
Professor Shapiro was one of the earliest
champions of Zionism. In 1882, he pub-
lished the first of his series of Hebrew
articles in which he proposed the found-
ing of a university in Palestine.
In 1882 Professor Shapiro founded the
Zion Society in Heidelberg for the pur-
pose of promoting Hebraic culture and
propagating the Zionist ideal. Shortly
thereafter he conceived the remarkable
idea of creating a Jewish National Fund
to purchase land in Palestine and hold
it in perpetuity for the benefit of the Jew-
ish people. He advocated this plan in a
telegram to the first conference of the
Lovers of Zion which met in Katowitz
in 1884. But at that time, when Zionism
was in its infancy, such a fund was out
of the question. This failure, and the
unsuccessful attempt to strengthen the
Zion Society at Heidelberg, caused him
to withdraw from public life. He lapsed
into silence from which he did not emerge
until roused by the call of Dr. Theodore
Herzl.
At the first Zionist Congress, Prof.
Shapiro again outlined his project. He
dramatically called upon the delegates to
declare their allegiance to the Zionist
cause. Although his plan was not ac-
cepted at the first Congress, Prof. Sha-
piro left the Congress rejuvenated. The
Zionist cause became his ideal and this
was the happiest year of his life. In the
following year, he received an invitation
to address a Zionist meeting in Cologne.
On returning he contracted a cold, and
shortly after he passed away. His last
words were: "We must strive and have
faith — we shall triumph in the end."
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
Arabs are believed buried in the debris.
Several Sternists were injured in an ex-
change of shots with British troops whom
they met as they left the scene of the
blast.
<r
Thf Central Committee of the Jewish
Immigrant Camps on Cyprus, which pre-
viously denied British allegations that
Communist agents were among the Pan
York and Pan Crescent immigrants, has
revealed that three of the visaless immi-
grants were beaten after being interro-
gated by a British officer.
The Committee told a Reuters corres-
pondent that the Jews were not queried
about visaless immigration but about
"Soviet activities in Bulgaria and Ru-
mania, particularly information concern-
ing the number, nature and kind of
Soviet vessels in the Black Sea, descrip-
tions of Russian armaments in Bulgaria
and details of Soviet troop movements."
When the three Jews said they knew
nothing of such matters the officer ac-
cused them of withholding information
and beat them.
Officials of Jewish organizations in
Munich protested to the German civilian
and American military authorities against
a series of anti-Semitic incidents which
occurred there over the week-end in
which the windows of two Jewish res-
taurants and a Jewish butcher shop were
smashed and the signs of several Jewish
organizations' offices were burned. The
Jews also expressed concern at the con-
tinued growth of anti-Semitism through-
out Germany.
The Munich Police Commissioner,
Franz Pitzer, said the incidents were the
work of anti-Semites because neither the
restaurants nor the butcher shop were
robbed. Military authorities similarly ad-
mitted that the acts may be the work of
anti-Semites. "Nobody is silly enough to
believe that the Nazis or nazism have
been eliminated from Germany," a mili-
tary spokesman said.
The British Legion, counterpart of the
American Legion, at a regional confer-
ence held at Carlisle, condemned the anti-
Semitic activities of the pro-fascist Brit-
ish League of Ex-Servicemen and asked
the public not to confuse its members
with those of the fascist organization.
Meanwhile, as protests mount against
Sir Oswald Mosley's organization of a new
fascist Union Movement, the board of
governors of the school in which the
group's first meeting was held, announced
an investigation of the granting of a
public hall to the fascists by the London
County Council.
Pope Pius XII blessed the efforts of the
United Jewish Appeal agencies when he
received 28 American Jewish communal
leaders comprising the U.J.A. delegation
touring Europe and Palestine to study the
needs of the Jewish survivors on the Con-
tinent and the new Jewish state in
Palestine.
After greeting each delegate personally,
the Pope told the delegation: "This is not
the first group of your much-tried peo-
ple we have been pleased to receive here.
We welcome the opportunity of your
visit to tell you once more how deeply
our paternal heart has been moved by
the manifestations of gratitude for what
we were able and so happy to do to
lighten the burdens of your people among
so many others in the dark days of the
war. We gladly invoke the blessing of
God most high on all the charitable en-
deavors you may undertake in His name."
★
Jacques Berlinski, the French Jewish
composer who fought in the French re-
sistance in Lyon, was announced the win-
ner recently of a $1,000 prize for his
symphonic work, "Kenaan," submitted in
the international contest for Jewish music
"reflective of the spirit of the Jewish
people," conducted by the National Jew-
ish Welfare Board in New York.
Berlinski, who came to France from
Poland in 1930, is director of music at
the Jewish Art Center of France for the
Advancement of Jewish Music. A prize
for a chamber orchestral work was given
at the same time to Jacob Avshalomoff,
music instructor at Columbia Univer-
sity, for his composition "Evocations."
Mr. Avshalomoff came to this country
from China in 1938.
The two awards were made at a cere-
mony at the offices of the J.W.B. David
Morgenstern, of Cleveland, presented the
prizes, which were donated by the Mor-
genstern Fund of the Cleveland Jewish
Community Council. Mrs. Frank Cohen,
chairman of the Music Council, spoke on
the aims of the contest and the Council -
sponsored Jewish Music Festival in which
synagogues, Jewish Community Centers
and Jewish educational and fraternal
groups are Currently participating.
On the judges' committee were: Leon-
ard Bernstein, conductor of the New
York City Symphony and composer of
the "Jeremiah Symphony"; Mark Blitz-
stein, composer of the "Airborne Sym-
phony" and "Cradle Will Rock"; Alex-
ander Dushkin, executive director of the
Jewish Education Committee of New
York City; Erich Leinsdorf, conductor of
the Rochester Symphony. Also Curt
Sachs, professor of music at New York
University; Randall Thompson, profes-
sor of music at Princeton University;
Joseph Yasser, chairman of the Jewish
Music Forum; and Bernard Hermann,
symphonic director of Columbia Broad-
casting System.
The Jewish War Veterans Award of
Merit was presented to Lt. Gen. Willard
S. Paul, director of the Personnel and Ad-
ministration Division of the Army De-
partment, for "invaluable aid to the Jew-
ish War Veterans of the United States."
The plaque was presented at a ceremony
in the Pentagon Building by Col. Julius
Klein, national commander of the J.W.V.
A delegation from the Palestine Arab
Higher Committee to Cuba told a press
conference in Havana that it had come
to Cuba to thank the Cuban people for
voting against the Palestine partition plan
at the last U.N. General Assembly ses-
sion. The delegation is touring Latin
America propagandizing against the
"Jewish invasion of Palestine."
Approximately 700 Zionist leaders
from all parts of the U. S. A. assembled
in Washington for a 2-day conference,
convened by the American Zionist
Emergency Council. Many of them vis-
ited Senators and Representatives in an
effort to impress them with the necessity
for America taking the lead in imple-
menting Palestine partition.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER NEWS
IN THE HEBREW SCHOOL
Rabbi Saltzman to Deliver Brotherhood
Sermon this Friday Night
This Friday night, February 27th, at
our late services, Rabbi Manuel Saltzman
will deliver the sermon on "The Struggle
for Civil Liberties" in commemoration
of Brotherhood Week.
President Truman has announced that
the week of February 22nd to 29th will
be National Brotherhood Week and Rabbi
Saltzman is devoting his sermon to this
very important theme.
Cantor Sauler will render a vocal selec-
tion and lead in the congregational
singing.
All members and their relatives and
friends are cordially invited to attend.
Advance Notice
Next Friday at our late services, Rabbi
Mordecai H. Lewittes will speak on the
subject "Poet of Padua — The Story of the
Founder of Modern Hebrew Literature."
Center to Celebrate Rabbi LevinthaPs
Sixtieth Birthday
The sixtieth birthday anniversary of
our Rabbi, Dr. Israel H. Levinthal, will
be celebrated on Tuesday evening, April
6th. The celebration will be held in the
Main Synagogue and will be limited to
Center members and their wives.
Watch for further details.
Hebrew School Registrations
Parents are reminded that beginning
September, 1948, no boys beyond the age
of ten will be admitted to the beginners'
class of the Hebrew School. Thus, each
boy will be assured of at least three years
of preparation prior to Bar Mitzvah.
This, of course, is only a minimum. Since
we have a six-year elementary Hebrew
course, it is advisable for the child to be
registered before he is eight so that he
might complete the full course by the
time he is fourteen. A maximum Hebrew
education should be the goal of every
student.
The Post-Bar-Mitzvah class under the
direction of Mr. Irvin Rubin presented
an "Eternal Light" radio script in honor
of Abraham Lincoln's birthday called
"The Postmaster of Quincy." This
script, based on an authentic incident,
relates how Lincoln paroled a Jewish con-
federate soldier so that he might go back
to visit his dying father. The following
took part in the presentation: Stanley
Green, Edward Sharkey, Richard Stadin,
Herbert Brown, Ronald Neuwirth, David
Braver, Thomas Kraner.
Impressive assemblies in honor of Jew-
ish Music Month were held on February
1 and February 22. The program con-
sisted of the following:
1. Y'rushalayim (class 3A2).
2. Chumash Melodies (composed by
Julius Grossman) — Hannah Swirin.
3. Az Yashir (recitation) — Hebrew
Club.
4. V'ulai — Cantor William Sauler.
5. Hapilu; Tzena (clarinet solo) —
Conrad Lefkowitz.
6. (a) Havdalah.
(b) Minhag Chadash — Victoria
Yousha (accompanied by Miss
Rhoda Rabinowitz).
The program was under the direction
of Mr. Julius Grossman. Rabbi Mordecai
H. Lewittes served as chairman.
Beth Pins were recently awarded to
those Hebrew School students who have
excellent records for attendance at
Junior Congregation services. The pin,
especially designed for the Junior Con-
gregation, has the colors blue and white
and the Hebrew letter Beth representing
Beth K'nesset (Synagogue). The fol-
lowing received the Beth Pins: Ileane
To Members Who Lost Sons or
Grandsons in Service
The Center is contemplating the erec-
tion in the near future of a tablet to
honor the memory of members of the in-
stitution, sons or grandsons of Center
members who made the supreme sacrifice
Altman, Helen Aronow, Joseph Aronow,
Renee Aronow, Rita Aronow, William
Berlat, Morton Bromberg, Bernard
Brooks, Edward Bressman, Jerry Cohen,
Leonard Davis, Paul Davis, Isaac Dress-
ner, Sheldon Freifeld, Jeannette Flamm,
Charles Feldman, Norman Gray, Bernard
Goldstein, Harvey Gottlieb, Alan Her-
man, Stanley Janow, Herbert Kasnetz,
Leonard Kabram, Arthur Kramer, Joseph
Karp, Arthur Kaplan, Barbara Kaplan,
Judith Leibowitz, Michael Lewis, Larry
Levy, Monroe Levine, Bruce Plapinger,
Stephen Schilder, Martin Sloate, Mitchel
Streger, Franklin Morrow, Leslie Silver-
stein, Robert Rood, Leonard Silverstein,
Stephen Wesely, Carl Schlam, Arnold
Zwibel, Charles Stromfeld, Richard
Weinberger, Seymour Siegel, Robert
Schreibman, James Mitnick, Arthur
Kramer, Sol Tanenzapf, Arthur Rudy,
Alan Richman, Conrad Lefkowitz,
Charles Schwager, Olin Schocket, Eugene
Sherman, Carla Lefkowitz, Stuart Perl-
man, Rena Rosenbaum.
In a recent standard Siddur test the
following received the highest scores in
the Hebrew School: Ira Denhoffer, Rob-
ert Goldberg, Harvey Gottlieb, Stanley
Janow, Ethel Persky, Arthur Rudy, Sey-
mour Siegel, Charles Stein, Gabriel Stol-
zenberg, Sol Tanenzapf.
Mrs. Beder, G. O. advisor, supervised
a visit of our G. O. delegates to the sixth
Annual Children's Community Assembly
on Monday, February 23, 1948, at Hun-
ter College. A program called "The New
Jewish State" was arranged under the
auspices of the Jewish Education Com-
mittee of New York.
in World War II. In order that this
tablet may be complete we would appre-
ciate receiving the names, both Hebrew
and English, as well as the Yahrzeit date
of those to be included in this tablet.
Please communicate this information to
our Mr. Goldberg"" (Pr. 4-1400).
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
II
Sisterhood Meeting — Monday,
March 8th
The next regular monthly meeting of
the Sisterhood will be held on Monday
afternoon, March 8th, at 1:00 o'clock.
The guest speaker will be Rabbi Morde-
cai H. Lewittes, who will review the cur-
rent best seller "East Side — West Side"
by Marcia Davenport.
Refreshments will be served.
All Center women are most cordially
invited to attend.
Torah Scholarship Fund
All Center women are most cordially
asked that they please reserve the after-
noon of Wednesday, March 17th, for a
dessert luncheon for the benefit of the
Torah Scholarship Fund. The subscrip-
tion will be $6.1 1 for you and your guest.
Reservations may be made with the
Chairman, Mrs. Sarah I. Epstein, 701
Montgomery Street, SL. 6-7413, or with
the Vice-Chairman, Mrs. Dorothy Wis-
ner, 760 Montgomery Street, PR. 3-6973,
or through the Center office.
Miss Isobel Walters, noted Radio and
Concert singer will be the featured en-
tertainer of the afternoon.
Post Consecration Junior Group
to Meet March 1st
The Junior Group of the Post Con-
secration Society will meet on Monday
evening, March 1st, at 8 o'clock at the
Center. Rabbi Saltzman will lead a dis-
cussion on the "Jewish State and Its Sig-
nificance for American Jews." All
Junior consecrants are invited to attend.
Yiddish Literary and Musical Evening —
Tuesday
An interesting evening of Jewish music
and entertainment will be given in our
Auditorium on Tuesday evening, March
2nd, at 8:30 o'clock. The following
artists will participate: Leo Lowe, famous
composer and conductor, with his choir;
Vladimir Heifetz, composer-pianist; Igor
Gutman, opera singer; Leizer Rosenstein,
singer of folk songs; Zvee Scooler, Jew-
ish humorist and narrator; and Aaron
Lutzky, poet. Admission will be $1.50
including tax. The evening is being ar-
ranged on the occasion of the publication
of the Yiddish book of poetry "Shtark
und Munter" by the well-known Jacob
MarinofF.
Membership Social — March 24th
Tin: next Membership Social will take
place on Tuesday evening, March 24th,
on the eve of Purim.
Please watch the Bulletin for further
details of the program.
In the Junior Clubs
All the Saturday night Junior Clubs
are now in the midst of preparation for
their Purim Projects which will be cele-
brated jointly on Saturday evening,
March 27th, at 8:15 o'clock with a gala
Purim Rally.
On Saturday evening, February 14th,
there was a Music Program Festival in
honor of the Jewish Music Month, led by
Mr. Julius Grossman. The following par-
ticipated: Conrad Lefkowitz, Barbara
Kaplan, Renee Aranow, Ruth Berman
and Paula Spinrad.
Bar Mitzvah
A hearty Mazel Tov is extended to
Mr. and Mrs. Kalman Sloate, of 145 Lin-
coln Road, upon the Bar Mitzvah of their
son, Alan Richard, which will be cele-
brated at the Center, this Sabbath morn-
ing, February 28th. Our sincere con-
gratulations are also extended to the
grandparents, Mr. and Mrs. Louis Kaplan,
of 516 Crown Street.
Sisterhood Notes
The Women's Division of the United
Jewish Appeal will formally open its
campaign on Thursday morning, March
11th at 10:30 A. M., at the Hotel St.
George with a rally followed by a lunch-
eon. All contributors of $180.00 and
over will be invited.
Congratulations
Heartiest congratulations and best
wishes are extended to the following:
Dr. and Mrs. Samuel M. Levenson of
734 Montgomery Street on the engage-
ment of their daughter, Ruth Marian, to
Dr. Milton Abramson of Newark, New
Jersey on February 21st.
Dr. Betty Zuckerman of 274 New
York Avenue, daughter of Mrs. David
Zuckerman and the late Dr. David Zuck-
erman, on her engagement to Dr. Jesse
Schertman.
Gala
Leap
I Year
DANCE
SUNDAY EVENING
FEBRUARY 29 — 8:30 P.M.
Sponsored by
The Young Folks League
for the benefit of
UNITED JEWISH APPEAL
Dance to Good Band Music
Members and one guest invited
Contribution — $1.50
as ate
Hebrew Club for Children Organized
A Hebrew Speaking Club for children
has been organized in the Center. Chil-
dren from the third grade up to twelve
years of age are eligible for membership
in the club which is under the able lead-
ership of Dora Muhlbauer, and engaged
in a program of Hebrew drama, story-
telling, dances and songs. This group
meets Wednesday afternoons at 4:15 p.m.
Center Library
The Center library, located on the
third floor, is open on Mondays, Tuesdays,
Wednesdays and Thursdays from 3 to 9
o'clock and on Sundays from 10 A. M.
to 3 P. M.
Members are invited to make use of this
department and consult the librarian, Dr.
Elias N. Rabinowitz, regarding books for
reading. Works in English, Hebrew and
Yiddish are available.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
YAHRZEITS— MARCH, 1948
S. Kamenetzky
Mother
March
1
20 Adar I
Mrs. L. J. Levinson
Husband
March
1
20 Adar I
Mrs. Louis Albert
Mother
March
2
21 Adar I
Sam Katz . .
Mother
March
2
21 Adar I
Jacob Shapiro
Father
March
2
21 Adar I
Simon Gluckstern
Mother-in-law
March
3
22 Adar I
Dora Leaks
Father
March
3
22 Adar I
Max Levine
Father
March
3
22 Adar I
Dr. Benjamin Koven
Max N. Koven
> Mother
March
3
22 Adar I
Morris T. Koven
I
Philip Feinberg ......
Father
March
4
23 Adar I
Isador Lowenfeld
Mother
March
4
23 Adar I
Mrs. Ida Fried
Father
March
5
24 Adar I
Meyer Rosen
Brother-in-law
March
5
24 Adar I
Charles Wunderlich
Father
March
5
24 Adar I
Mrs. S. A. Schneider
Mother
March
6
2 5 Adar I
Jacob Levine
Mother
March
7
26 Adar I
Mrs. Jacob Rutstein
Husband
March
7
26 Adar I
Jacob A. Fortunoff
Mother
March
8
27 Adar I
Joseph Levy, Jr.
Father
March
8
27 Adar I
Lewis E. Weingarten
Mother
March
8
27 Adar I
Mrs. Hannah Zirinsky
Son |
March
27 Adar I
Harry Zirinsky .
Brother (
8
Dr. Harry Bernstein
Brother
March
9
28 Adar I
Isidore Gottlieb
Mother
March
9
28 Adar I
Morris Groden
Father
March
9
28 Adar I
Dr. M. L. Levy
Father
March
9
28 Adar I
Mrs. Hyman Teperson
Father
March
9
28 Adar I
Mrs. Jacob L. Holtzmann
Mother
March
11
30 Adar I
Louis J. Roth
Mother
March
11
3 0 Adar I
Louis Gordon
Mother
March
IS
4 Adar II
Louis J. Roth
Father
March
18
7 Adar II
Benjamin Werbelovsky
Father
March
19
8 Adar II
Mrs. Harry Levy
Mrs. Isador Lowenfeld
y Father
March
24
1 3 Adar II
Dr. Irving Moskowitz j
Isidore Fine
Mother
March
25
14 Adar II
Jacob Stang ...
Mother
March
25
14 Adar II
Lewis L. Weingarten
Sister
March
26
1 5 Adar II
Charles Goody
Mother
March
30
19 Adar II
DAILY AND SABBATH SERVICES
Daily Services
Morning services at 8:00 o'clock.
Mincha services at 5:20 p.m.
Sabbath Services
Friday evening services at 5:10.
Kindling of candles at 5:24.
Sabbath services, "Ki Tisa" — Exodus
30.1 1-34.3 5; Prophets— I Kings 18.1-39,
will commence at 8:45 a.m.
Mincha services Saturday at 5:00 p.m.
Rabbi Saltzman will preach on the
weekly portion of the Torah.
Rabbi George Abelson will continue
his lecture in Yiddish this Saturday after-
noon at 4:15 pm.
MALE
CHOIR
The Center has organized a
male choir and invites mem-
bers and all interested men
in the community to join.
•
LEARN TO SING
Palestine Songs
American Folk Songs
Synagogue Music
In 4-Part Harmony
Write to or call Julius Gross-
man, Music Director of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center.
Acknowledgment of Gifts
We acknowledge with thanks receipt
of donations from the following for the
purchase of Prayer Books and Taleisim
and books in our library:
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph N. Blumberg, in
honor of the birth of a grandchild.
Mr. and Mrs. Isaac Goldstein, in honor
of the Bar Mitzvah of their son.
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Reich, in honor
of the marriage of their son.
Mrs. Louis Posner in honor of the birth
of a grandchild.
Mr. and Mrs. Abraham J. Stelzer in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their son.
Mr. and Mrs. Morris D. Wender, in
honor of the marriage of their son.
Library
Florence Block.
Mr. Harris Goody.
Mrs. Nathan T. Schwartz.
Mr. and Mrs. Paul Spiegel.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
Membership Applications
The following have applied for mem
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Abrams, Miss Evelyn
Res. 228 E. 38th St.
Proposed by Abe Mann,
Phyllis Cohen
Arum, Samuel
Res. 91e Montgomery St.
Bus. Accountant, 400 Madison Ave.
Married
Baron, Miss Irma
Res. 1441 Prospect Pi.
Bass, Abraham
Res. 960 Sterling PI.
Bus. Hotel Supp., 300 Bowery
Married
Proposed by Jos. Richman
Beren, Ralph
Res. 421 Crown St.
Bus. Crockery, 17 E. 1st St.
Married
Proposed by Edw. Fuchs,
Michael Kahn
Berson, Miss Florence Ray
Res. 564 E. 51st St.
Birman, Miss Ruth
Res. 544 Bedford Ave.
Proposed by David Gold,
Rubin Brenner
Blevitsky, Miss Doris
Res. 62 5 E. 15th St.
Proposed by Yvette Waldman,
Betty Pearlman
Bloomberg, Dr. Henry H.
Res. 675 Linden Blvd.
Bus. Physician
Married
Proposed by Sol Goldberg,
Edw. Shwom
Carr, Herbert
Res. 138 5 Carroll St.
Bus. Auto Sales, 4650 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Maurice Bernhardt
Chaliff, Miss Maralyn
Res. 2035 Union St.
Proposed by Gertrude Brumel,
Eleanor Grager
Dudakoff, Miss Sylvia
Res. 146 E. 5 5th St.
Ebner, Miss Dorothy
Res. 2818 W. 23rd St.
Fabrikant, Ben
Res. 95 Maple St.
Bus. Jewelry, 66 Bowery
Married
Proposed by Abe Mann,
Lou Klein
Fiinstein, Miss Helene
Res. 1483 St. Johns PI.
Proposed by Ruth Rothenberg,
Lynn Mitzner
Feinstein, Miss Zelda
Res. 1483 St. Johns PI.
Proposed by Ruth Rothenberg,
Lynn Mitzner
Friedman, Lawrence
Res. 101 Christopher Ave.
Bus. Instruments, Thomson Ave.,
L. I. C.
Galina, Louis
Res. 70 Linden Blvd.
Bus. Printing, 6 W. 28th St.
Married
Gaynes, Sidney
Res. 101 Ocean Pkway.
Bus. Machinery, 214 Centre St.
Married
Proposed by Aaron Finkelstein
Gellar, I. William
Res. 1068 Park PI.
Bus. Iron and Steel, 15 Warren St.
Married
Proposed by Katherine W. Reiter,
Anna H. Molow
Geiman, Miss Esther R.
Res. 831 Saratoga Ave.
Goldman, Raymond
Res. 429 Barbey St.
Bus. Paper, 233 Spring St.
Single
Proposed by Morris Hecht,
Abr. B. Kazdan
Goldstein, Miss Shirley
Res. 484 E. 4th St.
Proposed by Naomi Bachman,
Phyllis Cohen
Gottlieb, Miss Cora
Res. 217 Ocean Ave.
Haber, Jack
Res. 905— 43rd St.
Bus. Men's Wear, 1115 Bway.
Married
Hecht, Reuben
Res. 12 5 Remsen Ave.
Bus. Rayons, 71 W. 3 5 th St.
Married
Proposed by Morris Hecht
Herman, Sam
Res. 645 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Tailor, 512 — 7th Ave.
Married
Hershenov, Jerry
Res. 701 Empire Blvd.
Bus. Student
Married
Hoffman, Irving
Res. 157 Van Buren St.
Bus. Hosiery, 389 — 5th Ave.
Single
Kaplan, Max
Res. 1098 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Sales Agency, 488 — 2nd Ave.
Single
Proposed by Barnett Kaplan,
Meyer Pearlman
Kerzer, Seymour
Res. 3 58 Kosciusko St.
Bus. War Dept., Ft. Hamilton
Single
Kessler, Allan
Res. 50 LefFerts Ave.
Bus. Haberdasher, 302 Central Ave.
Single
Proposed by Philip Levin
Leonard Lebow
Kobre, Marilyn E.
Res. 532 LefTerts Ave.
Proposed by Mrs. Morris Lapidus,
Mrs. J. Rosenman
Korn, Irving S.
Res. 1153 St. Johns PI.
Bus. Watches, 608 — 5th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Robert Krampner,
Morris Krampner
Korn, Reuben
Res. 8 88 Montgomery St.
Bus. Elec. Supp., 636 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Robert Krauss
Kramer, Miss Estelle
Res. 1245 President St.
LlEBERMAN, NORMAN
Res. 1 505 President St.
Bus. Accountant, Govt.
Married
Proposed by Max D. Zankel,
Robert Krauss
Loonin, Herman
Res. 646 Montgomery St.
Bus. Steel, 300 Meserole St.
Married
Proposed by Alvin E. Moscowitz,
Ralph R. Moscowitz
Mn ler, Sidney J.
Res. 45 5 Schenectady Ave.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
Bus. Buyer, 281 — 8th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Leon Hyman,
Israel Eisenberg
Philipson, George
Res. 1248 Union St.
Bus. Printing, 531 Gates Ave.
Married
Proposed by Max Mendelsohn,
Jos. Sheinberg
Rakofsky, Miss Ida
Res. 2176 E. 13th St.
Bus. Attorney, 15 0 Bway.
Single
Rattner, Miss Selma
Res. 3 81 Schenck Ave.
Richman, Albert H.
Res. 29 Ludlam PI.
Bus. Furs, 158 W. 29th St.
Single
Proposed by Bernard Feinstein,
Harry Machler
ROSENFELD, LESTER R.
Res. 748 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Cottons, 729 Bway.
Single
Proposed by Isidor B. Rosenfeld,
Leonard Moscowitz
RUBENSTEIN, HAROLD L.
Res. 466 Crown St.
Bus. Importing, 91 Wall St.
Single
Proposed by Jack Axelrad,
Michael Kahn
ScHAEFFER, EDWARD P.
Res. 48 5 Ocean Ave.
Bus. Service Sta., 2 59 Empire Blvd.
Married
Proposed by Phil Amster,
Geo. Feldman
Schwartz, Miss Florence
Res. 1024 Montgomery St.
Proposed by Dr. Adolph M. Kellerman
Schwartz, Miss Lillian
Res. 3 85 So. 4th St.
Shapiro, Jay
Res. 339 New York Ave.
Bus. Jobbing, 72 Duane St.
Single
Proposed by Geo. A. Shapiro
Shapiro, Miss Jeanne
Res. 165 Rockaway Pkwy.
Proposed by Naomi Bachman,
Phyllis Cohen
Shlakman, Martin J.
Res. 742 Montgomery St.
Bus. Dental Equip., 141 — 5 th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Saul A. Shlakman
Shulruf, George H.
Res 1604 St. Johns PI.
Bus. Heating, 187-40 Hollis Ave.
Single
Proposed by Morris Hecht
Soicher, Miss Rhoda Anne
Res. 1103 Winthrop Ave.
Spector, Albert
Res. 789 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Real Est.
Married
Proposed by Frank Schaeffer
Spruck, Miss Thelma
Res. 2101— 76th St.
Proposed by Moriam Margolies,
Sylvia Lichtman
Schlussle, Miss Lillian
Res. 1469 President St.
Proposed by Harry Klaristenfeld
Steinberg, Herbert
Res. 160 Langhorn St.
Bus. Trucking, 756 Flushing Ave.
Married
Proposed by Harry Radutzky,
Alex Radutzky
Steinberg, Julius
Res. 8 514 Avenue B
Bus. Knitwear, 736 Flushing Ave.
Married
Proposed by Harry Radutzky,
Alex Radutzky
Weseley, Dr. Louis J.
Res. 28 5 New York Ave.
Bus. Physician, 902 Lincoln Pi.
Married
Proposed by Dr. Harry B. Weseley,
Ben Markowe
Wiskoff, Miss Gertrude
Res. 1705 President St.
Yachnowitz, Bernard
Res. 2289 E. 24th St.
Bus. Butcher, 2317 Avenue X
Single
Proposed by Rita Kaplan,
Muriel Chalkin
Zipin, Miss Arline A.
Res. 946 Bushwick Ave.
Proposed by Dr. M. S. Elsberg
The following have applied for re-
instatement:
Horowitz, Samuel
Res. 225 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Finance, 80 Wall St.
Married
Proposed by Dr. Irving L. Cohen
Senft, Henry
Res. 718 Montgomery St.
Bus. Radio Announcer
Single
Proposed by Fred Senft
Zucker, Manny
Res. 60 Clarkson Ave.
Bus. Children's Sportswear, 114 E.
17th St.
Married
Proposed by Louis Simon
LATE APPLICATIONS
Berliner, Oscar W.
Res. 2169— 74th St..
Bus. Sportswear, 141 W. 3 6th St.
Single
Proposed by Florence Gallant,
Minnie S. Cutler
Bruckner, Martin
Res. 832 Eastern Parkway
Single
Proposed by Gerald Jacobs
Kleidman, Ruben
Res. 4421 — 9th Ave.
Single
Proposed by Murray Willig,
Sam Schoenfeld
Rosenberg, David
Res. 378 Utica Avenue
Bus. Pants, 12 East 18th St.
Single
Proposed by Leo Cohen,
Stanley Levenson
Salpeter, Daniel
Res. 162 Bradford St.
Bus. Textile, 237 Church St.
Single
Proposed by Murray Willig,
Sam Schoenfeld
Swerlin, Morris
Res. 1452 Carroll St.
Bus. Board of Transportation
Single
Samuel H. Goldberg,
Chairman, Membership Committee.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
15
ANNUAL REPORT OF THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
DELIVERED BY THE PRESIDENT, EMANUEL GREENBERG
At the Annual Meeting of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center held on
January 29th the following report
on the activities for 1947 tvas given
by the President.
THE numerical growth of our mem-
bership from a hoped-for maximum
of one thousand to a membership of
two and one-half times that size has
brought about various problems of adjust-
ment. One of them was that of spiritual
leadership. It was apparent that with so
large a membership we required the ser-
vices of another rabbi who would share
with Dr. Levinthal the duties and respon-
sibilities of ministering to the needs of
our congregants. Rabbi Manuel Saltz-
man was appointed as Assistant Rabbi
and assumed his duties on September 1,
1947. Besides sharing the pulpit with
Rabbi Levinthal on Friday evenings and
on Sabbath and Holiday mornings, he
supervises the activities of the Institute
of Jewish Studies for Adults, our Junior
Congregation, the clubs for our youth,
the Post Consecration Group, etc. He
joins the Sisterhood in planning its pro-
grams and cooperates in many other Cen-
ter activities. Rabbi Lewittes, who here-
tofore served as a part-time principal of
the Hebrew School, has become the
Assistant Rabbi in charge of our Hebrew
Department. He is now serving as a
full-time principal of the afternoon He-
brew School, and of our Religious School,
which meets on Sunday mornings, and is
sharing with Rabbi Saltzman the respon-
sibility for the Junior Congregation.
Another innovation was the engage-
ment of Mr. Julius Grossman as a full-
time Musical Director of the Center. Mr.
Grossman directs the musical activities
of the Hebrew School and Junior Con-
gregation, and has recently organized a
most successful Sisterhood Chorale of
sixty women. The Ritual and Religious
Service Committee has for years been
grappling with the problem of improving
our congregational singing. Following a
number of conferences, and with the ap-
proval of the Board of Trustees, it has
embarked on the organization of a Con-
gregational Singing Group under Mr.
Grossman's leadership. This experiment
will continue for ten weeks and, if suc-
cessful, it may become a permanent fea-
ture at our Sabbath and Holiday services.
Mr. Grossman will also organize and di-
rect the Center choir for the coming
High Holy Days.
THE membership of the Center has
grown steadily in the past years and,
as of December 31, 1947, the enrollment
was 2,5 06. Of this number 1,608 were
married and 898 unmarried. At our last
annual meeting we reported a member-
ship of 2,284, comprising 1,5 3 8 married
and 746 unmarried members. Our net
gain for the year was 220, an increase
not as large as that for last year or the
year before. We must be realistic and
admit that the tremendous leap in mem-
bership from 1,000 in 1942 to more than
2,500 in 1947 was not a normal increase.
We can expect a considerable drop in the
years to come, particularly if economic
conditions should change.
Much to my regret I must report that
we have made no progress in our cam-
paign for funds to erect our Educational
Institute. In fact, no real attempt was
made to raise money for this much needed
addition to our facilities. There are sev-
eral reasons for this, the first and prin-
cipal one being that in these times of
stress for our people we felt that we must
give preference to campaigns of more im-
mediate urgency, such as the United Jew-
ish Appeal for the salvation of the Jews
in Europe and Palestine. Another rea-
son was the apathy of our members. Too
many have failed to respond to our ap-
peals for contributions to the Building
Fund. The amount raised thus far is
kept intact and will be available when
needed. A committee has recently been
appointed to devise plans for the resump-
tion of the campaign, the details of which
will be announced in the near future.
Because of the great rise in the cost of
construction, it will be necessary to re-
vise our original estimate of $2 5 0,000 for
the cost of the building. This will make
the task of the Committee even more dif-
ficult. We have confidence, however,
that the membership, which is the largest
in our history, will not fail us.
OECAUSE of war conditions we found
"^ it necessary to postpone badly needed
renovations of the Center building. Last
summer a committee consisting of Mr.
Samuel Lemberg, Dr. Moses Spatt and
Mr. Bernard J. Aaron was charged with
the responsibility of supervising these im-
provements and the results speak for
themselves. Special attention was given
to renovations in the Auditorium, Lounge
Room, Dining Room, Men's and Ladies'
Social Rooms and Ladies' Dressing Room.
The Committee did a splendid job and
we are most grateful to it.
•
The regular activities of the Center
have functioned uninterruptedly and
with considerable success.
We are conducting three schools for
the education of our youth, the After-
noon Hebrew School, the Religious
School which meets on Sundays, and the
Center Academy. The Hebrew School
has a registration of 293 boys and girls,
while the Religious School and Conse-
cration classes were attended by 290
pupils. The registration in the Center
Academy, our progressive school combin-
ing Hebrew and secular instruction, was
184. As a result of conferences between
a committee of the Board of Trustees and
a committee of the Academy, plans were
worked out for more intensive Hebrew
studies in that school. Changes were also
made in the administrative staff of the
school which, we hope, will improve its
standing in the field of Jewish and secu-
lar education. The total number of boys
and girls receiving their Hebrew educa-
tion at the Center is 767, a most impres-
sive figure.
The Ritual and Religious Service De-
partment has worked diligently to im-
prove our services and, as already noted,
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
(6
is now giving its attention to the problem
of better and more harmonious congre-
gational singing. The Friday night lec-
ture services and all the services through-
out the year were well attended.
•
The Forum Committee has added one
more activity to that of the Weekly
Forum Lectures and the Round Table
Discussion groups which meet on Mon-
day evenings through the season. Begin-
ning this year a number of course lec-
tures to be delivered on Wednesday eve-
nings have been inaugurated. These are
of an alternate character, one month be-
ing devoted to general topics and the
other to subjects of special Jewish inter-
est.
•
The Institute of Jewish Studies for
Adults sponsored by the Center has had
a considerable gain in registration. It
is now attended by 184 men and women,
who are enrolled in its courses in He-
brew, Bible, Jewish History, Religion,
Talmud, Prayer Book and Yiddish.
WE ARE proud of the publications
issued by the Center, consisting of
the monthly Brooklyn Jewish Center
Review, a literary magazine of Jewish
interest, The Weekly Bulletin, and the
Center Diary, published annually before
the High Holy Days. These publications
have been of considerable help in keeping
the membership informed of the events
of the Center and of Jewish life in gen-
eral. The Review has been given high
ranking in its field, and is read and re-
spected not only by our members, but
by the leaders of Jewish communities
throughout the country. I thank the
Editorial Board for a fine accomplishment.
•
The Library of the Center has been
advancing consistently in size and in
popularity. It now contains more than
7,000 books. Our biggest concern is to
find space to provide for its continued
growth. Like all other activities in the
building, it is suffering from crowded
conditions. The solution can only be
the early erection of the Educational
Institute.
The Sisterhood, the Young Folks
League and all the clubs for our youth
functioned successfully and provided
their membership with interesting pro-
grams and entertainment.
Our Physical Training Department had
a most successful year. The attendance
in 1947 consisted of 43,187 men, women
and children. The Center Basketball
League has been reorganized this year,
and our team is again taking a leading
part in this sport.
We have given much assistance to sev-
eral of the important Jewish fund-
raising campaigns through special com-
mittees appointed for that purpose. Fore-
most was the annual United Jewish Ap-
peal, which resulted in the raising of close
to $1,100,000. from the membership of
the Center. This was among the largest
amounts raised by any Jewish institution
in the country. The campaign for the
Federation of Jewish Philanthropies is not
yet completed. Thus far, approximately
$5 00,000. has been raised by the Center.
Our quota for the Jewish Theological
Seminary was $50,000. Through dinners
given by the Center, we are confident
that this quota will soon be reached.
•
I am not including the financial re-
port in this message. Our Treasurer, Mr.
David Goodstein, will give a special re-
port which will include this information.
• -
It is now my pleasant task to express
thanks and appreciation to some of those
who were helpful to the Center in the
past year.
First and foremost, I want to thank my
fellow officers, Dr. Moses Spatt, Hyman
Aaron, David Goodstein and Frank
Schaeffer, as well as the members of the
Board of Trustees and Governing Board.
It was their constant and unstinted co-
operation that made our success possible.
Sincere thanks are due to the officers of
the Sisterhood and Young Folks League,
as well as to the members of our insti-
tution for their loyalty and continued
support.
In your behalf and for myself, I ex-
tend thanks to our spiritual leader, Rabbi
Israel H. Levinthal. We are looking for-
ward to the forthcoming celebration of
his sixtieth birthday, an occasion when
public recognition will be given to what
he has meant to the Center and to Jewish
life in this country.
I am also grateful to our Assistant
Rabbis, Manuel Saltzman and Mordecai
Lewittes, to Dr. Elias Rabinowitz, our
Librarian, to our Cantor, William Sauler,
to our Sexton, Meyer Rogoff, to the fac-
ulties of our schools and to the members
of our staff for their splendid service to
the Center.
To my right hand, Mr. Joseph Gold-
berg, are due many thanks and much
praise for his unselfish devotion to the
Center and for giving so unstintingly of
his labor and effort to its welfare.
May I now say a personal word on the
completion of five years as your President.
You will recall that I succeeded to the
leadership from that most gracious of
men, the late Joseph M. Schwartz, of
blessed memory. I realized what a hard
task it was to follow in the footsteps of
such a hard working and self-sacrificing
leader. Now that five years has passed,
all I can say is that I did all that was in
my power to be worthy of his memory,
and of your confidence in me.
We have just ended a year that will
be memorable in the history of our peo-
ple. 1947 will be remembered as the
year when the civilized world, through
the United Nations, gave official sanction
to the establishment of a Jewish State in
the land of our ancient glory, Eretz
Israel. Now that the jubilation is over,
we must give all our energies to help
bring about the fulfillment of our two
thousand-year-old dream. Fervently do
we pray that this golden opportunity will
not find our generation remiss in its duty
to this sacred cause and that we shall
soon see the Jewish State function suc-
cessfully for the benefit of our people and
of all mankind.
EDITORIAL BOARD
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Louis J. Gribetz, Chairman
Joseph Goldberg M. H. Lewittes
Joseph Kaye Manuel Saltzman
I. H. Levinthal William I. Siegel
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
OFFICERS, MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND GOVERNING BOARD
OF THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER FOR 1948
EMANUEL GREENBERG
DR. MOSES SPATT
HYMAN AARON
FRANK SCHAEFFER
DAVID GOODSTEIN
OFFICERS
President
First Vice-President
Second Vice-President
Secretary
Treasurer
SAMUEL ROTTENBERG
Honorary President
Hyman Aaron
Maurice Bernhardt
Harry Blickstein
Isidor Fine
Jacob A. Fortunoff
Moses Ginsberg
MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES
David Soodstein Morris Miller
Emanuel Greenberg Kalman I. Ostow
Max Henfeld Samuel Rottenberg
Jacob L. Holtzmann Frank Schaeffer
Fred Kronish Nathan D. Shapiro
Samuel Lemberg Dr. Moses Spatt
Phillip Brenner
Pincus Glickman
Charles Goell
HONORARY TRUSTEES
Henry Gold
Nathan Halperin
Benjamin J. Kline
Max N. Koven
Jacob Levy
Sol Sussman
Morris Weinberg
Aaron, Bernard J.
Abelov, Saul S.
Albert, Louis
Beldock, George
Benjamin, A. David
Bernhardt, Mrs. M.
Bernstein, Alex
Blacher, Chas.
Brenner, Mrs. Ph.
Cohen, Dr. Irv. L.
Cooper, Harry
Daum, Louis
Dilbert, Chas.
Doner, Jacob S.
Fine, Chas.
Fine, Jesse J.
Finkelstein, Dr. R.
Frieman, Reuben
Ginsburg, Abraham
Gluckstein, Ira I.
Gold, David
Goldberg, Max
Goldberg, Saml. H.
Goldsmith, Herman
Goldstein, Joseph
MEMBERS OF
Goldstein, Nathaniel
Gottlieb, Aaron
Gottlieb, Isidore
Gottlieb, Irv. J.
Greenblatt, Samuel
Gribetz, Louis J.
Gross, Henry H.
Halperin, Louis
Halpern, David
Heimowitz, Jos.
Horowitz, Irv. S.
Horowitz, Mrs. Jos.
Isacowitz, Bernard
Jacobs, Gerald
Jaffe, Benj.
Joley, Albert
Kamenetzky, Saml.
Kaminsky, David B.
Kaufmann, Leo
Klinghoffer, Morton
Levenson, Dr. S. M.
Leventhal, Julius
Levine, Max H.
Levine, Morris B.
GOVERNING BOARD
Levine, Mrs. M. B.
Lowenfeld, Isador
Lowenfeld, Mrs. I.
Lurie, Leib
Markoff, Dr. S. T.
Markowe, Benj.
Martz, Benj.
Melker, Abr. R.
Miller, Dr. Solomon
Mitrani, Solomon
Neinken, Morris
Palevsky, Philip
Parnes, Louis
Pollack, Aaron
Preston, Harry
Rachmil, Hyman
Richman, Jos.
Rivkin, Louis
Rosen, Meyer
Rosenson, Ira L.
Rubin, Irvin I.
Safier, Chas.
Schiff, Lawrence
Schneider, S. A.
Schrier, Isaac
Schwartz, Harry
Schwartz, Nathan T.
Shorin, Abraham
Siegel, Wm. I.
Siegmeister, Isaac
Silberberg, I.
Simon. Louis
Sokoloff, Ralph
Spiegel, David
Stark, Abe
Stark, Joseph
Stark, Samuel
Stelzer. Abr. J.
Sterman, Jack
Turner, Herbert
Weinstein, A. A.
Weinstock, Louis
Wender, M. D.
Wiener, Mrs. I.
Wisner, Benj. H.
Witty, Mrs. Al.
Zeitz, Harry
Zimmerman, Mort.
Zirn, Abr. H.
Zwerdling, Tobias
SUSTAINING MEMBERSHIP FOR I947
The following is a list of the 1 947 sustaining members of the Brooklyn Jewish Center. We are
thankful to them for their fine spirit of cooperation and loyalty in voluntarily paying the higher
rate of membership.
Aaron, Hyman Goodstein, William Kline, Benjamin J. Schrier. Heyman
Bernard, Mrs. Louis W. Jablow, George Kronish, Fred Shapiro, Abraham
Cohen, Julius Kaplan, Benj. Lurie, Leib Shorin, Mrs. M.
Elowsky, Samuel M. Katz, Samuel Salwen, Nathan Steingut, Hon. Irwir
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
SUMMARY OF BROOKLYN JEWISH
CENTER EVENTS FOR 1947
FRIDAY NIGHT LECTURES AND
SERVICES
"Seeing Jewish Life Whole" — Rabbi
Jerome Unger — Jan. 3rd.
"Whither American Judaism" — Rabbi
Levinthal — Jan. 10th.
"Resistance in Palestine" — Rabbi Le-
wittes — Jan. 17th.
"Is the Only Choice Capitalism or
Communism?" — Dr. Sidney Goldstein —
Jan. 24th.
"Pathways Through the Bible" — Rabbi
Levinthal — Jan. 31st.
"What of the Jewish Future" — Rabbi
Abraham Nowak — Feb. 7th.
"If Lincoln Were Alive Today" —
Rabbi Lewittes — Feb. 14th.
"The Founders of Our Republic and
Their Message to Us Today" — Rabbi Lev-
inthal — Feb. 21st.
"Amelek and Haman" — A Purim Mes-
sage — Rabbi Levinthal — Feb. 28th.
"The Miracle of Hebrew Reborn" —
Rabbi Lewittes — Mar. 7th.
"What the Army has Taught Us for
Post-War Living" — Chaplain David Eich-
horn — Mar. 14th.
"The Eternity of Israel" — Rabbi Saltz-
man — Mar. 21st.
"Induction Services" — Installation of
Rabbi Manuel Saltzman as Assistant
Rabbi.
Introductory Address by Rabbi Lev-
inthal — Responding Address by Rabbi
Saltzman, Rabbi Lewittes and Judge
Emanuel Greenberg, participating.
"The American Rabbi in Israel" —
Rabbi Saltzman — Oct. 31st.
"The Balfour Declaration — The Story
of a Dream, a Struggle and Fulfillment"
— Rabbi Levinthal — Nov. 7th.
"American Jewry's Challenge to the
Rabbi" — Rabbi Saltzman — Nov. 14th.
"Blessed is the Match" — Rabbi Le-
wittes — Nov. 21st.
"The Gift for Democracy — Our Great-
est Cause for Thanksgiving" — Rabbi
Levinthal — Nov. 28th.
"The Rebirth of Our People and Our
People's Land" — Rabbi Levinthal — Dec.
5 th.
"The Dedication of the New Jewish
State — A Chanukah Sermon" — Rabbi
Saltzman — Dec. 12th.
"The Book — The Life of Our People"
— Rabbi Manuel Saltzman — Dec. 19th.
HOLIDAY SERVICES
Purim Services — Reading of the Megil-
lah— March 5 th.
First days of Passover — Dr. Levinthal,
speaker — April 6th and 7th.
Concluding days of Passover — Dr.
Levinthal and Rabbi Lewittes — April
1 1th and 12th.
Shevuoth Services — Followed by Con-
secration Services — May 25 th.
Shevuoth Services — 2nd Day — Dr.
Levinthal, speaker. Cantor Sauler offi-
ciated on both days — May 26th.
Special Baccalaureate Sermon for all
Center graduates — Dr Levinthal, speaker
— June 14th.
Tisha B'ab Services — July 26th and
27th.
Slicoth Services — Sept. 6th — Cantor
Sauler, assisted by Mr. Oscar Julius and
Choir.
Rosh Hashonah Services — Dr. Levin-
thal, speaker — "The Need for Faith in a
Faithful Age" — Sept. 15 th. Cantor
Sauler officiated throughout the holidays
together with the Julius Choir.
Second day of Rosh Hashonah — Rabbi
Saltzman, speaker — "Seeing God from
Afar" — Sept. 16th.
Rosh Hashonah Services in the Audi-
torium — Rev. Max Hoeflich, officiating.
Sermons amplified from the Main Syn-
agogue on both days.
Kol Nidre Services — "Peace of Mind
— Can It Be Attained" — Dr. Levinthal,
speaker — Sept. 23rd.
Kol Nidre Services in Auditorium —
Rabbi Saltzman, speaker — "Changing
Human Nature" — Sept. 23rd.
Yom Kippur Services — Dr. Levinthal
— "The Twofold Task Facing the Amer-
ican Jew Today" — Sept. 24th.
Yom Kippur Services in the Audi-
torium — Rev. Max Hoeflich, officiating
— Sermons amplified from Main Syna-
gogue — Sept. 24th.
Junior Congregation Services for the
RELIGIOUS
EDUCATIONAL
RECREATIONAL
SOCIAL
High Holidays under leadership of Rabbi
Lewittes.
Succoth Services — Dr. Levinthal,
speaker — "The Significance of the Fes-
tival" — Sept. 29th.
Concluding Succoth Services — Dr.
Levinthal, speaker — Oct. 7th and 8 th.
MONDAY NIGHT FORUMS
Rabbi Morris Adler — "American Jewry
— A Critique and an Appraisal" — Jan.
6th.
Frances Perkins — "The Destiny of
Labor" — Jan. 13 th.
O. John Rogge — "The Challenge to
Democracy" — Jan. 20th.
Father Michael J. Ahem — "Design for
Racial and Religious Understanding" —
Feb. 3rd.
Percy Chen and Chu Tong — Debate —
"Should the United States Continue to
Support the Nationalist Government in
China?"
Gen. Yakhontoff and Prof. Sydney
Hook — Debate — "Russian Foreign Pol-
icy" — Feb. 24th.
Hilda Yatsing Yen — "United Nations
and World Peace" — Mar. 3rd.
Prof. Israel Efros — "Travels Among
European Jews" — Mar. 10th.
Dr. Solomon Goldman — "World Crisis
and American Jewry" — Mar. 24th.
Max Lerner — "America and the Crisis
of Our Times" — Nov. 17th.
Gerold Frank — "Behind the Headlines
in Palestine" — Nov. 24th.
Prof. Henry Pratt Fairchild and Prof.
Sydney Hook — Debate — "Which Way
American Foreign Policy? — Truman or
Wallace" — Dec. 1st.
Leon Henderson — "What Can Be Done
About the High Cost of Living?" — Dec.
8 th.
Dr. Carl Herman Voss — "Fascism in
the Guise of Religion" — Dec. 22nd.
ROUND TABLE DISCUSSIONS
Discussion of "Thieves in the Night"
— by Arthur Koestler — Hon. William I.
Siegel — Jan. 27th.
Discussion of "Resolved That the Use
of Violent Resistance in Palestine is Un-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
I?
justified and Should be Discouraged" —
Judge A. David Benjamin and Harry A.
Harrison — Feb. 17th.
Discussion of "Do Teachers Have the
Right to Strike?" — Samuel Wallach and
Samson Inselbuch — Mar. 17th.
Discussion of "High Prices — Their
Causes, Effects and Remedies" — Dr.
Jacob Klein — Harry Cooper, moderator
—Dec. 15th.
YIDDISH LECTURES
May 11th — Yiddish Literary Evening
— Translation of Shakespeare's "King
Lear" by Dr. Abraham Asen. Other par-
ticipants: A. Glanz, Mordecai Jaffe, Abr.
Reisen, fm, Edlin, Dr. S. Simon, A.
Teitelbaum, A. Lutzky, Al Harris and
A. L. Baron. Proceeds donated to fund
for European Jewish writers.
WEDNESDAY EVENING COURSE
LECTURES
"Modern Literature" — Charles Lee.
Dec. 3rd — "How to Enjoy Reading."
Dec. 10th — "Current Fiction Best
Sellers."
Dec. 17th — "Current Non-Fiction
Best Sellers."
SISTERHOOD ACTIVITIES
Jan. 13th — Meeting — Discussion of
"Who Are to be Our Leaders and
Teachers of the Future" by Mrs. Isaac
Wiener — Musical Program.
Jan. 30th — Installation and election of
officers at the Annual Meeting of the
Center.
Feb. 19th — Meeting — Report of the
"World Zionist Congress' by Mrs. Han-
nah O. Jaffe. Musical program by Miss
Lucy Kelston, Soprano.
Mar. 10th — Dessert Luncheon for the
purpose of raising a "Torah Scholarship
Fund" — Entertainment by Irene Rosen-
berg, Pianist, and Sylvia Rosenberg,
Violinist.
Apr. 14th — Evening meeting — Review
of "Gentlemen's Agreement" by Mrs.
Naomi Finkelstein.
Apr. 17th and 29th — Participation in
the United Jewish Appeal Luncheons at
the Hotel Plaza.
May 12 th — Closing meeting of season
— Program celebrating Mother's Day.
June 4th — Sisterhood Executive Board
— Closing Luncheon.
June 9th — United Jewish Appeal Tea.
Oct. 13th — Opening meeting of sea-
son — "Jewish Home Beautiful" — Rabbi
Saltzman, narrator — Chants by Cantor
Wm. Sauler — Greetings by Dr. Levinthal.
Oct. 22nd — Annual Mother-Daughter
Luncheon.
Nov. 17th — Participation in "Night
of Stars."
Oct. 23rd — Sisterhood Chorale Or-
ganized — Julius Grossman, Leader.
Oct. 27th-28th-29th — Participation in
Women's Division, Federation of Jewish
Philanthropies Luncheons.
Nov. 10th — Meeting — Hon. William
I. Siegcl, speaker — "Palestine Before the
United Nations" — Movie Film.
Dec. 15th — Meeting — Shulamith Perl-
berg, Vocalist — Shifrah Baraks, Monolo-
gist — "The Current Jewish Scene" by
Rabbi Saltzman — Community Singing
led by Julius Grossman.
YOUNG FOLKS LEAGUE
Jan. 7th — Meeting — Social evening.
Jan. 14th — Meeting — Rabbi Mordecai
H. Lewittes, speaker — "Jewish Customs
and Traditions."
Jan. 2 1st — Business meeting — Social
hour.
Jan. 28 th — Cocktail Party for the
"March of Dimes" project.
Feb. 4th — Meeting — Social evening.
Feb. 1 1 th — Business meeting — Social
hour.
Feb. 18 th — Meeting — Social evening.
Feb. 2 5th — Meeting — Social evening.
Mar. 4th — Purim Party — Dancing and
Cocktails — Clothing drive for SOS.
Mar. 1 1 th — Business meeting — Prep-
aration for Convention of Young Peo-
ples' League of the United Synagogue of
America — Social hour.
Mar. 23rd — Participation in Annual
Convention of Young Peoples' League of
the United Synagogue.
Mar. 2 5th — Cultural meeting — Dis-
cussion on "Orthodox, Conservative and
Reform Judaism" — Social hour.
Apr. 8 th — Professional Talent Night
— Hy Rosen, Master of Ceremonies —
Arthur Marcus, Pianist.
Apr. 13 th — Dance in behalf of the
United Jewish Appeal.
Apr. 15th — Meeting — Election of offi-
cers and members of the Executive Board.
Apr. 22nd — Talent Night — Herbert
Levine and Arthur Marcus participating.
May 20th — Game Night and social
hour.
June 3rd — Meeting of Roof Garden —
Dancing and social hour.
June 10th — Dance in behalf of the
United Jewish Appeal.
June 17th — Participation in Hapoel
Soccer Game at Ebbets Field.
June 24th — Roof Garden meeting —
Social hour.
Sept. 1st — Participation in Young
Peoples' League Labor Day Week-end at
Camp Cejwin.
Sept. 24th — Yom Kippur Night
Dance.
Oct. 7th — Season's opening meeting —
Social hour.
Oct. 14th — Meeting — Social hour.
Oct. 2 1st — Meeting — Film showing
and social evening.
Nov. 4th — Election Night Social Get-
Together.
Nov. 11th — Meeting — Professional
Talent from Center Membership Social.
Nov. 15 th — Participation in Young
Peoples' League Dance at Temple Ansche
Chesed.
Nov. 18th — Meeting — Group discus-
sion on "Jewish Contributions to Art and
Literature."
Nov. 2 5th — Dance for the Damon
Runyon Cancer Fund.
Dec. 9th — Social Get-Together — Pro-
gram of entertainment.
Dec. 1 6th — Celebration of "Jewish
Book Month" — Gideon Schocken, Guest
Speaker.
Dec. 23rd and 30th — Social Gct-
Togethers.
PHYSICAL TRAINING COMMITTEE
Basketball Games
B.J.C. vs. Jersey City "Y" — Jan. 5 th.
B.J.C. vs. Union League of Deaf
Mutes — Jan. 12 th.
B.J.C. vs. Pelham Parkway House —
Jan. 19th.
B.J.C. vs. Arverne Club — Jan. 26th.
B.J.C. vs. Spartan A. C— Feb. 9th.
B.J.C. vs. Union Temple — Feb. 12th.
B.J.C. vs. Pelham Parkway A. A. —
Feb. 16th.
B.J.C. vs. Grand Street Boys — Feb.
23 rd.
B.J.C. vs. Jersey Park A. A. — Mar.
2nd.
B.J.C. vs. New York Collegiates —
Mar. 9th.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
B.J.C. vs. Hebrew Educational So-
ciety — Mar. 16th.
B.J.C. vs. Union Temple — Mar. 23rd.
B.J.C. vs. College All-Stars — Mar.
30th.
B.J.C. vs. Park A. A. of New Jersey
— Nov. 9th.
B.J.C. vs. Grand Street Boys — Nov.
16th.
B.J.C. vs. Collegiate All-Stars — Nov.
23 rd.
B.J.C. vs. Boro Park "Y" — Nov.
30th.
B.J.C. vs. 92nd Street "Y" — Dec.
14th.
B.J.C. vs. Washington Heights "Y" —
Dec. 21st.
B.J.C. vs. Bronx College All-Stars —
Dec. 28th.
JUNIOR ACTIVITIES
Maccabees and Tzofim — Game Night
— Jan. 4th.
Junior League — Meeting — Discussion
on "Shall We Accept or Reject Partition
as a Solution for the Question of Pales-
tine — Jan. 9th.
Inta-League Girls — Discussion on best
sellers dealing with Palestine — Jan. 18th.
Inta-League Boys — Discussion — "The
Madison Square Garden" — Jan. 18th.
Junior League — Meeting — Social and
dancing — Jan. 23rd.
Junior League — Meeting — Film —
"Home Are the Hunted" — Dancing —
Feb. 6th.
Inta-League Girls and Boys — Joint
party celebrating Chamisha Oser B'shvat
— Feb. 1st.
Junior League — Novelty Dance — Feb.
13 th.
Inta-League Girls and Boys — Annual
Theatre Party at the Provincetown Play-
house — Feb. 15 th.
Junior League — Meeting — Stunt
Night, Marty Karlin, Leader — Social hour
and dancing — Feb. 20th.
Junior League — Meeting — Social and
cultural evening — Feb. 27th.
Junior Clubs — Joint Music Festival
given by the Music Division of the Youth
Groups to all Junior Clubs — Feb. 27th.
Junior League — Meeting — Rabbi Le-
wittes, speaker — "Purim in Palestine" —
Mar. 13 th.
Junior League — Novelty Night — Scav-
enger — Mar. 20th.
Junior League — Meeting — Rabbi Le-
wittes, speaker — "Passover in Palestine"
—Mar. 27th.
Inta-League Clubs — Carnival in behalf
of the United Jewish Appeal — Mar. 29th.
Junior League — Meeting — Discussion
of "Gentlemen's Agreement" — Dancing
— Apr. 3rd.
Junior League — Spring Hop — Apr.
12th.
Inta-League Clubs — Films on Palestine
and Comedies — May 10th.
Junior League — Meeting — Social eve-
ning — May 15 th.
Junior League — Meeting — Larry Green
of Jewish War Veterans, speaker —
"Fighting Hate Groups" — May 22nd.
Junior League — Meeting — Musical
Quiz — Mar. 29th.
Junior League — Meeting — Discussion
"Operation Nevez" in cooperation with
the Crown Heights Yeshiva — June 4th.
Junior League — Business meeting —
Plan discussion for closing affair of sea-
son — June 12th.
Junior League — Closing social — Danc-
ing and entertainment — June 23 rd.
Junior League — Opening of season —
Meeting — Sept. 13 th.
Junior and Intermediate Clubs — Open-
ing Meeting — Oct. llth.
Junior League — Novelty Night — Oct.
16th.
Junior League — Meeting — Discussion
of "The Problem of Inter-Marriage" by
Rabbi Lewittes — Oct. 23rd.
Junior League — Meeting — Social eve-
ning — Nov. 6th.
Junior League — Meeting — Panel dis-
cussion on "Does College Contribute
More Than the Business World in the
Development of Personality?" — Nov.
13th.
Junior League — Musical Program — So-
cial evening — Nov. 20th.
Junior League — Thanksgiving Social —
Nov. 27th.
Junior Clubs — Joint celebration of
"Jewish State" — Palestinian songs and
dances — Nov. 29th.
Inta-League Clubs — Celebration of
"Jewish Book Month" — Book Reviews
and Quizzes — Nov. 29th.
Junior League — Meeting — Discussion
— "The Jew on the American Literary
Scene" in celebration of "Jewish Book
Month" — Dec. 4th.
Junior Clubs — Chanukah celebration —
Skits and Festival Songs — Dec. 6th.
Junior League — Chanukah Pageant —
Dec. llth.
Junior League — Business meeting —
Discussion of plans for the Vacation
Dance — Dec. 18th.
Junior League — Vacation Dance — Dec.
30th.
SOCIAL ACTIVITIES
Annual Meeting — Election and Instal-
lation of Officers — Jan. 30th.
Participation in Borough Dinner on be-
half of the Jewish Theological Seminary
— Judge Emanuel Greenberg, Chairman
—Feb. 26th.
Membership Social — Jewish Music Fes-
tival — Dvora Lapson, Elia Belsin and
Gadl Saleski — Mar. 5th.
Passover Sedorim — Apr. 4th and 5 th.
Annual Dinner in behalf of the United
Jewish Appeal — Mr. Samuel Lemberg,
Chairman — May 1st.
Membership Social — Program by Hy
Rosen, Arthur Marcus and John Prince
Mendez — May 7th.
Participation in sale of tickets for the
Hapoel Soccer Game at Ebbets Field —
June 17th.
Membership Social — Entertainment by
Israel Welichansky, Character Portrayals
— Murray Schnee, Concert Violinist —
Hapoel Hamizrachi Youth Choral — Oct.
2nd.
Center dinner in behalf of Federation
of Jewish Philanthropies. Mr. Samuel
Lemberg, guest of honor — Oct. 30th.
Membership Social — Entertainment by
Emil Boreo — Ken Whitmer — Nov. llth.
Thanksgiving Dinner for Center mem-
bers — Nov. 27th.
Jewish Book Night — Speakers — Dr.
Levinthal, Mrs. Sophie Udin Ginguld —
Cantor Sauler, Soloist — Dec. 2nd.
Membership Social — Chanukah Pro-
gram — Eli Mintz — Yfrah Neaman, Pal-
estinian Violinist, and Cantor Wm.
Sauler accompanied by Sisterhood Chorale
—Dec. 9 th.
New Year's Eve Dinner and Dance —
Dec. 31st.
HEBREW AND SUNDAY SCHOOL
ACTIVITIES
Jan. 26th — Pargod (Hebrew Theater
party).
Feb. 5 th — Chamisha Asar Beshvat cel-
ebration.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
21
Feb. 23rd — Annual Children's Assem-
bly at Hunter College.
Feb. 27th — United Parent-Teachers
Association Meeting.
Mar. 5 th — Children's Magillah reading.
Mar. 6th — Purim Class Parties.
Mar. 9th — Purim School Entertain-
ment.
Mar. 16th — Histadrut Ivrit Campaign.
Apr. 1st — Model Seder.
Apr. 4th- 12 th — Passover Vacation.
Apr. 13th — Theater Party, "Rich Man
— Poor Man."
Apr. 14th — PTA meeting. Rabbi Gor-
don speaker on "A Chaplain Views Jewish
Education."
May 11th — Lag B'Omer Assembly.
May 15 th — PTA meeting. Mr. Eman-
uel Edelstein, speaker. Topic, "Educa-
tional Standards."
May 18th — Hebrew Educators Cam-
paign for funds.
May 2 5th — Consecration Exercises.
June Sth — Palestine Exhibit Outing.
June 15 th — Hebrew and Sunday
School Graduations.
June 15 th — Inter-School Music Rally.
June 22nd — Kerem Ami Allocation of
Funds.
June 24 th — Promotion Day.
June 26th — Teachers' End-term Meet-
ing.
Sept. 4th — Opening of Hebrew School.
Sept. 28th — Opening of Sunday
School.
Oct. 6th — Simchat Torah Procession
and Initiation.
Oct. 19th — G. O. Assembly.
Nov. 23rd — Thanksgiving Assembly
and play.
Dec. 7th — Chanukah Entertainment.
Dec. 31st — Winter vacation.
Dec. 31st— J.N.F. Drive. $405. col-
lected and a garden planted in Palestine
as a reward.
HEBREW EDUCATION COMMITTEE
(a) Institute of Jewish Studies
for Adults
Dr. Israel H. Levinthal, Director.
Rabbi Manuel Saltzman, Associate Di-
rector.
Mrs. E. N. Rabinowitz, Secretary.
Hebrew A-l: Every Thursday at 8
P.M., Mrs. Eveelyn Zusman, Instructor.
Hebrew A-2: Every Thursday at 8
P.M., Mr. Samuel Edelheit, Instructor.
Hebrew B: Every Thursday at 8 P.M.,
Mrs. Paula Weinreb, Instructor.
Hebrew C: Every Thursday at 8 P.M.,
Mrs. Jean Serbin-Beder, Instructor.
Advanced Hebrew and Bible in He-
brew: Every Thursday, 8:30-10 P.M.,
Miss Lillie Rubee, Instructor.
Yiddish: Every Thursday at 7 P.M.,
Mr. Samuel Edelheit, Instructor.
Religion: Every Thursday at 9 P.M.,
Rabbi Manuel Saltzman, Instructor.
History: Every Tuesday at 8 P.M.,
Mr. Leo Shpall, Instructor.
Talmud A: Every Tuesday at 9 P.M.,
Dr. Michael Higger, Instructor.
Talmud B: Every Tuesday at 8 P.M.,
Dr. Michael Higger, Instructor.
Special Day Classes —
Religion and Bible: Every Wednesday
morning 10-12, Dr. Alexander J. Burn-
stein, Instructor.
Prayer Book: Every Monday morning
10-12, Mr. Leo Shpall, Instructor.
(b) Three-Day Week Hebrew
School
Meets weekdays from 4 to 6 P.M.,
Sundays at 9:45 and 11:15 A.M. Cur-
riculum includes Hebrew, Chumash, Sid-
dur, Jewish History and Music.
(c) Religious School
Primary department, kindergarten
through 5 th grade, meets every Sunday
from 10 A.M. to 12 M. Boys beyond
third grade are required to attend He-
brew School. Girls in the upper three
grades (6, 7 and 8) attend an additional
session during the week.
(d) Post-Graduate Class
Meets from 10 A.M. to 1 P.M. every
Sunday. Restricted to graduates of the
Hebrew School and Center Academy.
Curriculum includes Hebrew literature,
Tanach and Jewish History.
(e) Consecration Group of Girls
Every Sunday morning, 10 to 12.
(f) Post Bar-Mitzvah Fellowship
Meets every Sunday morning from 10
to 12.
(g) Florence Marshall Hebrew
High School
Meets three times weekly. Four-year
course.
(h) Post-Consecration Group
Junior Group, meets the last Monday
of each month at the Center.
Senior Group, meets every third
Wednesday of month with Rabbi Saltz-
man at home of a Post-Consecrant.
(i) Junior Congregation
The children of the Hebrew School
meet every Saturday morning and dur-
ing holidays in the Beth Hamedrash. Ser-
mons are delivered by the members of
the Hebrew School Faculty and guest
speakers. High Holy Day services for the
Junior Congregation were held during
Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur.
HEBREW AND SUNDAY SCHOOL
FACULTIES
Dr. Israel H. Levinthal, Director;
Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Principal;
Mrs. E. N. Rabinowitz, Registrar; Mr.
Julius Grossman, Musical Director; Miss
Phyllis Polikoff, Secretary. Mr. Samuel
Edelheit, Mr. Leo Shpall, Mrs. Jean
Serbin-Beder, Mrs. Paula Weinreb, Mrs.
Evelyn Zusman, Mr. Yehudi Cohen,
Mr. George Epstein, Mr. Murry Gabel;
Mrs. Nellie Cohen, High School Depart-
ment; Sunday School: Miss Judith Abel-
*son, Miss Mildred Mogilensky, Miss
Chayah Weisgal, Miss Hannah Wiedman,
Miss Lila Marcus, Miss Laura Sorscher,
Mrs. Miriam Tessler, Mr. Jacob Grumet,
Mr. Irving Gabel, Mr. Seymour Wadler;
Miss Laura Viders for the Consecration
Class and Mr. Irvin Rubin for the Post-
Bar Mitzvah Fellowship.
Saturday Afternoon Class
Meets every Saturday afternoon
throughout the season. Rabbi Gerson
Abelson, speaker.
Classes in Talmud and Mishnayith
Class in Talmud meets Saturday after-
noon throughout the year. Mr. Jacob
S. Doner, Instructor.
CENTER CLUBS
Young Folks' League — Unmarried
Center members as well as children of
members, males over 21 years and females
over 18 years.
Masada Chapter — Young men and
women of college age. Zionist and social
program. Meets weekly.
Junior League — Boys 17-20. Girls
16-19. Meets every Thursday night.
Inta-League Boys — Boys in junior
and senior years of high school. Cultural
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
athletic and social program. Meets every
Saturday night.
Inta-League Girls — Girls in high
school. Cultural and social program.
Meets every Saturday night.
ANU — Boys and girls of high school
age. Intensive Jewish program impro-
vising the tutoring of Judaism. Meets
Monday nights.
Shomrim — Boys in the first two years
of high school. Young Judean and ath-
letic activities. Meets every Saturday
night.
Vivalets — Girls in the upper grades.
Young Judean and social program. Meets
every Saturday night.
Tzofim and Maccabees — Boys in ele-
mentary school. Young Judean and ath-
letic program. Meets every Saturday
night.
Candle-Lites — Girls up to 11. Games,
Arts and Crafts. Meets every Saturday
night.
Boy Scout and Girl Scout Troops.
Center Clubs are open to the children
of Center members and to the students
of Center schools. The clubs are guided
by expert leaders under the supervision
of Rabbi Saltzman.
RECORD OF BAR MITZVAHS
Robert Allen Stachenfeld, son of Mr.
and Mrs. Wilfred Stachenfeld— Jan. 4th.
Leonard Allen Gottlieb, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Irving J. Gottlieb — Jan. 11th.
Donald and Morton Manes, twin sons
of Mr. and Mrs. Edward Manes— Jan.
18 th.
Thomas Blumberg, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Jack N. Blumberg — Jan. 25 th.
Philip Alan Silverman, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Nathan Silverman — Feb. 1st.
Jonathan Chernoble, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Samuel Chernoble — Feb. 8 th.
Elliott George Levy, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Joseph Levy, Jr. — Feb. 22nd.
Howard Lieberman, son of Mr. and
Mrs. S. H. Lieberman — Feb. 22nd.
Jack Stewart Caplan, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Henry Caplan — Mar. 1st.
Joseph Kofsky, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Irving Kofsky — Mar. 1st.
Norbert Weissberg, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Bernard Weissberg — Mar. 8th.
Jed Isaacs, son of Mr. and Mrs. Edward
Isaacs — Mar. 15 th.
Paul Beldock, son of Hon. and Mrs.
George J. Beldock — Mar. 22nd.
David S. Kenin, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Louis Kenin — Apr. 19th.
Harold Mitrani, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Solomon Mitrani — Apr. 26th.
Chester Feldman, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Abr. Feldman — May 3rd.
Michael Aronchick, son of Dr. and
Mrs. George C. Aronchick — May 3rd.
Milton Sheldon Herman, son of Mr.
and Mrs. Samuel Herman — May 10th.
Edward Roy Haiken, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Benjamin Haiken — May 10th.
Simon Harrison Jerrold, son of Dr. and
Mrs. Harry E. Jerrold — May 17th.
Philip Rubin, son of Mr. and Mrs. Mil-
ton Rubin — May 17th.
David Samuel Rosen, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Abraham N. Rosen — May 24th.
Jay P. Joseph, son of Mrs. Arthur Jo-
seph — May 31st.
Edward Kaplan, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Simuel Kaplan — May 31st.
;-rry Marder, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Murray Marder — May 31st.
Louis and Abraham Dan, twin sons of
Dr. and Mrs. Julius M. Dan — June 7th.
Stephen Mark David, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Louis David — June 14th.
Stephen Roger Leventhal, son of Ethel
S. Leventhal and Norman Leventhal —
June 14th.
Morton Bromberg, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Micheal Bromberg — June 21st.
Irwin Nelson, son of Dr. and Mrs.
Louis S. Nelson — June 21st.
Jacob Soloway, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Hyman Soloway — June 21st.
Andrew Volet, son of Mr. and Mrs.
William B. Volet— June 28th.
David Lawrence Siegel, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Milton Siegel — June 28th.
Edward Elliott Sharkey, son of Mr. and
Mrs. David Sharkey— July 5 th.
Martin Kramer, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Irving Kramer — Sept. 13 th.
Jerry Buchalter, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Seymour Buchalter — Sept. 20th.
Gerald and Ira Rosenbloom, twin sons
of Mr. and Mrs. Hillie Rosenbloom — Oct.
11th.
William Fischer, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Jack Fischer — Oct. 11th.
Ronald Neuwirth, son of Mr. and Mrs.
George Neuwirth — Oct. 18th.
Stanley Shapiro, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Michael Shapiro— Oct. 25 th.
Jonah Atlas, son of Mr. and Mrs. Her-
man Atlas — Nov. 1st.
Harry B. Lipton, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Murray Lipton — Nov. 8 th.
Samuel M. Rappaport, son of Mr. and
Mrs. Murray Rappaport — Nov. 22nd.
Edmund Stelzer, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Abraham J. Stelzer — Nov. 29th.
Charles Diker, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Daniel Diker — Dec. 6th.
David Heller, son of Mr. and Mrs. Jo-
seph Heller — Dec. 13 th.
William Goldstein, son of Mr. and Mrs.
Isaac Goldstein — Dec. 20th.
Irving Dworetzky, son of Dr. and Mrs.
Morris Dworetzky — Dec. 27th.
CENTER ACADEMY EVENTS
Jan. 15 th — Meeting of P.T.A. Dr.
Milton I. Levine, speaker; topic, "Child
Discipline."
Feb. 6th — Meeting of 8 th Grade par-
ents to discuss High Schools — Mrs. Soskin
and Mrs. Greenstein, speakers.
Feb. 12th — Brotherhood Assembly.
Feb. 19th— Meeting of P.T.A. Rabbi
Israel H. Levinthal, speaker; topic, "Edu-
cational Philosophy Underlying Our Cen-
ter Academy."
Mar 6th — Purim Celebration.
Mar. 19th — P.T.A. meeting. The
Community Folk Dance Group entertain
and conduct folk dancing for member-
ship.
Mar. 19th — Registration for school
year 1947-48 opens.
Apr. 1st — Seder conducted by the
pupils of Center Academy.
Apr. 16th— Meeting of P.T.A. Dr.
Norman Kelman, practicing psychiatrist
associated with the Jewish Board of Guar-
dians and American Institute of Psycho-
analysis, speaker; topic, "Building Emo-
tional Security in Children."
May 21st — Closing meeting of P.T.A.
for the term. Election of officers of the
P.T.A. for year 1947-48 and report of
the surveys of the school given by Dr.
Solomon J. Miller, President Board of
Trustees of Center Academy.
May 25 th — Shevuoth celebration.
June 11th — Graduation.
June 13 th — School closes.
Sept. 8th — School opened.
Oct. 5 th — Succoth celebration.
Oct. 29th — Executive Board meeting
of P.T.A.
Nov. 3rd — School open for visitors.
Nov. 5 th — Executive Board meeting
of P.T.A.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
Nov. 10th — Armistice Day Assembly.
Nov. 19th — First Meeting of P.T.A.
Report by Educational Committee. ,
Nov. 26th — Thanksgiving Assembly.
Dec. 2nd — Jewish Book Month Cele-
bration. Graduating class in charge of
Juvenile Exhibit.
Dec. 11th — Chanukah celebration.
Dec. 17th — Classroom meetings of the
P.T.A.
The Jews In Vienna
[Continued from page 6]
correspondent, I. F. Stone, who described
it as follows:
"Its squalor and vitality contrast with
the faded loveliness of the city. When
we marched up, the sidewalk and the
steps were crowded with refugees waiting
to greet any friends, relatives, or com-
rades they might find among the new-
comers. There were cries of joy, kisses
and hugs, when some of those waiting
recognized people they knew in our
group. . . . We were shepherded through
the crowds and down a dark staircase
into a basement full of people. We
passed rooms used as a trades school and
as a repair shop for shoes and clothing
into a large room for our medical exam-
ination. ... To march across borders
illegally, stateless and homeless, without
documents, and then to come at last to
a place where one meets a friendly re-
ception, where one is given an identity
card, is something only a refugee can
fully appreciate. One suddenly becomes
a person, with a name, a number, and
a paper. One now has a right to move
freely in the American zone of Austria.
This privilege and this blessing the Jew-
ish refugee owes to the American occu-
pying forces."
Very often the Viennese, hungry and
insecure as they are, blame all their ills
on the DP's, especially the Jewish ones
— even if the latter constitutes less than
one-tenth of the entire DP population
of Austria. Crypto-Nazis foster anti-
Semitism whenever possible (although the
statement that Jewish lives will be threat-
ened after the end of occupation seem
to be exaggerated). So far, only a few
Austrians have begun to realize that it
is they who are to be blamed for the
catastrophe of 1938 and the seven lean
years of Nazism, since they had never
been truly democratic, truly peace-loving
people. But perhaps it is unfair to argue
with those existing on a starvation diet.
(This is, at least, the opinion of Chief
Rabbi Dr. Leo Baeck concerning the Ger-
man people!) It is true that in order to
better the life of Austrian Jewry the
living conditions of all Austrians, regard-
less of faith and origin, will have to be
improved. But it remains to be seen
whether the Austrians will prove worthy
of the trust put in them by the world
once the substantial loan they are going
to receive under the Marshall Plan will
have diminished their economic worries.
U. J. A. Campaign
[Continued from page 4]
United Jewish Appeal this year. The
lives of our brethren in Eretz Israel de-
pends on our money and our aid.
In most communities the U.J.A. drive
for the unprecedented sums needed will
soon be launched. The complete mobil-
ization of all the energies of the Ameri-
can Jewish community is needed in order
to insure the success of this effort to pro-
vide for the national defense and the eco-
nomic strength of the new Jewish State.
All Zionist organizations have already
pledged themselves to form a United
Front for U.J.A. by cooperating with
local committees conducting the cam-
paign and by not engaging in any pub-
licity or activity which may divert Zion-
ists for this major campaign.
We usually think of the Yishuv in
Eretz Israel as being only the recipient of
American dollars and campaign funds.
But the Yishuv itself is setting an exam-
ple of generosity and self-sacrifice which
is beyond all praise. It is planning to
announce an increase in its quota for na-
tional defense from two million dollars
to a minimum of eight million dollars.
This does not include its own campaigns
for the Jewish National Fund, Keren
Hayesod, etc. Thus, the Yishuv is not
only providing the manpower in the
struggle for a Jewish State, but is doing
more than its share in contributing eco-
nomically along with American Jews to
the campaign.
Every American Jew must set his heart
and his mind to work to provide for
Jewish defense and for the new Jewish
State. We who are most fortunate must
not fail in our responsibility to Eretz
Israel and to our people.
— M. S.
HYMAN
SPITZ inc.
OUR ONLY STORE
Dickens 2-4000
1685 PITKIN AVENUE
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
■ ■
ABBOT'FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES— SERVICE
507 Flatbuth Avenue
JESSE J. FINE Brooklyn, New York
J/\£K ABBOT Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
RIVERSIDE-
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2-6600
Far Rockaway, L. I. Miami Beach, Florida
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE 1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
FAr Rockaway 7-7100 Miami 5-7777
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle, we have arranged to
serve your Community. We have at our disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn.
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed
Sec. 562, P. L. ft R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
W
ISRAEL H.
LEVWTHAL
The Brooklyn Jewish Center and The American Jewish
Community Honor Rabbi Levinthal on His Sixtieth Birthday
• CENTER BULLETIN BOARD •
F1 BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
orura Lectures and Discussions
CONCLUDING FORUM LECTURE
of the Season
MONDAY EVENING, MARCH 29th
at 8:30 o'clock
•
/Speaker
JOHN HAYNES HOLMES
Famous liberal preacher, minister of the
Community Church. Dr. Holmes has re-
cently returned from an extended trip to
Asia and Europe.
•
Subject
"WHAT THE WORLD LOOKS LIKE
TODAY — THE OBSERVATIONS OF
A WORLD TRAVELER' 7
9
Admission to the lecture will be free to mem-
bers. Non-members will be charged 40^ in-
cluding tax.
PASSOVER SEDORIM
will be conducted at
THE CENTER
Friday and Saturday Evenings
April 23 and 24
The Srdorim will be conducted by
Rabbi Israel H. Levinthal
with the assistance of
Cantor William Sauler
Final Basketball Came
of the Season
This Sunday Evening, March 28th
Brooklyn Jewish Center
vs
All Star Team
Conisting of leading basketball players in the city
Preliminary Game at 8:00 P. M.
Admission
Center members — 75c (incl. tax)
Non-members — $1.20 (incl. tax)
DRAMA
The Young Folks Talent Group will present
at the meeting on March 30 its annual thea-
trical production — "The Happy Ending
of a Gruesome Ghost" The performance
will begin promptly at 9:00 P. M.
A Social Hour Will Follow
Admission only by presentation of 1948
membership cards.
MUSIC
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
CHORAL SOCIETY
• Join our newly formed Mixed Choir
• Open to all men and women of the com-
munity
• Sing in four part harmony
• Songs of Palestine, Hebrew melodies,
American Folk Songs, Negro Spirituals
• Come and Bring a Friend
• No Musical Requirements
Rehearsals Every Tuesday at 8:00 P. M.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Vol. XXIX
MARCH, 1948 — ADAR-II, 5708
No. 28
Center Celebrates Sixtieth Birthday of Dr. Israel H. Levinthal
The Brooklyn Jewish Center and leaders in public life are taking pleasure in honoring Dr.
Levinthal on the occasion of his reaching the three-score milestone. Fete men in the American
Jewish community have led so useful and distinguished a life as has Dr. Levinthal, and few have
received the affection that has warmed his career. The "Review" joins in celebrating this anniver-
sary.
RABBI LEVINTHAL AT SIXTY
By LOUIS J. GRIBETZ
A GRATEFUL and affectionate
congregation at the Brooklyn
Jewish Center is paying homage
to its revered Rabbi and spiritual leader,
Dr. Israel H. Levinthal, on the occasion
of his sixtieth birthday. This anniversary,
in which the community at large will also
participate, will be marked by appropriate
ceremonies and festivities at the Center,
including a public celebration on April
6th, and a dinner on April 8 th, and the
publication of this special dedicatory is-
sue of the Center Review. X nrou g n
these events the membership and the com-
muity will not only express their deep ad-
miration and affection for the Rabbi, but
will also draw renewed inspiration and
fresh stimulation from his life and work.
The occasion has already called forth a
great outpouring of messages in praise of
Dr. Levinthal from local and national
organizations and representative lay and
religious leaders in the community and
country. These tributes express high ap-
preciation of Dr. Levinthal's character
and ideals, acclaim his noted and sincere
contributions as a religious and communal
leader, and bear testimony to the debt his
people owe him for his ardent and useful
public service.
Dr. Levinthal may derive deep satis-
faction from hearing the full chorus of
"well done" from the multitudes who
delight in honoring him. To receive
commendation from those who are them-
selves praiseworthy is a priceless reward.
Dr. Levinthal has added reason to re-
joice. He is very happy in his personal
life; he is successful in the career he
planned in his youth; he can witness the
luxuriant blossoming of the Center un-
der the leadership indefatigably rendered
by him over long and troublous years;
he has the confidence and affection of
the entire Jewish community; his keen
and fertile mind holds promise of many
more years of signal intellectual achieve-
ment.
The lavish opulence of welcome and
tribute to Dr. Levinthal has more than
personal significance. It points a moral
to the American rabbinate and to Amer-
ican Jewry. For Dr. Levinthal's life and
career demonstrate vividly the glorious
opportunities for creative service which
the American Rabbinate should and might
render, but, alas, has, in large measure,
failed to do.
In the attainment of the highest ends
of their ministry, the American rabbi
appears to have encountered serious diffi-
culty. Whether because of the complexi-
ties of Jewish life in this country, or be-
cause of the fast tempo of the age, or
because of a misconception of their true
functions as spiritual leaders, or because
of manifold burdens thoughtlessly as-
sumed by or thrust on them, some rabbis
have not developed their ministerial po-
tentialities to the full and have not given
American Jewry an adequate service, or
enabled it to acquire the rich and stimu-
lating fruits of the Jewish heritage.
•
A multitude of distractions have di-
minished the energies of some rabbis and
left them little time to soak themselves
in the treasures of Jewish tradition. The
sphere of things Jewish has at times
shrunken to a small area of their inter-
ests and concern. Frequently discoursing
on a wide range of subjects, these rabbis
generally succeed in emphasizing every-
thing but what is specifically Jewish.
Empty philosophies, false cultures,
strange theologies, specious sociology —
these, along with speeches "full of sound
and fury, signifying nothing", have all
too often found their way to the pulpit.
Rhetorical flourishes and felicitous phrases
have far too frequently been utilized not
to supplement a sermon but to supplant
it.
It is to the everlasting credit of Dr.
Levinthal that he has not allowed him-
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Sreenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Soodstein, Treasurer Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthal, D.D., D.H.L, Rabbi Manuel Salhman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
4
A TRIBUTE FROM GOVERNOR DEWEY
I AM happy indeed to send warm greetings to the members of the Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center on the occasion of the celebration of the sixtieth birthday of the
distinguished spiritual leader, teacher and scholar, the Reverend Dr. Israel H.
Lev in thai.
It is most fitting that you pay such a tribute to a clergyman who has deserved
so well of the congregation he has served, of American Jewry at large, and of the
entire community. A man who is at the same time a scholar and a capable leader
and an organizer has a rare combination of gifts. Dr. Levinthal is a fine embodi-
ment of the highest type of Hebrew culture.
May he continue to serve as an inspiration to his people for many decades to
come.
With kindest regards and best wishes.
THOMAS E. DEWEY,
Governor of New York.
self to be swerved by false ideas, to be
captivated by spurious ideals, to depart
from the path of Jewish knowledge and
inspiration, to forget or cease observing
zealously his true functions as a teacher
and preacher in Israel. Thoroughly at
home in all the other fields which mark
the modern man of culture, busy as he
has been in non- Jewish matters, Dr.
Levinthal has always sedulously striven
to emphasize the value and content of
Jewish tradition and learning. He has
ever endeavored to follow and exemplify
the high standards of Jewish scholarship.
•
The staple of his preaching has been
the vast and ancient fundamental Mid-
rashic literature. He once said to the
writer: "If you take away from me the
Midrashic Literature, I cannot preach,
for I have no cause and I have no knowl-
edge." There can be no Jewish life, he
asserts, where there is no root connection
with the Jewish past. Judaism cannot be
taught or understood without the help
of intelligent and informed interpreters of
the centuries-old body of Jewish litera-
ture. We are dependent on instruction
from the past. We must get illumination
from the ancient pages. Rabbi Levinthal,
therefore, followed the old formula,
"maggid ha-katub" (the Scriptures
teach) , "Yelammedenu rabbenu" (let our
master teach us). Thus he gives prom-
inence to the wisdom of the ancient
Jewish masters. To suffuse the minds and
hearts of his listeners with the holiness,
beauty and goodness of Judaism, Rabbi
Levinthal lets "The Great ones of the
Generation," "The Great Interpreters of
the Law," "The Men of the Great As-
sembly," the Soferim, Tannaim, Arao-
raim, the "Darshomin Geclolim" speak
through him when he interprets and ex-
pounds the law from the pulpit. Dr.
Levinthal fulfills the admonition of the
Fathers: "Search the Torah carefully;
search it again, for everything is con-
tained therein, and swerve not therefrom
for thou canst have no greater excellency
than this." With the utmost painstaking
care, he prepares his sermons. Long and
extensive is the time he devotes to re-
search and study on his themes.
For nearly thirty years Dr. Levinthal
has been preaching in the Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center to a crowded synagogue.
People flock from far to hear him. He
delivers not a speech, but a Derashah in
the old-fashioned style. With rarely a
deviation, he bases his sermon on the
Sabbath and the Holy Days on the Sidra
(portion) of the week. He takes a
Ma'amar (verse from the Scriptures) and
elucidates it with Talmudic Midrashic
explanations. Like the Darshan (preacher)
of former days he gives his sermon a
"hidush" (novelty) and a "harifut"
(sharpness). He employs illustrations,
parables, allegories, and arguments from
old Midrashic collections and from his
comprehensive knowledge of secular
branches of learning. His ingenious ex-
planations of Biblical passages delight his
hearers.
Dr. Levinthal's sermons, speeches and
discourses, on all occasions, teach an
ethical and devotional lesson. Under his
fine treatment the wonders and beauty of
the Bible and Jewish history and re-
ligion assume a new grandeur and sanc-
tity. He makes the audience feel that
we need the wisdom and strength of Jew-
ish civilization for guidance in life today.
Torah — the Jewish tradition — is current
coin, not a curio in a cabinet to be taken
out for inspection on rare occasions. The
ideals of the modern Jew can be realized
in and through Torah. Torah has an im-
mediate relation to and an immediate ef-
fect on man's conduct here and now.
Dr. Levinthal's career is a successful
refutation of the argument that "what-
ever was good enough for our fathers is
not good enough for us." In the Jewish
[Continued on page 23]
ZIONIST ORGANIZATION GREETS DR. LEVINTHAL
IT IS with a sense of deep personal pleasure that I take this opportunity to extend
both my personal greetings and those of the Zionist Organization of America,
on the occasion of the 60th anniversary of Dr. Israel H. Levinthal.
I count Dr. Levinthal among my closest friends and as a most valued associate
in our common goal to build the Jewish State in Palestine.
No member of the Jewish community can fail to be aware of the great con-
tribution he has made to the Brooklyn Jewish Center and to American Jewish life.
Under his inspired and devoted leadership, the Brooklyn Jewish Center has become
truly a center of Jewish life. It has nourished and developed the highest ethical
and spiritual values in the community. Through it, he has helped bring Zionism
to the ever-increasing numbers of American Jews.
Dr. Levinthal has served his people well during the long years of peace and
bloodshed, hope and despair, frustration and realization. We hope that he will long
continue to serve God and his people and to witness that day that will see our
hopes and dreams realized.
DR. EMANUEL NEUMANN,
President, Zionist Organization of America.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
I HAVE known Dr. Israel Herbert Lev-
inthal so long and heard him speak
so often in his synagogue, at pub-
lic meetings, and on many other occasions
that, trying to revive my impressions of
him and to put them down in writing, it
is difficult to point to any particular
thought or utterance of his which would
be typical or characteristic of the man
and his work. But there is one incident
which remains fresh and vivid in my
mind, and to which, indeed, I love to
return as often as the thought of Levin-
thai and his striking success in the Amer-
ican Jewish ministry comes to me.
The Jewish Theological Seminary was
holding its annual commencement exer-
cises about thirteen years ago and the
occasion being simultaneous with Dr.
Levinthal's twenty-fifth anniversary in
the rabbinate, he was called upon to
preach the sermon. With the brilliant
sunshine of a June afternoon streaming
into the auditorium, an impressive pro-
cession of members of the faculty, rabbis,
and candidates for degrees gowned in
their multi-colored academic robes,
swung slowly towards the platform. The
usual ceremonies incidental to such an
event, were conducted with solemn dig-
nity by Dr. Cyrus Adler, then the ven-
erable head of the Seminary.
When Dr. Levinthal rose to speak, all
eyes were upon him, and he was himself
visibly affected. It was no easy task to
preach in the presence of his teachers and
masters for so many years, no light matter
to offer counsel and advice to students
and colleagues critical of his every word
and gesture. The past twenty-five years
must have rolled back in his mind when,
on a similar occasion, it was not his voice
that was raised in admonition, but that
of the unforgettable Professor Solomon
Schechter. This was a moment to make
any man's heart tremble with fear and
distrust of himself.
•
But once he began to speak, he was
both master of himself and master of
his audience. He began weakly and
slowly, but soon his voice was clear and
resonant, charged with a depth of feeling
and unmistakable sincerity. He spoke a
full hour, but not a word or thought he
uttered was lost. There was no weariness
among his listeners, only complete ab-
sorption. Even the older members of
ISRAEL HERBERT LEVINTHAL— AN
INTERPRETATION
the faculty, pretending indifference to
ceremonial sermons, forgot themselves
and stealthily lifted an eye to the speaker.
It was not Levinthal alone who spoke
that afternoon, but centuries of Jewish
thought and conviction, and the genera-
tions of his rabbinical forebears.
This was one of the most memorable
sermons. I have listened to many other
addresses, and on similar occasions, but
they were of the exhibitionist and preten-
tious kind, more pompous than enlight-
ening, more platitudinous than instruc-
tive, in which half-learning was made to
appear as learning, and quotations from
the classics brought in to atone for the
speaker's ignorance of the ancient sources
of Jewish wisdom — the very opposite of
what Dr. Levinthal was saying to the
young rabbis before him.
•
In a magnificent stirring appeal, ele-
gantly phrased and supported by the au-
thority of the ancient Jewish masters,
adressed both to the rabbi sitting in his
presence and his colleagues all over the
country, Dr. Levinthal, drawing upon his
quarter of a century experience in the
Jewish ministry, wove the pattern of the
Jewish rabbi's work in facing a new
world. "We are told," he said, "that the
entire conception of the rabbinate's role
must change. The rabbi is not to be
what he was in ancient times; he must
be something new, something altogether
modern, to fit the new day and answer
the new demands of this modern age. . . .
But if change there must be, we first
ought to make it clear to ourselves from
what we want to depart and at what
we want to aim."
He appealed to his colleagues to be the
people's spiritual architects, the fashion-
ers of the sanctuary of Jewish life. While
it was the rabbi's duty to bring a message
of hope and courage, it was his highest
function to implant in the people the
love of Torah. And with as much scorn
as his gentle nature would permit, he cas-
tigated those of his brethren in the min-
istry who would make the pulpit a pub-
licity medium for the latest Broadway
show, popular novel or sensational news-
By JACOB S. MINKIN
paper headline. "If the twenty-five years
of my humble ministry have taught me
anything," he emphasized, "it is this —
that the masses of our people crave for
Torah from the lips of their spiritual lead-
ers. ... A sermon that reviews a book, or
that even presents a lesson in economics
or politics, will not impress them, for in
these fields you are not their authorities.
. . . Today, even in the humblest syna-
gogue, there are college graduates and men
of culture who, no less than the rabbi,
arc familiar with the currents of modern
life and thought. . . . You can and will
impress them if you bring to them the
message which the Torah, our rich and
varied Hebrew literature, has to offer with
reference to any of the vital problems
that confront life today."
Because of his profound belief that in
modern life there is no question, no is-
sue, no vexing or perplexing problem
which ancient Jewish wisdom cannot help
to illuminate or solve, Dr. Levinthal af-
firmed, that, "The congregation has the
right to expect the leader to be well versed
in the fields of modern knowledge. . .
He must discuss the important issues and
pressing problems that confront the en-
tire world. But upon these discussions,
he must bring the imprint of Torah; he
must reveal what Judaism has to say upon
all these manifold concerns that affect the
life of the world today." With charac-
teristic Schechtcrian insistence, uttered,
indeed, on the day of the preacher's own
ordination as a rabbi, Dr. Levinthal made
the highest demands on his colleagues in
the rabbinate. He called for a ministry
of the mind and the heart, of piety and
learning, wisdom and holiness.
I have singled out this one particular
sermon of Dr. Levinthal from scores of
others and secular addresses happily res-
cued for the future in three published
volumes, not because it is so outstanding
from the rest, but because, in my estima-
tion, it is typical of the man, typical of
his method, typical of his vision and out-
Broolclyn Jewish Center Review
c
look and, in a large measure, indicates
why he has held his unique place in the
love and affection of his colleagues in the
American Jewish ministry. In speaking
to the rabbis, to his colleagues, he re-
vealed himself, etching a more authentic
image of himself than anyone could have
done.
Dr. Levinthal might be made to figure
in many lights, delineated in many
aspects. As far as his interests and sym-
pathies arc concerned he is among the
most versatile characters in the American
rabbinate. He fought in many battles,
championed many causes, sponsored many
movements. No department of American
Jewish spiritual and cultural life re-
mained untouched or uninfluenced by
him. In this country there are few more
community-minded men than he. The
footnotes to his sermons and addresses
in the three published volumes, giving the
time, place and occasion of their delivery,
is almost the sum total of our American
Jewish cultural and spiritual activity.
He speaks to laymen and he speaks to
rabbis, in his own pulpit and from many
another pulpit and platform throughout
the land. Wherever there are hearts to
be inspired, minds to be enlightened, and
men and women to be won for their faith
and people, there Levinthal is a familiar,
loved figure. He is as known in Canada
as he is in the United States, as admired
and respected in the South and West as
he is in his own community. Zionist
gatherings are flattered by his appearance,
Hebrew cultural audiences listen to him
with rapt attention, noisy conventions are
silenced by his voice, and he brings peace
and harmony to disputatious rabbinical
assemblies.
What is the power of this man Levin-
thal? What are his qualities, faculties or
talents which surround him everywhere
with an atmosphere of love and devotion?
The answer lies not in his physical ap-
pearance, nor in any dramatic, spectacular
act. Looking at Dr. Levinthal's picture
before me as I write, his face has no
particularly arresting features. His eyes
behind his spectacles are kind and mild,
but not strong or penetrating; there is a
distinguished, aristocratic quality to his
mien and features, revealing the scholar
or preacher, but it is not of the over-
powering kind. Jewish audiences are
stem judges, starkly critical, and are not
easily beguiled by such accidental things
as a man's pose or appearance.
Dr. Levinthal is unquestionably an ef-
fective speaker. Even as a very young
man, when still in his student days, he
won a medal for excellence in oratory.
His voice warm and refined, and what
gestures he chooses to employ, are of the
kind to win sympathy and confidence of
his hearers. Nevertheless, he is not the
picturesque, dramatic orator who over-
whelms an audience with the magic and
power of his eloquence. He discusses his
subject with clarity, vigor and insight,
but not with that intensity of feeling and
emotion which would affect one to a point
of self-forgetfulness. He is neither reck-
less nor impetuous, neither rash nor de-
fiant. His oratorical style is not of the
"prophetic" school of speakers. There is
more light than heat in what he says or
preaches. He is more expository than
creative, illuminating and instructive
rather than challenging. He makes use
of none of the deceptive tricks which
make an orator the "darling" of his audi-
ence — the mystic look, the sweeping ges-
ture, the holiday tone of voice.
•
If Dr. Levinthal has maintained him-
self in the Jewish ministry with such
power and distinction for so long a time,
preached in one of the greatest pulpits in
this country for nearly a generation, and
won the acclaim and admiration of his
friends and colleagues as did few other
men in the rabbinate, it is because the
secret of the man lies in the quality of
his preaching, in his high personal integ-
rity, and in the lofty conception he early
formed of the position and power of the
Jewish pulpit in the moral and spiritual
life of the people, and exemplified it in
his own nearly forty years of service.
When the romance of the American
Jewish pulpit, its vision and power, its
influence and accomplishments, will one
day be told, the part played by Dr. Levin-
thal will loom large. Until his coming,
the sermon was the feeblest staff Jews
could lean on in preparation for their
spiritual future. It neither instructed nor
inspired, neither saved nor served Jews in
their struggle for religious and cultural
survival. In the orthodox synagogue, the
pulpit was a negligible factor; either it
was silent altogether or, when it made it-
self vocal, it was in a language that was
incomprehensible to the younger members
of the congregation. And while in the
reformist temple floods of oratory re-
sounded, it was not the kind of preaching
Jews could depend upon to sustain them
in their religious yearnings and convic-
tions. Sermons were preached, but the
texts were as often from Thoreau, Emer-
son, and Walt Whitman as from Hillel,
Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai, and Rabbi
Akiba.
•
Rabbi Levinthal attempted what seemed
the impossible. He rediscovered the clear
bright flame that shone in the ancient
sources of Jewish wisdom. No new voice
from heaven was needed. It was there
where Jews always knew it existed. For
a thousand years and more, an entire
people had poured its life and devotion
into the thousands of pages of the
Talmud and the Midrash. They are life;
they arc real, not faded parchments of
the past. They are the immortal spirit of
the Jew. Their lesson, their message, their
admonition is for today, tomorrow, and
for all time. "Whatever a wise disciple
shall ever teach in the presence of his
rabbi, the Holy One had already made
known unto Moses on Sinai." In brief,
there is a great, rich, and illuminating
tradition of incomparable wisdom and
eloquence which needs but to be mined
from its hidden depths and intepreted to
make it shine in its exquisite beauty and
splendor.
The originality of Rabbi Levinthal's
method and manner of preaching consists
in the fact that he is the least original of
his American rabbinical colleagues. He
invented nothing; he only harked back
to a style and philosophy of preaching
that was practised by Jewish pulpit ora-
tors for probably two thousand years.
Listening to him, or reading his sermons
in print, one feels oneself transported to
the academies of Sura and Pumbedita or
to the Jewish preaching guilds of later
centuries, when a verse from the Bible
was minutely, almost microscopically,
dissected and analyzed for what bearing
it might have upon contemporary prob-
lems and conditions. Sometimes he may
seem involved over imaginative, some-
times too literal or excessive in following
the talmudic or midrashic rule of inter-
pretation. But the essential Jewish spirit
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
and its grc.it cultural heritage is never
wanting in what he says or writes.
Dr. Levinthal contributed mightily to
the saving of the prestige of the syna-
gogue. He made his pulpit conspicuously
Jewish and filled his sermons with con-
spicuously Jewish content. He found
that in the hearts of the average Jewish
men and women are Jewish instincts,
deeply-imbedded love for Jewish things,
Jewish memories, and a hunger for knowl-
edge quite apart from that to be derived
from the popular novel and play. He
also discovered that, being modern men
and women, American Jews are acutely
aware of the social, economic and political
forces which shape their lives. Dr. Levin-
thai exploited both these discoveries by
proving to the men and women of his
congregation, and to thousands outside his
synagogue, that for centuries Jewish sages
and thinkers had grappled and wrestled
with just such problems as perplex and
puzzle the modern mind and arrived at
conclusions and solutions which would be
well for our world to know.
He was more than successful. He be-
came the accredited ambassador of ancient
Jewish lore and wisdom to a world that
was poorly aware of their existence. He
carried the message across the land. By
publishing his sermons he extended the
area of his influence far beyond his own
pulpit. Indeed, Levinthal is the first
American rabbi to makes books of ser-
mons excellent sellers. Rabbis of all shades
of religious opinion forgot about the
homiletics they had studied in their semi-
naries and devoted themselves to Levin-
thal.
•
So far, little has been said about the
literary artistry of Levinthal's preaching,
the artistry that consists of gathering up
ideas, impressions, characteristics in a few
brilliant flashes. In the Jewish pulpit, this
writer knows of only one man who was
so gifted with that capacity — the late Dr.
Adolf Yellinek of Vienna. In Levinthal
pulpit artistry has reached a level rarely
attained before. We could quote many ex-
amples of his graceful prose, his sensitive
feeling for words and figures of speech,
but it will suffice to point to his mem-
orial tribute to the mystic-philosopher
Abraham Isaac Kook, the late Chief Rabbi
of Palestine. This writer knows no finer
and more penetrating characterization of
this great man's learning and wisdom,
patriotism and saintliness, (unless it be
the book that recently appeared on the
subject), than Dr. Levinthal's brief mem-
orial address, written with love and un-
derstanding, insight and devotion.
Dr. Israel Levinthal has crowned his
nearly forty years in the Jewish min-
istry with high purpose, noble idealism,
and historic achievement. He has broken
THE RABBI FACES
This is an excerpt from the ad-
dress discussed by Rabbi Minkin in
bis article on Dr. Levinthal. It was
given at the graduation exercises of
the Jewish Theological Seminary of
America on June 2, 1955, and is in-
cluded in Dr. Levinthal's book, "A
New World Is Born."
LIKE Solomon of old, the true leader
of today must pray: Chokmah
U'Madda Ten Li, "Oh grant me wisdom
of the Torah and knowledge of the
world!" But though this secular knowl-
edge is essential, the leader must ever re-
member the advice of Maimonides, that
science — for the Rabbi must be the hand-
maid of Torah, nor a substitute for Torah.
The great pity in Jewish life — so far as
the Rabbinate is concerned — is just this,
that many have made the Torah the hand-
maid of science, and science the substi-
tute for Torah. And that, in itself, is
the reason for the loss of the prestige of
the Rabbi in the eyes of the multitude
of our people.
We seem to forget that conditions in
our congregational lite have vitally
changed in the last twenty-five years. A
quarter of a century ago it was a novelty
— at least in the synagogues of the tradi-
tional school — for a Rabbi to speak Eng-
lish. Many of the congregants could not
read or speak the language of the land,
and hence the greatest respect was shown
to the preacher who could exhibit Daat —
a knowledge of modern literature science,
art and economics. But today, even in
the humblest synagogue, there are col-
lege graduates and men of culture who,
a path which has now become a highway
for his colleagues to follow. He is one of
the few rabbis in the country who did not
allow themselves to become narrowed.
He serves his congregation and he serves
his friends, but his range of vision in-
cludes all Israel. His heart aches for
them all, his spirit rejoices with them all,
his love and devotion embraces them all.
May his years of service to his faith and
people increase and multiply so that he be
a blessing unto them!
A NEW WORLD
no less than the Rabbi, arc familiar with
the currents of modern life and thought.
To them, the Rabbi who reveals this
knowledge is no longer a marvel; but he
is a marvel to them if he exhibits a fa-
miliarity with the teachings of our Torah.
A sermon that reviews a book or a play,
or that even presents a lesson in econom-
ics or politics, will not impress them, for
in the fields you are not their authorities.
You can and you will impress them if you
bring to them the message which the
Torah, our rich and varied Hebrew liter-
ature, has to offer with reference to any
of the vital problems that confront life
today.
I do not mean to minimize the value
of Daat as a prerequisite of Jewish leader-
ship. The congregation has a right to
expect the leader to be well versed in the
fields of modern knowledge; the Rabbi,
if he is to serve his people's needs well,
must be acquainted with the results of
research in the arts and sciences of our
day. He must discuss the important is-
sues and pressing problems that confront
the entire world. But upon these discus-
sions he must put the imprint of Torah;
he must reveal what Judaism has to say
upon all these manifold concerns that af-
fect the life of humanity today.
If I may be permitted to give a new
meaning to the classic words of the
prophet I should say: "The lips of the
priest shall guard Daat, knowledge" —
they must be familiar with all the trends
of secular life — VTorah Ycvaskushn
Mi[>ibn "But it is the Torah that the
people will seek from his mouth!" . . .
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
8
An Intimate Profile by the Levinthal Children
A WONDERFUL LIFE WITH
FATHER
WE HAVE tried very hard to
ev.ilu.ne our father objectively
so that this article will not
merely repeat the customary cliches of
filial respect and devotion due a parent.
But even evaluating dad objectively we
are forced to conclude that he is better-
natured than anyone we have ever known
— more considerate of the feelings of
others than anyone wc have known, and
by far the most understanding father
ever known. More than this, we con-
sider dad our friend, and friendship is
not something to be taken for granted
between parent and child.
Being his children, we are of course
in a position to tell so much about your
rabbi, and yet, probably nothing we say
will surprise those who have met him even
once. He is a genuinely sweet and kindly
person, and he remains sweet and kind
whether serving the community as rabbi,
or his family as father and husband.
There are many details about our dad
which might be considered unimportant,
but actually these are the very things
people are most anxious to know. He is,
for example, an unusually fastidious per-
son, and is immaculate both in his dress
and personal habits.
He dresses well; a man who takes pride
in looking well groomed, but a lavish
display of haberdashery would be incon-
sistent with his essentially simple way of
life. His neatness extends even to the
care of his hands, which always look beau-
tiful and well cared for. His taste in
neckties is conservative, as you would ex-
pect. It was only recently that he suc-
cumbed to family pressure and wore a
foulard pattern with a touch of red. This
was soon followed by a paisley with more
red. A recent attempt to foist a striped
tie on him failed because one of the
stripes was of a brighter shade of red.
Dad is so good-natured though, that if
we really urged him to wear it, he would
have undoubtedly put it on to please us.
Dad is neat in general. His clothing
closets would warm the cockles of a first
sergeant's heart. His knack of doing
things in an orderly manner has earned
for him not only the family's respect and
admiration, but recognition as the family's
official suitcase-packer. It is difficult for
us to reconcile father's aptitude for pack-
ing a valise with the methodical precis-
sion of a true scientist and his general in-
ability to cope with such mechanical baf-
flers as the can-opener, electric socket or
the snapshot camera.
Planning meals for dad is a relatively
simple task. He has a long list of foods
he won't touch, foods he would prefer
were not even served in his presence. But
those foods which he does eat will not
bore him no matter how often they are
placed before him. Two boiled eggs at
lunch could be served daily for weeks and
we doubt that he would complain. A
partial list of the foods dad has black-
listed include squash, turnips, bananas and
tomatoes. Incidentally, he loves tomato
soup, juice and ketchup. He has a sen-
sitive nose and will detect and abhor any-
thing that has had a nodding acquaint-
ance with garlic.
Until recently, we never knew dad to
eat canned salmon. It is only within the
last year that he sampled and seemed to
enjoy it. Needless to say, this was a big
By Helen L. Lyons
and Lazar E. Levinthal
day for our family and the event was dis-
cussed with much the same interest and
enthusiasm as was the Truman Doctrine.
Those of you who have had occasion
to observe your rabbi at a kiddush or a
wedding may have classified him as a
"nasher." We confirm it, but in his de-
fense, let it be known that he nashes with
a guilt complex. This you can detect by
his comment as he takes the sweet, "I
really shouldn't."
Few people enjoy hearing a good joke
as much as father does, but oddly enough
he never tells jokes. He is an excellent
teller of stories and we know that he
would have made a wonderful actor. He
will often return home from a gathering
and recount an amusing incident which
occurred. His gestures, facial expressions
Rabbi and Mrs. Israel Herbert Levinthal, from a very informal snapshot
taken by a friend of the family.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
and imitations easily capture the full
flavor of the incident. Me is a master of
the art of mimicking.
One of dad's unusual characteristics is
his ability to analyze a situation or a
problem from all angles, and to clarify it
colorfully and succinctly. Many is the
time when a group of friends have been
gathered in our living room and a heated
discussion would ensue. The nature of
the discussion matters little; be it secular
or religious, dad will invariably say little
or nothing until the argument has reached
a degree of heat. At the crucial moment
he will clear his throat, smack his lips and
automatically the room will be quiet and
all eyes turn to dad. With extraordinary
calm he will outline briefly the arguments
that have been presented for both sides
and then — and this is his unusual ability
— he will present his own argument, an
argument which goes deeper and more to
the heart of the issue than all the others.
Those present will invariably admit by
their silent nodding that dad's point is
well taken.
Dad must have been a fair athlete. We
recall his love for tennis, but this was
some years ago. He is still a good swim-
mer, although not very fast. His favorite
stroke is a variation of the breast stroke
wherein he substitutes the customary
"glide" for a series of short frog-like
kicks, making certain to pucker his lips
and raise the eyebrows at the same time.
He doesn't dive but prefers to use the
ladder, inch by inch. He also likes walk-
ing and ping-pong, but these are all sum-
mer activities. Mother is really the ath-
lete of the family; she can easily outswim
dad, and is more than his match at ping-
pong.
Father has no hobbies. His time is well
taken up with meetings, preparing ser-
mons and speeches, sick calls, weddings,
funerals and callers of all varieties. Dad
meets hundreds of people each week, and
it would tax the memory of an expert
to recall their names. Unfortunately, dad
is no expert and is constantly harassed by
the woman who is surprised and coyly
disappointed that Rabbi Levinthal doesn't
remember her. After all, he did officiate
at her sister-in-law's wedding in 1937!
A free evening at home is a great lux-
ury to father, and he will usually an-
nounce to the family, "To-night I am
going to relax, like a millionaire, and
read!" He loves to read history, biogra-
phy and books touching on Jewish affairs.
His prolific reading has given him a tre-
mendous fund of general knowledge.
There are, however, several aspects of our
contemporary culture that are still beyond
his grasp. To illustrate, we doubt strongly
dad's ability to explain fully the role of
a fullback in our complex society, or to
explain adequately the common phrase,
"Win, Place or Show." We have it on
reliable authority that when father was
asked recently at a gathering whether he
wanted a Tom Collins he replied, "Who?"
It might be noted at this point that
dad does not smoke, nor does he drink
anything stronger than the Tokay wine
used at our Sabbath kiddush.
Dad loves the theater, but here too, his
rabbinical duties afford him very few
opportunities for its enjoyment. He is
so deeply emotional that he both laughs
EDITORIAL
WE ARE told in the Book of Esther
that Haman cast lots (Purim) for
twelve months before he decided to exe-
cute his sinister plan of Jewish extermina-
tion. Similarly, the United Nations have
been toying with the future of our people
for almost a year, casting lots, making
decisions and unmaking them. During
this historic period the scales of fate have
been tipped to our advantage, as on that
fateful day of November 29th when the
United Nations registered approval of the
Partition Plan, or they have been drawn
almost irresistibly against the establish-
ment of the Jewish State, as in the pres-
ent sessions of the Security Council. If
the lots should finally and irrevocably be
cast against us, our modern Hamans be-
lieve that they will have condemned the
Yishuv to the status of a ghetto and that
they will have succeeded in dooming the
Jews of Europe to languish in D.P. camps,
forever prey to the evil machinations and
whims of future tyrants, dictators and
anti-Semites.
There can be little doubt that the na-
tions of the World will profoundly affect
our future by the lots they cast and the
decisions they reach. However, our
people have never succumbed nor bowed
and cries easily at the theater or cinema.
In life, too, he is visibly affected by the
problems that are brought to him, which
undoubtedly are responsible for many a
gray hair.
•
We have tried to portray for you an
intimate picture of our dad. We know
that the portrait lacks much of the color
and depth of his lovable personality.
This, not only because there are so many
aspects to the man but because writing
about father alone is difficult when all
our lives we have associated mother and
dad as a team. Few men have been so
blessed as to have found in their life's
partner the deep and abiding love which
is so evident to all who know mother and
dad. Never does one leave the house
without the other whispering in Yiddish
their heart's prayer, "Gey gezumlt, Kum
gezuniit,"
to the destiny outlined for us by our
foes. We have survived in spite of evil
decrees and edicts, because we were able
to muster enough spiritual power and
strength to defy them.
Once again as in the days of Mordecai
and Esther, we must rally to upset and
frustrate the schemes of our enemies. We
must take action to shape our own fate
and to mould our own destiny. We too,
must cast our own lots by using every
conceivable means at our disposal — prayer,
pressure and power — to tilt the scales of
destiny in our favor. Only then will the
conspiracy against us be destroyed and
these days of discouragement and dismay
be transformed into joy and gladness for
Israel and all mankind.
— Manuel Saltzman.
EDITORIAL BOARD
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Louis J. Gribetz, Chairman
Joseph Goldberg M. H. Lewittes
Joseph Kaye Manoel Saltzman
I. H. Levinthal William I. Sjecel
Through Prayer, Pressure and Power
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
TRIBUTES TO DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
DR. STEPHEN S. WISE.
• I have much pleasure in learning that
the Brooklyn Jewish Center will celebrate
the sixtieth birthday anniversary of my
beloved friend, Dr. Israel H. Levinthal. I
am glad, too, to learn that the March
issue of the Brooklyn Jeuisb Center Re-
lieu is to be dedicated to him and the
celebration which the Congregation is to
have.
It is commonplace and repetitious for
me to say again that I have long consid-
ered Dr. Levinthal one of the finest and
most serviceable and significant men in the
American Rabbinate. He has much Jew-
ish learning; he has a deep human friend-
liness ind he is a true Rabbi as well as
an extraordinarily effective preacher. If
I knew how to say more about him, I
would: and I shall have occasion to do so
upon 2 special occasion in the not remote
future.
RABBI ISRAEL M. GOLDMAN, Presi-
dent, Rabbinical Assembly of America.
• The celebration of the sixtieth birth-
day of Dr. Israel Herbert Levinthal, the
revered and beloved Rabbi of the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center, is a source of rejoicing
and pride to the whole of the American
Jewish conmunity. We, his devoted col-
leagues and admiring friends in the Rab-
binical Assembly of America, serving in
communities all over the United States
and Canada, are particularly pleased to
take note o: this significant event since
Dr. Levinthil is one of our most distin-
guished members and one of the rarest
gems in the crown of the American Rab-
binate.
Dr. Lcvin hal is one of the master-
builders of Conservative Judaism in
America. A? an honored former Presi-
dent of the R.abbinical Assembly, he has
throughout hs notable rabbinate carried
into effect it; exalted purpose, which is
stated in its constitution in these signifi-
cant words:
"To promote traditional Judaism, to
advance the cause of Jewish learn-
ing; to co-operate with the Jewish
Theological Seminary and the United
Synagogue; and to foster the spirit
of fellowship among the Rabbis and
other Jewish scholars of America."
These lofty aims Dr. Levinthal has
served with his great God-given talents
so that now he stands forth as one of the
great banner-bearers of the Jewish religi-
ous tradition in modern times.
While Dr. Levinthal has achieved
distinction in many fields of Jewish lead-
ership, he is pre-eminently known as the
preacher par excellence in American Jew-
ish life. Through his crystal-clear mind
and silver-tongued eloquence there are
combined the ancient tradition of Jewish
preaching and the modern needs of Jew-
ish living. To him as to few others in
the American Rabbinate, the time-hal-
lowed springs of Jewish wisdom are drawn
upon to bring forth timeless and refresh-
ing truths. In the pulpit he is the master
who has many followers but no equals.
It is a source of special rejoicing that
his greatest work was achieved through
the Brooklyn Jewish Center, which Dr.
Levinthal, together with the support of
enlightened lay leadership, has made into
one of the renowned strongholds for Jew-
ish life in this country. His congregants
know him and love him as Rabbi,
preacher, scholar, author, Zionist spokes-
man, civic leader, communal guide, and
personal friend.
Dr. Levinthal's colleagues in the Rab-
binical Assembly know that the follow-
ing words of the Psalmist fittingly de-
scribe his life and career:
"I have preached righteousness in the
great Congregation,
Lo, I did not refrain my lips;
O, Lord, Thou knowest.
I have not hid Thy righteousness with-
in my heart,
I have declared Thy faithfulness and
Thy salvation"
Dr Levinthal's hundreds of friends and
colleagues in the Rabbinical Assembly of
America rejoice in sending this word of
greeting on his sixtieth birthday and
unite in extending to him and to his dear
family every good wish for many more
decades of good health and useful service
to God, to Israel and to Torah.
MORRIS ROTHENBERG, President,
Jewish National Fund.
• I extend warm greetings to Rabbi
Israel H. Levinthal on the occasion of
his sixtieth birthday.
With his heritage of Jewish learning
and spirituality, with his own great at-
tributes of scholarship and eloquence, and
with his profound knowledge of his
people's psychology and needs, Rabbi
Levinthal has exercised a potent and last-
ing influence not only upon his own con-
gregation but upon the entire American
Jewish community. In the Zionist move-
ment, Rabbi Levinthal has been a thinker
and a leader of great distinction, illumin-
ating Jewish aspirations with eloquence
and incisiveness.
May Rabbi Levinthal long continue in
the full vigor of his powers his outstand-
ing contributions to the civic ideals of
our country and towards the realization
of the ideals of the Jewish people.
DR. ISRAEL GOLDSTEIN, President,
United Palestine Appeal.
• There are few men in the American
Rabbinate whose ministry has made as
deep an impression as that of Dr. Israel
Herbert Levinthal. His has been a rare
combination of gifts — gentleness in per-
sonal relations coupled with firmness of
principle, scholarship coupled with pop-
ular appeal, complete at home-ness in the
American environment coupled with deep
roots in the tradition of Judaism, com-
mitment to political Zionism coupled with
fervent espousal of its spiritual content,
mastery of the Jewish word coupled with
Mitzvah, the power of Jewish deed. No
rabbi in America has done more to up-
lift his community and to make of it a
power for good in American Judaism.
In following Rabbi Levinthal's leader-
ship the Brooklyn Jewish Center has be-
come a leader and a standard-bearer in
the vineyard of American Israel.
At the age of sixty, Rabbi Levinthal is
an ever fresh inspiration to his colleagues,
in the art of expounding Sacred Script
and interpreting American Judaism. I
deem it a privilege to be counted in the
abundant company of his colleagues who
rise and call him blessed.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
On behalf of the United Palestine Ap-
peal, I am happy to record the unanimous
gratitude of those who have dedicated
themselves to Palestine's upbuilding for
his lifelong devotion to binyan ha-eretz
u'techiyath ha -a in.
When the Jewish State, please God, is
established, Rabbi Levinthal's will be the
deep reward of knowing that he has been
one of the builders.
May he be granted many more years of
fruitful labor.
DR. JOHN HAYNES HOLMES
• I am proud to be included in the great
company of those who will join hand
and heart in the celebration of the six-
tieth birthday anniversary of Dr. Israel
H. Levinthal.
My first thought of Dr. Levinthal is
that of a friend, tried and true. He is
the most hospitable of men, the most
thoughtful and kindly of colleagues. He
has a golden heart.
Then comes the thought of Dr. Levin-
thal's tireless and highly successful work
as a rabbi. The Brooklyn Jewish Center
is a great monument to his achievement,
his power of leadership, his devotion and
his mastery of the arts of personal and
public service. I never visit the Center
without marveling that one man, year
after year, can administer and direct the
life of that veritable hive of human ac-
tivity, and still remain serene, cheerful
and courageous.
Lastly, I think of Dr. Levinthal as a
scholar. There are books of his, and the
gifts of his generous hand, here on my
library shelves, which I cherish as among
the great religious books of our time.
Jewish rabbis have ever been notable for
their learning, and Dr. Levinthal main-
tains the great tradition.
Dr. Levinthal is still young, at least
he is not yet old, but he is approaching
the time when he will need special care
and consideration, kindly services of help-
fulness and co-operation, the unfailing
concern of his congregation for his health
and abiding strength. I know that the
people of the Center, grateful for all that
Dr. Levinthal has done for them, will
draw close about him these days in true
and deep affection and together hold up
his hands.
DR. WENDELL L FIFIELD, Plymouth
Church.
• I am very glad to join with others in
paying tribute to Rabbi Israel H. Levin-
thal on the occasion of his sixtieth birth-
day. I was greatly surprised, in view of
his activity, to learn that he had reached
this milestone in his experience. I would
not have judged from his personality that
he had reached three score.
His contribution, not alone to his own
institution, but also to the civic and re-
ligious life of our borough, and even be-
yond our borough, has been a conspicuous
and outstanding one.
On behalf of the Plymouth Church of
the Pilgrims, as well as myself, I am glad
of this opportunity to extend our con-
gratulations and very best wishes.
J. W. HOOPER, Brooklyn Chapter
Chairman, The American National
Red Cross.
• We of the Brooklyn Chapter of the
American Red Cross are proud to join
the people of Brooklyn in honoring the
sixtieth birthday of one of our city's out-
standing spiritual and civic leaders Dr.
Israel H. Levinthal.
As a member of the Brooklyn Chapter's
Board of Directors Dr. Levinthal has ex-
hibited rare qualities of leadership and a
humble spirit of selflessness in planning
programs for the public good.
Similarly, in all his many endeavors
Rabbi Levinthal has always demonstrated
the devotion to all people, regardless of
race, creed or color that marks the truly
exceptional citizen.
On his sixtieth birthday, we extend our
warmest greetings to our fellow-member,
and congratulate the Brooklyn Jewish
Center for their good fortune in having
as their spiritual leader this great fellow-
citizen beloved by all of us.
MENACHEM RIBALOV, Editor, Hadoar.
• The Hadoar sends its heartiest congrat-
ulations to Dr. Israel H. Levinthal. He
has been one of its proud and honored
standard-bearers.
By virtue of his gifted qualities his elo-
quent preaching, which stems from a
mastery of the Midrash and his winning
personality, he occupies a special place in
American Jewish life. To know him is
to admire him, not only because of his
kindly temperament, but also because of
what he represents — a love of the old and
the new, an ideal synthesis of our ancient
Torah and of our modern culture. Mod-
ern Hebrew, which derives its life-blood
from our ageless Torah, has found an
enthusiastic supporter in Dr. Levinthal.
Devotedly he has served the cause of
Hebrew, knowing full well that the re-
vival of Hebrew literature and the He-
brew press is indispensable to the spiritual
revival of our people.
It is for this reason that he was among
the first to respond to the call of the
Hadoar when it was yet in its infancy,
and to work for its continued existence.
Dr. Levinthal, together with Joseph
Barondess, of blessed memory, helped
found the "Committee to Help the
Hadoar" which has recently been re-
named the "Friends of the Hadoar." Its
efforts enabled the Hadoar to maintain
itself for the past 27 years — a record not
equalled by any other Hebrew periodical
in America.
For more than two decades, Dr. Levin-
thal has steadfastly devoted himself to
this sacred task, thus setting an example
which has inspired others. He has dem-
onstrated that Hebrew in America is the
concern not only of the chosen few —
Hebrew authors and readers — but of all
Jews who wish to perpetuate the spirit
of Judaism wherever Jews are to be found.
Now that we stand at the threshold of
the Jewish state, we see the vindication
of the Hebraic ideal.
We join with those who celebrate
Rabbi Levinthal's sixtieth birthday and
offer the prayer that God will bless him
with many more years of health and
strength so that he will be enabled to con-
tinue his service in behalf of our Torah,
our culture and the freedom of our people.
RABBI THEODORE N. LEWIS, President
of New York Board of Rabbis.
• On behalf of the New York Board of
Rabbis, it is a pleasure to extend greet-
ings to Dr. Israel H. Levinthal upon at-
taining his sixtieth brithday.
His colleagues in the rabbinate rejoice
that the rare privilege has been vouch-
safed unto Dr. Levinthal to render dis-
tinguished service over a long and trying
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
period to Israel, to our beloved land and
to mankind.
The high and lofty rabbinic standards
which Dr. Lcvinthal follows have served
to raise the status of the American rab-
binate and to further the welfare of
American Israel. His active participation
in the Jewish life of our city, his ardent
Zionist labors, his devotion to the cause
of Jewish education, his civic-mindedness,
have inspired and challenged our people
to ever higher levels of living. His mas-
terful preaching, his eloquent interpreta-
tion of Biblical and rabbinic literature, his
skill as a homilist have demonstrated for
our generation of Jews the beauty, truth
and eternity of Israel's Torah, its unsur-
passed excellence as a guide for the whole
human family.
On this, his sixtieth birthday, his col-
leagues in the ministry greet him with the
fervent prayer that the Almighty may
vouchsafe unto him, His faithful servant,
physical strength and length of days,
that He may grant him the rich reward
which he has so justly earned, to the end
that he may continue to labor zealously
and fruitfully in the vineyard of the
Lord, to the greater glory of our God, our
Torah and our people Israel — Ad Meah
V'Esrim Shanah!
BROOKLYN BOARD OF RABBIS —
Rabbi A. Alan Steinbach, President;
Rabbi Isadore A. Aaron, Vice-Presi-
denf; Rabbi D. Bernard Stolper, Vice-
President; Rabbi Theodore S. Ross,
Vice-President; Rabbi Maxwell L.
Sacks, Treasurer; Rabbi Manuel Saltz-
man, Secretary.
• The Brooklyn Board of Rabbis deems
it a privilege to extend greetings and feli-
citations on the celebration of the sixtieth
birthday of our revered friend and col-
league, Dr Israel H Lcvinthal. As one
of the founders and first President of our
Board, Dr. Levinthal has wielded an in-
fluence for good that is far beyond com-
pute. His inspiration and guidance have
been our "Pillar of Fire" throughout the
years of our existence, and we are grate-
ful to the Almighty for having reflected
so much of Himself in this great leader
in Israel.
Every Rabbi in our Board joins in the
fervent prayer that Israel and America,
as well as the Brooklyn Jewish Center,
will for many years remain the benefici-
aries of the great gifts of heart, mind and
spirit Dr. Levinthal possesses in such rich
abundance.
LOUIS LIPSKY
• The kind of a man a rabbi becomes is
largely determined by the model he
chooses to emulate. All his life Rabbi
Levinthal has chosen to be a preacher and
teacher. He wanted to be a guide to the
members of his congregation. At all
times he has spoken with a keen desire to
know the truth before speaking and he
found truth in Jewish tradition and in the
teaching of the Sages. He seems always
to be guided by the desire to walk in the
footsteps of the Sages whose wisdom he
undertook to interpret to his congrega-
tion. To hear him preach is to have an
opportunity to look into the mirror of
Jewish wisdom. He has shown in all his
work that character and integrity is more
important than the resonance of sermons,
that unless a rabbi reveals in his daily life
the quality of the religion he professes,
his sermons are merely oratorical exercises
of indifferent value.
Thus, after a lifetime of devotion, the
influence of Rabbi Levinthal extends be-
yond his congregation and beyond the
borough in which he lives. He is known
and valued in wide Zionist circles and
among all American Jews who prize tra-
dition and Jewish ideals. He personifies
the glowing influence of a living Judaism.
As one who believes in the superior
function of the rabbi and that moral
leadership in Jewish life can come only
from rabbis who are true to the calling,
I pay tribute to Rabbi Levinthal as rabbi
and as Jew, and wish him a long life of
unimpaired service to his people.
ZIONIST ORGANIZATION OF AMER-
ICA, Brooklyn Region, Benjamin G.
Browdy, President.
• The Brooklyn Region of the Zionist
Organization of America is happy to join
the Brooklyn Jewish Center in honoring
its distinguished Rabbi, Israel H. Levin-
thal on the occasion of his sixtieth birth-
day.
In common with all of Brooklyn Jewry,
Brooklyn Zionists are indebted to Rabbi
Levinthal for many years of inspired lead-
ership in the great tradition of Jewish
history during periods of both Jewish
crisis and Jewish opportunity.
The Brooklyn Zionist Region has now
emerged as the numerically largest organ-
ization of Brooklyn Jewry. In its career
of service to Israel, this organization
could not have made such signal progress
were it not for the great contributions
of Rabbi Israel H. Levinthal as president.
His tenure of office was characterized by
brilliant and forthright leadership and
great initiative.
On his sixtieth birthday, the Brooklyn
Zionist Region extends to this eminent
son of Israel reverential felicitations, and
looks forward to many more years of ac-
tive and intimate association with him
and his congregation.
UNITED SYNAGOGUE OF AMERICA,
Samuel Rothstein, President; Albert
I. Gordon, Executive Director.
• We are delighted to hear that the
Brooklyn Jewish Center will pay its trib-
ute to your revered spiritual leader, Dr.
Israel Herbert Levinthal, on the occasion
of his sixtieth birthday.
We of the United Synagogue of Amer-
ica are delighted to join with the host
of friends and co-workers of Dr. Levin-
thal in paying our respects to him on
this important milestone of his life.
Dr. Levinthal has been the Rabbi of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center, but in a wider
sense, he has been a Rabbi to American
Jewry. His words, both oral and written,
have been listened to and read with grate-
ful appreciation by rabbinical and lay
leaders throughout this land. He who is
so steeped in Jewish lore has been a source
of inspiration not only to his own congre-
gation but to the United Synagogue of
America as well. Through the United
Synagogue, he has served the cause of tra-
ditional Judaism on a national scale, and
we shall always feel deeply indebted to
him.
May the years that lie ahead be bright
for him and his dear ones, and may he
and you who are his congregants continue
to work together in the Vineyard of the
Lord.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
BROOKLYN JEWISH COMMUNITY
COUNCIL, Maximilian Moss, Pres.
• The Brooklyn Jewish Community
Council, representing 8 50 constituent or-
ganizations and speaking on behalf of
approximately one million Jews of Brook-
lyn, extends to Rabbi Israel H. Levinthal
its warm affection on his sixtieth birth-
day. The Brooklyn Jewish Center is also
to be congratulated on the inspiring
leadership which Rabbi Levinthal has
given to it over the years.
This occasion has real meaning for
Community Councils, since they have
benefited so greatly from the wisdom,
statesmanship and counsel which Rabbi
Levinthal has unstintingly given to this
movement from its inception. We hail
our first President, our valued Trustee and
our present Honorary President.
The entire community of Brooklyn,
Jews and non-Jews alike, feels honored to
have Rabbi Levinthal as its distin-
guished citizen. His inspiration and cour-
age have contributed significantly to the
ideals and aspirations not only of Brook-
lyn but to other communities throughout
the nation.
We wish Dr. Levinthal continued hap-
piness and look forward to his future
achievements.
JEWISH THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY,
Dr. Simon Greenberg, Provost.
• It is a joy indeed to greet Dr. Levin-
thal on his sixtieth birthday. I do so not
merely as one who has personally treas-
ured his friendship, admired his character
and ability and benefited by his teach-
ing and example. I am, fortunately, pri-
vileged to speak also in behalf of the
faculties and Board of our beloved Alma
Mater, the Jewish Theological Seminary
of America. They all join his hosts of
friends throughout the country in thank-
ing God that American Israel was blessed
by his leadership.
Dr. Levinthal has, indeed, exemplified
at their highest the qualities that Ameri-
can Israel hopes to find in its spiritual
leaders. High moral character, persist-
ent and fruitful scholarly interests, de-
spite the tremendous pressure of his nu-
merous other duties, wisdom and kindness
as a counselor of his people, active leader-
ship in the manifold communal activities
[Continued on page 23]
JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
A QUIZ FOR YOUR FAITH
IT I IAS become quite popular among
the current periodicals and magazines
to publish intelligence and character
quizzes.
Recently a Rabbi in Boston — Rabbi
Beryl Cohon — prepared such a question-
naire on Jewish living. The test was pub-
lished in a recent issue of Liberal Judaism,
and republished in many Synagogue and
Temple publications.
The purpose of this quiz is to test, for
your own knowledge, your rating as a
Jew — how you fulfill your Jewish obli-
gations to your children, to your commu-
nity, to your fellow-Jews throughout the
world, to the Synagogue, to your Faith.
It is an excellent opportunity to take
stock of yourself. And I am reprint-
ing this quiz, in slightly modified form,
in the hope that every reader of the
Center Rei ieiv will give himself and her-
self this self-examination.
The Questionnaire
Part 1 — The Home.
□ 1. Does the wife kindle the Sabbath
lights? (4 points)
□ 2. Does she kindle the festival
lights? (4 points)
□ 3. Does the father say a word of
prayer or make Kiddush? (4
points)
O 4. Are the Sabbath and the festivals
respected in the home in actual
practice, e.g., refraining from
work, noisy games, etc.; reading
a Jewish book, etc.? (4 points)
| | 5. Is grace spoken before meals or a
prayer after meals? (4 points)
O 6. On Passover, do you have a
Seder? (4 points)
□ 7. On the Sabbath and holidays, do
the children attend synagogue
services, accompanied by at least
one adult, preferably a parent?
(4 points)
□ 8. On Hanukah are the lights
kindled and the blessings spoken?
(4 points)
! 9. Are there Jewish books in your
home? Are they read? Is there
a prayer book? Bible? (4
points)
lJ 10. Does a good Jewish periodical
come to your home (besides the
Center Review)} (4 points)
□ 11. Are there Jewish symbols in your
home — M'zuzo, menorah, candle-
sticks, kiddush cup, ceremonial
dish, etc.? (4 points)
□ 12. Do you discuss Jewish matters
respectfully in the hearing of
your children? (4 points)
Part II
n i.
□ 2.
□ 3.
□ 4.
Part 111
□ 1.
□ 2.
— The Synagogue.
Do you belong to a synagogue?
(5 points)
Do you attend services?
a — regularly (5 points)
b — occasionally (2 points)
c — on High Holy Days only (1
point)
Are your children in a synagogue
school?
a — Hebrew week-day classes (4
points)
b — Sunday morning school (2
points)
c — Do they receive good private
instruction? (3 points)
Do you belong to the auxiliary
bodies of the congregation and
are you reasonably active? (Sist-
erhood, Adult Classes, Discussion
Groups, etc.) (4 points)
— The Community
Do you consider yourself a good
citizen beyond the mere require-
ments of the law? Interested in
political, social, cultural welfare
of community? (13 points)
Are you an integrated person in
the life of the Jewish commu-
nity, contributing your honor-
able share to the philanthropic
and cultural institutions that sus-
tain our Jewish life, e.g., the
[Continued on page 23]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
NEWS MONTH
THE formation of a Chamber of
Commerce in the U. S. for Palestine
is urged in a report published by the
United Palestine Appeal recently, estab-
lishing that "Jewish Palestine and the
United States can form a reciprocal trade
partnership in which the Jewish state
would purchase at least $5 0,000,000 to
$70,000,000 annually of American
goods."
On Friday, March 19th, the world
was stunned by an act of betrayal
on the part of our Government in its
abandonment of Palestine Partition,
through its spokesman at the Security
Council, Sen. Warren Austin.
There is imperative need that every
American citizen should clearly under-
stand the full significance of the admin-
istration's policy with respect to Pales-
tine. An editorial which appeared in
the N. Y. Times of March 21st will help
illuminate the understanding of anyone
who may still be unable or unwilling to
appreciate how great an injustice this act
is to the Jewish people and to the world
generally, which staked its hope in the
United Nations. Even the A T . Y. Times,
whose policy toward Zionism may be
characterized as unsympathetic, cannot
escape the grim conclusion that the gov-
ernment's new policy on Palestine is an
astounding exhibition of "ineptness". We
believe that the American people concur
with the A r . Y. Ti?nes' arraignment
that the Truman administration has
lowered the dignity of America and
the character of its government. It is
the right and the duty of every American
citizen to denounce and protest against
the administration because "the prestige
of American foreign policy has suffered a
severe blow in the handling of this (Pal-
estine) issue", and for having "played a
shabby trick on the Jewish community in
Palestine".
We, therefore, reprint the Times edi-
torial.
— Editors.
One of Palestine's greatest problems,
the procurement of water suitable for
drinking and irrigation purposes, is now
in the process of solution, according to
an announcement by the American Com-
mittee for the Weizmann Institute of
Science. Despite the present situation in
the country, scientists of the Institute
continue to devote themselves to the long-
range problems of Palestine.
The Switch On Palestine
There can be little doubt that the
partition of Palestine is being blocked
by the struggle between the Soviet Union
and the Western Powers. A land once
known for milk and honey now flows
with oil, and the homeland of three great
religions is having its fate decided by
expediency without a sign of the spiritual
and ethical considerations which should
be determining, at least in that part of
the world. Ancient Palestine was once
described as "not the land of philosophers
but the home of prophets." It would
take a prophet sitting on a rapidly spin-
ning turntable to have foreseen the course
which our Government has pursued dur-
ing these last few months.
Three things need to be said, and to
be said at once, concerning the present
shift of American policy on Palestine.
The first is that it comes as a climax to
a series of moves which has seldom been
matched, for ineptness, in the handling
of any international issue by an American
Administration. The second is that it
is a plain and unmistakable surrender to
the threat of force. And the third is that
it holds little promise of being able to
avoid the very hazards which it is in-
tended to circumvent.
So far as the first point is concerned,
it may be said that all of the critical con-
siderations now enumerated by Mr. Austin
as reasons for our Government's change
of policy — namely, the strength of Arab
opposition to the partition plan, the neces-
sity of providing a large international
armed force to implement that plan, the
reluctance of the small nations and all
of the large Powers, with the sole excep-
tion of Soviet Russia, which has its own
objectives in the Mediterranean, to pro-
vide that force — were inherent in the sit-
uation when the original decision in favor
of partition was made last November 29.
Nevertheless, it was primarily on the ini-
tiative, and under the pressure, of our
Government that the decision for par-
tition was adopted. Somewhere along the
line there has been a shocking lack of
liaison and of common purposes between
the American State Department and the
American delegation in the United Na-
tions, with the White House itself ap-
parently utterly at sea. Inept, uncer-
tain and confused, the prestige of Amer-
ican foreign policy has suffered a severe
blow in the handling of this issue.
As for the second point — the sur-
render to the threat of force — it is ob-
viously and admittedly Arab intransig-
eance that has forced the American Gov-
ernment to change its policy and to bow
to Arab threats, and to propose that the
whole United Nations retreat with us in
the face of Arab scorn and fury. Un-
fortunately, if this is done, it will not
be the first time that the United Nations
has had to yield to the threat of force.
It has been bludgeoned out of Northern
Korea by Soviet Russia and out of the
Balkans by Soviet Russia's satellites, but
each surrender of this kind is a blow to
the authority of the United Nations.
Meantime, we have played a shabby trick
on the Jewish community in Palestine,
which put its faith in our promises.
Finally, where does this new decision
leave us? It leaves us still under the in-
exorable necessity of helping to furnish
that international armed force which we
have been so reluctant to provide. For
to maintain what Mr. Austin describes as
a "temporary trusteeship" over the whole
of Palestine will certainly require a."
armed force. It may well require an even
larger armed force than would be required
for partition, for, as Secretary General Lie
notes, the United Nations Special Com-
mission on Palestine drew the conclusion
that "a trusteeship for Palestine would be
fought by two parties instead of one."
This is the prospect with which the
whole series of moves now culminating in
Mr. Austin's announcement leaves us.
U. S. REVERSAL OF PALESTINE PARTITION
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
15
house, but found nothing to support the
boy's allegation.
Warning that the restitution law pro-
vides a five-year prison term for persons
failing to report they hold Jewish prop-
erty, Dr. Philip Auerbach, Commis-
sioner for Persecutees in the Bavarian
Government, reported that few Germans
owning such property have notified the
authorities.
Dr. Auerbach said that it would be
impossible to permit German police to
enter displaced persons camps to make ar-
rests, as was recently requested, since
many former Nazis have managed to join
the police force following their "denazifi-
cation." The commissioner also advocated
the enactment of a law which would give
concentration camp victims industrial
property, such as factories, which were
owned and operated by the camps "since
this property was paid for by the perse-
cutees with their own blood."
ft
Approximately 100,000 Jews in 200
DP camps and communities in the Amer-
ican zone went to the polls to vote for
representatives to the Central Committee.
The election, by secret ballot, was held in
all Jewish installations, including hospi-
tals and sanatoria.
A proportional representation method
of voting was used, with the voters ex-
pressing their choice of Zionist or non-
Zionist parties. First choices gained by
each party will determine the party's rep-
resentation at a general congress called
for the end of March where officers for
the Central Committee will be elected.
Final returns will not be determined for
several days because of poor communica-
tions throughout the zone.
•ft
The present leadership of the Jewish
community in Vienna does not fulfill its
duties to Austria and is undemocratic,
Vice-Chancellor Adolf Schaerf told a
Jewish mass meeting called in connection
with the forthcoming elections within
the Jewish community in Vienna. He
urged them to vote for the Socialist can-
didates.
Schaerf asserted that 26,000 apart-
ments, among them a considerable num-
ber of which had formerly belonged to
Jews, have since the liberation, been in-
habited by persons receiving Russian sup-
port. 1 le added, in answer to a question,
that restitution of Jewish property had
been delayed, but indicated that the
Austrian Government was helpless against
the Russians, who claim all Aryanized
property in Austria as German assets,
ft
An investigating commission of the
Vienna University's Medical Department
acquitted Dr. J. Zikowsky, head of the
infectious disease department of its hos-
pital, of charges of performing unneces-
sary medical experiments on twenty Jew-
ish refugee children last September.
Zikowsky was found not guilty be-
cause the incisions and lumbar punctures,
which Jewish physicians had called un-
necessary, were "entirely in accordance
with medical regulations," the commis-
sion's statement said. The police then
said they found no reason for further in-
vestigation.
ft
"The Trial," an Austrian film touch-
ing on the problem of anti-Semitism, will
be released for public consumption de-
spite the protest of the Vienna Jewish
community, Minister of Interior Helmer
declared this week.
Helmer said that several Austrian pro-
vincial governments had banned the
showing of the film on their own author-
ity. He termed their action as "border-
ing on censorship." The Ministry of
Trade and Reconstruction described the
movie as a "production of great artistic
value and heralding a trend against anti-
Semitism." The disputed film depicts a
ritual murder in a small Hungarian vil-
lage during the last century.
ft
Ditar von Wisiiczeny, Gestapo liai-
son agent with the puppet pro-Nazi Slo-
vak Government, has been sentenced by
a Slovak court to be hanged for his re-
sponsibility in the deportation of thou-
sands of Jews to German death camps.
Earlier, the court heard testimony to
the effect that Wisiiczeny had promised
many Jews their freedom from deporta-
tion if they would pay him a huge bribe.
The Slovak Jews, by that time already
impoverished by the Nazis and local
fascists who had confiscated or fined them
most of their worldly goods, managed to
raise the equivalent of $S 0,000 in cash
J. D. C. PROVIDES MATZOHS
FOR POLISH COMMUNITY
Close to 600,000 pounds of matzohs
and matzoh flour have reached the
offices of the Joint Distribution Com-
mittee for distribution to the Jewish com-
munity in Poland for the Passover holi-
days. Every Jew in Poland will receive
approximately four pounds of matzohs
and one pound of flour, it was estimated.
Representatives of the J.D.C. and the
Central Committee are working out a
distribution plan. It is expected that
wealthier individuals will be asked to con-
tribute a special matzoh tax which will
be used for Passover seders for the poor.
All homes for the aged and children's
institutions will receive matzohs free.
Jewish bakeries in Lodz, Cracow, Wroc-
law, Walbrzych and Rychbach have been
promised allotments of flour by the Food
Ministry for the local manufacture of
matzohs for Passover.
and turned it over to the Gestapo leader.
Witnesses testified, however, that despite
the payment of the bribe, the defendant
was responsible for the deportation of the
very Jews whom he had promised to
protect.
The Jewish cemetery in Bratislava was
the scene of a burial service for 180
scrolls of the Torah stolen from Dutch
Jewish communities by the Nazis. Dr.
A. Sicher, chief rabbi of Prague, officiated
at the service, which was attended by a
large number of local Jewish residents, as
well as two representatives of the Jewish
community in the Netherlands. The
scrolls had been mutilated by the Nazis
beyond possible repair.
Dr. Philip E. Auerbach, Commis-
sioner for Persecutees in the Bavarian
Government, who was confined in the
Oswiecim death camp for two years, told
the war crimes court in Nuremberg, try-
ing 21 top Nazi diplomats and ministers
that he knew from official records that
4,800,000 persons were exterminated in
the camp.
Auerbach said he was arrested by the
Gestapo in 1940 in France after the Ger-
mans overran that country and was sent
to Berlin where he remained under arrest
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
until 1943 when he was transferred to
Oswiecim. He was assigned to disinfect-
ing fellow inmates, he said.
Another prosecution witness, Mrs.
Jeanette Wolf, who is at present a mem-
ber of the Berlin city council, testified on
the terrible conditions in the Riga Ghetto,
where 20,000 Jews were held, to which
she was sent in 1941. The 60-year-old
witness said that on an extremely cold
November day, the Nazis rounded up
hundreds of children and took them away
from the ghetto in open trucks. They
were never seen again, she added.
The Post Office Department announced
it will not accept money orders for Pales-
tine. The action was taken pursuant to
a request of the Palestine Government.
Some 15,000 workers affiliated with the
International Ladies Garment Workers
Union quit work to attend a mass rally
to protest against the failure of the
United Nations to protect the new Jew-
ish state in Palestine.
The workers, members of many races,
nationalities and faiths, gathered in the
streets of the garment district and
marched to the Manhattan Center where
the protest meeting was held. The Cen-
ter could hold only a small part of the
marchers and an amplifying system was
set up so that those who could not enter
the auditorium could hear the speeches.
Despite the British position on Pales-
tine, sentiment in Canada is shifting to-
ward support of complete implementa-
tion of the United Nations decision to
partition Palestine.
In Parliament, Minister for External
Affairs Louis St. Laurent, in response to
direct questioning from the floor, indica-
ted that Canada will accept her full share
of responsibility for any action which the
Security Council may undertake to im-
plement partition or restore peace to Pal-
estine.
An attack on Britain's Palestine policy
was voiced in the Manitoba Provincial
Legislature by M. A. Gray, Labor M.P.
and a Jew, who expressed the hope that
"Canada will continue to support the
Palestine partition decision." He praised
the Canadian delegation at Lake Success
for fighting for partition "against every
open and covert attempt to defeat it."
In Montreal, two local newspapers, the
Herald and Standard, have warned that
failure by the U.N. to implement its de-
cision may mean the end of the interna-
tional body. The Herald said that the
future of the U.N. rests on its decision
on the Palestine Commission's request for
an "adequate force" to implement parti-
tion, while the Standard also rested its
analysis of the situation on the question
of an international force.
The three-member commission would
administer the act with regard to re-
strictions on qualifications for immigra-
tion, on whether adequate job and hous-
ing facilities exist for them in the com-
munity in which they would wish to
settle and whether they might become
public charges. The members of the
commission would be appointed by the
President with Senate approval, would re-
ceive an annual salary of $10,000 and
their terms would run to June 30, 1951.
The commission would be required to sub-
THE Senate Judiciary Committee re-
ported favorably to the Senate a report
on displaced persons and a bill calling
for the admission of 100,000 DP's to the
United States at the rate of 5 0,000 a
year for the next two years. It also pro-
posed the creation of a three-man dis-
placed persons commission to administer
the bill.
The report and bill were prepared un-
der the direction of Sen. Chapman Rever-
comb of West Virginia, chairman of a
Judiciary sub-committee which also in-
cluded Sens. Forrest C. Donnell of Mis-
souri, John Cooper of Kentucky, J. How-
ard McGrath of Rhode Island and Patrick
McCarran of Nevada. Sen. Cooper was
in favor of admitting 75,000 a year for
the two-year period, and Sen. McGrath
urged 70,000 a year, but both these rec-
ommendations were defeated in the full
committee, as was one by Sen. Homer
Ferguson of Michigan for 100,000 a year
for two years.
The deadline on a second section of the
bill dealing with the general immigration
picture was extended to May 1.
mit a yearly report to the President and
Congress on the operation of the program.
The bill also requires that not less than
5 0 percent of the visas issued shall be
available only to persons previously en-
gaged in agricultural pursuits and who
will be employed in the United States in
the same type of work.
Displaced orphans in Italy or the
British, French or American zones of
Germany or Austria lawfully adopted by
American citizens, may be admitted to
the U. S. as non-quota immigrants, the
bill provides.
The House Appropriations Committee,
which is considering funds for the De-
partment of Labor and the Federal Se-
curity Agency, voted to deny federal
funds to states which discriminate in em-
ployment and education on racial
grounds.
Rep. Frank B. Keefe, of Wisconsin,
chairman of the sub-committee, said that
medical aid, unemployment compensation
and vocational education would be chiefly
Displaced persons eligible under the
bill are those who, from Sept. 1, 1939 to
Dec. 22, 1945 entered Germany, Austria
or Italy, or who on July 1, 1948 were in
Italy or the American, British or French
zones of Germany or Austria, or persons
who were victims of Nazi persecution
who fled and were later returned to one
of those countries. Priority in the issu-
ance of visas will be given to persons
who are in displaced persons camps on
July 1 of this year but "in exceptional
cases," visas may be issued to eligible
DP's and orphans living outside the
camps.
The bill was reported out with one dis-
senting vote, cast by Sen. William Langer,
of North Dakota. A number of amend-
ments were defeated. Most of them were
variations on the number of persons to
be admitted each year. One that was
defeated would have allowed numbers to
accumulate from one year to the next
and another would have chosen DP's with
skills in proportion to a cross-section of
skills found in the DP camps.
Senate Committee Acts Favorably on Bill Admittins
D. P.'s to U. S. A.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
affected. The present law provides that
persons of all races must be given equal
opportunity, he said.
it
Tun first non-sectarian medical school
under Jewish auspices will be established
by Yeshiva University, it was announced
at a dinner of the Society for the Ad-
vancement of Pro-Medical Sciences at
Yeshiva University.
Dr. Elihu Katz, chairman of the So-
ciety, said that the first objective of the
organization was to enroll 100,000 mem-
bers to raise $7,500,000 for the Univer-
sity's academic and physical expansion
program. When sufficient funds are
available a medical school will be estab-
lished, he stated. Speakers at the dinner
included Under-Secretary of State David
A. Morse, Judge Jonah Goldstein, and
Dr. Horace Kallen of the New School for
Social Research.
ft
For the first time in the history of
Mexican Jewry, democratic elections were
held in Mexico City for the Jewish Cen-
tral Committee in which the entire Jew-
ish adult population was given the right
to vote.
Arthur Wolfowich, noted Zionist
leader, was re-elected president of the
Committee. The Zionist list of candi-
dates received sixty percent of all the
votes and won eight of the fourteen seats
in the Committee. The Jewish People's
Group secured three seats, while the In-
dependent Group and the Jewish Socialist
Bund won two seats each.
A group of Georgia teachers is institut-
ing court action to stop Tom Lindcr,
Approximately 2,000 Jewish refugees
are entering France monthly and
pose "vast new problems" to Joint Dis-
tribution Committee assistance efforts, it
was reported by Laura Margolis, J.D.C.
Director for France, who has just re-
turned to the United States.
"The refugees enter France from East-
ern Europe and the DP areas, dependent
on J.D.C. for basic necessities — food,
clothing, and medicines," Miss Margolis
declared. "J.D.C. provides all of this,
and also maintains a chain of 18 hotels
state commissioner of agriculture, from
using the Georgia Market Bulletin — a
state publication — to air his religious, ra-
cial and political prejudices. Lindcr was
elected to his present post with the sup-
port of the Ku Klux Klan, the report
said.
ft
The Esco Foundation for Palestine
composition scholarship, for study this
summer at the Berkshire Music Center
in Tangle wood, Mass., has been awarded
to 29-year-old Herbert Brun, of Tel
Aviv, by the American judges, Leonard
Bernstein, Henry Cowell, Ethel S. Cohen,
Frederick Jacobi, Wallingford Ricgger
and Stefan Wolpc.
ft
A plaque in memory of Major General
Maurice Rose of Denver, who died in ac-
tion while serving on the European front,
was unveiled in the synagogue at Bellc-
vue Hospital here.
The plaque was presented by the Jew-
ish War Veterans, whose national com-
mander, Brig. Gen. Julius Klein, said at
the unveiling ceremonies: "This is a re-
minder to those who slander American
Jews." High-ranking Army officers, in-
cluding Gen. J. Lawton Collins, Deputy
Chief of Staff, of the Army, attended the
ceremonies.
ft
The size and number of Reform con-
gregations in this country has been in-
creasing steadily, it was reported at the
closing session of a two-day meeting of
the Eastern President Conference of the
Union of American Hebrew Congrega-
tions in New York.
The parley, attended by 100 presidents
to shelter the newcomers." As a result,
she said, one-third of all J.D.C. appropri-
ations in France are going to this refugee
group.
According to the J.D.C. official, most
of the newcomers will be unable to emi-
grate from France within the near future
and need continued large-scale assistance
until they can become self-supporting.
She disclosed that the refugees enter un-
der the guarantee of the J.D.C. that they
will not become public charges.
BRITISH GOVERNMENT
SPONSORS CHAGALL EXHIBIT
N exhibition of 40 years of Marc
* * Chagall's works opened in the
London Tate Gallery, national gallery of
British art, under the auspices of the
British Art Council, a government-
sponsored group.
This is the first time such an exhibition
has been arranged for a Jewish painter.
A number of Chagall's works were as-
sembled for museums in all parts of the
world.
and vice-presidents of congregations in
the eastern part of the U. S., also heard a
report to the effect that the UAHC's pro-
gram of seminars, forums and symposia
for Christians and Jews was helping to
clear up misunderstanding among the
various faiths.
ft
Dr. Aiiram L. Sachar, who served for
15 years as director of the B'nai B'rith
Hillcl Foundations, was honored at a
dinner in New York, sponsored by the
Metropolitan Council of B'nai Brith. Dr.
Sachar, who resigned from his post at the
end of last year, will devote himself to
lecturing and writing. Speakers at the
dinner included Frank Goldman, national
president of B'nai B'rith.
ft
Twenty-i ive scrolls containing the
Book of Esther were sent to Jewish com-
munities in Poland and Italy by the
S.O.S. Collection of the J.D.C.
The scrolls, which were used during the
Purim celebration, were donated by con-
gregations in Texas, Tennessee, Pennsyl-
vania, West Virginia, Ohio and New
York. Additional shipments of the scrolls
were expected to be made to meet the
needs of 190 synagogues overseas which
reported they have none.
ft
Construction of temporary quarters
has begun at Neveh Abba, a new settle-
ment near Nathanya named in honor of
Rabbi Abba Hillcl Silver. Each settler
will receive a small house with about one
dunam of J.N.F. land suitable for truck
farming.
2000 Jewish Refugees Cross Into France Monthly
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER NEWS
IN THE HEBREW SCHOOL
Center to Celebrate Rabbi Levinthal's
Sixtieth Birthday
The Sixtieth birthday anniversary of
our beloved rabbi, Dr. Israel H. Levinthal
will be celebrated with a membership re-
ception to be given in his honor on Tues-
day evening, April 6th, promptly at 8:15
o'clock in our Main Synagogue. The
guest speakers will be Prof. Louis Finkcl-
stcin, President of the Jewish Theological
Seminary of America and Judge Louis E.
Levinthal of Philadelphia, former Presi-
dent of the Zionist Organization of
America. Greetings on behalf of the
Center will be presented by our Honorary
President, Mr. Samuel Rottenberg and
Judge Emanuel Greenberg, President of
the Center. Dr. Moses Spatt, Chairman
of the Committee, will preside. Rev.
Sauler and Sidor Belarsky, famous baritone
will entertain. At the conclusion of the
program, the guests will be invited to the
Dining Room and the Auditorium where
refreshments will be served. Admission
will be limited to members and their
wives. Members are therefore urged to
please send in their requests for cards of
admission, without which no one will
be permitted to attend.
Board of Trustees and Governing Board
to Honor Dr. Levinthal at Dinner
On the occasion of Rabbi Levinthal's
sixtieth birthday, the members of the
Board of Trustees and the Governing
Board and their wives will tender a tes-
timonial dinner to the Rabbi on Thurs-
day evening, April 8 th.
Dr. Levinthal to Preach Post Purim
Sermon This Friday Night
This Friday, March 26th, at our late
services which begin at 8:30 o'clock,
Rabbi Israel H. Levinthal will preach on
the subject "Haman and Amclek — A Post
Purim Message For Our Day." His
theme will deal with the treacherous
forces endeavoring to thwart the creation
of the Jewish State.
We are certain that many of our mem-
bers, their friends and relatives will want
to hear this timely and most interesting
lecture and are cordially invited.
A special breakfast was arranged for
the Post-Bar Mitzvah Class on Sun-
day, March 21, 1948. Mrs. Kushner,
president of the P. T. A. was in charge
of the arrangements. Others on the com-
mittee were Mi's. Altman Mrs. Flamm,
Mrs. Levitt, and Mrs. Stachenfeld. The
breakfast was preceded by a service con-
ducted by the Bar-Mitzvah boys. The
following led in the service:
Herbert Kasnetz, Robert Kritz, Stan-
ley Green and Edward Sharkey.
Three of the contestants from the
Brooklyn Jewish Center won prizes in
the city-wide contest arranged by the
Metropolitan Jewish Book Council in
connection with Jewish Book Month. The
winners were Toby Brown (grade 6E-
Hebrew School), Joan Seligman (grade
VII-Religious School), and Elizabeth
Gropper (grade 8, Center Academy).
A Purim Operetta under the direction
of Mr. Julius Grossman was presented on
Purim, March 2 5, 1948, for the Hebrew
and Sunday Schools. In addition, the
Palestinian film, "Assignment, Tel Aviv"
was shown. The following were in the
cast of the operetta:
Arthur Brimberg, Richard Stadin,
Hebrew School P. T. A.
Meeting March 31st
The next meeting of the Parent-Teach-
ers Association of the Hebrew and Re-
ligious Schools will be held on Wednesday
evening, March 31, 1948. It will be a
"Purim Festival Meeting." A Purim
Operetta will be presented by the Hebrew
and Sunday School choir, under the direc-
tion of Mr. Julius Grossman. Greetings
will be extended by Rabbi Mordecai H.
Lewittes. Rabbi Manuel Saltzman will
address the parents. Refreshments will
be served.
Sisterhood Campaign for U. J. A.
All women contributing between $52.
and $100. to the United Jewish Appeal
will be invited to a luncheon on April
5 th. Sisterhood members are kindly
urged to make reservations by contacting
Morton Bromberg, Sherry Stapleman,
Jeannette Flamm, Charles Stromfeld,
George Steinberg, Hannah Swirin, Judy
Wiles, Ellen Gofseyoff, Deborah Roth-
man, Ruth Berman, Sydelle Stenzler, Her-
bert Kasnetz, Stuart Perlman, and Alan
Gottdenker and the entire Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center school choir.
A special reading of the Megillah for
the students of the Hebrew School was
held on Wednesday, March 24, 1948 at
5:>30 P.M. Excerpts from the Megillah
were read by Mr. S. Edelheit. Purim
songs were sung by the school.
Campaigns on behalf of the Histadruth
Ivrith and the Children's Upbuilding
Fund for Palestine are now being run by
the students of the Hebrew and Religious
Schools. The Children's Upbuilding Fund
is under the auspices of the Hebrew Edu-
cators' Committee. Proceeds will be ded-
icated to a Palestinian naval school in
honor of William Bernstein, the first mate
of the Haganah ship, "Exodus, 1947,"
who died from wounds received when the
boat was intercepted by the British.
The P. T. A. donated an RCA Radio
and Record Player for use of the students
in the Hebrew and Sunday Schools.
Mrs. Isador Lowenfeld, 25 8 Sullivan Place,
SL 6-986 5; Mrs. Maurice Bernhardt, 1368
Carroll Street, SL 6-2135; or the Center
office, PR 4-1400.
Sabbath Services
Friday evening services at 6:00.
Kindling of candles at 5:54.
Sabbath services, "Zav" — Leviticus 6-
1-8.36; Prophets Jeremiah 7.21-8.3; 9-
22-23 — will commence at 8:45 a.m.
Mincha services Saturday at 6:00 p.m.
Rabbi Levinthal will preach on the
weekly portion of the Torah.
Rabbi George Abelson will continue
his lecture in Yiddish this Saturday after-
noon at 5:15 p.m.
Daily Services
Morning services at 8:00 o'clock.
• Mincha services at 6:00 p.m.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
19
Center Committees Appointed
OUR President, Judge Emanuel Green-
berg, has appointed the following
Chairmen and Vice-Chairmen of standing
committees:
Budget Committee: Samuel Lemberg,
Chairman.
Catering Committee: Dr. Moses Spatt,
Chairman.
Cemetery Committee: Samuel Lemberg,
Chairman; Isidor Fine, Vice-Chairman.
Chevra Kadisha: Louis Albert, Chmn.
Committee on Delinquent Accounts:
Morton Klinghoffcr Chairman.
Forum and Education Committee:
Harry Blickstcin Chairman; Isaac Sieg-
meister Vice-Chairman.
Committee on Fund Raising Activities:
Dr. Moses Spatt, Chairman.
Hebrew Education Committee: Frank
Schacffer, Chairman; Max Goldberg,
Vice-Chairman.
House Committee: Hyman Aaron,
Chairman; Bernard J. Aaron, Vice-
Chairman.
Library Committee: Dr. Irving L.
Cohen, Chairman; Morris Neinken, Vice-
Chairman.
Membership Committee: Samuel H.
Goldberg, Chairman; Herbert Turner,
Vice-Chairman.
Physical Training Committee: David
B. Kaminsky, Chairman; Isador Lowen-
feld, Vice-Chairman.
Publicity Committee: Louis J. Gribctz,
Chairman; William I. Siegel, Vice-Chmn.
Committee on Ritual and Religious
Si'riice: Louis Daum, Chairman; Morris
D. Wender, Vice-Chairman.
Sub-committees:
Musical Services: Irving S. Horowitz,
Chairman.
Ushers Committee: Jack Sterman,
Chairman.
Pulpit Committee: Morris D. Wen-
der, chairman
Social and Entertainment Committee:
Saul S. Abclov, Chairman; Ira I. Gluck-
stein, Vice-Chairman.
Visitations Committee: Louis Simon,
Chairman; Philip Palevsky, Vice-Chmn.
Youth Activities Committee: Reuben
Fricman, Chairman; Julius Zimmerman,
Vice-Chairman.
Zionist Activities Committee: David
Spiegel, Chairman.
Palestinian Journalist to Address
Zionist Meeting April 1st
A mass meeting under the auspices ol
the Zionist District No. 14 will be held
at the Center on Thursday evening, April
1st at 8:30 o'clock. The guest speaker
will be Yehuda Hcllman, Palestinian Jour-
nalist, an expert on Arab affairs. Mr.
Hcllman was a correspondent for the Pal-
estinian Post with the Anglo-American
Committee of Inquiry. He has covered
the London-Anglo Arab Conference and
the United Nations proceedings at Lake
Success. He will speak on "After Lake
Success — What Next In Palestine?" "The
Birth Of a Prophecy" — a film story of
the Jewish Agency in action, will be
shown. Center members and their friends
Advance Notice
Next Friday, April 2nd, at our late
services, Rabbi Manuel Saltzman will
preach the sermon on the subject "What
Religion Teaches Us About War."
Rabbi Lelyveld Guest Speaker
At U. J. A. Dinner
The Annual Dinner of the Brooklyn
Jewish Center Committee on behalf of
the United Jewish Appeal will be held at
the Center on Thursday evening, May 6th
at 6:30 o'clock.
The guest speaker will be Rabbi Arthur
J. Lelyveld, National Director of the
B'nai Brith Hillel Foundations and well
known Jewish communal and educational
leader.
Junior League News
The meeting of the Junior League
scheduled for Thursday evening, April
1st, will feature an April Fool Social di-
rected by Marty Karlin. This promises
to be one of the highspots of the season —
don't fail to attend. A social hour and
dancing will follow.
Unveiling
The unveiling of a monument in mem-
ory of Mr. Morris Shorin will take place
on Sunday morning, March 28th at 11:30
at the Montefiore Cemetery, Jewish
Center Subdivision, Plots 1-2-32, Block
322, Springfield Boulevard, L. I. In case
of rain, the unveiling will be held the
following Sunday.
In the Junior Clubs
Thl Junior Clubs have been busy pre-
paring for their Purim extravaganza
which will take place in the Beth Hamc-
drash Saturday evening, March 26th at
8 o'clock. All the clubs will be repre-
sented on the program. Jimmy Lewisohn
will speak on the "Significance of Purim
for Jewish Youth." Morton and Clara
Bromberg will render piano selections and
Conrad Lcfkowitz will play the clarinet.
Mr. Julius Grossman, Musical Director of
the Center, will lead the group in Purim
songs.
Adult Institute Classes
The classes which meet on Tuesday
evening, will meet on Wednesday, April
7th because of the celebration of Dr. Lcv-
inthal's birthday anniversary on Tuesday,
April 6th.
Congratulations
Heartiist congratulations and best
wishes are extended to the following:
Miss Charlotte R. Cohen of 12 Hart
Street, who announces her engagement to
Mr. Hy Edelson.
Mr. and Mrs. Robert E. Faber of 706
Eastern Parkway on the marriage of their
daughter, Elcnorc, to Mr. Milton H.
Schapiro on March 20th.
Mr. and Mrs. Solomon Ginsburg of
699 Lcffcrts Avenue, on the marriage of
their daughter Doris, to Mr. Edward A.
Fogelman on March 21st.
Mr. and Mrs. Alfred Greenblatt of
1372 Carroll Street upon the marriage of
their son, Irwin, to Miss Marilyn Barbara
Ginsberg on March 21st. Congratula-
tions are also extended to the grandpar-
ents, Mr. and Mrs. Isidor Silbcrberg and
Mrs. Hannah Greenblatt.
Mr. and Mrs. Jack Scharff of 92 5 Pros-
pect Place on the occasion of the marriage
of their son, Albert to Miss Selma Cohen
on March 21st.
Mr. Lawrence Schwartz of 5 57 Mid-
wood Street on the occasion of his mar-
riage to Miss Sandy Cohen on March 20th.
Congratulations are also extended to the
sister, Mrs. Harold Forman.
Bar Mitzvah
A hearty Mazel Tov is extended to
Mr. and Mrs. William Brody of 624 Em-
pire Boulevard on the Bar Mitzvah of
their son, James, which will be celebrated
at the Center this Saturday morning,
March 27th.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
YAHRZEITS— APRIL, 1948
Siim Katz
April 1
21
Adar
11
flayer Kcnin.
Mother
April 1
21
Adar
11
Seymour Scligman
Mother
April 1
21
Adar
11
Jacob Shapiro
Mother
21
Adar
11
Morris Traub
April 1
21
Adar
II
Dr. Benjamin Kovcn
Max N. Kovcn
> Mother
April 2
22
Adar
]1
Dr. Morris X. Kovcn
J
Miss Dora Leaks
Father
April 2
22
Adar
U
Max Lcvinc . .
Father
April 2
22
Adar
II
Philip Fcinbcrg
Father
April 3
23
Adar
11
Dr. Max Goldstein
Mother
April 3
23
Adar
11
Nathan Levitas
Brother
April 3
23
Adar
II
Isador Lowenfcld
Mother
April 3
23
Adar
II
Charles Wundcrlich
Father
April 4
24
Adar
II
Mrs. Annie Rcichman
Husband
April 5
25
Adar
11
Jacob Levine
Mother
April 6
26
Adar
II
Jacob A. Fortunoff
Mother
April 7
27
Adar
11
Joseph Levy, Jr.
Father
April 7
27
Adar
II
A. E. Ratncr
Mother
April 7
27
Adar
II
Mrs. H. Zirinsky
Harry Zirinsky
Son ?
Brother (
April 7
27
Adar
II
Isidore Gottlieb
Mother
April 8
28
Adar
11
Morris Grodcn
Father
April 8
28
Adar
11
Mrs. Simon Halpcrn
Husband
April 9
29
Adar
11
Mrs. Sol Horowitz
Mother
April 10
1
Nisan
Bernard Sussman
Harold Sussman
| Mother
April 10
1
Nisan
Jack Eaton
Father
April 11
2
Nisan
Barnctt Tancnbaum
Father
April 1 1
2
Nisan
Mrs. Alex Engcl .
Husband
April 12
3
Nisan
Mrs. Sol Horowitz
lather
April 12
3
Nisan
Samuel Horowitz
Brother
April 1 3
4
Nisan
Moses Rcznick
Father
April 13
4
Nisan
Louis Kohn
Father
April 14
5
Nisan
Charles Schless
Mother
April 14
5
Nisan
Mrs. Alex Bernstein
Mother
April IS
6
Nisan
Charles Safier . .
Father
April 15
6
Nisan
Mrs. Samuel Barnctt
Husband
April 16
7
Nisan
Abraham Karlin
Father
April 16
7
Nisan
Harry S. Katlowitz
Father
April 16
7
Mrs. Rose Fleischman
1
Abe H. Zirn
I Father
April 17
8
Nisan
Samuel Zirn
j
David B. Kaminsky
Father
April 18
9
Nisan
Irving Gottlieb
1
Mrs. Charles Safier
April 19
10
Nisan
Mrs. Norbcrt Ungcr
j. Father
David B. Kaminsky
Mother
April 19
10
Nisan
Benjamin Kaplan
Wife
April 21
12
Nisan
Mrs. Harry Levy
Mrs. Isador Lowcnfeld
| Brother
April 21
12
Nisan
Dr. Irving Moskowitz
Moses Resnick
Mother
April 22
13
Nisan
HYMAN
SPITZ inc.
OUR ONLY STORE
Dickens 2-4000
1685 PITKIN AVENUE
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
21
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Baumgarten, Miss Lillian
Res. 307 Sterling St.
Proposed by Morris Dershowitz
Benjamin, Mitchell
Res. 31 Billings PI.
Bus. Mfg., 110 West 40th St.
Single
Proposed by Florence Gallant,
Minnie S. Cutler
Berger, Morris
Res. 317 Albany Ave.
Bus. Insurance, 138 Montague St.
Proposed by Hyman Kaplan,
Aaron Pollack
Blumberg, Richard
Res. 201 Linden Blvd.
Student
Single
Proposed by Maurice Yaffe,
Jack M. Blumberg
Cohen, Isidore
Res. 321 East 92nd St.
Bus. Hebrew Home, 3573 Bruckner
Blvd.
Married
Proposed by Abe Mann,
Louis Rosenblatt
Daar, Joseph M.
Res. 1212 Lincoln PI.
Bus. Gov't, 90 Church St.
Married
DuBoff, Murray M.
Res. 654 Sheffield Ave.
Bus. Ins. Adjuster, 1797 Pitkin Ave.
Single
Proposed by Abe Mann
Engel, Harry
Res. 919 Park PI.
Bus. Import, 170 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Abraham Gross,
Max Pressner
Farber, Miss Florence
Res. 144 East 94th St.
Proposed by Dr. Alexander Leff,
Ben Leff
Friedrich, Dr. Martin
Res. 1486 President St.
Bus. Physician, 1504 President St.
Married
Proposed by Dr. Alex Slanger,
Abr. Shapiro
Garvin, Miss Lynn
Res. 706 Lefferts Ave.
Proposed by Richard Nepon,
Gerald Jacobs
Goldberg, Irving T.
Res. 751 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Attorney, 725 Nostrand Ave.
Married
Proposed by Joseph Levy, Jr.,
Abe Mann
Gottlieb, Harry
Res. 217 Ocean Ave.
Bus. Insurance, 217 Ocean Ave.
Married
Greenberg, Emil
Res. 240 Crown St.
Bus. Librarian, Brooklyn College.
Married
Proposed by Wm. C. Smerling,
Harry H. Cohen
Herman, Louis
Res. 564 Empire Blvd.
Bus. Millinery, 289 Kingston Ave.
Married
Proposed by Mrs. M. Robert Epstein
Joseph, Miss Estelle
Res. 475 Riverdale Ave.
Proposed by Hy and Sol Rosen
Leventhal, Jack
Res. 1360 — 48th St.
Bus. Hosiery, 60 Orchard St.
Single
Proposed by A. L. Goldman
Levy, Harold N.
Res. 934 Carroll St.
Bus. Shoes, 1136 Fulton St.
Single
Proposed by Abe Mann,
Jos. Schonbrun
LlEBERMAN, JACK
Res. 270 Crown St.
Bus. Pharmacy, 318 Rogers Ave.
Married
Proposed by Isador Lowenfeld,
Dr. Irv. L. Moskowitz
Meyerson, Miss Miriam
Res. 724 Montgomery St.
Proposed by Mrs. Louis J. Roth
Oginz, Miss Muriel
Res. 257 Herzl St.
Proposed by Richard Nepon,
Jacqueline Benson
Orlins, Myron S.
Res. 576 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Export, 20 Broad St.
Single
Proposed by A. L. Goldman
Raucher, Herman
Res. 50 East 19th St.
Student
Single
Proposed by Maurice Jaffe,
Jack M. Blumberg
Rosenblum, Edward
Res. 897 Empire Blvd.
Bus. Engraving, 265 Canal St.
Single
Proposed by
Schaeffer, Edward P.
Res. 485 Ocean Ave.
Bus. Service Sta., 259 Empire Blvd.
Married
Proposed by Phil Amster,
Geo. Feldman
Morris Rosen Son April 22 13 Nisan
Sol Horowitz Father April 23 14 Nisan
Mrs. Alexander Bernstein Father April 24 15 Nisan
SaulAbelov Mother April 25 16 Nisan
Charles Dilbert Mother April 25 16 Nisan
Mrs. S. A. Schneider Father April 26 17 Nisan
Victor Filler Wife ) Apfil 26 u Nisan
Mrs. Carl Sklar Daughter )
Louis Gordon Brother April 27 18 Nisan
Herman A. Katz J
Martin Katz I Mot h er April 27 18 Nisan
Paul Katz f
Phil Katz J
Leo Kaufman Mother April 28 19 Nisan
Note: Observance of Yahrzeit commences on the evening preceding
the specified date.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
Schwartz, Miss Lillian
Res. 3 85 So. 4th St.
Proposed by Jack Silverman
Sheren, Miss Beatrice
Res. 28 Christopher Ave.
Proposed by Hy and Sol Rosen
Sherry, Arthur
Res. 115 East 21st St.
Bus. Knit Goods, 93 Worth St.
Single
Proposed by A. L. Goldman
Simenowitz, Daniel H.
Res. 1079 Carroll St.
Bus. Attorney, 291 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Irving Kramer,
Frank Rose
Sorotsky, Miss Claire
Res. 919 Saratoga Ave.
Proposed by Milton Slow
Subin, Louis
Res. 1198 Carroll St.
Bus. Macy's, Herald Square
Married
Proposed by Isador Lowenfeld
Suess, Miss Marilyn
Res. 675 Empire Blvd.
Proposed by Richard Nepon,
Leo Chizner
Wolf, Morris
Res. 31 East 54th St.
Bus. Furs, 155 West 29th St.
Married
Proposed by Samuel Chasin,
Abe Mann
The following have applied for rein-
statement:
Cahan, Ben
Res. 50 Plaza St.
Bus. Food Packers, 269 — 37th St.
Married
Proposed by Chas. Dilbert
Engel, Harold Z.
Res. 5 5 1 Crown St.
Bus. Junior Wear, 13 59 Broadway
Proposed by Lawrence and
Samuel Stark
Strausberg, Morris O.
Res. 135 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Motion Picture, 120 W. 42nd St.
Married
Proposed by Abe Mann,
Meyer Hausner
LATE APPLICATIONS
Jablin, Miss Pearl
Res. 831 Saratoga Ave.
Kotin, Charles
Res. 1325 Union St.
Bus. Polo Shirts, 138 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Louis Gordon
Kozupsky, Harold
Res. 1687 Sterling PI.
Bus. Wholesale, 462 Broadway
Single
Proposed by Richard Nepon
Mizner, Miss Helen
Res. 1549 Prospect PI.
Proposed by Jeanette Block,
Bella Block
SCHOENBACH, JACOB
Res. 52 Balfour Pi.
Bus. Jobber, 1645 Bedford Ave.
Proposed by Richard Nepon
Siebner, Miss Lenore
Res. 1225 Eastern Parkway
Proposed by Jeanette Block,
Bella Block
Married
Shapiro, Miss Gertrude
Res. 831 Linden Blvd.
Proposed by Shirley Blacher
Wien, Allen A.
Res. 143 Penn St.
Bus. Furs, 158 W. 27th St.
Single
Proposed by Irwin Cohen,
Morris Dershowitz
Samuel H. Goldberg,
Chairman, Membership Committee.
Personals
Best wishes are extended to the follow-
ing:
Mr. Bruce Douglas, son of Dr. and
Mrs. William Douglas of 569 Eastern
Parkway, who will be graduated this
June from the New York University
College of Dentistry and has been ac-
cepted for his interneship at the Queens
General Hospital.
Mr. Daniel L. Kurshan, son of Mr.
and Mrs. Samuel L. Kurshan of 1495
President Street, who has been serving as
Chief of the Administrative Management
unit of the Mayor's Division of Analysis,
was named Program Director of the Citi-
zens Budget Commission.
Mr. and Mrs. Albert Ross of 270
Crown Street announce that their daugh-
ter, Sondra, recently married to Dr.
Chester Elliot, has received her Bachelor
of Science degree from George Washing-
ton University.
Acknowledgment of Gifts
We acknowledge with thanks receipt
of the donations for the purchase of
Prayer Books and Taleisim and books in
our library.
Mr. and Mrs. Morris Dworetzky in
honor of their son's Bar Mitzvah.
Mr. and Mrs. Isador Lowenfeld, in
memory of parents.
Mrs. Rose Posner in honor of the birth
of a grandchild.
Mrs. Rose Rosenberg, in memory of
parents.
Mr. and Mrs. Abraham Rothkopf, in
honor of son's marriage.
Mr. and Mrs. Kalman Sloate, in honor
of the Bar Mitzvah of their son.
SPECIAL POST-BAR-MITZVAH
SERVICE
The last Friday night service of the
year will be designated as a Post-Bar-
Mitzvah Service. Students of the Mar-
shalliah, Post-Graduate Hebrew Class and
Post-Bar-Mitzvah Class who have com-
pleted two years of study after their
Bar-Mitzvah will be awarded certificates
of achievement.
The following will receive certificates:
Burton Garber, Thomas Kraner, Robert
Kritz, Lawrence Heimowitz, Stanley
Green, Leonard Berman, Sandor Schaeffer,
Alex Sterman, Abner Beder, Morris
Flamm, Lloyd Altman, and Daniel Kling-
hoffer.
Young People's League
Convention April 1-2-3
The Young People's League of the
United Synagogue of America is holding
their convention at Atlantic City, Thurs-
day, Friday and Saturday, April 1st, 2nd
and 3rd, and members of our Young
Folks League are reminded to please make
plans to attend.
Young Folks League Notes
The Young Folks League of the Cen-
ter is asked to reserve Saturday evening,
May 22nd for an important Young Folks
League function. More details later.
Red Cross Campaign
Mrs. Lawrence Meyer has been ap-
pointed the chairman of the Red Cross
Drive for this year and members are asked
to please send their checks to Mrs. Meyer
in care of the Center.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
A QUIZ FOR
[Continued f
United Jewish Appeal, the Feder-
ation of Charities, educational
and higher institutions of learn-
ing? (13 points)
Read the above over carefully and
check your replies.
Should Your
The Score Be Rating
Part I— The Home 48
Part II — The Synagogue 26
Part III — The Community 26
This is not an exhaustive test, nor a
test of a truly intensive Jewish life. It
is rather a test of minimum duties as a
Jew. But if one has a low rating even in
such a minimum program of Jewish liv-
ing, it ought to serve as a reminder and
warning that he or she is failing in duty
YOUR FAITH
om page 13]
as a Jew. It should make the person real-
ize that we are unworthy of the name
Jew unless we try to live up to certain
obligations of Jewish living. And if one
is fortunate enough to pass this self-ex-
amination with a high rating, it should
spur him on to greater effort and to the
realization of further obligations, know-
ing that the greatest joy of Jewish living
comes to one who lives the Jewish life
in the fullest measure of the term.
CENTER ACADEMY NEWS
We are proud to announce that Eliz-
abeth Gropper of our 8th Grade is
one of the winners of the book review
contest conducted by the New York
MetropoUtan Jewish Book Council. Her
prize was enrollment as a member in the
Jewish Publication Society of America for
the year 1948. In connection with the
same contest she also received the book,
"Americans All" by Leonard as one of
the winners of the prize given by the
local community.
The members of the Senior Class at the
Center Academy were hosts to the Par-
ents-Teachers Association on Wednesday
evening, March 17th. The program for
the evening consisted of a round table dis-
cussion by the graduating class on the
Marshall Plan. The entire program was
under the direction of Mrs. Ann D.
Greenstein, teacher of the graduating
class.
TRIBUTES TO
[Continued
of our generation devotion particularly
to the cause of Zion and the rebirth of
an autonomous Jewish community in
Eretz Yisrael, unsurpassed brilliance as
a preacher, geniality as friend and com-
panion; these, and much more, which I
must leave unsaid have all contributed
to place him at the pinnacle of the Amer-
ican rabbinate. He has set a standard for
his younger colleagues to admire and to
Beginning March 28th, at the Jewish
Museum, 92nd Street and 5th Avenue,
there will be an exhibition of paintings
on the theme, "Life in Our Community."
The children of the Center Academy have
contributed several paintings to this ex-
hibit.
During the week of March 30th
through April 2nd, the Brooklyn Jewish
Center will present an exhibition of the
art work done by the children of the
Center Academy. Paintings and clay
work will be on exhibition in the audi-
torium. Parents are cordially invited to
attend the formal opening of the exhibit
on Tuesday, March 30th at 1:00 P. M.
Mr. Harris, the Art Teacher, will speak
briefly on the art work of the Center
Academy.
DR. LEVINTHAL
from page 13]
seek to emulate.
I thank God with Rabbi Levinthal that
his beloved and revered father can parti-
cipate in this hour of his joy. All of us
at the Seminary turn in fervent prayer
to the Almighty that He may spare him
and his dear, good wife in health and
happiness of heart for many more decades
to be his servant as he has always desired
to be, and a crown of glory for all Israel.
Rabbi Levinthal at 60
[Continued from page 4]
religion the Jew is taught to see joy, hope
and promise. By fulfilling the Torah, the
American Jew enhances his own well-
being as well as that of the community.
Judaism should be observed as a living
religion. For almost forty years, Dr.
Levinthal has been stressing from the
Center pulpit the spiritual affinity be-
tween the ideals of Americanism and
Judaism.
The wisdom and learning Rabbi Levin-
thal has showered on his Congregation
and the community during his long min-
istry has been of inestimable worth to
them. He has been an influence for
goodness permeating all ranks of Jewry.
Toiling ceaselessly, Dr. LevinthaPs pri-
mary and earnest concern has been that
the word of God should prevail as a force
motivating men's conduct. By observing
Torah, by leading righteous lives, by be-
lieving and acting in the Jewish tradi-
tion, the congregation and American
Jewry will vindicate all that Rabbi Lev-
inthal has fought for. That is the real
way to honor him and to encourage him
to continue, as we fervently hope he will
have the strength to do for many years
to come, in his beneficent service to his
people, his country and God.
The Jezcs of America Have
Undertaken the Stupendous
Task of liaising
$250,000,000
for the
United Jewish Appeal
The Brooklyn Jewish Center
Quota in tho Campaign is
$2,000,000
Every Center Member is
Expected to Contribute
Generously io Help Meet
the Unprecedented Needs of
the Jewish People.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
■ ■
ABBOT-FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES-SERVICE
507 Flatbush Avenue
JESSE J. FINE Brooklyn, New York
JACK ABBOT Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
RIVERSIDE-
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2-6600
Far Rockaway, L. I. Miami Beach, Florida
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE 1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
FAr Rockaway 7-7100 Miami 5-7777
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle, we have arranged to
serve your Community. We have at our disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn.
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eattern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Pottage Guaranteed
Sec 562, P. L. St R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
ALBERT EINSTEIN-CITIZEN OF
ONE WORLD
By ALFRED WERNER
A JEWISH STATE IN FACT
SALUTATION
A Short Story
By WILLIAM I. SIEGEL
By SYLVAN KARCHMER
THE WAY IT USED TO BE
By BERDIE BECK
PIONEER OF MODERN HEBREW
By LEO SHPALL
AN INVITATION
TO THE MEMBERS
OF THE BROOKLYN
JEWISH CENTER
Annual Dinner
of THE
Brooklyn Jewish Center
on behalf of the
United Jewish Appeal
Thursday Evening, May 6, 1948.
Guest Speaker
Rabbi Arthur J. Lelyveld
Subscription $5. per person — Please send in your reservation today.
Rabbi Arthur J. Lelyveld
Rabbi Arthur J. Lelyveld, a New
Yorker, is National Director of the B'nai
Brith Hillel Foundations, and well-known
in Jewish communal and educational
circles throughout the country. He is
one of the founders of the National Fed-
eration of Temple Youth, and a member
of the Commission on Justice and Peace
of the Central Conference of American
Rabbis.
NITED Jewish appeal can provide life-sustain-
ing help for 25,000 D.P.'s in Europe; can
prepare 75,000 for emigration to Palestine and
house and feed them on arrival; can speed the
economic recovery of Western Europe's 450,000
Jews, and provide the difference between life
and death for the 830,000 in Eastern Europe —
100,000 became self-supporting in 1947 . . . All
this can be done only if you help to make ade-
quate funds available NOW . . . Your contribu-
tions will provide not only these absolutely vital
needs, but many others without which our people
will suffer immeasurable hardships.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Vol. XXIX APRIL, 1948 — NISAN, 5708 No. 33
A JEWISH STATE IN FACT
THE declaration by the General
Council of the World Zionist Or-
ganization (printed on page 4)
is an epochal document. In legal, as well
as practical effect, it is the Declaration
of Independence of the new Jewish State.
In the sense that it is unilateral in ex-
pression it parallels other historic pro-
nouncements of similar kind, notably the
American Declaration of Independence.
In the fact, however, that it is based upon
a prior recognition of the existing rights
of the Jewish Commonwealth and, thus,
is a bilateral instrument, this declaration
is unique in international history. We
refer, of course, to the fact — indisputable
in the record, although, undoubtedly, it
will be sought in many quarters to dis-
tort it in interpretation — that the General
Council's declaration follows close in
point of time upon, and is grounded
deeply in point of law in, the Partition
Resolution, adopted November 29, 1947,
by the General Assembly of the United
Nations.
•
The kaleidoscopic succession of inter-
national tactics since November 29th un-
happily makes necessary a resume of the
events following that day. The United
Nations, under the sponsorship of the
United States, voted by a large majority
for the Partition of Palestine into Arab
and Jewish States. No contemporary stu-
dent can say of this action that it is a
completely just settlement of the Jewish
claim to Palestine, and no historian in the
future will be able to record it as any-
thing other than a fragmentation of Jew-
ish rights. The Partition Plan is in many
respects an inequitable provision for the
future of Jewish statehood.
Territorially, it deprives the Jews of
seven-eighths of the land guaranteed them
by the Balfour Declaration and the Man-
date. Militarily, it gives them a frontier
which can be defended, if at all, only by
supreme effort and at great cost. Gov-
ernmentally, it imposes on the Jewish
State a financial burden for the support
of the Arab State which has no warrant
in the facts of the situation and which
will for years redound only to the bene-
fit of the feudal masters of Arabia. It
ignores completely the illegal creation of
the Kingdom of Transjordania out of land
guaranteed to the Jews. At best, the Par-
tition Proposal was, in theory, a compro-
mise and a settlement forced upon the
Jews by the realization that its provi-
sions were the best for which they could
hope in a power-ridden international
assembly. The Jews accepted partition
in good faith. With a realism bred by
the centuries-long history of persecution
and chicanery forced upon them by
stronger powers they stood ready to make
the most, for themselves and for the land,
of this bad bargain.
•
It is almost as difficult to recount as
it is to explain subsequent developments.
The United States suddenly, to the
amazement of observers and to the deep
humiliation of its citizens who value the
honor of our country, and who hold in
high and sacred regard the reputations
of its pledge, executed an about-face.
This is an act which has had assigned
for it no tangible reason, and the mo-
tive for which becomes daily more ob-
scure in the murky insinuations of its
apologists that it is based upon so-called
considerations of national defense.
Whether willingly or not, Senator
Austin was compelled to seek justifica-
tion for this program of betrayal by an
interpretation of the statutes and consti-
tution of the United Nations which have
emasculated that body's charter and
which, if applied to other and subsequent
problems arising before the body, will
completely frustrate any possibility of
the United Nations becoming a vital
force in the preservation of international
peace. We have said that the reason for
the volte-face is inexplicable. That is to
say, there can be found no justification
in law, morals or ethics. Reasons, of
course, there are. It is a matter of rec-
ord that American and British oil com-
panies are the possessors of great inter-
ests in Saudi Arabian oil, and that they
have powerful connections in the Truman
administration. There is not merely an
accidental or coincidental relationship be-
tween the oil companies financed by
Dillon Reed & Co. and the presence in
the Truman cabinet of a powerful sec-
retary. It is mortifying to any American
citizen to be forced to this conclusion, and
yet it is a conclusion in which he is sup-
ported by the practically unanimous opin-
ion of responsible commentators, great
newspapers, clergymen, senators and men
of discernment and freedom and frank-
ness of expression throughout the land.
Indeed, these serious charges have not,
even by implication, been denied. So
secure apparently are the proponents of
the oil policy in their strength that they
have treated these charges with a silence
almost as contemptible as the policy
which they have sponsored.
There come times in history when a
people is enabled by supreme conviction,
great courage and undying devotion to an
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by th e editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Is affiliated with the United Synaqoque of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Greenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron. Vice-Presidents David Goodsteln. Treasurer Frank Schaeffer. Secretary
Israel H. levinthal, D.D., D.H.L, Rabbi Manuel Salhmen, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
ii
MANY, MANY THANKS
I WANT to utilize this column to ex-
press my profound appreciation to
everyone in and out of our Brooklyn
Jewish Center who helped to make the
occasion of my sixtieth birthday the
memorable event that it was for me.
It is a pity that words are often in-
adequate to truly express the feelings of
one's heart. No words that my hand
could pen could begin to tell how grate-
ful I am for the affection and the esteem
which have been shown to me. One heart
does feel another. I felt your love, and
I knew that your hearts felt the affec-
tion and the gratitude which flowed from
my heart toward you.
I think that this mutual feeling, which
has existed between us throughout all the
years, from the very inception of my
rabbinate in your midst, is part of the
secret of the success which the Brooklyn
Jewish Center has achieved.
Though I personally was the recipient
and the beneficiary of your affection, I
know that I was but a symbol in your
mind of the Rabbinate, the spiritual lead-
ership of our people, an institution which
you cherish and revere because you rec-
ognize the indispensable function which
it holds in the life of Israel. Nay, more,
it was a living proof of the reverence
which you have for Torah, and for all
those who endeavor to make our spiritual
and cultural treasures the heritage of our
people.
In my remarks at the reception, I men-
tioned those to whom I owe a special debt
of thanks. To all of them, from office
worker to the distinguished personalities
who honored me with their addresses and
their greetings, from the rank and file of
our membership and worshippers to the
officers and the committee, who did so
much to make my birthday party so suc-
cessful — to all, once again, I give my
heartfelt thanks.
I pray that I may be privileged to re-
ciprocate in some measure and to return
to each of you my felicitations and good
wishes for many joyous occasions in your
lives.
ideal to lift itself by its own boot-straps.
This the Jews are now doing in Palestine.
They are tired of the obfuscations of in-
ternational politics. They have deter-
mined, in the words of our Bible, no
longer to put their trust in princes. They
see themselves as the guardians of Jewish
destiny for all time to come. They stand
four-square upon the rights granted them
in the partition resolution and they chal-
lenge the world to deprive them of those
rights. Theirs is the strength, not only
of morals, but of law. The declaration
of November 29th by the United Nations
is a charter which once given cannot be
taken away. It creates as of May 16th
(the British Mandate terminating on May
15 th) a de )nre government which, even
at this moment, is a de facto govern-
ment. It is useless and silly to talk of
preventing partition from taking place
because partition is already an accom-
plished fact. There are intimations that
the United States will attempt to force
upon an unwilling United Nations a
trusteeship plan for all in Palestine which,
in essence, is an enlargement of the trus-
teeship plan for Jerusalem. That plan
must fail for a variety of reasons. Thus,
even in the case of Jerusalem, the United
Nations has not protected the Holy City
from Arab attack. Again trusteeship im-
plies responsibility, the one thing no one
in the United Nations appears to be ready
to assume with respect to any part of
Palestine. Lastly, trusteeship must fail
because it represents an inequitable and
illegal attempt to rescind a legal action
already accepted in the strong forum of
public opinion.
— Wm. J. SlEGEL.
SLAVES NO MORE!
AN INTERESTING Seder custom
prevails among Oriental Jews. At
the beginning of the Seder a knock is
heard on the door, and the younger mem-
bers of the family appear in the guise
of the wandering Israelites of old.
"Mi atem (Who are you)?" asks the
head of the family.
"Israelites — from Egypt," is the reply.
"L'an (Whither)?"
"L'Eretz Yisrael."
Jews who have been uprooted from
their homes by the Nazi scourge and the
devastation of the last war again ask,
"Whither?" And again there is but one
reply, "To Eretz Yisrael."
Passover, which commemorates the
birth of a nation, must inspire us today
to strive for the rebirth of our nation.
The Jews have been soldiers of liberty for
4,000 years — and again we strive to
achieve that independence for which our
chalutzim in Palestine have worked with
so much toil and so much self-sacrifice.
Freedom and independence have never
been won without a struggle. The
Yishuv in Palestine has shown that it is
willing to pay the price of liberty. It is
not for us, sitting in our comfortable
homes here in America, to determine the
course of our struggle in Eretz Yisrael.
But the Yishuv itself has spoken. The
Jews of Palestine have resolved that no
sacrifice will deter them from their goal
— a free Jewish state in Palestine.
It is for us in America to demonstrate
that the Yishuv does not stand alone.
Let not the words of the Haggadah
be empty phrases, but rather spurs to
action.
"Lo! this is the bread of affliction,
which our ancestors ate in the land of
Egypt. . . . This year we celebrate it here,
but the next year we hope to celebrate
it in the land of Israel. This year we are
slaves, but the next year we shall be free
men."
MORDECAI H. LEWITTES.
The text of the Jewish Declaration
of Independence is published on
page 26.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
ALBERT EINSTEIN-CITIZEN
OF ONE WORLD
RECENTLY the "One World Award
Committee," composed of outstand-
ing American liberals, decided that
the One World Award, established four
years ago in memory of Wendell L.
Willkie, would go this year to Dr. Albert
Einstein. When this selection was pub-
licly announced at a dinner for another
Nobel Prize winner and lover of peace,
Sir Norman Angell, the chairman ex-
plained that the Sage of Princeton had
been chosen because of his hatred of mili-
tarism, dictatorship and violence, and be-
cause he had lent "his unequaled prestige
to the causes he identifies with the cause
of mankind."
This is not the first time that the great
physicist has been honored in this
country. Years ago, when New York's
Riverside Church was built, the Reverend
Dr. Fosdick and his associates decided
that part of the edifice's ornamentation
should consist of the figures of important
men whose work has enriched the world,
and in a niche that includes the world's
outstanding scientists, the builders placed
a sculptured image of Einstein.
Einstein is not only one of the great
scientists of this century, but he is one
of the very few learned men who step
out of the ivory tower of pure science
to challenge the foes of humanity when-
ever they feel that mankind's spiritual
values are threatened. He has been called
an eminent physicist ever since 1905,
when he issued his first statement on the
theory of relativity, but his fight against
the forces of darkness has not yet been
fully recognized or acknowledged.
•
The old saying that the child is father
of the man has been proved to be true
in the case of Einstein. Even as a child
he heartily disliked militarism. Though
born and raised in Bismarck's sabre-
rattling Germany, he differed from other
German youngsters in that they enthusi-
astically watched the glamorous parades
of the German army while he, Albert,
used to cry at such sights. While most
German children dreamt of marching in
those parades as adults, Albert told his
parents: "When I grow up, I don't want
to be one of those poor people." With-
out trying to be stuffy, one of his biog-
raphers observes: "When the majority
saw the rhythm of a happy movement,
he (Albert) observed the coercion im-
posed upon the soldiers; he saw the parade
as a movement of people compelled to be
machines."
Small wonder that an independent in-
dividual of this type would loathe the
German system of education which per-
mitted the teachers in the elementary
schools to act like drill sergeants, while
the gymnasium teachers would treat their
pupils with the more refined sadism of
German lieutenants. It was to be ex-
pected that in this period of unmitigated
chauvinism the teachers would try their
utmost to instill into the minds of the
young folks a "Deutschland ueber alles"
attitude, yet young Albert remained un-
affected by this irrational appeal to cer-
tain atavistic instincts in man. However,
it would be wrong to assume that it was
his Jewishness which caused him to re-
main immune to Teutonic nationalism;
in the first place, Einstein got little for-
mal Jewish education, and he is, despite
his pro-Zionist activities, what is gen-
erally called an assimilationist; secondly,
many German Jews succumbed to the
lure of Teutonicism. Take the case of
Fritz Haber, the greatest chemist of his
time, and Nobel Prize winner. At the
beginning of the first World War, when
leading German intellectuals prepared a
Manifesto culminating in the absurd
assertion that German culture and Ger-
man militarism were identical, Haber was
one of the co-signers. Einstein, however,
then Professor at the University of Berlin
and a member of the Royal Prussian
Academy of Science, refused to put his
signature under it. Some of his col-
leagues accused him of being a traitor,
of deserting the Reich in a difficult time.
Later, some of these Germans became
highly proud of "their" Einstein (who
had acquired Swiss citizenship, but actu-
ally was a citizen of the world). A year
after the armistice, expeditions dispatched
by British scientific societies to Brazil and
West Africa to make certain astronomic
observations, verified Einstein's bold
theory that rays of light are bent as they
pass in the neighborhood of the sun.
By ALFRED WERNER
Einstein then became a German hero to
many. More ferocious Germans, however,
permitted their anti-Semitism to dismiss
Einstein's theories as "Bolshevism in
physics," "Jewish physics," and so forth.
At the same time British scientists hailed
the theory of relativity as "one of the
greatest achievements in the history of
human thought." However, since the
man in the street was bound to loathe
everything German, British newspapers
decided to sell Einstein to their public as
a Swiss, although he was a native of
Bavaria. Allergic to any sort of preju-
dice, whether directed against Jews, Ger-
mans, or any other group of people, Ein-
stein, in an article written for the London
Times, gently chided the editors for their
intentional inaccuracy:
"The description of me and my cir-
cumstances in the Times shows an amus-
ing flare of imagination on the part of
the writer. By an application of the
theory of relativity to the taste of the
reader, today in Germany I am called a
German man of science and in England
I am represented as a Swiss Jew. If I
come to be regarded as a 'bete noire,' the
description will be reversed, and I shall
become a Swiss Jew for the Germans and
a German for the English."
•
Einstein, who changed his citizenship
several times and is now a citizen of the
United States, never cared for any kind
of aggressive nationalism, nor was he ever
a member of a political party. On the
other hand, this solitary thinker, who
once characterized himself as "a horse
for single harness, not cut out for tandem
or teamwork," frequently abandoned his
profound studies for a while to lend his
prestige to the two movements that are
close to his heart, namely, Zionism and
Pacifism.
While deeply impressed by the ethical
values of the Old Testament, Einstein
has little, if anything, in common with
Jewish orthodoxy. If he felt that Zion-
Broolclyn Jewish Center Review
6
ism was aggressive or narrow-minded, he
would not have sponsored it, as he has
been doing for a quarter of a century or
longer, and whenever he noticed ten-
dencies and trends in Zionism not to his
liking, he would not hesitate to object to
them. But why did Einstein, known as
a foe of nationalism, espouse Zionism?
Because, according to one biographer, he
sees in Zionism the only active movement
among the Jews capable of arousing in
them the sense of dignity; because, ac-
cording to another biographer, he
ardently deplores the injustice on the part
of the world at large towards a people
that is constantly and unreasonably under
attack. In particular, Einstein noticed
with deep pain how discrimination against
Jews in many Eastern European univer-
sities prevented many a gifted youth from
embarking upon an academic career.
Realizing that a Hebrew University in
Jerusalem, the pet idea of Chaim Weiz-
mann, would enable many thwarted Jew-
ish professors and students to develop
their abilities as free men, Einstein gladly
accepted Weizmann's invitation to tour
the United States to help raise funds for
the establishment of the University. To-
gether with the great chemist and presi-
dent of the World Zionist Organization,
Einstein addressed mass meetings from
coast to coast. "Follow Weizmann, and
you will do well!" he admonished Amer-
ican Jewry. In the city of Cleveland,
all Jewish businessmen closed their shops
to march in a parade that accompanied
Einstein from the station to the City
Hall.
Einstein visited Palestine in 1923 as a
host of Herbert Samuel, the English Jew
who served as High Commissioner. Many
years later, at the opening of the Pales-
tine Pavilion at the New York World's
Fair, Einstein was chosen to deliver the
main address, as though he were the offi-
cial ambassador of Eretz Israel. He has
been a member of the Hebrew Univer-
sity's Board of Governors since its estab-
lishment, and its Institute of Physics is
named after him. In 1933, the afore-
mentioned Fritz Haber wrote to him that
he intended to apply for a position at
the Hebrew University. "The whole
world is topsy-turvy!" Einstein exclaimed
in surprise, remembering how the great
chemist had repeatedly urged him to
adopt the German nationalistic creed.
Dismissed by the Nazis, Haber had fled
to Switzerland. But he never went to the
Holy Land. In January, 1934, he killed
himself in Lucerne.
Einstein was never so alienated from
Judaism as was his unhappy friend. In
fact, he once even tried to discover the
roots of his pacifism in his innate Jew-
ishness.
"Jewry" he told a Jewish meeting in
Berlin "has proved that the intellect is
the best weapon in history. Oppressed
by violence, Jewry has mocked her en-
emies by rejecting war and at the same
time has taught peace. ... It is the duty
of us Jews to put at the disposal of the
world our several-thousand-years-old sor-
rowful experience and, true to the ethical
traditions of our forefathers, become sol-
diers in the fight for peace, united with
the noblest elements in all cultural and
religious circles."
•
As far as Einstein is concerned, he did,
indeed, "put at the disposal of the world"
his prestige in behalf of the preservation
of peace. His pacifism, based on his
"deepest antipathy to every kind of
cruelty and hatred," was stronger than
his desire to be left alone, so he accepted
an appointment to the Commission pour
la Cooperation lntellecttielle of the League
of Nations. Only upon noticing that the
League did not function satisfactorily and
that, instead of preventing the use of
force altogether, it urged the weak na-
tions to submit to the demands of the
big powers, did he resign: "I withdraw
because the League of Nations, as it func-
tions at present, not only does not em-
body the ideal of an international or-
ganization, but actually discredits such
an ideal."
How fervently Einstein loathes all
military institutions can be learned from
an appeal he issued in 1931, placing his
reputation at the disposal of the War Re-
sisters International:
"I appeal to all men and women,
whether they be eminent or humble, to
declare that they will refuse to give any
further assistance to war or to the prep-
aration of war. I ask them to tell their
governments this in writing and to reg-
ister this decision by informing me that
they have done so. ... I have authorized
the establishment of the 'Einstein War
Resisters International Fund.' "
Einstein deplored the fact that many
leading scientists contributed to man-
kind's self-destruction by producing in-
struments of war, and he wondered
whether those men of science could not
prevent the outbreak of further wars by
their joint refusal to use their talents for
war. Imbued with an idealism that some
will call naive while others may describe
it as "prophetic," he wrote letters to the
outstanding scientists in all countries,
asking them to meet with him and to
discuss the possibility of preventing fur-
ther wars. Einstein was shocked to learn
that only a handful of scientists cared
to answer his appeal affirmatively, whereas
the vast majority either did not answer or
called his plan hopelessly Utopian.
It was only Hitler's assumption of
power that caused Einstein to modify his
extreme views on pacifism. Realizing
that this was not the time for upholding
pacifist ideas ("When the time comes to
preserve life then we have to fight
back"), he persuaded himself that the
Fascists would stop at nothing, and that
the present civilization would be de-
stroyed by the new barbarians if they
would not be crushed in time. Having
left Germany shortly before Hitler had
become chancellor of the Reich, Einstein
demonstratively broke all his relationships
with the Reich and resigned from the
Prussian Academy. Thereupon he re-
ceived a peculiar letter from that insti-
tution: Not only did the Academy re-
gret his action, but it had even expected
him, Einstein, to range himself "on the
side of the defenders of our nation against
the flood of lies which has been let loose
upon it. ... A good word for the Ger-
man people from you in particular would
have produced the greatest effect — espe-
cially abroad."
•
Einstein who, as an exile in Belgium,
had learned everything that could be
known about the maltreatment of Jews,
liberals, leftists and other enemies of the
Third Reich, answered this hypocritical
and shameless letter with a brief epistle
which burned with indignation and
anger:
"Such a testimony as you suggest
would have been equivalent to a repudi-
ation of all those notions of justice and
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
7
liberty for which I have stood all my
life. Such testimony would not be, as
you put it, a good word for the German
nation; on the contrary, it would only
have helped the cause of those who are
seeking to undermine the ideas and prin-
ciples which have won for the German
nation a place of honor in the civilized
world. By giving such testimony in these
present circumstances, I should have been
contributing, even if only indirectly, to
the barbarization of manners and the de-
struction of all existing cultural values."
Once Nazism had forced Einstein to
alter his views, he continued to fight the
Brown Plague as a humanist as well as
in his capacity of a scientist. As is com-
monly known by now, it was Einstein's
early discovery that under certain con-
ditions matter could be changed into
energy and vice versa, which enabled the
scientists to construct the atomic bomb.
Worried about the possibility that the
Nazis might produce the weapon before
the Americans, Einstein, in August 1939,
wrote a letter to President Roosevelt say-
ing that a bomb could be produced which,
"exploded in a port . . . might very well
destroy the whole port together with the
surrounding territory." Fortunately, Ein-
stein's advice to accelerate research on
the practical use of uranium did not fall
on deaf ears, so that six years after the
scientist had mailed his letter the first
atomic bomb was dropped from a U. S.
airplane.
Although the war ended with an Al-
lied victory, Einstein did not stop worry-
ing about the state of the world. He
fully agreed with that bright American
high school boy, who, in an essay, summed
up the gigantic problem caused by the
terrible new weapon in one sentence
"The Atomic Age is here to stay — are
we?" Last year Einstein developed a
plan for the preservation of peace despite
atomic bombs:
"I am in favor of inviting the Rus-
sians to join a world government author-
ized to provide security," he told Ray-
mond Swing, "and if they are unwilling
to join, to proceed to establish supra-
national security without them. Let me
admit quickly that I see great peril in
such a course. If it is adopted it must
be done in a way to make it utterly clear
that the new regime is not a combination
of power against Russia. It must be a
combination that, by its composite na-
ture, will greatly reduce the chances of
war. It will be more diverse in its in-
terests than any single state, thus less
likely to resort to aggressive or preventive
war. It will be dedicated to a supra-
national security, and thus escape the em-
phasis on national supremacy which is so
strong a factor in war."
Warning the U. S. A. that other na-
tions, too, will be able to produce the
bomb, Einstein continued as follows:
"Unless Americans come to recognize
that they are not stronger in the world
because they have the bomb, but weaker
because of their vulnerability to atomic
attack, they are not likely to conduct
their policy at Lake Success or in their
relations with Russia in a spirit that fur-
thers the arrival of an understanding."
Thus spoke the Sage of Princeton, the
seer whom this country is honoring with
the "One World Award." Thus spoke
the greatest Jew of our time, who once
stated his credo as a Jew in these words:
"The striving after knowledge for its
own sake, the love of justice verging on
fanaticism, and the quest for personal in-
dependence — these are the motivating tra-
ditions of the Jewish people which cause
me to regard my adherence to them as a
gift of destiny. Those who rage today
against the ideals of reason and of indi-
vidual freedom, and seek to impose an
insensate state slavery by means of brutal
force, rightly see in us their irreconcilable
opponents. History has imposed upon
us a severe struggle. But as long as we
remain devoted servants of truth, justice
and freedom, we shall not only continue
to exist as the oldest of all living peoples,
but we shall also, as hitherto, create,
through productive effort, values which
shall contribute to the ennobling of
mankind."
LAND FOR DEFENSE
By HARRY LEVIN
The importance of land — settled
and cultivated land — as a part of de-
fense, cannot be too strongly em-
phasized in Jewish Palestine. If, for
example, tlxre were a network of
settlements between Jerusalem and
Tel Aviv, instead of the bare half-
dozen now existing, the danger of
cutting communications between
Jerusalem and the coastal area would
be far less threatening.
DURING the 1936-39 riots, when
Arab-produced food was difficult to
get, Jews intensified their own produc-
tion. The World War speeded up this
process. In Palestine, Jewish farmers also
fought Hitler with the plow. In 1936,
only 25% of the food consumed by the
Jewish population was produced in Jew-
ish settlements Today this percentage
has risen to 43. The rise is due to in-
creased areas of land settled by the Jews,
and to modern farming methods.
Palestine had 172 Jewish farming set-
tlements covering 2,000,000 acres in
1936. Nineteen percent of the Jewish
population at that time were farmers.
Today there are 305 settlements cultivat-
ing 3,200,000 acres. The percentage of
farmers has declined to 12.2 — yet there
is more food produced, due to improved
and intensified cultivation. The Yishuv
still has a long way to go to reach reason-
able self-sufficiency in food from its own
sources, but there has been progress along
that road.
Today, with each new attack on Jewish
communications or settlements, the stra-
tegic role of land in defense becomes
clearer. Ten years ago, Tirat Zvi, the
only settlement in Southern Beisan, was
attacked. Some 40 Arabs broke through
the guard and reached the gates. The
attack was repulsed, but only by a nar-
row margin.
Consider what happened in the latest
attack on Tirat Zvi in February. Five
to six hundred Arabs, many of them
Syrian regular soldiers with experienced
officers, assaulted the settlement. They
were thrown back long before they came
anywhere near the gates. In a sharp
counter-attack, the Haganah killed 57 of
the enemy and wounded many more than
this number.
Has Tirat Zvi become so much stronger
in these ten years? Not at all. But in
[Continued on page 27]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
3
EIGHT weeks before pesach, even
while there was still frost in the
air, my grandfather would start
talking about pesach. He didn't say very
much. He would stand in the kitchen
doorway, stroking his graying beard and
say, "What's going to be done about
pesach?" And then, he'd nod his head
once or twice and bemoan my brother
Ezra who refused to wear a yarmilka.
That was all he did. My grandmother
was the one who worked. No matter
what she said to him, or how, he would
do only certain things in the house. And
there was no changing him.
He wouldn't even go out shopping
with us for new dresses. That was the
first thing we did for pesach, shop for
new dresses. There were six of us. We
wore blue serge, and navy-blue kashmir,
and changeable silk, depending upon
whether we were of marriageable age.
We carried them home in heavy boxes
from the East Side, downtown, and hung
them away in the closet, not to be
touched, until pesach. The next time we
went shopping it was for shoes, high but-
ton shoes, patent leather, sometimes, with
a squeak. The shoes were always a little
too tight for us when we got them home.
I never knew why they always fitted so
well in the store, and then, at home, they
were tight, and the bigger girls had to
break them in for us younger ones.
After we had our spring outfits, we
started working on the house, one room
at a time. My grandfather used to su-
perintend the job in his own quiet way.
He'd stand around, stroking his beard,
watching me and my sisters and my
mother climb on the walls, scour the
corners, clean windows and put up
freshly washed and starched curtains, and
he would shake his head and threaten us
with punishment if we dared bring chom-
etz into that room after we had cleaned
it. In his own way he gave our work
glamor and point Ah, pesach! It didn't
matter to him that our hands were worn
because we worked so hard. Little by
little the house was closed up, and we
were cramped in our quarters, rushed,
got on each other's nerves, and yet ter-
ribly happy, anticipating pesach.
One room became the storehouse.
Usually it was the front parlor. The
closer it got to the holiday, the more
cluttered it became. There were the
When the Pre-Pesach Days Caused A Happy Revolution
in the Home — That Is the Way It Used to Be
THE WAY IT USED TO BE
fresh matzohs. My grandfather used to
take my grandmother and go down to
Meyer London's factory, on the East
Side, and wait outside, while they baked
the matzohs, then carry the boxes home
and put it in the front parlor. Pesach
was such a welcome guest! Near the
matzohs was the big earthenware jug of
pesachdike fat. Milk and butter were
not pesachdik in those days, and every-
thing we ate was made with fat. My
grandmother used to get the fattest
chickens she could buy for months be-
fore pesach, and kosher them in the front
parlor, in the big white pesachdike veg-
shaft, and sprinkle them with coarse salt,
then save the fat to render in a pesach-
dike pot. We languished on shmaltz
chickens for weeks, until we hated the
sight of fowl.
•
The grocer brought up a case of eggs,
twenty dozen, which we usually finished
down to the last one in eight days.
Everything had to be made with eggs:
chremsels, lotkes, matzohbrei, farfel —
you knew there were eggs in them, and
they tasted so geshmak!
A week before pesach we started on
the pantry shelves. My grandmother had
to do the work herself. First the wood
had to be scoured with hot water and a
stiff brush. Then a kettle of hot water
was poured over it. We had a heavy,
old, flatiron, and it had to be heated over
a low flame on the gas range, the handle
covered with three heavy flannel layers
to protect your hand from the heat. My
grandmother used to rub the boards with
it until they were dry. What if it took
all of one precious morning? What was
there to compare with a kosher pesach?
By that time the front parlor was so
full we had to put some things on the
pantry shelf: a five-pound box of
matzohs, in the lovely yellow paper, the
matzoh meal, which we used for making
those lovely light sponge cakes. (And
without the help of electric mixers!)
Sugar was kosher for passover only in
By BERDIE BECK
the solid, blue-paper packaged horn, and
we used to have to hew chunks out of
it with knife and fork. Delicious! the
yellows, and the blues, and the clean
sweetness of the pantry shelves! Oh
pesach!
My grandmother used to grind her own
pepper, and her own ginger and her own
cinnamon, and she was fragrant with the
spices, and sweet to kiss and so good to
us little girls. She made candy out of
carrots for us, spiced with ginger, and
candy out of beets, cut in strings, and
covered with cinnamon. There was
sugared orange peel, and grapefruit peel,
hard to chew and tart on the tongue.
In the living room there now stood a
barrel of borsht, fermenting for weeks,
giving the parlor a slightly sour aroma.
Everywhere we went in the house we
smelled pesach. But the most fun we had
was with the fish in the bathtub. It was
usually a live karp, and the water was
always running, cold, like a song, with
the overflow making echoes in the hollow
pipe of the drain. We used to sit on our
knees for hours, watching that fish, won-
dering how we were ever going to eat it.
My grandmother had to keep the fish
alive to have it fresh for the seder. There
were no refrigerators then, and the ice
box couldn't become pesachdik until the
last minute. The front parlor was cold,
but not cold enough for fish.
When we scoured out the bottom
shelves of the pantry for the dishes, we
used to sing. Those dishes! Maybe they
weren't china. They were blue and white,
and each one was counted. Each one of
us had our own glass cup for wine. Mine
was rough outside and it had a little glass
handle. I had it for twenty-five years.
We stayed home from school to polish
the flatwear, with sand. My grandfather
would spread a clean white paper on the
big kitchen table and sit us down before
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
it, making first sure that we had no
chometz about us, and set us to the job
of polishing.
At last, it was the day before pesach.
My grandfather had his candle and his
feather and his wooden spoon, and after
putting pieces of bread, carefully, one in
each room, he would lead us around, mak-
ing a complete tour of the house we had
already cleaned and made pesachdik, col-
lecting the pieces of bread, with a prayer.
Always, everything my grandfather did,
was with a prayer. When he tasted food,
when he looked at us in sickness, when
he came into the house after the Sab-
bath, or when he went to sleep— always,
with a prayer. His voice echoed through
the house, just as my grandmother's love
embraced us, wherever we stood.
But the day of the seder! Like the
day of a wedding! The chometz was
out of the house immediately after our
early breakfast. Charosis to make! My
grandfather wore a clean white apron
over his pants. His vest was open, and
he had no tie under his beard. He made
the charosis. I peeled the apples, and as
he prepared the charosis I ate it, surrep-
titiously, thinking he didn't see me. There
is nothing so delicious in the world as
pesachdike charosis. Even the bitter
herbs were not bitter. My grandfather
broiled the egg and the chicken's neck
himself. There were some things he
didn't trust my grandmother to make.
With the kitchen scoured, and the stove
clean and covered, pesach came out into
the kitchen, openly. And all the prep-
aration for the eight weeks was nothing
compared to the work of getting ready
for the seder.
•
We were six, counting my brother
Ezra, who refused to wear a hat in the
house. My aunts would come, with
their babies; they would be alike to me,
laid out on the beds, with chairs, to keep
them from rolling off. All my aunts
seemed to have babies around pesachtime.
Sometimes the children used to cry in
the bedroom. If one cried, they all cried,
and when they got tired, they all seemed
to get tired and keep still at once.
Sometimes a few of my aunts used to
help us set the table. Ah, those beauti-
ful Passover blue and white dishes on that
white tablecloth! Why is a pesachdik
knadle so delicious in a blue and white
pesachdik soup plate?
We always had one or two hungry
strangers for guests, men usually, who
were very careful of what they said, and
spoke only the thick, gutteral Yiddish
of greenhorns. And when they got up
from the table to wash their hands they
said to one another, "This isn't America
at all. This is like our home. I thought
that in America pesach would be dif-
ferent."
•
My grandfather used to watch us all
out of the corner of his eyes. He had
an old haggadah, and he used to read
from it, but I'm sure he knew it all by
heart. He knew, too, when we skipped
anything. We were afraid to arouse his
anger. He looked so kingly in his white
yarmilke, and his white robe — kittle, he
called it — with his beard combed and his
finger nails clean. He sat high above
us, on two chairs, with two pillows under
him, making every effort to lean on them,
as the good rule says, but finding it hard,
because he was a stern man, accustomed
to holding himself upright. On his right
was his oldest son, and on down the long
table, where the rest of us sat, according
to our ages. My grandmother was at the
foot of the table, near the kitchen door,
looking very gay in her pesachdik dress
when she remembered to look gay. Some
of us could see how tired she was. Maybe
it was because he saw her weariness that
my brother Ezra consented to wear a hat
at the seder. If she could almost kill
herself for pesach, he could wear a hat.
Most of us fell asleep after supper.
But my grandfather used to wake us up
in time to sing Hagadyah. "Louder!"
he would urge us, his deep baritone start-
ling us into wakefulness. Everyone in
the neghborhood knew it was pesach in
our house because they heard us. If we
couldn't see the words with our sleep-
filled eyes, we shouted the melody, and
felt happy all over.
When the seder was over my aunts
usually ran home with their babies. We
were left to wash the dishes and put them
away. Only one more seder left, we
thought, with regret — and with thank-
fulness.
The second seder found us all together
again. Only the sparkle was gone. The
tablecloth was soiled with wine and salt
water. The Hagadah went more
quickly. We were not so sleepy; we sang
all the words of the songs and wondered
what they meant, intending to ask, and
then forgetting, when all the babies
started crying at once.
The rest of pesach was like a game;
we wore our dresses that had grown too
tight on us, and our new shoes that
squeaked, and we played games with fil-
berts and ate nothing without chicken
fat , with matzohs, and without, and
loved it.
Reluctantly, we put away the dishes.
My grandmother did it herself. She used
to say aloud, "The hands that put these
away should take them down again next
year."
And my grandfather, in the kitchen
doorway, his hand to his beard, would
say, "Amen!"
Rabbis Explore the
Agunah Problem
IEWISH marriage laws, as they exist
J today, are fluid enough to prevent un-
due hardship on the part of the Agunah,
according to Rabbi Louis Epstein, one of
America's leading authorities on Jewish
law. An Agunah is a Jewish woman
whose husband has disappeared, but whose
death cannot be absolutely verified.
Rabbi Epstein made this statement at
a recent conference on Jewish law held
at the Jewish Theological Seminary under
the sponsorship of the Rabbinical Assem-
bly of America, and attended by rabbis
from every part of the country.
"Those who wish to modify the mar-
riage law by new and radical legislation,"
Rabbi Epstein said, "must recognize that
legislation requires authority, which we
have not and which no other existing
body of rabbis can now claim. Without
authority one can defy the law but
cannot change it. The woman who
marries a second husband without a
get (divorce) from her first husband
does not change the law; the rabbi or
group of rabbis who sanction it, with as
little authority as the woman has, are
equally violators of the law, not legis-
lators.
"One has the right, however, to hope
that out of the flux of our time a new
Jewish state may be born and that a new
supreme judicial body may come into
being. Such a body may dedicate itself
to the task of making our holy laws op-
erative normally in the life of a normal
people."
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
A Short Story of A Passover Today — and
An Old Man Who Remembered
SALUTATIONS
SEDER over Grandpa's was always
an occasion for us. Through the
years we remembered it as the
grand event of the year — with Grandpa
enthroned at the head of the table, chant-
ing the services in his mellifluous voice.
Of late, however, though we had con-
tinued to gather at his house, others —
his son and his grandsons — took a more
active part in the service, and it now
took on more of a social character, for
we freely interspersed conversation with
our prayers. This was something Grandpa
had never allowed, but he was a very old
man now, and we treated him with the
indulgence we adults reserve for the very
young and the very old.
Just now my Uncle Mark was reading.
The Hebrew did not come easily to him,
and he had no expert memory of the
verses, as Grandpa had. Stopping to
catch his breath at the end of a long
passage through which he had stumbled
rather hurriedly, he raised his head and
commented on something he had seen in
the newspaper which seemed apropos to
him.
•
My Uncle Mark remembered two de-
pressions, two wars, and butcheries in
Europe too numerous to retain their dis-
tinctive character in his mind. He was
inclined by nature to be pessimistic.
"You can't deny it," he told us at the
Seder table. "It's all in the cards — we're
headed for the worst depression we've ever
seen. Can't be more than a year off."
I shivered a little, inwardly. I had just
gone back to school after four years in
the army. It would just be my luck to
run into something like a depression.
The others at the table were not listen-
ing to our conversation. "I still think
it's too blustery to bring the baby out,"
said my cousin Joan. "After all, he's
only ten weeks old."
"What's that you say?" asked Grandpa.
He leaned forward in the overstuffed
chair which had been provided for him
at the table, and fixed his eyes upon Joan.
"Nothing — nothing at all. I said you
were looking fine, Grandpa." She raised
her voice. Actually she was his great-
granddaughter only by marriage.
"I didn't have a good winter," said
Grandpa to no one in particular. "Dr.
Shaw said I had a bad case of the flu.
But I told him not to worry. I wasn't
going to die."
He chuckled softly to himself and
nodded his lean white head up and down.
"I told Dr. Shaw I wasn't going to die
until I had my first great-great-grandson
at my table for seder."
He turned to survey the group on
either side of him. His daughter Sarah
was here, and Mark, his only surviving
son; the rest of us were grandsons and
granddaughters and great-children. Four
of his own children were dead, and he
was the last of his generation in the en-
tire community. This pesach he would
be ninety-five, or perhaps, ninety-six. He
didn't know himself. Since my return
from the army I couldn't get over how
shrunken he looked — yet, staring at him
as the others chatted now, I knew he had
not changed much since my first definite
recollection of him. His hair had thinned
a little and grown finer, more silken; his
hearing had faded; his skin a rosier hue,
but he could still read his Yiddish news-
papers and sometimes he played a game
of checkers with my cousins Ben and
Harry.
He was talking about the baby now.
"They say he looks like a Joachim," he
said. "They were my people," he ex-
plained to some of the in-laws, who were
not familiar with the ramifications of his
huge old family. "I am anxious to have
him at the table."
Ben was the baby's father. He got up
and touched Grandpa's shoulder. "He's
sleeping now — you wouldn't want us to
wake him."
"But I haven't seen him yet," fretted
Grandpa.
"Just as soon as he wakes up," prom-
ised Ben, "we'll bring him downstairs to
the table."
"They say he's a handsome baby," said
Grandpa. "If he looks like the Joachims,
he's sure to be a pretty child. What did
you name him?"
"He's forgotten," said Mark to me.
"Ben told him when he came in."
By SYLVAN KARCHMER
"Joseph," said Ben again, talking loud
in Grandpa's ear.
"Joseph — Joseph," repeated Grandpa.
His white head was raised questioningly.
"After whom did you name him?" he
demanded.
We looked at each other and shook
our heads. Poor old Grandpa, we thought.
Joseph was Mark's brother and Grandpa's
youngest son. He had been dead over
twenty-five years. None of us wished
to speak of these things to Grandpa, and
Uncle Mark started talking about the
coming depression. But Grandpa's mind
was on names. "Daniel would have been
a good name," he said. "My oldest
brother," he explained to us. He stopped
and his small eyes peered around the table.
Propped on the overstuffed chair, with the
white pillows to his left, he looked like a
kind of pink mummy — and incredibly
small.
"I wanted to name one of my own sons
after my brother Daniel," he said, "but
then we did not know he was dead. They
took him in the Czar's army and we never
heard about him. He was lost to us."
•
Uncle Mark switched from the coming
depression to anti-Semitism. "It's going
to be the worst yet," he said. "I don't
know how we're going to fight it."
Grandpa, now talking softly to him-
self, said, "Daniel was a beautiful name.
He was my oldest brother. I remember
the time he was Bar Mitzvah. We were
afraid to have too much of a celebration,
because we knew the Czar's soldiers
would come for him if they knew he was
of age for the army." He sat still for
a minute, brooding quietly over the past.
"They did come, too, and we never saw
him again."
Joan said, "He's the nicest baby. I
wish you could have seen how beauti-
fully he behaved when we had his pic-
ture made." She opened her purse.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
II
"Here, Grandpa, here's a picture of
Joseph."
"Joseph," he echoed, his small, round
eyes growing tiny and thoughtful again.
"Joseph, my son," he whispered, a pain-
ful onrush of memories sweeping over
him.
"But aren't you going to look at the
picture, Grandpa?" I asked.
"No," he replied. "I don't want to
see any pictures. I want the baby here.
I told Dr. Shaw I wasn't going to die.
I said I've lived this long — through all
the bad times and all the bad things
they've done to us — I said I'm going to
live a few more years. That's what I
told Dr. Shaw. I said I must have the
infant at my table on Passover."
He sighed and his voice grew hardy.
"To have him at our table will be a good
sign. It means we will go on. I was
sixteen when I told my parents goodbye —
it was a cold night, and I hid under the
straw in the wagon until we came to the
border. They wept, the old folks, my
parents — peace be unto them — but I was
too excited to understand . . . for I was
coming to America."
"Yep," said Uncle Mark. "Good thing
for all of us he came over. Where would
we be if he had stayed over there!"
Now Grandpa's thoughts were roaming
the past again. "One day my boy Joseph
came to me. He was in a uniform — he
said he was going to the old country —
he was going to fight in a war"
"Grandpa, that was the other war,"
said Ben. "The one in which Uncle
Joseph was killed."
Grandpa hesitated for a minute, his fin-
gers trembling a little as they touched
the wine glass on the white cloth before
him. I wondered if he had forgotten this
was pesach eve. Then his frail shoulders
shrugged. "They were all the same, the
wars," he said. "Alwavs bloodshed and
pogroms . . . Who was killed in the war
we just had? I had four grandsons to
go. In the shule on the flag there are
four stars. Always I look at the flag
when I go into the shule."
"Don't you remember I went," said
Ben. "I came here that dav when you
were sitting on the porch in the sun-
shine."
"Yes," said Grandpa, "I remember all
of vou who went."
"I hear him," cried Joan, jumping up
from the table. "I think the baby's get-
ting up."
In a few minutes she and the nurse
came back downstairs. The nurse was
carrying the baby on a blue silk coverlet,
and the baby's head rested on a white
lacy pillow.
"Let me hold him," said Grandpa, and
his voice quivered. "Let me hold him
on my knee."
"Oh, Ben," exclaimed Joan. "I was
afraid he'd want to."
•
Grandpa had risen from his chair, and
he could not stop the violent shaking of
his hands. Ben leaned over. "Why don't
you let the nurse put him on the pillows
right next to you?"
The baby started to whimper. "There,
there, precious," soothed Joan.
Grandpa said, "Let me take him, the
little man. Why can't I hold him." His
voice sounded hurt.
"He's got it in his head. We'll have to
let him now." Ben moved closer to the
baby.
"Watch him," cautioned Uncle Mark.
"He may drop the baby." He had been
talking about Palestine to me. "First
they give it to us — then they take it
away." He shook his head dolefully.
"There will always be trouble over there."
Grandpa pushed his chair back from
the table. It had been a long time since
he had held an infant in his arms. We
could see he was making an effort to
keep his hands from shaking, but it
wasn't any use. "He looks like my sec-
ond son Aaron," he. declared. "He's
smiling, too. He's not afraid for me to
hold him."
"Grandpa, don't you want Joan to take
him now?"
"No," replied Grandpa. "He is of
hardy stock. My grandfather lived to be
eighty-five. We do not die so easilv."
We all were silent watching him hold
the baby, except Uncle Mark, who was
still voicing his fears about Palestine.
"A hardy stock," repeated Grandpa,
rocking the infant on his knee. "He
lived to be eightv-five, and his father
once journeyed to Vilna to ask the Gaon
a question. Yes, he talked to the Rabbi
Elijah. He was a great rabbi, the Vilna
Gaon. He was like a saint. It strength-
ened one to talk with him."
And then he was quiet again, ignoring
our presence, as he picked up the
Hagadah. What was he thinking, I won-
dered, listening with half an ear to Uncle
Mark. My cousins and I had been
through a war . . . but it seemed it was
not completely behind us. In Palestine
there was a war on this very seder night;
in London our shop windows had been
broken, our synagogues defiled; and in
America . . . Suppose Uncle Mark was
right — suppose all that we had seen, all
that we had been through in the war,
still loomed ahead of us. Outside I heard
the blustery March wind, whipping at
the corners of Grandpa's old house.
The baby whimpered again; Joan made
an attempt to take him, but Grandpa
rocked him gently on his feeble, shrunken
knee.
"Now," said Grandpa, and a smile
played around the corners of his wrinkled,
aged mouth, and he passed the infant
back to Ben. "You must tell him this
— someday, when he can understand. Tell
him that he sat at his great-grandfather's
seder table."
He raised his head and peered at us
around the circle. "Tell him too that
one of his ancestors talked with the Vilna
Gaon."
Then he sat back, as if the speech had
exhausted him. "He should know that,"
he added. "In our family that is some-
thing we must not forget."
But why? I wondered to myself, out
of a century of memories . . . He had
seen the armies of Nicholas I conscript
his brother; he remembered the May
Laws, and the slaughter in Nazi Gcrmanv.
Out of a lifetime lived amid tears and
ever-multiplying anxieties . . . What a
strange thing to remember!
•
I raised mv head and looked at Grand-
pa. His old eves, tired with seeing the
woes of a centurv, were still bright. He
was smiling in the direction of Uncle
Mark, who for once remained verv quiet.
"We have much to sav," said Grandpa.
"We should not be wasting our time.
Come, bovs." he continued, and nicking
up the Hapadih in his trembling fingers,
he found the place, and without waiting
for the rest of us to catch up with him,
he commenced nimblv to chant — and all
the while, his alert old eves were smiling,
smiling — first at Uncle Mark and then at
Ben . . . and me . . . and the infant . . .
as if they held a rare and precious
secret.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
NEW BOOKS
Reviewed by DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
TalmuJic Encyclopedia, Vol. 1, Jerusalem.
American Agency, Block PublisJxng Co.
THE first volume of this gigantic en-
terprise, the publication of an ency-
clopedia of all the laws and doctrines
in the Talmud, which has recently ap-
peared, is the best evidence of the creative
genius of Palestine Jewry and shows how
great is the zeal for Jewish learning in
that new and vibrant Jewish community
in Eretz Yisroel.
It is a work that was greatly needed.
Every concept of law, every decision, is
here not only recorded but discussed in
all its development and ramifications. It
is the work of a group of great scholars,
and shows how painstaking they were in
their efforts to make this encyclopedia
worthy of the best traditions in Jewish
scholarship. The work when completed
will consist of twelve or thirteen volumes,
and the forthcoming books are to appear
at regular intervals. The head of this
venture and the chief editor is Rabbi Meir
Berlin, the world leader of the Mizrachi
Zionist Organization, and the first vol-
ume is a magnificent tribute to his
scholarship, organizing ability, and ven-
turesome spirit.
To fully appreciate the cultural status
of the Palestinian Yishuv, it is interest-
ing to learn that even in these dark days
of struggle, more than 2 500 copies of
this encyclopedia were sold there within
a few months after its publication.
Let us hope that American Jewry will
strive to match this record in supporting
a work that will do much to reveal the
incalculable treasures that have been the
heritage of Israel from time immemorial.
Toldot Ha-Poskim — History of Jewish
Codes, 3 volumes, by Prof. Chaim Tcker-
nowitz (Rav Tzair). Published by Ju-
bilee Committee, New York.
This monumental work by one of the
foremost Rabbinic scholars of our day,
Prof. Tchernowitz, will add further
laurels to those he has already gained.
The English title of the work does not
do it full justice. It is more than a his-
tory of the authoritative codes of Jew-
ish law; it is a history of Jewish law in
the entire period of its codification, from
the days of the early Geonim until the
Shulchan Aruch and its commentators.
The author gives us an analysis of the
principles and the methods that guided
the codifiers in the compilation of Jew-
ish laws and in their decisions of Jewish
law. The reader is referred to the spe-
cial article in tribute to this great teacher,
written by Rabbi Jacob Minkin, which
will appear in a forthcoming issue of the
Center Review, for a more detailed review
and appreciation of this great work. It
is a tribute to the scholarship and to the
fascinating style of this aged teacher, who
happily is still called Rav Tzair — the
youthful rabbi.
The work has been published by a spe-
cial Jubilee Committee in token of Amer-
ican Jewry's affection to this scholar on
his seventy-fifth birthday. May he con-
tinue to enrich our Hebrew culture for
many years to come.
The Mishnah O Berakoth, Peah, Demai —
English Translation by Jacob David
Herzog. Block Publishing Co.
This is a work that will be welcomed
by all Jews who wish to become familiar
with part of the rich storehouse of our
Rabbinic literature. The Mishnah repre-
sents the first collection of Rabbinic
teachings, after the Bible. It is the foun-
dation of all the later Rabbinic discus-
sions that comprise the Gemara, and
which, together with the Gemara, make
up the Talmud.
The present volume gives us the He-
brew text of the first three tractates of
the Mishnah, together with an excellent
English translation. In addition to the
usual classic Hebrew commentary of R.
Obadiah of Bertinoro, it has an illuminat-
ing commentary in English by the trans-
lator, Rabbi Jacob David Herzog, who,
by the way, is the son of Palestine's Chief
Rabbi, Dr. Isaac Herzog.
The work is made more valuable in
that it gives to the scholarly student all
the variant readings of the text found
in the different manuscripts, and other
important notes on the text, by the Fel-
lows of the Harry Fischel Talmud Insti-
tute in Jerusalem.
This volume was originally published
in Jerusalem, and is now presented as the
first American edition. It represents the
zeal and devotion to our literary heritage
on the part of the Rabbis in Palestine,
and their fine appreciation of the need
of bringing this classic literature closer
to the English-speaking Jewries of Amer-
ica and Britain.
Intelligent Jews, especially those who
would like to have some understanding
of the teachings of the Talmud, and those
who are interested in the study of juris-
prudence, would do well to secure this
volume, which reveals true scholarship,
fine literary use of the English language,
and which has succeeded in rendering into
a fluent English the intricate expressions
of Jewish law.
Ivri AnohJn (I Am a Hebrew) , by Dan-
iel Persky
This reviewer doubts if there is a Jew
anywhere who is more wholeheartedly de-
voted to the Hebrew language and He-
brew culture than the author of this in-
teresting book, Daniel Persky. He has
already enriched our Hebrew literature
with a number of fascinating volumes and
studies.
The author possesses a unique style. He
can treat a most serious subject — a ques-
tion of philosophy or grammar or ancient
usage — in a most popular manner, so that
the average reader can get the import of
his message. More than that, he pos-
sesses a rich sense of humor, so that each
essay is adorned with a flash that is
humorous and often brilliant.
This volume is unique in yet another
way. It is entirely devoted to problems
dealing with the Hebrew language, litera-
ture and culture. There is hardly a ques-
tion dealing with the revival of Hebrew,
which he does not discuss. The question
of pronunciation — Sephardic or Ashkena-
zic — the question of the proper use of
foreign terminology, the problem of
punctuation, the question of the use of
Aramaic expressions in current Hebrew
— and hundreds of similar problems, are
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
discussed with great insight, learning and
wisdom.
Above all, as one reads these essays,
one cannot help but feel the great love
that burns in the heart of the Hebraist
for our old-new language. The quota-
tion, which the author has inscribed on
the title page, taken from the great poet,
Jeudah Leib Gordon, is most certainly ap-
plicable to him and reveals him in truest
color — Eved Lo'Ivrit Onochi Ad Netzach,
"I am a servant of Hebrew for all time."
This is a volume that will give instruc-
tion and delight to the reader, and will
be welcomed by all who treasure the
Hebrew word.
I grot So f rim Ivrim (Letters of Hebrew
Writers), edited by Dr. Max Raisin.
Published by Israel Matz.
Some time ago, Mr. Israel Matz, the
great Maecenas of Hebrew literature, ac-
quired a treasury of letters written by
many of the writers of the Haskalah
period — of two and three generations ago.
Most of them are addressed to the Hebrew
publisher, Abraham Zuckerman, of War-
saw. These, together with many letters
addressed to Mr. Matz himself by many
of the leading Hebrew writers of our gen-
eration, have been collected and edited in
this volume by Dr. Max Raisin, the well-
known Rabbi and Hebrew writer.
The editor has also incorporated many
letters which he received from some of
the outstanding figures in Hebrew litera-
ture.
The letters reveal a close picture of
their authors' innermost self, their every-
day problems and how they faced them.
The style, of course, differs with the per-
sonality of the writer. Some write in the
flowery style of the classic era, some in
very simple and direct manner, others
with hints and allusions to Biblical and
Rabbinic quotations. Most of them deal
with money problems, and the financial
difficulties endured by many of these
writers. Some deal with personal mat-
ters, such as one would write to an inti-
mate friend without suspecting that they
would ever be read by others. One writer
asks that the addressee should give him a
true report about a young woman, whose
name has been suggested to him for mar-
riage and who dwelt in his town. "Tell
me the truth," he writes. "Is she pretty
or ugly, for I could not endure life with
a woman who was ugly, and I hear
rumors that frighten me." It is intimate
touches like these that add a special in-
terest to the volume. Most of the letters
received by Mr. Matz show the great debt
that the writers owed to this prince of
Hebrew culture, who, for more than a
generation supported Hebrew writers
with an open heart and hand, and enabled
them to publish their writings.
The volume is lovingly dedicated to
the beloved son of Mr. and Mrs. Matz —
Sidney Matz — who met a tragic death
more than a year ago.
Toldot Hachinnch B'Yisroel B'Dorot Ho-
Achronim (History of Jewish Education
in Modern Times), Vol. 11, by Prof. Zeii
Scharf stein. Ogett Publishing Co.
This is the second volume of a most
important work undertaken by one of the
eminent authorities in the field of Hebrew
education of our day, Prof. Scharfstein.
This reviewer has already had the oppor-
tunity to appraise the value of the work
when the first volume appeared several
years ago, and he can now but add to the
praises sung before. The second volume,
which deals with the history of Jewish
education in the Mediterranean countries
(outside of Palestine), England and the
United States, reveals the same careful
and diligent research which marked the
first volume. Every phase of Jewish edu-
cation is described, every effort is inter-
preted, the progress and failure of every
venture is recounted.
Despite the specialized subject and its
ONE of the young dreamers who
was inspired with the ideal of
Jewish Nationalism and of a re-
vival of Hebrew as a national language,
was Eliezer Ben Yehudah, who died
twenty-five years ago.
A man of energy and action, Ben
Yehudah went to Paris and entered a
medical school with the ultimate purpose
of settling in Palestine.
It was during his residence there that
he made his entry into the field of He-
brew literature with an article, "An Im-
portant Question," in which he advocated
the return to Palestine as the only solu-
scholarly treatment, the volume makes
interesting reading. Certainly those who
want to be familiar with the problems of
Jewish education must make this study
required reading.
Yotzre Safrut Hayelodim Shelonu — He-
brew Writers for Children — by Zevi
Scharfstein. Shilo Publislnng Co.
This little volume is a fascinating
resume of the rich Hebrew literature for
children which has appeared in the last
two or three generations. Prof. Scharf-
stein, in the opening sentence of his chap-
ter on Bialik, gives the theme of the
entire work: One of the principal foun-
dation stones on which every national cul-
ture is built is the poetry for children."
And in each chapter he shows the rich-
ness of our Hebrew culture in this field.
It is interesting to find that the authors,
whose names have won fame for their
great writings both in poetry and prose,
have also given of their genius in special
writings for children. This volume will
be welcomed by all Hebrew educators,
and by all parents who want to enrich
the lives of the children with the beauties
of Hebrew story and song — the creations
of the great masters of the Hebrew word.
A review and discussion by Rabbi Lev-
inthal of Rabbi Jacob Levinson's recently
published volume of Responsa, "A Word
in Due Season," under the title of "Jew-
ish Laws and the Problem of Jewish
Law" will appear in an early issue of the
Center Review.
tion of the Jewish problem. He main-
tained that the Jews could foster their
national spirit and the Hebrew language
only in their own land.
In a second article, he asserted that
Jews were unfit for national life because
they didn't speak a common language.
"And have we not such a language," he
wrote, "in which we can write whatever
we have in mind, and which we can
speak if only we will it?" He believed
that the Jewish people could make this
dream a reality. Unfortunately illness
interrupted his activities for a while, but
[Continued on page 25]
PIONEER OF MODERN HEBREW
By LEO SHPALL
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
CENTER CELEBRATES RABBI LEVINTHAL'S 60th BIRTHDAY
A Report on the Happy Events and Publication of the Addresses
ONE of the finest celebrations of
the long line of such events the
Brooklyn Jewish Center has
known took place on April 6 and 7. On
the two evenings of these dates the Cen-
ter celebrated the 60th birthday of its
rabbi, Dr. Israel H. Levinthal. Dr. Lev-
inthal reached the age of 60 on February
12, but because so many of the Center
members were winter vacationing the
birthday party was postponed.
The Anniversary Committee, headed
by Dr. Moses Spatt, arranged a reception
for the entire membership on Tuesday
evening, April 7, and a testimonial din-
ner by members of the Board of Trustees
and Governing Board on the following
evening.
The warmth and high regard that these
events brought out was inspiring to all
who took part in them — and those in-
cluded the majority of the Center mem-
bership. It is not often that a rabbi of
a synagogue can develop in his congrega-
tion such affection and admiration, and
equally rare that a congregation can
arouse in a rabbi such devotion as Dr.
Levinthal has shown to the Center. The
association of the minister and in his con-
gregation has been truly a marriage of
service on the highest levels.
A capacity audience of members filled
the synagogue on Tuesday evening. Fol-
lowing the singing of "The Star Spangled
Banner," and "Hatikvah," Rabbi Manuel
Saltzman delivered the invocation and
read greetings from the father of the
guest of honor, Rabbi Bernard L. Levin-
thal, of Philadelphia, who was unable to
be present because of illness. The Eng-
lish translation of this moving tribute by
the dean of the American rabbinate is
printed elsewhere in the Review.
The Chairman, Dr. Moses Spatt, deliv-
ered a brief address of welcome during
which he said:
"Our Sages tell us that a man's teacher
of Torah stands to him in the place of
a parent, and, as his spiritual father, the
teacher is entitled to the honor and rev-
erence due to his actual father. It is in
this spirit that we, members of this great
Center family, meet this evening, to give
honor and reverence to our spiritual
father, Dr. Israel H. Levinthal. Provi-
dence has been good to our institution in
that we have been blessed with his lead-
ership from the very inception of the
Center, almost thirty years ago. But his
influence has been felt not only in our
own community but throughout the
country."
JUDGE GREENBERG'S ADDRESS
Dr. Spatt then introduced the first
speaker, Judge Emanuel Greenberg, Pres-
ident of the Center. Judge Greenberg's
address follows:
"It is a fine privilege to pay tribute to
our beloved Rabbi on this 60th birthday
anniversary. It is a great personal privi-
A FATHER'S BLESSING
The revered father of our spirit-
ual leader, Rabbi B. L. Levinthal,
of Philadelphia, was unable to be
with us at the memorable celebra-
tion of our rabbi's sixtieth birthday
because of illness. From his sick
bed, he sent the following beautiful
prayer, which was read to the con-
gregation by Rabbi Saltzman:
"R NI bechori Yisroel asn er becho
Oespoer, l'yom holadt'cho ha
Shishim Bamo avorechecho?
"Avorechecho bozeh, b'shishim
ho'osios asher b'virkas kohanim.
Sholom lecho, Sholom bra'ayoscho
ho ahuvo ho'omedes liymincho.
Sholom lakehilo, kehilas hakodesh,
shehincho mechahen pe'er bekirboh
zeh rabos beshonim.
"Yehi rotzon shelo sibotel
b'shishim, u'sihiyeh keAvrohom
Ovinu, asher b'hiyoso ben shishim
hischil lidrosh borabim b'achdus
Eloah.
"Zos hi birkas ovicho, ohavcho
umokircho."
"Israel, my beloved son, in whom
I take great pride with what shall
I bless you on this your sixtieth
birthday?
"I will bless you with the sixty
letters which according to our
Rabbis comprise the priestly bless-
ing — May God bless you and keep
you. May He cause His coun-
tenance to shine upon you and be
gracious unto you. May God lift
His countenance towards you and
grant you His blessing of peace.
Peace unto you, Peace unto your
dear and beloved wife who stands
at your side. Peace unto the holy
congregation which you have
served with such glory for so many
years.
"May it be the will of God that
your physical strength and spiritual
power will not be lost at sixty.
May you be like Abraham, our
Father, of whom we are told that
at the age of sixty he began to
preach and teach the principles of
the true God.
"This is the blessing of your
father, who loves you and to whom
you are so dear."
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
15
lege as well, because Dr. Levinthal and I
have been friends for many years, from
the time he joined me in wedlock with
my charming wife almost thirty-two
years ago. Since then, he has taken part
in our family celebrations and joys, as he
has, no doubt, shared your happy events.
He has been taken into and been made
a part of our family life. We have
learned to admire, cherish and love him
dearly. And so, it is with much per-
sonal pleasure that I publicly attest to
the love we all have for our Rabbi.
"Tonight, however, we pay tribute to
him not only as an individual but as
one who has been truly an exemplar of
his noble calling, the rabbinate.
"There are some men in the ministry
who are distinguished because of their
learning. Others are fine authors and
writers. Some are great preachers and
accomplishment. I do not refer to the
physical structure of an institution, but
rather to the life that goes on in it, and
to all that it symbolizes.
"Dr. Levinthal has, over the years, been
actively identified with many very im-
portant communal matters. He has been
at the head of many movements of na-
tional and even international significance.
He is a real living force, such as few
men have been in American-Jewish life.
"To our Brooklyn Jewish Center, since
its very inception, he has given of him-
self unstintingly and most unselfishly.
At a great sacrifice to himself and to his
family, he has devoted most of his time
and attention to our growth and to our
well-being. We have received much from
our Rabbi. His rare wisdom, his sound
advice, his benign influence have greatly
Dr. Levinthal
at the member-
ship reception.
Left to right —
Dr. Moses Spatt,
Kabbi Levinthal,
Judge Emaniwl
Greenberg.
orators, and others are notable leaders and
organizers. Our Rabbi is the embodi-
ment of them all.
"As to his learning and scholarly at-
tainments, that has been highly appraised
by those most qualified to do so. He
has made his mark as an author and
writer. As a preacher and orator, we
of the Brooklyn Jewish Center, and nu-
merous others who have been privileged
to hear him, can testify to his great tal-
ents. And as to his leadership, just look
about and you can see evidence of his
contributed to our progress. Much that
we have accomplished was the result of
his labor. And, so, today, as has been
publicly and often acknowledged by
leaders in all walks of life, local and na-
tional, Jewish and non-Jewish, our Cen-
ter stands foremost among religious in-
stitutions in the country. Its standing
of pre-eminence is a personal triumph
for our spiritual leader. The Center is
Dr. LevinthaPs monument of accomplish-
ment. And, we, its membership, reflect
in his glory.
"We are deeply indebted to our Rabbi
for all of that. The true value of that
indebtedness can hardly be estimated. It
is my profound pleasure to not only pub-
licly acclaim our Rabbi for all that he
has accomplished, but also to acknowl-
edge our debt of gratitude, which no
words of mine can adequately evaluate
or describe.
"The officers, Trustees and Governing
Board members, the officers of the Sister-
hood and all of our members extend to
you, Dr. Levinthal, our deepest and sin-
cerest thanks for having served us so
well. We all wish for you and for your
dear wife and family and your revered
father good health and happiness for
many, many years, so that you may con-
tinue to be the forceful and benevolent
influence in the life of our congregation,
our community, our people, and our
country."
At this point in the reception, Cantor
William Sauler, of the Center, sang sev-
eral solos which were greatly enjoyed by
the audience. Then came the heartfelt
tribute of Rabbi Levinthal's brother,
Judge Louis Levinthal of Philadelphia
for the Levinthal family and also on be-
half of the Zionists. An extract from
speech is published in this issue.
The guest artist, Sidor Belarsky, then
sang a number of Jewish folksongs in his
inimitable style and was enthusiastically
applauded.
The greetings of the Jewish Theological
Seminary, the Alma Mater of Dr. Levin-
thal, and of the American rabbinate,
were presented by Prof. Louis Finkelstein.
Extracts from his address, too, are pub-
lished in the Review.
A surprise feature of the evening was
the unexpected appearance of Rubin
Tucker, former cantor of the Center and
now a leading tenor of the Metropolitan
Opera House. He sang but one cantorial
number, and so magnificently that he re-
ceived an ovation.
The entire audience rose to its feet
when the chairman presented the honored
guest, Dr. Levinthal, and gave him an
affectionate and rousing welcome. The
rabbi was greatly moved by this recep-
tion, the stirring climax of many years
of ardent labor. He delivered one of his
masterful addresses, one that the member-
ship will long remember. The text is
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
included in the speeches printed in this
issue of the Review.
A prayer by Rabbi Mordecai H.
Lewittes concluded the reception, after
which the audience left the synagogue
and passed the receiving line, where Dr.
and Mrs. Levinthal stood in a bower of
plants and flowers and greeted the
members. The guests were then invited
to the Auditorium and Dining Room for
refreshments.
On Wednesday evening, April 7th, the
members of the Board of Trustees and
Governing Board and their wives assem-
bled for a Testimonial Dinner to Dr. Lev-
inthal. Unlike the celebration on Tues-
day evening, this event was more inti-
mate, and numbered men and women who
have served the institution for many
years.
Dr. Moses Span, the toastmaster, ex-
pressed his thanks to the members of the
Committee on Arrangements, as well as
to the Administrative Director, Mr.
Joseph Goldberg, for their assistance in
planning the entire celebration.
Mr. Samuel Rottenberg, Honorary
President of the Center, recalled the in-
cidents leading to the call extended to
Dr. Levinthal in October 1919 to be-
come the rabbi of the proposed institu-
tion. There were no other names in the
minds of the founders, he said. It was
taken for granted by everyone concerned
that no one but Rabbi Levinthal would
be the spiritual leader of the newly con-
templated Center.
An excerpt from Mr. Rottenberg's re-
marks follow:
"Dr. Levinthal, I believe, is the richest
man in our congregation, which is not
lacking, thanks to God, Almighty, in
wealth. Who of us has been so honored,
or deserving of honor, as Dr. Levinthal?
His life has been dedicated and conse-
crated to serving his people and human-
ity. As I reflect upon my life, I real-
ize that there are two motivations in the
life of man — altruistic service to our
brethren, and the selfish accumulation of
material possessions. Dr. Levinthal's life
serves me as an example of the more
meaningful and significant existence. If
I could relive my life, I would try to live
it in the manner of a Dr. Levinthal.
"It has been said in this congregation
that I laud myself for having been the
one to have proposed Dr. Levinthal as
the spiritual leader of this congregation,
but I must say that I was merely God's
instrument in bringing him to us. No
one chose Dr. Levinthal for this work.
It was taken for granted by all that he
would be our rabbi. He was placed
among us by destiny.
"As a Kohan, in all humility, I would
like to bless our beloved rabbi with a
priestly blessing, wishing him and his
family long life and happiness"
The other former President, Mr. Isidor
Fine, reminisced about the four years of
his administration during which the Cen-
ter had to struggle with problems of fi-
nance resulting in continuous reductions
in employees' salaries to make ends meet.
Whenever he visits the institution, he
continued, he marvels at its great accom-
plishments and achievements, for which
he credits our beloved rabbi. He pic-
tured the rabbi as a beautiful crown
which adds lustre to the Center, and
pleaded that the members should aspire
to become worthy to wear such a crown.
The greetings of the Board of Trustees
were extended by Mr. Max Herzfeld, a
former officer and for many years a mem-
ber of the Board.
Mr. Herzfeld stressed the importance
of harmonious relations between rabbi
and congregation, and reviewed the rea-
sons for the especially happy relationship
that has existed throughout the years of
Dr. Levinthal's ministry in the Center.
Continuing, he said:
"Now I ask myself: What is it that
makes for this harmony and mutual re-
spect? Of course, Dr. Levinthal is a
scholar, learned in Torah and secular
knowledge. But many a scholar has had
difficulty with his congregation. I have
just read a biographical essay on Saadia
Gaon. Saadia was, I believe, the first
systematic Jewish philosopher. At any
rate, the first important Jewish philoso-
pher. He made tremendous contribu-
tions to many fields of Jewish learning.
But, notwithstanding his outstanding
merits as a scholar, he was difficult to get
along with. The exilarch, the civil ruler
of the Jewish community, who had ap-
pointed Saadia Gaon of the Academy of
Sura, removed him and Saadia was com-
pelled to go into hiding.
"I find the reason for the very happy
relations that have always existed between
our rabbi and the Board in an address de-
livered by Dr. Levinthal to the rabbini-
cal graduates of the Seminary. It is the
address that Rabbi Minkin referred to in
his article on Dr. Levinthal in last
month's issue of the Center Review. I
was present and heard this address and I
want to give you two brief quotations
from it. Dr. Levinthal advised the grad-
uates on the prerequisite qualifications for
success in the rabbinate and then admon-
ished them as follows: "The day is gone
when a man can say 'My people must re-
spect me for I bear the title rabbi.' Titles
only will not bring to you your people's
esteem. You will receive it if you earn
it." And, then, as final warning and ad-
vice, Dr. Levinthal said to these young
rabbis: "You must be imbued with a
divine passion to serve. I said serve ad-
visedly. In the words of the Talmud, I,
too, would exhort you: 'Do you think it
is the role of rulership that I give you?
It is service that I bequeath for you.' It
is this divine passion to serve without any
attempt to rule or dominate that has won
Dr. Levinthal the respect, admiration, af-
fection, reverence and esteem, not only of
the Trustees but of the entire congrega-
tion and of all who know him.
Mr. Louis J. Gribetz then spoke on
behalf of the Governing Board as one of
the oldest members of that body.
In his intimate talk he said:
"We have almost exhausted the vocab-
ulary of the language of banquets. We
have had a full setting forth of what
Dr. Levinthal is — his work and his life.
"This night, however, has more mean-
ing than merely an indulgence in the
agreeable task of paying tributes of ad-
miration. Dr. Levinthal has a message
for all of us. He is teaching us how to
meet "old age." At 60 he is serene,
genial, cheerful and possessed of a fresh-
ness and a vigor of youth.
"Of course, Dr. Levinthal has had
much experience in the art of becoming a
'zaken.' According to the Talmud, 'the
zaken is he who has acquired wisdom.'
Because of lack of space the
Review feature, "News of the
Month" had to be omitted.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
From this standpoint, Dr. Levinthal was
a 'zaken' many years ago.
"Our Rabbi has a message for the Rab-
binate. His success in the ministry has
demonstrated that the Jewish people long
for the light, sunshine and healing of our
traditions. For a period of almost 40
years, he has applied to contemporary
current life and problems the wisdom of
our Sages. He has taught us that Jew-
ish literature is an inexhaustible mine of
treasures.
"Dr. Levinthal coincides with two
great wars which brought mental con-
fusion and deep unrest to us. At a time
when the average man was occupied al-
most exclusively with the function of
matter, and when religion appeared to be
a casualty of war, Rabbi Levinthal
showed the healing courage, the beauty
and the bright promise that the Jewish
religion has for us even today."
The Center Sisterhood, through its
President, Mrs. Maurice Bernhardt, pre-
sented the rabbi with a certificate of
two scholarships awarded at the Jewish
Theological Seminary in honor of the
rabbi's birthday. She said:
"We of the Sisterhood have always had
a feeling of friendship and admiration
for our distinguished spiritual leader. In
all the years of the institution's existence,
we relied on the wise counsel and whole-
hearted cooperation of Rabbi Levinthal in
all matters affecting the welfare of the
Sisterhood.
"We are deeply grateful to him for the
many years of service to the community
and to the Center. The members of the
Sisterhood are aware of the great inter-
est Dr. Levinthal has always taken in
promoting Jewish scholarship and have,
therefore, awarded two scholarships at
the Jewish Theological Seminary in
honor of his sixtieth birthday. I am
happy to present the certificate to you,
Rabbi Levinthal, on behalf of the Sister-
hood membership.
"May God bless you with many years
of health and happiness together with
your beloved wife, children and grand-
children."
Mr. David Gold extended the greetings
of the Young Folks League, of which
he is the President. He presented the
rabbi with a certificate of trees planted
by the Young Folks League to celebrate
the occasion, as well as a Jewish National
Fund tree certificate on behalf of the
Eastern Parkway Zionist District No. 14.
The addresses were concluded by brief
remarks by our President, Judge Green-
berg, who, on behalf of the Center, pre-
pABBI Levinthal received several hun-
' * dred messages of congratulations on
his sixtieth birthday from rabbis and
Jewish leaders in all parts of the country.
We regret that lack of space prevents
listing of all of them in the Review. We
have, however, selected a few typical
greetings:
RABBI SOLOMON GOLDMAN, Con-
gregation Anshe Emet, Chicago
• Would I were in condition to pay
the tribute Dr. Levinthal merits. Briefly,
he belongs in the company of the truly
great preachers of our day, comparable
only to the giant Darshanim of Western
Europe. His insight into the Biblical
text and the acumen with which he
selects his thematic verse, his mastery of
Midrash, and skill with which he handles
it, are hardly matched, certainly not ex-
celled, in the pulpit. His published ser-
mons are perfect models of the homileti-
cal tradition, vivid historical apercus,
penetrating studies of the contemporary
world and brilliant essays to boot. But
Dr. Levinthal is more than preacher. He
is the consecrated Rabbi spurning the sen-
sational and flippant, and zealous for the
dignity and sanctity of his calling. He
has guarded Judaism against reckless in-
novation and advocated and accepted
changes that did not distort the essence.
Even more praise-worthy is his modesty.
Kindliness, geniality, a sweet, captivating
smile reveal his whole being. To hear
Dr. Levinthal preach is to admire him,
to know him is to love him. May God
grant him many healthy years. They
are sure to be fruitful and creative.
sented Dr. and Mrs. Levinthal with a
check to enable them to visit Palestine
in the near future.
Dr. Levinthal responded with thanks
to the Committee and to the members
of the Boards.
THE PROTESTANT COUNCIL OF
THE CITY OF NEW YORK, BROOK-
LYN DIVISION— J. Henry Carpenter,
Executive Secretary
• Since you have been in Brooklyn, you
have made a very marked impression on
the people of this community, the people
within your group and all of our citizens.
We are all very thankful in Brooklyn
for having a leader with such deep spirit-
ual insight and such great ability as you
have.
May God give you additional strength
and power as you go on in service to the
people in your synagogue and for the
many other interests of local and national
concern with which you are connected.
EDWARD LAZANSKY
O I salute the distinguished and learned
Rabbi, spiritual leader and forthright
patriotic American citizen. May he be
West with many more years of good
health and sound strength, to be a bless-
ing to countless thousands by his benign
influence. Here is a noble example of an
unselfish life devoted to humankind.
MOSES GINSBERG
• Shma Yisroel, Hear, Oh Israel Levin-
thal, the praises and glowing tributes
which are being paid to you by your
friends from near and far, and take them
into your heart. Mosbe Yedaher, this is
your life-long friend and admirer, Moses
Ginsberg, expressing heartiest good wishes
for your health and happiness on this
sixtieth birthday. Hineh lo yonmn velo
yishon shower Yisroel. You, the watch-
man named Israel, did not slumber nor
sleep these past thirty years, but awak-
ened in the hearts of Brooklyn Jewry, the
largest Jewish community in world his-
tory, the faith of Israel.
TRIBUTES TO DR. LEVINTHAL
Following arc messages of congratulations receii ed too late fo,
publication last month.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
MY BROTHER ISRAEL
Following is the text of the ad-
dress delivered by Judge Levinthal
at the Center membership reception
to Rabbi Lei in thai on April 6.
I SPEAK for all the members of our
family in tendering heart-felt thanks
to you, the friends of my brother, for
all the love you have shown him through-
out the years of his ministry in your
midst, and particularly for this beautiful
tribute on the occasion of his sixtieth
birthday. We Levinthals — all of us ex-
cept the guest of honor himself — are
mighty proud of our Israel. We are
proud of the record he has achieved, a
record not merely as a saintly rabbi, an
eloquent preacher, a learned author, an
inspiring communal leader, a devoted
public servant, but, what is no less im-
portant, his record in the ordinary, day-
by-day relationships of life — as a son, a
brother, a husband, a father, a friend, a
citizen, an American, a Jew, a human
being.
I welcome the opportunity to pay hom-
age this evening to the Brooklyn Jewish
Center whose rabbi Israel has been since
its inception. Anyone who is at all fa-
miliar with American Jewish life is aware
of the fact that this institution is out-
standing, indeed, in a class by itself. In-
dividually and collectively, the members
of this Center have demonstrated an un-
matched loyalty to the Jewish people.
They have consistently and increasingly
distinguished themselves in the field of
Jewish education, in ardent support of
the Zionist movement, and in generous
aid to all worthy American and Jewish
and humanitarian causes.
This well-deserved praise of the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center, of course, redounds
to the honor of its religious leader and
spiritual mentor. As an author is judged
by the books he writes and an artist by
the picture he paints, so a rabbi is to be
judged by the kind of men and women
he produces. Israel is not a preacher who
merely delivers interesting and instructive
sermons. What he says from the pulpit
is intended to achieve results in the hearts
and souls of his listeners, to make them
become different, to induce them to act
differently. Harry Emerson Fosdick re-
cently wrote that "a sermon should be
a convincing appeal to a listening jury
for decision." Every one of Israel's ser-
mons throughout the years has been a
convincing appeal to a listening JEWRY
for decision and for action. That is why
the Brooklyn Jewish Center has a glory
all its own.
Your Rabbi's influence, moreover, has
not been confined to the membership of
this Center, large and important as it is.
Through his speaking tours in all sec-
tions of the country, and through his
books of sermons, this great congregation
has been multiplied many times. I be-
lieve I may say, without being unchar-
itable, that many orthodox, reform and
conservative rabbis constantly resort to
Israel's published writings for their ser-
mons. His vogue may be illustrated by
the remark a rabbinical friend once face-
tiously made to me: "Ask your brother
Israel what he does on Saturdays with-
out Levinthal's volumes to quote."
By applying the teachings of our an-
cient rabbis and sages to the vexing prob-
lems of modern life, Israel has the rare
ability to get things done in the minds
and in the lives of his listeners. As he
put it in his Rosh Hashanah sermon in
1922: "We must stop drifting. We
must begin to steer, to direct, to act pru-
dently, wisely — but above all, to act —
not to drift!" He has himself been ever
"at the helm, like the captain on the
ship, on the lookout as to how good may
best be achieved." And he has succeeded
in inspiring the rank and file of his Con-
gregation to become captains of their own
souls, masters of their destiny.
In this dreadful time through which
our generation is passing, what we need
above all else are the serenity, the cour-
age and the wisdom of our ancestors —
serenity to accept what cannot be
changed, courage to change what can and
ought to be changed, and wisdom to
know the one from the other. Your
Rabbi, steeped as he is in Jewish lore,
may be relied upon to guide us through
these perilous days, patiently, boldly, pru-
dently, in the spirit of the Torah and in
the light of our people's historic experi-
ences.
As a fond brother, I naturally cannot
speak of Israel with "the cold neutrality
of an impartial judge." I venture, how-
By JUDGE LOUIS LEVIN7HAL
ever, to believe that my judgment,
though biased, is correct when I assert
that Israel has been a mighty influence
for good in this community not merely
by his preaching, but even more, by his
practice, by the example of his own life.
A popular rhymster put in verse what
most of us feel:
"I'd rather see a sermon than hear
one any day;
I'd rather one should walk with
me than merely show the way."
Israel has not only told us the way; he
has walked the long, hard road, hand-in-
hand with us, the gentle, ministering
servant, the loving, friendly companion.
He has been, in a literal sense, "a living
sermon illustrating the truth he has
taught." I wonder if we appreciate how
very fortunate we are to have the blessed
privilege of walking with him through
life, basking in the warm glow of his
inspired and inspiring personality.
Out of the depths of my heart I pray
that Israel may continue for many, many
years to come, in good health and in good
spirits, with his beloved wife and chil-
dren at his side, to lead us, to guide us,
to ennoble and to enthuse us, to inspire
faith in God, in ourselves, and in each
other!
Committee in Charge of the
Rabbi Levinthal Celebration
The following served on the
Committee in charge of the six-
tieth birthday celebration of Dr.
Levinthal:
Dr. Moses Spatt, Chairman, Saul
Abelov, Isidor Fine, Louis J. Gri-
betz, Max Herzfeld, Mrs. Isador
Lowenfeld, Frank Schaeffer and
Louis Simon.
Members of the Editorial Board
of the Review
Louis J. Gribetz, Chairman
Joseph Goldberg M. H. Lewittes
Joseph Kaye Manuel Saltzman
I. H. Levinthax, William I. Siegel
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
19
AN INTERPRETER OF HIS
GENERATION
This is the condensed text of the
ail dress delivered by Prof. Finkel-
stein, President of the Jewish Theo-
logical Seminary, at the reception to
Dr. Levinthal on April 6.
DR. LEVINTHAL is the greatest
master that I know of, of the an-
cient rabbinic Mid rash. But he is
not only a master of the words of our
ancient rabbis, he has also followed their
example. The remarkable thing about
him is that he not only teaches by precept
but by example. He is a descendant of
Aaron, and he also fulfills the command-
ment of Hillel, that says: "It is not
enough to be a descendant of Aaron, one
must be mitalmidar shel Aharon — One
must also be a disciple of Aaron." "Ohev
Sholom ve Rodef Shol&m, Ohev es
Habrius Um'korion I'Toroh."
As I was thinking of Dr. Levinthal's
sixtieth birthday, I knew that I would
be in this audience, which is an intimate
one to me because it is here that I grew
up. I remember these streets when they
did not have any houses on them, and I
can remember all of you when you were
much younger. As I was thinking back
over the years, it suddenly dawned upon
me that Dr. Levinthal's role in this com-
munity was an especially profound one.
Perhaps I would hesitate to say what I
am going to say in any other place, but
I feel that I can say it here, because I
am sure that my experience must be the
experience of many other people.
Many of you knew my father, olov
hasholotn, and knew what a fine scholar
he was, and how genial a man he was.
Well, he grew up in Slabodka and he
was a Taltnid Chochom. He knew many
things that I did not know when I was
young, and I still do not know. But
when I went to high school, I found that
I knew a great many things that my
father did not know. My brothers and
sisters spoke Yiddish to our parents, but
among ourselves we spoke in English.
And I always thought, in the back of
my mind, that when I grew up my re-
lationship to my children would be closer
than my father's could possibly be to me.
My father and I were good friends but
I thought that my children would be
closer to me because they would be going
to the very schools to which I went, re-
ceive the very education that I have; and
when they would have some difficulty
with their homework, I would be able
to help them.
Well, I know my children would not
mind my saying that it has not worked
out that way. There is a chasm between
us and our children much greater than
existed between our fathers and us. My
father and mother talked Yiddish and I
talked English, but we never needed an
interpreter when we talked to each other.
We managed to understand our parents
very well. But the world has moved so
rapidly in these years that almost every-
one of us needs an interpreter when we
talk to our children. We talk their lan-
guage, but they do not know what we
are talking about, and I suspect that we
do not know what they are talking about.
Well, among the people who are try-
ing to interpret, and succeed in interpret-
ing, what is going on in the minds of
parents to children and what is going on
in the minds of the youth to parents,
Dr. Levinthal is preeminent.
I would call him the great bridge-
builder — the man who builds the bridge
between generations. As I look over this
congregation and see people with grey
hair like myself, and people with black
hair — young people — I know, even more
emphatically than I knew before I came
here, what a remarkable bridge-builder
he has been. He has made every inch
of the Center an instrument of interpre-
tation of one generation to another, in an
age when we need it so much in our own
homes.
I wonder how many of us realize how
greatly indebted we and our children are
to him for the peace of mind, for the
happiness, for the geniality which fill our
homes. That which came to our ances-
tors so naturally, must come to us
through the great effort and the tireless
effort of an interpreter, who stands here
week after week, and tries to interpret
you to your children and your children
to you. There is no greater service that
any man can render than to help his
children understand him and to help the
father understand the children. And
By PROF. LOUIS FINKELSTEIN
that service Dr. Levinthal has not only
rendered here but to hundreds of com-
munities. It is not only his books that
are being studied and being quoted. He
is being studied and he is being emulated.
And would that it were possible for those
who emulate him to reach his stature.
There is another job of interpretation
that has to be done, and Dr. Levinthal
is preeminent in that, too, the interpre-
tation of each one of us to our neighbors.
You know the Bible says: Ve ohaito
Lereacho Kamocho. "Love thy neighbor
as thyself." When I was young, I was
very much impressed by what the Chris-
tian commentators say about that verse.
They say that the Bible means that you
should only love Jews, and they com-
plained that Moses did not tell us to love
people who were not our neighbors. For
many years I was really impressed with
that and I said to myself: "Why only
your neighbors? Why not love a person
who is not your neighbor, not your
friend?" It was only when I grew older
and watched people that I really got to
understand what the Bible is talking
about. I realized how easy it is to love
a person whom one has never seen in
one's life. It is so easy to love the
Chinese. We cannot be envious of the
Chinese; they do not take anything away
from us; they are 12,000 miles away.
Oh,- it is easy to love the Chinese. But,
how difficult it is to love one's next-door
neighbor! How hard it is to love the
person who is standing right next to us,
and who, in crossing our path, sometimes
does things that irk you; who insists
upon opening the window when you want
it closed, who insists upon standing up
when you want him to sit down, who
insists upon being a little more success-
ful than you, whose children look a lit-
tle better than yours. How hard it is
to love one's next-door neighbor and how
wise the Bible was when it said: "Thou
shalt love thy neighbor as thyself." How
[Continued on page 27]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
ON THE MEANING OF A BIRTHDAY
Dr. Israel H. Levinthal's Responses to the Celebration of His Sixtieth Birthday
The following is an extract from
Dr. Levin that's address at the dinner
given him by the Board of Trustees
and tlye Governing Board on April 6.
AS FAR as I know, there is no
reference in our Rabbinic litera-
ture to a birthday celebration —
except one, and strangely enough, that
one is of a sixtieth birthday. The Tal-
mud records that when Rav Joseph
reached his sixtieth year he made that
day a festive occasion for his fellow
rabbis. "I have been saved," said he,
"from being cut off prematurely." It
seems that the prevalent idea then was
that the years between 50 and 60 were
the dangerous ones, and that anyone who
died within these years suffered Kores,
being cut off before his time — evidently
because of some sin committed. But such
an explanation really does not fully ex-
plain Rav Joseph's celebration, for if this
were the common belief, then everyone
who reached the age of 60 would have
celebrated. Since this is the only celebra-
tion on record, it appears to me that there
is deeper meaning in this little tale.
Rav Joseph, who lived in the fourth
century, lived in a time of stress and
misery for his people. His was a very
difficult ministry. He had to build up
the morale of his brethren and preserve
their spiritual life. Often he felt he
would be crushed under the weight of
his burden. The Talmud, in that same
passage I have discussed, tells us that an-
other such leader, Rabbah, died at the age
of forty. He could not stand up under
the heavy strain. And thus when Rav
Joseph did reach what was regarded as
the ripe age of sixty he felt that a cele-
bration was justified, particularly with
his colleagues, who worked with him and
could appreciate the difficulties he had
encountered and overcome.
In a much more modest sense, mine,
too, has been a difficult ministry. I
often envied some of my colleagues who,
upon graduation, went immediately to
congregations of long standing, firmly es-
tablished, with a well formulated tradi-
tion of service. Mine was a different
fate. I always came to synagogues that
had to be built. The constant refrain
that resounded in my ears was mortgages,
debts, appeals for funds. And not only
were the synagogues to be new buildings,
but their organizations were new. Pol-
icies and philosophies had to be created
and implemented. Many a time, I, too,
felt crushed beneath the weight of the
physical problems that beset us. Often
I doubted if I could even carry on. Now
that I have reached the ripe age of Rav
Joseph, I too feel that I have a right to
celebrate.
And it is especially fitting that I cele-
brate together with you, officers, trustees
and governors of our institution. While
you are not fellow-rabbis, you are
Chaverim, comrades of mine in this holy
work. You are the ones who were
closest to me in our endeavors. You
shared with me our difficulties. You ap-
preciate the heavy obstacles that we faced
and overcame. This is indeed the Yoma
Tovo, the festive celebration, of Rav
Joseph and the Rabbonon.
I shall not be accused of conceit if I
say that some of the success and credit
that are mine have come to me because
of this work. But I do want to empha-
size that much of the success attributed
to me has come because of you.
Our Center has attained lofty heights.
And tonight I want to plead with you —
continue to stand on those heights of
aspiration, idealism and achievement. Do
not permit yourselves nor our institution
to descend from these heights. If you
go down, I go down with you.
You recall the Bible tale of the Jews
who made the golden calf. When God
saw what happened he said to Moses, who
was then on the mountain top, "Get thee
down, for thy people have become cor-
rupt." The Rabbis add to this picture:
"Get thee down from thy greatness," said
God to Moses. "This greatness with
which I have endowed thee, is only be-
cause of Israel. Now that Israel has
fallen, what art thou to me?" And the
sages go on to tell us that just then — in-
stantly — the strength of Moses vanished
and he lost his power to speak. Atoh
V'hem B'yridah, Thou and they fall to-
gether!
These words are my plea to you. I
say again, remain in the heights of spirit-
ual and cultural endeavors, that I too
may glory in those heights. If you
descend these Ani V'atem B'yridah, I too
go down with you.
Let us together, standing on high,
aspire to lift all the Jews of our com-
munity to those heights of Jewish living
which will make all of us the blessed of
God.
At the membership reception in
the Synagogue, Rabbi Levinthal,
after expressing his thanks to the
guest speakers, the artists who sang,
the Committee in charge, the officers,
the editor of the Center Review
and his associates, and to all who had
a share in this tribute, said, in part:
I DO not want to speak of myself nor
' of my work on this occasion. There
comes to my mind a warning voiced in
our Talmud. The book of Nehemiah is
always referred to in the Talmud as part
of the book of Ezra, as if the latter and
not Nehemiah was the author. "Why is
not this book called by his name?" ask
the sages. And the answer is quite sig-
nificant. "Because the author in that
book takes too much credit for himself.
He speaks too much about himself!"
Therefore he was punished by not hav-
ing his name remembered. I surely do not
want to suffer that fate, and therefore,
I shall refrain from speaking about my-
self, especially since others, out of the
goodness of their hearts, have said so
much about me — much more than I truly
deserve.
This, however, I may in all justice and
in all humility say of myself. I believed,
and I believe now in the Rabbinate. I
loved the ministry. And this is one of
the primary prerequisites for any success
that may be achieved. The Rabbis in
the Talmud tell us that "any priest who
does not believe in his service, in the
[Continued on page 26]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
21
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER NEWS
Concluding Passover Services
Services for the concluding days of
the Passover holiday will be on Thursday
evening, April 29th, at 8 o'clock, and on
Friday evening, April 30th, at 6 o'clock;
also on Friday and Saturday mornings,
April 3 0th and May 1st, at 8:30 o'clock.
Rabbi Saltzman will speak on Friday
morning and Rabbi Levinthal will preach
on the concluding day, Saturday morning.
Yizkor (memorial services for the
dead) will be recited at the services on
the last day of Passover, May 1st, at
about 10:15 o'clock.
Hebrew School News
The Hebrew School model Seder was
held on Tuesday, April 20. The follow-
ing led in the service: Larry Levy, Her-
bert Kasnetz, Charles Stromfeld, Frieda
Cohen, Rena Rosenbaum, Helen Aronow,
Ileane Altman, Ellen Machlin, Jules Hol-
lander, Martin Arkowitz, Toby Brown,
Carla Lefkowitz, Arlene Aaronson.
* * *
Impressive services were held by the
Hebrew School on April 8, and by the
Religious School on April 11, in connec-
tion with the Palestine Day of Prayer.
The program for the service was: Star
Spangled Banner; recitation of the poem,
"Weep Not"; address, Rabbi Saltzman;
Adon Olam; solo, "Song of Zion," Jane
Amster; Y'rushalayim, Grade 3; Letter
of Protest to President Truman, Ellen
Machlin; "America, the Beautiful"; ad-
dress, Rabbi Lewittes; Minute of Silence;
Hatikvah.
A Post-Bar-Mitzvah Service was held
on Friday, April 16, 1948. The program
was as follows: Opening remarks by
Rabbi Lewittes; Invocation, Lloyd Alt-
man; Theme: "Education and Our
Youth"; Introductory talk by Stanley
Green, followed by these addresses: "Our
Source of Inspiration," Alex Sterman;
"The Danger of Tyranny," Leonard Ber-
man; "Our Dream of Zion," Daniel
Klinghoffer; "Judaism and Democracy,"
Burton Garber; "World Peace," Law-
rence Heimowitz; "The Significance of
Our Past," Thomas Kraner; "Our Holy
Tongue," Sandor Schaeffer; "The Need
for Leaders," Robert Kritz. The program
continued with: Charge to Graduates,
Rabbi Saltzman; Conferring of Diploma,
Dr. Levinthal; Acceptance, Abner Beder;
Benediction, Dr. Levinthal; The Bar-
Mitzvah Prayer, Morris Flamm; Conclu-
sion of Service. Cantor Sauler during
the service.
The Kushner Post-Bar-Mitzvah award
for progress in Hebrew Studies was given
to Abner Beder.
Center Academy News
The annual Passover Seder of the Cen-
ter Academy was held on Tuesday, April
20, 1948, in the dining room of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center. The Day of
Deliverance, as in the past, was a busy
and exciting one for the boys and girls
of the Academy. All the traditions of
the holiday were faithfully observed,
from the preparation of the Charoseth to
the singing of the Chadgadya. The
senior class was in complete charge of
the festivities, with Arthur Greenberg
serving as the Father and Barbara Zevon
as the Mother. The services were opened
with the traditional Beur Chamitz cere-
mony, at which Rabbi Levinthal offi-
ciated.
* * *
On Pan-American Day, April 14th,
the 7th Grade children were hosts to a
group of 30 visitors from the Chelsea
Elementary School in lower Manhattan.
The 7th Grade was returning the hospi-
tality that had been extended to them by
the Chelsea students in February. The
visitors played basket ball and punchball
with us, had lunch, were given an ex-
planation of the significance of Passover
and saw an original play presented by
the boys and girls of the 7th Grade. At
the end of the day, after we served ice
cream and lolly-pops, our visitors bade
us au re voir.
Junior Clubs Close Successful Season
All the Junior clubs had their closing
session of the current year on Saturday
evening, April 17th. This season has
been a most successful one. The clubs
had a very fine Jewish program of ac-
tivities together with a very successful
athletic program. The last big event was
our Purim festival which featured a
talk on "The Significance of Purim for
the Jewish Youth" given by Jimmy
Lewisohn; piano selections by Morton and
Clara Bromberg; clarinet selection by
Conrad Lefkowitz. Mr. Julius Grossman,
Musical Director of the Center, led the
group in Purim songs.
The success of the club program was
due to the very fine leadership of the
groups and by the interest they stimu-
lated amongst the membership. The
members of the Junior clubs are eagerly
looking forward to the re-opening of the
club season next year.
Young Folks League
The annual installation of officers and
executive committee of the Young Folks
League will be held on Tuesday evening,
May 4th, at 8:30 o'clock. The rabbis
and officers of the Center have been in-
vited to attend. Members are urged not
to miss this important event of the
League.
Junior League News
The Junior League of the Center is
sponsoring an "Open Meeting" and "So-
cial Get-Together" on Thursday evening,
May 6th, at 8:30 o'clock. Members of
the Junior League are cordially invited
and are asked to bring their friends with
them.
Daily Services
Morning services at 8 a.m.
Mincha services at 7:30 p.m.
Junior Congregation Passover
Festival Services
Concluding Passover services will be
held in the Junior Congregation on Fri-
day and Saturday mornings, April 30th
and May 1st, at 9:30 o'clock under the
leadership of Rabbi Lewittes and Rabbi
Saltzman. All children of the community
are cordially invited to attend these very
impressive services.
Lighting of Candles During Concluding
Days of Passover
The lighting of candles on Thursday
and Friday evenings, April 29th and
30th, will be at 7:30 o'clock.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Baker, Miss Mildred
Res. 2315 Avenue S
Proposed by Elaine Glover,
Dorothy Kaplan
Bernstein, Frederick
Res. 430 Crown St.
Bus. Builder, 78-10 Parsons Blvd.
Single
Proposed by Samuel Bernstein
Braaf, Irving W.
Res. 3 07 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Catering, 836 Franklin Ave.
Married
Proposed by Ira T. Kraner,
Dr. I. H. Levinthal
Cohen, Benjamin
Res. 345 Montgomery St. *
Bus. Furs, 214 W. 30th St.
Married
Proposed by Harry Mandler,
Albert Richman
ElSENSTADT, RAYMOND
Res. 105 0 Greene Ave.
Single
Proposed by Seymour Eisenstadt
Falk, Irving
Res. 681 Lefrerts Ave.
Bus. Textile, 105 W. 40th St.
Married
Proposed by Leo Kaufmann
Fisgel, Mrs. Ricki
Res. 271 Parkside Ave.
Proposed by Mrs. Edward Schaeffer,
Dr. Jos. Leavitt
Frucht, William
Res. 13 5 Ocean Ave.
Bus. Post Office, 1714 W. 6th St.
Married
Proposed by Samuel Robbins
Geichman, Melvin
Res. 116 E. 94th St.
Bus. Luggage, 5 07 W. Bway.
Single
Proposed by Isador Lowenfeld,
Seymour Feingold
Glassberg, Mrss Esther R.
Res. 1651 Carroll St.
Proposed by Rose Snofsky,
Sylvia Nelson
Gold, David
Res. 1284 Dean St.
Bus. Export-Import, 50 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Mrs. I. Dolgin,
Bertram Hollander
Goldman, Miss Helen B.
Res. 1701 Avenue R
Bus. Dress Mfg., 1375 Bway.
Single
Proposed by Dorothy Kaplan,
Elaine Glover
Grinspan, Miss Shirley
Res. 1216 St. Johns Pi.
Proposed by Selma Hollander,
Irma Baron
Firestone, Miss Dorothy
Res. 1052 E. 52nd St.
Proposed by Ruth Keltz,
Judith Sorscher
Kaitz, M. Martin
Res. 1393 Carroll St.
Bus. Dresses, 296 Kingston Ave.
Married
Proposed by Mrs. M. Klinghoffer,
Mrs. B. Friedman
Kaye, Samuel
Res. 9409 Avenue A
Bus. Exporters, 39 W. 37th St.
Single
Proposed by Sam Horowitz,
Lorraine Pomerantz
Lieberman, Milton J.
Res. 201 Crown St.
Bus. U.J.A., 165 W. 46th St.
Married
Lieberman, Sidney
Res. 13 64 Sterling Pi.
Bus. Provisions, 500 Bway.
Single
NORENSBERG, JACK
Res. 5223 Tilden Ave.
Bus. Fruit, 12 Brooklyn Terminal
Married
Proposed by Hyman Jasper,
Lewis Glozer
Perlin, Jack
Res. 5614— 15th Ave.
Bus. Millwork, 1160 Flushing Ave.
Married
Proposed by Irving Perlin,
Louis Brown
Perlman, Philip
Res. 92 5 Prospect PI.
Bus. Ladies Handbags, 14 E. 32nd St.
Single
Proposed by Benj. Perlman,
Jos. Goldberg
Schonbach, Jacob
Res. 52 Balfour Pi.
Bus. Jobber, 1645 Bedford Ave.
Married
Proposed by M. Robert Epstein
Silverman, Miss Beatrice
Res. 1571 Carroll St.
Proposed by Benj. Grau,
Seymour Kornweiss
Simchowitz, Harry
Res. 14 E. 58th St.
Bus. Furs, 330— 7th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Julius Light,
Frank F. Rose
Sklarin, Miss Babbie
Res. 1833 E. 16th St.
Proposed by Bernard Meyerowitz,
Leo Chizner
Smith, Miss Gloria
Res. 1754 E. 24th St.
Proposed by Dorothy Kaplan,
Elaine Glover
Stern, Lawrence
Res. 639 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Shoes, 1580 Pitkin Ave.
Married
Suchman, Max
Res. 1522 Remsen Ave.
Bus. Furniture, 437 — 8th Ave.
Single
Proposed by John Dunaif,
Ben Goldberg
Wallach, Miss Roselyn
Res. 3086 W. 1st St.
Bus. Rent Control, 26 Court St.
Single
Proposed by Edward Schaeffer,
Dr. Jos. Leavitt
Zwerdling, Dr. Philip
Res. 297 New York Ave.
Bus. Physician
Married
Proposed by Tobias Zwerdling
LATE APPLICATIONS
Pollack, Miss Ruth
Res. 3 33 Neptune Ave.
Proposed by Thelma Spruck,
Sylvia Lichtman
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
Wachtel, Leo
Res. 961 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Clothing, 140 — 5th Ave.
Single
Proposed by John Dunaif,
Ben Goldberg
The following has applied for reinstate-
ment:
Marcus, Zachariah
Res. 961 Lincoln Pi.
Married
Proposed by Herbert Turner,
Leo Kaufmann
Samuel H. Goldberg,
Chairman, Membership Committee.
Congratulations
Heartiest congratulations and best
wishes are extended to:
Mr. and Mrs. Louis Weinstock of 13 5
Eastern Parkway on the birth of a son,
Douglas, to their children, Mr. and Mrs.
Gerard Weinstock, on April 19th.
Jewish National Fund Assembly
A Jewish National Fund Assembly
was held by the Hebrew School on Sun-
day, April 18th. A scroll, commemorat-
ing the planting of a garden in Palestine
in recognition of the large sum of money
contributed by our students, was pre-
sented by the J.N.F. Mr. Mordecai
Rudensky made the presentation on be-
half of the J.N.F. The citation on the
scroll read as follows: "A garden has been
planted in Palestine in honor of the stu-
dents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center He-
brew School in recognition of their ef-
forts on behalf of the Jewish National
Fund. November 1947."
The presentation of the scroll was fol-
lowed by Palestinian movies taken by Mr.
Samuel Edelheit when he visited Eretz
Israel.
In Memoriam
We announce with deep regret the
passing of our member
IHra. lanital) ZtnttBkij
of 361 New York Avenue on April 21,
1948.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center extends
its most heartfelt sympathy and con-
dolence to the family and relatives in
their bereavement.
Additions to the Library
The following books have been added
to our library and arc ready for circu-
lation:
"The Moonstone" — Wilkie Collins
"Great Expectations" — Charles Dickens
"Les Miserables" — Victor Hugo
"The Stoic" — Theodore Dreiser
"Years of the Pilgrimage" — K. S. Davis
"Masterworks of Philosophy" — Edited
by S. D. Frost, Jr.
"Van Hassel Diaries"
"An Explorer Comes Home" — Roy C.
Andrews
"Story of Mankind" — Hendrik Van
Loon
"Roget's Thesaurus" — C. O S. Mawson
"Milton Cross's Great Operas"
"Favorite Poems" — Henry W. Long-
fellow
"Unconquered" — Neal H. Swanson
"The Bishop's Mantle" — Agnes S.
Turnbull
"Prince of Foxes" — Samuel Shella-
barger
"The Enduring Federalist" — Chas. A.
Beard
"Selected Writings of Solomon Schech-
ter" — N. Bentwich
"Essays of Jewish Biography" — Alex-
ander Marx
"Selected Essay of Ahad Ha'am" —
Leon Simon
"Modern Nationalism and Religion" —
Salo W. Baron
"American Overture" — A. V. Good-
man
"Eagle in the Sky" — Van Wyck Mason
"The Jew in American Sport" — Her-
bert N. Ribalow
"Inside Karilevke" — Shalom Aleichem
"Abraham of Terah" — Florence Mar-
vyne Bauer
"Anti-Semitism in America, a Mark for
Privilege" — Carey McWilliams
Hebrew Books
"Aruch Ha-shalem" — Alexander Kohut
(2 vols.)
"Dibre Yeme Am Olam" — Simon Dub-
now (11 vols.)
"Abodath Israel" (Siddur) — Isaac Baer
(original 1868 edition)
"Toledoth Haposkim" — Haim Tscher-
nowitz (3 vols.)
"Sifre edition" — Meyer Friedman
"Sifra edition" — I. H. Weiss
"Pirke d'Rabbi Eliezcr with Commen-
tary of D. Luria"
"Milon Ivri" (Dictionary) — Jehudah
Grazovski
"Hechal Ledibre Ha'zal Upithgeme-
hem" — Haim Bloch
"Sefcr Ha-Chasidut" — Isaac Werfel
"Ha 'Yehudim Ve Ha 'Yeranim"
"Betkufat Ha 'Halenistis"
"Abigor Tschcrikover"
Bar Mitzvah
A hearty Mazel Tov is extended to
Mr. and Mrs. Morris D. Bergcr of 546
Montgomery Street on the Bar Mitzvah
of their son, J. Lawrence, which will be
celebrated at the Center on Saturday
morning, May 8th.
Acknowledgment of Gifts
We acknowledge with thanks receipt
of donations for the purchase of Prayer
Books, Taleisim and books in our library
from the following:
Mr. and Mrs. Michael Aminoff in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their son,
Melvin.
Miss Rhoda Bernstein.
Mr. Elias Burros in memory of his wife,
Esther.
Mr. and Mrs. Louis Daum in honor of
the marriage of their daughter, Rita.
Messrs. Meyer and Philip Feldman in
memory of parents.
Mr. and Mrs. William Garfinkle in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their son,
George Lawrence.
Miss Helene Wolfe.
Mr. Jacob Harmatz in honor of the
Bar Mitzvah of his grandson, Kenneth
Spatz.
Mr. and Mrs. Saul Kabram in honor of
the Bar Mitzvah of their son, Leonard.
THE
Brooklyn Jewish Center
has acquired
CEMETERY GROUNDS
in the
NEW
Montefiore Cemetery
at
PINELAWN, LONG ISLAND
•
Prices of Plots
4 Grave Plots . . $250.00
6 Grave Plots $3 5 0.00
1 5 Grave Plots
(facing main road) $1,000.00
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
24
YAHRZEITS-MAY, 1948
Kalman I. Ostrow
Mother
May 1
22 Nisan
Max Rudy . .
Father
May 1
22 Nisan
Mrs. L. W. Bernard
Husband
May 2
23 Nisan
Louis Rosenblatt
Mother
May 2
23 Nisan
Charles Fine
Brother
May 3
24 Nisan
Meyer Kenin
Father
May 3
24 Nisan
Joseph Richman
Father
May 3
24 Nisan
Mrs. Rubin Tucker
Mother
May 3
24 Nisan
Mrs. Louis J. Palatnick
Father
May 4
25 Nisan
Benjamin Dubrow . .
Father
May 5
26 Nisan
Dr. Reuben Finkelstein
Father
May 5
26 Nisan
Louis Hoffman
Mother
May 5
26 Nisan
Benjamin Levitt
Father
May 5
26 Nisan
Abraham Mann
Father
May 5
26 Nisan
A. Silverman
Mother
May 5
26 Nisan
Jacob A. Fortunoff
Mother
May 6
27 Nisan
Hon. Emanuel Greenberg
Father
May 6
27 Nisan
Philip Levine
Father
May 6
27 Nisan
Mrs. Sol Sussman
Father
May 8
29 Nisan
Charles Wunderlich .
Mother
May 8
29 Nisan
Mrs. Abraham Cohen
Mother
May 10
1 Iyar
Philip Palevsky
Mother
May 10
1 Iyar
Emanuel Goldsmith
Mother
May 11
2 Iyar
Joseph Horowitz
Father
May 12
3 Iyar
I. Silberberg
Father
May 12
3 Iyar
Mrs. Frank Brodie . r
Jerome H. Cole
> Mother
Mother
May 13
4 Iyar
Mrs. Edward Manes
Mrs. Samuel Nicoll
I
David Phillips
Wife
May 14
5 Iyar
Morris Traub
Mother
May 14
5 Iyar
Al Witty
Father
May 14
5 Iyar
Mrs. H. Lieb
Mother
May 16
7 Iyar
Mrs. I. Ginsberg
Daughter
May 17
8 Iyar
Abraham Ginsburg
Father
May 17
8 Iyar
Mother
May 17
8 Iyar
Frank Levey .
Father
May 17
8 Iyar
I. Jerome Riker . ......
Mother
May 17
8 Iyar
Mrs. I. Lazarowitz
Husband
May 19
10 Iyar
Mrs. S. A. Schneider
Mother
May 20
11 Iyar
Louis Weinstock
Father
May 20
11 Iyar
Husband ]
Alfred Greenblatt . I
(.
Father |
May 22
13 Iyar
Samuel Greenblatt .. J
Irving Steinberg
Mother
May 22
13 Iyar
Harold Cantor
Mother
May 23
14 Iyar
Max Herzfeld
Mother
May 23
14 Iyar
Abe Mann
Mother
May 23
14 Iyar
Samuel Rottenberg
Father
May 23
14 Iyar
Harry Glaubman ]
Joseph Glaubman
Mother
May 24
15 Iyar
Louis Glaubman J
Dr. Max Goldstein.
Father
May 24
15 Iyar
Morris M. Lubell
Mother
May 24
15 Iyar
Philip Rosenbloom
Father
May 24
15 Iyar
Morris D. Berger
Father
May 25
16 Iyar
To Members Planning Bar
Mitzvahs at the Center
Members who are planning Bar Mitz-
vahs in the near future are requested to
please reserve the date far in advance.
According to the rules of the Center,
the boy whose Bar Mitzvah is booked
first receives the privilege of getting the
maftir. In the event that more than one
Bar Mitzvah is scheduled for the same
day, the other boys receive one of the
other aliyahs and can read a passage from
the Torah.
Prior Registration in Center
Academy for Center
Membership
The Center Academy of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center is now open
for prior registration in the lower
school for children of Center mem-
bers. Vacancies are limited, so
please apply early.
CENTER LIBRARY
•
Open Mondays, Tuesdays, Wednes-
days and Thursdays from
3 to 9 p.m.
•
The Library, located on the third
floor of our building, has a fine col-
lection of books in Hebrew, English
and Yiddish.
•
Open to Center Members and the
Community.
Young Folk's League
United Jewish Appeal
COCKTAIL -DANCE
•
Sunday Evening, May 16th
8:30 o'clock
•
$2.00 Donation
Limited to Members only upon
presentation of 1948 card.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
25
PIONEER OF MODERN HEBREW
[Continued
the idea that Hebrew might become the
daily vernacular occupied his mind. He
learned that Hebrew was spoken by Jews
of the East, and he likewise began to
speak it. Soon he realized that Hebrew
lacked the necessary everyday words and
this prompted him to embark upon his
life work — the Hebrew dictionary.
In 1882, Ben Yehudah settled in Pal-
estine, and there he became a sturdy and
independent fighter for the revival of
spoken Hebrew. He founded the Hebrew
weekly newspaper Hazeri, which he edited
for several years, assisted by his wife and
his son. They formed the first Hebrew-
speaking family in the country.
The forty-odd years of his residence
in Eretz Israel were years of continuous
activity. He edited and published sev-
eral Hebrew weeklies, wrote a number
of text-books, and, above all, fought for
the spread of Hebrew speech. His zeal
was inexhaustible and his opinions un-
shakable. He was opposed to the old
ways of thought and actions, and fanati-
cally upheld his ideal — to make Hebrew
a living medium of communication.
Single-handed, he set out upon his
gigantic undertaking of the dictionary.
He worked in the leading libraries of the
world, searching for new words, suitable
expressions and idioms. When he found
no suitable terms in ancient literature,
he invented new ones to fill the gap until
from page 13]
words would spring up from life itself.
In 1903 Eliezer Ben Yehudah established
the Va'ad ha-Lashon, a Language Board,
which was to watch over the develop-
ment of the living Hebrew language and
its applications to the requirements of the
present.
Ben Yehudah succeeded in overcoming
all obstacles to his work.
The establishment of the new Yishuv
brought new life into Palestine. The
Halutzim endured their hardships and
labored to achieve success. They spoke,
sang and read only Hebrew. With re-
lentless fanaticism, they demanded He-
brew of the Jews of Palestine. And they
had their way. The new Yishuv was
completely Hebraized, and in this move-
ment the youth of all the settlements
joined hands. Eliezer Ben Yehudah thus
spent the last years of his life witnessing
the approaching fulfillment of the dream
of his youth.
Ben Yehudah stands out as the pioneer
of the Jewish Renaissance, a man who
made himself one with a Jewish home-
land. His life belongs fittingly to the
realm of story and fable. He has be-
come more a myth than a man. He was
and is a symbol of our national work
and of the cultural ideals of Free Pales-
tine. Ben Yehudah died beloved by all
classes of Jewish people in Eretz Israel.
YAHRZEITS
Hyman Bloomgarden
Nathaniel H. Jackson
Miss Dora Leaks
Mrs. Sadie Zankel
Charles Zankel
Max Zankel ..
Harry Zankel
Mrs. David Feinberg
Seymour Koff
Oscar Kurshan
Samuel Kurshan
Dr. Maurice Schnall
Judah Trotzky
Mrs. Charles Fine
Morris Miller
Samuel Robbins
Mrs. Abraham Ginsburg
Mrs. Louis Albert
Isidor Gray
Father
May
25
16
Iyar
Mother
May
25
16
Iyar
Mother
May
26
17
Iyar
Husband ]
1 Father f
May
26
17
Iyar
J J
Husband
May
27
18
Iyar
Father
May
27
18
Iyar
j Father
May
27
18
Iyar
Father
May
27
18
Iyar
Mother
May
28
19
Iyar
Father
May
29
20
Iyar
Father
May
29
20
Iyar
Father
May
29
20
Iyar
Father
May
30
21
Iyar
Father
May
31
21
Iyar
Father
May
31
21
Iyar
HYMAN
SPITZ inc.
OUR ONLY STORE
Dickens 2-4000
1685 PITKIN AVENUE
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
26
ON THE MEANING OF A BIRTHDAY
[Continued from page 20]
work that he has to perform, can claim
no share in the priesthood; only the priest
who believes in his service can claim the
rewards that the priesthood offers." I
can, in all modesty, say that I believed
in this work, that I loved it and was ever
thankful for it. And I am particularly
thankful that it was my privilege to serve
in your midst, a congregation of high
ideals, who have ever cooperated with me,
who encouraged and inspired me in all
that I aspire to achieve.
And this, too, I want and feel I may
say. There are three books in our Bible
which Jewish tradition attributes to the
authorship of King Solomon: Shir Ha-
sbirim, the Song of Songs, that beautiful
ode to love, perhaps the greatest love
poem in all literature; Mis hie, the book
of Proverbs, in which are gathered choice
words of wisdom; and Kohelet, Ecclesi-
astes, the philosophy of pessimism, which
rings with the refrain "Vanity of van-
ities, all is vanity." Now the Rabbis tell
us when Solomon wrote the Song of Songs
he wrote in his youth; Proverbs he com-
posed in middle age, out of the ripeness
of his experience, and Ecclesiastes he set
forth in his old age.
Like King Solomon, I, too, was privi-
leged to have sung a Shir Ha-shiritti in my
youth. And I am grateful to God that
I can still sing the Song of Love. Evi-
dently, I am still young. I pray that I
and my beloved wife may continue to
sing that Shir Ha-shirim for many years
to come.
After my graduation, when I began
to serve as Rabbi, I, too, like Solomon
of old, began to teach and preach the
Mishle of Israel — those wise teachings and
sayings of our ancient masters. I saw
in that rich Midrashic literature wisdom
spoken not for the ancient days alone,
but for all time.
But unlike Solomon — now that I have
reached sixty, which, according to the
sages, typifies Xiknoh, old age — I am not
ready to say "Vanity of vanities, all is
vanity." I still refuse to become the
pessimist. And if that is the sign of old
age, then I protest that I am still young.
For I am an inveterate optimist.
Birthdays are nice, and it is pleasant
to celebrate them. I am reminded, how-
ever, that the great Alexandrian Jewish
philosopher, Philo, in one of his books,
warns us that the celebration of birth-
days is a form of idolatry. If a birth-
day means nothing more than a joyous
celebration, then it is in truth a form of
idolatry — an empty, meaningless obser-
vance. The Jew is taught to count days
so as to acquire a heart of wisdom. He
looks to the passing of years as a chal-
lenge. That is the spirit in which I —
and I hope you too — regard this day. It
is a warning that the day is short — yea,
Resolution unanimously adopted by
the General Council of the World Zionist
Organization on April 12, 1948, at Tel
Aviv:
WHEREAS, after twenty-seven years
of an oppressive foreign regime that
had received Palestine as a trust on behalf
of the world to establish a national home-
land for the Jews, that trust was not
fulfilled:
Now, therefore, the Jewish nation will
establish its own state and independence
in its homeland.
The Jewish state to be established will
be ruled by justice, freedom and equality
for all inhabitants, regardless of race or
creed.
We call upon the Arabs of Palestine
and the neighboring states for an alliance
of peace and cooperation. Together we
shall build a state as citizens with equal
rights and in mutual respect, for our free-
dom is your freedom.
Our lives are dedicated to defense, and
the Lord of Israel will be our mainstay.
On this, the third day of Nissam, the
General Council of the World Zionist
Organization, its highest unit, announces
to the civilized peoples of the world, to
the representatives of the United Nations
and to the Jews scattered throughout the
world that it has been decided to set up
an organ of supreme authority of our
national independence in Palestine.
In pursuance of this purpose, we de-
clare that we refuse to remain a minority
dependent on the sufferance of others.
The mandate is about to end. On May
1 5 His Majesty's Government will sur-
render to the United Nations the trust
it received from the League of Nations
twenty-seven years ago and which it has
the day is getting shorter. And the work
is great — yea, so much is yet to be done.
Let it not be said of you nor of me that
"the workmen are sluggish." For "the
Master is urgent." Destiny summons us.
Time is of the essence. Let us on this
day rededicate ourselves to work, through
our beloved Jewish Center, to bring
closer the sunlight of peace and happi-
ness in the life of our people and our peo-
ple's land and in the lives of all the
peoples on earth.
failed to fulfill. It departed from the
spirit of the mandate and replaced it with
the selfish purpose of furthering its Mid-
dle East interests.
As a result of this policy, our refugees
were refused entry in the hour of their
direst need. They were interned instead
and condemned to lead a life of danger,
humiliation and helplessness while the
mandatory treated with our sworn en-
emies, the friends and allies of the Nazis.
And while refusing entry to Jews striv-
ing desperately after a last refuge they
opened our frontiers to hordes of in-
vaders come to make a mockery of the
decision of the United Nations. And
now the mandatory is proposing to de-
stroy the very foundation of our existence
and leave the country in utter chaos.
To prevent this we have resolved this
day that the termination of the manda-
tory government of Palestine shall in fact
mark the end of all foreign domination
in this country. With the termination
of this mandatory rule, a government of
the Jewish state shall come into being.
In this hour we turn to the Arab citi-
zens of the Jewish state and our Arab
neighbors. We desire to build our state
in common with the Arabs as equal citi-
zens. Their future and ours rest on com-
mon endeavor.
Sure in the justice of our cause, we are
ready to give our all to its achievement
and we call on the Jews of all lands, and
especially in Palestine, to close their ranks
for the carrying out of this, our sublime
task. Assured in our faith, we appeal to
all nations to grant us the right to our
own salvation, and rest our trust in God,
the Lord of Israel.
JEWISH DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
27
AN INTERPRETER OF HIS GENERATION
wise Moses was — how he knew what he
was talking about when he said: Never
mind the fellows whom you never see —
try to love the fellow who is standing
right next to you. The other fellows
will take care of themselves.
Well, Dr. Levinthal is a man who helps
us love and understand our next-door
neighbors. In our Rabbinic Assembly,
which consists of all the graduates of the
Seminary and a number of other rabbis,
and of whom I think I can say, without
undue pride, that it is probably the most
distinguished group of ministers in this
country, Dr. Levinthal is the great in-
terpreter of man to man. When feelings
become tense, it is a remarkable thing to
have Dr. Levinthal there. He peers
through the maze of arguments to the
issue and shows how people who think
they are disagreeing are not disagreeing
at all, but only think they are disagree-
ing; they are rationalizing into disagree-
ment the things which, when they see
them, they are ashamed of. And so he
does the job that Aaron did — he meets
people and brings them together and does
that great miracle of transforming peo-
ple, who might very well become en-
emies, into friends. We, of the Semi-
nary, the rabbis of America, like you, are
indebted to him for his great leadership.
We look across the years, and remember
so many instances when the air was tense
with difficulty, and when the calm words,
the benign smile, the loving glance of
Dr. Levinthal, and his great wisdom
brought peace where there might have
been struggle and difference.
And then, of course, there is another
great job of interpretation that must be
done, one so vital today — the job of get-
ting the world to understand what we
Jews are talking about — why we are
Jews. What great catastrophes have come
upon the world as well as upon us be-
cause the peoples of the world do not
understand this small Jewish people.
What a different world it would be in
1948 if the world in 1933 would have
known the heartache of the Jewish peo-
ple and what we meant when we said
that the attack on the Jews was not an
attack on the Jews but an attack on
civilization. How many who are now
dead would still be living, how many who
[Continued from page 19]
are now wounded would not be wounded
at all, and the great dangers facing us
today would not even be a distant night-
mare, if only in 1933 we could have got-
ten the ear of the world when we said,
"We are not a people that is trying to
live to be a people. We are trying to
render a service to mankind. We are
trying to maintain a tradition — a proph-
ecy — and, when we are disliked and per-
secuted — it is not we who are being dis-
liked and persecuted, it is the Prophets
who are being disliked and persecuted;
and they are not our prophets, they are
the world's prophets."
All this the world did not know and,
alas, we did not have enough Dr. Levin-
thals to make what we said clear to the
world of 1933. A frightful price has
been paid and God knows when the end
is going to be.
Dr. Levinthal is doing as much as one
man Can possibly do to give dignity to
the Jewish name. He is beloved by all
of us; but he is beloved way beyond
the boundaries of the Jewish people.
The real work of interpreting Judaism
to the world is being done here, in the
Center, and by our great rabbi and his
disciples and the disciples of this Center
in other places. So, I bring to Dr. Lev-
inthal tonight the tribute of his Alma
Mater, the tribute of my colleagues on
the faculty of the Seminary, and the
tribute of the rabbis of the country. He
has rendered us a service of which not
everyone is yet aware. It is a service of
the spirit, and it is characteristic of the
service of the spirit that you do not know
when you have been affected by a great
man. He has put to his debt not only
us of this generation, but the children
and grandchildren who are coming after
us because, if the Talmud were not to be
handed down from one generation to an-
other, where would our grandchildren get
it from?
I know that you will realize that I am
not speaking out of blasphemy, but out
of the depth of my heart, when I say
that it is possible for a man to put God
in his debt. There is nothing that God
wants more than good men, I am sure,
and when one of his children devotes him-
self to making human beings better
human beings, that person has put God
in his debt.
I pray that God may repay that debt
with great blessings for Dr. and Mrs.
Levinthal and their children, and Dr. Lev-
inthal's father and his brothers, and all
of you who are so dear to him, so that
he may have many years of happiness,
and that, in your day and in his, there
may come peace to the world and to our
people some solace and comfort after so
many years of hardship and trial.
LAND FOR DEFENSE
[Continued from page 7]
the interval, more land had been ac-
quired in southern Beisan and three new
settlements established. Today its flank
and rear are covered; if it is hard pressed,
there is help near at hand. If still more
land were bought and two new settle-
ments built, a closely-linked chain of
Jewish defenses would exist along the
Jordan, strengthening each other and
forming a barrier to the west.
A similar pattern was started on the
Syrian frontier in the Upper Huleh
region. Dan and Dafne, with only about
a mile between them, buttress each other.
Between Dafne and Maayan Baruch, how-
ever, there is a space of about three miles.
Another settlement link would have
strengthened the chain.
In the Negev, twenty-three outposts
scattered over a vast expanse including
southernmost Judea serve a double pur-
pose. Isolated and vulnerable though most
of them are, they serve not only as foot-
holds for our further forward progress
and oblige the enemy to scatter his own
resources, but they also prevent, in a
measure, the concentration of enemy
forces in this great empty region.
Less than 7% of Land Jewish-Owned
The master-plans of land purchased by
the Jewish National Fund — especially
since 1936 — have given high priority to
considerations of defensive strategy. But
with less than seven percent of Palestine
land in Jewish ownership, these plans are
necessarily only in the early stages of real-
ization.
— From "Haganah Speaks.**
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
■ ■
ABBOT-FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES— SERVICE
507 Flatbush Avenue
JESSE J. FINE Brooklyn, New York
JACK ABBOT Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
— —RIVERSIDE—
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2-6600
Far Rockaway, L. I.
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE
FAr Rockaway 7-7100
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle, we have arranged to
serve your Community. We have at our disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn.
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed 'U '^ J0 *>
Miami Beach, Florida
1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
Miami 5-7777
Sec. 562, P. L. & R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
-3SSS
(The {B^uwAlyn
62*
May, 1948
THE FUTURE OF AMERICAN
JEWRY NOW
By LUDWIG LEWISOHN
CHAIM TCHERNOWITZ AT 75
By JACOB S. MINKIN
THE PROBLEM OF JEWISH LAW
By DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
THE MEANING OF THE WORD
"ISRAEL 7 7
.■rm
AS I REMEMBER THE
CENTER HEBREW SCHOOL
By LAZAR E. LEVINTHAL
NEWS OF THE MONTH
ISRAEL CHRONOLOGY
1822-1948
The foil o icing com pre hens i v e
chronology of the development of
Zionism and creation of the Jewish
State uas published by the "New
York Times" in its issue of May 16.
1882:
Jan. — Zionist colonization in Palestine
begins with immigration from Russia.
1897:
Aug. — First Zionist Congress, sponsored
by Theodor Herzl, founds World Zionist
Organization. Jewish population of Pal-
estine is about 50,000 out of total of
650,000.
1917:
Nov. 2 — Balfour Declaration affirms
British approval of Jewish National Home
in Palestine, furnishing political basis for
the Zionist movement.
1922:
June 3 — Churchill White Paper reaf-
firms British recognition of Zionism, but
vetoes an all-Jewish Palestine and limits
future immigration to the "absorptive
capacity of the country." Arabs reject
the Churchill policy; Jews accept it.
July 24 — League of Nations approves
British mandate. Jewish population of
Palestine is about 85,000 out of 750,000.
1929:
Aug. 23-29 — Bloody rioting between
Jews and Arabs follows a long period of
increasing tension based in part upon
conflict over Jerusalem's Holy Places.
1933:
Oct. — Riots and strikes accompany
Arab protests against Jewish immigration
and purchase of land.
193 5:
Jan. — The Haifa, Palestine, branch of
the oil pipeline from Iraq is opened.
1936:
April 15-25 — Amid new violence,
Arabs declare "national political strike"
to enforce demands for immigration re-
striction. The Arab Higher Committee
is informed.
1937:
July — The Peel Commission (British)
recommends partition of Palestine into
Jewish and Arab areas with Jerusalem
under international control. Jews and
Arabs reject the plan.
1939:
May 17 — Britain issues White Paper
restricting Jewish immigration to 75,000
in the next five years.
1940:
April — British allow resumption of
immigration at rate of 1,000 per month
after stoppage due to war Jewish popu-
lation of Palestine is about 450,000 out
of a total of nearly 1,500,000.
1945:
March 22 — League of Arab states is
established at meeting in Cairo.
Aug. — President Truman calls on Brit-
ain to open Palestine to 100,000 Jewish
refugees from Europe. Britain refuses.
Nov. — Jewish extremists stage disord-
ers in retaliation for British detention of
refugee immigrants in excess of quota.
1946:
April 30 — Anglo-American Committee
presents report recommending (1) ad-
mission of 100,000 refugees, (2) Palestine
to be neither a Jewish nor an Arab state,
(3) retention of the mandate. Attlee
says the report cannot be implemented
without American support.
July 25 — The Anglo-American Cab-
inet Committee presents the "Morrison"
plan for partition of Palestine into Jewish
and Arab provinces under the mandate.
Jews, Arabs and the United States reject
it.
Sept. 10 — A Palestine conference con-
venes in London with Jews not partici-
pating.
1947:
Jan. 27 — The Palestine conference re-
sumes after lengthy adjournment. Jews
are not taking part but conferring in-
formally with British.
Feb. 18 — Bevin announces Britain will
submit the Palestine problem to the
United Nations; calls for a special session
of the General Assembly.
May 15 — The U. N. General Assembly,
which had convened at Flushing Meadow
April 28, names a special committee on
Palestine to draw up recommendations by
Sept. 1.
July 18 — Refugee ship Exodus 1947,
with 4,500 aboard is captured by British
after fight and is later sent to a French
port, where the refugees refuse to land,
and then to Hamburg, where they are
removed.
July 29 — Jewish extremists hang two
British soldiers in reprisal for execution
of Jewish terrorists in Acre prison. Ten-
sion increases.
Sept. 1 — The U. N. Special Committee
presents report, with the majority recom-
mending (1) partition of Palestine into
Jewish and Arab states to become inde-
pendent by Sept. 1, 1949, (2) admission
of 150,000 refugees.
Sept. 26 — Britain announces decision
to end the mandate and withdraw all
British troops. Later the end of the
mandate is set for May 15.
Nov. 29— U. N. General Assembly
adopts partition plan of special committee
which had been accepted by the Jews but
rejected by the Arabs.
1948:
Feb. 24 — The U. N. Security Council
takes up the problem of how to enforce
partition against Arab opposition.
March 19 — Warren R. Austin, Ameri-
can delegate to the Security Council, an-
nounces a reversal of America's stand on
partition, asking suspension of the plan
and establishment of a temporary U. N.
trusteeship for Palestine.
April — Arab states threaten invasion
of Palestine as soon as the British with-
draw.
April 7 — U. N. attempts to get Arabs
and Jews to declare a truce. Jewish
forces continue recent victories over the
Arabs.
May 13 — Haganah takes over Jaffa
after Arabs declare it open city.
May 15 — The British mandate ends.
The Zionist state of Israel is proclaimed.
The United States recognizes the new
state.
Brooklyn
Jewish Center Review
Vol. XXIX MAY, 1948 — IYAR, 5708 No. 37
YISROEL CHAI!
ISRAEL lives! Surrounded by vindic-
tive enemies, drenched in the blood of
an unholy onslaught, struggling
against the cold indifference of half the
world and battling the calculated and
cynically sophistic policy of most of the
rest of the world — nevertheless, Israel
lives!
What is more, Israel lives now, not on
the sufferance of others but by reason of
its own might, purpose and strength.
The high gallantry of the Jewish soldier
in Palestine, sustained by the united de-
votion of the entire Yishuv is daily writ-
ing a story of heroism and military skill
which is winning the acclaim of everyone
whose values are not distorted by un-
reasoning partiality. Truly, David once
again fights Goliath. The seven member
nations of the Arab League are daily find-
ing more cause to regret the precipitancy
with which they sent their armies into
Israel. The British, we suspect, must be
finding it more necessary every moment
to stiffen the backs of these henchmen.
It may even be necessary for Mr. Bevin
to increase the $8,000,000. annual sub-
sidy to Abdullah for the Transjordan
Legion in order to induce these Arab
nomads to continue their losing battle.
Certainly, the Hagannah is forcing the
British to divert daily from the hard-
pressed British treasury more and more
of the funds loaned by America to
England for worthier purposes. That
expedition, originally envisaged by Brit-
ish and Arab strategists as a picnic jaunt
into a defenseless Israel for the collection
of loot and plunder — that demarche
fostered by British politicians as a means
of ending by force that which not all
the devious maneuvers of policy could
prevent — that projected throttling of
the infant Medina th, Israel, at borning
— all of these are being pulverized into
nothingness by the courage, strength and
skill of an army which at a modern
Armageddon is again battling for the
Lord and for righteousness.
Seldom in history has there been a
moment equal to this period of the re-
demption of Israel. Other nations have
been born, and some, even, have been
reborn, after short and temporary periods
of destruction. There is, however, no
real parallel to the re-emergence of the
Jewish State. Physically, it is an amaz-
ing fact that this tiny people, deci-
mated in the last generation alone to
an extent beyond the power of the mind
to comprehend, should be able, in the
space of a day, to attain statehood, par-
ticularly in the mad world of today.
Ideally, the creation of a Jewish State is
a lesson in the ultimate permanence of
justice. The roll of its oppressors is as
old as recorded history. Ancient Egypt
(and who knows, maybe even its modern
successor), the Assyria, Babylon, Rome,
Germany — their places in history are but
the shadows of yesterday. But Israel
lives! Medinath Israel is thus, in its cre-
ation, proof of the ancient challenge of
the Jew to all the world: K' M'Z/ow Tetse
Torab." From Zion, shall go forth
Torah."
•
We American Jews, who are not in
Israel and thus are not part of the
physical struggle of our people, are never-
theless favored by history in that we see
in our day a fructification of the ancient
prayer of our people for redemption. We
shall find as time goes on that the vic-
tory of the Yishuv and the complete de-
velopment of Palestinian Jewish life will
be a boon to us in every phase of our
lives as Jews. Israel will again be a well-
spring whose sweet waters will freshen
and revive the cultural and spiritual life
of Jews throughout the diaspora. The
fact of a Jewish State will add immeasur-
ably to the pride and dignity of Jews
wherever they live. The ancient stigma
of homelessness will be removed, and with
it should end the taint of the gipsy that
has been to some great degree a contribut-
ing cause of anti-Semitism everywhere.
•
What of the bugaboo of divided al-
legiance, that convenient device of the
anti-Zionist? It is interesting to note
that the first pronouncement of the
Council for American Judaism at the
time of the proclamation of the Jewish
State on May 15th was an insistence upon
its own American patriotism. This was
an example of that consistency which
Emerson so rightly attributed to little
minds. No one has ever questioned the
American patriotism of Zionists except
the Council and its ilk and the lunatic
fringe of MacWilliams, Winrod, Pelley,
et als. Indeed, the functioning of Israel
in the Near East is in a very real sense a
triumph for the American spirit. Cer-
tainly, it will, in fact and in political im-
plications, widen of the sphere of opera-
tions for the American spirit. The same
qualities of living and thinking which
constitute the American pattern are ex-
plicit in the life and government of
Israel. Alone in the Near East (and, in-
deed, almost alone outside of the borders
of the United States), Israel will be a
(Continued on next page]
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway. Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Sreenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Goodstein, Treasurer Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthal, D.D., D.H.L, Rabbi Manuel Saltiman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewit+es, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
4
"JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES"
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
WITH GOODWILL OR WITHOUT
THIS is being written as the radio
is flashing the news from Eretz
Yisroel that the new Jewish State
has been proclaimed and is now an actual
fact. How fortunate we of this age are
— to have witnessed the dawn of a day
for which our fathers have hoped and
prayed for 1900 years!
Until the last moment we were ner-
vous, fearful, lest something might arise
to prevent the realization of our dream
and our hope. There were so many at-
tempts to thwart the fighters in their
task. What politics, what cruel diplo-
macy, what chicanery were practised by
those who endeavored to put an end to
the Jewish hope.
Alas, to our sorrow it must be said,
that the part our own beloved America
played in these crucial events — until a
few moments after the establishment of
Israel was proclaimed — did not add credit
to our country nor to our country's lead-
ership. Happily, however, America re-
deemed itself. I never lost faith in the
true America. I knew, in the dark weeks
of March and April, when America
seemed to have lost its way, that America
had not yet spoken the last word on Pal-
estine. The conscience of America may
be stifled for a moment, but it cannot be
stilled. And President Truman's instant
recognition of the State of Israel truly
represented the voice of the conscience
of America. We Jews have an ancient
Rabbinic tradition, that the Baal Teshu-
vah, the repentent sinner, stands even
higher than the saint who never sinned.
It requires more moral courage to ac-
knowledge one's wrong and to forsake
it. We look upon the Administration as
a Baal Teshuvab, and hope that it will
now prove its determination to undo the
wrongs of the past and, with its power,
help the infant State of Israel which it
has recognized to grow and to develop
into strength and maturity.
•
We are grateful to God that we have
lived to see this day. We are grateful
to our Heavenly Father for this miracle
of the ages which He has wrought. We
are proud of the Yishuv and, above all,
of the brave and heroic members of the
Haganah, who have proven themselves
true Maccabees of our day. They have
won a new respect for the Jew from the
peoples of the world. The nations be-
hold a new Jew in that new State — no
longer the cringing Jew, but the Jew
with a straight back, who knows his
rights and who is determined to stand
by his rights.
We realize, of course, that we have not
yet won our complete freedom. Like the
Pharoah of old, there will be those today
who will try to bring the Jews back to
the bondage of a modern Egypt. We
will yet have to cross the waters of a Red
Sea. But our brothers in the new Israel
are undaunted; they are confident in the
ultimate triumph of the justice of their
cause. And I am confident that Ameri-
can Jewry will not forsake them in this
historic hour. I know that the Jews of
America will be ready to give whatever
help will be in their power to preserve
what has now been achieved by the sweat
and the blood of our heroic brothers.
The leaders of Israel extended the hand
of peace and fellowship to the Arabs in
Palestine and in the neighboring countries.
This was not just a gesture. We pray
that this outstretched hand will be taken.
We hope, too, that the other nations,
and the United Nations, too, will soon
give the new Jewish State their recogni-
tion and their blessing. The days of
theorizing are past; the world is facing
an actuality which must be reckoned
with.
We plead and pray for peace and good
will. But whether that will be granted
us or not, the Jewish State has come to
life, and, with God's help, will remain
alive, endeavoring to serve to the world
as a holy nation dedicated to the lofty
purpose of making God's Law the guide
of its national life. We pray that the
prophecy may be fulfilled in our day:
"For out of Zion shall go forth the
Law, and the word of the Lord from
Jerusalem!"
democratic republic, based on the com-
plete equality of all peoples living with-
in its borders. It is a young nation
which, having had to fight for its inde-
pendence against the encroachment of
power politics, will all the more cherish
and guard the ideals and practices of real
democracy. In the short space of its pre-
paratory life, the Yishuv has given ample
proof of its high evaluation of education,
free economic opportunity and progres-
sive social attitudes . This it has managed
to do against the backwash of Arab medi-
evalism and feudalism and British ob-
structionism. Certainly, in the unhamp-
ered freedom of its own management,
will Israel continue and accelerate the
process. It is not too much to believe
that a functioning partnership between
the mighty United States and the infant
, CHAll
Israel in these departments of common
activity can speedily arise and long flour-
ish to the benefit of all the world.
There will, of course, be those, who for
shorter or longer periods will mouth the
accusation of dual citizenship against the
Jews of America. Let us not be disturbed
by this canard. The record of absolute
patriotism of the American Jew is as old
as this republic. It has been proved on
the field of battle and in every peaceful
aspect of American life. That the Jew
in America has sufficient spiritual re-
sources to be true not only to this coun-
try but to the land of his ancestors in the
past — which is now the land of hope for
so many people, Jew and non-Jew alike —
is certainly not a reproach to the Ameri-
can Jew.
— William I. Siegel.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
An Eminent American Jew and Zionist
Points to the Road We Should Follow
THE FUTURE OF AMERICAN JEWRY
NOW
WE LIVE in apocalyptic times.
So strange and swift and over-
whelming is the march of his-
tory, so ineffable its tragedies, so tense
and electric its triumphs, that all speech
has become difficult and all prognostica-
tion vain. Does it not seem just the
other day that there was revealed to us
the full and awe-inspiring horror of the
destruction of one-third of our people in
Eastern and Central Europe? Did there
not appear just yesterday that immortal
volume of fragments from the dead and
the survivors, edited by Charney Niger,
and called Kiddusb Ha-Sbem? And time
is swift and the memory of the individual
not very tenacious and there is a danger
that men may forget to grasp as a single
movement of history both the dread de-
struction arid the proclamation and rec-
ognition of the Medinath Yisracl — the
state, our state, called Israel.
Yet nothing can be surer than that
the historic process is continuous and is
one. The Jewish State arose out of the
ashes of our slain; it arose from the un-
answerable necessity that this must not
happen again. We know that the Yisbuv
might again and again have bought pros-
perity and apparent security had it been
willing to confine itself to approximately
its present numbers. Yet no member of
the Yishuv, older or younger, galuth-
born or sabra (native-born) dreamed
even for a moment of accepting that bar-
gain and that easiest way. No one. No
single soul. The homeland was to be a
homeland for all Jews. For that our
brethren fought; for that they pro-
claimed the state of Israel; for that they
are embattled on three fronts today; for
that they are defying the powers and
principalities of evil. For that so many
beautiful young lives are being offered
up with eagerness and grace. For that
and that alone.
They face and will continue to face —
for not too long, we pray — a hundred
difficulties and dangers. But they do in-
deed face them. Their road is straight.
Doubt or confusion are spared them.
Amid all dangers that is their supreme
good fortune. Never in all history, to
vary a phrase of Winston Churchill, have
so few fought so magnificently and
single-mindedly for the redemption of so
many — for the remnants in Europe, for
those in the Muslim lands, morally, too
for us and for our children. Their faces
are set toward the light.
Our situation, the situation, above all,
of Jews in America, is or should be
equally clear; the road ahead of us should
be equally straight. Yet there is a deep
difference and cleavage — the difference
and cleavage between being victim and
victor and only witnessing from afar
both the sacrifice and the victory. While
our people were dying and being born
again, we were able to continue our more
or less normal lives with a more or less
normal preoccupation with secondary and
second-rate things. We had to rely
wholly on the promptings of the heart
and the exercise of the imagination. And
it may be said that, considering this vital
disadvantage, American Jewry or at least,
large sections of American Jewry, came
off very well indeed.
•
Now the great and immediate problem
for American Jewry today is not to let
sloth invade the heart and not to let the
imagination cease to be exercised. On
the material side the danger is probably
small. It will be clear to men in a highly
industrialized and business civilization
that a community of 750,000 cannot pay
for a total war and at the same time
house and feed and heal the remnants
who are even now streaming into the
land. It will be clear to these American
Jews that any cessation of intensely sac-
rificial giving would today and tomor-
row — literally today and tomorrow — ex-
pose the State of Israel and its people to
unpredictable disaster and us and our
children to perpetual moral slavery and
perpetual shame. It is not to be thought
of that the Jews of America will not con-
tinue to realize with the utmost intensity
that without money you can buy neither
arms nor food nor shelter and that with-
out us those beautiful armies in our land
and those whom they protect and redeem
would be delivered up naked and help-
By LUDWIG LEWISOHN
less to a barbarous enemy. That aspect
of our road ahead is clear.
Our difficulties arise from our inter-
nal situation. The political aims of the
Jewish people, identical with that im-
memorial aspiration for the cheruth, the
freedom of Israel, of which the liturgy
speaks — these aims have been achieved.
The various Zionist organizations will re-
move the Basel platform from their
letter -heads. The Jewish Agency is in
a necessary state of liquidation; the
World Zionist Organization will have to
be transformed into a non-political in-
strumentality. Well, it may be asked,
what difficulties are involved? The an-
swer is this: We live in a politically
minded and in a materially minded civil-
ization and atmosphere. It is precisely
the political work and struggle after free-
dom and a state that captured the heart
and the imagination of the best part of
American Jewry. The giving of money
to the State and those whom it must
defend and harbor and house will con-
tinue to be understood. But what, mean-
while, will become of us — of our inner
relationship to Israel, of our moral situa-
tion when the great incentive of the at-
tainment of freedom and of a state will
have been wholly achieved?
For Judaism and Zionism — the two are
historically identical — will have to return
to spiritual and moral sources. It will
have lost the lift and ardor of political
aims and political involvement. Galuth
Jewry, American Jewry, profoundly as it
will and must be devoted to the Republic
of Israel, will become, must become, de-
spite its partaking of both peoplehood
and ethnic homogeneity, a spiritual, a
moral, an intellectual community — held
together no more by a political aim but
by its millenial aspiration towards becom-
ing a viamlcchet kohanim v'goy kadosb,
[Continued on page 23]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
6
>
CHAIM TCHERNOWITZ
AT 75
By JACOB S. MINKIN
JEWISH scholars writing in Hebrew-
must resign themselves in advance to
the likelihood that all avenues of
European and American renown will be
closed to them. Few Hebrew productions
of genuine Jewish scholarship are trans-
lated into other languages. It is now
more than half a century since the last
volume of Isaac Hirsch Weiss' stupendous
"History of Jewish Tradition" appeared,
and all we have in English of its great
erudition and marvellous scholarship is a
short essay by the late Professor Solomon
Schechter. Other works of like impor-
tance to students of Jewish history and
literature have not fared better. Non-
Jewish scholars working in the same field
rarely take notice of them — not even
through a footnote.
When, therefore, Professor Chaim
Tchcrnowitz, at an advanced age, with
breathless industry and his eyes fixed on
the unwavering goal, continues adding
one learned book after another to his al-
ready impressive list, it is because of his
love of learning and his devotion to
Torah, which kept Judaism alive through
the ages. He works with the zeal and
self-consuming devotion that would do
credit to one much younger than his
years. In a period of less than fifteen
years, he enriched Jewish literature with
a steady flow of works which are as
astounding for their scholarship as for
their beauty and freshness of style and
diction. And this quite apart from his
many other activities, such as a busy
teaching schedule at the Jewish Institute
of Religion and a Hebrew monthly
periodical, Bifzaron, of which he is not
only editor but principal contributor as
well.
Prof. Tchernowitz's position in the
world of scholarship is unique. It would
be unique at any time, but it is espe-
cially so today, when learning among
Jews has become pedantic, and scholar-
ship, instead of interpreting and serving
life, is being pursued as a means of es-
caping it. It is to the eternal credit of
The Eminent
Hebrew Scholar
and Editor
Chaim
Tchernowitz
Dr. Tchernowitz that, in these disturbed
and crucial days for Jews, he grasped the
true significance of the Jewish scholar's
task and mission. He has lived in more
than two generations and in widely-
separated lands and continents, has served
in the priesthood of Jewish scholarship
for a longer period than many another
Jewish savant living, yet never has he
been known to have lost contact with
the living Jewish people. In this respect,
he is perhaps the finest exemplification of
the Russian rather than the German type
of Jewish scholar. Unlike so many others
of his learned colleagues, Prof. Tcherno-
witz lives the daily life of his people,
fighting their battles, sponsoring their
causes, and giving himself to their every
interest with unsparing zeal and devotion.
Besides his books and learning, Prof.
Tchernowitz is a spiritual personality of
a rare kind. He is not the frozen or
crusty type of scholar, not the man from
whom books and learning have drained
every other human interest. On the con-
trary, he is kind and amiable, genial and
warm-hearted, a man of feeling and senti-
ment, whose conversation on all subjects
is both stimulating and animated, par-
ticularly on matters affecting Jews. In
his life there is no blank page between
the book and the people, between the
Jews' past and their present and future.
Dr. Tchernowitz has made many valuable
contributions to Jewish science, but it is
his devotion to the Jews as a living people
that is the most characteristic feature of
all his thinking and doing.
The conception of the Jews as a living
people cannot be sufficiently emphasized.
If Prof. Tchernowitz did not create this
conception, he is certainly one of its
greatest exponents, especially in the field
of what became known as "Jewish
Science," or, to give it its proper desig-
nation, Wissenschaft des Judentutns.
Jewish Wissenschaft was born in a Prus-
sian atmosphere and it bore the Prussian
label. Its origin did not stem from the
conviction of a Jewish national ideal, a
spiritual thread that would unite the past
and present, but it came as a means of
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
7
severing that thread, of disavowing what
real or mystic relation existed between
the Jews as a dead and as a living entity.
Even Zachariah Frankel, who stood closer
to the Jewish spirit than many of his
Wissenschaft fellow-workers, did not
hesitate to call upon the Jews of Germany
to surrender what national hopes and
aspirations they may have entertained as
a thanks-offering for the removal of their
civil disabilities. Professor Moritz Stein-
schneider, whom his American enthusiasts
crowned as the "Urim and Thummim" of
Jewish scholars, had not concerned him-
self with the Jews as a living people. He
hated Jewish nationalism, condemned Dr.
Pinsker's Autoemancipation, and stigma-
tized Zionism as a kind of "folk-psychosis
which could be cured only gradually by
systematic education."
•
There is a breath of Jewish life in
everything Dr. Tchernowitz writes, a
quickening national spirit not only in his
lighter essays and articles but also in his
more serious scientific work. His books
are not the cold memorial tablets of the
dead as are the works of so many another
Jewish scholar. They are the product of
a living, loving and creative Jewish mind.
The thread is continuous and unbroken;
his work reaches far back into the past,
illuminating the present, and propheti-
cally looking toward the future. It is a
heritage which he received at his birth,
but which was acutely sharpened and de-
veloped by his association with the
thinkers and poets famous as the Sages
of Odessa, who made up the Jewish in-
tellectual world more than half a century
ago. The great historian Graetz had the
same quality of genius and wrote in the
same spirit. In his work too the Jewish
national soul was never dead or frozen.
He conceived of the Jews as a living peo-
ple and wrote about them with exquisite
beauty and eloquence, something for
which his Wissenschaft colleagues had
never forgiven him. Zunz, for instance,
scorned Graetz and refused any other
comment on his "History" than a frown
and, as to Steinschneider, Graetz was his
pet aversion.
Dr. Tchernowitz is unique in still an-
other way. He writes in the Hebrew
language, and in a style so clear and lucid
that it is impossible not to understand
him. It is the tragedy of our modern
Jewish scholars that they separated Jew-
ish literature from the language in which
it was written. Hoping in vain to catch
the attention of a non-Jewish savant, they
write in almost all the alphabets and
vocabularies of the world except in the
one language in which Jewish scholarship
eternally has its being. In his earlier, less
rationalistic days, when the romance of
the Jewish national spirit had not yet be-
come completely dried up within him,
Professor Steinschneider pleaded with his
colleagues not to occidentalize everything
Jewish by writing in foreign languages
on Jewish subjects. "The holy tongue,"
he said, "must remain the international
language of Jewish scholarship." But it
was not very long before he forgot his
youthful enthusiasm for Hebrew and
adopted the German language for the
Prof. Tchernowitz and a Group of
Associates at the Odessa Yeshiva
great learned literature he had single-
handed created.
Dr. Tchernowitz may also be said to
be unique for his perennial spring of liv-
ing, creative power which, despite his
years and active life, shows no signs of
exhaustion. He is a man of tireless energy
and prodigious industry. As if born to
the task, there is no place for leisure in
his life. Day by day and deep into the
night, the pen never rests idle in his hand.
Visiting friends find him either working
on a new manuscript or correcting proof
which must be rushed off to the printer.
The condition is chronic. It is the same
in summer as in winter, whether at home
or on his vacation. He never works on
one subject at a time. There are always
interruptions. For Dr. Tchernowitz is
not a hermit living and working in a cell.
His study is not padlocked against the
noise and tremor of his time. A thou-
sand eyes are always peering over his
shoulders. They may be those of his peo-
ple in the concentration camps of Europe
or of those in their frenzied fight for life
in Palestine. They cannot wait. Their
struggle, their suffering, their future —
our future — may be in jeopardy. The
book, the manuscript, the proof-sheets
can wait. A ringing call to action is
rushed off to the press.
He has a huge appetite for work.
Every morning witnesses in his study a
new battle. It may be an intricate tal-
mudic problem, a question of rabbinic
law that is to be solved and decided, or
a subject of current popular interest.
And all this besides the pressure of many
other obligations. For, as already re-
marked, Dr. Tchernowitz is not exclu-
sively a man of the book. He is su-
premely a man of the people. In addition
to his literary and scholarly work, there
are meetings, conferences, and consulta-
tions to attend. The pulse of current
Jewish life and problems is very much
alive and active in his veins. He is per-
haps the nearest approach to the Jewish
ideal of the scholar-patriot, whose love,
whose life and interests are divided be-
tween his books and his people, between
his study and the fighting arena. It is
no unfamiliar experience to behold this
long-passed septagenerian scholar stroll in
on a conference of Jews of whatever
party shading and humbly take his place
as one of the people.
Dr. Chaim Tchernowitz came to Jew-
ish scholarship fully and richly equipped.
He was a disciple of great masters, a stu-
dent and associate of famous men. Rabbi
Yitzhak Elhanan of Kovno was one of
them. Later, his mastery of rabbinic lit-
erature was broadened and deepened by
the scientific researches of the modern
school. He might have become a crusty
and musty scholar of the traditional type
were it not his good fortune to fall under
the influence of that unique gathering of
men whom Tchernowitz himself had im-
mortalized as Hakme Odessa, the Sages
of* Odessa. They stirred in him feelings,
sentiments, and interests which were
never crowded out in the course of years.
They also aroused in him that love for
Zion and the Jewish people which re-
mained the crowning inspiration of his
life.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
8
Dr. Tchernowitz is a prolific writer.
Besides his major works, he has to his
credit a harvest of no less than 250 con-
tributions that appeared in a great variety
of learned and popular publications in
Europe, Palestine, and this country. His
occasional writings seem to be dashed off
with great ease and little effort. At any
rate, their style and diction fail to betray
the sweat and toil of composition. On
the other hand, his more permanent con-
tributions, such as, for instance, his
ToJdot ha-Halakdy History of the Oral
Law, are masterpieces of scientific schol-
arship and accuracy, and were written
with great care and deliberation. Not
only the text, but almost every footnote
is packed with a mass of scholarship
which testifies to the author's learning
and intimate grasp of his subject.
•
It is characteristic of Prof. Tcherno-
witz's prodigious industry that, at an age
when most men try to lighten their bur-
dens, he should venture upon a task both
daring and stupendous, requiring tremen-
dous labor and scholarship of the most
precise sort. But he not only dared and
ventured but actually completed the task
which, for its clarity and learning, for its
novelty and freshness of style and dic-
tion, is unequaled in Jewish literature.
We have, of course, reference to his re-
cently published three-volume work,
Toldot ha-Poskim, "History of the Jew-
ish Legal Codes and Codifiers."
It is a stupendous work which, in less
expert hands than his, might not have
rewarded the toil and labor of a lifetime.
No brief summary of so comprehensive
a work can be here undertaken. For that
a more detailed study is required. Suffice
it to say that it covers a period of rabbinic
legislation of about fifteen hundred years,
from the completion of the Babylonian
Talmud until almost the present day. The
author takes his readers on a long but, on
the whole, fascinating journey through
almost all the places of the then Jewish
habitation. We find ourselves one time
in the congenial atmosphere of Babylonia
with its great men and schools of learn-
ing; another time in the sun-splashed spa-
cious North Africa, immortalized for
Jews by its distinguished men of learn-
ing; at another time we are in the fading
glory that was Spain, or landing for a
long while at Safed, in Upper Galilee, that
ancient marvellous city of scholars, mys-
tics and holy men, where the overshadow-
ing Sbulhan Aruk was conceived and
born; there are occasional stop-overs in
Russia and Poland, likewise famous in
other times and under different conditions
for their great and saintly men. We meet
everywhere with great men, giant intel-
lects, knights of the Torah, such as Rav
Hai Gaon, Rav Saadyah Gaon, Alfasi,
Maimonides, Nahmanides, R. Asher,
Joseph Cairo — one and all passionately
devoted to Judaism, loving their people,
giving their all and spending their all that
both might live and not disappear. It is
SHEVUOTH has developed a number
of customs and ceremonies which
symbolize the agricultural and religious
significance of the holiday. Originally
it was the feast of harvest, when baskets
of fruits were carried to Jerus'alem in
procession from the remotest corners of
the land. The memory of the agricultural
origin of the holiday has been kept alive.
The practice of decorating the synagogue
with plants and flowers is first mentioned
in Safed in the 14th century. We know
that in the seventeenth century it was
the custom for the sexton of the syna-
gogue to distribute plants to every wor-
shipper during the morning service. In
Eastern Europe bundles of fresh grass
were scattered over the floor, and many
homes were decorated with flowers.
The agricultural character of Shevuoth
was in time replaced by one of an his-
torical significance, symbolizing it as the
day of the giving of the Torah. As time
went on certain liturgical hymns were in-
cluded in the service, which dealt mainly
with the wonders of Revelation. Through
the influence of the Kabbalah, the cus-
tom arose of remaining awake through
the first night of the festival and reading
a book, entitled "Tikkun Lei Shevuoth."
This work contains selections from the
Pentateuch, prophets, the Hegiographa
and other sources. According to the in-
terpretations given by popular lore, the
custom of staying awake is explained as
follows: God revealed himself on Mount
Sinai at noon. But it happened that the
Israelites were still asleep, and Moses had
to go to their tents and wake them up.
a great work, great in its conception and
execution, and great also for clear, or-
derly, and masterly presentation which
make the reading of it both a profitable
and pleasurable experience.
At seventy-five, Prof. Tchernowitz's
flame of life still mounts high. He glows
with work and vitality. The Jews have
need of him. They have need of his cour-
age, his vision, his devotion, and his un-
extinguishable faith in their future. He
has been a torch unto them. May he
live for many more years to behold his
dream of a restored Israel come true.
The Jews therefore, stay awake on She-
vuoth eve to show that there is no need
to wake them to study the Torah.
In the Middle ages parents adopted a
custom of introducing the boy to school
on Shevuoth. The ceremony of initiation
was performed partly in the school and
partly in the synagogue. Early in the
morning the child was brought to the
synagogue and placed in the pulpit before
the scroll, from which the Ten Com-
mandments were read. The early leaders
of Reform Judaism selected Shevuoth as
the day of confirmation, because it is the
holiday of the confirmation of the Jewish
people in their faith by Moses. It is also
the day on which the Book of Ruth is
read in the synagogues, telling of Ruth's
acceptance into the fold of Israel. The
conservative synagogue introduced the
consecration ceremony for girls.
The prevalent custom of eating dairy
dishes on Shevuoth is of ancient origin.
It is associated with the expression found
in the Bible comparing the Torah to milk
and honey. Another reason is given: the
Jews returned to their tents from the
foot of Mount Sinai very tired and hun-
gry; they could not wait until the women
prepared a meat meal so they rushed to
eat whatever dairy products were avail-
able. Honey was also an important in-
gredient in the preparation of the She-
vuoth dairy dishes because the Torah is
often compared to honey. A cake was
prepared of fine flour, oil, milk and honey
and on its surface several biblical passages
were inscribed. This cake was given to
children.
SHEVUOTH CUSTOM
By LEO SHPALL
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
An Alumnus of Distinguished Parent-
hood Calls Forth Nostalgic Memories
AS I REMEMBER THE CENTER
HEBREW SCHOOL
SEVERAL weeks ago I visited the
synagogue of the Society for Ad-
vancement of Judaism out of curi-
osity to see how the Reconstructionist
service differs from our own Conservative
services. After the reading of the torah
I realized that the cantor was strangely
familiar to me and soon I remembered
who he was. He was our old Hebrew
School singing teacher, Mr. Moshe Na-
thanson. His voice and his face had
hardly changed during the twenty-year
interval since last I saw him. After the
services we chatted, and it seemed like a
dream — those long forgotten Hebrew
School years.
I can hardly believe that more than
twenty years have slipped by since I was
a student at the school — and I use the
word figuratively, not literally. So much
has happened since that warm humid
night when we received our diplomas that
probably few of us have had the time to
pause and look back.
In looking back on those old Hebrew
School days I will not linger in the pre-
historic times when Mr. Louis J. Gribetz
(the very same gentleman who now,
amongst other endeavors, heads the
Editorial Board of the Review) and
Mr. Joshua Goldberg (now Commander
Joshua Goldberg, the Ranking Jewish
Chaplain of the U. S. Navy) conducted
classes in rooms located on the ground
floor, at a point somewhere opposite the
present day handball courts. But let me
recall those years which I remember best,
1926-29. Our faculty, headed by the
genial Mr. Mordecai Halevi, included the
saintly Mr. Benjamin Hirsh, Mr. Eman-
uel Edelstein, Mrs. J. Serbin Beder, a Miss
Rappaport and our popular singing in-
structor, Mr. Nathanson.
Each teacher had his own method and
his own devices to convert us into
talmida chacbumim, but some worked
better than others. Naturally, as we
grew from children of ten years to men
and women of twelve and thirteen, the
teaching methods also changed. One of
the earliest memories I have of the school
is the speed reading contest which Mr.
Halevi conducted from time to time to
see how fast his pupils could read aloud
from a page of Hebrew which we had not
ever read before. I cannot explain how
I remember that one of the boys banged
out an amazing one hundred and eighty-
four words per minute. His name — and
it's strange that I can remember him so
well — was Seymour Freed, a blondish red-
faced youngster who always wore a happy
smile. Seymour lived on Empire Blvd.
as did the runner-up, Rosalind Kramer.
According to the rules of the game, each
error cost the contestant one word from
his actual score. I recall that I was a
plodding but thorough reader whose only
claim to fame was that not one error
was ever charged against me. At the time
few of us understood the importance of
being able to read Hebrew as fast as the
Lucky Strike auctioneer can rattle off the
buyer's bids, but three years ago I learned
my lesson.
I was in Calcutta for the Passover
seder and was the guest (along with sev-
eral other American, Australian, Cana-
dian and British soldiers — and even a
South African Jew) of Rev. Abdul Mor-
ris, the city's only rabbi. He chanted
from the Hagada at a pace so rapid that
we could follow the text only by watch-
ing him turn the page. He was of Per-
sian descent and his Oriental inflection
and pronunciation made matters all the
worse for his audience. Suddenly his
daughter Queenie, who happened to be
the most capable stenographer at our
American air base, reminded her father
that "Levee," as I was known, was the
son of a rabbi and should be allowed to
read a passage or two. Rev. Morris
turned to me and graciously offered the
choice paragraphs describing the Four
Sons — the good and the bad sons, the sim-
ple son, and the poor fellow who didn't
know enough to even ask a question.
After several moments of slow and de-
liberate reading I looked up and caught
his scornful and puzzled look. I'll never
know, but it was my impression at the
time that he was struggling with the de-
cision as to whether I typified the third
or the fourth son.
By LAZAR E. LEVINTHAL
Another classmate who stands out
vividly was a tall likeable kid who was
undoubtedly better liked by his classmates
than his teachers. (But this statement
could apply equally well to the rest of
us.) Little did we then realize that he
was to spend many months as a German
prisoner of war, after being shot down
on a bombing mission with our Eighth
Air Force. His name — Irwin Witty. I
shall never forget the time Irwin went
into the wardrobe closet of our class-
room to get something from his overcoat
pocket just before class was to have be-
gun. Someone playfully closed the door
on poor Irwin a moment before Mr.
Hirsh, our teacher, came in. Either be-
cause he was too embarrassed to call out,
or because Irwin was quite content to re-
main in the dark closet he stayed there
without uttering a sound. The class was
convulsed at the thought of his predica-
ment and Mr. Hirsh soon realized that
something was up. A quick glance
around the room gave him a clue. Witty,
as Mr. Hirsh was wont to call him, was
not in his seat. Following the direction
of our gaze he headed straight for the
closet and to everyone's amusement but
Irwin's, pulled Irwin from the dark re-
cess. It was several minutes before the
class was ready to resume the study of
irregular verbs.
•
Although Mr. Hirsh was a man whom
we genuinely loved, we were undoubt-
edly too young to fully appreciate his
remarkable mind and saintly character.
I am happy to say that before his un-
timely passing, our class had outgrown
the period of childhood, and as young
men and young women we were able to
show him our mature admiration, love
and respect. Even the good students felt
guilty when they met him later in their
lives — guilty that they had not been bet-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
ter students. I can remember no one dur-
ing my entire childhood who could tell a
story as well as he did, and on those Sat-
urdays when we knew Mr. Hirsh was
to preach the "sermon" everybody made
a special effort to be there early.
The faculty, I might add, served not
only as teachers during the week, but
they were the guiding spirits behind the
Junior Congregation. Each Saturday
morning one of the three regular teachers
would deliver the talk to the congrega-
tion. Mr. Edelstein and Mr. Hirsh re-
told the story of the bible and colorfully
pointed out the moral to be derived.
They wanted to make better children of
us. Mr. Halevi, on the other hand, had
a different outlook. He was first the
Hebrew School teacher and as such he
strove not to make us better children,
but better pupils. Often he would start
in the usual pattern, telling us the story
of the weekly portion, but always he
came back to the Hebrew School and
those responsible for the acts of sabotage
which occurred daily. These acts were
not only gratifyingly varied but at times
fiendishly clever. Most popular among
the student pranks was the blackout.
Some student who may not have had the
aptitude to master his chumhh or gem-
morah was bright enough to discover that
all the lights on the third floor were con-
trolled from a central fuse box. From
the date of that discovery, Hebrew teach-
ing was never the same at the Center.
•
As I remember, the brightest student
in our class, and perhaps in the entire
school during this period was young
Morty Ostow (now Dr. Ostow, special-
izing in psychiatric disorders, and the
husband of a charming young girl whom
I just recently met). Morty grasped
Hebrew as readily as he did algebra,
chemistry and chess, which accounted for
the fact that he probably won more
scholastic awards than any other Center
graduate. "We had quite a few bright stu-
dents, Rosalind Kramer, Sidney Weiner,
Albert Edelman and Dinah Hirsh, just
to name a few. Albert, by the way, was
formerly on the staff of Special Attorney
General John Harlan Amen, who was ap-
pointed some years ago to conduct a spe-
cial investigation of the Kings County
District Attorney's Office. I might fur-
ther add that Abbie (as he was then
known) had one of the finest voices in
the class and was one of the best cantors
in our junior congregation. "We needed
him badly as a replacement for another
fine singer who was in the process of out-
growing the Junior congregation, Joe
Greenblatt, now known as Joseph Green-
lief. Joe lives in Mt. Vernon, N. Y., and
is a very active worker in the Zionist
Organization and a member of the Ex-
ecutive Board. I would say that Joe was
the finest cantor the Junior Congregation
had during the years 1926-1932. I am
not qualified to speak for the years fol-
lowing because it was at this time that I
left to attend college.
•
Genetically, there must be something
about a Hebrew teacher that brings forth
the brightest qualities in children. I can-
not otherwise explain the fact that the
children of our teachers were all unusu-
ally fine students. Mr. Hirsh's daugh-
ter, Dinah, was in my class and was al-
ways at the top. (When last heard from
Dinah was one of the writers on the staff
of Newsweek and received special praise
from the publisher for an article she
wrote on the G. I. Bill of Rights. I re-
member this because I first read the
praise, which appeared in an issue pub-
lished after her article appeared, and I
scoured the Red Cross Clubs from Cal-
cutta to Karachi to find the article. I
did find it, and it was well worth the
effort.) Mr. Halevi's son, whom we
called Mussie, would occasionally pay the
class a visit. He was much younger
than we were but would good-naturedly
help us with our lessons. Mr. Edelstein's
son was also a bright student both in
Hebrew and secular subjects, and also
seemed to be made of the stuff of Quiz
Kids.
When some of us reached manhood and
were bar-mitzvahed, it was assumed by
us that our Hebrew education was com-
plete, and perhaps fatalistically concluded
that whatever could not be learned in the
first thirteen years wasn't worth learning.
Because of this, many a parent gave up
the fight and let their sons leave the
school. The result was a dislocation of
the student body, and sometimes it was
necessary, for the convenience of the fac-
ulty, to consolidate several classes, or
parts thereof. The result was not always
to the student's liking, as in the case of
one Lester Prensky, who to this day looks
back with bitterness to the day he was
told that because of his good work he
would be placed in a Rapid Advance sec-
tion. When class met for the first day
of the new term, Lester discovered that
his "promotion" actually put him back
two semesters. It was only recently that
he poured out to me this story of
injustice.
An account of the early days of the
Hebrew School would not be complete
unless it brought back the warm mem-
ories we all have of our Mr. Mueller. He
was the uniformed policeman assigned by
the Holmes Protective Service to the main
lobby of the Center. He loved children,
and although his duties often made it
necessary to subject us to discipline and
order, he did so in such a kindly way
that I'm sure every former pupil experi-
enced a moment of deep sadness when
he learned of Mr. Mueller's death some
time ago.
* * *
Those were rich years and they were
happy years. Time has tip-toed by so
softly that it is oftentimes difficult to
realize we are no longer the children we
were. It would be nice for us to meet
again someday soon, and when we do I
look forward to joining again in the sing-
ing of Techizachnah, our Hebrew School
song, led by our former teacher, Cantor
Nathanson.
Stephen Wise once engaged in a de-
bate with a man who made a very long
speech.
Dr. Wise's response was: "I agree with
the gentleman in all but two points: his
premises are false and his conclusions
erroneous."
It is related of the late Sol Levitan,
who was quite a political figure in Wis-
consin in the days of the elder La Follette,
that once the candidate opposing Uncle
Sol for the state treasuryship made what
amounted to an anti-Semitic speech. In
this address, he particularly stressed the
"stinginess" of Jews.
When Sol got up, he said that he would
have to agree with the opposing candidate
in much that he said, then wound up.
"Elect me, a stingy man, as your State
Treasurer, and I won't squander any of
your money."
He was elected.
—By J.T.A.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
II
A Guide to Those Who Wish to Live
According to the Laws of Our Faith
THE PROBLEM OF JEWISH LAWS
OUR distinguished colleague and
neighbor, Rabbi Jacob Levinson,
who already has to his credit a
number of notable Hebrew works, has
recently published an interesting collec-
tion of T's/mvot* — legal responsa — deal-
ing with many problems of Jewish ritual.
Unlike so many such works, which
deal mostly with problems not at all re-
lated to current life, Rabbi Levinson, as
he indicates in his apt title, does deal
with matters in due season, matters which
are of great concern to Jews of our day
who want to live in consonance with the
laws of our faith. Thus, for example,
he renders legal opinions on such ques-
tions as whether we may dispense with
the individual recitation of the prayers
and fulfil our duty by listening to the
Cantor's rendition alone — particularly in
the case of the Musaf prayer; whether it
is permissible to call one to recite the
blessings of the Torah, as we do in our
Center Synagogue, by just saying Ya-
amod Ha-kohen, or Ya-amod Ha-Levi,
"Let the priest come forward," or "Let
the Levite come forward," or whether
one must be called by his and his father's
name — as was and as is the custom in
the old synagogues; whether or not it is
obligatory to have a Bimah — a reading
desk — in the center of the Synagogue, in
addition to the pulpit stand near the Ark;
questions about the removal of the dead
from one grave to another, especially if
the deceased was buried by mistake in a
plot that belonged to another and the
latter refuses to dispose of that plot; the
problem of whether burial in a mausoleum
is permissible; whether the practice, now
in vogue in many synagogues, of dis-
tributing cards at a holiday service and
having them bent in to designate sums
donated in response to appeals, violates
Jewish law, and many other such ques-
tions — in fact, there are thirty-one such
responsa, all dealing with similar prob-
lems concerning the life of the pious and
observant Jew.
•
Rabbi Levinson, as those of us who
know him would expect, shows great
erudition and comprehensive knowledge
of the old authorities who dealt with Jew-
ish law. He writes in a clear, beautiful
Hebrew and in a lucid style, going direct
* Davar B'ito (A Word Spoken in Due Season) .
to his subject and avoiding all intricacies
in discussion. Again, unlike many who
write on such themes, he does not lose
himself in unnecessary argumentation,
and confines himself to a logical presen-
tation of the legal opinion.
The question, however, that must per-
force come to the mind of the reader of
these responsa is — what is the essential
word that must be spoken "In due season"
when we deal with the problem of Jew-
ish Law? Is it enough to follow the prin-
ciple current in the old Common Law —
stare dicisis — "look at the previous deci-
sions," or it is not essential to re-interpret
these old decisions because of new condi-
tions and thus make them living, vital
decisions which can direct and influence
the life of today? Rabbi Levinson him-
self, in his finely written introduction,
quotes the well-known statement in the
Talmud (Gittin 60 b) which would pro-
hibit putting legal decisions into written
form. There is great wisdom in that
statement, and it clearly reveals the lib-
eral outlook the ancient Rabbis had of
the whole concept of Jewish law.
•
Those Sages did not want the Law to
become fixed and frozen — and that is the
danger when once it is put into printed
form. They wanted it to grow, to de-
velop, to constantly take into account
new conditions, new demands from every
land and every age. We may indeed em-
phasize the words which our author
quotes from Rabbi Jacob Emden: "The
Talmud is not yet completed, nor will it
ever be completed. For all discussions of
the men wise in Torah, in every age, be-
come part of this inclusive Talmud. For
the search of the explanations or inter-
pretations of the commandments are
handed over to the wise of every gen-
eration!"
Rabbi Levinson senses this need. He
quotes the beautiful Midrash: "There
is not a day that passes in which the Holy
One Blessed Be He does not Mechadesh
By DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
Halachah — does not renew the Law in the
Heavenly Court (genesis Rabbah 64.4)."
What this Rabbi meant in the term
"Mechadesh Halachah" was not just repe-
tition of the law, but a renewal of the
law, finding a Chidush, something new,
in the old, which would make the old law
new again, fit it to the new conditions
of every new day in life.
That is the problem and the need that
faces all law, and particularly so Jewish
law.
•
This is not the place to go into a de-
tailed analysis of these decisions. A brief
reference to two or three will suffice for
our purpose. Let us take the very first
problem that our author poses. By the
way, he is not correct in stating that
Conservative congregations are either
planning or discussing the elimination of
individual recitation of the prayers in the
synagogue service. I cannot imagine
where he acquired this misinformation.
As far as I know even the most radical
reform congregation endeavors to encour-
age the individual worshipper to recite
the prayers. What has been done in some
Conservative congregations in America
is to adopt a practice in vogue in some
of the leading Orthodox congregations
in Great Britain, the dispensing of the
Cantor's repetition of the Musaf prayer,
except the early benedictions with the
Kedushah and the last few benedictions
and to have the congregation pray, in
silent recitation, that part of the service.
In Rabbi Levinson's discussion of this
problem he quotes sufficient authorities —
Maimonides included — for one with a lib-
eral outlook to make a very convincing
case for such a practice. But it requires
a liberal outlook, and above all, a daring
approach, to alter a practice in vogue, //
there is some authority of note upon
whose opinion or decision one can base
his liberal viewpoint.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
Or take Dr. Levinson's discussion of
how one is to be called to the Torah. His
main argument for retaining the old prac-
tice is that it helps to prevent the Jew
from forgetting his Jewish name. But
in all the congregations where the new
practice has been adopted, the Jewish
name of the person called, and his father's
name, are given in the Mi She-berach,
which the Reader chants after the Jew
recites his Torah blessings. Here again
one with a liberal viewpoint of the law
finds no difficulty to be a Mechadesh
HclacJxth, and to find in the old suffi-
cient warrant for the establishment of a
practice which only changes a custom but
does not affect a vital law.
An even clearer case is the one which
discusses the need to have the Bimah sta-
tioned in the center of the Synagogue so
that if the Synagogue is a large one every
worshipper is able to hear the reading of
the Torah. The precedent for this cus-
tom was created by the magnificent Syn-
agogue in ancient Alexandria. We are
told that it was so large and the congre-
gation so vast that the precentor had to
raise a flag as a signal to the congrega-
tion to respond Amen. But in the dis-
cussion our author quotes a great author-
ity who definitely states that where the
Synagogue is small, and worshippers can
hear the reading of the Law, the center
Bimah may be dispensed with. Surely,
enough legal warrant may be adduced to
prove that where, under modern archi-
tectural design and acoustic planning, the
reading can be heard it would not be a
breach of law to have the reading desk
placed near the pulpit.
I do not wish to imply that it is an
easy matter thus to solve all problems in
ritual or ceremonial practice that face us.
I speak only of those cases which offer
some legal warrant by past authorities
to make the Chiddmh. No one who rec-
ognizes the important role that Jewish
law plays in Jewish life would dare to
say that the ancient authorities should
be disregarded. They must still be our
guides. We must lean upon the teachers
of the past generations. No people can
separate itself from its own past. But
we must know how to utilize these an-
cient authorities so that by reinterpre-
tation their wisdom may guide us again
in our day.
That great American jurist, whose lib-
eral approach to American Constitutional
Law made him one of the most beloved
figures in our Supreme Court for more
than a generation — Oliver Wendell
Holmes, defined the true function of Law
when he declared: "The law, so far as
it depends on learning, is indeed, as it has
been called, the government of the liv-
ing by the dead. To a very considerable
extent no doubt it is inevitable that the
living should be so governed. The past
gives us our vocabulary and fixes the
limits of our imagination; we cannot get
away from it. There is, too, a peculiar
logical pleasure in making manifest the
continuity between what we are doing
and what has been done before. But the
present has a right to govern itself so
far as it can, and it ought always to be
remembered that historic continuity with
the past is not a duty, it is only a
necessity" (Gitlow vs. N. Y., 268 U. S.
6 52, 672; cf. Max Lerner, "The Mind
and Faith of Justice Holmes," p. 324).
That is the attitude which must be adopt-
ed toward the problem of Jewish Law,
that must become our guiding principle,
if we want Jewish Law to take on a new
lease on life and to become once more
a vital force in the everyday life of our
people. What Justice Holmes says in that
same decision about the framers of our
American Constitution may also be said
about our great Sages, the moulders of
Jewish Law: "The framers of the Con-
stitution were not creators of a document
but of a living organism — a people."
What the Jewish sages were anxious to
see preserved was a living organism — a
Jewish people — living according to the
ever life-giving precepts of the Torah.
•
But all this requires a change in atti-
tude, in approach, to the entire problem.
It requires a liberal viewpoint, what the
Talmud calls the Kocha D'hetera — "the
power, or the gift, that enables one to
permit rather than to prohibit." And the
Talmud is so liberal that it assures us
that this Kocha D'hetera Adif (Berachot
60 a), "this power, if one possesses it, is
the greater gift" — far greater, worthier,
than the Kocha D'issurin, the power al-
ways to prohibit, to forbid.
This is the spirit that animates the Tal-
mud, and that helped to make it a living
instrument in the life of our people. This
is the principle that guided the classic in-
terpreters of Jewish law in all ages, and
that made them the leaders pre-eminent
in their generation.
The entire matter is best summed up
in a striking statement of one of the great
sages of the Talmud. "Jewish laws," he
assures us, "will never be abolished, as it
is written Halichot Olam Lo, 'The ways,
the goings, of the world are His.' " Tal.
Jer. Megillah 1.5; cf. also T. B. Megillah
28b, Nidda 73a; Habakuk III.6.) There
is a deep mystic meaning in this comment.
The Rabbi connects the word Halachot
(laws) with the word Halichot (going,
making forward steps) ; both are derived
from the same root Halach — of going,
walking. In other words, this sage would
have us understand that Jewish laws will
never disappear so long as they retain
that inherent quality of Halichot, going
forward, of progressing and developing
with the march of time. For just as the
goings, the progressive steps of the world
are His, so, too, is the continuing growth
of Jewish Law the reflection of the Will
of God Himself. And it is particularly
interesting to note that the last tractate
of the Gemara in the Talmud closes with
this very illuminating comment — as if
the Sages wanted to impress upon us a
great truth: while the Gemara is con-
cluded, Jewish Law is not completed, but
is on the march with time just like the
Halichot Olam, the goings of the world.
•
Rabbi Levinson is deserving of our
thanks and congratulations for having
made the first important step in giving
us the "Word Spoken In Due Season."
He has grappled with living issues, with
problems that concern the life of the re-
ligiously observant Jew. We, who are
his friends and admirers, hope and pray
that he may be blessed with life, health
and strength — and also the vision — to be
able to take the next important step, and
to give us that word so needed today
which will show that our Halachot are
still linked with the Halichot Olam, that
Jewish Law properly applied to modern
life can guide us now as it guided our
people in the days of old.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
THE MEANING OF THE WORD
"ISRAEL"
By DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
The name given to the new Jewish State, Israel, has been the subject of
explanation and discussion. In the material presented beloiv, Rabbi Levinthal
gives the authentic derivation and Biblical and Rabbinic background of the
word, ami resolves the controversy regarding the interpretation of "Israel."
The name was given Jacob by a being assumed to be an angel with whom
he wrestled all night before extracting his blessing. The questions have been
asked why Jacob had to wrestle with the angel to obtain a blessing, and fyow
could a mortal vanquish an angel, presumed to be a representative of God.
These questions Dr. Levinthal answers with his usual erudition and spiritual
insight.
The opening article is an extract from a sermon preached by the rabbi as
long ago as 1926, and sIjows a surprising prop/jet ic quality; the second article
was written now as a supplementary note.
ISRAELITE was the name given by the
Angel of God Himself to Jacob, the
last of the patriarchs, and through him
to his descendants (compare the Rabbinic
dictum) : "All that happened to Jacob
happened also to his descendants." You
recall the story as told in the Bible, how
Jacob wrestled with the Angel and could
not be defeated, and how the Angel said
to him: "Thy name shall be called no
more Jacob, but Israel, for thou hast
striven with God and with men and thou
hast prevailed."
For the etymology of the word Israel
we must, therefore, properly understand
these words spoken to Jacob by the Angel.
It would appear that Yisroel is formed by
the union of two words: "Yisra," "he will
strive" or "he will fight," and "El," God.
Note that the verb in its retained form
is in the future tense. It, therefore, does
not refer to Jacob's struggle alone, but
to the struggle, the battle, that is to be
waged by his descendants. The Targum
Onkelos, the Aramaic translation that you
find at the side of your Hebrew text in
your Bibles, senses the deeper meaning
that is hidden in the Angel's words. It
translates "hn Elohiiu" not "with God"
but "Kodom Adouoi V'iin Gnvrayo" —
"Before God, with men." In other words,
an Israelite is a soldier, battling with men
before God for the ideals that are His.
The Rabbis grasped the true significance
of this name conferred upon Jacob. For
the Midrash tells us, in the name of Bar
Kappara, that "He who calls Jacob by the
name Jacob and not Israel violates a posi-
tive command;" and another Rabbi, not
so strict, says: "Israel may also be called
Jacob, but Jacob must ever be the Tofel,
the less important, while the name Israel
must ever be the Ikor, his principal di-
stinction. Now, if we recall this fact,
if we understand why the name Israel
was given unto us, our whole attitude
in life must change. We can be success-
ful Jews— Jacob — prosperous tradesmen
and business men. But that is the Tofel
— of the least importance. The Ikor, the
principal fact that we must remember, is
that we must be Israels — Princes before
God — warriors of God amongst men!
In other words, you can be a Jew and
yet not be an Israelite. Racially, you
may belong to us, but functionally — or
let us say, in its truest sense, religiously,
you may not fulfil your life-task. To
fufil that task you must be a battler in
behalf of all those ideals with which we
surround the name of God.
THIS verse, giving the explanations for
the name Israel, is one of the most
interesting in the whole Bible. The Bib-
lical text must not, in every instance, be
taken literally but must be read in the
light of the classic interpretations of the
Rabbis and other ancient translations in
order to be properly understood.
The Biblical text does not say that an
angel wrestled with Jacob. Literally,
the text reads: "And there wrestled a
man with him." The Rabbis say that this
mysterious man was the representative of
Esau, and Jacob had to wrestle with this
enemy all through the dark night until,
at the approach of dawn, he succeeded in
wresting a blessing from him.
The word Elohirn in this verse, "Thou
hast striven with Elohiiu," need not mean
God, but can also mean powers, mighty,
almost supernatural powers, against which
Jacob had to contend, and the verse
would therefore mean: "Thou hast striven
with powers and men, and thou hast pre-
vailed." The Septuagint, (Greek), and
the Vulgate (Latin) translations of the
Bible, render the verse: "Thou didst pre-
vail with God and thou shalt prevail
against men."
Maimonides is of the opinion that the
whole incident was a "prophetic vision,"
and other commentators likewise have in
all ages regarded the contest as symbolic,
the outward manifestation of the struggle
This, then, is our purpose, our func-
tion in life revealed to us in our name —
Israel!
within the patriarch between his lower
self and his nobler ideals, until he saw
his nobler self prevail.
Israel, then, is clearly a title of Victory
— Champion or Prince of God, Contender
for the Divine, Conquerer by strength
from Above.
Just for Fun
DESPITE the grimness of present events
in Palestine, the Yishuv has not for-
gotten how to laugh. It reflects all
phases of the struggle. One story is a
commentary on the Arabs' tendency to
minimize their losses in their battles
against the Jews. The story goes that in
a recent engagement with the Haganah,
the Arabs lost fifty men.
These fifty Arab dead knocked at the
gate of heaven. The Mufti had promised
the Arabs that if any of them fell in
battle with the Jews, they would be
granted unconditional admittance into
Paradise, but when the Arabs came to
the Heavenly door, only eight were al-
lowed to enter.
"Why cannot we get in?" chorused the
others, "we, too, fell in the battle with
the Jews."
"Sorry," they were told. "The report
we have from the Arab Higher Com-
mittee shows that only eight Arabs were
killed in that engagement."
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
HADOAR" ON RABBI LEVINTHAL
The following article appeared as
an editorial in "Hadoar," written by
its editor to honor Dr. Israel H.
Levinthal on his sixtieth birthday.
DR. LEVINTHAL'S personality does
not admit of partisanship or fac-
tionalism. By his very tempera-
ment, he is the impartial pursuer of peace,
the harmonizer who brings unity out of
division.
Having received his training from his
father, Dov Aryeh Ha-Kohen, dean of
Orthodox Rabbis in America, Dr. Levin-
thal's life and work reflect the indelible
imprint of his father's guidance.
He conceives of American Jewry as a
unified whole in whose vitality and fu-
ture he has unbounded confidence. For
many decades he has preached a Jewish
way of life, nationalism, Zionist redemp-
tion and the creation of cultural values
in the national language of our people,
Hebrew. He is one of the loyal friends
of the Hebrew language and literature
in America, for his is a sincere love for
the sacred tongue of the Jewish people.
He enthusiastically greets all efforts on
behalf of Hebrew, willingly doing his
share and lending his influential support.
This love for Hebrew also comes by
inheritance from his father, who was one
of the pioneers of spoken Hebrew in
America and who, to this very day, en-
hances many of our conferences and gath-
erings with his eloquent Hebrew speeches.
For this reason, Dr. Levinthal was one
of the very first to respond to the
Hadoar's appeal for help at the beginning
of its career, when it struggled to over-
come the obstacles in its path. Together
with Joseph Barondess, of blessed mem-
ory, Dr. Levinthal founded the "Hadoar
Committee" now renamed "Friends of
the Hadoar." If our magazine has suc-
ceeded in maintaining its existence for a
period of 27 years — a record unparalleled
by any other American Hebrew periodi-
cal — it is to a large extent because of the
efforts of these pioneers, among whom
Dr. Levinthal's name looms large.
•
To Dr. Levinthal, as with all who go
back to original Jewish sources, Hebrew
is the key that unlocks our rich national
resources. The Sages of the Midrash,
through their ideas and sayings, provide
him with a veritable treasure-trove from
which the modern Jew — with the aid of
the rabbi and preacher — may derive spir-
itual sustenance.
Rabbi Levinthal's distinction in Jewish
life may indeed be said to be by virtue
of his talents as a preacher and orator.
He knows the secret of unearthing the
beauty contained in the Midrash, in our
homiletical literature, in sage Rabbinic
sayings, in folk-parables that have become
inextricably intertwined with our ancient
literature, in poetic-philosophic insights
that illuminate the crumpled parchment
of old texts. This modern preacher has
attuned himself to the voices and expres-
sions of a wise and understanding nation,
to the spiritual undertones of an op-
pressed and suffering nation — and these
ideas, so unique in their profundity and
beauty, he has translated into the ver-
nacular of the man of today. Thus, his
speeches retain the rare flavor of this
precious wine, hitherto sealed in hidden,
inaccessible casks.
e
It is Dr. Levinthal's merit that he has
been able to lift his audience from the
hard, prosaic world of reality in which
they live to the exalted world of the
Agada and Midrash created by the genius
of the Hebrew poetic imagination.
It is as if Rabbi Levinthal, like the
Agadists of old, has said to his congrega-
tion: "Do you wish to understand God?
Study Agada, then you will learn to know
the Holy-One-Blessed Be-He, and to cling
to his ways." Or, "Do not regard the
parable lightly, for through parables we
may learn the true meaning of the
Torah."
Indeed, by formulating the words of
the Agada in modern terms, in keeping
with the spirit of our own day, by giving
new meaning to ancient words, by recon-
ciling the prophecy of the past with
the reality of the present — this beloved
preacher creates a synthesis of old and
new, of the Jewish and the universal,
thus disclosing the true and the beautiful
in our nation's cultural heritage.
This has been Rabbi Levinthal's method
since the beginning of his ministry, and
that is why his listeners derive such en-
joyment from his sermons and speeches.
Jews have become accustomed to many
By MENAHEM RIBALOW
(Translated from the "Hadoar" by
Mordecai H. Lewittes)
voices and many sounds, but he is par-
ticularly sensitive to those sounds that
contain the traditional Jewish note. That
is why he will hasten to hear the prayers
and chants of the talented Chazan whose
sweet-sad melodies strike a responsive
chord within him. For this same reason
the Jewish worshipper will hearken at-
tentively to the Rabbi who, skillfully
drawing his words from that ancient
fount in which derash and agada and
musar find their common source, reaches
the ear and the heart of the pious
synagogue-goer.
Dr. Levinthal has discovered the secret
path to this fount of Judaism and has
drawn deeply from its waters. He has
succeeded in building a great institution,
a center of Torah and prayer, combining
educational and recreational activities for
its members and its worshippers. In
addition, he has taught his congregation
that the Brooklyn Jewish Center, impor-
tant though it may be, is only one strand
in the embroidery of Jewish life, and that
each one, above all, owes a duty to the
entire Jewish people by aiding in the con-
struction of the Jewish State and Jewish
spiritual regeneration in all the lands of
the Diaspora.
Funds raised by the United Jewish Ap-
peal enabled 145,000 displaced Jews from
Europe to find new homes in Palestine,
the United States and other lands, it
was announced by Henry Morgenthau,
Jr., former Secretary of the Treasury
and general chairman of the U.J.A.
$250,000,000 drive.
He reported that since V-E Day, May
8, 1945, more than 70,000 Jewish ref-
ugees were settled in Palestine, nearly
50,000 entered the United States and ap-
proximately 2 5,000 were admitted to
other countries in North and South
America, Australia, South Africa and
elsewhere. Morgenthau stressed that the
year 1948 was one "of the most crucial
years for large-scale emigration activity."
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
15
NEWS
OF THE
MONTH
THE FOUNDING OF ISRAEL
SO RAPID is the passage of events in
and relating to Israel that it is dif-
ficult for even a daily paper to keep
up with them. As the Kevietv goes to
press there are distressing reports from
Jerusalem. The British subsidized and
trained Arab Legion from Trans-Jordan
claimed to have occupied four-fifths of
the city; in other parts of Israel Jews
were holding practically all the territory
allotted to the new state in the United
Nations Partition Plan. Egyptian planes
bombed Tel Aviv a number of times, and
Israeli planes, for the first time, took to
the air and bombed Arab military con-
centrations.
In the United Nations the effort of the
United States to declare the Arab na-
tions attacking Israel as aggressors and
invoking sanctions against them was sup-
ported by Russia and Poland, but ob-
structed by Great Britain and China, as
well as by other countries, represented on
the Security Council, making the success
of this movement almost impossible.
The situation in Israel gave impetus to
the demand that the United States lift
the arms embargo in favor of the new
state, and brought forth protests, some
in Congress, against the English govern-
ment for permitting the Trans-Jordan
Army to wage war against the Jews.
There was heard talk of excluding Britain
from the benefits of the European Recov-
ery Plan.
tit
Preceding these events was the recogni-
tion of Israel by the United States im-
mediately following the establishment of
the State of Israel at 6:01 p.m. Friday,
May 14 (New York date and time).
Russia, Guatamala and Poland followed,
together with Yugoslavia, Czecho-Sla-
vakia, Ukraine. The French Chamber
of Deputies, in the absence of recognition
by France, sent greetings to Israel.
Chaim Weizmann was elected Presi-
dent of the Council of Government of
Israel. David Ben Gurion became Prime
Minister and Moshe Shertok Foreign Min-
ister Eliahu Epstein was appointed Min-
ister to the United States, and Major
Aubrey S. Eban as Israel's representative
to the United Nations.
tit
Throughout the American continent
there was the greatest rejoicing among
the Jewish populations A great mass
meeting was held in Madison Square Gar-
den in New York that overflowed deep
into the adjoining streets. The crowd
was estimated at 75,000. The speakers
were Rabbi Abba Hillel Silber, Emanuel
Newmann, Stephen Wise, Senator Robert
A. Taft, Mayor O'Dwyer, Henry Morgen-
thau, Herbert H. Lehman and Brig. Gen-
eral Julius Klein. President Weizmann
was to have made the principal address
but was confined to his apartment in the
Waldorf-Astoria Hotel by illness. In
Chicago more than 50,000 people jammed
into the Chicago Stadium in a "Salute to
Israel," sponsored by the Americans for
Haganah. Senator Wayland Brooks, of
Illinois, Bartley Crum and Mayor of
Chicago Martin H. Kennelly were among
the speakers. At the foot of the con-
tinent, in Buenos Ayres, a crowd equally
as large, celebrated the founding of Israel.
After the meeting the audience massed in
a huge procession and marched to the
statue of San Martin, laying a wreath on
the monument to the country's liberator.
In London, a meeting of Jews, small by
comparison — 3,000 — hailed the new state.
Prof. Selig Borodetsky and Berle Locker,
of the Jewish Agency Executive, ad-
dressed them. Vienna, Paris, Rome,
Stockholm, Warsaw, Bucharest, Prague,
Budapest, joined in the celebrations, as
did far-off Johannesburg, South Africa.
Text of Israel's Declaration of Independence
THE land of Israel was the birthplace
of the Jewish people. Here their
spiritual, religious and national identity
was formed. Here they achieved inde-
pendence and created a culture of na-
tional and universal significance. Here
they wrote and gave the Bible to the
world.
Exiled from Palestine, the Jewish
people remained faithful to it in all the
countries of their dispersion, never ceas-
ing to pray and hope for their return and
restoration of their national freedom.
Impelled by this historic association,
Jews strove throughout the centuries to
go back to the land of their fathers and
regain statehood. In recent decades they
returned in their masses. They reclaimed
a wilderness, revived their language, built
cities and villages, and established a vigor-
ous and ever-growing community, with
its own economic and cultural life. They
sought peace, yet were ever prepared to
defend themselves. They brought bless-
ings of progress to all inhabitants of the
country.
In the year 1897 the first Zionist Con-
gress, inspired by Theodore Herzl's vision
of a Jewish state, proclaimed the right of
the Jewish people to a national revival
in their own country.
This right was acknowledged by the
Balfour Declaration of November 2, 1917
and reaffirmed by the mandate of the
League of Nations, which gave explicit
international recognition to the historic
connection of the Jewish people with
Palestine and their right to reconstitute
their national home.
The Nazi holocaust which engulfed
millions of Jews in Europe proved anew
the urgency of the re-establishment of the
Jewish state, which would solve the
problems of Jewish homelessness by open-
ing the gates to all Jews and lifting the
Jewish people to equality in the family of
nations.
Survivors of the European catastrophe
as well as Jews from other lands, claiming
their right to a life of dignity, freedom
and labor, and undeterred by hazards,
hardships and obstacles, have tried un-
ceasingly to enter Palestine.
In the second world war, the Jewish
people in Palestine made a full contribu-
tion in the struggle of freedom-loving
nations against the Nazi evil. The sacri-
[Continued on page 23]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
The rate of natural increase of Jews
in the United States lags behind the gen-
eral population and American-born Jews
tend to have smaller families than Jew-
ish immigrants or other native Ameri-
cans, it was revealed in a study by Dr.
Nathan Goldberg, just published by the
American Jewish Congress.
The study, "Population Trends Among
American Jews," attributes this situation
to anti-Semitism, desire for security, in-
termarriage, concentration of Jews in
urban centers and the general emancipa-
tion of women. Dr. Goldberg, a member
of the faculty of Yeshiva College, says
that discrimination tends to inhibit the
size of the Jewish family because Jews
are forced to work harder to overcome
economic and social obstacles placed in
their path by anti-Semites and frequently
are faced with the choice of a greater
degree of security and a smaller family
or economic insecurity and children.
The study reveals that in several Con-
necticut cities the rate of intermarriage
has risen from slightly above one per cent
at the turn of the century to over six and
seven per cent at present. The tendency
to intermarry is greatest among Jewish
college youth, the study adds. Dr. Gold-
berg traces the Jewish population growth
in this country from 6,000 in 1826 to
50,000 in 1848, 230,000 in 1877, to over
5,000,000 in 1947.
"Gentleman's Agreement"
Doing Good Business
AN ATTEMPT to prevent the show-
ing of "Gentleman's Agreement"
in Tulsa, Oklahoma, by Gerald L. K.
Smith, was defeated when Judge Eben L.
Taylor of that city denied Smith's motion
for an injunction against the film. The
movie, dealing with social anti-Semitism
in the United States, opened on schedule.
Smith sought an injunction against
the 20th Century - Fox film on the
grounds that his name is referred to in
one sequence. Meanwhile, reports from
southern cities exhibiting the movie indi-
cate that the motion picture industry's
apprehensions that it will meet with dif-
ficulties in that area have proven un-
founded. Box office receipts in southern
cities are matching those in northern
cities, it was revealed.
The first Canadian Festival of Jewish
Music was held in Toronto at Holy Blos-
som Temple and featured a selection of
numerous unpublished Jewish musical
compositions. Rabbi Abraham L. Fein-
berg, who organized the festival, an-
nounced that the works are available
gratis to Jewish congregations or educa-
tional institutions wishing to use them.
A report published in New York al-
leging that the majority of the displaced
Jews in Germany have lost interest in
Palestine because of the "uncertain
future" there, and that about 80 per cent
of them prefer to emigrate to the United
States, was denied in Frankfurt.
Dr. William Haber, adviser on Jewish
affairs at U. S. military headquarters, de-
clared that he is convinced that even
under the existing unsettled conditions,
the vast majority of displaced Jews in
Germany and Austria would emigrate to
Palestine when legal immigration is
authorized.
"They are tired of endless waiting in
DP camps and would gladly sacrifice tem-
porary security in these camps for the
hazards of life in Palestine," Dr. Haber
stated.
The United Synagogue of America
convention, held in Chicago, recently,
adopted a resolution presented by Judge
Emanuel Greenberg, Chairman of the
Resolutions Committee, expressing the
"profound gratitude" of the 1,000 dele-
gates to President Truman for his "forth-
right, wise and just act of statesmanship"
in being the first head of a major power
to extend recognition to Israel.
The Convention, attended by delegates
representing more than 420,000 Conserv-
ative Jews in all parts of the U. S., also
approved resolutions calling for the lift-
ing of the American embargo on shipment
of arms to Palestine; urging the U. S. to
sponsor the admission of Israel to the
United Nations; and expressing the hope
that legislation to facilitate the admission
of DP's to this country would soon be
passed.
Negotiations for a merger of the
Central Jewish Committee and the Fed-
Supreme Court's Banning of
Restrictive Contracts Apply
Also to Jews
THE Department of Justice interpreted
* the Supreme Court decision rendering
court enforcement of restrictive cove-
nants based on race or color illegal as
applying also to religious groups. The
Court's decision mentioned only private
real estate agreements which barred
groups on the basis of race or color.
"It is the opinion of the Department
of Justice that the rulings of the Supreme
Court are applicable with equal force to
similar agreements based on creed," the
Department said. "It would now seem
certain that no state through its courts
can support or enforce private agree-
ments which are designed to do what
the state itself is prohibited from doing."
eration of Jewish Communities of Poland
hit a snag when the Central Committee
declined to accept the principle of Sab-
bath observance, offered by the Chief
Rabbinate, an affiliate of the Federation,
as one of five points to be discussed dur-
ing the current talks. The Committee,
however, has accepted in principle the
other four points. They are:
1. Kosher food shall be served in all
Committee-sponsored kitchens; 2. Auton-
omy for all religious children's homes
shall be preserved; 3. Financial indepen-
dence for the Federation; 4. Continuation
of the "Talmud Torah" method in the
country's Jewish educational system.
A spokesman for the two organizations
announced that agreement had been
reached on the questions of restitution of
Jewish communal real property; the ex-
humation of Jewish martyrs and their
reburial in Jewish cemeteries; and the
provision of adequate supervision for
Jewish burial places. He pointed out that
the purpose of the merger discussions is
to set up a unified Jewish representative
body.
"ir
One hundred Jewish refugee orphans
from Eastern Europe arrived in Ireland
for resettlement in the Dublin area. The
children, between the ages of four and
16, were brought to Dublin under the
auspices of the Chief Rabbis Emergency
Relief Council.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
The British Government agreed this
week to extradite Dr. Wladislaw Nehring,
Polish war criminal, who, as Nazi-
appointed chief surgeon at Oswiecim, is
allegedly responsible for performing
18,000 "experimental operations" on the
camp's inmates, most of whom were Jew-
ish women.
After the war, Nehring joined Gen.
Anders' Polish army in Italy and later
arrived in England as an army physician.
He was arrested in 1947 following pub-
lication of the U.N. War Commission
list of unapprehended war criminals. He
is wanted not only in Poland but also in
France and Czechoslovakia.
•Cr
A Danish committee for the Haganah
has been formed in Copenhagen with Dr.
Erik Warburg as president. The commit-
tee is planning a campaign to raise
$100,000 for the Haganah. Members of
the committee include Jews and non-
Jews, the latter being mostly professors
and clergymen.
fr
The Latin American office of the Joint
Distribution Committee sent a represen-
tative to Bogota to study the needs of
Jews there for credit and other forms of
constructive aid in recovering from the
damage to their property during the re-
cent anti-government uprising. The
J.D.C. office, located in Buenos Aires, has
learned that the Bogota Jews are not in
need of immediate relief assistance.
Single Jewish Girls to Relieve
D. P. Women Shortage
SUGGESTIONS that unmarried Jewish
refugee girls from Sweden be brought
to Italy to relieve the acute shortage of
women among the displaced Jews were
made in Rome by Jewish leaders. The
number of Jewish male refugees in Italy
is entirely out of proportion to the num-
ber of women in the group, with esti-
mates running as high as 70 per cent more
men than women in given areas.
Refugee leaders point out that the
shortage is particularly severe in kibbutz
settlements. They declare that there are
large numbers of unmarried Jewish girls
in Sweden, many of whom were brought
there from German concentration camps
by the Swedish Red Cross during the last
months of the war.
Charles Jordan, former director of the
J.D.C. in Shanghai, sailed for Paris to
assume the post of director of its immi-
gration service in Europe. During the
past few years the service has aided some
45,000 Jewish refugees to resettle in
the United States, Palestine and other
countries.
<&
More than 600 workers in various
unions throughout the United States have
"adopted" a refugee child in Europe under
a plan sponsored by the Jewish Labor
Committee.
Under the plan each of the benefactors
contributes $300 toward the support of
a child. Nearly 300 of the children are
in private homes or institutions in Poland,
a like number in France and the remain-
der are distributed in Belgium, Rumania,
Italy and Sweden. Over $180,000 has
already been contributed to this project.
•ir
Communications officials in Australia
are trying to track down a secret radio
station which has been cutting into regu-
lar programs with anti-Semitic propa-
ganda.
Officials expressed the belief that the
station is using a mobile transmitter and
changes its location every day. Recently
the clandestine radio broke in on a li-
censed program with 25 minutes of
scurrilous propaganda.
•&
The Revisionist Party in South Africa
denied reports in the local press that the
police recently raided the organization's
headquarters in Capetown. Despite an
official silence on the part of the police,
it was learned from reliable sources that
Betar, the Revisionist youth organization
in Capetown, was raided following re-
ceipt of reports that members of the
group were training with arms and were
storing weapons for Palestine.
Meanwhile, a local newspaper, Die
Vadcrland, has published an article charg-
ing that the Revisionists are purchasing
planes and ammunition in South Africa
for shipment to the Sternists in Palestine.
The newspaper adds that the Haganah
informed the local police and that
Premier Jan Christian Smuts has issued
secret instructions to the authorities to
halt these activities.
Quebec Synagogue Wins 15-Year-
Old Fight to Exist
AN AGREEMENT by the Quebec
city administration to revoke regu-
lations intended to prevent the erection
and use of a synagogue within the city
limits has ended a 15 -year-old case during
which legal and illegal methods have been
used by anti-Semitic forces in the com-
munity in an attempt to interfere with
the religious life of the Jews.
During the course of the dispute, un-
paralleled in Canadian Jewish history,
enemies of the Jews forced passage
through the municipal council of zoning
laws to prohibit the building of the syna-
gogue to replace a century-old temple.
When this method failed and the struc-
ture was erected, the municipality passed
a law expropriating the land on which
the building stood. In addition uniden-
tified vandals stoned the synagogue and
set fire to its interior.
The Canadian Jewish Congress, which
led the fight to prevent the ousting of
the Quebec Jews from their house of wor-
ship, campaigned throughout the country
to arouse sentiment in favor of the Jew-
ish cause. In a statement after the
municipality's decision to revoke its re-
strictive and illegal regulations, the Con-
gress said the "security of the synagogue
is insured as a result of this important
victory."
The first Yiddish-language theatre* in
Italy will open near Rome shortly, the
Joint Distribution Committee announced.
The Central Jewish Refugee Committee
had asked the J.D.C. to subsidize the
project, pointing out that DP's in camps
in all parts of Italy are extremely anxious
to attend Yiddish theatrical performances.
At present, amateur dramatic groups
are presenting performances in numerous
refugee camps. At least 15 professional
Yiddish actors and actresses who per-
formed in Poland and Lithuania in pre-
war years will be brought to a kibbutz
near here by the J.D.C. to set up the
Yiddish troupe.
A new suburban settlement near
Ramat Gan, in Israel, will be named for
Dr. Emanuel Neumann, president of the
Zionist Organization of America.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER NEWS
Center Academy Graduation
ONE of the largest graduating classes
in the history of the Center Acad-
emy will receive its diplomas from Rabbi
Levinthal at the Academy's graduation
exercises which will take place in* the
Brooklyn Jewish Center Auditorium on
Wednesday, June 16.
In accordance with Center Academy
tradition, the graduates will present two
original plays. The first will be "Alice
in Historyland." The other, to be pre-
sented entirely in Hebrew, will have as
its theme the trials of Jewish displaced
persons in their search for avenues of es-
cape to Palestine and their subsequent
rehabilitation there. These plays are
being directed by the 8th Grade teachers,
Mrs. Ann D. Greenstein and Miss Irene
Bush, with the assistance of the Music
and Art Teachers, Miss Frieda Prensky
and Mr. Louis Harris.
The graduates and invited guests will
be addressed by Rabbi Levinthal, Dr.
Solomon J. Miller, President of the Board
of Trustees of the Center Academy, and
Mr. Hyman Sorokoff, Principal of the
Center Academy.
Plans for the day include a reception
by the graduating class for their invited
guests. The members of the class are:
Irving M. Dworetzsky, Audrey Edith
Eichner, Arthur A. Greenberg, Elizabeth
Rose Gropper, Ann Kay Honig, Samuel
Harvey Lindenbaum, Herbert Stanly
Punia, Ina Ruth Resnick, Michael J. Ross,
Gertrude Scheff , Robert Neil Shorin, Mel-
vin B. Solomon, Paul Martin Tobin, Bar-
bara Nan Zevon, Corinne Beverly Zucker.
Consecration Services to be Held on
Shevuoth, Sunday Morning, June 13th
The congregation is cordially invited
to worship with us at our Synagogue ser-
vices on the Shevuoth holiday. On the
first day of Shevuoth, Sunday morning,
June 13 th, we shall have our annual Con-
secration Service. Twenty-three girls rep-
resenting the student body of the Mar-
shall iah High School, the Center Post-
Graduate Course and the Religious School
will take part in a very interesting and
impressive program. The consecration
theme will be a "Sabbath Cantata" writ-
ten by Rabbi and Mrs. Morris Adler of
Detroit, which symbolizes in song and
dialogue the role that the Sabbath has
played in Jewish life. The class has been
under the instruction of Miss Laura
Viders and the music for the Consecra-
tion Service is being coached by our Musi-
cal Director, Mr. Julius Grossman. The
following girls will take part in the ser-
vice this Shevuoth: Isadora Aptaker,
Shirley Aronow, Joyce Bernhardt, Arline
Brill, Tobia Brown, Helene Crane, Bar-
bara Danciger, Rita Davis, Erna Finkel-
stein, Marcia Gingold, Joan Heimowitz,
Julia Heimowitz, Gladys Hoffman, Anne
Kabram, Lorna Kaye, Ruth Klinghoffer,
Joyce Krimsky, Anne Joy Levitt, Bar-
bara Lipson, Isabel Miller, Mary Rosen-
berg, Doris Shapiro and Marcia Spevack.
Institute of Jewish Studies for Adults
Holds Closing Exercises
The closing exercises of this season's
work at the Institute of Jewish Studies
for Adults took place on Monday eve-
ning, May 24th, in the Auditorium of
our Center. The Review was already in
press when this affair took place and a
detailed report will be presented in our
next issue. A very interesting program
was arranged for those present and a large
number of men and women attended the
function.
Yiddish Literary and Musical Evening
An interesting literary and musical
evening has been arranged for Monday,
May 31st (Decoration Day) at 8 o'clock.
The evening is arranged in honor of the
well known Yiddish poet and novelist,
Z. Segalovitz. The following will par-
ticipate: Abraham Reiser, famous poet;
Daniel Charney, writer and novelist;
Bella Ballerina in a program of recita-
tions; Menashe Oppenheim, folk singer;
Dinah Halperin in recitations; Nahum
Nardi in a program of Palestinian songs.
The great poet and dramatist, H. Leivick,
will preside. Dr. Abraham Asen will
open the program. Admission will be
$1.00.
Rabbi Levinthal Appointed Visiting
Professor in Homiletics at Seminary
The Board of Directors of the Jewish
Theological Seminary have invited our
Rabbi, Dr. Israel H. Levinthal, to become
Visiting Professor in Homiletics at the
Seminary for the academic year 1948-49.
The news of this appointment has
aroused great interest among the students
of the Seminary who look upon Rabbi
Levinthal as one of the outstanding
preachers and they feel that they will de-
rive much knowledge in the art of
preaching from the rich experience of
our rabbi.
Joseph Goldberg Elected President of
Nat'l Assn. of Synagogue Administrators
At the last Biennial Convention of the
United Synagogue of America held in
Chicago, Joseph Goldberg, Administra-
tive Director of the Brooklyn Jewish
Center, was elected President of the newly
formed National Association of Syna-
gogue Administrators.
The organization is comprised of Exec-
utive Directors and Secretaries of Syna-
gogues and Jewish Centers affiliated with
the United Synagogue.
Important Sisterhood Dates and Events
The members of the Sisterhood are
asked to please make note of the follow-
ing important dates of several coming af-
fairs in which the women of the Center
are cordially invited to participate:
June 2nd: Evening — Installation of
Sisterhood Officers and Executive Board.
Rabbi Levinthal will install the new offi-
cers. An interesting program for the eve-
ning will include the popular tenor, Ian
Cosman, assisted at the piano by Jack
Baras.
June 3rd: Afternoon — Tea sponsored
by the Sisterhood, Eastern Parkway
Hadassah and the Center Academy for
women contributing $18.00 or over to
the United Jewish Appeal.
June 7th: Afternoon — Closing meet-
ing of the Executive Board at the home
of Mrs. Ruth Bernhardt, 1368 Carroll
Street.
Brooklyn Jtwish C«nttr Revitw
19
Sisterhood's Tribute to Jewish Mothers
On Monday evening, May 10th, Sister-
hood paid an unusually unique tribute to
Jewish mothers, and especially to the
women of our organization. Under the
direction of Mrs. Morton Klinghoffer and
Mrs. Benjamin Wisner, our own women
participated in a magnificent pageant,
glorifying the Jewish Home Beautiful,
and the important role which the Jewish
mother plays in preserving its sanctity,
beauty and dignity. Colorful and appro-
priate displays distinguished each candle-
lit table, festively arrayed with the sym-
bolic traditions and foods associated with
the holidays of Purim, Passover, Shevuoth
and Shabbat. A new addition to this
quartet of tables on exhibition included a
cleverly-arranged exposition of Palestine,
indicating its progress to date. Besides
editing the narrations delivered by Rabbi
Manuel Saltzman as Narrator, Mrs. Kling-
hoffer wrote a glowing introduction and
a most inspiring original script on Pal-
estine. An audience of about 450 mem-
bers were visibly impressed with this per-
formance, evidenced by the spontaneity
with which they joined Cantor Sauler in
his rendition of "Hamavdil." In addi-
tion to the Cantor, Mrs. Mabel Berman
and Mrs. Ethel Pashenz lent their lyric
voices to songs of the Sabbath and
Shevuoth. At the Passover table, the
third generation, in the person of little
Barbara Kaplan, asked the Four Questions.
The entire musical background was pro-
vided by our very capable music direc-
tor, Julius Grossman. Other matters of
importance, like the ratification of our
new Constitution, and the election of a
slate of officers for 1948, took second
place that night. The entire audience
were thrilled with the beautiful perfor-
mance, and showed great appreciation for
the efforts contributed by the following
participants:
Mrs. Fanny Buchman and Mrs. Bess
Altman, who decorated the Purim table.
Mrs. Eleanor Horowitz, Mrs. Gert
Ostow, Mrs. Lilly Levy, who decorated
the Passover table.
Mrs. Lila Leonard, Mrs. Bea Shaeffer,
Mrs. Mabel Berman, who decorated the
Shevuoth table.
Mrs. Sarah Epstein, Mrs. Ethel Pashenz,
Mrs. Rose Joley, who decorated the Shab-
bat table.
Mrs. Mildred Levine, Mrs. Ruth Win-
ick, Mrs. Jennie Levine, who decorated
the Palestine table.
Refreshments were served to those
present who enjoyed especially tasting the
holiday foods prepared by the ladies for
their table.
Center Academy Holds Music Festival
A gala festival and concert was
given by the Center Academy Glee Club
on Tuesday afternoon, May 2 5, at 2
o'clock in the Brooklyn Jewish Center
auditorium. The program, under the di-
rection of the Center Academy's music
teacher, Miss Frieda Prensky, consisted
of American and Hebrew folk songs, and
piano, violin and flute solos. The mem-
bers of the Glee Club are: Grade IV —
Joyce Greenberg, James Flug, Ira Miller,
Roslyn Radutzky, Joel Rappaport, An-
drea Penkower; Grade V — Carol Am-
reich, Janet Feldman, Robin Finkel,
Debra Levrant, Joan Scheff; Grade VI —
Elaine Appelbaum, Nancy Blumberg,
Rena Globe, Rita Goldberg, Barbara Sat-
low; Grade VII — Leonard Fischbach,
Tirzah Gordon, Sara Boukstein, Barbara
Miller, Linda Resnick, Joel Rothman,
Marion Yablon.
Young Folks League U.J.A. Pledges
Members of the Young Folks League
who were kind enough to make pledges
to the United Jewish Appeal at their last
affair are asked to please send in their
checks, payable to the U. J. A. Junior
Division, in care of the Center. It is
very urgent that all monies be turned
over to the U.J.A. with the least pos-
sible delay.
Sabbath Services
Friday evening services at 6:00.
Kindling of candles at 7:58.
Sabbath services, "Behar" — Leviticus
25:1 — 26:2; Prophets-Jeremiah 32:6-27,
will commence at 8:30 a.m.
Mincha services Saturday at 6:00 p.m.
Rabbi Saltzman will preach on the
weekly portion of the Torah.
Class in Talmud led by Mr. Jacob S.
Doner will be held at 4 p.m.
Rabbi George Abelson will continue
his lecture in Yiddish this Saturday after-
noon at 5:15 p.m.
Daily Services
Morning services at 8 a.m.
Mincha services at 7:45 p.m.
Acknowledgment of Gifts
We acknowledge with thanks receipt
of donations for the purchase of Prayer
Books and Taleisim from the following:
Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin Gedinsky in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their son,
Irwin Maxwell.
Mr. and Mrs. Alfred Greenblatt in
honor of the marriage of their son, Irwin.
Mr. and Mrs. Frank Wolk in honor of
the Bar Mitzvah of their son, Bruce.
Bar Mitzvah
A hearty Mazel Tov is extended to
Mr. and Mrs. Philip Epstein of 1209
President Street on the Bar Mitzvah of
their son, Henry M., which will be cele-
brated at the Center this Sabbath morn-
ing, May 29th.
Handball Tourney Ends With Bang
The Handball Tournament closed on
Thursday evening, May 13 th, with the
finals of the "One Wall Open Doubles
Championship." This match which was
played before a large crowd, proved to
be one of the best set of matches seen
for a long time. The winners who were
Sandy Blank and Al Schuckman, who
also emerged on top in 1947, came
through by winning the best 2 out of 3
games. The scores were 21-12, 51-21,
21-18. The opposition, Phil Levine and
Milton Slow, played grand games but
could not fully cope with the speed,
agility and hard hitting of the 1948
champions.
The four wall tournament was won
by Sam Smith and Al Greenberg when
they defeated the favorites, Dr. Harold
Cook and Bill Wciner, by the scores of
11-21, 21-8, 21-16.
Winners and runners-up of both tour-
naments received beautiful trophies em-
blematic of same.
Junior League News
The usual monthly open meeting of
the Junior League will be held on Thurs-
day evening, June 3rd, at 8:30 o'clock.
A very fine social evening is being
planned and all members and their
friends are cordially invited.
Decoration Day Gym Schedule
The holiday schedule will prevail in
the Gym and Baths Department on Mon-
day, May 31st (Decoration Day) and
will be open for men from 10 a.m. to
2 p.m., and for boys from 2 to 4 p.m.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
HEBREW SCHOOL NEWS
THE graduation of the Hebrew and
Sunday Schools will take place on Sun-
day, June 6. Featured on the program
will be a Cantata, "Our Bialik," by
Judith and Ira Eisenstein, to be presented
by the graduates of the two schools and
the Choral group under the direction of
Mr. Julius Grossman.
The following students will receive
diplomas or certificates: Post-Graduate
Hebrew Course: Anita Brown, Leonard
Bcrman, Julia Heimowitz, Judith Klein,
Sandor Schaeffer, Alex Sterman, and
Eleanor Zelvin. Post-Barmitziab Course:
Stanley Green. Hebrew Schools Arline
H. Aaronson, Ileane Altman, Melvin
Aminoff, Martin Arkowitz, Helen Aro-
now, Morton Bromberg, Tobia Brown,
Frieda Cohen, Henry Epstein, Sheldon
Friefeld, Robert Gluckman, Jules Hol-
lander, Martin Kramer, Carla Lefkowitz,
George Levy, Jerome Lubetzki, Ellen J.
Machlin, Stuart Perlman, Rena Rosen-
baum, Eugene Sherman, Stephen Silver-
stein, David Sirota, Alan Sloate. Sunday
School: Jane Amster, Barbara Berman,
Marilyn Epstein, Laura Ginsburg, Naomi
Goldfarb, Myra Greenman, Susan Jaffe,
Anna Leibowitz, Doris Rabbiner, Judith
Rutenberg, Jean Serota, Lila Silverman,
Barbara Staub, Edith Wecht, Barbara
Weitzman.
Following will be the program: Pro-
cession and Pledges, Opening Prayer,
Carla Lefkowitz; Palestinian Songs; Ad-
dress, Hon. Emanuel Greenberg; Greet-
ings from Post-Graduate Hebrew Class,
Alex Sterman; Distribution of Certifi-
cates to Post-Graduate and Post-Bar
Mitzvah Class, Rabbi Manuel Saltzman;
Post-Graduate Hebrew Award to Julia
Heimowitz; Cantata, "Our Bialik," Grad-
uates and Choral Group; Presentation of
Awards, Mr. Frank Schaeffer, Chair-
man, Hebrew Education Committee,
Mrs. Julius Kushner, President, Parent-
Teachers Association; Sisterhood Gift to
Hebrew School Graduates, Mrs. Morton
Klinghoffer; Address to Graduates, Dr.
Israel H. Levinthal; Distribution of He-
brew School Diplomas, Rabbi Mordecai
H. Lewittes and Mr. Leo Shpall; Solo,
Cantor William Sauler; Distribution of
Sunday School Diplomas, Mrs. Miriam
Tessler; Blessing of Graduates, Dr. Israel
H. Levinthal; Closing Prayer, Robert
Gluckman; Hatikvah and Recessional.
sS- ft ft
On Sunday, April 18, a special J.N.F.
program was held. A scroll commemo-
rating the planting of a garden in Pal-
estine in honor of the students of the
Hebrew School was presented by Mr.
Mordecai Rudensky and accepted by
Tobia Brown, president of the G. O., in
the name of the students of the Hebrew
School. Following the presentation of
the scroll, Mr. S. Edelheit showed Pales-
tinian films.
«• * *
The students of the Hebrew School
raised $234.31 for the Histadrut Ivrit
in connection with Hebrew Month for
the promotion of Hebrew education.
The Sunday School raised $386.13 for
the William Bernstein Naval School in
Palestine. This project twas sponsored
by the Hebrew Educators Committee.
* *
A playlet in honor of Mother's Day
by E. E. Levinger was presented by Grade
IV under the direction of Miss Laura
Sorscher on Sunday, May 9.
An original playlet dealing with the
same theme was presented in Hebrew and
English by Grade 2B1 of the Hebrew
School on May 10, 1948, under the di-
rection of Mrs. E. Zusman. The play
showed how Jewish children came to
learn the significance of the fifth com-
mandment, "Honor thy father and thy
mother."
ft * *
The final P.T.A. meeting of the season
was held on Tuesday, May 2 5, 1948. Mrs.
Kushner, president of the P. T. A., de-
scribed the very successful activities of
the organization during the past season.
The guest speaker was Rabbi Abraham
Karp, executive director of the Metro-
politan Board of the United Synagogue.
Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes spoke of
some of the outstanding achievements
of our school during the past year and
our plans for the future. Cantor Wm.
Sauler sang a group of songs, and Mr.
Julius Grossman led in community
singing.
Inta-League Girls and Boys Clubs
Have Successful Season
The Inta-League club activities this
year have been aimed to meet the needs
of the American High School student in
the social, recreational and especially in
the cultural needs of their lives.
Some of the outstanding programs
which were actively and enthusiastically
participated in by the members of the
clubs included dramatic presentations,
Eternal Light scripts, motion pictures
followed by discussions, group discussion
of phases of Jewish life, such as Palestine,
religious observance, special observance
of Jewish Holidays and participation in
the many events that are happening here
because of the rebirth of our Homeland.
The leaders of the groups, Miss Marilyn
Hochman and Mr. Herbert Kummel,
assisted by Mr. Irvin I. Rubin, Director
of Senior Club Activities, feel that much
progress has been made with these young
people in helping them to live an active,
positive Jewish life in America today.
Congratulations
Heartiest congratulations and best
wishes are extended to:
Mr. and Mrs. Maurice Bernhardt of
1368 Carroll Street and Mr. and Mrs.
Harry I. Model of 576 Eastern Parkway
on the marriage of their children, Marcia
Bernhardt to Bernard Model, at the Cen-
ter on May 26th.
THE HIGHLIGHT EVENT
OF THE YEAR
sponsored by the
JUNIOR LEAGUE
Saturday Evening, May 29th
•
FORMAL DANCE
For the benefit of the
UNITED JEWISH APPEAL
•
Dancing to Orchestra Music
Refreshments
Only members of the League
are invited to attend!
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
21
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Angel, Miss Sara
Res. 371 Rodney St.
Proposed by Mrs. Louis J. Roth,
Miriam Mayerson
Buchin, Ellie
Res. 285 E. 91st St.
Bus. Furniture, 42 W. 15 th St.
Single
Proposed by Samuel I. Samuels
Doniger, Arthur
Res. 25 Tennis Court
Bus. Paper, 103 Lafayette St.
Married
Proposed by Chas. Davis,
Max Goldberg
Firestone, Sidney
Res. 300 Sullivan PI.
Bus. Photography, 49 W. 45 th St.
Married
Proposed by Dr. Sol A. Gross,
Irv. Ehrlich
Green, Martin
Res. 1119 Foster Ave.
Bus. Lawyer, 391 Fulton St.
Single
Proposed by Judge A. David Benjamin,
Robert Krampner
Katz, Dr. Samuel
Res. 540 Crown St.
Bus. Physician, Park Pi.
Married
Proposed by Morris Neinken,
Samuel P. A below
Kopp, Alexander
Res. 569 Montgomery St.
Bus. Lawyer, 270 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Judge Emanuel Greenberg,
K. Karl Klein
Kopp, Robert E.
Res. 569 Montgomery St.
Bus. College Student
Single
Proposed by Judge Emanuel Greenberg,
K. Karf Klein
Kroll, "William
Res. 60-30 Madison St.
Bus. Ice Cream, 399 Blake Ave.
Married
Proposed by Robert Krampner,
Jerome B. Simonson
Manheim, Milton
Res. 283 Kingston Ave.
Bus. Shoes, 144 Duane St.
Married
Proposed by Reuben Lubetzki
Meyers, William
Res. 1483 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Liquor, 629 Grove St.
Married
Proposed by Sidney A. Gold,
Jules W. Gold
Nass, Milton
Res. 346 New York Ave.
Bus. Poultry, 145 Orchard St.
Single
Proposed by Nat Horowitz,
Harry Nass
Robins, Daniel J.
Res. 1591 Union St.
Bus. College Student
Single
Proposed by Dr. Israel H. Levin thai,
Joseph Goldberg
Rosen, Seymour
Res. 102 Liberty Ave.
Proposed by Sol Rosen,
Hy Rosen
Sapon, Leonard
Res. 1076 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Buyer, 500 — 7th Ave.
Single
Proposed by Nathan Sapon
Schatzow, David H.
Res. 1025 St. Johns Pi.
Bus. Lawyer, 152 W. 42nd St.
Married
Proposed by Neil M. Lieblich,
Judge Emanuel Greenberg
Scheiman, Isidore
Res. 328 Albany Ave.
Married
Proposed by Abe Mann
Sherman, Joseph
Res. 8 E. 92nd St.
Bus. Metal Works, 186 Wooster St.
Married
Proposed by Judah Trotzky,
Abe Mann
Sharkey, Melvin
Res. 40 Clarkson Ave.
Bus. Chemicals, 3 51 W. 3 5 th St.
Married
Proposed by Center Academy
Topol, Sidney
Res. 2100 Westbury Court
Bus. Optical, 88 Livingston St.
Married
Proposed by Morris Schwartz,
Bernard R. Perlman
The following have applied for re-
instatement:
Linett, Dr. Joseph M.
Res. 1474 President St.
Bus. Physician
Married
Proposed by Samuel N. Caplow,
Dr. Harry A. Warwick
Brautman, Henry W.
Res. 225 Sterling Place
Bus. Loan Service, 360 Knickerbocker
Avenue
Married
Proposed by M. Robert Epstein,
Morton Klinghoffer
Dershowitz, Leo
Res. 95 Linden Blvd.
Bus. Jewelry, 101 Maiden Lane
Single
Proposed by Abe Mann
Additional Applications
Gradus, Miss Harriet
Res. 701 Empire Blvd.
Proposed by Hy Rosen,
Marvin Blickstein
Stein, Miss Bess
Res. 1634 Eastern Parkway
Weinstein, Miss Dorothy
Res. 1087 Carroll Street
Proposed by Samuel Babbit,
Lillian Baumgarten
Samuel H. Goldberg,
Chairman, Membership Committee.
Center Choral Society
to Perform at Central Parle
Our Choral Society has been invited to
participate at the mass outdoor rally to be
held on the Central Park Mall, Sunday,
June 6th, at which a Bekurim Festival will
be presented, sponsored by the Jewish Na-
tional Fund. Our Choral Society will be
combined with the Zionist Choral Group.
Young Folks League Roof Meetings
to Start June 1st
The summer schedule for the Young
Folks League weekly meetings on the roof
every Tuesday evening, weather permit-
ting, will commence on June 1st and
be held each Tuesday thereafter. Mem-
bers of the League are urged to take ad-
vantage of these delightful roof meetings.
Admission will be limited to members
only upon presentation of their 1948
membership cards.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
YAHRZEITS — JUNE, 1948
Sidney J. Lipson . .
Mother
June 1
23
lyar
Joseph Schorr . .
Father
June 1
June 4
23
26
lyar
lyar
Mrs. Louis Weinstock
Mother
Oscar Kurshan
■ Father
Samuel Kurshan
June 5
27
lyar
Mrs. Margaret Levy . ..
Mrs. Isador Lowenfeld .
► Mother
June 5
27
lyar
Dr. Irving Moskowitz ...
Jacob Levine
Father
June 5
27
lyar
Philip Feldman
Brother
June 6
28
lyar
Abraham Ginsburg
Mother
June 6
28
lyar
Jacob Greenspan
Mother
June 6
28
lyar
Charles Fine
Brother
June 7
29
lyar
Irving G. Forman
Father
June 7
29
lyar
Morris Smerling
Samuel Smerling
■ Brother
June 1 1
4
Sivan
Archie Polsky
Father
Mrs. Samuel Strausberg
Husband )
June 12
5
Sivan
Morris O. Strausberg
Father |
June 12
5
Sivan
Dr. H. R. Litchfield
Father
June 13
6
Sivan
William B. Volet
Mother
June 1 4
7
Sivan
Philip Feldman
Father
June 15
8
Sivan
Louis Gordon
Father
June 1 5
8
Sivan
Ephraim Shapiro
Father
June 1 6
9
Sivan
Samuel Rottenberg
Mother
June 18
11
Sivan
David Karron
Father
June 19
12
Sivan
Samuel Albert
Father
June 23
16
Sivan
Charles S. Feinberg..
Philip Feinberg
Mother
June 23
16
Sivan
Harry A. Freedman.
Mother
June 23
16
Sivan
Leib Lurie
Father
June 24
17
Sivan
Mrs. Morris Hirsch ...
Husband
June 25
18
Sivan
Morris Weinberg
Sister
June 26
19
Sivan
Jacob Rosenman
Mother
June 27
20
Sivan
Mrs. Frank Brodie
Jerome H. Cole
Mrs. Edward Manes
■ Father
June 28
21
Sivan
Mrs. Samuel Nicoll...
Nathan T. Schwartz
Father
June 28
21
Sivan
Harry Preston
Father
June 29
22
Sivan
Maurice Rosenwasser
Mother
June 30
23
Sivan
Kiddush
A kiddush will be given to the Junior
Congregation on Saturday morning, June
5 th, by Mr. and Mrs. Morton KlinghofFer
in honor of the confirmation of their
daughter, Ruth, and the graduation from
Midwood High School and the Marshal-
liah Hebrew High School of their son,
Daniel.
Give Your Child a Jewish Education
Registration Now Open
for the
Brooklyn Jewish Center
Hebrew School
Classes meet 3 times a week — 2 hrs.
each session. The curriculum in-
cludes Siddur, Hebrew, Bible, His-
tory and Jewish music. Expert
faculty under the direction of
Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes.
HYMAN
SPITZ INC.
OUR ONLY STORE
Dickens 2-4000
1685 PITKIN AVENUE
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE
[Continued from page 1 5 ]
ficcs of their soldiers and efforts of their
workers gained them title to rank with
the peoples who founded the United Na-
tions. On November 29, 1947, the
General Assembly of the United Na-
tions adopted a resolution for re-estab-
lishment of an independent Jewish State
in Palestine and called upon inhabitants
of the country to take such steps as may
be necessary in their part to put the plan
into effect.
This recognition by the United Nations
of the rights of the Jewish people to
establish their independent state may not
be revoked. It is, moreover, the self-evi-
dent right of the Jewish people to be a
nation, as all other nations, in its own
sovereign state.
Accordingly we, the members of the
National Council, representing the Jew-
ish people in Palestine and the Zionist
movement of the world, met together in
solemn assembly by virtue of the natural
and historic right of the Jewish people
and the resolution of the General As-
sembly of the United Nations, hereby pro-
claim the establishment of the Jewish
state in Palestine, to be called Israel.
We hereby declare that as from the
termination of the mandate at midnight
this night of the 14th to 15th of May,
1948, and until the setting up of duly
elected bodies of the state in accordance
with a constitution to be drawn up by
a Constituent Assembly not later than
the 1st day of October, 1948, the pres-
ent National Council shall act as the
Provisional State Council, and its execu-
tive organ, the National Administration,
shall constitute the provisional govern-
ment of the State of Israel.
The State of Israel will promote the
development of the country for the bene-
fit of all its inhabitants; will be based on
precepts of liberty, justice and peace
taught by the Hebrew prophets; will up-
hold the full social and political equality
of all its citizens without distinction of
race, creed or sex; will guarantee full
freedom of conscience, worship, educa-
tion and culture; will safeguard the sanc-
tity and inviolability of shrines and holy
places of all religions, and will dedicate
itself to the principles of the Charter of
the United Nations.
The State of Israel will be ready to co-
operate with the organs and representa-
tives of the United Nations in the imple-
mentation of the resolution of November
29, 1947, and will take steps to bring
about an economic union over the whole
of Palestine.
We appeal to the United Nations to as-
sist the Jewish people in the building of
its state and to admit Israel into the
family of nations.
In the midst of wanton aggression we
call upon the Arab inhabitants of the
State of Israel to return to the ways of
peace and play their part in the develop-
ment of the state, with full and equal
citizenship and due representation in all
its bodies and institutions, provisional or
permanent.
We offer peace and amity to all neigh-
boring states and their peoples, and invite
them to cooperate with the independent
Jewish nation for the common good of
all. The State of Israel is ready to con-
tribute its full share to the peaceful
progress and reconstruction of the Middle
East. Our call goes out to the Jewish
people all over the world to rally to our
side in the task of immigration and de-
velopment, and to stand by us in the
great struggle for the fulfillment of the
dream of generations — the redemption
of Israel.
THE FUTURE OF AMERICAN JEWRY
[Continued from page 5]
a kingdom of priests and a holy nation.
Well, in what condition are we for set-
ting our feet upon this road? Every
rabbi will tell you how political Zionism
has poured life and strength into the veins
of contemporary Jewry and how difficult
it has been in this materialistic, wwmeta-
physical, cheaply rationalistic and pre-
dominantly illiterate environment, to
guide Jews toward the sources of their
being, to draw Jews into the spiritual
universe built up through the ages by the
prophets and poets, the saints and sages
of our people.
It is from this point of view and in a
strong faith in the victory of our politi-
cal cause that I have for many years
pleaded for a deepening of Jewish faith
and Jewish learning and Jewish education
and Jewish culture in America. Unless
we failed — and I never believed that we
would fail — this hour and its problems
were destined to arise. The hour was
destined to come in which, our political
ends having been accomplished, the Jewry
of America would be thrown back for
coherence, for a truly human life, for
inner freedom, for sheer continuity, for
life itself, upon the deeper sources of its
being. The destined hour has come. The
road ahead for American Jewry is from
now on a road of spiritual re-integration,
of moral conquest — a road away from
the cheap and vulgar irreligion and glori-
fication of the mechanical that fills our
world, a road of resistance to the environ-
ment of pagan values and pagan destruc-
tion. Our feet must be set upon this
road. There is, there can be, no other.
Congratulation
Our sincere congratulations and best
wishes are extended to Mr. and Mrs.
Abraham Feldman of 919 Park Place on
the birth of a daughter, Georgaine Jo
on May 18th. Congratulations are also
extended to the grandfather, Mr. Samuel
Feldman.
Mr. Benjamin Crau of 1245 Eastern
Parkway, who announces his engagement
to Miss Scena Trister.
State of Israel Assembly
An impressive assembly celebrating the
establishment of the State of Israel was
held by the students of the Hebrew
School on Tuesday, May 18, 1948. Rabbi
Lewittes introduced the guest speaker,
Baruch Friedman, a member of the Haga-
nah.
A SUITABLE GIFT BOOK
FOR YIDDISH READERS
first Yiddish Edition of
SHAKESPEARE'S KING LEAR
Translated by
DR. ABRAHAM ASEN
Cloth, 180 pages — $2.00 Postpaid
Sold by
BLOCH PUBLISHING CO.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
■ ■
ABBOT-FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES-SERVICE
507 Flatbush Avenue
JESSE J. FINE Brooklyn, New York
JACK ABBOT Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
RIVERSIDE-
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2-6600
Far Rockaway, L. I. Miami Beach, Florida
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE 1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
FAr Roclcaway 7-7100 Miami 5-7777
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle, we have arranged to
serve your Community. We have at our disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn.
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed
Sec. 562, P. L. & R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
15th
ANNIVERSARY
ISSUE
Presentation Copy
ANNIVERSARY MESSAGES TO THE REVIEW
FRANK L. WEIL, President, National
Jewish Welfare Board
I am happy to take the occasion of
the Review's 15 th anniversary milestone
to make public the observation that
this publication has from its inception
achieved — and to this day maintains — a
remarkably high standard of literary ex-
cellence and breadth of "coverage."
It is a publication one can look for-
ward to reading regardless of one's own
synagogue affiliation. I find the Review
bright, original, and, in the range of
topics it deals with, most helpful. May
I extend to its editors and the readership
it serves my sincerest wishes for continued
achievement and service.
It is particularly gratifying to be able
to say these words of unstinted praise in
behalf of a publication which is the
product of a constituent of the National
Jewish Welfare Board and which has
done — and of course continues to do — so
splendid a job of serving the cultural, rec-
reational and Jewish educational needs of
Brooklyn Jewry, the largest Jewish com-
munity in the world.
SOLOMON GRAYZEL, Editor, The Jew-
ish Publication Society of America
Is rr only fifteen years that the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center Review has been in
existence? I have become so accustomed
to seeing it that I thought it has existed
for a longer time. During this compara-
tively brief period it has created a place
for itself in Jewish life.
Its articles have been of a uniformly
high standard, and its point of view in
favor of intelligent traditional Judaism
has been highly influential. I am proud
to say that I examine its every issue most
carefully.
The Editorial Board of the Review de-
serves the thanks of the Jewish com-
munity. Please accept my heartfelt wishes
for its continued existence and influence.
MORDECAI M. KAPLAN, Chairman, Jew-
ixh Reconstructionist Foundation, inc.
I am happy to congratulate the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center Preview on its fifteenth
anniversary of publication and to wish it
many more years of continued service.
I believe that the Review is much more
than a synagogue bulletin. It serves the
purpose, or so it seems to me, of acting
as a link between the members of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center and all those
events in Jewish life which shape our
common future. In this way it fulfills
the purpose of emphasizing the common
soul which is the basis of Judaism.
I believe that this function, together
with the local function of acting as a
medium of disseminating information and
as an organ of self-expression for the Jew-
ish Center membership, makes the Review
one of the outstanding Anglo-Jewish pub-
lications extant today.
LEON CRYSTAL, News Editor, Jewish
Daily Forward
Warmest congratulations to the Center
as publisher and to the editors, con-
tributors and readers of the Brooklyn
Jewish Center Review on the occasion of
its Fifteenth Anniversary. It is impos-
sible to contemplate this first period in
the life of your publication without real-
izing that it began immediately after
Hitler's usurpation of power and is being
concluded right after the proclamation
of Jewish National Independence in the
State of Israel. It was during this most
devastating and most creative epoch of
our history that your publication served
a great Jewish community
I am confident that the Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center Review will continue to de-
velop and grow, pursuing the same ideals
and employing the same journalistic meth-
ods, which gained for it a prominent
place among the magazines in its field.
All those who have labored to make the
Review what it is today have every reason
to be proud of it.
SOLOMON DINGOL, Editor, The Day
I wish to commend you on the splen-
did job you are doing in spreading knowl-
edge of Jewish affairs among Brooklyn
Jewry, the largest Jewish community in
the world.
You have made the Review not only
an organ representing the Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center, but a magazine which can
stand comparison with the best American-
Jewish publications. It does honor to its
editors and contributors, and to the
Brooklyn Jewish Center at large.
Good luck and more power to you!
M. J. NVRENBERGER, Managing Editor,
Jewish Journal
I am happy to take this opportunity
of congratulating you on the splendid
work that the Revieiv is doing in ac-
quainting its readers with the problems
confronting world Jewry.
As a member of your community, I
hope that you will carry on in your good
work of enlightenment which the Jewish
people so need in these days.
LOUIS FINKELSTEIN, The Jetcish Theo-
logical Seminary of America
I am delighted to hear that the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center Review is celebrating
its fifteenth anniversary.
The Review has already become more
than a congregational journal. It has
contained articles of enduring, as well as
wide interest. All of us look forward
particularly to Dr. Levinthal's comments.
I want to congratulate the Editorial
Board on the excellence of the magazine,
and I hope that it may have many pleasant
anniversaries.
ABBA HILLEL SILVER
I was pleased to learn that the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center Review will celebrate
its fifteenth anniversary soon. Permit me
to send you my heartiest felicitations. I
receive the Review regularly and I have
found in it some very useful and stimu-
lating articles which I enjoyed reading.
It has also kept me informed about the
significant cultural and religious activities
of your splendid institution.
ABRAHAM A. NEWMAN, President,
Dropsie College
I am happy to extend cordial greetings
and felicitations to The Brooklyn Jewish
Center Review on the occasion of its fif-
teenth anniversary. Any publication or
activity which emanates from the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center and under the im-
primatur of my dear friend, the distin-
guished rabbi of the Brooklyn Jewish
Center, Doctor Israel Herbert Levinthal,
is certain to be constructive, Jewish and
forward looking.
[Continued on page 8]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Vol. XXIX
JUNE- JULY, 1948 — SIVAN-TAMMUZ
No. 41
DAVID MARCUS - SYMBOL OF A NEW SPIRIT
THE defense of Medinath Israel has
become a catalyst in Jewish life and,
in America, has changed and fused
currents of thought to a degree which
stirs the imagination and warms the
heart. During the half century since the
first Zionist Congress a relatively small
group of men and women labored and
fought in this country to widen the circle
of Zionist influence and increase the num-
ber of Zionist adherents. For more than
forty years this effort was successful only
to a relatively limited degree. Zionism
had, during this period in America, great
leaders; but their followers were not
always listed in the numbers which the
cause merited. The brilliant oratory of
a Wise, the logical clarity of a Lipsky —
these, and even the instinctive obligation
which the cause itself imposes on Jews —
met resistance in the materialistic influ-
ences of our environment.
Overnight, almost, this has miracul-
ously changed. With the exception of
the Council for American Judaism, its in-
finitely small number of adherents and its
deluded leader, all Jews in America are
united in a common bond in the deter-
mination that Medinath Israel shall sur-
vive and in an effort to make that deter-
mination play a useful and large part in
the magnificent struggle being waged by
our brethren in Israel. The United Jew-
ish Appeal, with its unprecedented and
enormous tax on the resources of Ameri-
can Jewry, is successful. The Red Mogen
Dovid is transfusing the blood of Ameri-
can Jewry into the veins of the wounded
of Israel and thus literally joining the
living pulse of the galuth with the Yishuv.
Jews in America are readying themselves
for actual battle at the side of their Israeli
brothers when that becomes possible, and
so we have already entered the fray.
The death of any Jew in the defense of
Israel is a blow to every other Jew. The
death of Col. David Marcus in the battle
for Jerusalem has brought a sense of di-
rect personal loss to many in our commu-
The Review 7s 15
Years Old
This issue is dedicated to the
Fifteenth Anniversary of the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center Review, founded
in 1933.
Though the youngest of Center
cultural activities, the Review is now
occupying a leading position in the
life of our institution. It was nat-
ural that the Center should supple-
ment the spoken word coming from
its pulpit and platform with an
organ of literary standing that
would reach the homes of its mem-
bership and become a welcome and
respected guest in the homes of
Jewish lay and religious leaders
throughout the country.
The greetings published in this
issue will indicate the fine reputa-
tion enjoyed by the Review.
The members of the Editorial
Board are grateful to the officers,
trustees, directors and members of
the Center who, by their encourage-
ment and support, have made pos-
sible the continued and uninter-
rupted publication of the Review.
They also thank the writers, too
numerous to list, tvho contributed
their talent to make the Review a
unique publication in the life of
American Jewry.
— The Editors.
nity. The number of his friends was
legion. The fact of the loss of his capa-
cities is at one and the same time hard
to realize and sad to admit. He had
given much of himself to peoples, to
governments and to causes. But he had
so much more left to give. His sure in-
stincts, implemented by a vast experience
in the varied fields of military tactics and
of governmental practice, would have
been an inexhaustible mine of value both
for the country of his citizenship and
for the new land which had captured his
love and enlisted his service. A man who,
in a short forty-seven years had already
contributed the service which constitutes
the record of David Marcus' life could
readily have been and would certainly
have become, a major figure on the
horizon of this day.
In the midst of the sorrow which
Colonel Marcus' death has caused, we find
at least this consolation: every man of
worth knows that in the last analysis men
live not for themselves but for the causes
which are the common heritage of hu-
manity. To serve these causes is a privi-
lege which must be paid for by the work
of the hand, the devotion of the heart
and, if need be, by the gift of life itself.
Colonel David Marcus knew this with the
sure knowledge that comes to men who
place their ideals above their gains.
Quietly, and with the genuine simplicity
and humility which was the half-way
mark of his character, he offered his ser-
vices and himself not only for the saving,
of the State of Israel, but for the great
principles which are inextricably bound
up with its salvation to the benefit of all
mankind. We, who are the beneficiaries
of such sacrifice, humbly acknowlege the
magnitude of his gift. We shall be spurred
on to greater efforts by his example. In
the annals of our people and in the mem-
[Continued on page 4]
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Greenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Goodstein, Treasurer Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthal, D.D., D.H.L, Rabbi Manuel Saltzman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
4
"JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES"
"waxy irra"
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
GOOD WORK WELL DONE
IN 1933 the Brooklyn Jewish Center
decided on an important venture — to
publish a magazine which should not
only record the activities of our institu-
tion, but which would endeavor to bring
to our members — and to many outside of
our institution — the products of some of
our best minds on all topics of vital in-
terest in Jewish life.
As far as I know, ours is the only con-
gregation in America that publishes such
a periodical. And the very fact that the
Review has appeared regularly these fif-
teen years and has long ago achieved rec-
ories of all peoples of good will — the
name of Colonel David Marcus will be
forever enrolled as one of mankind's
benefactors.
— William I. Siegel.
IRGUN FUND RAISING
UNJUSTIFIED
NOW that the State of Israel is actu-
ally a fact, recognized, by eight
states (not including Britain), there is a
necessity for the clarification of the status
of the Irgun Zevi Leumi in Israel and of
the many-named, but essentially single
group of its adherents in America.
Prior to the establishment of the Jew-
ish State, the Irgun was a military force
in Palestine. At the same time, in this
country a group of men, generally known
as the Bergsonites, propagandized on be-
half of the Irgun. Their efforts took the
form of numerous and successive commit-
tees, but essentially these committees
always had the same personnel. The fact
of their existence created debate and dis-
sention. Many people, with a genuine
love of the Zionist cause, could not un-
derstand why there was, for instance, the
Zionist Organization and, at the same
time, the American Committee for a
True Palestine.
Both the Palestinian and American
ognition as one of the leading Anglo-
Jewish periodicals in this land is indeed
cause for congratulations. For it shows
not only a daring spirit on the part of
the officers and members of our Center
but also a fine understanding and keen
appreciation of the value of the printed
word in moulding a healthier and more
intelligent approach to the many prob-
lems that face the Jew of our day. I
said it shows a daring spirit, because it
was not — and is not now — an easy task
for a Synagogue Congregation to publish
this magazine each month.
branches of the Irgun stem directly from
the Revisionist split from the World Zion-
ist Congress. The Revisionists left the
World Zionist Movement and formed
their own organization with their own
treasury. It is possible to feel a com-
plete sympathy with their disagreement
and at the same time deplore their action.
Today, however, the Irgun as a mili-
tary force has now been incorporated in
the national Israeli army. Its needs will
be cared for out of the country's treasury.
Its activities will be directed by the mili-
tary leaders of the State. Outside of the
military sphere, the Irgun will be nothing
more than a political party within the
State. As such, it has a complete right
of existence. But there is no longer any
right to make collections in America on
behalf of the Irgun under the pretext that
these monies will be used for the defense
of Israel. By agreement with the Gov-
ernment of Israel such collections have
all been channelled through the United
Jewish Appeal and all contributions
should be made to this source alone. The
Irgunists in this country would be true to
fact and honest in practice if they would
make acknowledgment of this principle
and cease their separatist activities.
W. I. S.
And it was a daring venture also be-
cause it imposed such a heavy added bur-
den upon our already overtaxed executive
and office staff. But all of them — from
our Administrative Director to the office
assistants who read the proofs and mail
the copies — all of them accepted this
added responsibility gladly and performed
the work with a zeal and devotion which
guaranteed the success of this venture.
Our Center Review served as a com-
panion aid to our pulpit. It brought the
message of the Synagogue to the homes
of our congregants.
The Review also has helped to develop
a Jewish cultural life. We have encour-
aged Jewish writers, and the pages of the
Review are filled with the work of many
to whom this publication served as an
impetus. Poets and essayists, writers of
fiction and of the current scene, found
in our Center Review a welcome and a
happy opportunity to develop their tal-
ents and to find an appreciative and an
encouraging reading public.
We rejoice in these accomplishments.
We are proud that our beloved Brooklyn
Jewish Center has this notable achieve-
ment to its credit.
We offer our sincere thanks to all who
made this work so successful, and we are
particularly grateful to the Chairman
and to all his associates on the Editorial
Board.
I know that every member of our Cen-
ter wants to see the Review grow in
strength and in influence, and I am cer-
tain that I speak for all its readers when
I say that it is our fervent hope that the
Center Review may celebrate many anni-
versaries of successful accomplishment in
the years to come.
EDITORIAL BOARD
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Louis J. Gribetz, Chairman
Joseph Goldberg M. H. Lewittes
Joseph Kaye Manuel Saltzman
I. H. Levinthal William I. Siegel
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
THE CENTER'S UNIQUE PROJECT-
THE REVIEW
AS THE interminable speakers at
the interminable banquets might
say, we are proud and privileged
to celebrate the 15 th anniversary of the
publication of the Brooklyn Jewish
Center Review. We are really proud, be-
cause, as you will note by the magnifi-
cent set of congratulatory messages pub-
lished elsewhere in this issue, many emi-
nent and expert people think well of us.
In fact, putting expected modesty aside,
we may state frankly that the Review
is unique in its field, which is the field
of Jewish institutional publications.
Members of the Center should be given
the pleasant information that whenever
there are national contests to select the
best institutional organ the Review is no
longer entered because the judges believe
it has no competitors. We know we are
being a bit forward to say this, but on
an occasion like the present we may be
excused for sounding our own trumpets.
Seriously, members of the Center have
every right to congratulate themselves
that they had the initiative, perseverance,
generosity and love of a cultivated life
to publish, even through the worst period
of depression, a magazine of the scope of
the Review. •
Fifteen years ago two members of the
Editorial Board of the Review trudged
up a creaking staircase in an ancient and
wavering building somewhere that mem-
ory recalls as a slum in Brooklyn, and in
an incredibly grimy and littered little
print shop prepared the first issue of the
magazine. Very fittingly, the one com-
positor wore a yarmalke. He was a de-
vout little Jewish gentleman and spoke
garbled English with a rich accent; yet
he did an excellent job in making up the
new publication. To this little skull-
capped printer, wherever he is now, go
our thanks for a good and loyal send-off.
The remarkable thing about the Re-
view then was that it was started during
the depths of the depression, when other
institutions were cutting down their ac-
tivities. At one time the Center was
obliged to ask certain members of its
staff to accept reductions in salary; but
the Review was inviolable, appearing reg-
ularly each month except for the vaca-
tion period of July and August, and with-
out any shrinkage in size.
It was intended to be a family journal
presenting material of Jewish interest. As
Leon Crystal, the News Editor of the
Daily Forward has pointed out in his
flattering letter, the Review began dur-
ing Hitler's rise to climactic infamy, and
celebrates its present birthday with the
birth of the Jewish state. During this
notable epoch of Jewish history this
magazine did what it could to inform
the Center members of what took place
in Jewish life, to guide opinion through
articles by capable writers, and to raise
the curtain on significant past events.
That this work was done reasonably
well is indicated by the fact that the
Review has a considerable mailing list of
people outside the Center membership.
Jewish leaders, lay and rabbinical, have
requested it and keep it on file. The late
Justice Brandeis was a regular reader, and
was meticulous in apprising the Center
office of any changes in his address.
The Review is a binder between the
ever-growing Center membership, not
By JOSEPH KAYE
only keeping it informed of the many
important undertakings of this institution
and disseminating its spirit, but bringing
news of Jewish events. Until the found-
ing of Israel made Jews newsworthy in
the English press, Jewish readers who
were unfamiliar with Yiddish had little
opportunity to know what took place in
the Jewish world. The Review provided
this information.
In accomplishing its purpose the Review
has served as a literary home for a goodly
number of homeless writers. The field
of Anglo-Jewish journalism is notoriously
poor. Publications derive their material
sustenance from advertising, and the
English-Jewish publication is in a pecu-
liarly unhappy position to receive ads.
Advertisers say that if they wish to ap-
peal to the Jewish buyer who does not
; . . . ii
\«,..<y
/W, MWui £w£< WW
One of several post- fa tnkt^
cards written by Louis
D. Brandeis requesting
that the Review be sent
to a summer address.
"I
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
6
read English they can reach him through
the Yiddish press; the other division of
Jewry, of course, reads the English news-
papers and magazines. Therefore, why
advertise in the English publications of
Jewish interest?
This has been the great handicap which
the Anglo-Jewish press has never been
able to overcome. Consequently, publi-
cations in this class must scbnorr their
way through life, if their ethics are not
especially strong, or lead a hand-to-mouth
existence. Some time ago the Review
published an article on Isaac M. Wise,
the famous pioneer of Reform Judaism.
It told how Wise, who had his own paper,
the Cincinnati Israelite, was obliged to
use fantastic methods to make ends meet.
So pinched was he financially that he
inaugurated the practice of publishing
the names of subscribers who were de-
linquent in their payments. The pro-
priety of this device never troubled him.
He had a cause in the Israelite and he
pursued it with burning zeal. "We shall
continue to write for the last ten of our
readers," he announced in an outraged
appeal to his supporters.
In such a pauperish existence Anglo-
Jewish journalism has generally lan-
guished. Editors do not pay for contribu-
tions — or pay token pittances; some edi-
tors lift material from other publications
without credit; some use syndicated ar-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
tides (which costs very little), most of
them poor.
The Review has made it an invariable
practice to pay its authors decently, rarely
avails itself of syndicates (except for
news furnished it by the excellent Jewish
Telegraphic Agency), never reprints
without full credit, and welcomes new
writers. Our files are full of letters from
satisfied clients.
One of the most interesting writers
developed by the Review is N. Pearlroth.
Pearlroth is the researcher for "Believe It
Or Not" Ripley. He is a tall, handsome
former Austrian officer who once relieved
the monotony of bank clerking in New
York by sending an item of strange in-
terest to Ripley, then beginning his career
as a cartoonist of weird facts on the old
Daily Mail. That started an association
that has continued since. Several years
ago we got to know Pearlroth and one
day at lunch were astounded by his de-
scription of some of the convolutions as-
sumed by Jewish surnames. We sug-
gested that he transfer his astounding
knowledge in the field of Hebraic monik-
ers for our benefit and he obliged. It
turned out there wasn't a Jewish name
that he didn't know the history of, and
his series on "What Your Name Means,"
was a popular feature of the Review for
a number of months. They were re-
printed all over the United States (often
without credit or payment, as usual) , in
England and South Africa, and formed
the basis for a series of articles in the
Day.
Another Austrian writer who had his
beginnings in the Review is Alfred
Werner, a clever, learned and adroit
journalist — quite a remarkable combina-
tion. Werner came to the Review soon
after he arrived here from Europe, where
he had served a grim stretch in Dachau
concentration camp. His English then
was such that his edited manuscripts
looked like cryptograms; today, within
only a few years, he writes the language
like a native. He has become one of the
most, noted Anglo-Jewish journalists in
the country, and certainly the most pro-
lific.
•
Among other refugees who found a
welcome in the Review was a German
lawyer, Dr. Ernst Warschauer. Dr. War-
schauer is not a professional author, and
writes only occasionally. What made
him attractive to us was his amusing
stories of his adjustment to American
life. A highly cultured gentleman, of
fine scholarship, the center of a coterie of
German intellegentzia in his Washington
Heights home, Dr. Warschauer was re-
duced to doing the most surprising and
menial jobs. Yet he never lost his sense
of humor. Other refugees were inclined
to mourn their old life and constantly
look back. Not so Dr. Warschauer. He
was forever grateful to this country,
happy to be here, and regarded his strange
experiences in making a living with cheer-
ful philosophy.
A quiet, very unobtrusive, gentle per-
son is Dr. Mark Soliterman, also a mem-
ber of the Review community. Dr.
Soliterman was a minor official of the
Bowery Savings Bank, did his daily job
in the foreign department as diffidently
as he went about all his daily living, and
recently retired. But the bank clerk was
a man of great erudition and fine liter-
ary ability. He hesitantly brought to
the Review various manuscripts dealing
with important literary figures and the
Review thankfully published them. He
is the author of striking studies of Dis-
raeli, Bernard Lazare and others.
7
Among the Review's favorite people is
Harold Berman, who has been faithful
to Anglo-Jewish journalism for many
years. Berman is continually annoyed by
lapses from the good Jewish living and
records them. But — for literary purposes,
anyway — he is a gentle soul, and pre-
sents his criticism with sympathy and
amiability.
One of the outstanding of the Review
contributors was Andre Spire, the emi-
nent French critic and authority on
poetry. Spire, when he was in this coun-
try, wrote for the Revietv a comprehen-
sive three-part history of French Jews
that is a noteworthy addition to studies
of Jewish life.
Among the Review's regular contribu-
tors is Rabbi Jacob S. Minkin, whose
writings are too well known to need com-
ment, Harry Wedeck, a teacher-author
with a unique style, Rabbi Leo Spitz, a
wise observer from New Haven, Dr.
E. N. Rabinowitz, the Center Librarian
and Leo Shpall, also of the Center staff
and an authority on Holy Day customs.
One of the Review's special prides is
the publication of a number of woodcuts
by Isac Friedlander. Friedlander is one
of the most powerful delineators of the
tragedies of Israel, and the full-page re-
productions of his prints were a wonder-
ful asset to the Review and its readers.
It is regrettable that there is no room
in this issue to reprint some of the fic-
tion which the Review has published. As
in general Anglo-Jewish journalism, An-
glo-Jewish fiction has not flourished. The
rewards, both material and spiritual, have
been so insignificant that few writers of
ability have been tempted to create
stories of Jewish life. In the non-Jewish
publication field, fiction of Jewish inter-
est is sometimes successful, but there
is little incentive for the good fiction
writer to contribute to Anglo-Jewish
periodicals. Nevertheless, we have pub-
lished some very fine work. Sylvan
Karchmer, a young veteran, has written
unusually understanding and at the same
time pungent tales of Jewish experiences
arising from the war; Joan Kinner did
some amusing and sympathetic studies of
children, and Jack Levine, a promising
young writer, had one story in the Re-
view, "Conquest," which told in very
dramatic terms, of a young war-worker's
determination to show a sneering foreman
that he could work as hard as anyone.
Many contributions to the Review
come from non-Jewish writers, most of
them intent on solving the problem of
anti-Semitism. They are all extremely
well-meaning folk who have discovered
the "Jewish Question" and are becoming
slightly fanatical about it. Their analyses
and remedies are painfully naive — being
based largely on the "fault" of the Jew
in building barricades around himself
through kashruth and opposition to inter-
marriage, and also on the fault of being
overly sensitive and looking for trouble
where there isn't any. How to answer
these writers with the tact prescribed by
appreciation is the editors' problem. In
extreme instances Rabbi Levinthal is
called upon to send a diplomatic reply.
Oddly, or perhaps characteristically,
humorous contributions to the Review are
rare. Once though we did get a batch
of manuscripts from a Jewish writer who
signed himself "Doctor of Humor." He
started his sales-letter by saying, "The
telling of stories and the swapping of
jokes has been one of the greatest of all
democratic institutions," and added: "I
think sometimes that people — whole
families of 'em — literally perish for want
of a good, hearty, whole-souled, mouth-
opening, throat-stretching, side-aching
laugh." But the doctor's laughter only
soured the usually sunny disposition pos-
sessed by the Review staff.
Among the interesting achievements of
the Review is the monthly column by
Rabbi Israel H. Levinthal. He was urged
to write it several years after the Review
began publication, and most of the
columns have been reprinted in various
magazines and newspapers. Perhaps the
most striking article Dr. Levinthal has
produced is the one titled "Futile Bas-
kets For the Bereaved." It is one of
the strongest and most humane criticisms
of the practice of bringing luxury re-
freshments into houses of sorrow.
•
The work that the Review is most
proud of is the founding of the Center
Library of Nazi-Banned Books. After
the Hitlerites threw the books of liberal
thinkers into the flames in that notorious
bonfire that history will never forget, the
Review initiated the creation of a home
for all the volumes committed to the
flames in Berlin, and to preserve it as a
monument to the victims. The library
was built up in the Center, and formed
the nucleus for the present large collec-
tion of books — one of the largest Jewish
libraries in the country. The task of as-
sembling so many of the Hitler-banned
books — some of them rare in this coun-
try — was a very difficult one, and for
days we were to be seen ransacking every
second-hand book store on Fourth Ave-
nue. The final books were obtained just
before the opening of the library, which
was dedicated at a notable banquet at-
tended by Prof. Einstein and Edwin
Markham, the poet, among others. Ein-
stein presented the library with a man-
uscript of his Field Theory, now one of
the Center's treasures.
•
During the entire fifteen years of
Review history the Editorial Board has
changed very little. The chairman was
and is Louis J. Gribetz, and with the
exception of Rabbis Lewittes and Saltz-
man, his colleagues have been the same
since the early days — Joseph Goldberg,
Joseph Kaye, William I. Siegel, with
Rabbi Levinthal, as an ex-officio member.
One member of the Board who used to
do valiant work has now settled in
foreign Mt. Vernon and cut himself adrift
from his moorings. He is Lester Lyons,
Dr. Levinthal's son-in-law. Lester used
to write the news for the Review, was
always punctual and did an excellent
job.
Since few Center members have ever
penetrated into the sacred sanctum of the
Editorial Board, here is a private view
of one of its meetings. Usually the
gathering is in Joseph Goldberg's own
office. There has been a long-standing
dispute as to which Board member has
the best record for lateness. The deci-
sion usually goes to Louis Gribetz, who
comes rushing in with an innocent smile
and wonders how it was possible that the
others should have arrived before him.
Once settled in various parts of the room,
the appearance of the Board is something
like this: Bill Siegel lolls on a chair, a
bland, cynical grin his usual expression;
Louis sits upright, benevolent and mag-
isterial; Joe Goldberg is the worried ca-
talyst, trying to fuse all things together
between a succession of calls, which he
answers with extraordinary good-nature;
[Continued on page 35]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
ANNIVERSARY MESSAGES TO THE REVIEW
[Continued from page 2]
As the organ of the Brooklyn Jewish
Center, the Revieu has played an impor-
tant part in molding the character of its
membership and in making the Center a
radiating source of strength and inspira-
tion to the Brooklyn Jewish Community.
I congratulate the Editorial Board and
extend to them my warmest good wishes
for the growth and progress of the
Review and its ideals.
LOUIS E. LEViKJHAL, Judge, Court of
Common Pleas, Philadelphia
I welcome this opportunity to con-
gratulate the editors of the Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center Review. I have found each
number of this periodical not merely in-
teresting, but instructive. Its high stan-
dard of excellence is precisely what one
would expect of a magazine published
under the auspices of an outstanding cul-
tural and spiritual institution like the
Brooklyn Jewish Center.
The new era which now dawns for the
Jewish people with the reestablishment of
the Jewish State in Palestine, presents a
challenge to all of us who are endeavor-
ing to preserve and enrich our spiritual
and cultural values wherever Jews live.
I am confident that the Review will dis-
charge its responsibility and will continue
in the future to educate, enlighten and
inspire its readers so that they too may
share in the glorious enterprise of assuring
a dignified and creative renaissance of
Israel.
JOHN IIAYNES HOLMES, The Com-
munity Church
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is
the best parochial publication I have ever
seen. Its report of your local interests
is remarkable, and the paper does not fail
to recognize as well the larger interests
of the community. I hope that this
organ of Jewish thought and life may
grow from strength to strength.
ISIDORE S. MEYER, Librarian, Ameri-
can J{>tcish Historical Society
Permit me to extend my hearty con-
gratulations to you and to the editorial
board on the occasion of the fifteenth
anniversary of the Brooklyn Jewish Cen-
ter Review. It is one of the few excep-
tions to the general type of Jewish com-
munal and synagogue publications that
comes to our Library.
Research students, who use our Library,
on occasion refer to the fine articles
printed in the columns of the Review.
For, in addition to the regular news items
pertaining to the daily activities of your
Congregation and Center, the Review de-
votes part of its space to the intellectual
and spiritual endeavors of our people here
and abroad.
ROBERT CORDIS, Rabbi, Rockatcay
Park Hebrew Congregation
The Brooklyn Center Review repre-
sents another pioneering step in American
Jewish life initiated by the Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center.
The leaders of this distinguished con-
gregation did not content themselves with
a mere congregational bulletin, which is
usually nothing more than a house organ
chronicling group activities and personal
items. Instead, they created a monthly
magazine in which high seriousness of
purpose and maturity of content are
wedded to an attractive format and popu-
larity of interest and presentation.
The editors of the Brooklyn Jewish
Center Review have consistently pro-
duced a monthly publication which ranks
with the finest periodicals of Jewish in-
terest in English. They are to be com-
mended heartily upon this unique medium
for enhancing Jewish life in America.
May the Review go forward for many
more significant anniversaries.
JOSHUA BLOCII, Chief, Jetvish Division,
New York Public Library
I have followed the progress of the
Revietv virtually from its very inception
and am very much impressed with the fine
service it renders to its community. In-
deed the publication serves as an example
worthy of emulation by other Jewish
community centers. However, I can not
help thinking that the great success
which the Brooklyn Jewish Center has
made, not only in connection with the
publication of the Review, but with the
manifold activities it carries on, could not
have been possible without the inspiration
and leadership of the Rev. Dr. Israel
Herbert Lcvinthal.
The Editorial Board of the Brooklyn
Jewish Center Review is indeed very for-
tunate to be able to draw upon his coun-
sel. No wonder the Review plays so fine
a role in promoting the ideas and ideals
which permeate American Jewish life at
its best.
MILTOIS JAMES FERGUSON, Chief Li-
brarian, Brooklyn Public Library
For fifteen years you have been enrich-
ing the periodical literature of the Brook-
lyn Public Library by sending us copies
of The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review.
To, have carried on such a work during
depression and war required strength and
determination which you and your asso-
ciates have met in full measure. May
we offer you our congratulations and best
wishes for the next fifteen-year period in
your history.
ALAN M. FAIRBANK, Bunker Hill Con-
gregational Church of Waterbury,
Conn.
Your very live and ably edited maga-
zine has been a treat and a source of trust-
worthy interpretation to me through
these years. May your work and influ-
ence increase during the years to come.
May God bless you and keep you, and
graciously guide you in the ways of truth
and service. Thank God for men like
Rabbi Levinthal and those who are active
in the work of the Center. You repre-
sent the very best influences alive in
Brooklyn today and throughout the
country.
ARMOND E. COHEN, Rabbi of Cleveland
Jewish Center
Your Review is in a class by itself.
No other congregation in America has as
yet succeeded in maintaining a compar-
able literary publication of such high
order. This magazine, published and
managed by laymen, points the direction
to a goal which others might well seek
to emulate.
I have no doubt that the publication
has exerted a greater influence than even
its editors recognize. The constant por-
trayal of the sound Jewish activities that
are conducted in your congregation has
offered inspiration to similar groups
throughout the country.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
SELECTIONS FROM THE REVIEW-1933-1948
When presenting an anthology it is customary to say that the col-
lection is the "7>esf" of whatever has been collected. The Review
herewith presents a brief anthology of material published by it during
the fifteen years of its existence. But we do not say it is the "fee*/" the
Review contains for the simple reason that we do not know what is
the best. "Z?es/" is a matter of personal preference, and what we think
is very good yon might regard with indifference. So we reprint this
selection merely as a sampling of the interesting articles, stories, edi-
torials and poems we have used.
Undoubtedly other contributions should have been included, and
would have been were we richer in pages or less fallible as surveyors
of our huge 15-year field. As it is, most of the material has been con-
densed. For this we beg the indulgence of sensitive authors and the
forgiveness of readers who may be aunoyed by abrupt transitions. The
reader is also warned against many seeming anachronisms in these
articles, siuce they were written throughout the years.
— The Editors.
CHAIM WEIZMANN *v louis lipsky
OF WHAT other national leader
present when peace was made at
Versailles can it be said that he
still holds the confidence of the people he
presumes to lead? All of them have
passed off the stage of public life. Some
of them died in the fullness of years,
honored and respected; others lost the
favor of their people; some are now in
exile. Two men of that period still re-
main central figures on the world stage
— Winston Churchill and Chaim Weiz-
mann. In the interval when he was not
in power, Mr. Churchill stood on the
sidelines in opposition, maintaining his
leadership through sheer intellectual
power; now he is the war leader of an
England fighting for all that is best in
the British Empire. With the exception
of two years when the Zionist Organiza-
tion was presided over by Nahum Soko-
low, Dr. Weizmann remained continu-
ously in power, continuously in the center
of the leadership, although frequently
the object of bitter personal attack; and
with his people today begins again a
struggle in the international field which
is expected to bring the movement closer
to its goal. He stood at the cradle of the
birth of the Balfour Declaration. He is
destined to play the chief part in the next
historic chapter which, it is hoped, will
tell the story of fulfillment.
What is the secret of Dr. Weizmann's
political endurance?
From the days of Theodore Herzl, the
Zionist approach to the political problem
was through the way of friendship and
sympathy. That friendship and sympa-
thy was to be evoked from certain states
and political leaders. Zionism had to
create a party qualified to make a
political alliance. Before that party
came into being, friendship and sym-
pathy were essential. Zionism did not
deal with power, but with justice and
sentiment. Herzl used the allegory of the
lion and the mouse when he spoke to the
Sultan; the mouse might be able to do the
lion a good turn, for which the lion
might be expected to be grateful. The
good turn Herzl had in mind was the
refunding of the Turkish debt. That
good deed slipped out of Herzl's hands.
When the Kaiser was spoken to, he was
more concerned with a German protector-
ate and with the road to Baghdad than he
was with the plight of the Jewish people.
Herzl soon found himself in the position
of a promoter who was nothing more
than a middle-man. Not all his ingenu-
ity could set up a scheme of genuine, mu-
tual political interests. There was noth-
ing he could pay for what he wanted of
the world. Therefore, he had to win
friends, nurture them at all cost, and to
look for more of them. The appeal was
to justice, self-interest, religious senti-
ment, which could not so easily be sup-
ported by demand or threat. In the
World War, we made a great deal of what
the Jews had done to prove their claims
to Palestine — the sacrifices they had
made, the colonies they had built, the
schools they were maintaining, the sym-
pathies Jews the world over had expressed
for the Allies in anticipation of the Bal-
four Declaration. But the Balfour Decla-
ration was a jewel set in a mosaic of many
motives, not the least of which was the
imperial interests of England.
•
From the days when — as a professor
of chemistry in Manchester — Dr. Weiz-
mann made his first approaches to Eng-
lish statesmen, it was quite apparent that
his most valuable assets was his ability to
win good-will and sympathy, and to
arouse the nobler feelings of the men
with whom he discussed the Jewish ques-
tion. He had to create good relations and
to maintain them. He built his influence
upon confidence, upon the reasonableness
of his case. He had to take into account
the state of mind, the manners and habits
of vis-a-vis. As part of this task, it was
also important to spread the mantle of
good-will to cover the Organization for
which he acted. It was essential that
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
both Ambassador and Government re-
main persona grata with the friends at
Court. Whatever his personal feelings,
no matter how provoked or tormented,
this was essential for Zionist policy until
out of the good-will and friendship,
parallel with its growth, the substance of
national values would be created in the
Promised Land. He accepted that as one
of the conditions of his Zionist life, and
has never been able to visualize any ra-
tional or reasonable policy under any
other theory.
•
It was a simple matter for Dr. Weiz-
mann to maintain this calm, farsighted
approach, but not so simple for the Zion-
ist movement. Within the forms of Jew-
ish life, there are always some semblance
of individual freedom of opinion and
freedom of action. In Jewish communi-
ties there was a reasonable degree of free
expression. But all Jewish life was paro-
chial. With the coming of Zionism, Jew-
ish life stepped upon a world stage. All
that was free and democratic in that life
— extending beyond the community —
poured itself into the Zionist movement.
The Zionist Organization was the first in-
ternational Jewish body which was con-
ducted in a public, democratic way.
Within the circle of Zionist life there was
freedom, and ideas varied and clashed.
Zionism was never a well-ordered, well-
managed affair, deferring to social re-
straint. It had all the vigor and reckless-
ness of a people long frustrated in ex-
pression, and now finding freedom to
speak its mind. In Zionist affairs, the
amenities had to take a back seat. Auda-
city, rudeness, controversy, demagoguery,
personal and group ambitions — all of
them settled in the cauldron of Zionist
life, which had its congresses, its confer-
ences, its public meetings, its newspapers.
Leadership had to bring ordered action
out of this clash of individualities and
groups. The mass either backs leadership
without reserve, or breaks it without re-
morse. To survive in this struggle, lead-
ership must be made of stern stuff. It
must be resilient and enduring. It must
have the ability to maintain its seat at
the rudder, in the stormiest weather. It
must be able to give and to "take".
The Zionist leader is called upon to be
a speaker. He must be able to expound
his ideas, and to defend them. He must
win support through speech. It is a fact
that Dr. Weizmann has been unfortunate
in his speaking to Zionists. How many
times has he been right in policy but
wrong in speech? How often did he
speak of things the Zionist movement did
not want to hear, and how often have
these indiscretions made him the center
of revolt which threatened the policies he
pursued? His utterances at one time in
Berlin, at a meeting of the Actions Com-
mittee will be remembered. He gave ex-
pression to his ideas of a "bi-national"
state, which produced an upheaval of
opinion which almost unseated him on the
spot. How often, when we were en-
raged with England, did he speak as if
he were defending the policy of the Man-
datory Government? And yet, in spite of
the provocation he often excited within
Zionist circles, he has carried on through
these many years and has maintained his
vision, his good nature and his strong
hold on the confidence of Zionists. He
remains the most exciting personality in
Zionist leadership because he has been the
indispensable Ambassador, speaking the
truth to both sides, at the same time, con-
veying to his own people the feeling of
utmost faith in the things they believed
in and in the feelings that excited them.
At no time was there any dissonance in
spirit and in faith between Dr. Weizmann
and the Jewish people. At all times it
was felt that he was a limb of the Jewish
body, that their loves and hates were his,
their sentiments and aspirations were his.
This has always been best expressed by
Dr. Weizmann's discussions in public
with the others — those who were not
with us. It is in his addresses to the
"others" that he is superb. In these
public utterances, what he says may not
always be in accord with programs or
with issues of the day, but through his
mouth speaks the quintessence of Zionism
— the dignity of an appeal, the persua-
siveness of a reasonable thought, the deep
emotion of a conviction about a matter
of justice.
•
In short, it may be said that he has
maintained his leadership through these
stormy days because his spirit and mind
were chained to faith, and this faith was
re-enforced by good common sense. He
never allowed the goal to be obscured by
feelings of indignation, the desire to give
vent to a sense of outrage. Herzl was
burned out after less than eight years of
strenuous political activity. His disap-
pointments were unrelieved. Dr. Weiz-
mann has had the good fortune of being,
from his earliest days, a disciple of the
essence of Achad Ha'Am's thought, and
then a believer in the thesis that the
growing national strength of the Jewish
people had to be utilized — with sanction
or without it — in the building of Pales-
tine. As the representative of the polit-
ical ideal, he operated simultaneously in
the two fields with the same intensity
an4 the same confidence of ultimate vic-
tory in both. A disappointment in one
direction was compensated for in the
other. He used the slightest political ad-
vantage for the maximum possible prac-
tical effort, and vice versa. This alter-
nation of program made life and leader-
ship possible and bearable. It enabled him
to maintain his good humor, not to take
things too seriously, to be always neither
too "high" nor too "low".
•
The world set up in 1918 is now
broken beyond recognition. It will have
to be reassembled and reconstructed if a
civilization, based upon justice, is to be
made to work again. The destructive
forces of the new barbarism have smashed
the old Galuth and created a Jewish world
of unparalleled suffering and endless wan-
dering. Since 1918, the Palestine of the
Mandate has become a Jewish Palestine
capable of absorbing hundreds of thou-
sands and of becoming, through its own
strength, that Jewish State of which
Herzl dreamed. Because the tragedy of
Jewish life is so appalling and involves so
large a part of Jewish life, the coopera-
tion we expect at the hands of the Vic-
torious Democracies will have to be ade-
quate to enable the Jewish people to cope
with the situation. Dr. Weizmann re-
ceived the Balfour Declaration as the
head of the World Zionist Organization.
It will be his good fortune — when peace
comes — as President of the Jewish
Agency, to negotiate for the fulfillment
of the Balfour Declaration. More power
to him!
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
II
I AM fascinated by names. Often when
I catch a new name I completely
ignore its bearer and it seems as if an
historical incident were recreated for my
personal benefit. The other day I was
trying to recall a name. By way of
mnemonic aid I continued to read my
newspaper, and came across a Russian war
communique. And that's where I found
a clue to the missing name. Among the
cities captured by the Russian armies that
morning was one named Levoca. But
surely, you will object, no man can be
named Levoca. You are right. To ar-
rive at the name it was necessary for me
to reconstruct the history of that city.
Levoca, now part of Czechoslovakia, for-
merly belonged to Poland. Its Polish
name was Lewkowice, pronounced Lef-
kovitze. There I had the name — Lefko-
vitze. The first bearer of that name had
been a native of Levoca.
The chief category of names is de-
rived from the native town of your first
ancestor who assumed a family name.
Names in this class are Wiener (from
Vienna), Pariser (Paris), Lembcrger
(Lemberg), Krakauer (Cracow), Grod-
ner (Grodno), Berliner (Berlin). The
very common name of Shapiro — or Spira,
Schapiro, Safier, etc., is derived from the
Palatine city of Speyr, the oldest Jewish
settlement in Central Europe. In the 6th
century, when a sizable Jewish commun-
ity settled in Speyr, the town's name was
Spira. This category can also be extended
to include Rappaport, a name created by
the famous 16th century Rabbi, Mena-
hem Abraham Rapa, from the Italian
rapa, turnip, and the "hame of his native
town, Porta, near Verona.
A second category is the occupational
one. I have a friend whose name Is Feit-
ler. His name means "Shirt Man," and
was first assumed by a village peddler
whose specialty was shirts. To this class
belongs names like Schlesinger (Silesian),
and Greenberger (native of Greenberg,
Silesia). Those who first assumed these
two names were not natives of the two
localities. The names mean that their
owners were engaged in the business of
selling Silesian linen, which in the 18th
century was the finest in the world.
Another occupational name is Kreisler
(sometimes spelled Chrysler). The man
who first bore it was a Feather Curler,
WHAT YOUR
that is, he prepared the feathers both for
millinery and featherbed use. Kruger
was first taken by a man who dispensed
wine in a country inn — krug meaning a
pitcher. Schroeder means butcher. But
don't conclude that if a man's name
is Muller, or Mocller, his agnate must
have been the operator of a saw or flour
mill. It is much more likely that he was
a Jewish mohel.
A little more difficult are the occupa-
tional names contracted into versions of
initials only. Such a name is Schoen,
which has nothing to do with the German
word meaning beautiful. Schoen as a
name represents the initials of the He-
brew "SHuliah Neeman," "a trustworthy
messenger," a title borne by the secre-
tary of the Jewish Community. A
similar name is Schatz, consisting of the
combined initials of SHuliah TZibur, the
official title of a Cantor.
•
Veritable princely names in this cate-
gory are Katz and Segal. Both have a
great age and belong to the oldest family
names in existence. Katz was a name
borne by no less a patriarch than Aaron,
the brother of Moses, and meant that he
was a Koben Tzedek, a true priest.
Segal, or Siegel, signifies "Prince of the
Levites," and means that the bearer is a
descendant of the tribe of Levi. Katz
has the same significance as Kohen, the
Polish Kaplan and the Italian Sacerdote.
Segal has the same meaning as Levy (or
Weil, which is merely a transposition of
the German "Lewi").
The next category truly delights me.
These are names bearing a romantic and
historical association. They include Shalit,
Heidt, Bash, Spanier, Shack, Shick, Saks.
Shalit resembles a Hebrew word mean-
ing "a ruler." But the name really has
two meanings. In the olden days it was
customary in addressing a superior, either
in a worldly or religious sense, to append
to the form of address the word "Shalit,"
representing the initials of the Hebrew
sentence, "SHeyihye L'orekh Yomin
Tovim." In time this sentence became a
' You Don't Know the Meaning
of Your Name Read —
NAME MEANS
By N. PEARLROTH
sort of attribute of respectability, until
its initials were adopted as a family sur-
name. However, in some cases the name
has been traced to a delightful Jewish
Sabbath dish called "Shalet," which every
Jewish child brought up in Eastern
Europe will recall with relish. I have
found the same dish in Spain under the
name of "Chuleta."
"Heidt" harks back to the days when
Germany was, as today, the most anti-
Semitic country in the world. It stained
itself with the blood of Jewish thousands
even in the Middle Ages. The children
of the slain were given the name of
Heidt, which is formed of the Hebrew
initials of an invocation reading "May
God avenge their blood."
A peculiar class of Jewish names in-
cludes Kaiser (emperor), Konig (king),
Bischof (bishop) and Minister. Since no
Jew could ever boast of having been an
emperor or a king — at least not since the
Khazar kingdom was destroyed by Russia
in the 10th century — these four high-
sounding names have been traced to a
Purim custom. On the eve of the fes-
tival troupes of amateur players would
visit the homes of rich Jews to offer
Purim performances. The cast always
included a king or emperor (Ahasverus
or Pharaoh) and a Prime Minister
(Haman or Joseph). From these theatri-
cal titles the family names originated,
for after a player had acted his Purim
role for many years he became identified
with it. Krol (Polish for king) and
krolevich (Polish for king's son), prob-
ably have the same background. Some-
times such a title-name would be trans-
lated into Hebrew. The famous French
composer Meilhac (for Melech, king)
traced his name to such a source.
That leaves only Bischoff (bishop) to
be explained. It was found that the name
is an all too human exaggeration of the
name Cohen (priest). Instead of refer-
ring to himself as "priest" to a local
German registrar, a man would promote
himself to "Bishop."
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
HOW had the 360,000 Jews of
France reacted to anti-Semitism
from about 1S80 on?
At the beginning, and above all dur-
ing the Dreyfus affair, their problem was
in effect to defend the principles of
equality and political and religious liberty
contained in the Declaration of the Rights
of the Man and the Citizen. Their cause
was the same as that of all French liberals
and republicans.
Among the defenders of republican
and democratic institutions they found
courageous and active allies. In 1882,
after the first Russian pogroms, Victor
Hugo presided over a committee of pro-
test and aid, members of which included
Jules Simon, one of the founders of the
Third Republic, Scheurer-Kestner, Alsa-
tian Protestant and militant republican
under the Second Empire; Gambetta,
Renan, and the Archbishop of Paris.
With the aid of Scheurer-Kestner, the
disciples of Gambetta, Jules Simon (and
after his death, illustrious members of
his family) , Havet, professor at the Col-
lege de France; Renan's daughter and
her husband, Jean Psichari, and Clemen-
ceau, the unhappy victim who had be-
come the symbol of the detested princi-
ples of 1789, were rescued from the
clutches of the royalists, Caesarians, and
clericals. French socialist youth joined
them, and at their head was Jean Jaures,
who had written: "The Jews are the ex-
ploited of history."
The pogroms of Kischineff (1893)
shocked French consciences profoundly,
and numerous pamphlets and protests
were circulated in which, next to Jewish
signatures, were to be found the names
of all the most outstanding in the ranks
of the defenders of the republic, among
them the great French poet and pamphle-
teer, the republican and Catholic Charles
Peguy.
The Chief Rabbi of the Central Con-
sistory of the Israelites of France was at
that time Zadock-Kahn, a man of ex-
treme culture and of great intelligence
and sensibility. Among the leaders of
official Judaism there were also a number
of personalities filled with the dynamic
spirit of the courageous youg men who,
in 1860, had founded the Alliance Is-
raelite Universelle. The Alliance was
A Famed Critic Reviews French- Jewish History
— Particularly of Assimilationists
THE JEWS OF FRANCE
then still truly universal, for the organ-
ization continued to intervene through-
out the world in behalf of those who
suffered because they were Jews. But,
after the elections of 1902, which
brought to power the parties of the Left
with whom the Jews had fought for
Dreyfus, there took place what has been
called "the Dreyfusian decomposition."
The ties of solidarity which had united
the partisans of Dreyfus, non-Jews as
well as Jews, were broken. Each one
joined the group in which his natural
interests lay. The upper Jewish bourge-
oisie, which had joined forces with the
radical groups, began again to think that
above all it was a bourgeoisie, and many
of them made advances to the more mod-
erate parties, even the parties of the
right, without remembering that the lat-
ter were their natural enemies. A sort
of weakening of the Jewish conscience
took place among the leaders of French
Judaism. The generation of 1860 had
almost completely disappeared. The men
who took their place, brought up as they
had been in a French environment, did
not dare to show more religious feeling
than their friends who were sons and
grandsons of Voltairians. They were los-
ing the sense of historical Judaism. Their
concern was, in short, to make their mark
in French Society, and while fulfilling —
through kindness, family tradition, or
ambition — their philanthropic duties, to
bar the way to everything which might
embarrass their easy life of assimilated
Jews.
Their man was the Chief Rabbi Israel
Levi, who, thanks, to their influence, was
elevated to the dignity of Chief Rabbi
of the Central Consistory after the death
of his father-in-law, Zadock-Kahn.
He was a distinguished man of learn-
ing, professor at the School of Higher
Studies at the Sorbonne, handsome, of
polished manners, worldly, subtle — with
more subtlety than strength — a veritable
Saduccean belonging to a priestly family.
He was much more interested in conserv-
ing for the Alliance and the other institu-
By ANDRE SPIRE
tions which gravitated about the Rab-
binate — which he had peopled with his
creatures — the large contributions which
the rich of all religions and all parties
distribute to those who become the ser-
vants of their desires and their interests,
than in safeguarding that which in the
course of the centuries had been the
spiritual and moral heritage of the Jewish
people. Through his feeble hands French
Judaism tended to empty itself of sub-
stance, to become something very insipid,
very mundane, and as has been said, "a
Judaism very much a la Louis-Philippe —
very commonplace."
•
Obedient to the instructions of medi-
ocre men who thought that they could
escape the attacks of their adversaries
by taking refuge in self-effacement and
silence, he put himself in opposition to
everything which might draw attention
to the Jewish world. He succeeded in
communicating his views to the "Alli-
ance," whose representatives, recruited by
a sort of co-optation, had no connection
with the Jewish masses, and also to the
Consistory of the Parisian Section, whose
contact with the masses was scarcely
greater, inasmuch as it was constituted
by an electoral body which, at most, in-
cluded hardly five to six thousand electors
among the 115,000 Jews of the Parisian
district.
Now two matters seemed especially
conspicuous, noisy, and therefore dang-
erous to these pseudo-representatives of
Jewish public opinion: the increasing im-
migration of foreign Jews, and Zionism.
Zionism had been founded by Theodore
Herzl in 1896 in the course of the Drey-
fus Affair because, by a truly prophetic
intuition, he had realized that if France
itself could have been so profoundly in-
fected by the anti-Semitic virus, then
the expansive power of the liberating
principles of the French Revolution was
nearing its end.
With regard to immigrants, the policy
of official Judaism was one of distrust.
Certainly its members continued to as-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
sist them in their misery; they established
schools to teach them the elements of
French, opened apprenticeships for them,
and helped them to find work. Inexpen-
sive housing quarters situated not far
from the center of Paris were established
to relieve the congestions of the Jewish
neighborhoods. But they did all they
could to assimilate into French life this
population which only asked to share in
its benefits. But this was found to be a
slow process, and it was quite annoying
that just as one generation was about to
become assimilated and lose itself in its
environment, another arrived with its
foreign customs. They did all they could
to separate the old Jewish families from
the new arrivals, who were considered
troublesome intruders. There was no
link, in fact, between the official institu-
tions and the immigrant groups. A sort
of protectionism erected its barriers be-
tween the assimilated Jews and the Jews
of East and Central Europe, who were
called by the generic name of Polacks.
I remember the rejection of a distin-
guished and highly educated young man,
a brilliant jurist and an excellent writer,
as candidate for an important situation
in a consistorial institution. When I
asked the Secretary-General of the group,
Mr. Silb, the reason for it, this gentle-
man, who believed himself a hundred-
percent Frenchman because he had short-
ened his name Silbermann by two syl-
lables, answered: "Impossible, absolutely
impossible for us, Monsieur, with such a
name as Ritbinot itch!"
In short, they did all they could to re-
move the immigrant from the territory
of the Republic, and to facilitate the de-
parture of those who had already settled
there. The Jewish Territorial Organiza-
tion, the ICA, founded in 1902 with
Baron de Hirsch's millions, after its staff
had yielded to the ideas of the directors
of official Judaism, was of magnificent
assistance in this well-known policy of
providing a one-way ticket.
The Judeo-French thought themselves
definitely established in French life. As
for the Jews of the rest of the world,
their liberation would take place gradu-
ally as liberal constitutions were estab-
lished or became stronger in Eastern and
Central Europe according to the model
of the French, English, and American
constitutions.
Zionism seemed to them an immediate
danger if the hopes of its founders should
meet with success. "Well then," the
anti-Semites were not slow to say, "if
you have a Jewish country in Palestine,
don't forget to join your brothers there.
For you can't pretend, in the German
manner, to have the right to a double
nationality. You must choose. You can-
not be at the same time Jews and French-
men."
•
This conservative attitude appeared
detestable not only to newcomers but
also to the sons and grandsons of immi-
grants who had become French citizens,
and even to descendants of old Jewish
families long established in France.
These young or still young men had in
the course of the Dreyfus Affair found
again their Jewish pride. When the Af-
fair was over, they did not return to the
timid bosom of the bourgeoisie. Having
mingled with the movement of the
People's Universities, they had remained
in contact with the working classes,
among whom they had met recent immi-
grants. They had studied not only the
history of the people of Israel but also
the bloody history of the Jewish people,
and through investigation and travel had
informed themselves concerning the eth-
nographic and juridical situation of the
Jews in the countries of Eastern Europe.
When between 1904 and 1909 the
"Cahiers dc la Quinzoine," by Charles
Pcguy, acquainted the French public
with the works and the Zionist and terri-
torialist activity of Israel Zangwill, it
was for many of them a thunderbolt.
On some his poem "Chad Gadya," the
refrain of the assimilated Jew who is
dying because he has lost his Jewish soul,
acted like a religious conversion — a flood
of tears, a sudden reorientation of an en-
tire life, the birth of an ideal. Some be-
came militant Jews. Others felt the need
to pour out, to express in song, their re-
gained Jewish consciousness. A Jewish
literature in the French language was
born in which, side by side with their
elders Bernard Lazare, Gustave Kahn and
Andre Spire, there were ranged little by
little the poets Henri Hertz, Henri
Franck, Edmond Fleg, Ivan Goll, Ben-
jamin Fondane, Ilarie Voronka and the
novelists Jean-Richard Bloch, Armand
Lunel, Elissa Rhaiss and Lily Jean Javal.
The action of this militant Jewish lit-
erature made itself felt especially in the
years which followed the signing of the
Peace Treaty.
Official Judaism began to withdraw its
opposition. Thenceforth it took a hand
in the task of reconciling the various
factions of Judaism.
ON JAN MASARYK B y Joseph goldberg
An Editorial — Published January, 1939
THE recent United Palestine Appeal
■ Conference gained in significance
through the presence of Jan Masaryk, son
of the founder and first President of
Czecho-Slovakia. Himself a distinguished
diplomat, serving until recently as his
country's Minister to London, Jan Masa-
ryk played an important role in the his-
toric negotiations preceding the fateful
Munich settlement. He saw his beloved
homeland abandoned by its former friends
and allies and left at the mercy of Hitler
in their policy of "appeasing the dic-
tators."
Disillusioned at the sight of a dismem-
bered Czecho-Slovakia turned into a vas-
sal of Nazi Germany, he resigned his
diplomatic post and resolved to champion
the cause of another historically tragic
people and to work for their rehabilitation
in their ancient homeland, Palestine.
Addressing the Washington Conference
he said: "Three months ago I stood be-
fore the Government of Great Britain
and demanded justice for the Czechs.
Now I stand before you in Washington
and appeal in behalf of another minority
— the Jewish people. I want to hope that
this time I shall be more successful. When
the superpogrom broke out in the land of
Goethe, Heine, Bach and Handel, I real-
ized that my place was with the Jewish
brethren, and that the suffering of my
people has made my cause your cause and
your cause my cause. And here I am!"
Jan Masaryk is, indeed, a welcome guest
in our midst. We clasp his hand of
friendship in a common hope that the
dark clouds hovering over mankind today
will disappear and real civilization will
again be enthroned in the world.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
IT WAS in September 1932 when I had
the rather doubtful pleasure of being
faced by the hateful eyes of the
Fuehrer-to-come. Few jews have been
in such direct contact with him as I have
been. At that time he was a witness and
I was counsel for the defendant in a law
suit against an Aryan writer named Abel.
This Abel had testified under oath in a
previous suit that Hitler had received
money from Mussolini; since Hitler de-
nied this fact Mr. Abel was indicted for
perjury.
In the course of this procedure Hitler
WHY HITLER
attempted to shout vehemently, as he
always did when accused of defamatory
and low actions. When I started cross-
examining him he became excited and
confused, and was at a loss for answers.
I could clearly see hate distorting his face,
and finally he cried: "I refuse to give an
answer to a Jew lawyer."
I then moved for his punishment for
contempt of court, and the judge sen-
HATED JEWS
By DR. KURT ROSENFELD
Pre-Hitler Prussian Minister
of Justice
Published November, 1938
tenced him to a fine of 1,000 Reich
marks.
At that time there were still judges in
Germany.
At that time I asked myself as I have
since: Why, after all, does Hitler hate
the Jews?
Historians attempt to find the answer
in his own life. It has been said that
Hitler, as a youth, had some unpleasant
experiences with a Jew which thereafter
prejudiced him against the entire Jewish
race. Yet there are no facts to substan-
tiate such an origin of his anti-Semitism.
It is true from his twentieth to his
twenty-second year Hitler lived in Vienna
among what is called in German lumpen-
proletariat. At that time he made his
living by shoveling snow in the winter
and begging in summer; he ate his daily
soup in the public kitchen and spent his
nights in the shelter maintained by the
twentieth borough in Brigittenau, where
he constantly met the poorest of the poor
Jews. He pretended to have learned dur-
ing this time that it is possible to recog-
nize Jews as Jews only by their noses.
He held to this absurd theory even later
when he met other Jews. He stressed
the fact that the appearance of Jews dif-
fers from that of the German people.
The dominating party in Vienna then
was the Christian Social, which fought
both Jews and Socialists. Its leader was
Mayor Karl Luegcr, whom Hitler has
praised as the "most outstanding mayor
of all times." I remember this man very
well. I heard his first speech when he
began his duties as mayor. It was filled
with blind hatred against socialists and
Jews. Yet he fought rather religion than
race.
In 1912 Hitler left Vienna for Munich.
He said: "This melting-pot of races of
which the capital consists filled me with
utter disgust. I hated this mixture of
Czechs, Poles, Hungarians, Ruthenians,
Serbians, Croatians. Among all those
people grew the eternal parasites of
IN THE FOREST OF HEDERA
By DAVID SHIMANOVSKY
Translated from the Hebrew by Mordecai H. Letvittes
An excerpt from the long poem by the noted Palestinian poet.
REB BEREL reclined and smiled as he watched the mounting clouds,
To him it seemed as if higher and higher ascended the clouds,
They appeared to grow bluer and finer, until soon the eye could perceive
The highest welkin, through rifts in the canopy of leaves . . .
These few days past he'd been ill, hence burdened with labors light,
He would fetch the water from springs or cook the porridge at dusk
To appease the famished company . . . But now he was free
To lie flat on his back in the shade of thick eucalyptus trees:
He recalled how he hiked on the Sabbath to Zichron Yaakov:
The spring new moon had been blessed, the Passover feast was nigh,
Since morning the sun beat down, and the cattle herd in the swamp
Half-emerged from the mire and basked themselves in the warmth of the sun,
As they shook their heavy heads, and inhaled the pure spring air,
While unswervingly rose the mists from the pestilential pools;
The clouds turned blue that enveloped the Shomron mountain tops;
With sprightly mincing feet walked the girls in Zichron's streets,
In their braids anemones fiery, while their eyes sparkled brightly and glimmered;
They were clothed in embroidered linen, their raiment, transparent and white . . .
Spring's harbingers were here; and the youthful pedagogues
Who slowly trod at night beside pretty sun-tanned maids,
Pedagogic difficulties unwittingly forgot,
As they dreamed with those they escorted of a hike to Jericho's plains . . .
On Bat Shloma's winding hills weird cries had frightened the herds,
And once more the shepherds related that a "Debah" was seen on the mount
That wandered from hill to hill and fearfully laughed and cried . . .
Spring's harbingers were here; the waters had not yet dried
From ravines of the glens and glades; the valley streams still flowed
With a joyful roaring shout . . . And Berel recalled and smiled:
He was walking by Shomron's mounts, and sorrow sucked at his heart,
His strength and life-flame had been dimmed because of his people's sad lot.
Of a sudden the stream was before him. It followed a sinuous course,
It wound its way amidst the cliffs, joyed to greet the rocks in its path,
Its foamy locks were youthful and pure, 'twas all spring joy . . .
He quickly removed his shoes and crossed the stream on foot,
Its cool waves caressed his flesh, the hum penetrated his soul,
'Twas pure delight to his heart; he forgot his people's sad lot,
He was passing the Jordan at Gilgal ...
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
humanity, the Jews. Jews and Jews
again. The capital seemed to me to be
the incarnation of incest."
After the war ended, Hitler held the
Jews responsible for Marxism, which he
hates as deeply as he does the Jews them-
selves. Marx' doctrine is, according to
him, a product of the Jewish race and
its tool to conquer the world. Evidently
he does not know that neither Hegel nor
Feuerbach, whose philosophies decisively
influenced Marx were not Jews; or that
Marx' closest collaborator Engels and
Kautsky, who did more than anybody
else to propagate Marxism, and Lenin,
who further developed Marx' original
ideas, were all Gentiles. Hitler does not
know that Marx considered assimilation
of the Jews as the only solution of the
Jewish question. He refuses to see what
he does not wish to see. The Nazis never
listen to objections at their meetings.
They tolerate neither contradiction nor
discussion. During the period of the
Weimar Republic, when somebody at-
tempted to raise a question at such a
meeting he immediately found himself
thrown out. The National Socialists
knew very well that it would be easy to
refute them if they permitted free dis-
cussion.
Hitler's strongest argument against the
Jews always has been and still is that
world Jewry is striving for world domi-
nation. He constantly talked himself and
his followers into believing that world
Jewry is plotting to subjugate the Gen-
tile world.
But there were more concrete and ef-
fective arguments used by National So-
cialist agitation. After the war one
economic crisis after the other shook the
German people. Unemployment grew
worse and worse. Millions of unem-
ployed were condemned to idleness. To
these millions Hitler pointed out the Jews
who still had property and kept their
positions. The unemployed Jews were
not as noticeable as the well-to-do Jews.
Thus it was rather easy to incite the low-
est instincts of competition by drawing
attention to those Jews who played an
important part in the public, economic,
financial, and commercial life of the
country, as well as to those Jews who
had distinguished themselves in the pro-
fessions and arts. By demagogic means
it was possible to promise liberation from
unemployment by displacing or expelling
a few thousand Jews. The Nazis are
masters of propaganda and their dema-
gogic method was all the more successful
since there was no effective counter ac-
tion on the part of the Jews. The ma-
jority of the German Jews were con-
vinced that silence was the safest way to
remain inconspicuous and so to escape
persecution. Frequently one heard the
opinion voiced (and unfortunately this
opinion is still alive in other countries)
that the anti-Semitic movement assumed
This story was written in 1901
and published in a Viennese paper in
1903. Its moral reflects the posi-
tion of the Jew, "the gentleman
with the green necktie" in a preju-
diced world. The translation was
authorized by Heinrich Schnitzler,
son of the late poet.
IN A small house on the outskirts of
the city there lived in complete pri-
vacy a young gentleman named
Cleophas. One morning, however, he
was seized with the desire of venturing
out in the park. Therefore he dressed
carefully as was his habit, choosing a new
green necktie, and took himself off. The
people he met greeted him politely, no-
ticed that the green tie suited his com-
plexion perfectly and for several days
they talked with great admiration of Mr.
Cleophas' cravat. Some of them tried to
imitate him, but their ties were made of
inferior material and tied without chic.
Some time later Mr. Cleophas took an-
other walk in the park, in a new suit,
but wearing the same green tie. There-
upon some people shook their heads
gravely and remarked: "Again the green
tie! It seems that's the only one he has."
Those who were ill-tempered as well as
envious exclaimed: "He'll drive us crazy
with his green tie!"
The next time Mr. Cleophas appeared
he wore a blue necktie. Some observed
shrewdly: "He can't make us believe
that this tie is blue. It must be green."
Next time when Mr. Cleophas took a
walk he was dressed as carefully as usual,
15
political importance only because of those
Jews who protested against anti-Semitism
or fought it.
It is always in periods of economic
crisis that Jew baiting grows most suc-
cessfully. The rise and fall of anti-
Semitism corresponds to the rise and fall
of economy; with almost mathematical
precision one can prove that economic de-
pression always provokes a high tide of
Jew baiting and that correspondingly,
during periods of economic prosperity
there is a low tide of anti-Semitism.
and wore a tie of the most beautiful pur-
ple. But when, from a distance, the peo-
ple saw him approach, they jeered: "Here
he comes, the man with the green tie!"
There was, however, a few individuals
who could not afford to wear anything
around their necks but a string. They
explained that this string was most dis-
tinguished, and the dernier cri of fashion.
Anyway, they hated everyone who wore
a tie.
When Mr. Cleophas appeared in the
park again, the noisy man with the string
around his neck shouted: "The men with
the green ties are thieves!" And some
people shouted with him.
And when he returned once more, the
entire crowd, led by the noisy fellow with
the string tie, screamed: "The men with
green ties are murderers!" Cleophas no-
ticed that many eyes were focused on
him. Remembering that he too had
occasionally worn a green tie, he turned
to this fellow and asked: "Precisely
whom do you mean? Perhaps me?"
Whereupon the other replied suavely:
"But Mr. Cleophas, how can you think
that — ? You don't wear a green tie!"
And he shook hands with him and
assured him of his deep respect.
Cleophas bowed and left. But as soon
as he had gone far enough, the man with
the string around his neck clapped his
hands and exclaimed: "Did you see how
it struck him? Who dares doubt now
that Cleophas is a libertine, a thief and
a murderer!"
THE MAN WITH THE GREEN NECKTIE
By ARTHUR SCHNITZLER
Translated by Alfred Werner
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
An Old-New Tale of the Old-New Land
22 DIED IN ELIEZER DON
SLONIM'S HOUSE
On August 24, 1929, occurred the
terrible massacre of Jens by the
Arabs in Hebron, Palestine. Rabbi
Gottesman, u Jjo had studied at the
Yeshivah in Hebron, and knew most
of the victims, was one of the
Americans affected by the tragedy.
TW ENTY-TW O died in the home of
Eliezer Don Slonim, and he the first
of them, on the morning of August
24th. His heroic martyrdom in death
was characteristic of the man. With him
died his wife, Hannah, their little son
Aaron, and a younger child.
Eliezer Don, manager of the local bank,
was the son of Jacob Joseph Slonim,
Rabbi of Hebron; his wife, the daughter
of Rabbi Orlansky of Zichron Jacob.
His interests were wide, embracing all
of modern life and centering particularly
upon Jewish affairs. He was a protago-
nist of the Zionist movement, and an
ardent supporter of the Mizrachi. To the
latter organization he was devoted with
heart and soul. A man of culture, both
worldly and Jewish, an accomplished lin-
guist, he found time among other things
to be the correspondent of the Hebrew
Palestinian daily newspaper Haaretz, in
Jerusalem. He used the pen-name
Haduny.
•
It is noteworthy that in his column
Chadushot W Hebron he gave a good
deal of space to the Arab community,
describing their doings and their progress
in very friendly and constructive terms.
He knew the Arabs well and was on
terms of best friendship with them. On
cold nights during the rainy season, when
the best Arab homes are none too com-
fortable, the local Sheiks were accustomed
to gather in Eliezer Don's house, to talk,
and play chess, and drink black Arabian
coffee.
He, Slonim, did much for the Arabs
in general and for their leaders and poli-
ticians in particular. Many were the
favors he obtained for them, which in-
cluded loans. He had much faith in the
Arabs — far more than later events jus-
tified.
I recall how once, when he had to
transfer £5,000 in gold from the bank
in Hebron to Jaffa, he took along just
one Arab as a guard.
No one of any importance who came
to Hebron failed to visit the hospitable,
charming home of Eliezer Don and Han-
nah Slonim. No one ever failed to find
a welcome there. On holidays the older
students of the Yeshivah would gather
at his home to sing and make merry. Not
every home was thus open to the students
— for some of the old generation Hebron
Jews were not heartily in favor of the
new constructive spirit that had come in-
to Palestine and of which the Yeshivah
was one of the most conspicuous mani-
festations. For this reason Eliezer Don
was loved by all the Yeshivah bahurim.
On the Saturday of the massacre a
large number of people were gathered in
the house of Eliezer Don Slonim, includ-
ing his wife, his two children, and his
wife's parents, Rabbi and Mrs. Orlansky,
of Zichron Jacob.
Shortly before that fatal day, Han-
nah's parents came to Hebron to visit.
It was thus that they were present when
the unbelievable atrocity was perpetrated.
It is no wonder that so many people came
to Eliezer Don's home for shelter when
it became evident that the Arabs were
on the rampage. Could it be that they
would forget his friendship — his wife's
kindness?
•
As a matter of fact they did not for-
get. A number of Arabs came knock-
ing at his door. Give us the strangers
you are harboring there, they cried, and
we will spare you, and your kinsfolk.
His answer, a culminating step in his
martyrdom, was characteristic of the
man:
"I have no strangers here — only my
brethren!"
Eliezer Don had a revolver, which he
was licensed to carry because of his posi-
tion in the bank. When they shattered
the door, the Arabs found themselves
facing Eliezer Don, revolver in hand; be-
hind him, the huddled crowd of men and
women and children. Eliezer Don pulled
By RABBI LEO GOTTESMAN
the trigger. The revolver had never been
used. It jammed. They sprang upon
him, and so he was first to die.
Hannah was not killed by the Arabs.
She died there because her heart burst
when she saw her husband murdered.
Little Aaron they killed, and the
younger child.
Hannah's parents they killed.
Twenty-two, in all, died in Eliezer
Don's house. Twenty-two martyrs.
Their souls rest in peace.
There Were no arms in the house — ex-
cept Eliezer Don's revolver that failed.
The people were defenseless.
Two were saved in that house as by a
miracle. A girl of fifteen, Hannah's sis-
ter, was pushed into a closet by Lazar
Yanishker — one of the students in the
Yeshivah. Yanishker, twenty-four years
old, powerfully built, was known as the
giant of the Yeshivah. He held the girl
confined in the closet during the mas-
sacre. When she saw her parents killed
— she was watching through a crack in
the door — she would have screamed.
Yanishker held her mouth — held it so
tightly that her lips were swollen and
distorted for weeks after.
When the Arabs had done slaughtering
they turned to plunder. They tried to
open the unlocked door of the closet.
Yanishker held its handle inside — held it
so fast that they gave up trying to pry
the door open. He saved his own and
the girl's life thereby — much more than
he could have done, despite his physical
prowess, had he tried to face the armed
killers.
The Arabs had not forgotten the
friendship of Eliezer Don Slonim.
Because this is a special is-
sue of the Review, most of the
customary material, including
the Monthly News Survey, had
to be omitted.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
Because Ravel Wrote "Kaddish" He
Was Not Necessarily a Jew
WHO ARE THE JEWISH
COMPOSERS?
A GREAT deal of dishonest jour-
nalism, combined with a ten-
dency of many to be influenced
by superficial evidences, has so obfuscated
the subject of Jews as great composers
that a great many famous composers are
today accepted as Jews even though they
did not have the remotest connection
with our race. As one who has done a
great deal of research in this very field
in this country and in Europe, I should
like, once and for all, to throw some il-
lumination upon a sadly confused subject.
Our greatest composer was, of course,
Felix Mendelssohn — one of the towering
figures in Romantic music — in whose
veins flowed the Jewish blood of his
grandfather, Moses Mendelssohn. Before
Mendelssohn only one great creative fig-
ure is deserving of our attention. He is
Salamone Rossi, a composer of great
stature, who deserves to be better known.
Rossi, who called himself "Ebreo" ("The
Hebrew"), was born in Mantua in 1587
and died in the same city in 1628. He
was a court musician to the Duke of
Mantua, and in that post fulfilled a his-
toric role.
•
There were other Jewish musicians in
the court of Mantua (Allegro Porto and
Abrama Delia Arpo Ebreo) as well as in
the court of Pope Leo X (Giovanni
Maria, Jacopo Sansecondo), but these
composers have long since been forgotten
and need not detain us.
In the field of opera, the following
Jews were of far-reaching influence and
importance: Karl Goldmark, Jacques
Halevy, Giacomo Meyerbeer, Jacques
Offenbach. Karl Goldmark wrote a re-
markable opera called "The Queen of
Sheba" which is drenched with Oriental
colors. Jacques Halevy is best known,
of course, for his masterpiece, "La Juive,"
familiar to every lover of grand opera.
Meyerbeer — one of the great contributors
to operatic literature — produced a series
of masterpieces, including "Les Hugue-
nots," "Le Prophete," and "L'Africaine."
And Offenbach, of course, was the in-
comparable master of opera-buffa, though
his grand opera, "Tales of Hoffmann,"
is a classic.
At this point, I should like to raise
the name of Georges Bizet, composer of
"Carmen," who has frequently been
spoken of as a Jew. Bizet was married
to a Jewess — the daughter of Jacques
Halevy. On this basis, many have
ascribed a Jewish origin to Bizet which
all modern research denies. I have dis-
cussed the subject with musicologists in
Paris as well as with some Jewish organ-
izations there, and they all insist that
there is no Jewish blood in Bizet.
Among the great instrumental com-
posers who were undeniably Jewish were:
Stephen Heller (a talented composer for
the piano), Gustav Mahler, Moritz Mosz-
kowski, Nachez, Napravnik, Anton
Rubinstein, Karl Goldmark, Henri Wieni-
awski, and Max Bruch.
Bruch's Jewish ancestry has been fre-
quently questioned. There are numer-
ous musicologists — Alfred Einstein among
them — who insist that Bruch was not a
Jew, notwithstanding the fact that he
composed the remarkable "Kol Nidre."
These musicologists, no doubt, base their
convictions on the fact that several of
Bruch's ancestors held ecclesiastical posts.
But there are numerous other historians
who insist upon Bruch's Jewish origin.
Brahms, his personal friend, spoke of him
as a Jewish composer — and Brahms would
not have made such a statement about a
friend if he had not known the facts.
The question of Richard Wagner's
racial origin has been subjected to a great
deal of controversy. It has been long
debated whether Richard Wagner was the
son of Karl Friedrich and Johanna Bertz
Wagner, or whether he was the illegiti-
mate son of Johanna Bertz Wagner and
the Jewish actor, Ludwig Geyer. Equally
imposing arguments have been summoned
for both sides of the debate. However,
recently, the famous Wagner authority,
Ernest Newman — after many years of
painstaking research into Wagneriana —
has come to the inescapable conclusion
that Wagner was the son of Geyer, hence
a Jew by birth. Newman has presented
his conclusions in the latest volume of his
monumental "Life of Richard Wagner"
(vol. 3), published a year ago. These
By DAVID EWEN
conclusions were based on two documents
which Newman discovered. One of
these proved that Johanna Wagner, and
her infant Richard, traveled from Leip-
zig to Teplitz to visit Geyer (Karl Fried-
rich was still alive). Such a difficult
journey required strong motivation, in
the opinion of Newman; and the motiva-
tion, according to Newman, was that the
mother was taking her child to see his
rightful father. The second document
was a letter written by Wagner in which
he spoke of Geyer as "father," and with
tenderness and affection.
•
Among modern composers, we find nu-
merous Jews who hold a dominating posi-
tion. In France there have been Paul
Dukas and Darius Milhaud, both of un-
deniably Jewish birth. It is strongly be-
lieved that Maurice Ravel was a Jew,
largely because he wrote some exquisite
Hebrew songs, including "Kaddisch."
But Ravel himself told me that not a
drop of Jewish blood was in his veins,
and when I later visited his birthplace in
Ciboure I had occasion to see his birth-
papers and ascertain for myself that he
could not have had any Jewish ancestry.
Leading German-Jewish modern com-
posers include Kurt Weill, Paul Dessau,
Karol Rathaus; Jewish composers of note
from Vienna include Arnold Schoenberg,
Alexander Zemlinsky, Ernst Toch, Erich
Korngold, and Egon Wellez. Other Euro-
pean composers of our times of whose
Jewish origin there is no question include:
Alexander Tansman (Poland), Castel-
nuovo-Tedesco (Italy), Jaromir Wein-
berger (Czechoslovakia), Leo Weiner
(Hungary), Arthur Benjamin and Fred-
erick H. Cowen (England), and Alex-
ander Veprik (Soviet Union).
Leading serious composers in America
who are Jewish include: Marc Blitzstein,
Ernst Bloch, Abram Chasins, Aaron Cop-
land, George Gershwin, Rubin Goldmark,
Louis Gruenberg, Frederick Jacobi, Lazare
Saminsky, and William Schuman.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
SCIENTISTS say that scientific
knowledge is based on the aphor-
ism, "See in order to foresee."
What do we sec today?
(1) A crisis in Democracy.
By trial and error, man evolved a new
scheme of government and life — Democ-
racy. It came as the crown and flower
of human civilization, just as man came
last in an ascending series of earthly crea-
tures. It is superior to every other form
of government as man is superior to
animal.
Mankind greeted the democratic pro-
gram with joy, a universal gladness such
as the exuberance with which all living
things respond to springtime.
Why? Because this program rescued
nations from feudal tyranny, emancipated
the individual man from oppression and
restrictions on liberty, and gave him
political equality and social, economic,
and political justice. Modern democracy
elevated the whole human family and
made it conscious of a destiny of progress
in freedom and in the humanities,
e
The freaks of time and fortune how-
ever are playing strange tricks in our
generation. Suddenly a flood of anti-
democratic reaction is over-running the
world. That which only yesterday was
universally adored and reverenced is now
being condemned and flouted.
Heads of governments openly despise
the ideals of democracy and class them
as tragic legends of bygone days. Many
lands have abolished altogether demo-
cratic institutions. Everywhere men are
recreant to the traditions and ideals of
democracy. Everywhere democracy is on
the defensive.
(2) We see a crisis in Jewry.
The attack on democracy has unsettled
the whole order of civilized life. It has
unloosed man's worst passions and organ-
ized cruelties.
For the Jews particularly the assault on
democracy has had a special, direct and
most acute significance. It is our his-
toric fate to be among the first bene-
ficiaries of civil and religious liberty and
the first victims of intolerance. Our ex-
istence rests on liberty and justice, on tol-
erance toward minorities, on respect for
the weak.
A prominent British journalist who vis-
AMERICAN JEWRY HOLDS THE
DESTINY OF THE JEWISH PEOPLE
ited America three years ago said to
American Israel: "You may take it from
me as a simple statement of fact that
European Jewry has disappeared. Jewry
as a community, as a body that means
anything in a communal sense, has com-
pletely vanished. For God's sake, take
over the control of Jewry. Take over the
leadership of Jewry and save what there
is to be saved of our Jewish people."
This spectacle, held out to us three
years ago, is even more real now. Wher-
ever our gaze turns we painfully witness
the same tragic conditions — a dreary uni-
formity of sorrow and disaster. In re-
lentless, continuous succession calamity
follows calamity. In Russia spiritual and
cultural Judaism is in utter stagnation,
terrible decay. The Jews of Germany
seem like a desolate valley of dry bones
with no sign of life. Jewry in Hungary
is a lifeless imitation of what it once was.
Austrian and Czechoslovakian Jewry is
a pitiful mass — just so much prey and
plunder to barbaric rapacity. Polish
Jewry is in want and despair.
The assault upon civilization has ex-
posed world Jewry to catastrophes un-
paralleled in 2,000 years of history.
(3) But out of the dark night there
shines forth like a morning star the lumi-
nous figure of American Jewry. Even
as in the days of old, when the sun of
Jewry set in the East it began to rise in
the West. We are the largest, the most
favorably situated Jewish community on
earth. We constitute a quarter of the
entire Jewish population on the surface
of the globe. In this hour of distress we
are the hope and the refuge of all Jews
elsewhere. We may consider ourselves the
"remnant of Israel" to which our foreign
kinsmen must look for light and leading.
We have at our disposal the materials
necessary for leadership and succor. We
have the men and the means — the human
and material resources — indispensable to
help mend the broken life of Jewry.
Yea, more. We have the freedom.
Freedom not the result of emancipation,
By LOUIS J. GRIBETZ
An Editorial — Published May, 1940.
freedom not a faint and sickly hot-house
plant, but freedom that is the natural and
thriving product of American civiliza-
tion. Further, we have the sympathetic
understanding and respect of all America.
America looks with shuddering horror on
the bigotry and the fanaticism to which
the" Jew is subject. She looks with dis-
dain and contempt upon those who in-
sult the dignity of man. America is still
in passionate quest of those things which
sweeten the life of humanity with justice
and equality.
•
We have a righteous case and faithful
allies. America is realizing that the
wounds which dictatorships inflict on the
Jews are also being inflicted on freedom.
(4) I think it is fair to say that we
can foresee that in a large sense the des-
tiny of the Jewish people has been placed
in the hands of American Jewry. The
greatest need, therefore, of all of us is
Jewish solidarity. No one individual
alone can deal with what confronts us.
Only together can they be solved. Let
us have a united front in defense and fur-
therance of Jewish rights. Let the com-
bined strength of American Jewry ex-
press their faith in justice and in the
ideals of democracy. To meet the de-
mands of the hour, the whole American
Jewish community must assert itself.
Every individual Jew must participate in
the fulfillment of this duty. Our power
will be rendered ineffective by separation
and disunity. Let us all use our power
and our talents in behalf of our causes
discreetly and prudently.
In his affliction Job said, "I know that
my redeemer liveth." The Hebrew word
for redeemer is "Goel," which means kins-
man. Job was certain of two things: of
the existence of his redeemer and that
his redeemer was his kinsman, his brother.
We, too, must understand that the
achievement of Jewish redemption is to
be effected by the "Goel," by ourselves.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
19
The Story of a Man Who Shocked His People
and Aroused their Sympathy
THE TRAGEDY OF da COSTA
ONE day in April, 1640, a pistol
shot rang out from one of the
houses in the little Marrano col-
ony of Amsterdam. Quickly a crowd of
frightened and excited men gathered. It
was the first time that their quiet and
peaceful life had been thus disturbed.
When the door was forced open and the
house entered, Uriel da Costa was found
dead at his desk with a bullet wound in
his head. One hand rested on the Latin
manuscript of his just completed auto-
biography, "An Example of a Human
Life."
His death created a commotion, but
little genuine regret among his contem-
poraries. There may have been a few
tears shed by the members of his family,
but he had no sooner been buried than
he was forgotten. It was the price he
paid for a stormy and turbulent life.
For many years he had been at odds with
his brethren, at odds with the members
of his own family, the cause of many
conflicts, the center of many quarrels
and disputes.
Yet, strange as it may seem, this lonely
and tragic figure, lying in an unmarked
grave in the ancient cemetery of Oude-
kerk, is still remembered. All attempts
to silence him, to expunge his very name
from the records of Jewish history, have
failed. Posterity has been kinder to him
than his own generation. Men still think
of him, pause and ponder his strange,
romantic career and tragic death. No
other Marrano Jew created so much in-
terest, aroused so much pity, excited so
much discussion.
•
Uriel da Costa (called Gabriel at his
birth) represents another chapter in the
long travail and suffering of the Marrano
Jews. He was a son of Marrano parents,
and his father, Bento, had adapted him-
self to his Christian environment with
an easy conscience.
He brought up his children, of whom
Uriel was the oldest, in the same simple
Christian piety that guided his own life.
Uriel was a sensitive and impressionable
child who, like his father, took religion
seriously. There were no spiritual con-
flicts in his life, for Catholicism was the
only religion he knew. What knowledge
of Jews and Judaism he had came from
the abusive sermons he had heard in the
church, or the scornful remarks of his
teachers. At his home the subject was
never mentioned, and when he inquired,
his father was annoyed and irritated, and
his mother strangely silent, though her
sad and melancholy eyes made him feel
that she knew more than she cared to
tell.
•
There were not many outlets in those
days for young men seeking a career.
Almost all the avenues to success led
through the holy orders. When Uriel
grew older and his career considered, he
was sent to the University of Coimbra
to prepare himself for ecclesiastical jur-
isprudence. The university was a re-
ligious school, a Jesuit institution.
Uriel responded to the religious atmos-
phere of the school perfectly. While law
books were his principal companions, re-
ligion continued to be his favorite sub-
ject. He became fanatically pious, sub-
duing the needs of food, drink and sleep
till they had no meaning for him.
Imaginary sins began to possess him;
the fear of damnation shadowed his every
step. Yet, there was nothing he could
do, for, was there a prayer he had not
recited, a shrine he had not frequented,
a holy image before which he had not
kneeled? He thought that a holy life
would give him the peace and tranquillity
he sought. To this purpose he copied the
example of the grimmest ascetics and
adopted their method till his face was
pale from fasting and his eyes dim from
weeping. As long as he prayed, he felt
relieved, and a great peace would come
over him, but with the last word of the
prayers, his fears would return.
Thus Uriel lived, feeling himself lost
and rejected. Suddenly, a faint shadow
of doubt began to form in his mind. Was
it the call of blood, the voice of stifled
tradition, or something of the subtle
Jewish spirit which had not yet been al-
together dead in his nature? The deeper
he delved into the mysteries of the Cath-
olic religion, the more preoccupied he
was with the Jesuit teachings, the larger
By JACOB MINKIN
and larger grew the cloud of doubt until
it almost completely covered his mind.
The Church had disappointed him; she
failed to give him the peace and tran-
quillity for which his soul had been long-
ing — could these things be had outside
her domain?
To trace Christianity to its core he
read the Old Testament from which it
sprang. He more than merely skimmed
its pages, but let its words, its very let-
ters flow through his mind. What a
fresh breath, like a cool summer breeze,
blew from its pages, confused and dis-
figured though it was in its Latin guise!
At last Uriel had found his anchor! He
was confused and troubled no more. His
imaginary sins no longer frightened him,
and the prospects of hell and damnation
had no terror for him. The Bible had
not a word to say about the things that
almost brought him to spiritual despera-
tion. The discovery shook the very foun-
dations of his Christian faith.
It was thus that Uriel forsook Chris-
tianity, at least in his heart, and became
a Jew.
•
Was this the resolution of his own
mind, or a determination fired by the ac-
tive propaganda of the local Marrano
group of which Antonio Homen, a mem-
ber of the Coimbra faculty, was the most
conspicuous figure? His own autobiog-
raphy contains no information on the
question. But for Uriel his mental tor-
ments had only begun, for it galled him
to play the hypocrite. To escape the
vigilant eyes of the Inquisition, he still
carried out the symbols of the Christian
religion, although his soul no longer re-
sponded to these things.
Upon his graduation, he returned to
Oporto, the city of his birth. Months,
perhaps several years, Uriel lived in
spiritual duplicity, outwardly carrying
out all the gestures of the Christian re-
ligion, while inwardly obeying the man-
dates of his new creed. At last the time
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
came to throw off the disguise and flee
to a land where he might live as a Jew.
Cautiously he communicated his inten-
tion to his mother and brothers — his
father was already dead — and together
they resolved to expose themselves to the
danger of secret emigration, to abandon
their hearth and home, surrender their
respected position in society and exchange
the comfort and security of their life for
an unknown future.
They fled to Amsterdam, that strange
and remarkable Jewish community almost
all of whose members had been born and
brought up as Christians. Some had even
been prelates and high Church digni-
taries. Uriel had to learn everything
anew, for now he was in the company
of Jews to whom Judaism was no longer
a secret conviction but a living practice.
He carried out the numerous prescrip-
tions of his new creed conscientiously,
and complied with everything his instruc-
tors had declared to be the law.
Sometimes, however, he was irked. For
he soon discovered that Judaism was a
much more complicated and exacting re-
ligion than the religion he had abandoned.
Never, for instance, could he eat or drink,
or perform any of the normal functions
of a human being without finding him-
self confronted with an outraged religious
injunction menacingly staring in his face.
His coming and going, his sitting and
standing, the very closest intimacies of
life, he found ruled and governed by
laws and regulations not the slightest
trace of which he could find in the Bible.
A disturbing doubt began to steal itself
into his mind. He craved for informa-
tion, but in the narrow circle in which
he lived there was no one to give it to
him, for the erstwhile Marranos observed
the rituals of their religion without ques-
tion.
It did not take very long before his
secret doubt developed into open rebel-
lion. It was for freedom that he had
risked his life and braved the dangers of
the Inquisition — was he now to be
shackled by the tyranny of the syna-
gogue? He no longer frequented divine
services, was careless in the observance
of the dietary laws, and was guilty of
many other similar religious lapses.
When the report of Uriel's religious
misconduct was noised about, the Jews
were stunned by it. It was the first
flagrant break in the religious solidarity
of the Marrano colony, and they felt the
hurt deeply. Uriel was regarded as a
heretic, a blasphemer, a defiler of the
Holy Law. Pious men avoided him, chil-
dren insulted him on the street, even the
beggars refused his alms, as though the
FRIDAY NIGHT
By Ruth Gonzer
THE white candles burn silently
In the tall silver candlesticks.
The light flickers in pale gold spurts
On the starched white tablecloth and
The mound of white-covered bread.
The air is very still and warm —
The bowed old figure at the head
Sits motionless in the huge carved chair
Like an ivory statue, modelled
In black and white. The wrinkled fore-
head
Gleams palely beneath the black silk cap.
The large heavy-lidded eyes are closed,
The thin colorless lips move fervently
But no sound comes forth. The room
Grows strangely quiet. Even the children
Are silent, deep awe-stricken gazes
Fixed on the ancient, ecstatic face.
The wine in the squat crystal goblets
Sparkles luridly under the candlelight
Like tumblers of smooth dark red blood.
The prayer is finished.
The bowed figure straightens, the lids
open,
And the thin lips stretch in a smile.
It must be a signal, for the children
Break into chatter and the adults
Smile and nod across the table.
The mother, white apron over dark silk,
Comes with steaming bowls of fragrant
soup.
The cloth glows with good hot, filling
food.
The children eat noisily and the
Little gray figure at the head
Watches with wise, ageless black eyes.
The candles droop a little in
The silver holders, and great scalding
Tears drop gently on the stained white
cloth.
money was tainted and not to be touched.
In his loneliness, separated from his
people, Uriel da Costa occupied his time
by examining some of the beliefs current
among the Jews in the light of their
biblical authority. His mind fell on the
doctrines of the immortality of the soul,
and reward and punishment after death.
He was so struck by the glaring contrast
between the universality of these beliefs
and their almost complete absence in the
Bible, that he not only communicated his
findings to the few friends he still met,
but resolved to publish a book on the
subject.
•
Da Costa was playing with fire. The
Jews might have been willing to over-
look his heresy, but how could they for-
give an attack that was levelled against
the Church no less than against the syn-
agogue? The freest state in Europe was
not yet free enough to countenance an
assault upon one of the most cherished
teachings of Christianity, made by one of
the very people they had admitted into
their midst and treated so generously.
And they lost no time in doing it.
They not only called on Samuel da Silva,
an Amsterdam physician and scholar, to
refute da Costa's pernicious teachings,
but denounced him to the local author-
ities. Uriel da Costa was arrested, kept
several days in prison, and his work was
condemned to the flames.
Uriel felt the hurt intensely. Of a
quick-tempered nature, an enthusiast
whose impetuosity overpowered his bet-
ter judgment, he now rushed headlong
from one indiscretion to another. A long
series of squabbles and irritations, of petty
quarrels and persecutions followed on
both sides, during which time Uriel da
Costa found himself living alone in a
hostile community, separated from his
race, even his family.
Everything had been cut off from
him; like a prisoner condemned to soli-
tary confinement he saw nothing of the
world but four walls of his cell. The
silence of his house almost crazed him.
He could not endure his isolation, to be
shunned by all as one smitten with a
plague. He was not a strong-minded
man, a thinker of the first order who
could live happily in his world of ideas
as in boundless space, unconcerned about
those around him, as Spinoza was to do
not many years later.
At last, he could stand his solitude no
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
21
longer and resolved to make his peace
with the synagogue. He yielded to the
urgency of necessity. His family had
renounced him, and his wife had been
dead for some time. To put an end to
his loneliness, he wanted to remarry, and
this was impossible so long as he was in
excommunication. He was willing to
pay tribute to Judaism with his lips when
his heart had long fallen away from it,
or, to quote his own words, he resolved
"to be an ape among apes." Neverthe-
less, da Costa was a man of feeling, senti-
ment and emotion, the product of a re-
ligious childhood and a Jesuit training.
Religion was deeply rooted in his soul,
although he could not find his spiritual
climate in either Judaism or Christianity.
He, therefore, evolved a religion of his
own, a kind of deistic faith, based on
natural law without creeds and cere-
monies, without rituals and observances
— an abstract religion without super-
natural or theological implications.
•
It was not to be expected that Uriel
da Costa would keep his secrets. Silence
had never come easy to him, especially
when the subject was religion. When,
therefore, he was approached by two
Christians who had intended to embrace
Judaism, and asked his opinion, he gave
them such a gloomy picture of the Jew-
ish faith, warning them against the heavy
yoke they would be laying on their necks,
that, frightened and discouraged, they
gave up their intention. To add to his
difficulties he was betrayed by one of his
nephews, who reported his uncle's un-
religious conduct.
Again was he excommunicated, this
time with even greater severity than be-
fore, and again was he condemned to a
life of loneliness. Had he lived on an-
other planet with no one around him, he
could not have been so utterly alone. At
the age of forty-nine, when men feel the
need of the warmth and congeniality of
friendship, he was immured in this prison-
house with no heart or face to cheer him.
Uriel da Costa was by this time a
broken and disheartened man; his power
of resistance was blunted and he had no
strength to fight. What years were still
left him, he longed to spend in peace.
It was, therefore, from a sense of ex-
pediency rather than honor that, for the
third time, he was prevailed upon to sign
a document of recantation.
The terms of his penance that had been
agreed upon were mild, with nothing in
them to hurt his proud and sensitive na-
ture. Instead, the penance turned out to
be as spectacular a performance as was
ever conceived by the gloomy genius of
the Inquisition. None of the sadistic
practices of the so-called Holy Office
were left out. Da Costa's description of
what happened in the little synagogue in
Amsterdam is so gory that the proceed-
ings could not but fill him with disgust
and loathing, and there is no reason to
doubt its authenticity.
Although a man of middle age, his
many trials had made him an old man.
Yet this had not deterred his tormentors
from parading him before a jeering and
mocking congregation, dressed in a peni-
tent's robe and holding a lighted candle
in his hand. He was made to stand up
and recite in a loud voice a confession of
sins which he had signed hardly knowing
its contents.
Nor was this his worst ordeal; for,
when the reading was ended, he was led
to a corner of the synagogue, made to
strip to the waist, and administered the
thirty-nine biblical lashes. Quivering
with pain and humiliation, and possibly
with bleeding wounds, he was made to
stretch himself across the threshold of the
synagogue and suffer the people to step
over his prostrate body as they walked
out, some kicking him with spiteful, pious
loathing, while others merely stepped over
him jauntily.
•
It was a mortifying experience par-
ticularly to one as sensitive as Uriel da
Costa. Blinded by rage, faint, and with
torn garments, he groped his way back to
the stillness and seclusion of his home,
vowing revenge for the humiliation he
had suffered. "I want the power of re-
venge," he muttered to himself as he
paced the corridor of his lonely house.
And the revenge he planned and executed
was too terrible even for so crazed and
tormented a mind as his. It was his "An
Example of a Human Life," portending
to be his autobiography, but in reality
more a challenge than a true history of
his life, more of a furious blast against
his tormentors than an impartial state-
ment of his case, every word dipped in
gall, every sentence reeking with hate and
venom.
Death alone could wipe out the re-
proach of da Costa's conduct and put an
end to his futile life.
Suicide may be cowardice, but some-
times it is cowardice that keeps one from
it. He took out his pistol, cleaned it,
loaded it well, and, with a steady hand,
made an end to his strange and tangled
life.
A FORMULA FOR JEWISH LIFE IN AMERICA
By DR. SAMUEL NEWMAN
EVEN those Jews who have retained
their nominal affiliation with the syn-
agogue have been a little hesitant about
describing their religion in terms of pure
faith. Faith was not a word in good
scientific standing. It suggested dogma-
tism; it implied a stubborn refusal to be
open-minded; it was not thought to be
the most fruitful approach to an under-
standing and comprehension of reality
and the universe.
According to an influential — and
fashionable — school of Jewish religious
thought, Judaism was interpreted in
terms of, and identified with, social jus-
tice and righteousness. Justice and right-
eousness were thought to mark and to
delimit the highest and farthest goals of
Judaism.
At the other extreme of the multi-
colored spectrum of divergent religious
opinion were those who viewed Judaism
as a civilization, a way of life for a lim-
ited and delimited racial or ethnic group.
To the exponents of this philosophy of
Judaism, ritual and ceremonial had value
neither as a sacrament or visible sign in-
stituted by God by which grace was con-
veyed to the individual soul nor as a
symbol of an abstract religious idea but
as a framework for the preservation and
transmission of a distinct folk life or
culture.
A considerable number of Jews who
drank deeply from the wells of western
culture concerned themselves with the
problem of Judaism not in a positive
[Continued on page 35]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
Hehirich Kranz, as the antlx>r of
this article was huowii originally,
came to the Retiew as a Viennese
journalist bitterly anxious to awake
American Jewry to the dangers fac-
ing the Jewish people. This article
u-as written before the war.
AGAIN the hour of doom has
struck for many thousands of
Jews. The Jews of two coun-
tries hitherto democratic and friendly to
Jews, Norway and Denmark, have fallen
under the domination of barbarians and
they must await oppression, persecution,
exile.
The Danish Jews — about seven thou-
sand, according to the last count — can
look back upon a proud history. The
first Jewish settlement in Denmark was
founded by Sephardic Jews from Holland
and Hamburg in the middle of the seven-
teenth century. But soon the Sephardim
yielded in numbers and importance to the
Ashkenasim. There is an excellent por-
trayal of Jewish life in Denmark by the
etcher, Salomo Bennet, who spent the
years between 1792 and 1795 in Copen-
hagen.
"The Jews here enjoy the full freedom
of assimilated citizens, they bear their
share of the burdens and taxes, and play
their part in public life just like the other
inhabitants of the country," he wrote.
"They are hospitable, eager to serve both
native and foreigner, and industrious at
their trade, be it commerce or handiwork.
They have also produced excellent doc-
tors and surgeons and a few artists."
The influence of the enlightened group
around Moses Mendelssohn reached Co-
penhagen, which formed a progressive
congregation at the time. When the cele-
brated Chief Rabbi, A. A. Wolff, came
to Denmark, from Darmstadt, Germany,
he was able to contribute a great deal
toward the preservation of sound Juda-
ism. David Simonsson, the scholar and
social economist followed him in office.
Let us mention just a few names to
indicate the significance of the spiritual
and social life of Denmark during the last
decades: George Brandes, the literary his-
torian, who interpreted and translated the
works of Ibsen, Bjocrnson and Strindberg
into the Western languages, and wrote
the monumental "Stream of Nineteenth
THE JEWS IN SCANDINAVIA
Century Literature"; Carl Brandes, his
brother, Minister of Finance in several
Danish cabinets; Meyer Hermann Bing,
publisher and member of the Industrial
Union; Meir Aaron Goldschmid and
Henri Nathanson, both famous play-
wrights; Markus Rubin, director of the
Danish National Bank; N. Wallich, well
known botanist; Moritz and Moses Mel-
choir, financiers, and generous patrons of
Danish literature and science; the Jacob-
sohn family, who gave Denmark several
artists; Siegfried Wagner, sculptor of
the mighty National Memorial in Copen-
hagen; Mayer Jacob Goldschmid, one of
the best stylists in Danish literature;
Peter J. Freuchen, famous Arctic explorer
and writer, whose books were very popu-
lar in Germany. It is not generally
known that Politiken, Copenhagen's
greatest international newspaper, was
founded by Edvard Brandes, a Jew.
During the first World War Copen-
hagen was the seat of the Central Bureau
of the Zionist Organization. It issued
the so-called Copenhagen Manifesto on
the twenty-fifth of October, 1918. In
it were formulated demands for a national
home in Palestine, equal rights in all
By HEINRICH KRANZ
lands, and national autonomy for all
countries where there was mass immigra-
tion by Jews.
•
Norway has the youngest and numeric-
ally weakest Jewish colony of all Scandi-
navian lands. Only about eighteen hun-
dred Jews live there, one thousand in
Oslo, three hundred in Trondheim, fifty
in Bergen, and the rest scattered through
towns as far as Narvik. There are even
a few Jewish residents in Hammerfest,
the northernmost city in the world. Di-
viding them according to trade, they are
to be found in commerce and the shoe,
tobacco, textile, and clock industries.
There are also Jews in the professions, and
Jewish officers in the Norwegian army.
Not till the beginning of the nine-
teenth century do we find sizeable Jewish
immigration in Norway. At that time
the existent ban on Jewish immigration
was lifted by a few persons friendly to
the Jews. But the settlers did not get
to the point of forming a congregation in
Oslo till 1892. There was practically no
anti-Semitism.
EXPOSING IRRESPONSIBLE ACTION
By JOSEPH GOLDBERG
An Editorial — Published January, 1944
The methods adopted by certain "front
groups" are known. Taking advantage
of the plight of the Jews, a few individ-
uals band themselves together and enlist
the endorsement of well-meaning but
misguided men and women who "lend
their names" freely in the hope that they
are helping a worthwhile movement of
responsible leadership. Armed with these
high-sounding names, publicity is ob-
tained by means of paid advertisements
in leading American newspapers. The
vicious circle begins. The inevitable cou-
pon printed in a corner of the advertise-
ment brings in contributions, which in
turn, are used to pay for more advertise-
ments.
Those who are encouraging these cha-
otic acts must be made to realize that
instead of helping the cause of Jewry
they are actually doing us a disservice
by creating confusion in Jewish life and
undermining the efforts of organized
leadership in American Jewry. There is
no dearth of organizations to fight our
cause and protect our interests here and
elsewhere. What is sorely needed is dis-
cipline in our ranks and a maximum of
support given to agencies created by the
will of the majority of our people.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
The Life of a Practical Idealist
LOUIS DEMBITZ BRANDEIS
OUIS DEMBITZ BRANDEIS in his
career as lawyer and judge must
frequently have looked with impa-
tience, however characteristically benign
and well-concealed, upon the allegorical
conception of Justice. The blindfolded,
ample, female figure which in stone and
in bronze has immemorially been the cor-
poreal symbol of Justice is the direct anti-
thesis of that method of thinking, plead-
ing and adjudicating by which Brandeis
has been so distinctively marked off from
the generality of contemporary advocates
and judges.
Brandeis always insisted on a full
understanding of relevant facts as the in-
dispensable element in the true adminis-
tration of justice.
From his earliest days of maturity this
insistence upon facts oriented the devel-
opment of his legal and civic point of
view. Graduation from Harvard Law
School (as admittedly its most brilliant
student) brought him toward the close
of the 19th century into professional life
among an American people suffering from
an economic self-hypnosis.
The country's inexhaustible natural re-
sources furnished material for the struc-
tures of great industrial organizations.
Need for expanding credit facilitated the
establishment by banks and financial
trusts of an apparently invulnerable
hegemony. The interplay of such indus-
trial and financial interests fostered inter-
locking directorates and resultant monop-
oly. An unending stream of immigration
insured the requisite supply of patient
human labor on which this machine
poised itself. The translation of the pio-
neering spirit from the physical frontier,
finally attained, into the market place,
the factory and the counting house cre-
ated the now-legendary captains of in-
dustry and finance whose manipulations
set into motion stratifications of wealth.
In all this vast panorama of action and
reaction every theory save one seemed
reasonable; every industrial practice ex-
cept one was permitted; every class save
only one procured advantages.
The class excepted from the generous
distribution of national wealth was the
laboring class. The theory omitted from
the standard ideology of the day was that
the labor of human beings in one form
or another is the crucible in which na-
tional wealth is created. The one indus-
trial practice hardly even conceived of,
much less initiated, was the practice of
industrial justice. A conception of labor
as something other than a commodity to
be purchased as cheaply as possible — as a
dignified and co-equal element with capi-
tal in the unity of Industry: this, except
among a fractional minority, was heter-
odoxy and anathema to the actual as well
as the titular rulers of the country. In
no other epoch of our history since the
outlawing of slavery was the industrial
and social plane of the country so low.
•
Such a condition factually expresses
a philosophy — one first propounded in the
Biblical question "Am I my brother's
Keeper?" In sober revolt against the pre-
vailing philosophy, both because of a rea-
soned recognition of its futility as a
standard of human conduct and because
of ancient currents of Hebrew morality
forming the essentials of his character.
Brandeis became an actor in this drama
of the ensuing decades. Inevitably he
became a member, and early emerged as
a leader of the group of men and ideas
which must be termed, now as well as
then, the hope in America of decent and
civilized social relationships.
Most immediately necessary in any pro-
gramme of reform was the strengthening
of Labor: Brandeis (at a time when his
clientele included many large, and cor-
porate, employers of labor) vigorously
championed the growth and power of
unions. In public forum and in legal
brief he forcefully expressed the economic
and legal arguments which steadily freed
labor from the restrictions of the com-
mon-law doctrine of conspiracy and in
resultant judicial decisions and legislative
enactments legalized the strike, picketing,
and other essential union methods. In
all 'this, he had the manner and method
of the statistician because of a compelling
integrity of intellect; but the aim was
that of an idealist.
In the forms of price and rates, the
great industrial monopolies were exorbi-
tantly taxing the American people.
By WILLIAM I. SIEGEL
Brandeis attacked the prices and the rates,
not alone as evils in themselves; he at-
tacked the economic inutility of the
structures.
This matter of the forms of social
structure is a cardinal point in any eval-
uation of Brandeis' work. Brandeis stood
always apart from the extremists of the
Right and the Left. The basic idea of
his position was the necessity (and the
practicability) of what for convenience
sake we call Capitalism as permitting the
least restrained scope of individual abil-
ity and effort in the creation of total
national wealth.
By no means, however, was Brandeis
enamoured of that system. He recog-
nized that the word Capital is but an-
other name for — a description of — the
process whereby wealth is created and
also of the channels through which it is
distributed. It was the province of Bran-
deis to graph and chart those perversions
of Capitalism which have simultaneously
stifled the creation of wealth and clogged
its distribution.
•
In this endeavor he was, like all
prophets, a generation and more ahead of
his day. Decades of bitter debate were
to elapse before old-age pensions, cheaper
insurance, unemployment security, in-
dustrial cooperation, shorter hours and
higher wages passed out of the realm of
the Utopian into accepted codes of indus-
trial relations. The race has not been en-
tirely to the swift in thought, nor the
battle wholly to the strong in spirit, for
both the race and the battle must for
long be carried on. Yet this, at least, has
been permanently established: that at
long last the principle of these reforms
has become current in the coin of social
intercourse, and the debate is as to detail
mainly. To Brandeis as much as to any
— and more than to most — of the cham-
pions of change and progress is due the
fundamental reversal of emphasis.
Democratic government frequently
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
24
justifies itself in terms of personal inci-
dent. A dramatic example was Brandeis'
elevation to the Supreme Court. The
totality of the forces opposed in 1916 to
his nomination by President Wilson was
tremendous. In a very real sense the op-
position represented a marshalling of
power by every conservative and reac-
tionary element in the country against
liberal movements which they hated —
which, moreover, they feared and which
they knew were personified by him. Sel-
dom in our history have ideas been so
completely identified with a personality.
The President recognized this, and in
pressing for confirmation by the Senate,
beautifully described his appointee when
he wrote: "He is a friend of the just
and a lover of the right; and he knows
more than how to talk about the right;
he knows how to set it forward in the
face of its enemies."
It is not possible to exaggerate the con-
sequence of Brandeis' judicial labor be-
ginning as they did with the national
problems generated by the World War.
Brandeis, with his friend and early
mentor, Justice Holmes, strove against
the assault of legislation born of wartime
hysteria. They failed; but they failed so
splendidly that history will be likely to
record the influence of their minority dis-
sents rather than the judgment of the
majority. *
Jews as Americans and as Jews are
proud of Mr. Justice Brandeis. Jews as
Jews are rightly grateful to Louis Dcm-
bitz Brandeis. His leadership of our
cause in critical times; his contribution
of energy and vision; the influence of his
example on wavering Jews; the power
of his name in the non- Jewish world;
these have been more than an army to us.
Until 1910 his contact with the Jew-
ish people had been only occasional and
had given him no feeling of particular
identification with, or obligation to, them
or their problems. In that year he served
on an arbitration board dealing with the
Jewish textile trade, and from that ex-
perience formed impressions of admira-
tion for the Jews with whom he dealt
in these perplexing questions affecting a
predominantly Jewish industry. In 1912
his real and lasting interest in Zionism
became an activating force of his future
years. For this the Jewish people owe a
great debt of gratitude to Jacob De Haas,
who stamped indelibly on Brandeis' at-
tention and purpose the facts of the Jew-
ish situation in the Goluth. These facts
made him definitely and in terms of his
own efforts indefatigably a Zionist. As
he had written: "Only a generation ago
this was a hope merely — a wish piously
prayed for, but not worked for. The
Zionist movement is idealistic, but it is
also essentially practical."
•
The facts which acted as the catalytic
agent on Brandeis were both negative and
positive. The first was the "universal
and endemic" nature of anti-Semitism.
He recognized that however different in
different countries might be the manifes-
tations and the degrees of anti-Semitism,
This is one of Rabbi LeiinthaVs
articles from his column, "Just Be-
tween Ourselves."
I HAVE unfortunately frequent occa-
sions to visit people during "Shivah,"
when they observe the week of
mourning. Again and again I am struck
by the sight of huge baskets of fruit,
candies and other delicacies, sent by good
friends to show their sympathy for these
sorrowing folk.
I wonder how many of these well-
meaning people ever give a thought to
the wastefulness of this gesture. In most
of the cases the people do not need these
delicacies, and certainly do not want to
derive any enjoyment from something
that is linked with their sorrow.
A nobler gesture could be made in such
circumstances, one that would have a far
greater meaning to the bereaved and
would be an effective way of perpetuat-
ing the name of the deceased. If these
friends were to plant a tree on Palestine
Jewish National Fund land in memory of
the departed one, how much finer, how
much more useful, this action would be.
Imagine the feeling of the mourners up*on
receiving the certificate from the Jewish
National Fund with the name of their
dear departed inscribed upon it, and tell-
ing of a tree that will blossom in the
sacred soil of the new Judea and bear
the name of their beloved one.
the problem which it created was a uni-
versal Jewish problem. The positive fact
which he made part of his reaction and
which in addresses of compelling logic
and stirring appeal he expounded to the
Jewish and the non- Jewish world alike
was that not by a mawkish assimilation
and not by a concealment of Jewish ra-
cial and national identity could this prob-
lem be solved. Only in a militant Zion-
ism and only by insistence upon the
creation of a national home for a Jewish
nationality was the answer to be found.
Thus he sounded the note of Jewish pride
and self-respect: "While every other
people is striving for development by
asserting its nationality and a great war
(Continued on page 31]
I do not mean to limit the suggestion
to the Jewish National Fund. The offer-
ing may be a contribution to any worthy
cause, to any fine institution to which the
departed one was devoted in life. We
sometimes receive a gift in our Center
Library in memory of someone who died.
The family is notified of this act, and I
am confident that they experience a joy
in the midst of their sorrow that the
name of their beloved one will be blessed
by readers of these books for years to
come. I often see a request, included in
the death announcement published in the
press, that friends who wish to honor
the memory of the deceased should make
a contribution to some specified charity
that was close to the heart of the one
who has passed on. Such acts have mean-
ing. They are productive of good. They
help to keep alive the name of the dead.
It is high time that people of intelli-
gence drop this senseless practice of
wasteful spending now in vogue in order
to express a sacred feeling of sympathy
with one's loss. But let the motive which
prompted the rise of this custom be util-
ized in a manner worthy of the solemnity
of the occasion. Let us unite the name
of the dead with a cause that brings
blessedness to the living, and then in
truth will the name and memory of the
departed ones live on in the hearts of
grateful people.
FUTILE BASKETS FOR THE BEREAVED
By DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
25
IN DECEMBER, 1937, I sat by the
sickbed of a great and pitiful man,
the poet Ernst Lissauer. The helpless
giant, weighing some two hundred and
twenty pounds, had been taken to the
Spital der Israclitischen Kultusgcmeinde
(Hospital of the Jewish Community) of
Vienna, suffering a serious heart attack.
According to the doctor, his illness had
been caused by abnormal fatness and high
blood-pressure. But his friends knew
better. The poet's heart was simply re-
fusing to function in a world dominated
by Hitler.
Having abandoned my study of Ger-
man literature and devoted myself com-
pletely to my cultural readjustment in
the New World, I almost forgot my old
friend Lissauer. But recently I came
across his name in the late Stefan Zweig's
autobiography, "The World of Yester-
day." Superbly, Zweig described the man
who belonged to his own generation —
Lissauer was born in Berlin in 18 82 — but
who differed in a hundred ways from the
Viennese poet, "a round little man, a
jolly face above a double double-chin,
bubbling over with self-importance and
exuberance, stuttering in his haste, and
so possessed with poetry that nothing
could keep him from citing and reciting
his verses again and again. But for all
the laughable things he did, I had to like
him because he was warm-hearted, com-
radely, honest and demoniacally attached
to his art."
When I made his acquaintance, in the
early 1930's, I soon learned that Lissauer
was a profoundly unhappy person. For
almost twenty years he had been a dead
man, an outcast because of his "Hass-
gesang gegen England" (Hymn of Hate
Against England), a forty-eight-line
poem published in the beginning of the
first World War and distributed by the
millions among the soldiers of the Cen-
tral Powers in pamphlet form. The
power of the poem is to be felt even in
translation:
"Hate by water and hate by land,
Hate of the head and hate of the
hand,
Hate of the hammer and hate of the
crown,
Hate of seventy millions, choking
down.
We love as one, we hate as one,
We have one foe and one alone —
GERMANY'S
England!"
Lissauer, who stemmed from a wealthy
German-Jewish family, was an ardent
German nationalist. When the war broke
out, he failed to see that the Kaiser's
boundless ambition and German haughti-
ness and imperialism were responsible, to
a large extent, for the great catastrophe.
All that mattered to him was that his
country had been attacked. In his mind,
Sir Edward Grey, the British Foreign
Minister, and the English race, had done
wrong, not only to Germany, but also to
him, Ernst Lissauer. He first hurried to
the recruiting office to enlist, but the fat
little man was flatly rejected by the
army doctors. Thereupon he decided to
serve his country's war effort as a poet,
and through his "Hassgesang" he became
famous over night. The German Kaiser
bestowed the Order of the Red Eagle
upon him, millions of school children
learned the poem by heart, it was set to
music and sung in the theatres, and Ger-
man as well as Austrian officers read it to
their men at the various war fronts. I
still remember how my father, coming
home from his office, brought us a copy
of the "hymn" and read it out loud, even
though he did not approve at all of the
tremendous propaganda of hatred that
swept the country. But the poem was
also published in the French, English, and
American press as an example of the fury
of German hatred. For a few months
Lissauer was known to hundreds of mil-
lions all over the globe.
•
When Lissauer wrote his Song of Hate,
he was thirty-three; when he died he was
fifty-five. To his bitter disappointment
none of his many works — he published
some thirty books of poems, stories,
dramas and criticism — came anywhere
near to the popularity of his Song of
Hate. Besides, after November, 1918, the
same people who had praised his "Hassge-
sang" turned cold to him, refusing to
take further notice of the "hater." They
did not listen to him when he explained
— as he did to me — that he regarded
he End of the Man Who Wrote
the World's Worst Hate Song
TRAGIC JEW
By ALFRED WERNER
the "Hate Song" as one of the least signi-
ficant of his creations; that it had gained
its tremendous popularity against his will;
the others, like Thomas Mann, or the So-
cialist arbeitcr-dichter, had written lines
no less spiteful than his own; that he
was anything but a politician, and that
he had publicly apologized for his
wretched poem in a letter to a Berlin
paper in 1919. It was in vain — his re-
nown was to burn him for the rest of his
life like the shirt of Nessus, to use Stefan
Zweig's words. This kind, highly edu-
cated, immensely gifted poet was a
marked man; many of his colleagues re-
fused to greet him; an unpleasant silence
fell when he entered a meeting, and
friends of mine rebuked me for having
contact with that "monster," although,
actually, he was only a victim of the hys-
teria of hate that befell all belligerent
nations.
Like Walther Rathenau and other
super-assimilated German Jews, Lissauer
profoundly admired the Prussians, and he
remained a typical Prussian even though
he spent the last fifteen years of his life
in Vienna, where he had gone with his
second wife, a kind-hearted Gentile
woman who survived him and who, in
1938, when the Nazis invaded Austria,
courageously aided many of her late hus-
band's Jewish colleagues ( Lissauer 's first
wife, a Jewess, died in a mental asylum.)
But the German nationalists rejected his
enthusiastic odes (written in a forceful
style reminiscent of Walt Whitman) on
such German composers as Bach, Beetho-
ven, or Bruckner, and his expressionist
dramas on Martin Luther, Thomas Muen-
zcr, and General York — subjects only
an "Aryan" should be allowed to deal
with. Yet when Lissauer turned to Jew-
ish topics, such as the story of Moses (in
his remarkable drama, "Der Weg des Ge-
waltigen") or that of "The Wife of
Jcpthah," the Jewish press, angered by
Lissauer's former alliance with German
[Continued on page 35]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
26
Of Some Surprising Traits in Jefferson^
Paine and Others
FREE-THINKERS AND ANTI-SEMITISM
MANY Jewish readers will be shocked
to learn that even so noble and cul-
tured a person as Thomas Jefferson, who
was a deist, came under that influence
which regarded deism as synonymous
with, and antipathetic to, the Jews and
the Bible. Jefferson, who regarded the
tale of the mystical birth of Jesus
through God in the womb of a virgin,
on a par with that of the birth of Minerva
from the brain of Jupiter, and who con-
ceded an atheist may be a most virtuous
person, nevertheless libelled the ancient
Jews and their Bible. He said that their
character was perverse and that their
ideas of God as reflected in the Old Tes-
tament was degrading and injurious.
Needless to say no Jew will think less
of the great Jefferson for the mistaken
views under which he had fallen. They
were shared by, and no doubt in part
adopted from, two personal friends, both
great Americans, Thomas Paine, the deist,
and Joseph Priestley, the founder of Uni-
tarianism in America.
Lately there has been a revival of in-
terest in Thomas Paine, a revival that
must be called healthy. His spirit is
necessarily still when fundamentalists op-
pose by law the teaching of the theory
of evolution. Thomas Paine is a reli-
gious reactionary from the point of view
of many liberal, yet religious scholars,
who have gone far beyond him in bold-
ness. But in the revival of Paine it is to
be feared that many Jews not familiar
with their own literature, and adopting
his dogmatic attitude and ignoring the
historical or psychological approach, will
conclude that his malicious animadver-
sions upon the Jews and the Bible are
beyond refutal. In his "Age of Reason"
he manifested a special hatred for Moses,
whom he called "most detestable villain,"
"assassin" and "impostor." While in
Biblical criticism as such, and also in
some moral judgments, Paine is often
right, he is naive in his final conclusions.
He makes much of the fact, for ex-
ample, that the Bible says that God sanc-
tioned the killing of prisoners of war — a
practice which was resorted to by all
peoples and which has come down in part
to our own day. We have even gone
further by bombing innocent women and
children. When people practice cruelty
that they believe is justified, they in-
stinctively attribute approval of it to
their deity. That is how the ancients
wrote history. Even in our time God is
represented as sanctioning the death of
those who represent a different cause from
our own. Paine believed that he attacked
the Jewish God, but what he was attack-
ing was an ancient practice which the
rabbis of old tried to interpret in the true
spirit of their faith, and which Jews today
will join in with him without feeling that
they must give up their belief in the God
of righteousness, as depicted by the
Prophets.
•
Now how did Paine and the whole
group of thinkers who fought supersti-
tion so courageously come to take this
attitude toward the ancient Jew? It is
THE Jewish people at all times believed
that their existence can rest on no
other basis than liberty and justice. Their
sole protection was their just and equal
rights. Dictatorship of any kind was
repugnant to them not only as a form
of government but as a form of life.
When their equal rights were assailed or
threatened they instantly reacted with
cries, anger and protest. The more vigor-
ous dictatorships grew, and the more in-
tense the pain of the Jew, the more
aroused were his moral and spiritual fac-
ulties. His protests, his boycotts, his
pamphlets became the visible manifesta-
tions of his emotional response to the evil.
He used every weapon at his command.
He spoke the language of a minority —
"it is not just, it is not fair, it is cruel,
it is unsocial" — the words that burn.
The Jews sought to interpret and to
make audible to the world the voice of
religion and truth, the sacred principles
of the human heart in the face of a re-
lentless Niagara pouring hatred and
bigotry. The crippled soul, the creeping
intellect, counseled caution, docility, sub-
By ALBERT MORDELL
easy to say that they still unconsciously
were infected with the prejudices of the
people among whom they had been
reared, and also that they could not for-
give Judaism for being the mother re-
ligion of Christianity, which they equally
detested, if not even more. These are
not the sole reasons.
•
Freethought existed in Europe for
many centuries before the birth of Eng-
lish deism as we know it, but it was not
as a matter of principle anti-Semitic.
Paine and the later rationalists simply
followed in a tradition that had been
developed as incidental in a deistic
controversy.
mission, little suspecting that such coun-
sel reflected merely helplessness in the face
of the stark reality of the conflict.
The Jews became the objects of obser-
vation by the world. Our pains and suf-
fering indeed elicited compassion but the
world's emotional state was in abatement,
in suspense. The world's reaction time
was very long. The injury inflicted did
not immediately wound the observer.
The reaction, however, is here and slowly
the dawn is breaking. The world is
realizing that the wounds which dictator-
ships inflict on the Jews are being in-
flicted on freedom. It is realizing that
we are living in a day of peril for human-
ity, that the persecution of the Jew rep-
resents a veritable conspiracy against the
rights and progress of the human race. A
sense of solidarity among justice-seeking
people is growing.
•
Let us continue to proclaim our be-
lief in democracy and our abhorrence
of dictatorships. That which we pro-
claim today the world will acknowledge
tomorrow.
THE JEWISH WILL TO LIVE
By LOUIS J. GRIBETZ
An Editorial — Published February, 1939.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
27
THE HIGH COST OF DYING
This is another of Rabbi Levin-
thai' s column and may be considered
a companion piece to his "Futile
Baskets For the Bereaved."
TWO or three years ago I preached
a sermon which I named "The High
Cost of Dying." I recall now that
a number of people in the congregation
that evening frankly told me that they
knew the high cost of living, but never
realized that dying too might be included
among the expensive luxuries.
The sermon to which I refer was based
upon a report published in book form by
a special committee appointed by the
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company. I
happened to be a member of this com-
mittee. We were asked by the Metro-
politan to make a survey and a study of
the costs of funerals and burials, and also
to ascertain the attitude of the various
religions toward this problem.
The results of the survey were as en-
lightening, as they were astounding.
Statistics were offered to show that among
certain sections of our population, fam-
ilies put themselves into debt for years
to come in order to give their departed
what they liked to term a "nice funeral."
It is not an infrequent sight to behold
a poor widow spending all of the little
insurance money left her in order to pro-
vide a coffin with ornamental figures and
metal trimmings, for no other reason than
that her neighbor had used a similar costly
accessory, and her husband could not be
treated in lesser fashion.
The Metropolitan study concluded with
an appeal for a campaign of education
that would bring home to men and
women the uselessness and wastefulness
of the extravagance so often lavished on
funerals.
Now we could very well understand
such practices among ignorant classes,
among those who are easily influenced by
the childish motive of "making an im-
pression" upon their neighbors. The dis-
appointing feature of the whole matter
is the fact that you often see the same
display among people seemingly intelli-
gent and credited with some degree of
culture. And even more disappointing
By DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
is that you see this practice emulated by
Jews.
It is bad enough that the living toil
and slave to acquire not only the neces-
sities of life but also the things with
which to impress their neighbors and
friends with their importance and suc-
cess. One would imagine, however, that
when death comes, all this nonsensical
display would be cast aside, that we would
at least then realize its vanity. One
would think that death would hold sway.
It is therefore, so such a time the spirit
of democracy, which looks upon all men
as equal, would hold sway. It is there-
fore so disappointing to see the dead laid
out in richly bedded coffins, with trim-
mings of expensive metal, with beautiful
engravings on silver or golden plates, all
of which, after all, are placed six feet
deep in the ground, to await the same
fate as the humble coffin of plain pine.
In ancient Jewish life the rich also in-
dulged in these luxurious burials. One
vied with the other in the arrangement
of elaborate processions, scaffoldings,
hangings and coffins. The Talmud tells
us that "formerly they brought the bodies
of the rich to the house of mourning in
nettings of silver and gold, but those of
the poor in baskets of wickerwork; thus
the poor men were put to shame. Ac-
cordingly the rule was decreed that
everyone should bring his corpse in a
basket of wickerwork." (Moed Katan
27a.) Since funeral expenses became
common extravagances and an object of
alarm to relatives, the great sage,
R. Gamliel II, set the example by the
order he gave for his own funeral, and
thus introduced the custom of burying
the dead in simple linen garments.
(Ketubot 8b, Moed Katan 27b.) This
was in protest against the custom prac-
ticed by the wealthy to cast the most
costly garments and ornaments upon the
bier of the departed. And Rabbi Gam-
liel's example was followed continuously
throughout the ages down to the last cen-
tury. It is only in modern times that
we have witnessed the revival of the old
practice of waste and extravagance.
I can very well understand the senti-
ment of many people who cannot permit
themselves to use the simple and frail pine
coffin that was in vogue among all Jews
up to recent times. Their conception of
respect to the dead demands a firmer rest-
ing place within the grave. But that
should not lead to the other extreme of
coffins made of the most expensive wood
and metal.
Let us display true democracy at least
in time of death. Let us shun all display,
all luxury, all extravagance.
And let not anyone justify such action
with the childish argument, "We do it
to show our respect to our dead." If we
truly want to show the departed our re-
spect, let us take the money spent for
these useless displays and offer it in their
memory to some worthy cause or charity.
It is bad enough that we have to grap-
ple with the high cost of living. Let us
be sensible and not encourage the high
cost of dying!
According to its practice
the Review will suspend
publication during the sum-
mer months of July and Au-
gust, resuming with the
Rosh Hashonah issue. This
will contain the New Year
Greetings. Center members
and others who wish to avail
themselves of this welcome
and effective means of con-
veying their Rosh Hashonah
Greetings to their friends
are urged to reserve space
early. Please communicate
with the (.enter office.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
28
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER NEWS
Hebrew School News
Impressive Graduation exercises were
held on Sunday, June 6, 1948. An audi-
ence of 900 filled the synagogue and wit-
nessed 23 Hebrew School students and 14
Religious school students receive diplomas.
In addition, the first seven students to
complete a two-year Post-Graduate He-
brew course were given certificates of
achievement. The following received
prizes for excellence in studies: Tobia
Brown — Rachmil Gold Medal for Gen-
eral Excellence; Carla Lefkowitz — Parent-
Teachers Association Gift; Robert Gluck-
man — Faculty Gift; Helen Aronow,
Ileane Altman, Frieda Cohen, Sheldon
Friefeld and Rena Rosenbaum — Citations
for Excellence in Hebrew Studies; Doris
Helen Rabbiner — Sunday School Faculty
Prize; Julia Heimowitz — Post-Graduate
Hebrew Award.
Judge Emanuel Greenberg and Rabbi
Manuel Saltzman addressed the graduates
and guests. Awards were distributed by
Mr. Frank Schaeffer, Mrs. Julius Kushner
and Mrs. Morton Klinghoffer. A cantata
on the work and life of Bialik was
presented by the graduates and members
of the choral group under the direction
of Mr. Julius Grossman. Rabbi Mordecai
H. Lewittes presided.
The graduates will continue their He-
brew studies either in the Marshalliah
Hebrew High School or in the Post-
Graduate Hebrew Course. The follow-
ing graduates were given second-year
status in the Marshalliah Hebrew High
School: Tobia Brown, Robert Gluckman,
Ileane Altman, Rena Rosenbaum, Frieda
Cohen, Sheldon Friefeld and Carla Lef-
kowitz.
Lloyd Altman was made the recipient
of the Benjamin Hirsh Memorial Award
on June 19, 1948, for outstanding service
to the Junior Congregation.
Closing Exercises of the Institute of
Jewish Studies for Adults
A large gathering of men and women
filled our main auditorium on the evening
of May 24, to attend the closing exer-
cises of our Institute of Jewish Studies
for Adults. Rabbi Manuel Saltzman,
Associate Director of the Institute, pre-
sided and delivered an introductory ad-
dress. Greetings and brief addresses were
delivered by our president, Judge Eman-
uel Greenberg, Mrs. Morton Klinghoffer,
president of the Sisterhood, Mr. Frank
Schaeffer, chairman of the Hebew Edu-
cation Committee, and Dr. Reuben Fin-
kelstein, chairman of the Institute Com-
mittee.
A very fine feature of the program was
the presentation of the cantata, "Road
to Freedom" by the Zamir Youth Chorale,
written by Moshe Kohn, and led by
Naftali Frankel, in which a large group
of young men and women participated.
It was a very timely and fitting cantata
in view of the present situation in Pales-
tine. The cantata was received with ac-
claim by the entire audience.
Rabbi Levinthal presented Certificates
of Achievement as well as certificates
from the National Academy of Adult
Jewish Studies to the following students,
who had finished a sufficient number of
courses which entitled them to this
award: Esther Alpert, Fania Asen, Rose
Auster, Rose Bromberg, Emma Cohen,
Sylvia Dilbert, Theresa Drosen, Dora L.
Gaba, Augusta Gordon, Jennie Griff,
Celia Kierman, Gertrude Sharcoff and
Emil Schiller.
For the first time in the history of our
Institute we were able to present a spe-
cial certificate to those who had accom-
plished additional work after having once
received a Certificate of Achievement.
The following received such awards, hav-
ing taken four years of additional study:
Henry Cohen, Harry Einberg, Jennie
Finkelstein, Rebecca Ginsberg, Mollie
Goodman, Frieda Katz, Sadie Kaufmann,
Anna Krotinger, Florence Lapidus, Risha
Levenson, Mollie Rosenbaum, Joseph
Schlam, Rose Simon, Beatrice Sterman,
Anna Weinstock, Hilde Zauderer and
Frieda Zavin.
Cantor William Sauler rendered several
beautiful musical selections which termi-
nated an evening which will be long re-
membered by those present.
Rabbi Levinthal Awarded Honorary
Degree, Doctor Jewish Theology
Rabbi Levinthal was honored at the
commencement exercises of the Jewish
Institute of Religion on Sunday morning,
June 6th, with being awarded the Hon-
orary Degree of Doctor of Jewish The-
ology. At the same exercises our Rabbi's
distinguished father, Rabbi Bernard L.
Levinthal, was awarded the Honorary
Degree of Doctor of Hebrew Letters.
Unfortunately, the senior Rabbi Levin-
thal was unable to be present because of
his illness and his son accepted for him
the degree.
What made the event quite unique was
the fact that our Rabbi's brother, Judge
Louis E. Levinthal of Philadelphia, was
also honored on the afternoon of the same
day at the graduation exercises of the
Jewish Theological Seminary with the
Honorary Degree of Doctor of Humane
Letters. We are privileged to print in
this issue of our Review the Citations
read when the degrees were awarded to
Rabbi Levinthal and his father.
Citation by Prof. Henry Slonimsky,
Dean of the Institute:
Rabbi Bernard L. Levinthal — the grand
old man of the Orthodox Rabbinate of
America — Ga-dol U-ven G'do-lim — son
of a distinguished line of rabbis in the
old world, and father of a new genera-
tion of rabbis and scholars in the new —
we wish to document our attachment to
traditional Judaism by this token of our
admiration and affection for one whom
we may well call the Dean of the Rabbi-
nate of America.
Israel Herbert Levinthal — the embodi-
ment in rarest fashion of all the virtues
of Conservative Judaism — in sweetness
and light, in qualities of heart and of
mind, as exemplary practical leader of a
great synagogue, and at the same time as
notable thinker on the theological bases
and ideas of Judaism, of such high dis-
tinction as to qualify him for a chair in
any Jewish Seminary.
Award of degrees by Dr. Stephen S.
Wise, President of the Institute:
Israel Herbert Levinthal: Mine is the
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
29
unique privilege, on behalf of the Jewish
Institute of Religion, of admitting you
and your distinguished Father together
into the Fellowship of the Honorary
Alumni of the Institute. Would that
it had been possible for your aged and
revered Father to be present on this occa-
sion. But we know that you will be good
enough to present this diploma to him in
token of the Institute's abiding reverence
for a teacher outstandingly learned, and
an eloquent Rabbi of Orthodox Jewish
life in America.
As for the Honorary Doctorate, which
the Institute confers upon you, the Fac-
ulty and the Board of Trustees alike re-
joice to think of you as one of the fine,
learned, inspiring teachers of American
Israel, firmly Conservative withal gen-
erously tolerant. You are not only
preacher in Israel, but a preacher's
preacher; teacher, in the highest, of the
preaching gift, who have built up a Con-
gregation, the Brooklyn Jewish Center,
which is become one of the great and
effective instruments of Jewish life in
the largest Jewish community of history.
The Jewish Institute of Religion is
honored to confer upon you an Honorary
Degree, which brings you nearer to it,
to us, who proudly and gladly welcome
you into the fellowship of the Honorary
Alumni of the Institute.
(Picture of award ceremony on page 34)
Sisterhood Installation and
Annual Meeting
At the Annual Meeting held last
Wednesday evening, June 2nd, Sisterhood
was happy to install into office, to serve
for the coming year, its new staff of offi-
cers, with Mrs. Morton Klinghoffer as the
new President, and its Executive Board.
The officers installed were: Vice-Presi-
dents, Mesdames Morris B. Levine, M.
Robert Epstein and Joseph Levy, Junior,
Recording Secretary, Mrs. Frank Schaef-
fer, Corresponding Secretary, Mrs. Ben-
jamin H. Wisner, Social Secretary, Mrs.
Louis Zakhem, and Treasurer, Mrs.
Hyman Rachmil.
The Annual Report, given by our out-
going President, Mrs. Maurice Bern-
hardt, reviewed the activities of the past
year, and the financial status reported by
our Treasurer, Mrs. Rachmil, stimulated
interest in Sisterhood's obligations. In
his role as installing officer, Rabbi Levin-
thai reminded the women of their spirit-
ual debt to our young people, married as
well as single, and urged that we plan
to include and inspire them to take part
in Center activities. Mrs. Klinghoffer,
as the new President, in her reply of ac-
ceptance for the entire staff, pledged to
emulate her predecessors and encouraged
the co-operation and participation of all
members in Sisterhood affairs. A delight-
ful musical program was rendered by the
tenor, "the singing cop," Ian Cosman, ac-
companied by Jack Baras at the piano.
Rabbi Saltzman, in a brief greeting, asso-
ciated the virtues of Ruth and Naomi
with those of our women, recommending
in his analogy closer ties with Sisterhood.
Surprise Testimonial Luncheon
To Mrs. Ruth Bernhardt
Sisterhood, as well as the guest of
honor, Mrs. Maurice Bernhardt, outgoing
President, enjoyed tremendously a testi-
monial luncheon given in her honor, on
Thursday, June 10th, at the Center.
Coming as a complete surprise, Mrs. Bern-
hardt was overwhelmed by the affection
in which she was held, so as to merit such
a beautiful party. The committee, in-
cluding Mrs. Isidor Lowenfield, Mrs. Mor-
ton Klinghoffer, Mrs. Israel Kaplan and
all the officers, outdid themselves in the
luncheon and. program arranged. Mrs.
Morton Klinghoffer wrote a parody on
"A Pretty Girl is Like a Melody," as her
tribute, beautifully sung by our own
Mabel Berman. Speakers included Mau-
rice Bernhardt, Mrs. Warwick Penny, rep-
resenting Red Cross, with whom Mrs.
Bernhardt was so actively associated dur-
ing the War, Mesdames M. Kaplan, S.
Klinghoffer, H. Modell and L. Lowenfeld,
who presented as a gift from the Sister-
hood, a beautiful gold watch. Richard
Harvey, star of the current Broadway
success, "Ballet Ballads," almost "stole
the show," his charming personality ex-
uding from each number he sang. The
informality and genuine cameraderie
which attended this affair, was a true
manifestation of the high regard in which
Mrs. Bernhardt is held.
Young Folks League Continue Weekly
Roof Meetings During Summer
The Young Folks League will continue
their weekly meetings on the roof,
weather permitting, every Tuesday eve-
ning. Admission is limited to members
only upon presentation of their 1948
membership cards. Come and join in the
sociability and cool relaxation of summer
evenings.
Impressive Consecration Exercises
Held On Shavuot
Our annual Consecration Service took
place on the first day of Shavuot, Sun-
day morning, June 13 th, at the close of
the Festival Service. The synagogue was
filled to capacity and the congregation
was deeply moved by the entire program
rendered by the Consecrants.
The theme of the Consecration this
year was, "The Sabbath in Jewish Life"
based on a cantata written by Rabbi and
Mrs. Morris Adler of Detroit, Mich., and
elaborated on by Rabbi Levinthal.
The Consecrants were led in the pro-
cession to the pulpit by our president,
Judge Emanuel Greenberg, and the chair-
man of our Hebrew Education Commit-
tee, Mr. Frank Schaeffer. While the
Consecrants were led to the pulpit, Can-
tor William Sauler and our synagogue
choral group, rendered a musical selec-
tion.
The following program was rendered:
Opening Prayer — Tobia Brown.
Blessings for the Torah — A — Ruth
Klinghoffer.
Blessings for the Torah — B — Marcia
Ginguld.
The following Consecrants took part
in the cantata: Barbara Danciger, Isa-
dora Aptheker, Anne Kabram, Joyce
Krimsky, Lorna Kaye, Helene Crane, Rita
Davis, Erna Finkelstein, Mary Rosenberg,
Joan Heimowitz, Arline Brill, Barbara
Lipson, Gladys Hoffman, Ann Joy Lev-
itt, Joyce Bernhardt, Marcia Spevack,
Isabel Miller, Shirley Aronow.
Pledge of Consecration — Julia Heimo-
witz.
Post Consecration Greeting — Bernice
Levitt Greenberg.
Conferring of Certificates and Blessing
— Dr. Israel H. Levinthal.
Closing Prayer — Doris Shapiro.
Procession from the pulpit, during
which Cantor William Sauler and the
congregation joined in the singing of
Adon Olam, the concluding hymn of the
Festival Service, after which the closing
benediction was pronounced by Rabbi
Levinthal.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
30
SISTERHOOD REPORT
By MRS. MAURICE BERNHARDT
Credit for the success of the Conse-
cration Service is due to the teacher of
the class, Miss Laura Viders; to Mr Jul-
ius Grossman, the musical director of our
Center, and to Rabbi Manuel Saltzman
who gave his personal supervision.
A suitable gift was presented to each
member of the class by the Sisterhood of
our Center.
Bar Mitzvah
A hearty Mazel Tov is extended to
Dr. and Mrs. Joseph Kasnetz of 678 East-
ern Parkway on the Bar Mitzvah of their
son, Herbert, which will be celebrated at
the Center on June 26th.
Congratulations
Our heartiest congratulations and best
wishes are extended to the following:
Air. and Mrs. Reuben Brenner of 146
Hooper Street on the marriage of their
son, William, to Miss Rose Schwartz, on
June 19th.
Mr. and Mrs. Herman Goldsmith of
770 St. Marks Avenue on the marriage
of their daughter, Thelma, to Mr. Irving
G. Kessler on June 20th.
Mr. and Mrs. Sydney Kasnowitz of
1024 Montgomery Street on the marriage
of their daughter, Rhoda, which will be
held at the Center on June 27th.
Mr. and Mrs. A. Kiel of 133 East 38th
Street on the celebration of their 2 5th
wedding anniversary on June 24th.
Mr. and Mrs. Maurice Levin of 1072
Park Place, who announce the marriage
of their daughter, Edith to Mr. Seymour
Blum on June 20th.
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Levin of 367
Crown Street on the occasion of the mar-
riage of their daughter, Adele, to Mr.
Stuart Gurman at Ridgefield Lakes,
Conn., on June 27th.
Mr. Irvin I. Rubin of 1475 President
Street on the occasion of his marriage to
Miss Laura Viders at the Center on June
23 rd.
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel H. Silberman of
590 Eastern Parkway on the announce-
ment of the marriage of their daughter,
Lila Phyllis to Mr. Bernard Benjamin on
June 20th.
Donation of Synagogue
Table Cover
A pulpit table cover was donated to
the Center in honor of the fiftieth wed-
ding anniversary of our treasurer, Mr.
David Goodstein and Mrs. Goodstein.
We extend to Mr. and Mrs. Goodstein our
heartiest thanks.
THIS report covers a period of V/ 2
/ears. Heretofore our elections and
installation of new officers were held in
January. This seemed impractical, and
the elections will now be held in the
spring.
Under the able chairmanship of Shirley
Gluckstein, the Center Sisterhood par-
ticipated enthusiastically in the one-day
drive for S.O.S., successfully soliciting
canned goods in local stores and apart-
ment houses. Through its efforts S.O.S.
led in Brooklyn.
Our October meeting was an outstand-
ing event in Sisterhood history. Under
the chairmanship of Anna Witty, we pre-
sented part of the Jewish Home Beauti-
ful, depicting the winter Jewish Holi-
days. Never will anyone who attended
this meeting forget the beauty and in-
spirational quality of the program.
This presentation was repeated in May,
with Sarah Klinghoffer as chairman, and
Dorothy Wisner as co-chairman. On this
occasion there was a presentation of the
Spring Jewish Holidays, making it an-
other memorable evening.
On October 22 we had our annual
mother and daughter luncheon, which
was most successful. Our chairman, Mrs.
Shirley Gluckstein, did an outstanding
job. We raised over $700.00 and a very
good time was had by all.
In October too we acted as hostesses
to the Federation of Jewish Women's
Organizations, with much acclaim and
appreciation for our hospitality.
Our group was well represented in the
Women's League Chanukah luncheon on
December 8. Under the able chairman-
ship of Lilian Lowenfeld, we packed and
shipped 100 Chanukah gift packages to
tbe D. P. camps for children in Europe.
Because of our 1946-47 contribution
to the Home for Aged, the institution
dedicated a bed tablet.
On December 8 the Sisterhood acted
as hostesses and sponsors of a Chanukah
party for the post-consecration girls, re-
sulting in an unusually interesting
evening. This event was under the chair-
manship of Mildred Levine and Dorothy
Wisner.
Through Sisterhood efforts, with Hattie
Roth as chairman, Sisterhood gave the
kiddushim to the Junior Congregation on
Rosh Chodesh of every month. Mr.
Brukenfeld gave the November Kiddush;
Mmes. Zakhem and Levitt and Irvin
Rubin gave kiddushim in December. In
Left to right: Standing — Mrs. Frank Schaeffer, Mrs. Ben']. Wisner, Mrs. Hyman
Rachmil, Mrs. Harry Zakhem. Seated: Mrs. Joseph Levy, Jr., Mrs. Morris B.
Levine, Mrs. Morton Klinghoffer, Mrs. M. Robert Epstein.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
3!
YAHRZEIT JULY, 1948
Manes Malz
Father
July 1
24 Sivan
Or. Louis S. Nelson
Mother
July 1
24 Sivan
Sol Sussman
Brother-in-law
July 2
2 5 Sivan
Isador S. Kocppel
Mother
July 2
2 5 Sivan
Louis H. Samuels
Tulv 2
2 5 Sivan
Herman D. Raabin
Mother
July 2
2 5 Sivan
Henry Teller
Father
July 2
2 5 Sivan
A. L. Goldman.,
Mother
July 3
26 Sivan
Mrs. Phillip Brenner
July 4
S. Kamenetzky
Father
July 4
27 Sivan
Joseph Feldt
Father
July 5
28 Sivan
Mrs. Ida Ginsberg
Father
July 6
29 Sivan
Tobias Zwerdling
Father
July 7
30 Sivan
Hon. A. David Benjamin
Brother
July 9
2 Tammuz
Mrs. H. Lieb
Husband
July 9
2 Tammuz
Mrs. Samuel Greenblatt
Father
July 10
3 Tammuz
Abraham Shapiro
Wife
July 10
3 Tammuz
Louis Albert
Father
July 11
4 Tammuz
Morris W. Haft
Mother
July 11
4 Tammuz
Charles Fine
Father
July 12
5 Tammuz
Mark J. Goell
Mother
July 13
6 Tammuz
Henry A. Kahan
Brother
July 13
6 Tammuz
Dr. Abraham Levine
Brother
July 13
6 Tammuz
Julius Light
Mother
lulv 13
6 Tammuz
Lewis E. \^eingarten
Father
July 13
6 Tammuz
Mrs. Leo Kaufmann
Father
July 14
7 Tammuz
Nathan Schwartz
.Brother
Tnlv 14.
juiy it
7 Tammuz
Joseph Lazarowitz.,
jury i>
8 Tammuz
Mrs. Jacob G. Ellis
Husband
July 18
1 1 Tammuz
Mrs. George Dubrow
Father
July 19
ic 1 amrr.uz
Bernard Isacowitz
)
> Father
13 Tammuz
Murray D. Isacowitz
July 20
Rabbi Israel H. Levinthal
Mother
July 20
1 3 Tammuz
Mrs. Nathan D. Shapiro
Mother
July 20
13 Tammuz
Harold L. Forman
Father
July 21
14 Tammuz
Dr. Samuel D. Greenfield
Father
July 21
14 Tammuz
A'lurray Flusid
Mother
July 21
14 Tammuz
July 21
14 Tammuz
Wife
Tulv 22
1 5 Tammuz
A^Irs. Emanuel Flalperin
) Husband }
July 22
15 Tammuz
( Son |
Philip A. Levin
Father
July 22
1 5 Tammuz
Joseph H. Rose
Mother
July 22
1 5 Tammuz
rSernara jussman
)
j Father
July 22
1 5 Tammuz
Harold Sussman
Mrs H. Lieb
Daughter
July 23
16 Tammuz
Dr. Jacob Ruchman
Father
July 23
16 Tammuz
Tobias Zwerdling
Brother
July 23
16 Tammuz
Morris Brukenfeld
Mother
July 24
17 Tammuz
Louis Horowitz
Brother
July 24
17 Tammuz
Mrs. Louis Posner
Husband )
Father J
July 24
17 Tammuz
Dr. Leonard Posner
Eli as Burros
Father
July 2 5
18 Tammuz
Aaron Gottlieb
Father
July 26
19 Tammuz
Mrs. Samuel L. Kaplan
Husband
July 26
19 Tammuz
January, Mrs. Katz; February, Mrs. Elea-
nor Horowitz; March, Lil Levy; April,
Mrs. Kushner; May, Mrs. Gross; and
June, by Mrs. Klinghoffer.
We participated very actively in Fed-
eration of Jewish Philanthropies drive, un-
der the chairmanship of Ida Fortunoff. A
substantial amount was raised. We also
participated in Jewish Day for the Blind.
Hannah Stark, Lillian Zakhem, Lilian
Lowenfeld and Mrs. Heman Pashenz were
on the committee.
I am very proud that during my regime
a Sisterhood constitution was written and
adopted.
We held a very successful Torah
Scholarship Fund luncheon under the
chairmanship of Sarah Epstein, with Dor-
othy Wisner, co-chairman, and Lucy
Greenberg in charge of refreshments.
They received wonderful cooperation. As
a result of this event we presented Rabbi
Levinthal with a certificate for two
scholarships, given in honor of his 60th
birthday, to the Seminary.
We hope that our participation in
U.J.A., under the chairmanship of Lil-
ian Lowenfeld — assisted in a small way
by myself — will be very successful.
Our meetings throughout the year have
been very interesting, meaty with Sister-
hood activities and culture. Much time
and effort was given to this part of our
work by your newly elected president,
Mrs. Sarah Klinghoffer. I want to thank
her. I believe it was through her efforts
that the Sisterhood has grown to such
proportions.
I want to thank the outgoing officers
for their heartfelt cooperation. To the
board of directors, who regularly attended
all meetings and inspired me to carry on,
many sincere thanks. To Rose Weiner
my gratitude for acting as pinch-hitter
secretary when we needed her most. To
Mrs. Rachmil, who is always our finan-
cial guide, to Mrs. Zakhem, as hostess-
chairman, and to Mrs. Lowenfeld, whose
efforts were invaluable throughout. Also
to Rose Weiner, chairman of nomination
committee, who, together with her com-
mittee, presented you with such a grand
array of officers and board of directors.
I wish to thank Mr. Joseph Goldberg,
Miss Chertoff, Mrs. Powell and Mrs. Rose
for their never-failing cooperation.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
32
Arthur Granovsky
July 29
22 Tammuz
Mrs. Solomon Mitrani.
Father
July 29
22 Tammuz
Louis J. Roth
Brother
July 30
23 Tammuz
Charles Fine ... .
Mother
July 31
24 Tammuz
Simon Gluckstern
Son
July 31
24 Tammuz
Dr. Max Goldstein
Wife
July 31
24 Tammuz
AUGUST-1948
George Fein . .
Mrs. Max Portnoy...
J. L. Horowitz
Benjamin Werbelovsky .
Mrs. Joseph Zucker
Dr. Louis A. Friedman
Victor W. Filler
Louis B. Hymes
Hyman Rachmil
Abe Schlusselberg
Jack Silverman
Mrs. Louis B. Hymes
Jacob S. Donor
Mrs. Harry Green
Morris Groden
Herman A. Katz
Martin Katz
Paul Katz
Phil Katz
Samuel Pasner
Akiba Margolin
A. E. Rothman
Hyman Aaron..
Joseph I. Aaron
Oscas Kurshan
Samuel L. Kurshan
Arthur Granovsky
Mrs. Julius L. Rawick
George Shapiro
Nathan D. Shapiro
Mrs. Louis J. Roth
Barnett Tanenbaum
Mrs. Ida Ginsberg
Benjamin Levitt
Mrs. Tillie Leff
Mrs. Jesse Fine
Mrs. Oscar Swarzman...
Irving Rosenbluth
Mrs. Louis N. Jaffe .
Albert Jaffe
George Fein
Mrs. Max Portnoy
!
Mother
August
1
25
Tammuz
Mother
August
1
25
Tammuz
Mother
August
25
Tammuz
Father
August
1
25
Tammuz
Father 1
and >
August
2
26
Tammuz
Mother J
Mother
August
4
28
Tammuz
Father
August
4
28
Tammuz
Brother
August
4
28
Tammuz
Mother
August
5
29
Tammuz
Mother
August
5
29 Tammuz
Father
August
7
2
Ab
Mother
August
8
3
Ab
Father
August
8
3
Ab
Mother
August
8
3
Ab
Father
August
9
4 Ab
Mother
August
9
4
Ab
Son
August
11
6
Ab
Father
August
11
6
Ab
Mother
August
12
7
Ab
Mother
August
12
7
Ab
Mother
August
13
8
Ab
Brother
August
13
8
Ab
Mother
August
14
9
Ab
Daughter
August
14
9
Ab
Mother
August
15
10
Ab
Father
August
15
10
Ab
Husband
Father
| August
16
11
Ab
Father
and
August
16
Ab
Mother
Husband
Ab
Father
j- August 17
12
Father
August
18
13
Ab
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Bloom, Sam
Res. 765 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Handbags, 1165 Bway.
Married
Glass, Allen
Res. 225 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Attorney, 509 — 5 th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Samuel Horowitz
Kammerman, Mrs. Rebecca
Res. 212 E. 94th St.
Proposed by Benj. Adler,
Alfred Cohen
Maslow, Seymour
Res. 789 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Student, N. Y. U.
Single
Proposed by Dr. Herman Maslow
Palley, Miss L. Laura
Res. 22 5 Eastern Pkwy.
Sragowitz, Joseph
Res. 95 India St.
Bus. Student
Single
Taub, Miss Debra
Res. 118 Sutter Ave.
Taub, Samuel, N.
Res. 1 1 8 Sutter Ave.
Single
Weitz, Mortimer
Res. 290 E. 93rd St.
Bus. Electronics, 3410 Linden PI.
Single
Weitz, William
Res. 290 E. 93rd St.
Bus. C.P.A., 1451 Bway.
Single
Woods, Harry E.
Res. 101 Lincoln Rd.
Bus. Attorney, 1 Park Pi.
Married
High Holy Day Tickets
Due to the lateness of the High Holy
Days this year we are anticipating an
unusual demand for seats. The Commit-
tee will endeavor to accommodate our
membership, as far as possible. Center
members who occupied seats last year are
requested to please notify us immediately
whether they intend to occupy the same
seats during the coming High Holy Days.
Seats not reordered will be assigned to
other members making reservations for
them.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
33
Abraham Winter
Joseph Winter
Moses Reznick ...
Mrs Harold Abrams
Mrs. H. R. Litchfield
M. M. Lubcll
Dr. Max Goldstein
A. Lieberman
Robert J. Bank. ...
Israel M. Dolgin
Harry Preston
David Seideman
Julius L. Horowitz
Dr. Jacob Monto
I. Jerome Riker
Hyman Aaron
Joseph I. Aaron
Joseph Goldstein
Joseph A. Solevei
Sidney J. Lipson
Joseph Horowitz
Morris Neinken
Hyman Rothkopf
Morris Rothkopf
S. Rothkopf
Isidor Fine
Mrs. David Greenberg .
Judah Trotzky
Samuel Marcus
Rubin Tucker
Mrs. Jacob Garlick
Irving Horowitz
Mrs. J. D. Posner
Mrs. Arthur Joseph
Mrs. Roy Leibler
Dr. M. L. Levy ,
Louis Simon
Mrs. Ida Ginsberg
Louis Brenner
Phillip Brenner
Mrs. Louis Hornick
David Halpern
Joseph Stark
Samuel Stark
Mrs. Harold Abrams
Mrs. H. R. Litchfield ..
Mrs. A. Prince
Isidor Wexler
• Father
August 18
13
Ab
Mother
August 19
14
Ab
. Mother
August 20
15
Ab
Father
August 22
17
Ab
M.-in-law
August 23
18
Ab
Father
August 24
19
Ab
Father
August 25
20
Ab
Father
August 26
21
Ab
Mother
August 26
21
Ab
Mother
August 26
21
Ab
M.-in-law
August 27
22
Ab
Father
August 27
22
Ab
Father
August 27
22
Ab
Mother
August 28
23
Ab
Father
August 28
23
Ab
Father
August 28
23
Ab
Father
August 29
24
Ab
Mother
August 30
25
Ab
Father
August 30
2 5
AD
IBER-
1948
Mother
September
1
27
Ab
Father
September
2
28
Ab
Father
September
2
28
Ab
Father
September
2
28
Ab
Father
September
3
29
Ab
Mother
September
3
29
Ab
Husband
September
4
30
Ab
Mother
September
5
1
Elul
Husband )
Father }
September
5
1
Elul
Mother
September
6
2
Elul
Mother
September
6
2
Elul
Husband
September
8
4
Elul
Brother
September
9
5
Elul
Husband
September
7
3
Elul
Mother
September
8
4
Elul
Father
September
9
5
Elul
Father
September 1 0
6
Elul
Husband
September
10
6
Elul
Mother
September 1 1
7
Elul
Graduation
Miss Elaine Samuels, daughter of Mr.
and Mrs. Philip Samuels of 814 Mont-
gomery Street has been graduated from
Syracuse University on July 14th.
Miss Marilyn Levine, daughter of Mr.
and Mrs. Nathan J. Levine of 675 Em-
pire Boulevard has been graduated from
Brooklyn College receiving a Bachelor of
Arts degree.
Center Contributes $10,000
To United Jewish Appeal
In Honor of the Jewish State
The Board of Trustees, at a meeting
held on June 17th, unanimously voted a
contribution of $10,000 to the United
Jewish Appeal. This contribution is
made in honor of the establishment of the
State of Israel and to further its welfare.
At the same meeting it was agreed to
again tax High Holy Day tickets for
the benefit of the Jewish National Fund.
Tickets selling for more than $10.00 will
be taxed with $1.00, while those selling
at $10.00 or less, will be taxed 50 cents.
Congratulations
Hearty congratulations are extended
to:
Mr. and Mrs. George Fein of 2209
Avenue K on the marriage of their son,
Sheldon H., to Miss Marilyn Jacobs at
the Center on June 20th.
Mr. Isidor Fine, our former President
and Mrs. Fine of 13 5 Eastern Parkway
on the occasion of their fortieth wedding
anniversary on June 20th.
Mr. and Mrs. Jacob Jcntelson of 40
East 8 8 th Street, New York City, on the
announcement of the engagement of their
son, Theodore, to Miss Elaine Frances
Rosenfeld of Scranton, Pa.
Mr. and Mrs. Harry M. Levine of 576
Eastern Parkway on the birth of a son,
Norman Lee, to their children, Mr. and
Mrs. Harry Silver on June 15 th.
Mr. and Mrs. Morris Levinson of 1448
President Street on the marriage of their
daughter, Joan, to Mr. Richard Allan
Silverman of New York City, on June
4th.
Mr. and Mrs. Louis J. Roth of 44
Hampton Place on the occasion of the
marriage of their son, Sidney, to Miss
Maria Neumann on June 22nd.
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph J. Prince of 532
LerTerts Avenue on the engagement of
their daughter, Thelma Evelyn, to Mr.
Frank Berlin on June 11th.
Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin Schwartz of
290 Empire Boulevard on the birth of a
daughter, Susan Laurie, to their children,
Mr. and Mrs. Martin Safron on June 15 th.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
34
From left to right: Dr. Stephen S. Wise, President of the Jewish Institute of Religion,
Rabbi A. Granison, assistant to the President, Dr. Henry Slonimsky, dean, Dr. Israel
H. Levinthal and Dr. Sidney E. Goldstein, Professor of Jewish Social Service.
Center Academy Holds
Commencement Exercises
The Graduation Exercises of the Center
Academy, at which 400 parents, guests
and students were present, was featured
by the presentation of two original plays,
"Alice in Historyland" and "Habonim
Shel Israel."
Fifteen members of the graduating
class received their diplomas at the hands
of Dr. Israel H. Levinthal, who exhorted
them to keep alive the interest in the
Judaic traditions which he felt sure had
been implanted in them at the Center
Academy.
The graduates were presented to Dr.
Levinthal, by Dr. Solomon J. Miller,
President of the Board of Trustees.
Hyman Sorokoff, Principal of the Center
Academy, in the closing address, spoke
briefly on the position of the Jew in
American life today.
Summer Gymnasium Schedule
The following Gym and Baths De-
partment schedule will prevail during
July and August:
Monday: Men, 3 to 10 p.m.; Women,
10 a.m. to 3 p.m.; Boys, 3 to 5 p.m.
Tuesday: Women, 10 a.m. to 10 p.m.;
Girls, 3 to 5 p.m.
Wednesday: Men, 3 to 10 p.m.; Wo-
men, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.; Boys, 3 to 5 p.m.
Thursday: Men, 5 to 10 p.m.; Women,
10 a.m. to 5 p.m.; Girls, 3 to 5 p.m.
Friday: Men and Boys, 1 to 6 p.m.
Sundays and Legal Holidays: Men, 10
a.m. to 2 p.m.; Boys, 2 to 5 p.m.
During "Nine Days"
The Gym and Baths Department will
be closed during the "Nine Days" begin-
ning Friday, August 6th through Sunday,
August 16th. The department will re-
open as usual on Monday morning, Au-
gust 16th at 10:00 a.m. for women.
Summer Library Schedule
The library of the Center will be
open during the summer months on Mon-
days, Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thurs-
days from 3 to 9 p.m.
Sabbath Services
Friday evening services at 6:00 and
7:00.
Kindling of candles at 8:12.
Sabbath services, "Behaaloteka" — Num-
bers 8:1 — 12:16; Prophets - Zechariah
2:14 — 4:7, will commence at 8:30 a.m.
Mincha services Sat. at 6:00 p.m.
Rabbi Saltzman will preach on the
weekly portion of the Torah.
Class in Talmud led by Mr. Jacob S.
Doner will be held at 4:00 p.m.
Rabbi George Abelson will continue his
lecture in Yiddish this Saturday afternoon
at 5:15 p.m.
Daily Services
Morning services at 8:00 a.m.
Mincha services at 8:20 p.m.
Condolence
Our heartfelt condolences are extended
to Mr. Julius H. Gruber of 751 St. Marks
Avenue, on the loss of his beloved father,
Max, on June 9th.
SEPTEMBER — 1948
Samuel Horowitz Mother September 1 1 7 Elul
Mrs. A. L. Goldman Mother September 12 8 Elul
Philip Feldman Mother September 13 9 Elul
Mrs. David Greenberg. ... .... Father September 14 10 Elul
Mrs. Jacob Ruchman Mother September 14 10 Elul
Hyman Rachmil Sister September 15 11 Elul
Moses E. Fuchs Father September 15 11 Elul
Samuel Meltzer Mother September 15 11 Elul
Mrs. Jacob Fortunoff Father September 16 12 Elul
Louis Samuels Mother September 18 14 Elul
Phillip Brenner 1 Mothcr & ber 20 16 Elul
Louis Brenner \
Hon. Irwin Steingut Mother September 21 17 Elul
Hyman Bloomgarden Wife September 21 17 Elul
Philip Rosenblum Sister September 21 17 Elul
Mrs. Morris Brukenfeld Father September 21 17 Elul
Charles Saner Mother September 22 18 Elul
David Spiegel Nathan Spiegel ) September 22 18 Elul
Mrs. Harold Halpenn )
Abraham Shapiro Father September 23 19 Elul
Mrs. Leo Hirsch Husband September 2 5 21 Elul
Louis Saffer Mother September 25 21 Elul
I. Jerome Riker Father September 27 23 Elul
Abraham Goldsmith Mother September 28 24 Elul
Mrs. Aaron Lewis Husband September 29 2 5 Elul
Harold Lewis j September 29 25 Elul
Philip Lewis J
Note: Observance of Yahrzeit commences at sundown on the evening preceding
the specified date.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
35
LOUIS DEMBITZ BRANDEIS
[Continued from page 24]
is making clear the value of small na-
tions, shall we voluntarily yield to anti-
Semitism and instead of solving our prob-
lem end it by ignoble suicide? Surely
this is no time for Jews to despair. Let
us make clear to the world that we too
are a nationality striving for equal rights,
for life and to self-expression."
His subsequent service to Jewry and
to Zionism have been legion. In the war
years he addressed meetings throughout
the country and united Jewish opinion in
support of the proposals which were later
at the Versailles Peace Conference to take
form in the Mandate. At the Confer-
ence his persuasive influence on Balfour
played a great part in the actual birth
of the Mandate. He served as chairman
of the Provisional Committee for gen-
eral Zionist affairs. His voice called to-
gether in Jewish life the captains of the
tens and the captains of the thousands,
THE CENTER'S UNIQUE
[Continued from page 7]
dicating that he is beginning to realize
the hazards of tilling the communal soil;
the chief characteristic of Joe Kaye is
impatience, which his associates com-
monly describe as intolerance.
When the meeting opens Mr. Goldberg
produces one of his inexhaustible sheets
of scrap paper and draws up an agenda.
As he does so Louis makes a passing com-
ment on some item of news; Bill idly
answers, while shifting his feet from the
floor to the President's desk. During the
next forty-five minutes there is a contest
between a swelling discussion engaged in
by Bill and Louis, and the agenda lying
before Mr. Goldberg's troubled eyes.
Finally one line of the agenda wins, but
not for long. A three-four-or-five-cor-
nered debate suddenly springs up from
GERMANY'S
[Continued from page 25]
nationalism, ridiculed him, declaring that
he had made his Biblical heroes talk like
Nordic heathen gods and barbarians — a
reproach not entirely justified.
What was this man, then, that I saw
die in the Jewish hospital of Vienna a few
months before Hitler was to occupy Aus-
trij? An opportunist, a mere mounte-
and by the force of his personality and
the completely selfless energy of his work,
these captains and their followers were
molded into a unity which made the op-
position of the few remaining dissidents
seem puerile and vacuous.
The miracle of Jewish survival for two
thousand years in an adverse world has
been due to the qualities of our people
and to the ideals which we have cher-
ished. Equally, however, a force with
these has been the emergence in time of
need of heroic men and women, of wise
counsellors, and of inspiring exemplars.
In that long line of men and women who
on the canvas of History have personified
the Jewish people Louis Dembitz Brandeis
will take his proper place among those
who have led "earnestly, courageously and
joyously in the struggle for liberation,"
and who have stricken from the mind of
the Jewish people the curse of inferiority.
PROJECT — THE "REVIEW"
nowhere and the agenda is obscure once
more. Finally, just before quitting time,
the next issue of the Review is planned,
manuscripts accepted or rejected and
other technical matters attended. How
this is done no one has known for fif-
teen years, and no one is likely to know
in the future.
* * *
Now the Review proceeds to journey
on to another anniversary, and the period
it will live through will be one of the
most inspiring, most productive and most
critical in Jewish history. It is surely a
privilege for the Review to live through
such an epoch, and to reflect, through its
work, the fine spirit of service which has
always been identified with the Brooklyn
Jewish Center.
TRAGIC JEW
bank, an "Aher" of German Jewry? I
do not believe so. I think he was sincere
in his desire — like that of the late
philosopher Hermann Cohen — for a
complete amalgamation of Judaism and
Germanism, without, however, abandon-
ment of the Mosaic faith. When Hitler
came to power in Germany, Lissauer's
dreams seemed destroyed forever, and in
his last years he wrote a cycle of tragic
confessional psalms no less moving than
the longing stanzas Heinrich Heine had
written on his matratzengruft in Paris
eighty years before.
A FORMULA FOR JEWISH
LIFE IN AMERICA
[Continued from page 21]
sense but in a negative sense. They sought
plausible ways and means of disassociat-
ing themselves from Jews and Judaism
without too much violence to their self-
respect. Some luminaries in the firma-
ment of western culture did not even
shrink from cowardly compromise and
base surrender to the dominant faith.
The catacylsmic events in Europe,
symbolized by the rise of Fascism and
Nazism, caused modern man to re-
examine his attitude towards religion and
to realize that art and science, without
leverage outside of themselves, are not
sufficient to insure moral evolution of so-
ciety; that without religious sanctions
rooted in a firm belief of immortality,
divine justice, and human responsibility
to a universal God, the Nietzschean phi-
losophy of force will ultimately dominate
the world. Humanitarianism, the finest
flower of the Hebraic prophetic genius,
mediated into the larger world by Chris-
tianity, will, in a neo-pagan world, be
considered, in the words of Hitler,
The strutting and conquering legions
under the sign of the swastika resemble
in presumption, fervor, absoluteness, and
mysticism, the conquering legions of
Mohammed. Only by realizing and rec-
ognizing that Nazism is a resurgent pagan
faith and not a temporary political ex-
pedient of an aggrieved people, can we
adequately mobilize the forces of the
world in battle against it. These forces,
in the last analysis, must be spiritual and
moral.
Give Your Child a Jewish Education
REGISTRATION NOW OPEN
for the
Brooklyn Jewish Cenier
Hebrew School
Classes meet 3 times a week — 2 hour?
each session. The curriculum includes
Siddur, Hebrew, Bible, History and
Jewish music. Expert faculty under
the direction of Rabbi Mordecai H.
Lewittes.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
■ ■
ABBOT-FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES-SERVICE
507 Flatbush Avenue
JESSE J. FINE Brooklyn, New York
JACK ABBOT Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
■ RIVERSIDE
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2-6600
Far Rockaway, L. I. Miami Beach, Florida
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE 1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
FAr Rockaway 7-7100 Miami 5-7777
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle, we have arranged to
serve your Community. We have at our disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn.
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed
Sec. 562, P. L. & R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
(7h& CJ&ijcrtykLwi
THE AMAZING SABBATAI ZEVI
By JACOB S. MINKIN
HOW ISRAEL'S NATIONAL
THEATRE STARTED
By R. BEN-ARI
NEW BOOKS
Reviewed by DR. ISRAEL H. LEVI NTH AL
m
NEWS OF THE MONTH
mi
ROSH HASHONAH GREETINGS
CENTER BULLETIN BOARD
ANNUAL MOTHER -DAUGHTER LUNCHEON
and FASHION SHOW
Presented by
THE CENTER SISTERHOOD
Wednesday, October 27, 12 Noon
Reservations may be made at the Center Office, or through
Chairman, Mrs. Robert M. Epstein, 701 Montgomery Street, SLocum 6-7413
ENROLL IN
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER INSTITUTE
OF JEWISH STUDIES FOR ADULTS
Affiliated with the National Academy for Adult Jewish Studies
COURSES OF STUDY FACULTY
Director:
THE PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION ISRAEL HERBERT LEVINTHAL
JEWISH HISTORY ^***RABB MMANUEL SALTZMAN
TALMUD ALEXANDER J. BURNSTEIN
SAMUEL EDELHEIT
HEBREW MICHAEL HIGGER
THE BIBLE IN HEBREW JEAN SERBIN-BEDER
HEBREW LITERATURE PaSl^W^REB
PRAYER BOOK EVELYN ZUSMAN
Registrar:
YIDDISH MRS. E. N. RABUSOWITZ
— Registrations Daily at the Center Office —
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER HAS
ACQUIRED CEMETERY GROUNDS IN THE
NEW MONTEFIORE CEMETERY, PINELAWN, LONG ISLAND
Prices of Plots
4 GRAVES $ 250.00
6 GRAVES 350.00
15 GRAVES - - - - 1.000.00
(Facing the Main Road)
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Vol. XXX AUGUST - SEPTEMBER, 1948 — ELUL 5708 No. 3
CONSTITUTIONAL PROBLEMS IN ISRAEL
IN THE conflict between the State of
Israel and its Arab and British enemies,
the people of Israel are fighting as one
with a united courage that has, at this
moment, fought to standstill the might
of eight nations.
The peace will, however, not find the
people of Israel in such complete agree-
ment. On the contrary, the differences
of opinion on questions of economics, re-
ligion and government will probably ap-
pear at least to be stronger and more
fiercely decisive in Israel than in most
countries much greater in size and popu-
lation. There is nothing unhealthy or
deplorable in such a situation. Israel is
a new country, but its people are an old
people. They come from many lands,
and they represent a multiplicity of ex-
periences from which have developed dif-
fering and, in instances, conflicting at-
titudes and basic philosophies of life and
government. These have, in turn, been
grafted upon basic and traditional Jewish
concepts. It is small wonder, therefore,
that the new state of Israel, youngest of
all nations, but at the same time heir to
the experiences of all nations, is the most
interesting and the most significant polit-
ical experiment of our time.
•
It is this background which is condi-
tioning the contemporary process ot cre-
ating the forms of government of Israel
and establishing its constitutional basis.
A constitution must concern itself
with those fundamental laws which out-
line the ultimate attitudes of a people to-
wards its manner of living and its rela-
tion to the government under which it
will live. A constitution cannot contain
within itself the numerous laws by which
this basic attitude is implemented. It
is the road along which the destiny of a
country is travelled and not the vehicle
by which the journey is made. Obvi-
ously, therefore, all groups which parti-
cipate in the creation of such a constitu-
tion are eager that their points of view
shall prevail in arriving at a basic law.
We know that some of the greatest de-
bates in history, participated in by some
of history's most notable men, occurred
during the drafting of the American con-
stitution. With less present knowledge
as to details, we know that the same
process is occurring in Israel now.
•
A drafting committee is setting up in
provisional form an instrument which
will be submitted to a constitutional con-
vention. The problems faced by this
committee are numerous, intricate and
fundamental. They involve, for instance,
a consideration of religious questions, eco-
nomic matters, and also questions of the
forms of government itself. It is not
intended here to particularize the situa-
tion. A mere statement of some of these
problems will show the enormous com-
plexities of the subjects being dealt with
by this committee: Shall there be a state
religion? If yes, what form of observance
and to what degree of orthodoxy shall it
take? If no, to what extent shall the
government support religion in general?
In the field of government, shall there be
a parliamentary system, with a cabinet
responsive directly to the parties, or shall
there be a republic with a government
existing for a stated period between elec-
tions as in the United States? Shall the
executive be strong, or shall the greater
degree of power reside in the legislative
body? Shall the legislature have one
house or two? In the field of economics,
to what extent shall government regulate
industry and labor? Shall government
guarantee and create opportunities for
work? And if it does, shall the individual
citizen be obliged to work, and under
what conditions? Shall new enterprise be
stimulated by government or by private
capital? And if the latter, to what ex-
tent, and with what governmental en-
couragement and immunities?
•
Other nations have had generations of
practice by trial and error to arrive at
least approximate solutions to these prob-
lems, Israel is faced with the same urg-
ency of time with respect to these vital
questions as it has been in the matter of
its very birth and defense. No one can
say now how wisely these problems will
be treated in the adjustment to the con-
ditions of Israel. W'c do, however, have
the right to believe that the same united
devotion which has defended the country
will give the various parties and partisans
the wisdom to submerge unimportant dif-
ferences and to bring about a unity of
spirit from which will emerge a govern-
ment under which the people of Israel
can be happy and the nation of Israel can
be strong and enduring.
— William I. Siegel.
EDITORIAL BOARD
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Louis J. Gribetz, Chairman
Joseph Goldberg M. H. Levtittes
Joseph Kaye Manuel Saltzman
I. H. Levinthal William I. Siegel
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Greenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Goodsteln, Treasurer Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthal. D.D., D.H.L., Rabbi Manuel Saltiman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
4
"JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES"
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
YEAR 1 OF ISRAEL
IT IS with a feeling of gratitude and
in a mood of solemnity that we shall
assemble in our Synagogues on the com-
ing Holy Days. We shall express our
thankfulness for the historic change that
has come into the life of our people and
our people's land. The hope that we
voiced in our prayers a year ago has been
realized — Israel has been re-born, the
Jewish State in the land of Israel is now
established. Yea, our hearts will overflow
with thanksgiving to God for the miracle
that we were privileged to behold; we will
recall with loving appreciation the heroism
and the martyrdom of our brothers and
sisters in Israel who helped to make this
miracle possible in our day.
But it will also be a feeling of awe
and solemnity which will fill our hearts
as we enter our Houses of Prayer during
this New Year. For we realize that the
task is not yet finished, that our goal is
not yet reached. To quote the words of
our immortal Bialik: "The path is yet
long; great is yet the war!"
We are living in an age when, alas,
justice has not yet been enthroned. The
fate of Israel is but a phase of the world
struggle which we now behold, and ex-
JEWS throughout the world approach
the New Year of 5709 with an enthu-
siasm of faith which may make Rosh
Hashonah the turning point not only of
Israel's political future but of the history
of religion and the story of mankind. Not
since the exodus from Egypt has an event
been as revolutionary and cataclysmic in
its implications as the rebirth of the State
of Israel. For the Jew only the theophony
at Mt. Sinai, when the children of Israel
stood round the mountain and heard the
voice of God out of the flames of fire
amidst the thundering and lightning, can
be compared to the soul-stirring rebirth
of Israel which has infused our people
with new courage and hope. Our faith
pediency is still regarded as a more potent
rule to follow than morality. We shall
therefore have to gird ourselves for fur-
ther struggle. On these "Days of Awe,"
we must consecrate ourselves anew for
the battle of justice and righteousness
which the land of Israel symbolizes.
American Jewry has served Israel glori-
ously in the past few years, but we must
continue to serve and to help with even
greater devotion and sacrifice in the crit-
ical months ahead. We cannot, we dare
not, forsake our brethren now.
On these Yomim Noraim, when we
pray for life, let us think, too, of the
life of our people and our people's land.
For with the assurance of life to Israel,
our lives too will be enhanced. May the
year 5709, which is year I of the new
Israel, vouchsafe for us, for our brothers
yet languishing in Europe, and above all,
for the new Jewish State in Israel, the
dawn of a new life — a life of joy and
happiness, of hope and confidence, of
strength and achievement, of peace and
blessedness.
Israel H. Levi nth al
in God has been vindicated.
In the past we survived against the
crudest odds because we possessed an un-
alterable faith in the God of Justice. We
maintained the belief that the Lord was
in our midst, although oft-times His
presence was obscured and obliterated by
the clouds of hatred and persecution that
enveloped us. It was in this atmosphere
of injustice and cruelty that we would
assemble for Rosh Hashonah to reaffirm
our faith in God. Now we have beheld
the work of the Lord. The vitality and
recuperative power of Israel, a people re-
jected and despised, will forever serve as
a symbol of the strength that comes from
faith in the principles and the values of
A GREAT WORK NOW
AVAILABLE
"The Authorized Daily Prayer Book, with
English translation, Commentary and
Notes, by the late Chief Rabbi, Dr.
Joseph H. Hertz. Bloch Publishing
Co., 1948.
THE first revised American edition of a
* great work has just been published by
the Bloch Publishing Company. This is
"The Authorized Daily Prayer Book," by
the late Chief Rabbi of the British Em-
pire, Dr. Joseph H. Hertz.
Here in one volume is the complete
Prayer Book for all the year, with an
English translation and a running com-
mentary on practically every prayer. Dr.
Hertz gives you the benefit of the re-
search of the great scholars, ancient and
modern, in interpreting the prayers, and
thus helps the reader to get a new and
better appreciation of these ancient out-
pourings of the Jewish heart.
The many explanatory and historical
notes which are scattered throughout its
pages are one of the most valuable fea-
tures of the volume. They form a verit-
able storehouse of information with re-
gard to many of the theological beliefs
and doctrines to which the prayers gave
expression.
Our religious life would be greatly en-
riched and our Synagogue services would
certainly be more meaningful, if our
people would study this work and master
the true meaning and significance of our
prayers, which are made so clear by the
rich and penetrating comments of Dr.
Hertz.
— Dr. Israel H. Levinthal.
Judaism and religion.
We must not permit our lives to revel
in the ecstasy of our achievement of the
past year. The new Year confronts us
with a host of problems perhaps more
formidable than those we have already
encountered. Cynicism and doubt, tem-
porarily defeated, are conspiring to un-
dermine our faith and hope. The chal-
lenge of the New Year is whether we
can sustain our faith. The year 5709
must become a year in which we will
all experience a more profound faith in
consequence of greater achievements and
blessings for Israel and mankind.
— Manuel Saltzman.
A TIME FOR RENEWED FAITH
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
The World Notes the 300th
Anniversary of a Startling Event
THE AMAZING LIFE OF
SABBATAI ZEVI
ON ROSH HASHANAH, in the
year 1648, a young man of
twenty-two, Sabbatai Zevi, pro-
nounced in the full hearing of an awed
congregation in Smyrna, the four-lettered
name of the Deity. This was an act un-
heard of since the Holy Temple in Jeru-
salem was in existence, and then the name
was pronounced only by the High Priest.
With this utterance, the youth put an
end to the battle that raged in his mind
for some time past. And as he strolled
out of the synagogue, pale with excite-
ment, into the cool air of the street, he
left a congregation that was hovering be-
tween panic and jubilation.
Was this Sabbatai Zevi madman or Mes-
siah, blasphemer or the promised Re-
deemer? His daring left no other
thoughts. For the dazed men in the con-
gregation well knew that in the Diaspora,
uttering the sbem bantpborasb, the full
name of God, was only the privilege of
martyrs at the stake and, in the End of
Time, of the Messiah. But here was the
son of Mordecai, the youth they knew so
well and, indeed, admired for his piety,
learning, and modest bearing, making
himself guilty of the most stupendous of-
fense! Was a spell cast over him, or had
he lost his mind because of his pre-occu-
pation with the occult science of the
Kabbalah?
•
So mused the hoary heads of the syna-
gogue, but the young men in the con-
gregation were of another opinion. They
received Sabbatai Zevi's daring declaration
with an ecstasy of fervor seldom ac-
corded to so young a man. Indeed, they
laid aside their prayer books and, with
transported faces, they looked up to him,
calling out rapturously, "Messiah." Even
one or two of the older men, forgetting
for the moment their skepticism, were
swept away by the excitement and joined
the multitude in their adulation of the
risen Messiah. Thus passed the first
phase of his struggle; he must now make
the whole world his arena.
It did not all happen suddenly. Young
though Sabbatai was, what transpired in
the synagogue was the culmination of
years of careful and exacting preparation.
He was the eldest of his father, Mordecai
Zevi's three sons, and although of deli-
cate health, he mastered enough of bibli-
cal and talmudic scholarship to draw the
attention of men who valued nothing so
much as learning.
Were that all, Sabbatai would have ex-
cited little more interest than any other
talented boy of his time and place, and
one of the most comic -tragic chapters in
Jewish history might not have been writ-
ten. But in addition to his intellectual
qualities, he was of a highly emotional
temperament, a temperament which found
fulfilment in dreams and visions of per-
sonal supernatural power and grandeur.
To so sensitive and imaginative a youth,
the Kabbalah, with its messianic doc-
trine, in which the coming of the Messiah
is not only set down but the precise date
of his advent is fixed, came as a heaven-
sent gift.
•
It was a discovery for which he had
vaguely been longing. Soon books had
no knowledge and wisdom no instruction
but what was contained in the Zobar,
the Book of Illumination of the thirteenth
century, and the writings of Isaac Luria,
the German-Egyptian-Palestine anchorite
of the sixteenth century. Young though
he was, he spent his days in solitude and
his nights in study. He made himself a
recluse in a city that teemed with mer-
chants from all over Europe. Prayer,
fasting, and rigorous self -discipline were
the only "pleasures" he knew. Women
were powerless to disturb the loneliness
of his life — not even the Levantine
women with their burning eyes and sen-
suous figures. When his father pressed
him about marriage, he vowed that the
Torah would be his only bride. When
the pressure became so insistent that he
could no longer refill it, he created a
scandal in the city by marrying two
women, one after another, without ever
approaching them. Rumors of his sexual
impotency, and darker whisperings, were
spread about him, but they did nothing
to dampen the enthusiasm of the small
By JACOB S. MINKIN
band of followers who detected in him
signs of the Messiah.
With the deepening of the Exile, and
the ghastly Chielnicki massacre which
plunged almost all Jewry into suffering
worse than the Crusades and the Spanish
Inquisition, what the Jews cried out for —
what they were in desperate need of was a
visible Redeemer, now and without delay,
and not the impersonal Messiah of the
philosophers whose influence, to use Mar-
tin Buber's words, is "poured out over
the ages." In their melancholy and de-
spair, in the tortured souls of the surviv-
ing victims a fresh hope grew. Scholars
searched their books and mystics ex-
plored the Kabbalah for the faintest al-
lusion to the Redeemer. And what they
found provided their expectations with a
momentary thrill of reality. They dis-
covered that the year of their ordeal —
1648 — was to be simultaneously the time
of their redemption — indeed, that the
very name of their tormentor was but an
abbreviation of bcblc mashaib yabo Volant,
"The labor pains which will usher in the
coming of the Messiah." Indeed, it was
the mystic certainty of his coming, the
promise that could not fail, which em-
boldened Sabbatai Zevi to make his sen-
sational pronouncement in the little syna-
gogue of his native town.
And when the appointed time had
passed and the footprints of the Son of
David failed to make themselves visible,
the Jews prayed and fasted and explored
their holy books further. To their deep
chagrin they discovered that they had
made a slight mistake in their calcula-
tions, that the measure of their suffering
was not yet full; they would have to wait
still another eighteen years for their re-
demption, until the year sixteen hundred
and sixty-six.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
6
It was a fateful year for both Jews
and Christians alike. For in the middle
of the seventeenth century messianic
dreams and hallucinations flamed up
fiercely in almost all the countries of
Europe. Christendom was in ferment;
dramatic events were predicted; super-
natural happenings such as the world had
not witnessed were in the offing; the so-
called apocalyptic date was set for the
year 1666. In Switzerland, France, Hol-
land, and Puritan England prophets had
arisen who proclaimed the Millenium
which would restore the Jews to their
nationhood in the Holy Land. Perhaps
never in history was such concern taken
in the Jews and their problem by the
nations of the world as in those strange
and hectic times. Even so astute a states-
man as Oliver Cromwell was prevailed
upon to readmit the Jews to his shores,
feeling certain that, on their way to the
Holy Land, their stay in England would
be of short duration. There was of course
a missionary twist in the sudden interest
in the Jews for, with the coming of
Christ the Messiah, it was hoped their
conversion would be accomplished. Had
the Jews possessed the political wisdom
and sagacity, they might have turned the
popular delusion to their advantage.
•
These things were rumored about in
Sabbatai Zevi's father's home, where
Jewish and Gentile merchants gathered
for news and gossip no less than for busi-
ness. What he heard made a powerful,
if not bewildering, impression on the
young scholar's mind already dizzied by
his kabbalistic speculations. From all he
knew and heard, the times were ripe for
the coming of the Messiah. His appear-
ance was on the lips of men of diverse
tongues. Sabbatai was physically a sick
man, suffering from a malady that alter-
nated between fits of deepest depression
and exaggerated, almost insane, faith in
himself. It was in such mood that the
conviction of his messiahship had taken
of him. He had seen his people suffer,
pillaged and decimated, rebellion pierced
through his mind. What if he were him
self the Awaited One, appointed to save
and to succor? Had he not prayed,
fasted, and flagellated himself till the
blood spurted from his clean, young body?
Had he taken advantage of the oppor-
tunity and played the patriot, striking
out for his people's liberation, he might
have gained a following even among the
supine and complacent Jews of Smyrna,
but as King Messiah he was a complete
failure. He was not taken seriously; he
was even resented and regarded with sus-
picion. The older and more experienced
heads of the community remembered the
misfortune such self -deluded fanatics had
brought upon their people in the past.
Three years long they put up with his
extravagant claims and notions, and then
sensing the danger of his fantastic pre-
tensions, they made no secret of the fact
that it would be well for him to choose
some other place as the scene of his mes-
sianic operations.
His exile, and the cherem — religious
ban — which followed, provided Sabbatai
Zevi with the credentials Jewish tradition
offers as the lot of the Suffering Messiah.
His itinerary led him through many
towns and provinces, where his reception
varied. In Salonica, a wealthy and cul-
ylDDISH, according to recent statis-
tics, is the language of two-thirds of
the Jewish people the world over. Before
the last World War, 9 out of 17 million
Jews, particularly those in Europe, used
no other language but Yiddish. Yiddish
possesses a large literature, and folklore,
and a lively daily and periodic press. It
is the Yiddish language that most easily
links the Jews of different countries.
Sholom Aleichem once said: Yiddish
is the best and finest language in the
world because — everybody understands it.
How old is Yiddish? It originated
about 1000 A.D. It is then almost a
thousand years old, the same age as most
European languages.
Yiddish originated in the Rhine basin
of Germany when the Jewish settlers,
who had spoken Romance (old French),
adopted the German language of that
period.
From the 13th century on, the Yid-
dish-speaking Jew came to Poland, Lithu-
ania, Ukraine, etc., and, in the course of
time, Eastern Europe became the center
of Yiddish.
In the 18th century Yiddish was the
tural community, he fared no better than
in his own native town. The only re-
sponse he received to a sumptuous ban-
quet and an improvised marriage cere-
mony with the Torah as his mystical bride
was an amused shrug of the shoulders
and an order to leave the city on the
morrow. Luck favored him in Constan-
tinople, the Ottoman capital, with its
bizarre and passionate oriental Jews, like
himself crying out for the Messiah, and
who produced parchments announcing
his coming. While he was cold-should-
ered by the rabbis who, indeed, bade him
leave the city in short order, he was ac-
costed by one, Abraham Yarchini, a seedy
but talented scholar and an expert in
copying and forging old documents.
With many salaams, he presented the
would-be Messiah with a parchment
which he pretended to have discovered
in a cave, and which, he alleged, bore
unmistaken testimony to Sabbatai Zevi's
messiahship. Sabbatai read the document
language of practically all the Jews of
Europe.
During the 19th century Yiddish has
become a crystallized language and devel-
oped literature thriving on its wholesome
and nourishing resources and creativeness.
Within a short time, it became powerful
enough to sink roots, in the form of
translation, into the literary fields of most
of the European languages. Simultane-
ously, the Yiddish literature was enriched
also by borrowing from classic and pop-
ular writers.
A good many of our Yiddish poets and
writers have been translated into the
modern languages the world over. And
their Yiddish artistic creations have been
towered over others written by authors
of the highest rank. Sholem Asch, I. I.
Singer, Z. Shneur, are only a few exam-
ples. Yehoash, the great poet, was privi-
leged to be the chosen one to translate
our Bible — all of the 24 books from cover
to cover and thus standardize the Yiddish
language. There is no literature, that has
not the translation of the Bible among
its valuable treasures.
THE GROWTH OF YIDDISH
By DR. ABRAHAM ASEN
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
7
avidly. They beheld each other in mute
but eloquent silence, each knowing what
was in the other's heart.
•
Sabbatai Zevi was now a "certified"
Messiah, but still no nearer the goal than
when he first set out from his father's
house. He had roamed over the world,
visited many places, met many people, and
distributed gifts and alms with a lavish
hand. He was tall and handsome, with
a black beard and benign countenance,
every inch a King Messiah. But a King
Messiah without friends, without a fol-
lowing, without an Elijah to trumpet his
coming, without even a home where to
lay his head. But Sabbatai Zevi was not
dismayed: he was astute, ingenious, and
resourceful . He had been banished from
many places, but the Holy Land would
welcome him, for Jerusalem, is the birth-
right of the Son of David. It is from
there that the message of the risen Mes-
siah must come.
In Cairo, on his way to Palestine, Sab-
batai Zevi accepted the hospitality of
Raphael Joseph Chelibi, one of the most
unusual Jews of his generation, a man
who combined great piety with great
wealth, an exalted official position with
extreme modesty, oriental splendor with
deep concern for the poor. He was
Master of the Mint, a position equal to
that of the Secretary of the Treasury.
But when not in the royal entourage, he
lived the life of an ascetic, fasting, doing
pennance for his sins, and wearing a
rough hair shirt underneath his splendid
court attire. A mystic who followed
dutifully every prescription of the Lurian
Kabbalah, he found in Sabbatai Zevi a
kindred spirit, and when he was permit-
ted a glance of Yachini's parchment, he
treated the would-be Messiah with the
deepest veneration. Two years Sabbatai
spent at his Egyptian patron's home
amidst truly messianic splendor. But the
crucial year 1666, with the eyes of all the
world upon it, was drawing nigh and the
Messiah had not yet revealed himself. He
therefore left hastily for Palestine, hoping
that something would happen to realize
his ambition.
And, indeed, something did happen,
something bizarre and unexpected, be-
yond Sabbatai's wildest imagining. For
in Gaza he met the man — Nathan Benja-
min Levi, who subsequently became
world-famous as Nathan Ghazati, who
acted as both his John the Baptist and
Paul, and who very nearly succeeded in
capturing all Jewry for the new mes-
sianic creed. The meeting of these two
men was of momentous consequences —
one of those historic encounters which
blaze new trails and create new move-
ments.
•
Sabbatai Zevi and Nathan Ghazati
found in each other both kindred and
contrasting spirits. They were allied in
their vanity and ambition, in their emo-
tions and attitudes, in their insane lust
for power and in the mystic faith in
themselves. But they also differed physi-
cally, mentally, in their spiritual powers
and intellectual capacities. Sabbatai
TWICE TOLD TALES
Dr. Emanuel Neumann tells this
story. A lawyer, astronomer and a
surgeon were discussing which occupation
is first mentioned in the Bible. The
astronomer said that the Bible speaks of
God having created the heavens and the
earth, so there must have been an astron-
omer there. The surgeon pointed to the
fact that the rib was removed from Adam
to create Eve, so there must have been a
surgeon. The lawyer, however, won the
argument when he said: "The Bible tells
us that first there was chaos, and who
could have created the chaos but some
lawyers?"
Disraeli was once asked what was the
difference between the word "calamity"
and the word "misfortune."
Replied he: "If Gladstone were to fall
in a river, that would be a misfortune,
but it would be a calamity if someone
were to fish him out."
Once Frederick the Second and Moses
Mendelsohn were guests at a great library
opening. At the end of the ceremonies,
a book was handed to the celebrities in
which they were to sign their names.
First, of course, the book was held out
to the monarch. Instead of signing his
own name, Frederick wrote "Mendelsohn,
the crazy man." Then Frederick turned
the book over to Mendelsohn and
chuckled. Mendelsohn quietly wrote:
"Frederick the Second." — By J. T. A.
Zevi was already forty years old, often
morose and taciturn and not infrequently
given to spells of despondency; the Gha-
zitc was half his age, a youth full of en-
ergy, dash, and almost unlimited driving
power. And, to complete the contrast,
while the "Messiah" presented himself
as saint and ascetic, a stranger to the
ways of the world, and with little organ-
izing ability, the Ghazite was tense and
dynamic who startled all the world with
his messianic agitation. Left to himself,
Sabbatai Zevi would have remained one
of the anonymous self -deluded fanatics;
in the hands of Nathan, he became a
conspicuous world figure whose dominion
extended far and wide.
Events now moved rapidly. In the
four years they worked together, Nathan
accomplished more than what was
achieved by Sabbatai in the fifteen years
of his messiaship. Tireless and energetic,
and with full confidence in the authenti-
city of his superior's purpose, Nathan
took full charge of the campaign. He
was learned and eloquent, and wrote in a
fine, clear and precise style. He dis-
patched letters to Jerusalem and to almost
every segment of Jewry in the world, pav-
ing the way for Sabbatai as the "true Mes-
siah," the "Celestial Lion," the "Supreme
Excellency," the "King of Kings," who
was to gather dispersed Israel and "re-
deem our captivity." Sabbatai Zevi was
no longer an obscure figure; he became a
celebrity. In Palestine, and the farthest
reaches of Jewry, Nathan made Sabbatai's
name ring with the hosannas of an ac-
credited Messiah.
•
In the Holy City, Sabbatai behaved
with the modesty becoming the Servant
of the Lord. He kissed its sacred soil,
poured forth copious tears at the holy
places, made the streets of Jerusalem re-
sound deep in the night with holy and
profane hymns and songs to which he
gave mystical interpretations. What
convinced most of that impoverished and
sorely-stricken community of his divine
mission, was that he dealt out alms with
a lavish, royal hand. When the heartless
Turkish officials imposed upon the Jews
of Jerusalem a cruel tax which threatened
to squeeze out the last farthing from the
shabby beggars, he volunteered to per-
sonally appeal to the Saraph-Bashi of
Cairo, by which title Raphael Joseph
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
8
NEW BOOKS
Chelibi was known, for help and succor.
It was a journey which did more than
establish his reputation as a miracle-work-
ing Messiah, for at the palace of the Egyp-
tian Jewish patron-mystic an episode
took place which cast a halo of romance
about the brooding metaphysical head of
the messianic pretender.
Sabbatai Zevi had little taste for women
in the flesh. His first encounter with
them created a scandal which made gos-
sips doubt his manly potency. But a
woman now appeared from afar who
thrilled him mystically, spiritually and,
who, he determined, was the fit bride to
share his throne. Her name was Sarah,
and her story is as strange and exciting
as that of the man who later became her
Messiah husband. Miraculously escaping
the Chmielnicki butchery, she was
brought up in a Catholic convent in
Poland where she spent ten years feasting
her eyes on the images of saints and her
mind on stories of the crucified Messiah,
but inwardly she remained faithful to
Judaism and the memories of her child-
hood. At the first opportunity she
escaped her detested surroundings and
sought out a Jewish cemetery for her
refuge. When discovered, she was a dis-
turbingly beautiful maiden of sixteen,
luscious, ripe, and tempting, but as silent
as the grave concerning her past, answer-
ing every question with the statement
that she was the destined bride of the
Messiah. To escape complications with
the Catholic authorities, she was packed
off to Amsterdam, where she had a
brother. But she proved a burdensome
charge and, unprotected, she roamed
through the cities of Frankfort, Constan-
tinople and other places, sharing her
loveliness with many a man, but giving
herself in marriage to no one, always
meeting every proposal with, "I am the
appointed bride of the Messiah."
•
The news of the strange creature was
flashed to Sabbatai Zevi and he immedi-
ately sent for her. What had the Messiah
to do with women, he who had failed in
his duty as a husband to two wives? But
his curiosity was aroused by what was
prophetically revealed to her. Harlot or
virgin, what mattered it to the King
Messiah, who was above the law? When
pressed for an explanation, he could
always quote Hosea, whom God likewise
[Continued on page 39]
"The Book of Books, An Introduction,' 1 ''
by Solomon Goldman. Harper &
Bros.
THIS is the first volume of a monu-
* mental series dealing with the Jew's
greatest contribution to civilization — the
Bible. Dr. Solomon Goldman is emi-
nently fitted for this great task of giving
to the world a new appreciation and a
richer understanding of this greatest of
all books. He plans to give a new trans-
lation as well as a commentary on all
important passages and historical notes,
presenting the views of ancient and mod-
ern commentators.
In this introductory volume, the au-
thor, in his inimitable style, tells the story
of the Bible, how it has influenced man-
kind's thinking, and the message it still
holds for the world of today.
One of the most fascinating sections of
the volume is "Echoes and Allusions," in
which Dr. Goldman offers us a rich store-
house of quotations, culled from the writ-
ings of the world's greatest personalities,
dealing with every aspect of the Bible. In
this one book the reader will find 429
names of the world's most notable per-
sons, whose thoughts on this Book of
Books are here represented.
Dr. Goldman is known not only as a
great preacher and orator, but also as
a distinguished scholar who has already
enriched Jewish literature with a number
of valuable works. But this volume
represents his greatest contribution. This
reviewer hopes that every reader of these
lines will see to it that this important
work, the "Book of Books," will become
part of his home library. In it he will
find intellectual delight and spiritual joy.
It will instill within him a new sense of
dignity and self-respect. Above all he
will understand why his people deserved
the honored appellation — the People of
the Book.
"Essays in Jewish Biography " by Alex-
ander Marx. The Jewish Publication
Society of America.
Professor Alexander Marx — one of the
world's greatest Jewish scholars has, for
almost a half a century, been professor
Reviewed by
DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
of Jewish history at the Jewish Theo-
logical Seminary of America. He is the
veritable creator and guiding spirit of the
Seminary Library, now the greatest Jewish
library in the world. No one is better
fitted to give us a true evaluation of some
of the notable figures in Jewish literary
life than he.
Here we find fascinating studies of
Rab Saadya Gaon, who a thousand years
ago tried to harmonize faith and reason,
and to give us a synthesis of religion and
philosophy; of Rashi, whose commentaries
on the Bible and the Talmud are still the
most popular aids in Jewish studies; of
Maimonides, the greatest of all Jewish
philosophers. Here, too, the reader will
find interesting and appreciative studies
of the great scholars who created the
science of Jewish studies in modern times
— Moritz Steinschneider, David Hoffman,
Solomon Schechter, Israel Friedlander,
Meyer Sulzberger and others.
As one reads the story of the lives and
achievements of these men, one gets to
understand the richness of the creative
spirit of the Jew, and how the real heroes,
those who gave life to our people, were
the men of mind and spirit. Their works
nourished hearts and souls throughout all
the ages.
The reader of "Essays In Jewish Biogra-
phy," will learn much and find intellec-
tual delight in every one of its fascinating
chapters.
"Saayda Gaon — The Book of Beliefs and
Opinions," translated from the Arabic
and the Hebrew by Samuel Rosenblatt.
Yale University Press.
Our former fellow-Brooklynite, Mr.
Louis M. Rabinowitz, created a living
monument to his devotion to Jewish
scholarship by establishing at Yale Uni-
versity the "Judaica Research Founda-
tion" for the promotion of research "in
Hebrew lore and literature." That this
research will be on the highest scholarly
level is attested by the names of the men
[Continued on page 39]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
A Vivid and Authoritative History of the
Habimah By One of Its Founders
HOW ISRAEL'S NATIONAL
THEATRE STARTED
/// October the Habimah, which
played a successful engagement on
Broadway last season, will open in
Israel with a new play rehearsed while
the famous troupe was in the United
States. The following article, by one
of the founders of the Habimah, was
published in the Review a number
of years ago and is of especial interest
now that Israel has its truly national
theatre.
Beu-Ari is active in Neic York
both as a player and as a director of
the Dramatic Department of the
Neiv School for Social Research. He
is an unusually fine writer on the
theatre, and this article is now part
of one of his books.
THE years 1918-1920 in Moscow
were years of hunger, pogrom, revo-
lutions — and in a corner of this
stricken city, a group of youths from all
parts of Russia gathered to study theatre.
Everyone was in search of something —
something that would keep the human
being from spiritual decay. With energy
and love, we betook ourselves to our dif-
ficult task of developing a Hebrew
theatre, but we soon discovered that it
was next to impossible to work without
a leader. Upon the recommendation of
Stanislavsky, his pupil Vachtangov was
accepted as rcgisseur of Habimah, so that
our lot was completely cast into the hands
of this Armenian who was to become
world-famous for his revolutionary work
in the theatre.
At the time that Vachtangov came to
Habimah, he was a devoted disciple of
the Stanislavsky system. It was the sys-
tem of spiritualized experiences and one
hundred per cent realism. But he felt
that something was lacking, and it was
only natural that upon chance observance
of Meyerhold's experimental work in
Petrograd, he was impressed so deeply,
that it reacted upon his manner of acting
and directing. He formed a group, ex-
perimented, sought and created.
Vachtangov soon got to work on the
Dybbuk, and Habimah will never forget
those days and nights spent on rehearsing
this play. They were truly the pleasant-
est and most beautiful times of our lives.
Work would last for hours at a stretch
and final rehearsals extended to early
morning. Every rehearsal was a distinct
performance. Vachtangov never came to
the rehearsals with a definite plan, or with
a previously conceived opening and clos-
ing of acts. He groped about for new
ways, and these extemporaneous search-
ings were breath-taking and fraught with
the greatest suspense.
We had to rehearse the first act over
and over. Even when it seemed perfectly
complete and in the best of form, Vach-
tangov found fault with it. As was
usual, after the lowering of the curtain
we gathered around him and listened to
his criticism. He would not utter a word,
but order us to go on the stage and begin
to act again. Immediately the whole act
was radically changed. Scenes created
overnight were immediately displaced.
Some parts were eliminated, and new ones
were created. The whole act soon as-
sumed an entirely different color. His
imagination was so great, that he used
to play with the scenes. We were like
putty in his hands. After a night of
study and strained creation, when the rays
of dawn crept through the crevices of the
narrow windows, we gathered around
Vachtangov fatigued and hungry. He
then sang his favorite Armenian song, one
replete with sadness and subdued ecstasy.
He sat at the piano and we grouped
around him. Louder and louder grew the
sound of this lugubrious melody, stronger
and stronger became our echo in the va-
cant little theatre. When dawn finally
came we left, refreshed by this melody.
At night we gathered once more. There
was more grouping, more singing, and
again, creating. . . .
o
It was then that Vachtangov became
ill. He could not sleep, and he could not
eat. His only relief was in soda water.
As soon as he entered the theatre, he took
his customary seat, drank some soda, and
called out "begin." We were impatiently
awaiting the signal. We began with the
"batlan" scene. Vachtangov listened,
halted us, and commanded "once more!"
By R. BEN-ARI
The scene seemed to us to be perfect, and
we could not understand what was wrong.
Once more, we sang the "Mipnaimah"
and again the cry "once more!" This
was repeated several times. The rehear-
sal was stopped for a few moments and
Vachtangov pointed out that the first
batlan had omitted the sigh "Oi!" This
was nothing compared to the pyrotech-
nics that followed when an actor omitted
a word. Nevertheless, our rehearsals were
not mere exercises in diction or expres-
sion. It was a matter of finding a form
for the Dybbuk, and the batlanim had set
the tone for for the entire performance.
None of us will forget his wild outcry
of "Eureka" whenever he found the scene
he was looking for.
Vachtangov, in his work with Ha-
bimah, sought and created a new form
of the theatre. He arrived at a sort of
synthesis of Stanislavsky and Meyerhold.
It was because of this that the Dybbuk
reached the highest level of tragedy. He
brought a certain pathos to the Dybbuk
and defined every character so completely
that each ceased being a figure and be-
came a symbol.
•
The year in which we were to produce
the Dybbuk — 1922 — was laden with im-
poverishment and sorrow. Although there
was some relief in the political situation,
the hunger continued, and Vachtangov's
ailment increased. The subsidy which we
received from the government ceased, and
our existence became nothing short of a
miracle. To mitigate our distress, Ha-
bimah through some unknow n and magic
source, procured for its players barley
soup, which it distributed every night
during rehearsals. The soup usually con-
sisted of hot water and a grain of barley.
Vachtangov saw all this and decided to
arrange an evening so that the remaining
wealth of Moscow might contribute some-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
thing to the support of Habimah. Men
prominent in the community and well-
known artists were invited. The evening
arrived and everyone was well enter-
tained. Then came the moment for the
appeal. All were quiet, bored, seemingly
deaf. There was no response. It looked
as if the evening was a failure. Suddenly
Vachtangov and his friend, the great
writer Anton Tchechov, appeared dressed
in white aprons and carrying trays of
tea. Everybody was amazed to see them
serving tea to all the guests in the hall.
But they soon realized their purpose. As
they handed a glass of tea to the guests,
they removed their hats and asked a con-
tribution for the tea. And — miracle upon
miracle — the hat became filled with bills.
Everyone's mood changed. One wanted
to top the other in his contribution. The
honor of drinking tea served by Vach-
tangov and Tchechov was too tempting
for any man to resist. However, Vach-
tangov, with two hatfuls of money, was
not content. His imagination was aglow.
The whole idea became a bit of theatre.
He had to resort to every device to open
the pockets of those present. Soon came
a new scene. Vachtangov jumped on a
chair and auctioned off Tchechov. The
writer stood near the chair, his expres-
sion so sheepish that one had to laugh.
The people warmed up and began to bid.
Tchechov was sold for a goodly sum for
the benefit of Habimah.
•
The third act was finished. News-
papers were already carrying notices of
the Habimah's production of the Dybbuk
under Vachtangov 's direction. In our
hearts we were somewhat skeptical. We
all expected something to happen. The
costumes were new and rather unusual.
The scenery was unusual, too. The make-
up was such that was never seen in Mos-
cow. We anxiously pondered what re-
ception Moscow would give us.
Particularly were we interested in
the impression the play would make on
the "lions" of the theatre — Stanislav-
sky, Dantchenko, Katchaloff, Moskvin,
Tchechov, and other well known Mos-
covites.
At one of the last rehearsals, during
the scene of the chasidim, Vachtangov
showed once more what great intuition
he possessed. Discontinuing the rehearsal,
he shouted to us: "Arc these chasidim,
is it this what you call a cbasid?" He
then delivered a lecture on chasidim
worthy of a Schechter. He spoke so con-
vincingly that everybody had to believe
him. After the explanation, he walked
on the stage and showed us how to play
a cbasid. He acted tearfully and with
great exaltation. Then turning to us he
said: "That is the way to play a chasid"
That night the chasidim were acted right
and that saved the third act.
Two weeks after that came the pre-
miere. Vachtangov was pale and excited,
the actors nervous and high strung. We
were told that all the most prominent
people of the theatre were in the house.
Vachtangov was back-stage and had a
good word for all of us. One he cor-
rected, another he made up, on a third
he fitted a wig, and to everyone he smiled
benignly, like a mother ready to display
the beauty of her children. The gong
was finally sounded for the third time.
We were all gathered around Vachtangov
waiting for the final word. Sternly he
addressed us, "Did we realize what this
night meant to us? Did we know that
Stanislavsky and others were in the
theatre?"
The first act was over. The audience
responded coldly. The second act was
about to begin. Vachtangov came into
our dressing rooms and said good-
naturedly: "Children, here is where we
raise them out of their seats." The act
did take the audience by storm. We had
to stop after the dance, until the ap-
plause subsided. Vachtangov's genius
had conquered.
After the performance, we all sur-
rounded Vachtangov and sang his Ar-
menian song. We did not leave him until
late that night. He kissed us all good-bye
and wept. We wept with him. It looked
as if we were parting forever. Everyone
felt that if this mood weren't immediately
changed, we would all soon be on the
point of hysteria. Vachtangov went to
the center of the theatre, and smilingly
began to address us in Hebrew. He soon
passed over to one of the monologues in
the Dybbuk . . . changed his pose to that
of the messenger, then said: "And now,
let us sing our melody, my favorite
Armenian melody." We all began to
sing, then we danced.
•
Vachtangov was ill again. The good
news of the phenomenal success of the
Dybbuk was brought to him. Moscow
was all agog with this performance.
There was hardly a journal that did not
praise the New Vachtangov Style. Even
if just out of curiosity they went to see
the "New Theatre." However, Moscow
did not know that Vachtangov was plan-
ning a new surprise with "Princess
Turandot." He could not attend the
premiere of this famous production be-
cause he was not allowed to leave his
sick bed. Stanislavsky telephoned after
every act and told him how it went.
Israeli's Constitution
TJ-IE following three-point pledge is
contained in the preamble of a draft
of the Israeli Constitution, accepted by a
constitutional committee as a basis for
discussion: 1. To build our commonwealth
in accordance with the ideals of peace and
justice of the prophets of Israel. 2. To
open our land to every Jew who seeks
entry and to maintain the rights of the
strangers within our gates. 3. To pro-
mote the peace of the Holy Land and
the security and prosperity of all who
dwell therein.
The pledge will be carried out through
a sweeping program providing all Israeli
citizens with cradle-to-grave insurance,
"an equitable share" of the national in-
come and adequate education. Under the
provisions of the constitution "everyone
has the right to work" and the national
government must ensure a decent living
standard, regulate wages and hours, pro-
tect women and children and keep watch
over labor's right to organize and strike.
Vachtangov's condition became worse
from day to day.
On May 29, 1922, at one of the per-
formances of the Moscow Art Theatre,
the actors were interrupted, and Nemiro-
vitch Dantchenko came out and asked
the audience to rise. Word had just
come that Yevgeny Bagratianovitch
Vachtangov had died. There was a dead
silence in the theatre. Sighs and sobs
were heard. The next day, theatrical
Moscow mournfully followed the hearse
of this great teacher and creator. The
members of Habimah followed the
casket, sad, orphaned and bereft of its
great director and guide.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
II
NEWS
THE first meeting of the Jerusalem
members of the newly-elected World
Zionist Executive took place in Jeru-
salem. Bcrl Locker was elected chairman
of the executive and was put in charge
of public relations. Dr. Israel Goldstein,
of New York, was elected treasurer. He
will return to the United States but is
scheduled to assume his office in Jerusa-
lem within a month.
Another American elected to serve on
the Jerusalem executive is Haim Green-
berg, Laborite. He will be in charge of
the Education and Culture Department,
but is not expected to assume his duties
immediately. Other portfolios were di-
vided among the members of the Jeru-
salem executive as follows:
Rabbi Wolf Gold, Mizrachi, is in
charge of the Jerusalem developments de-
partment; Eliahu Dobkin, Laborite, will
head the organizational department; Itz-
hak Wcrfcl, Mizrachi, will be in charge
of the housing program for refugee im-
migrants; Jacob Zerubavel, United
Workers Party, will be responsible for the
department to care for Oriental Jews;
Moshe Kolodny, General Zionist, will con-
tinue to head the Youth Aliyah move-
ment, and Levi Shkolnik, Laborite, will
be responsible for colonization and agri-
culture. Eliezer Kaplan, Laborite, and
S. Z. Shmagai, Mizrachi, were given no
portfolio.
The economic department, under
Grossman, has been charged with four
functions. They are: mobilization of pri-
vate capital for investment in Israel;
supplying information abroad of the eco-
nomic development of Israel; foster an
Israeli export program and, build up a
tourist trade for Israel.
David Remez, Communications Min-
ister, and Aaron Zisling, Agriculture Min-
ister, both members of the special Cabi-
net committee on Jerusalem, attended
the meeting to participate in the discus-
sion on education. The problem is be-
coming acute because schools throughout
Jerusalem and Israel have now opened,
and the Agency has taken no action to
offer financial aid despite the fact that
the school system is in financial difficul-
ties.
At a press conference, Dr. Goldstein
said that he foresaw a budget of
$192,000,000 for the Jewish Agency this
year. Of this sum about $72,000,000
will be allocated for immigration and
$24,000,000 for colonization, he said,
adding that the rest would be divided
among the various other projects sup-
ported by the Agency, with special at-
tention being paid to the problem of
developing Jerusalem.
•
The immigration rate to Israel is ex-
pected to be about 10,000 per month, he
declared. The figure will vary accord-
ing to "the needs of the DP's" and the
ability of Israel to absorb them. "It is
up to the Jewish people to determine how
large the immigration program shall be,"
he stressed.
He estimated that this year, as in the
past, from 65 to 75 percent of the
Agency's receipts will come from Amer-
ican Jewry. The Agency will not con-
tribute to Israel's current needs, Dr.
Goldstein stressed.
LATE
AS the Review goes to press it was
reported that the Arabs were pre-
paring an offensive against Israel to pre-
cede the opening of the United Nations
General Assembly in Paris. The object
would be to seize Jerusalem.
In a dispatch from Paris to the N. Y.
Times, C. L. Sulzberger, its correspon-
dent, described an expected change of
Russian policy, favoring the Arabs. It
was rumored, wrote Mr. Sulzberger, that
"an arrangement was now under discus-
sion in the Kremlin whereby bases might
be granted to the Soviet Union in Syria
in exchange for tacit assistance against
the new State of Israel." The correspon-
dent adds that rumors of such a pact are
considered unlikely to be well founded,
but nevertheless they can act as a threat
The Zionist Actions Committee con-
cluded its session with the election of a
new World Zionist Executive from which
all members of the Israeli Cabinet were
eliminated except Eliezer Kaplan who was
given a seat without a portfolio.
Prior to the election of the new execu-
tive, it was officially announced to the
delegates that David Ben Gurion, Moshe
Shcrtok, Goldie Meirson, Dr. Itzhak Gru-
enbaum, Rabbi Judah L. Fischman and
Moshe Shapiro — all members of the Israeli
Cabinet — had given up their seats on the
executive. They have been replaced by
Dr. Israel Goldstein, General Zionist, Levi
Shkolnik, Laboritc; Baruch Zuckerman,
Laborite; Zcrubawel, United Workers
Party; Zvi Lurie, United Workers Party
and Itzhak Werfel, Mizrachi Labor.
Yehuda Gravinsky of the United Workers
Party and Dr. I. Schechtman of the Re-
visionists were elected deputy members.
Leon Gelman of the Mizrachi was chosen
as an advisor.
The new executive, which now in-
cludes representatives of the United
Workers Party and the Revisionists, will
be divided into three branches, The Amer-
ican branch will be composed of Dr. Abba
Hillel Silver, Dr. Emanuel Neumann, Dr.
Nahum Goldmann, Hayim Greenberg,
Zuckerman, Lurie, Mrs. Rose Halpern and
Eliahu Stone. Dr. Schechtman will act
as deputy member in the American branch
and Gelman will serve as advisor to it.
NEWS
to the United States, "forcing Washing-
ton to dilute its assistance to Israel."
Sulzberger also says that it is believed
that Communist agents are active in the
Arab countries taking advantage of the
local and international situations in the
interests of Russia.
THr: High Court of Israel, consisting of
a President and four judges, opened
officially in Israel. This is the first Jewish
high court in Eretz Israel since the de-
struction of the second temple, when the
Sanhcdrin, consisting of a chief justice
and 70 members, ceased to exist. The
five judges were sworn in by the Minister
of Justice, Felix Rosenblith. They are:
Dr. Moshe Smoika, Rabbi Simcha Assaf,
Yitzchak Olshan, Dr. Menachem Dun-
kelblum and Dr. Schneur Zalman Cheshin.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
The Jerusalem branch of the executive
will be composed of Dr. Goldstein, Berl
Locker, Kaplan, Shkolnik, Eliahu Dobkin,
Moshe Kolodny, Rabbi Wolf Gold,
Werfel, S. Z. Shragai and Zerubawel.
Gravinsky will be its deputy member.
Prof. Selig Brodetsky will constitute a
one-man London branch of the executive.
The American branch of the executive
will include the economic department,
which is charged with promoting trade
and investment for Israel. It will also
bear responsibility for public relations
among the Western Hemisphere countries.
It is also expected that Dr. Goldstein will
succeed Kaplan as treasurer of the World
Zionist Organization.
The Jewish Agency adopted a resolu-
tion declaring that it would no longer
contribute funds for security, military or
political purposes in Israel. The text of
the resolution reads in part:
"Whereas the state of Israel has been
proclaimed, and its Provisional Govern-
ment is now exercising all the functions
and prerogatives of government . . . the
Agency funds will continue to be em-
ployed solely for charitable purposes and
for no other use and purposes whatso-
ever."
A spokesman for the Export-Import
Bank announced that it could take no ac-
tion on Israel's formal request for a
$100,000,000 loan until conditions there
have "settled down." He added that the
Bank must have "reasonable assurances"
it will be repaid before it can be author-
ized.
An Israel mission spokesman said that
"we already offered every guarantee that
the loan will be repaid."
■6
The World Revisionist Court, which
hears appeals from decisions of the World
Revisionist Executive, has declared illegal
the Israeli Revisionist Executive which
was elected in Tel Aviv following a deci-
sion of the local Revisionist Party to
amalgamate with the Irgun-sponsored
Freedom Movement.
The world Revisionist body has ordered
a new election for members of the Israeli
party executive within three months.
Balloting will be restricted to registered
members of the Revisionist Party, thus
keeping the Irgunists from infiltrating the
elections.
The Revisionist Party of Israel split,
following adoption of a decision by a ma-
jority of the delegates to merge with the
Irgun Zvai Leumi, which will be active
in the forthcoming Israeli elections as
part of the Freedom Movement.
The resolution for the merger, adopted
by 63 against 32, reads: "The Revision-
ist Party of Israel decides to unite with
Irgun, but Revisionists will, nevertheless,
remain within the World Zionist Execu-
tive." After this resolution was adopted,
the opposing delegates, headed by Dr.
Arich Altman, head of the party, walked
out of the conference.
Dr. Altman and his followers claimed
that the convention of the Israeli Revi-
sionists was not authorized to decide on
a merger with the Irgun. This, they
argued, is a matter which must be de-
cided by the world convention of the
Revisionist Party. After the opposing
delegates left the hall, the conference
elected an executive of eight, all affiliated
with the Freedom Movement, and left
three seats vacant for the minority.
The second post-war national conven-
tion of the Brith Trumpeldor of America
adopted a resolution urging the world
Betar conference in Paris to sever all ties
with the Revisionist Party and to per-
suade Menachem Beigin, commander of
the Irgun Zvai Leumi, to assume leader-
ship of Betar, it was announced in New
York by the organization.
t:
The Foreign Ministers of Denmark,
Sweden and Norway have decided not
to recognize the state of Israel until
Count Folke Bernadotte, the United Na-
tions Mediator in Palestine, has com-
pleted peace negotiations between the
Jews and Arabs.
The Israeli question was among points
discussed by the Scandinavian ministers at
a meeting held in preparation for the
U.N. General Assembly sessions in Paris.
The British Foreign Office indicated
that the Government has no objection to
the establishment of an Israeli representa-
tion in London, notwithstanding the fact
that Israel is not recognized by Britain.
Emphasizing that the Government of
Israel "cannot of course have a minister
here," a Foreign Office spokesman added:
"But no one can stop them from putting
'State of Israel' over their door if they
want to."
The spokesman made his statement fol-
lowing a report that an official of the
Jewish Agency in London announced that
the state of Israel intends establishing
representation here. "It will be some
weeks yet before the representation is
established," the official said. "The build-
ing of the Jewish Agency may continue
to be used until new quarters are found,
but the Agency will continue to exist here
as a separate body."
ix
The Egyptian Government has now
formally charged three persons with the
15% British Tainted
With Anti-Semitism
Only 20 to 25 percent of the people
of Britain are free from some form
of anti-Semitism, delegates of the psycho-
logical section of the British Association
for the Advancement of Science were told
by Dr. H. J. Eysenck, noted British psy-
chologist.
Dr. Eysenck said that anti-Semitism
appears to be correlated to other social
attitudes, such as patriotism and religious
feelings. Anti-Semites generally believe
in the death penalty, flogging and that
war is inherent to human nature. He
said that he found conservatives more
anti-Semitic than liberals and liberals more
anti-Jewish than socialists. Asserting
that anti-Semitism shows a lack of emo-
tional maturity and stability, Dr. Eysenck
said that much must be done before
methods of combating anti-Semitism
are developed.
stoning to death of Stephan Haas, Phila-
delphia Jew killed in Cairo July 18, and
has pledged officially that they will receive
the punishment they merit, the State De-
partment announced in Washington.
The Department said, however, that it
definitely does not consider the incident
closed, and will watch the trial closely.
It was noted that the Egyptian message,
delivered August 22, was the first formal
reply received to official United States
protests on July 19 and 24.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
An appeal to the Nehru Government
to condemn the "mass massacre of the
Jews by Arab armies" in Palestine and
to recognize the state of Israel appeared
in the English-language newspaper Jw-
forma, published in Delhi.
The publication pointed out editorially
that "when the minority of India de-
manded the partition of India this was
backed almost by all the Arab countries."
Asserting that it "fails to understand"
the Arab opposition to the partition of
Palestine, Informa added that there is no
reason "why the Zionists should not be
allowed to form their own state."
ft
A striking change for the worse in the
Palestine military picture and in the pos-
sibility of continued peace took place with
the arrival of a large Iraqui force from
Mafrak, Transjordan. This brings the
strength of the Iraqui army to about
10,000 men — the largest Arab force in
Palestine. It is also equipped with mod-
ern American transport and new types of
fighter and bomber planes.
The cease-fire has little meaning in
Jerusalem where artillery and automatic
fire is heard almost every day and where
a recent large-scale duel between Arab
and Jewish mortars and cannon resulted
in a number of casualties. For the Jeru-
salem inhabitants the truce has been al-
most as costly in lives, dislocation of
everyday living and in economic losses as
a full-fledged war.
The editor and publisher of the Stern-
ist newspaper, Mivrak, were arrested for
censorship violations and later released in
$200 bail. The publication of the paper
has been suspended.
It was authoritatively learned that the
reason for the government's action was
a long-time contravention of the censor-
ship regulations by the staff. Mivrak vio-
lated the regulations both by not sub-
mitting material to the censor in advance
of publication and by printing material
forbidden by the censor.
Recently Mivrak carried a violent at-
tack against the United Nations truce
observation staff and against the British
in the matter of immigration restrictions.
The article threatened action against both
the U.N. staff and the British — it was
assumed that the "vengeance" would take
place outside Israel. Later the newspaper
carried photographs and descriptions of
a raid on a Sternist camp near here. The
articles were either run without permis-
sion or in defiance of the censor. The
government is known to consider them
as constituting "incitement to violence."
ft
Displaced Jews from Austria who will
embark at Italian ports for Israel will
pass through Italy in sealed trains accom-
panied by Italian police from the Austro-
Italian frontier to the harbor.
The announcement was made following
the arrival of the first group of several
hundred Jewish DP's from Austria at the
Italian port of Genoa, whence they will
sail on an Italian ship to the French port
of Marseille before heading for Israel.
Refugees in U. S. A. Can
Have Permanent Status
Immigrants who entered the U. S. on
a temporary basis or on transit visas
before April 1, 1948, may apply for a
change of status to permanent residents,
it was announced by the Attorney Gen-
eral's office.
Under rules approved by Attorney
General Tom Clark, persons who entered
this country as government officials, visi-
tors, transits, seamen, merchants or stu-
dents may become permanent residents if
their applications are approved following
hearings by the Immigration and Natural-
ization Service. Application forms will
be available on and after September 1 5 at
any office of the Immigration and Natu-
ralization Service, but will not be accepted
before October 1. Authorization for the
changes in status was provided under the
recently adopted DP law.
Jewish leaders in Rome reported that
since early last month the legal emi-
gration of displaced Jews from Italy to
Israel has been increasing at a terrific rate.
It is now expected that some 18,000 refu-
gees will have been cleared out of DP
camps, training centers and residences in
the major Italian cities within another
month, they said.
Before the mass migration to Israel be-
gan, there were an estimated 12,000 Jews
in DP camps, 8,000 in training centers
and 5,000 living in the cities. By the
end of September or the beginning of
October it is hoped to reduce that total
to 3,000 in the camps — all with destina-
tions other than Israel — 4,000 in the cities
and several hundred in the centers. At
present the training centers are being
used for transients only and are being
closed up one by one.
The atmosphere in the camps is one of
intense excitement. The immigrants have
prepared their few belongings weeks in
advance. They have purchased some
things which they believe they will need
in Israel and have sold bulky or unneces-
sary property which they have acquired
during their stay in Italy.
ft
A program of accelerated emigration
and intensified reconstruction activities
was recommended by Moses A. Leavitt,
executive vice-chairman of the Joint Dis-
tribution Committee, and Dr. Joseph J.
Schwartz, J.D.C. overseas director, as the
only means for economic and spiritual
rehabilitation of Europe's 1,400,000 suf-
fering Jews. They spoke at the third an-
nual meeting of the J.D.C.'s east central
region, held in Cincinnati, which was at-
tended by 300 delegates from six states.
Dr. Schwartz, who recently returned
to this country after having conferred
with Moshe Shertok, Israeli Foreign Min-
ister, and Eliezer Kaplan, Finance Min-
ister, on the new state's immigration
plans, asserted that "ten thousand Jews
a month can and must be absorbed into
Israel." Pointing out that the first groups
of DP's bearing Israeli visas have already
arrived in Haifa, the J.D.C. overseas di-
rector revealed that the agency's assist-
ance activities in this field were greatly
expanded recently. He announced that
J.D.C. provided rations and sent trained
nurses with each departing convoy.
J.D.C. announced that its September
budget amounts to $5,576,000. This
brings the total for the first nine months
of 1948 to nearly $54,000,000.
The largest single item for September
is $1,400,000 for emigration purposes,
Moses A. Leavitt, executive vice-chairman
of the J.D.C, reported. So far this year,
he said, more than 40,000 displaced Jews
from Europe and Shanghai have been
helped to reach new homes in Israel, U. S.,
Canada, Latin America and elsewhere,
ft
President Jose Figueres of Costa
Rica has assured a representative of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
SYRIAN GOVERNMENT PROTECTS
ITS JEWS
By HARRY J. SAMUELS
Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society that the
status of some 1 ,000 Jewish immigrants
who arrived in that country since the end
of the war in Europe will be legalized
soon.
tr
The Freeland League issued a statement
expressing regret over the fact that the
Government of Surinam has suspended
negotiations for the mass settlement of
Jewish refugees in Surinam "pending clar-
ification of the international situation."
The statement said that the League is still
in communication with the Surinam au-
thorities in an attempt to secure imple-
mentation of an agreement reached last
year under the terms of which 30,000
Jews were to be admitted into the colony
of Dutch Guiana.
"An agreement between the Freeland
League and the Government of Surinam
for the settlement of 30,000 Jews was
made and approved by the Legislative
Council of Surinam and the Netherlands
Government," the statement declared.
"This agreement was announced on No-
vember 27, 1947, by the Netherlands Del-
egation at the General Assembly of the
United Nations."
Large numbers of anti-Semitic circu-
lars were received recently from Pieter-
maritzburg, South Africa, which local
Jewish circles believe is becoming a new
center of world anti-Semitic propaganda.
The leaflets were mailed to English pro-
fessional and literary groups by "The
League for Fair Play and Decency."
Although the Rumanian Government
has ordered the nationalization of all
schools in the land, the ORT will be
permitted to continue to operate its
schools and training center independently,
George Stroe, head of the Rumanian ORT,
announced
The Rumanian Government gave the
ORT schools special status because the
Jews are in great need of vocational
training, Stroe said, adding that the gov-
ernment plans to issue a law giving the
ORT complete charge of all Jewish re-
training centers in the country.
■Cr
A permanent body representing Jewish
youth and young adult councils and other
Jewish youth groups throughout the
United States was created at the close of
the first National Jewish Youth Confer-
[Continued on page 38]
JEWISH residents of Lebanon and
Syria have literally gone "under-
ground," not to fight a war of sabo-
tage and attrition, but solely to keep out
of sight until Arab passions have cooled
or the issue of Palestine has been settled.
Contrary to expectations, there have
been few incidents and no massacres. The
Jews live quietly in their "ghettoes,"
which are misnamed, because the guards
there are to keep Arabs out rather than
imprison the Jews inside. Most of the
Jews have lost their jobs or abandoned
their trades; their stores have been boarded
up for the "duration," and they are gen-
erally living in increasing poverty. By
selling their remaining possessions, they
manage to secure enough money for food.
The Syrian Government, still smarting
under the French assertions of years ago
that they could never treat their minori-
ties fairly, has gone out of its way to
ensure that the Jews are not molested.
There is a saying in Syria that "when
the government means business, it sends
gendarmes to the scene of trouble; when
the government is not serious, it sends
police." Last December, when Syrian
crowds, angered by the U. N. partition
of Palestine, stormed the American Lega-
tion and tore down the flag, the govern-
ment sent police to control the rioters.
But when mobs periodically form to burn
the Jewish quarter near the "Street Called
Straight," of Biblical fame, gendarmes are
invariably rushed to the scene. It has
become a matter of pride to the Syrian
Government to protect its Jewish minor-
ity.
The only serious rioting occurred at
Aleppo, where rabble-rousers incited a
mob to burn Jewish homes and commer-
cial houses. But the gendarmes quickly
restored order and no Jews were harmed.
The Jews are living a quiet, self-
integrated life. They rarely leave their
homes except to visit a near neighbor.
Schools and small synagogues are still
open. Syrian shopkeepers has asked the
Jewish artisans to continue producing
copper and bronze ware but the shortage
of these in Damascus indicate that the
Jews are not inclined to do so.
The Lebanese Government has in-
terned about 30 "dangerous" Jews sus-
pected of espionage. They are held in a
former French barracks at Baalbek,
where the quarters, although cramped, are
clean. Their rations are short but rela-
tives are permitted to visit the internees
and bring them extra food.
The Syrians originally interned 200
suspects, but have now released all but
approximately 50. Occosionally they
pick up an odd "spy," such as the 12-
year-old bootblack who was arrested two
weeks ago outside the Orient-Palace
Hotel, where he was accused of listening
to conversations.
An additional 70-odd prisoners of war,
captured when the Syrians took Mishmar
Hayarden, are held in Damascus. This
correspondent visited the camp, and al-
though food was scanty, the prisoners
seemed to receive fair treatment.
The Syrians have not molested any
Jewish property in Damascus except to
seize all radios. Anti-aircraft machine-
guns, however, were placed on the roofs
of six Jewish homes.
The Jewish population is truly a "float-
ing" one. Figures are difficult to obtain.
The government listed 29,000 Jews liv-
ing in Syria in 1944, and officials say that
about half of these emigrated to Palestine.
But the usual figure given for Jews in
Syria now is about 10,000, of which ap-
proximately 4,000 are in Damascus.
A large number of Jews, especially the
more prosperous ones living in Aleppo,
fled to Lebanon. The Syrian press com-
plained that 3,000 had crossed the border
in this manner and urged that the Leba-
nese force them to return. The Leba-
nese, however, deny that any such num-
ber ever came into their country, and
estimate that the Jewish population of
Lebanon is 7,000. They admit, however,
that these figures are purely guesses; there
are Jews hiding in the mountains, or liv-
ing with relatives in smaller cities.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
15
NEWS OF THE CENTER—
Greetinss to the Center Membership
THE approach of the Jewish New Year
affords us the opportunity to extend
to the members of the Institution and
to their families our best wishes for a
happy, healthy, and blessed year.
The officers gratefully acknowledge
the loyal cooperation they have received
from the membership of the Center and
are looking forward to their continued
support so that our institution may grow
from strength to strength. Leshono Tovo
Tikosevul
Emanuel Greenberg, President
Dr. Moses Spatt, 1st Vice-Pres.
Hyman Aaron, 2nd Vice-Pres.
Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
David Goodstein, Treasurer
From the Sisterhood
The officers and the Sisterhood extend
their New Year Greetings to all members
Schedule for High Holiday Services
We are anxious that our services shall
be decorous and inspiring. We therefore
ask the earnest cooperation of all who
will attend.
Services for Rosh Hashonah will be
held on Sunday and Monday evenings,
October 3rd and 4th at 5:30 o'clock, and
on Monday and Tuesday mornings, Oc-
tober 4th and 5th at 7 o'clock. The
Torah reading will commence at 9:15
a.m. The Shofar will be sounded at
10:15 a.m. All worshippers should be in
their seats before that hour. The sermon
on both days will be preached at about
10:40 a.m. The doors will be closed
while the sermon is delivered. The Musaf
services will begin at 11:10 o'clock, and
we would like the service to close at
1:15 o'clock.
Yom Kippur Services
The Kol Nidre services which usher
in the Fast of Yom Kippur will be held
on Tuesday evening, October 12th at
5:30 o'clock. Rabbi Levinthal will preach
immediately after the chanting of the
Kol Nidre service.
of the organization and their families.
Mrs. Morton Klinghoffer,
President
Mrs. Morris B. Levine,
Mrs. M. Robert Epstein,
Mrs. Joseph Levy, Jr.
Vice-Presidents
Mrs. Hyman Rachmil, Treasurer
Mrs. Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Mrs. Benj. H. Wisner,
Corr. Secretary
Mrs. Louis Zakhem,
Social Secretary
From the Center Staff
On behalf of the Center staff I extend
to all the officers, directors and members
of the Brooklyn Jewish Center and their
families cordial greetings and best wishes.
Joseph Goldberg,
Administrative Director.
Yom Kippur services will begin on
Wednesday morning, October 13 th at
7:00 a.m. The Yizkor service will be
held at 11:15 following which Rabbi
Levinthal will preach. Rev. Sauler, as-
sisted by the Center choir, under the
leadership of Mr. Julius Grossman, will
officiate.
Additional Yizkor Services
For the benefit of worshippers who
have not purchased seats for the High
Holy Days, the Center will conduct
special Yizkor services on Yom Kippur,
Wednesday morning, October 13 th in
the Dining Room of our building. There
will be three such services, at 10 o'clock,
10:30 and 11.
Slicoth Services
Slicoth services will be held in our
Main Synagogue this Saturday evening,
September 2 5 th promptly at 12:30
o'clock. The services will be conducted
by Cantor William Sauler, assisted by
the Center choir under the leadership of
Mr. Julius Grossman. All welcome.
Sermons for the New Year
The sermons will be preached on both
days of Rosh Hashonah at 10:40 o'clock.
The Shofar will be sounded at 10:15 and
members are urged to be in their seats
before that hour.
On Yom Kippur Eve, the sermon will
be preached immediately after the chant-
ing of Kol Nidre. On Yom Kippur
morning, the sermon will follow the
Memorial Services.
Rabbi Levinthal will preach on the
first day of Rosh Hashonah.
Rabbi Saltzman will preach the sermon
on the second day.
On Kol Nidre Eve, Rabbi Levinthal
will speak.
On Yom Kippur, Rabbi Levinthal will
preach.
Holy Day Sermons in the Auditorium
The sermons to be delivered by Rabbi
Levinthal and Rabbi Saltzman on both
days of Rosh Hashonah and Yom Kippur
will be amplified from the Synagogue to
the congregation worshipping in the Au-
ditorium.
Rabbi Saltzman will deliver the ser-
mon at the Kol Nidre services in the Au-
ditorium.
Taleisim for the Holidays
Members and worshippers are re-
quested to bring their own taleisim dur-
ing the High Holidays. Our uniform
Holiday prayer book will be supplied to
worshippers at the Main Synagogue ser-
vices.
Junior Congregation Services
The Rosh Hashonah services in the
Junior Congregation will be held on
Monday and Tuesday mornings, October
4 and 5th at 10:00 a.m.
The Kol Nidre services will be held
on Tuesday evening, October 12th, at
5:30 p.m.
The services on Yom Kippur will be-
gin Wednesday morning, October 13th
at 10:00 a.m.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
Junior Congregation Meets
Every Saturday
Junior Congregation services are held
every Saturday morning in the Beth
Hamedrash at 9:45 o'clock. All Center
children and children of our Hebrew and
Religious Schools as well as children from
our community are invited to attend these
delightful and inspirational services.
Bar Mitzvah
A hearty Mazel Tov is extended to Mr.
and Mrs. Manuel Gottdcnker of 1588
President Street on the Bar Mitzvah of
their son, Allan I., which will be cele-
brated at the Center this Sabbath morn-
ing, September 26th.
Candle Lighting During High Holidays
Candles will be lit on Sunday and
Monday evenings, October 3rd and 4th
(Rosh Hashonah) at 5:16 p.m.
On Yom Kippur, Tuesday evening, Oc-
tober 12th, candles will be lit at 5:01 p.m.
Sunday School Registration
Registration for Sunday School will
take place this Sunday morning, Septem-
ber 26th at 10 a.m. Old students are to
report to their old classrooms. All new
pupils will go to the Ladies' Social Room
on the second floor. Registration is taken
daily in the school office between 10:30
a.m. and 6:00 P.M.
Junior League News
The Junior League of the Center has
gotten off to an excellent start and the
coming season promises to be a most suc-
cessful one. The meeting scheduled for
Thursday evening, September 30th will
highlight Rabbi Manuel Saltzman as guest
speaker. He will speak on the topic,
"What Do the High Holidays Mean to
the Jew Today?" A discussion will fol-
low the address. Social dancing will fol-
low.
Center Junior Clubs to Open Season
Saturday, October 16th
All our Saturday night Junior Clubs
will have their opening meeting on Sat-
urday evening, October 16th. The fol-
lowing groups are scheduled to open for
the coming season:
Inta-League Boys — Boys in the jun-
ior and senior years of high school. Zion-
ist, athletic and social program.
Inta-League Girls — Girls in high
school. Zionist, cultural and social pro-
gram.
Shomrim — Boys in the first two years
of high school. Young Judean and ath-
letic activities.
Vi valets — Girls in the upper grades.
Young Judean and social program.
Tzofim and Maccabees — Boys in
elementary school. Young Judean and
athletic program.
Candle-Lites — Girls up to 11.
Games, Arts and Crafts.
These clubs are under the expert guid-
ance of efficient leaders. Members' chil-
dren and students from our Hebrew and
Sunday Schools, who are eligible, are cor-
dially invited to attend.
Acknowledgment of Gifts
We acknowledge with thanks receipt
of donations for the purchase of Prayer
Books and Taleisim from the following:
Mr. and Mrs. William Brody in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their
son, James S.
Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Mitnick in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their
son, James.
Mr. and Mrs. Abraham Rothkopf in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their
son, Arthur.
Mr. Edward Leopold in memory of
his brother, Arnold Leopold.
Mr. and Mrs. Charles Saner in honor
of the marriage of their son, Eu-
gene.
Dr. and Mrs. Martin Friedrich in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their
son, Gerald.
Dr. and Mrs. Joseph P. Kasnetz in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their
son, Herbert.
Holiday Gym Schedule
The Gymnasium and Baths will be
closed on Monday and Tuesday, October
4th and 5th (Rosh Hashonah) and will
reopen on Wednesday morning, October
6th for women at 10:00 a.m.
The department will be open for men
on Tuesday, October 12th from 1-4 p.m.
and will be closed on Wednesday, Octo-
ber 13th (Yom Kippur); it will reopen
on Thursday, October 14th for women
at 10 a.m.
Young Folks League
The next regular meeting of the
Young Folks League scheduled for Tues-
day evening, September 28th will include
a program in keeping with the Rosh
Hashonah holiday. A social hour and
dancing will follow. All members of the
League are cordially invited to attend.
Limited to Center members only upon
presentation of their membership cards.
There will be no meetings on Tuesday
evenings, October 5 th and 12th, due to
the intervening holidays.
Yom Kippur Night Dance Opens
Young Folks League Fall Season
The Young Folks League of the Center
is opening their fall season with a dance
to be held in the Dining Room of our
building on Wednesday night, October
13th (Yom Kippur Night), at 9 o'clock.
Members are cordially invited to attend
the League's first affair of the season. Ad-
mission is $1.5 0.
Rabbi Samuel M. Cohen Memorial
Essay Contest Sponsored by Y. P. L.
The Young People's League of the
United Synagogue of America announces
the inauguration of the "Rabbi Samuel
M. Cohen Memorial Essay Contest," as a
tribute to the memory of its beloved
Executive for twenty-seven years, Rabbi
Samuel M. Cohen. All rules and infor-
mation regarding the contest are listed
below:
Topic: "How Can Conservative Jewish
Youth Best Serve Judaism and
Themselves?"
Length: The essay is to be no less than
1200 words, and no more than
2500 words.
Deadline: All essays should be received
at Y. P. L. office, 3080 Broadway,
New York City, postmarked no
later than midnight, January 1,
1949.
Prizes: 1st prize — $75 U. S. Savings Bond.
2nd prize — $2 5 U. S. Savings Bond.
Additional prizes for the runners-up
will soon be announced. Type your man-
uscripts, if possible.
All members of the Young Folks
League and the Junior League of the
Center are eligible to enter this contest
and are urged to participate.
Sabbath Services
Kindling of candles at 6:32 p.m.
Friday evening services at 6:00 P.M.
Sabbath services, Parsha "Ki Tabo"
Deut. 26.1-29.8. Prophets— Isaiah 60.1-
22.
Rabbi Saltzman will preach on the
weekly portion of the Torah.
Mincha services at 6:00 P.M.
Daily Services
Morning services at 8:00 o'clock.
Mincha services at 7:00 P.M.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Abramson, Edward
Res. 590 Parkside Avenue
Bus. Cleaners, 265 Brooklyn Ave.
Married
Proposed by Joseph Goldstein
Alterman, Morty
Res. 789 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Lawyer
Married
Proposed by Frank Schaeffer,
Joseph Richman
Altneu, Herbert N.
Res. 1437 Carroll Street
Bus. Engineering, 150 Broadway
Single
Proposed by Morris Swerlin,
Martin Bruckner
Bady, Louis
Res. 461 Crown Street
Bus. Metal Stampings, 250 Moore St.
Married
Proposed by M. Robert Epstein
Barnett, Benjamin
Res. 984 East 95 th Street
Bus. C P. A., 984 East 95th St.
Married
Proposed by Dr. I. E. Shack,
Joseph P. Kasnetz
Belferder, Ben
Res. 485 Schenectady Avenue
Bus. 1326 Fulton Street
Married
Proposed by Dr. Philip Zwerdling
Berkowitz, Dr. Milo M.
Res. 1051 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Dentist, 1632 President St.
Single
Proposed by Lillian Schlussel
Boloker, Charles
Res. 903 New York Avenue
Bus. C. P. A., 1440 Broadway
Single
Proposed by Malcolm Zeger
Brecker, Miss Lottie
Res. 1229 East 23rd St.
Proposed by Ben R. Berke, Hy Rosen
Brown, Sidney H.
Res. 191 Sullivan Place
Bus. C. P. A., 122 East 42nd St.
Married
Proposed by Dr. Maurycy Silber
Coburn, David
Res. 100 Woodruff Avenue
Bus. Restaurant, 64 W. 36th St.
Married
Cohen, Miss Jeanette
Res. 1720 Sterling Place
Cohen, Morris
Res. 1059 Union Street
Bus. Fruit, 1267 43rd St.
Married
Proposed by A. Jolcy, A. H. Zirn
Diamond, Albert
Res. 747 Miller Avenue
Bus. Acct., 220 Broadway
Married
Eisenberg, Charles
141 East 19th Street
Teacher, Midwood High School
Married
Proposed by Center Academy
Epstein, Bernard R.
Res. 1504 Carroll Street
Bus. Chemical, 548 Mescrol e St.
Married
Proposed by Edward Fuchs,
David Hirsch
Epstein, Meyer
Res. 161 East 93 rd Street
Bus. Optometrist, 161 East 93rd St.
Single
Proposed by Sam Horowitz,
B. Fields
Fane, Arthur
Res. 5702 — 14th Avenue
Bus. Teacher, P. S. 197
Married
Proposed by Center Academy
Fauer, Stanley
Res. 1187 East 10th Street
Bus. Truck Renting, 501— 10th Ave.
Single
Proposed by Philip Shorin
Feldman, Abraham
Res. 22 Bartlett Street
Bus. Dresses, 64 Manhattan Ave.
Married
Proposed by Albert Eller,
Hyman Rosen
Fox, Mrs. Joy
Res. 413 Miller Avenue
Widow.
Friedman, Nathaniel
Res. 503 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Dresses, 463 — 7th Ave.
Single
Proposed by Dr. Isadore IT. Sackadorf
Fuchs, Harry
Res. 827 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Factors, 1412 Broadway
Single
Proposed by Saul Zolot,
Moses E. Fuchs
Gerofsky, Joseph
Res. 379 Crown Street
Single
Proposed by Joseph Heimowitz,
Herman Gerofsky
Goldberg, Maurice
Res. 645 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Insurance, 38 Park Row
Single
Proposed by Leo Kaufman
Gorman, Miss Evelyn
Res. 270 Rochester Avenue
Greenberg, Miss Emily
Res. 334 Eastern Parkway
Greenberg, Miss Lillian
Res. 334 Eastern Parkway
Greenberg, Murry H.
Res. 2264 East 29th St.
Bus. Insurance, 23 Flatbush Ave.
Married
Proposed by Leonard Greenberg,
Edward Edelman
Gross, David
Res. 1060 Union Street
Bus. Retail Ready to Wear,
280 Jackson Ave., J. C, N. J.
Married
Proposed by Leo Kaufman, Abe Mann
Handelsman, Louis
Res. 4276 Bedford Avenue
Bus. Acct's., 1 West 34th St.
Married
Proposed by Dr. Charles Windwer,
Harry Katz
Heller, Herbert
Res. 983 Dumont Avenue
Bus. Luncheonette, 71-24 Main St.,
Flushing
Single
Proposed by Lillian Schlussel
Hi rzfeld, Stanley W.
Res. 13 5 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Lawyer, Newark, N. J.
Single
Proposed by Max Herzfeld
Jaffe, Miss Harriet
Res. 12 5 Lenox Road
Proposed by Rose Snofsky,
David Rosenberg
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
Karlin, Martin
Res. 541 Montgomery Street
Bus. Student, Brooklyn College
Single
Proposal by Abraham Karlin
Karten, Ben
Res. 1191 Carroll Street
Bus. Gov't., 90 Church St.
Married
Proposed by Moe Levy,
Morris D. \\"ender
Kasenetz, William
Res. 115 Lincoln Road
Bus. Real Estate, 80 LefTerts Ave.
Married
Katz, Sidney M.
Res. 22 5 Park Place
Bus. Mfg., 512 Seventh Avenue
Married
Proposed by Irving Rosenfeld
Kessler, Adolph
Res. 894 Park Place
Married
Proposed by Benjamin LefT,
Dr. Alexander LefT
Kirchman, Milton F.
Res. 233a Brooklyn Avenue
Bus. Architect, 230 W. 13th St.
Married
Proposed by Dr. Louis Blumenfeld,
Emanuel Schlosberg
Levy, Dr. Jacob H.
Res. 571 Lincoln Place
Bus. Dentist
Married
Proposed by Abe Mann
Lobsenz, Benjamin
Res. 467 Brooklyn Avenue
Bus. Aniline Dyes, 5 0 White St.
Married
Proposed by Maurice Rubin
LUXENBERG, LEON
Res. 1710 Avenue H
Bus. Acct. 154 Nassau St.
Married
Mattes, Littman
Res. 1004 Montgomery Street
Bus. C. P. A., 401 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Simon Abraham
Morris, Miss Helen R.
Res. 28 Christopher Avenue
Proposed by Hy Rosen, Sol Rosen
Polishuk, Paul
Res. 158 N. Elliot Walk
Bus. Laundry, 404 E. 64th St.
Married
Proposed by Center Academy
Rankin, Simond
Res. 25 5 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Mirrors, 119 West 23 rd St.
Married
Proposed by Albert Witty
Rosenthal, Imre J.
Res. 158 Jaffrey Street
Bus. Factors, 145 0 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Mrs. Margaret Levy,
Mrs. Isador Lowenfeld
Rosenthal, Murray
Res. 497 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Salesman, 2 5 Columbia Hghts.
Single
Proposed by Dr. Isadore H. Sackadorf
Rosner, Chaim
Res. 468 Crown Street
Single
Proposed by Judah L. Falik
Rosner, Joseph S.
Res. 468 Crown Street
Single
Proposed by Judah L. Falik
Rossler, Herman
Res. 175 Rochester Avenue
Bus. Trimmings, 242 West 36th St.
Single
Rossow, Philip
Res. 1427 East 7th Street
Bus. Textiles, 51 Madison Ave.
Single
Proposed by Abraham Shorim
Scharf, Miss Florence
Res. 432 Stone Avenue
Bus. Mfg., 395— 4th Ave.
Single
Proposed by
Schenker, Abraham
Res. 221 Linden Blvd.
Bus. Fund-raising, 45 E. 17th St.
Married
Schindler, Miss Marilyn
Res. 8 86 Nostrand Avenue
Proposed by Dr. Melvin C. Goldberg
Schwager, Miss Jean
Res. 1184 President Street
Proposed by Mrs. Hyman Rachmil
Sells, William S.
Res. 1014 Avenue K
Bus. Hats, 687 Broadway
Single
Proposed by Philip Shorin
Seril, Abraham
Res. 1045 St. Johns Place
Bus. 3 1 Bond St.
Married
Proposed by Louis Rivkin,
Morris D. Wendcr
Shour, Benjamin
Res. 440 Lenox Road
Bus. Income Tax, 90 Church St.
Married
Proposed by Oscar S. Kurshan,
A. H. Zirn
Silberman, Harry
Res. 1254 Lincoln Place
Bus. Interstate Traffic, 111 — 8th Ave.
Single
Proposed by David Rosenberg
Slater, Miss Mary
Res. 419 Amboy St.
Snyder, Jacob
Res. 65 5 Linden Blvd.
Bus. Steel, 110 Green St.
Married
Stein, Bernard G.
Res. 622 Empire Blvd.
Bus. Building
Single
Proposed by Morris Hecht
Strom, Donald
Res. 28 5 Albany Avenue
Bus. Furniture Salesman, 45 E. Bway.
Married
Proposed by Mrs. E. Pressner
Sussman, Stanley R.
Res. 704 Lefferts Avenue
Bus. Liquor, 57 Liberty Ave.
Married
Proposed by Hyman Gold
Taft, Max
Res. 699 Montgomery Street
Bus. Liquor, 179 Bedford Ave.
Married
Proposed by M. Robert Epstein
Samuel H. Goldberg,
Chairman, Membership Committee.
The following have applied for re-
instatement:
Dembicer, Sam
Res. 410 New York Avenue
Bus. Real Estate, 410 New York Ave.
Married
Proposed by Louis Glaubman,
Lou Jacobson
Nelson, Benjamin
Res. 5 65 Montgomery Street
Bus. Engineering, 25 0 Hudson St.
Married
Proposed by Abraham Karlin
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
ROSH HASHONAH GREETINGS
Mr* and Mrs. Moses Ginsberg
AND FAMILY
extend their best wishes for a Happy New Year
to all the Officers, Trustees, Directors and
members of the Center, as well as to
their friends and relatives
Mr* and Mrs. Morris Rubin
AND FAMILY
1577 Carroll Street
extend greetings for a Happy and Healthy New Year
to all their relatives and friends
MR. and MRS. PHILLIP BRENNER
AND THE ORGANIZATION OF
Original BRENNER BROS.
Wish their friends and patrons
the best of everything for the New Year
60 DIVISION STREET, N. Y. OUR ONLY STORE
•
Mr. and Mrs.
HAROLD CANTOR
226 New York Avenue
extend New Year Greetings to all their friends and relatives
•
Mr. and Mrs.
LOUIS GREENFIELD
616 Empire Boulevard
extend their New Year Greetings and best wishes to
all for everlasting Peace, Happiness and Contentment
•
Mr. and Mrs.
ISAAC SCHRIER
AND FAMILY
101 Lincoln Road
wish all their relatives and friends a Happy New Year
Mr. and Mrs.
HYMAN AARON
Children and Grandchildren
Mr. and Mrs.
JOSEPH I. AARON
MAY THE NEW YEAR BRING PEACE TO ISRAEL AND ALL ITS
NEIGHBORS, AND BESTOW HAPPINESS AND GOOD HEALTH
ON ALL OUR RELATIVES AND FRIENDS.
Mr. and Mrs.
JULIUS LEVENSON
225 Eastern Parkway
Dr. and Mrs.
MAX DANNENBERG
1464 Eastern Parkway
MR. CHARLES BLACHER
AND FAMILY
20 Plaza Street
MR. and MRS.
IRVING BALMUTH
AND FAMILY
769 St. Marks Avenue
MR. and MRS.
LOUIS BRENNER
AND FAMILY
Harriman, New York
THE SEASON'S GREETINGS TO ALL OUR RELATIVES AND FRIENDS.
MAY THE NEW YEAR BEGIN AN ERA OF BROTHERHOOD AND
PROSPERITY FOR THE WORLD.
MR. and MRS.
MORRIS BRUKENFELD
1276 President Street
MR. and MRS.
ABE FELDMAN
919 Park Place
MR. and MRS.
ISIDOR FINE
AND FAMILY
MR. and MRS.
PHILIP FLEISHER
1 160 Lincoln Place
MR. and MRS.
JACOB A. FORTUNOFF
AND CHILDREN
GERSEY STATIONS, INC.
MR. and MRS.
EDWARD SCHAEFFER
259 Empire Blvd.
MAY THE SOUND OF THE SHOFAR USHER IN THE BLESSED DAYS
OF UNIVERSAL PEACE, TOLERANCE AND WELL-BEING.
MR. and MRS.
JOSEPH GLAUBMAN
919 Park Place
ATTORNEY GENERAL and MRS.
NATHANIEL L. GOLDSTEIN
AND FAMILY
MR. and MRS.
DAVID GOODSTEIN
1 338 Carroll Street
MR. AND MRS,
SAUL GRAFF
AND FAMILY
486 Brooklyn Ave.
MR. and MRS.
HENRY H. GROSS
751 St. Marks Avenue
DR. and MRS.
WILLIAM H. HYDE
857 Eastern Parkway
MAY THE NEW YEAR BRING PEACE TO ISRAEL AND ALL ITS
NEIGHBORS, AND BESTOW HAPPINESS AND GOOD HEALTH
ON ALL OUR RELATIVES AND FRIENDS.
DR. and MRS.
DAVID KERSHNER
95 Eastern Parkway
KOTIMSKY & TUCHMAN
CATERERS OF DISTINCTION
MR. and MRS.
MAURICE KOZINN and SONS
HAROLD and PAUL
615 Empire Boulevard
THE LESSERS
of Lesser Lodge
White Sulphur Springs
New York
MR. and MRS.
JOSEPH LAZAROWITZ
388 Crown Street
MRS. LIEB LURIE
AND FAMILY
1451 Union Street
WE EXTEND OUR NEW YEAR'S GREETING TO ALL RELATIVES AND
FRIENDS, AND WISH THAT THE COMING YEAR WILL BRING THEM
GOOD HEALTH AND PROSPERITY.
DR. and MRS.
SAMUEL T. MARKOFF
AND MYRNA
1481 President Street
MISIKOFF BROS.
1406 Pitkin Avenue
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL L. POMERANTZ
AND FAMILY
1304 President Street
MR. and MRS.
NATHAN SALWEN
135 Eastern Parkway
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL WEISS
AND FAMILY
603 Empire Boulevard
MR. and MRS.
JULIUS KUSHNER & SONS
798 Montgomery Street
THE SEASON'S GREETINGS TO ALL OUR RELATIVES AND FRIENDS.
MAY THE NEW YEAR BEGIN AN ERA OF BROTHERHOOD AND
PROSPERITY FOR THE WORLD.
THE EDITORIAL BOARD
OF
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH
CENTER REVIEW
Louis J. Gribetz, Chairman
Joseph Goldberg Joseph Kaye
Israel H. Levmthal Manuel Saltzman
Mordecai H. Leivittes William I. Siegel
THE
YOUNG FOLKS LEAGUE
of the
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
RABBI and MRS.
ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
RABBI and MRS.
MORDECAI LEWITTES
AND DAUGHTER
RABBI and MRS.
MANUEL SALTZMAN
AND DAUGHTER
ROSH HASHONAH GREETINGS
FROM THE YESHIVA TALMUD
TORAH OF CROWN HEIGHTS
THE Board of Trustees of the Yeshiva Talmud
Torah of Crown Heights, 310 Crown Street, its
members and its faculty, extend their best wishes
for a Happy New Year to the Rabbi, the directors
and trustees and the members of the Brooklyn Jewish
Center.
The Yeshiva of Crown Heights is highly appre-
ciative of the cooperative attitude of its neighboring
institution and is thankful for the valuable support
which many of its members extend so liberally.
May the Lord bless them and grant them, as well
as all the members of our suffering people, a year of
true happiness. May this year see the triumph of the
cause of justice and righteousness.
HERBERT TENZER, President
Z. BRANDES, Exec. Director
JOSEPH M. BAUMOL, Rabbi
THE SEASON'S GREETINGS TO ALL OUR RELATIVES AND FRIENDS.
MAY THE NEW YEAR BEGIN AN ERA OF BROTHERHOOD AND
PROSPERITY FOR THE WORLD.
A Happy Neiv Year
— from —
RATNER'S
RESTAURANT
138 DELANCEY STREET
NEW YORK CITY
MRS
HYMAN ABRAMS
MR. and MRS.
404 Crown Street
RUBIN BELFER
MR. and MRS.
426 Eastern Parkway
HERMAN ATLAS
and family
DR. and MRS.
311 Albany Avenue
HARRY BERMAN
MRS. SAMUEL BARNETT
1408 President Street
MR. and MRS.
HERBERT BARNETT
MR.
AND DAUGHTER
LOUIS BLANKSTEIN
AND FAMILY
MR. and MRS.
SOLOMON LEVINSON
762 St. Marks Avenue
AND CHILDREN
MAY THE SOUND OF THE SHOFAR USHER IN THE BLESSED DAYS
OF UNIVERSAL PEACE, TOLERANCE AND WELL-BEING.
MR. and MRS.
MR. and MRS.
HENRY BREIER
LOUIS DAUM
75 5 Ocean Avenue
748 St. Marks Avenue
MR. and MRS.
FRANK BRODIE
MR. and MRS.
295 Montgomery Street
CHARLES DILBERT
MR.
MR. and MRS.
ELIAS BURROS
JACOB S. DONER
98 5 Park Place
AND FAMILY
MR. and MRS.
BENJAMIN DUBROW
and family
706 Eastern Parkway
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL EDELHEIT
MR. MAX FABRICANT
441 West End Avenue
DR. and MRS.
DAVID FARBER
865 Eastern Parkway
MR. and MRS.
JOSEPH FELDT
AND FAMILY
85 5 Ocean Avenue
DR. and MRS.
REUBEN FINKELSTEIN
576 Eastern Parkway
WE EXTEND OUR NEW YEAR'S GREETING TO ALL RELATIVES AND
FRIENDS, AND WISH THAT THE COMING YEAR WILL BRING THEM
GOOD HEALTH AND PROSPERITY.
MR. and MRS.
HARRY A. FREEDMAN
AND THEIR CHILDREN
Dr. and Mrs.
GERALD BRANOWER
and Son
13 5 Eastern Parkway
MR. and MRS.
A. FRUCHTHANDLER
364 Crown Street
MR. and MRS.
PINCUS GLICKMAN
AND FAMILY
MR. and MRS.
J. JOSHUA GOLDBERG
and children
MR. and MRS.
JOSEPH GOLDBERG
and their children
EPHRAIM, NATALIE, HOLLIS and ALVIN
MR. and MRS.
MAX GOLDBERG
410 Eastern Parkway
MR. and AIRS.
HARRY GOLDEN
and children
MR. and MRS. JEROME DIAMOND
1524 President Street
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL GOLDEN
599 Montgomery Street
DR. and MRS.
PAUL E. GOLDSCHLAG
AND FAMILY
960 Sterling Place
MR. and MRS.
EDWARD GOLDSMITH
AND FAMILY
780 Montgomery Street
MR. and MRS.
HERMAN GOLDSMITH
595' Lefferts Avenue
DR. MAX GOLDSTEIN
334 New York Avenue
MAY THE NEW YEAR BRING PEACE TO ISRAEL AND ALL ITS
NEIGHBORS, AND BESTOW HAPPINESS AND GOOD HEALTH
ON ALL OUR RELATIVES AND FRIENDS.
MR. and MRS.
JACK J. GOLDSTONE
314 Kingston Avenue
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL GREENBLATT
MR. and MRS.
ISRAEL HALPERIN
225 Eastern Parkway
DR. and MRS.
JACOB HALPERIN
BELLE HARBOR, L. I.
MR. and MRS.
LOUIS HALPERIN
MR. and MRS.
NATHAN HALPERIN
AND FAMILY
910 Park Place
MR. and MRS.
DAVID HALPERN
AND FAMILY
MR. and MRS.
HARRY HOROWITZ
125 Hawthorne Street
789 St. Marks Avenue
MR. and MRS.
JOSEPH HEIMOWITZ
410 Crown Street
MR. and MRS.
JACOB L. HOLTZMANN
The family of the late
LOUIS N. JAFFE
HANNAH O. JAFFE
HAROLD and PATRICIA JAFFE
and DAUGHTER
ALBERT JAFFE
MRS.
ARTHUR JOSEPH
AND FAMILY
210 West 101st Street
WE EXTEND OUR NEW YEAR'S GREETING TO ALL RELATIVES AND
FRIENDS, AND WISH THAT THE COMING YEAR WILL BRING THEM
GOOD HEALTH AND PROSPERITY.
MR. S. KAMENETZKY
42 Hampton Place
MR. and MRS.
BENJAMIN J. KLINE
MR. and MRS.
BENJAMIN KATZ
MATTHEW and MORDECAI
1399 Carroll Street
MR. and MRS.
MORTON KLINGHOFFER
RUTH, DANIEL and BERYL
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL KATZ
959 Park Place
MR. and MRS.
FRED KRONISH
HERBERT, SYLVIA and KAREN
KRONISH
MR. and MRS.
MORRIS B. LEVINE
687 Montgomery Street
MR. and MRS.
ISADOR LOWENFELD
AND FAMILY
28 5 Sullivan Place
MR. and MRS.
M. LEVRANT
MR. and MRS.
AND DAUGHTER
MANES MALZ
1717 Avenue N
576 Eastern Parkway
MR. and MRS.
PHILIP L. LIPSHUTZ
IRA, BARBARA, RAYMOND
NANCY HARRIET and HENRY EDWARD
MR. and MRS.
BENJAMIN MARTZ
ALVIN and CAROL ANN
MAY THE SOUND OF THE SHOFAR USHER IN THE BLESSED DAYS
OF UNIVERSAL PEACE, TOLERANCE AND WELL-BEING.
MRS.
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL MOSKOWITZ
and Sons
BENJAMIN PERLMAN
AND FAMILY
925 Prospect Place
MR. and MRS.
KALMAN I. OSTOW
CHILDREN and GRANDCHILDREN
MR. and MRS.
HERMAN PLAFKER
285 Albany Avenue
LOUIS PARNES FAMILY
498 — 7th Avenue
MR. ISIDOR POLIVNICK
New York City
250 Crown Street
MR. and MRS.
ARCHIE POLSKY
DR. and MRS.
HARRIS M. RABINOwITZ
13 5 Eastern Parkway
770 St. Marks Avenue
MRS.
LOUIS POSNER
DR. ARTHUR RAEDER
AND FAMILY
615 Eastern Parkway
20 Plaza Street
MR. and MRS.
DR mrl MRS
ELIAS N. RABINOWITZ
FRANK RAUCH
and son
736 Eastern Parkway
DANIEL J. ROBINS
MAY THE NEW YEAR BRING PEACE TO ISRAEL AND ALL ITS
NEIGHBORS, AND BESTOW HAPPINESS AND GOOD HEALTH
ON ALL OUR RELATIVES AND FRIENDS.
MR. and MRS.
DR. and MRS.
MAURICE M. REISS
MORRIS ROOD
1650 President Street
1336 President Street
MR. and MRS.
MR. and MRS.
ISIDORE H. REITER
MEYER A. ROSEN
990 President Street
480 Eastern Parkway
MR. and MRS.
MR. and MRS.
LOUIS RIVKIN
ADOLPH M. ROSENHEIM
1025 St. Johns Place
1478 President Street
ROTHMAN'S INN
MRS.
28 5 Kingston Avenue
JACOB RUTSTEIN
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL ROTTENBERG
MR. and MRS.
T T T / T) \ f A A T OAT y""VTk * y^VTV T
HERMAN SALOMON
13 5 Eastern Parkway
374 Eastern Parkway
THE HOUSE OF ROUS
CANTOR and MRS.
25 rarade rlace
WTT TTAM <s A T TT FR
and DAUGHTER
THE SEASON'S GREETINGS TO ALL OUR RELATIVES AND FRIENDS.
MAY THE NEW YEAR BEGIN AN ERA OF BROTHERHOOD AND
PROSPERITY FOR THE WORLD.
MR. and MRS.
MR. and MRS.
FRANK SCHAEFFER
NATHAN T. SCHWARTZ
789 St. Marks Avenue
AND FAMILY
MR. and MRS.
MR. HEYMAN SCHRIER
75 Central Park West
SIGMUND SCHWARTZ
AND FAMILY
615 Empire Boulevard
DR. and MRS.
JACOB SCHWARTZ
MR. and MRS.
919 Park Place
NATHAN D. SHAPIRO
MR. and MRS.
JACK SILVERMAN
THE HYMAN SPITZ FAMILY
13 5 Eastern Parkway
MR. and MRS.
SAMUEL STARK
MR. and MRS.
MORTY SILVERSTEIN
122-20 Ocean Promenade
Rockaway Park, L. I.
MR. and MRS.
SIMON SPIEGEL
MR. and MRS.
A. J. STELZER
AND FAMILY
901 Washington Avenue
730 Empire Boulevard
MAY THE SOUND OF THE SHOFAR USHER IN THE BLESSED DAYS
OF UNIVERSAL PEACE, TOLERANCE AND WELL-BEING.
MR. and MRS.
MR. and MRS.
SOL SUSSMAN
AND FAMILY
NATHAN WEISS
AND FAMILY
399 Ocean Parkway
MR. and MRS.
HENRY TELLER
1516 President Street
MR. and MRS.
ALBERT WITTY
AND FAMILY
41 Dunne Place
Lynbrook, L. I.
MR. and MRS.
LOUIS WEINSTOCK
13 5 Eastern Parkway
Extend their New Year Greetings
to all members of the Center
MR. and MRS.
CHARLES WUNDERLICH
715 St. Marks Avenue
[These Greetings continued on page 38]
Mr. and Mrs. SIMON ABRAHAM
Mr. and Mrs. M. J. DANCIGER
AND FAMILY
and daughter
Mr. and Mrs. ABRAHAM GINSBURG
1626 Carroll Street
621 Crown Street
576 Eastern Parkway
Mr. MORRIS BERGMANN
763 Eastern Parkway
Mr. and Mrs. NATHAN DVORKIN
AND IAMILY
MR. CHARLES GOELL
Mr. and Mrs. ALEX BERNSTEIN
and family
1503 President Street
Mr. and Mrs. CHARLES FINE
919 Park Place
Mr. and Mrs. MARK J. GOELL
AND SONS
Dr. and Mrs. LOUIS BLUMENFELD
221 Brooklyn Avenue
Mr. and Mrs. MAX FORTUNOFF
561 Livonia Avenue
Mrs. JACOB GOELL
Mr. DAVID M. GOLD
Mr. and Mrs. HENRY BREIER
Mr. and Mrs. HENRY FROELICH
AND FAMILY
75 5 Ocean Avenue
751 St. Marks Avenue
165 East 19th Street
WE EXTEND OUR NEW YEAR'S GREETING TO ALL RELATIVES AND
FRIENDS, AND WISH THAT THE COMING YEAR WILL BRING THEM
GOOD HEALTH AND PROSPERITY.
Mr. and Mrs. ABE G. GOLDBERG
AND DAUGHTERS
201 Eastern Parkway
Mr. and Mrs. JACOB S. GREENSPAN
692 Eastern Parkway
Dr. and Mrs. BENJAMIN KOVEN
Mr. and Mrs. MARTIN M. GOLDMAN
763 Eastern Parkway
Mr. and Mrs. JOSEPH HOROWITZ
2 5 Eastern Parkway
Dr. and Mrs. DAVID KUPERSTEIN
920 Montgomery Street
Mr. and Mrs. SIMON GOLDSTEIN
and family
2 88 Crown Street
MR. HARRY JACKSON
2969 Perry Avenue
Bronx, N. Y.
Mrs. AARON LEWIS
1482 Carroll Street
Mr. and Mrs. AARON GOTTLIEB
Mr. and Mrs. LEON JAFFE
Mr. and Mrs. LEO KAUFMANN
AND IAMILY
1601 Carroll Street
22 5 Eastern Parkway
639 Eastern Parkway
Mr. and Mrs. ISIDOR GRAY
AND FAMILY
Mr. BENJAMIN KAPLAN
KLEBANOW AUTO EQUIPMENT
1459 President Street
1632 Carroll Street
1402 Bedford Avenue
Mr. and Mrs. OSCAR KURSHAN
Mr. and Mrs. AKIBA MARGOLIN
Mr. and Mrs. PHILIP PALEVSKY
AND FAMILY
AND FAMILY
1166 Eastern Parkway
C Q ^ (~"t, /-»wm Itbvpt
1254 Union Street
MRS. FRANCES PRINCE
Mr. and Mrs. ALEX. LEFKOwITZ
Mr. and Mrs. BENJAMIN MARKOWE
and sons
515 Crown Street
AND daughters
284 Eastern Parkway
510 Lenox Road
Mrs. MARGARET LEVY
Mr. and Mrs. HYMAN RACHMIL
and Sheldon
Mr. and Mrs. MORRIS NEINKEN
1056 President Street
1 1 Ludlam Place
543 Crown Street
Mr. and Mrs. JACOB LIPPMAN
Mr. and Mrs. STEPHEN REY
Dr. and Mrs. LOUIS S. NELSON
AND family
1136 Sterling Place
AND FAMILY
3 52 Crown Street
1315 President Street
Mr. and Mrs. SIDNEY J. LIPSON
Mr. and Mrs. I. JEROME RIKER
BARBARA and BARRY
320 East 72nd Street
Mr. and Mrs. LOUIS J. ORLOFF
615 Montgomery Street
New York City-
WE EXTEND OUR NEW YEAR'S GREETING TO ALL RELATIVES AND
FRIENDS, AND WISH THAT THE COMING YEAR WILL BRING THEM
GOOD HEALTH AND PROSPERITY.
Mr. and Mrs. MURRAY ROSEN
Mr. and Mrs. ISIDOR STARK
Mr. and Mrs. MORRIS 1). WENDER
486 Brooklyn Avenue
37 Amherst Street
JERRY, ARTHUR, TOPPY
Mr. and Mrs. MORRIS ROTHKOPF
Mr. and Mrs. I. WIENER
Mr. and Mrs. JOSEPH STARK
AND family
AND IAMILY
Hotel Granada
68 Stfrling Street
Mrs. HARRIS SAL1T
Mr. and Mrs. HARRY ZIRINSKY
1344 Carroll Street
Mr. and Mrs. MORRIS STIFTEL
5 50 Crown Street
480 Montgomery Street
Mr. and Mrs. ISIDOR SHIMANSKY
Judge and Mrs. NATHAN SWEEDLER
ALPERT PRESS
328 Albany Avenue
Printers of the
194 Cro>* n Street
"REVIEW"
138 LIVINGSTON STREET
Mr. and Mrs. LOUIS SIMON
Mr. and Mrs. BARNETT TANENBAUM
Brooklyn 2, N. Y.
1373 Carroll Street
38
GREETINGS
[Continued from page 35]
Mr. and Mrs.
SAMUEL A. SEEGER
and FAMILY
57 Garden Drive
Lynbrook, L. I.
MR. and MRS.
BENJAMIN H. WISNER
760 Montgomery Street
MR. and MRS.
NATHAN ZUCKER
129 East 38th Street
•
Mr. and Mrs. BENJAMIN Z. LEVITT
and family
30 Ocean Parkway
NEWS OF THE MONTH
[Continued from page 14}
cnce at Narrowsburg, N. Y. The parley
was held under the auspices of the Jewish
Welfare Board's National Jewish Youth
Planning Commission.
The Czechoslovak Government has
sent an answer to a U. S. note regarding
American pilots flying planes from Czech-
oslovakia to Israel. "The reply must have
dispersed all fears of the U. S. Govern-
ment," the Foreign Ministry statement
said.
The statement denied that the Ameri-
can note charged Czechoslovakia with
exporting arms to Israel. It emphasized
that the note dealt only "with the ac-
tivity of planes of American origin and
American citizens."
it
The latest financial report of the
Czechoslovakian Economic Ministry re-
vealed that 170,500,000 crowns worth
of goods were exported to Palestine for
the month of July. This places Israel as
the sixth most important customer for
Czech goods.
It was reported that General David
Shaltiel, Inspector General of the Army
of Israel, arrived here for a brief visit.
He was, until recently, the commander
of the Israel Sixth Brigade and had di-
rected all military operations in the Jeru-
salem area. Ruben Burstin, political sec-
retary of the Histadruth, has also arrived
in Prague. As the first official delegate
of the Histdruth, he will hold important
talks with the leaders of the Czechoslo-
vakian trade union movement.
Anti-Semitism is at "a high pitch" in
Germany and there is no hope for any
possible adjustment of displaced Jews
there, it was reported at the conference
of representatives of the American Jewish
Committee in Europe. Prof. Herman
Gray and Zachariah Shuster, who returned
from Gremany, warned the conference
that increased vigilance by Jewish organ-
izations in order to lessen anti-Semitic
tension during the next few years is neces-
sary.
No outside relief assistance may be
needed by the Jews in Poland after 1949,
Prof. Joseph Sak, member of the Polish
National Council and vice-chairman of
the Jewish Central Committee, declared
at a press conference. He said that all
Zionist parties, except the Revisionists,
are permitted to function in Poland.
BOOKS THAT SHOULD BE
IN EVERY HOME
The Universal
Jewish Encyclopedia
Latest and most authoritative refer-
ence work on all Jewish subjects.
The Authorized Jewish Prayer
Book with Commentary and
Historical Notes by the Late
Chief Rabbi Joseph H. Hertz
•
The Model Jewish Home Library
•
For all books of Jewish interest,
call or write to:
RABBI LOUIS HAMMER
672 Eastern Parkway
Brooklyn, N. Y.
Strausberg Legacy
The Center acknowledges with thanks
receipt of a check in payment of the be-
quest left by the late Mr. Samuel Straus-
berg, a former member of our Governing
Board.
Congratulations
Heartiest congratulations and best
wishes are extended to the following:
Dr. Harry S. Kieval of 921 Washington
Avenue on his engagement to Miss Irma
Rubin.
Mr. and Mrs. Kalman I. Ostow of
523 Crown treet on the birth of a son,
Meir, to their children, Dr. and Mrs.
Mortimer Ostow on September 12th.
Mr. and Mrs. Louis Rosen of 792 Mont-
gomery Street on the birth of a son, Ar-
thur Rodney, to their children, Mr. and
Mrs. Ira Rosen of Dalton, Ga., on June
13 th.
Regular Gym Schedule Resumes
The following schedule will now pre-
vail in the Gym and Baths Department
and will be open as follows:
Monday
Men 3 p.m. to 10 p.m.
Women 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Boys 3 p.m. to 5 p.m.
Tuesday
Women 10 a.m to 10 p.m.
Girls 3 p.m. to 5 p.m.
Wednesday
Men 3 p.m. to 10 p.m.
Women 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Boys 3 p.m. to 5 p.m.
Thursday
Men 5 p.m. to 10 p.m.
Women 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Girls 3 p.m. to 5 p.m.
Friday
Men 1 p.m. to 4 p.m.
Boys 1 p.m. to 4 p.m.
Sunday and Legal Holidays
Men 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.
Boys 2 p.m. to 4 p.m.
To Members Planning Bar
Mitzvahs at the Center
Members who are planning Bar Mitz-
vahs in the near future are requested to
please reserve the date far in advance.
According to the rules of the Center,
the boy whose Bar Mitzvah is booked
first, receives the privilege of getting the
maftir. In the event that more than one
Bar Mitzvah is scheduled for the same
day, the other boys receive one of the
other aliyahs and can read a passage from
the Tor ah.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
39
THE AMAZING LIFI
[Continued
had commanded to take unto himself a
wife of harlotry. The nuptials were cele-
brated with the pomp and circumstance
befitting so high a wedlock. But it was
a cold and calculated marriage, without a
gesture of love or intimacy passing be-
tween them. Each one knew the part the
other was playing, and they kept the
secret to themselves. But, on the whole,
Sabbatai had the best of the bargain, for
hearts that remained adamant to his mes-
sianic pretension were easily won over by
Sarah's seductive charms. Thus it was
that for the first time in history Jews
were presented not only with a King
Messiah but also with a Messiah Queen to
share his throne.
Their entry into Jerusalem resembled a
triumphal procession. Great crowds
lined the streets, with women and chil-
dren pushing to touch and kiss the hem
of his robe. Sabbatai Zevi was no longer
merely a dispenser of royal alms who
poured out Chelibi's wealth with a muni-
ficent hand but a deliverer in their sorest
straits, indeed, a very Messiah. Nathan
Ghazati helped to spread the delusion. An
intensive campaign was set in motion.
All of Palestine was flooded with circu-
lars in which Sabbatai was referred to as
the King of Messiah, and not only Pales-
tine but such distant Jewish communities
as Constantinople, Salonica, Venice, Am-
sterdam, Hamburg, Frankfort, Paris, Lon-
don, and the thickly populated Jewish
centers in Poland. The news came to
them like a thunderbolt, but not with-
out a measure of profound satisfaction
and belief, for they remembered their
people's recent tragedy and the prophe-
cies of redemption.
•
But the far-sighted in Jerusalem had
their doubts, and they made no secret of
them. Indeed, they defied the popular
acclaim of Sabbatai Zevi and set in mo-
tion a counter-agitation against him.
With his accumulation of power, the
would-be Messiah became bold and care-
less. He attempted to dominate by
threats and violence; he distributed Cheli-
bi's largess with a discriminating hand,
favoring especially his friends and fol-
lowers; but what particularly aroused the
ire of the elders of the Holy City were
the liberties he took in matters of re-
OF SABBATAI ZEVI
om page 8]
ligion. The saint and mystic of Smyrna
was no longer the meek and humble Ser-
vant of the Lord he had appeared pre-
viously, a model of piety and impeccable
religious conduct. He became guilty of
such violations of the religious law as to
stamp him in the eyes of the pious as a
heretic. He failed to observe the pre-
scribed hours of prayer; he was careless in
the matter of the dietary laws; he tam-
pered with the traditional fast-days and
even dared to declare some of them no
longer binding.
It became evident to Sabbatai Zevi that
Jerusalem was not destined for the honor
of the messianic manifestation. He had
in mind a more dramatic setting for his
self-revealment. What greater satisfac-
tion could come to a man drunk with
vanity and ambition to make the very
city that disowned and banished him the
scene of his glory? There may have
been some practical reasons for his de-
cision to make Smyrna the center of his
future messianic activities. As a result
of a war between Turkey and Venice,
Smyrna, formerly an isolated and gloomy
town, became the hub of the Levant
trade. His own family had become en-
riched by the change. Merchants, and
especially Jewish tradespeople, gathered
there from almost all parts of Europe.
What better tribune to trumpet the mes-
NEW
[Continued
who make up the board of Editors, Pro-
fessors Julian Oberman, of Yale, Louis
Ginzburg, of the Jewish Theological Sem-
inary of America, and Harry Austryn
Wolfson, of Harvard.
This volume by Saadya Gaon is the first
of the series of translations of ancient and
medieval Jewish classics which will appear
under the auspices of the Foundation. It
is a work which has had a tremendous in-
fluence on Jewish philosophic thought. It
was written by Saadya Gaon almost a
thousand years ago, when Arabic philoso-
phy had attracted the intellectuals of that
age, and when the cultured Jew found
himself in need of a philosophic rationale
for his religious beliefs.
Dr. Samuel Rosenblatt, well known
Rabbi, and member of the faculty of
sage of the risen Messiah than the city
from which the news would be carried to
all the Diaspora?
The high-geared publicity machine of
Nathan the Ghazite, with his scores of
secretaries and copyists, was again set
hard to work. The impending event was
addressed to all the Jewries of the world
in the vivid, imaginative oriental style,
exhorting the people to give Sabbatai Zevi
the honors due the Messiah and prepare
for their imminent return to the Holy
Land. "Remember that the hour is at
hand" was the refrain of every letter and
circular. The agitation had its effect.
The highly-publicized Messiah met with
almost divine honors wherever he chose
to put in an appearance. In Aleppo and
Constantinople, and all through all his
journey, he was greeted with the roar of
thousands of voices. Men deemed them-
selves blessed if he as much as bestowed
a glance upon them, and communities
vied with each other for the privilege of
having him stay with them overnight.
Intoxicated with faith and expectation,
and seeing their bitter galut at an end,
young and old and in town after town
overwhelmed him with an enthusiasm
that sprang from their despairing yet
trusting hearts.
Part Two of Rabbi MinkJu's dra-
matic narrative will be published
next month.
BOOKS
from page 8]
Johns Hopkins University, has rendered a
careful and beautiful English translation
of the complete text of this classic work.
His reputation as scholar in Arabic lan-
guage and literature is well established,
and this work gives further evidence of
his painstaking devotion to the highest
ideals of scholarly research. Despite the
fact that this book appeared originally
almost a thousand years ago, it still offers
much to those who are interested in a
philosophic approach to the teachings of
our religion.
A good way to interest your
friends in the Center is
through the "Revieic." Pass
it on to them. Or get another
copy from the Center office.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
ABBOT-FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES— SERVICE
507 Flatbush Avenue
JESSE J. FINE Brooklyn, New York
JACK ABBOT Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
FLOWERS • WEDDING DECORATIONS
HYMAN SPITZ, Inc.
1685 Pitkin Avenue, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Dickens 2-4000 OUR ONLY STORE
FRUIT BASKETS
= — RIVERSIDE- —
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2 - 6600
Far Rockaway, L. I. Miami -Beach, Florida
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE 1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
FAr Rockaway 7-7100 Miami 5-7777
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle, we have arranged to
serve your Community. We have at our disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed
Sec. 562, P. L. & R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
Jewish, CknteJv
OKexrLejUL)
i
W
Qotolt&i, 1948
ONLY TEN YEARS AGO -a reminder
OF BLACK THURSDAY
By ALFRED WERNER
THE AMAZING SABBATAI ZEVI
-VJ'
m
By JACOB S. MINKIN
WHAT I SAW IN THE D. P. CAMPS
By MAX HERZFELD
THE LANGUAGE OF STATEHOOD
By DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
• CENTER BULLETIN BOARD •
JpQRUM JjECTURES
and DISCUSSIONS
at the Brooklyn Jewish Center
667 Eastern Parkway, on 2nd and
4th Monday evenings at 8:H.
FIRST LECTURE — NOVEMBER 8
DR. STEPHEN S. WISE
Veteran Jewish Leader and Orator
Subject
"THE STATE OF ISRAEL AND
THE NEW JEWISH WORLD"
SECOND LECTURE — NOVEMBER 22
WILLIAM L SHIRER
Fatuous Correspondent, Radio Commentator, Author of
"Berlin Diary and other noted works.
Subject
'A LAST EYEWITNESS REPORT
FROM GERMANY"
Admission: For Dr. Wise's lecture, free to members, 40^ (including tax),
to non-members. For Shirer's lecture, members 40^, non-members, 60^
(including tax).
JOIN
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
CONGREGATIONAL
SINGING GROUP
AND
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
CHORAL GROUP
under the leadership of
Sholom Secunda
Members of the Center and their
friends who wish to join one or
both of these groups are asked to
please leave their names at the in-
formation desk.
•
The first organization meeting of
the Choral Group will be held on
Tuesday, November 9th at 8 P.M.
MANY RARE BOOKS
As well as popular and ref-
erence works are in
The Library of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center
Available to the Center membership
and public for loan and reference.
Open Monday through Thursday,
3:00 to 9:00 P.M.
Sunday, 10:00 A.M. to 3:00 P.M.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Vol. XXX
OCTOBER, 1948 — TISHRI 5709
No. 7
THE MYTH OF DIVIDED ALLEGIANCE
LIKE the unlamcnted Bourbons, the
Jewish anti-Zionists forget noth-
ing old and learn nothing new.
Now that the State of Israel is a de facto
reality, soon to be a de jure sovereignty,
immune to the futile efforts of the anti-
Zionists to prevent the creation of the
State, they are turning their energies to-
ward the aim of minimizing support for
Israel. Perhaps, their hope is, that which
they could not stifle at birth they may
yet cripple in its growth.
For a half-century the program of
American Zionism was propaganda and
education for the creation of the Jewish
State. Consistently, bitterly, artfully,
but eventually hopelessly, the antis have
fought on every front to hamper and
hinder. Like the cuckoo, the only bird
that fouls its own nest, they have be-
smirched their birthright and denied
their history. The present design is the
same, only the materials are to be colored
differently in order to paint a new picture.
American Jewry still has a large part
to play in the upbuilding of Israel. The
State is rich in potentialities, but poor in
present realization of its resources. There-
fore, in the years of growth and develop-
ment which will come, American Jews
must assist with money, commercial
knowledge and scientific technique. The
Israelis are strong in spirit and invincible
in courage, as the record of their victories
has proven. Nevertheless, they are still
beleaguered on all sides by enemies. There-
fore, American Jews must, as long as the
necessity exists, furnish the sinews of war
for the use of Israeli Warriors. The cause
of Israel is a just one There are, however,
still men like Bevin in England and Mar-
shall in America whose machinations must
be countered and blocked by the force of
an enlightened public conscience. For
this, the political strength of American
Jewry must be allied to the good will of
all Americans, of every creed, who believe
in international morality.
To oppose this program, the Jewish
anti-Zionists raise the alarm of divided
allegiance. It is an old bugaboo, worn
threadbare by the rough handling it has
received over the years from men like
Louis Brandcis and Woodrow Wilson.
These statesmen long ago demonstrated
the identity of spiritual quality between
true Americanism and true Zionism. Both
taught that a Jew is a better American
for being a good Zionist, and both gave
the lesson the verity of a proppsition in
logic. But the anti-Zionist has no other
argument; and being bound by the limi-
tations of his own obstinate blindness,
must walk the treadmill of his errors, end-
lessly.
Let those of us who know better the
lesson of man's progress go on with our
work and leave the anti Zionists to the
limbo to which the verdict of history; if
not of his own conscience, will consign
him.
— William I. Siegel.
OBSERVE JEWISH BOOK MONTH
THE month preceding Chanukah has
been designated Jewish Book Month.
This annual celebration, sponsored by the
National Jewish Welfare Board, is a
timely reminder of the value of the Jew-
ish book. The book-mark issued by the
Jewish Book Council carries as its slogan
the words of Judah Ibn-Tibbon: "Books
shall be thy companions; bookcases and
shelves, thy pleasure-nooks and gardens."
Let us indeed seek out the companion-
ship of Jewish books. Recent publica-
tions include many worthwhile works of
special interest to the Jewish reader, such
as Howard Fast's novel of the Maccabean
revolt, Ibn-Zahav's reconstruction of the
Shylock story, Maurice Samuel's study of
the world of I. L. Peretz, Ausubel's
"Treasury of Jewish Folklore," Ruth
Gruber's story of the "Exodus — 1947,"
the Efros translation of Bialik's poems,
Kaplan's "The Future of the American
Jew."
No gift is more appropriate than a
book. Why not a charming kindergarten
favorite like the "Adventures of Kton-
ton" (Jewish tom-thumb) as a Chanukah
gift for the Jewish child instead of the
usual flimsy toy so quickly discarded?
Above all, let us not forget the Book
of Books — the Bible — which has earned
us the title of "The People of the Book."
The reader may recall a large banner at
the Palestine Pavilion of the World's Fair
which carried a slogan from Chaim Nach-
man Bialik: "The Land of Israel gave us
the Bible, and the Bible is destined to re-
store to us the Land of Israel."
The love of Zion, the hope of restora-
tion, the renaissance of the Hebrew people
— all these ideals were given immortal ex-
pression by the Bible.
Without the Book the miraculous re-
vival of Israel in our own day would have
been impossible. The new State of Israel
is indeed a living proof of the power of
the Book.
MORDLCAI H. LCVCITTES.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Greenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Goodstein, Treasurer Frank SchaefFer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthal. D.D., D.H.L, Rabbi Manuel Salhman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
4
"JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES"
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
It Is Not Enough To Love Peace — Pursue It
IN THESE days, when in the press and
over the radio we are constantly being
spurred on to thoughts of war, when
we read and hear only of the evils of the
enemy against whom we arc called upon
to oppose, an article that recently ap-
peared in the New York Times came as
a refreshing breeze in a stifling atmosphere
of heat.
I refer to an article written by the
well known commentator, Hanson W.
Baldwin, entitled "Military Criticized," in
which he expresses in most vehement
tones criticism of Secretary of the Army
Kenneth C. Royall for his recent charac-
terization of Russia's leaders as "interna-
tional shysters."
"Time was," says Baldwin in this
article "when the military and their rep-
resentatives, with a due regard for pro-
tocol and the proper place of the military
in a democracy, refrained in their public
remarks from attacks upon any nation or
from comments on domestic or inter-
national politics. There was, generally
speaking, a scrupulous regard for this
convention before World War II, and the
errant who deviated from it was likely
'to be slapped down.' This custom, like
so many others, seems to have gone with
the wind."
Mr. Baldwin then goes on to tell us
how prevalent is the dangerous disregard
of this practice and quotes other digni-
taries of the army and navy who have
been speaking and writing openly about
war with the Soviet Union and about at-
tacking it with atomic bombs.
"Such language ... at a time of deli-
cate international tension," he continues,
"would seem to indicate irresponsibility.
It is language that can do no good what-
soever and it is certain to do much harm.
It is the language of war — and all United
States' efforts ought to be directed to-
ward keeping the peace, though always
without sacrifice of the vital interests of
the nation."
Mr. Baldwin, in this well-written
article, touches upon the danger of the
military taking hold of the foreign policy
of our government instead of the Presi-
dent and the State Department. But his
general criticism applies to all leaders of
thought in our nation, and is most timely.
We hear too much this "language of War"
from the commentators over the radio,
and read too much in many of our news-
papers this "sabre-rattling," as Baldwin
terms it. He utters a wise warning when
he tells us "the United States has reached
a psychological frame of mind — danger-
ous in the extreme — that can, in itself,
be a cause for war."
Would that these words of Baldwin
could reach all the citizens of our land.
It has become fashionable for all who
speak and write, for all who mould pub-
lic opinion, to whip us into a frenzy of
hate and belligerency, not realizing that
this feeling of hate and enmity in itself
can drive us into a third worlcl war.
I do not ignore or belittle the difficul-
ties now existing between East and West,
and the strained relations between Russia
and our own country. But just because
the tension is great, we need an atmos-
phere of calm, so that our heads of gov-
ernment can act wisely and justly to win
peace with justice to all parties concerned.
"A great sense of public responsibility,"
said Baldwin, "is above all essential in
time of crisis." The calling of names and
the kindling of passions will certainly not
help to ease the crisis. Let us have faith
in those who lead our national destinies,
and instead of crying for war, let us show
a desire for international peace, so that
this desire for peace may help our leaders
achieve it.
The ancient Jewish sage reflected the
wisdom of ages when lie urged us to
"Love peace and pursue it." If peace is
to be achieved it is not enough to love
it — we must pursue it, we must seek it,
we must strive for it.
Mr. Baldwin concludes his article with
this quotation from "The Gathering
Storm," by Winston Churchill, which we
thankfully reprint, and which we hope
that Churchill himself will take to heart:
"How many wars have been averted by
patience and persisting good will! . . .
How many wars have been precipitated
by fire-brands!"
NEW BOOKS
"Days of Awe," translated from the
Hebrew by Sbmuel Yosef Agnon.
Schocken Books.
^J/HEN this volume originally ap-
▼V peared in Hebrew it won the hearts
of all readers. Now that it appears in
English, we are confident that it will also
bring delight to all who will be privileged
to read it.
Agnon is one of the most gifted of our
Palestinian writers, and in this volume
he displays not only the gift of style, but
a uniqueness of theme. In "Days of
Awe" — the English for Jamhn Nora'im
— he collects all of the fascinating legends,
tales, traditions concerning the entire sea-
son of the Days of Awe — Rosh Hashanah,
Yom Kippur and the days between, the
days of penitence.
This treasury of beautiful thoughts and
comments represents a collection from
300 volumes, ancient and modern, and
gives the reader a new appreciation of
what these Days of Awe actually meant
to the Jew throughout the ages.
What will undoubtedly prove of great-
est interest to the modern reader are the
rich and unique interpretations and les-
sons quoted from the great and classic
Hassidic Teachers, which reveal their
keen understanding of the human soul and
its thirst for the higher ideals in life.
And all this has been rendered into a
beautiful and masterly English transla-
tion, which succeeds in making clear to
the reader even the hidden meaning of
some of the Hebrew comments.
Schocken Books deserve to be congratu-
lated for bringing to the English speaking
Jews of America this beautiful, soul-and-
mind-enriching work, by one of our most
distinguished authors. — I. H. L.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
A Reminder of Black Thursday
By One of Its Victims
ONLY TEN YEARS AGO
IT WAS a Thursday, November 10,
1938. "Herr von Rath killed by )ew
Gryuszpau!" the newsboys shouted,
rushing through the streets of Vienna. I
happened to be on my way to the Mac-
cabi Club, but I decided to go home.
After a few minutes I was stopped. "Are
you a Jew?" The man who asked me
this question had the tough appearance
of a gangster. Frequently Jews were
beaten and robbed in the streets of Nazi
Vienna in broad daylight. So intimidated
were our people that often they did not
dare to cry for help. I tried to escape
the man by going faster. He caught me.
A short wrestling match began. People
gathered around us. Although all of
them wore Nazi badges, they took my
side, regarding the fellow a common crim-
inal. But he scornfully shouted at the
crowd: "Off with you — Gestapo!" He
took a brass check out of his pocket. I
never saw such a stampede before!
The Gestapo-man put handcuffs on me.
As if I were a thief, I was dragged
through the crowded streets of my native
city, on that gloomy November day. We
happened to cross the Judenplatz, no
longer a Jewish section, though in the
Middle Ages the center of the ghetto.
Strange as it sounds I remember the
stories of persecution I had been told as
a child — how in 1421 all Jews were ban-
ished from Vienna, after hundreds of
Jewish men and women had been burned
at the stake because they refused the last
minute chance of purchasing their free-
dom at the price of a conversion. How
they had spit before the generous Duke
and gone to death, according to the medi-
eval Jewish chronicler, "as if they were
led under a Chuppah."
I looked up to the medieval tablet com-
memorating in corrupt Latin the expul-
sion of the "Hebrew dogs." With another
glance, I made sure that the statue of Les-
sing, upright fighter for tolerance and a
close friend of Moses Mendelssohn, was
still there. Obviously the Nazis had for-
gotten to take it down as they had done
the monuments of Popper-Lynkeus and
others.
That Black Thursday journey through
the Vienna streets led me eventually to
the horrors of the Dachau concentration
camp.
Last summer, almost ten years later, I
visited my native city, as an American
journalist and United States citizen, and
I took the trouble of walking from the
spot where I had been arrested and
through Judenplatz to the police station.
On Judenplatz I found no trace of the
Lessing Monument — the Nazis did get
around to it. But the medieval tablet of
1421 was still affixed to the house, and
both in Germany and in Austria I noticed
quite a few signs of anti-Semitism a la
1938.
Ten years have now passed since the
progroms of November, 193 8, and I wish
I did not have to revive the nightmarish
memories of that period of terror. I wish
I could act like that merciful Jewish
author who, mentioning the Ukrainian
pogroms of 1648, declared: "We are
ashamed to describe what the Cossacks
and the Tartars did to the Jews so that
we may not disgrace the human species
that was created in God's image." But I
feel that the story of "Black Thursday"
must not be forgotten, neither by Chris-
tian nor by Jew, at least as long as the
ruins of burned synagogues are crying to
heaven in Berlin and Vienna, Frankfort
and Koenigsberg; as long as the earth is
quivering with the bones of six million
dead, slaughtered as an aftermath to the
dress rehearsal of November, 1938.
After all, it is now almost certain that
future historians will treat the pogroms
of 1938 as an event as important in the
history of Man as was the Massacre of
St. Bartholomew. When the Duke of
Guise, leader of the Catholic Party in
France, ordered his followers to kill the
Huguenots (Protestants) in Paris on
August 24, 1572, his motive was of a
political, not of a religious nature, though
he used the fact that the Huguenots were
Protestants as a pretext. Similarly Hitler
ordered the final destruction of the Jewry
within his realm because of political con-
siderations, not because he was enraged
by the assassination of Ernst von Rath
by that young Polish Jew, Hershel Gryn-
szpan. What was that minor official at
the Embassy in Paris to him that he
should weep for him?
By ALFRED WERNER
Real poll tik, not an emotional upsurge,
was behind the large-scale riots. After
his diplomatic victory at Munich, Hitler
was convinced that it would be easy for
him to conquer the "decadent" democra-
cies, so he ordered the pogroms. These
were intended to rehearse the German
people, and particularly the Storm Troop-
ers and Elite Guards, in the "treatment"
of conquered nations, to intimidate the
enemies of Nazism within and with-
out the Reich, and to bolster up the
shaken war economy of the Reich by the
confiscation of Jewish property.
The immediate and more obvious aim
of the "Black Thursday" was, of course,
the final liquidation of the remnants of
German Jewry. When the Nazis came
to power, in 1933, about 550,000 Jews
lived within the boundaries of Germany.
Despite their humiliations, their physical
sufferings at the hands of Nazi hoodlums,
and the drastic curb on their economic
life, there still remained in November,
1938, some 350,000 Jews, even though
these were becoming more and more de-
pleted. In Austria, where the speed of
the anti-Jewish legislation was much
greater and the brutality of official and
semi-official Jew-baiting much worse than
in the Reich, by November, 1938, more
than 50,000 of the original 200,000
Jews had left the country. A small num-
ber of Jews were trapped at Karlsbad and
other cities in the Sudeten area when the
Nazis occupied it after the Conference of
Munich, while the majority of the Jews
fled to Prague.
Even the elimination of practically all
Jewish-born professional men from the
cultural life in Germany, the introduc-
tion of the medieval ghetto, and the im-
poverishment of all classes of Jews did
not satisfy the radical elements in the
Nazi Party. They waited for the right
moment to strike a decisive blow at help-
less German Jewry so as to eliminate the
"Jewish danger" for all times. So wel-
come was the assassination of Ernst von
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
6
Rath to the Nazis that some people be-
lieved — without foundation — that young
Hershel Grynszpan was a voluntary or
involuntary tool in the hands of the Ges-
tapo. The pogrom, and its "legal" con-
sequences — notably the infamous Billion
Mark Fine Atonement Decree, and the
Decree Concerning the Elimination of the
Jews from German Economic Life — had
the desired results: while thousands died
in Nazi prisons and concentration camps,
tens of thousands fled the Reich, abandon-
ing their property.
It is interesting to recall, ten years
after the catastrophe, the democratic
world's immediate reaction to those
ghastly events. The pograms took place
only a few weeks after the war had been
"averted" by the infamous Munich Pact.
Chamberlain and his clique, the world
would learn, had vainly endeavored to
restrain the German beast by feeding it
Austria, Czechoslovakia and Memel. Some
people may still have believed that the
events of November, regrettable though
they were, "only" concerned the Jews,
but an editorial in The Nation, warned
the Americans that the pogroms should
rather be regarded as the "direct conse-
quences of the Munich triumph which
completed the rout of all sober elements
around Hitler and established the power
of the extremists."
No prophetic gifts were necessary at
that time to see clearly that the pogroms
indicated a beginning, not an end.
Philip J. Noel-Baker, Laborite M.P., felt
clearly that the pogroms would hardly
be the last atrocities to be committed by
the Nazis. "Where is this thing going
to end? What is it going to mean to us
before it is ended?" he asked the House
of Commons in a memorable speech de-
livered on November 21st of that year.
"Dr. Goebbels would like us to think that
it is a domestic question, that it is no
concern of ours how his Government
treats the racial and religious minorities
within their state. If the treatment of
minorities is a domestic question, by what
right did Germany concern herself with
the fate of the Sudeten Germans two
months ago? Certainly by no treaty
rights." Mr. Noel-Baker's speech cul-
minated in the statement that everything
is international which stirs the conscience
of mankind.
Alas, the events of the period 1938-
1948 should prove that even some of the
worst atrocities failed to stir the "con-
science of mankind." In that period
millions were killed, millions of defense-
less civilians — Jews, Czechs, Yugoslavs,
Russians, and others — yet very few states-
men spoke out against this new crime of
"genocide," and nothing was done by the
nations of the world to stop it.
On my recent trip through the Amer-
ican zone of Germany, and through Aus-
tria, I talked with several Christians
about the events of November, 1938.
They all regretted them — but when I re-
marked that recently Jewish cemeteries
had been desecrated in the Reich and in
Austria, and that movie audiences had
laughed and hissed when the re-opening
of the Munich synagogue was shown in
a newsreel, they angrily declared that
this could not be true.
Fairness requires us, however, to admit
that not all Germans were happy about
the burning of houses of worship, and the
maltreatment of their fellow-townsmen
in 1938. I wish to quote from two
diaries recently published in this country.
Mrs. Ruth Andreas-Friedrich, author -of
"Berlin Underground" who, in November
1938, hid Jews in her apartment, tells of
compatriots who were "ready to die of
pity and shame." Still, the author's con-
science is not at ease concerning the ex-
tent of her resistance to Nazism: "We
really ought to spit at each other for
standing by without opening our
mouths," she writes remorsefully when
relating the willful destruction of syna-
gogues and the killing and robbing of
innocent Berlin Jews. As for Ulrich von
Hassell, the diplomat who was executed
by the Nazis for his participation in the
plot to kill Hitler on November 2 5, 1938,
the old man jots down these words of in-
dignation:
"I am writing under crushing emotions
evoked by the vile persecution of the Jews
after the murder of von Rath. Not since
the World War have we lost so much
credit in the world. But my chief con-
cern is not with the effects abroad, not
with what kind of foreign political reac-
tion we may expect — at least not for the
moment. I am most deeply troubled
about the effect on our national life,
which is dominated ever more inexorably
by a system capable of such things."
(From the Von Hassel Diaries.)
I am sure that quite a few Germans
did not like the happenings of the "Black
Thursday." But not a single German
was courageous and upright enough to
protest openly and strongly against this
madness and bestiality. At best, they
confided their horror to trusted friends,
or to diaries. This lack of action was
recently revealed by a man who himself
had once climbed upon the Nazi band-
wagon but had later left it to work
against his Fatherland as an agent of the
American OSS. In his memoirs, "To the
Bitter End," this man, Hans Bernd Gise-
vius, writes:
"Not a single (German) minister, un-
do r-secretary, or general would have been
sent to concentration camp for calling
things by their right name; any concerted
protest might well have led to a revolt
of the decent men. Only those whose
high office conferred on them the obliga-
tion to act showed a little more courage.
Because the Neuraths, Schwerings, Seldtes,
Dorpmuellers, Raeders, Keitels, and Brau-
chitsches could muster up such courage,
they sank deeper and deeper into the pit
of guilt; and at the same time they
brought upon millions of innocent hu-
man beings, who were waiting for them
to lead and to be examples, the terrible
lot that has befallen Europe."
Perhaps Gisevius overestimates the "de-
cency" of the non-Nazis in Hitler's en-
tourage who were supposed to put a limit
to the Third Reich's excesses. But why
did the Nobel Prize winner, Gerhart
Hauptmann, keep silent after the po-
groms, forgetting the countless Jews in
the realm of art who had helped him be-
come the "German Ibsen," the "German
Shakespeare?" After all, an attempt on
his part to protect the Jews would have
involved no danger to the life or liberty
of a man of his standing, age and prestige.
Not all the waters of the Rhine River
can wash off the stain on Germany's 20th
century history, put there by the horrible
events of November 1938. As for the
Jewish people, it will never, never forget
them. Significantly, for the past nine
years many a Jew from Central Europe
has made it a habit to go to synagogue on
the sixteenth of the month of Cheshvan
to thank God for not having been killed
in the "Night of the Hatches," that
ghastly climax in Hitler's war of exterm-
ination against the Jews. Yet what ap-
pears to be a second "Tisha b'Av" to the
Jew, marks November 10, 1938, as the
precise start of the second World War.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
7
The False Messiah Died A Broken Man
and Lay Buried in an Unmarked Crave
THE AMAZING SABBATAI ZEVI
Part II
This is the second and concluding
part of Rabbi Minkin's study of one
of the most bewildering characters in
Jctvisb history.
HISTORIANS find it hard to ac-
count for Sabbatai Zevi's strange
career or to appraise him. He
seems to stand outside of history. He
took his leap in the dark, carrying with
him little that is memorable. Even in
the record of the pseudo-messianic move-
ments, his chapter is without a parallel.
Many another messianic pretender had a
flair for the spectacular, but the role Sab-
batai Zevi played is fantastic beyond
imagining. The tribe of religious fanatics
to which he belongs, when not vulgarly
motivated by personal gain or popularity,
were rebels against one thing or another;
usually rabbinical Judaism. The libera-
tion of the Jews they sought to bring
about was not so much a liberation from
the yoke of the galut as it was a libera-
tion from the "yoke" of the talmudic leg-
islation which became hateful to them.
But Sabbatai Zevi and his followers
went further than any of their predeces-
sors. Tlie flag of rebellion they hoisted
was by far the more radical and danger-
ous, for it was an insurgency against both
the oral and the written law, against the
legislation of Moses and the legislation of
the Rabbis, indeed, a proclamation of a
new covenant. It was a heresy hereto-
fore unknown among the Jews, one which
threatened to blot out thousands of years
of Jewish history and experience. "Sab-
batianism," writes Gershom Scholem in
"Major Trends in Jewish Mysticism,"
"represents the first serious revolt in
Judaism since the Middle Ages; it was
the case of mystical ideas leading directly
to the disintegration of the, orthodox
Judaism of the 'believers.' "
•
It was not long before Sabbatai was
worshipped not only as the King-Messiah
but as a deity as well. The transition
was easily accomplished, and without a
murmur of protest. The times were
sufficiently irregular and agitated for any
superstition or blasphemy however fan-
tastic. The dissolution of Judaism was
accomplished by abolishing beliefs and
practices Jews had tenaciously clung to
for thousands of years, and proclamations
addressed to the Jews of the world by the
Messiah's secretary, Samuel Primo, were
signed in his master's name, "1, the Lord
your God, Sabbatai Zevi."
The Man-God-Messiah had met with
little encouragement in Palestine, despite
the energetic campaign of his heralds and
apostles. The imposture was too coarse
and vulgar to make any impression, but
all along the road to Smyrna, the goal of
his triumphal procession, he was accom-
panied by a storm of ovations which did
credit to the expert showmanship of his
managers. The roads were blocked for
miles; regular traffic was detoured; thick
masses of humanity were on the move to
catch a glimpse of the Man-God-Messiah.
Endless cheering; deafening uproar; a
thousand voices raised at once at the mere
sight of him. Sometimes the procession
would be halted and Sabbatai reviewed his
admirers as a general reviews his troops;
and then, what enthusiasm, what ap-
plause, what frenzied gesticulation of
hands and bodies!
The Man-God-Messiah played his part
to perfection. He was indeed a wondrous
sight to behold — black beard, burning
eyes, ascetic chalk-white face. Wrapped
in the great prayer shawl which com-
pletely covered his majestic form, he
looked the veritable Son of David he had
proclaimed himself to be. Acting always,
he never uttered a word or lifted an eye-
brow, but absently gazed into the dis-
tance. He was as a man not of this
world. What were his thoughts in the
moments of continued storms of adula-
tion? Were there doubts, questions, dark
forebodings of the fate that befell all the
self-hypnotised Messiahs? We shall never
know, for Sabbatai never spoke, never
confided, failed to leave a written docu-
ment by which his inner thoughts and
feelings, if he had any, might be surmised.
But the honor and glory (that) came
to him from the shrieking tumultuous
crowds were as nothing as compared with
the frenzied enthusiasm that greeted him
when he approached the city that seven-
By JACOB S. MINKIN
teen years ago had excommunicated and
banished him. For the moment reality
seemed to have been blotted out by scenes
of the most fantastic kind. People en-
slaved, beaten, and crushed by the cen-
turies poured out their love for the man
who passed as their deliverer.
His every step was made a magnificent
procession; his every move was hailed with
clamorous demonstrations; flowers were
strewn in his path; Smyrna resembled a
forest of waving banners; the Messiah-
Prophet was silent, but what occasional
psalm he murmured was passed from
mouth to mouth till it became a thun-
derous chorus. Everywhere the Messiah
showed himself there was singing, danc-
ing, serenading — men and women acting
as though possessed. Young and old
pressed about the Messiah's carriage, try-
ing to catch a glimpse of him and his
lovely Queen. During all these ceremo-
nies, Sabbatai remained calm, aloof, dis-
tant. But it was more than innocent joy
that swept over Smyrna's population. In
the mystical transport that fell over the
town excesses were committed in which
men lost their restraint and women their
virtue. Pious rabbis cried out in horror
against what was happening, but there
was no damming the tide in wake of the
Messiah.
There were also somber and solemn
scenes. The news of the King-Messiah
created among the sin-laden a desire to
put themselves right with their better
conscience. An orgy of self-inflicted
penitential tortures swept over the fanat-
ical crowd. Some flogged themselves till
blood spurted from their bodies; others
had themselves buried in snow and broken
ice, and still others flagellated themselves
with nettles or wore rough hairy shirts
against their naked skins. They gave
their wealth to the poor with a lavish
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
8
hand. In their eager, almost hysterical
excitement, they believed they no longer
had any need of material things. Sabbatai
Zevi may be accused of vanity, ambition,
and delusions of grandeur, but no trace
of avarice can be laid at his door. He
took of no man's gold and of no woman's
jewels, although both were unstintingly
laid at his feet. Of what was offered to
him not a farthing remained in his posses-
sion. He gave everything away to the
poor, supporting himself and his consid-
erable entourage by what subsidy he re-
ceived from his rich brothers.
The delirium that seized upon the
people was world-wide, stretching all the
way from Smyrna, the Messiah's capital,
to Salonica, Constantinople, Amsterdam,
Hamburg, even as far down as the towns
and hamlets in darkest Poland. The air
was full of expectations, the atmosphere
was charged with rumors of the wildest
sort. Wonderment befell not only the
common folk, but great and dignified
rabbis wrote to each other long letters
full of bewilderment, not knowing what
to believe. Christians no less than Jews
were caught in the messianic hysteria.
Strange portents were seen in all the lands
of Europe; streams turned in their course,
comets fell like hail, ships with Hebrew
inscriptions on their sails were sighted in
the dawn-light. The credulous "saw",
wondered, and waited.
Even so enlightened a scientist as Hein-
rich Oldenburg, a friend of Baruch
Spinoza, became curious about what he
had heard of the Turkish Messiah, and
wrote to the Amsterdam philosopher:
"There is a rumor in everybody's mouth
here that the Jews ... are to return to
their country. Few in this place believe
it, but many wish it. Tell your friend
of what you hear and think about this
matter. ... If this important announce-
ment is true, it would seem to bring
about a crisis on the whole world." The
skeptical Spinoza did not believe in mir-
acles and messiahs, but he regarded the
eventual restoration of the Jews to their
homeland as both feasible and desirable.
In the general messianic fever that
swept over the world, great Gentile mer-
cantile establishments were on the verge
of bankruptcy and foreign governments
made representations to the Kadi of
Smyrna to check the agitation. It was
all in vain. Like a tidal wave, the cred-
ulity of the masses was beyond any man's
control. Business was at a standstill,
merchants were ruined, stores and shops
closed their doors, debts were cancelled.
In their readiness for the Messiah no one
paid any attention to the things of this
IN THE NEWS
By Boris Smolar
FOR the first half of this year, Jewish
women in 28 5 cities raised more than
$13,000,000 for local Jewish Federations
and Welfare Funds.
The cooperation existing between the
Joint Distribution Committee and world
Zionist leadership even before the estab-
lishment of Israel is best illustrated by
the fact that from 1914 through 1946,
J. D. C. expenditures in Palestine and
Palestine-related fields amounted to some
$21,600,000.
•ft
Edwin Samuel, son of Sir Herbert
Samuel, the first High Commissioner of
Palestine, who has himself lived in Pal-
estine for almost thirty years, is now
teaching at Dropsie College, Philadelphia.
Fluent in both Arabic and Hebrew,
Samuel has been engaged as Visiting Pro-
fessor by the newly-founded Institute for
Israel and the Middle East at Dropsie Col-
lege to lecture on Middle East Govern-
ment and Administration.
The Jewish Post of Winnipeg is the
first, and so far the only, English- Jewish
newspaper on the American continent to
carry a Hebrew column for the benefit
of its young readers. Its editor, Melvin
Fenson, wanted to start the Jewish New
Year right, and introduced this innova-
tion in his Rosh Hashonah issue.
The autobiography of President Chaim
Weizmann of Israel will be published by
Harpers under the title "Trial and Error."
In addition to the regular edition, there
will be a limited two-volume edition that
will be autographed by Dr. Weizmann.
—By J. T. A.
world. Only the poor and the indigent
prospered, for since there was no longer
any need for money, people gladly parted
with their possessions to make their way
to the Holy Land easier.
In the meantime, in the little time left
him before claiming his kingdom, the
God-Messiah had completely abandoned
himself to the sweet odor of incense which
so well agreed with his capacious vanity.
Smyrna was his capital, and its swarming
masses, augmented by pilgrims from al-
most all the world, were his mute, obedi-
ent slaves. His rule was unquestioned,
his authority undisputed. What oppo-
nents he had he crushed with a firm, un-
messianic, hand. He was the lord and
master of his community. He showed
none of the gentleness tradition ascribes
to the Messiah. He did pretty much as
his whim or fancy dictated. He intimi-
dated, expelled, and dealt out painful
blows to all who dared stand in his way.
Not only the Jews, but the Turkish offi-
cials as well stood in fear and awe of him.
It was due largely to him that Smyrna,
for long an obscure and poverty-stricken
town, became a flourishing city hailed all
over the world as the seat of the King-
Messiah. A nod from Sabbatai and short
shrift was made of any man who chal-
lenged his power and authority.
But his greatest moment was yet to
come. And it came on a Sabbath, in the
self-same synagogue and from the self-
same dais, where seventeen years before,
he hurled, in the presence of the self -same
congregation, the four-lettered name of
the Deity and was banished for it. He
now stood up and declared himself, "I
am the Messiah" without a murmur of
dissent from any of the worshippers. As
before, the pious and skeptics heard and
were shocked, but they no longer dared
make their voices heard in protest. It
was a great moment, indeed; but it was
also the last and final word that passed
the lips of the King-Messiah unchallenged.
Sabbatai Zevi's spell was now broken.
He did not realize that the year 1666,
which he himself had designated as the
year when he would dethrone the Sultan
and assume the kingship, was almost at
hand. The people were getting nervous,
restless; their expectation could not any
longer be deferred. They were eager to
behold the realization of their hopes and
promises.
•
On the God-King-Messiah the ap-
proaching Year of Fulfillment produced a
dismal effect. He was nervous; he was
fidgety; he waved before his face the cool-
ing palm with a trembling hand. Sab-
Brooldyn Jewish Center Review
9
batai Zevi knew Smyrna and he knew
the Jews, but Constantinople and the
Turks — they were something else. Still,
he did not give up hope. He hoped for
something to turn up. At any rate, it
was too late in the game to turn back.
There were neither wreaths nor gar-
lands on the little nutshell vessel which
carried Sabbatai Zevi on his fateful jour-
ney to Constantinople on December 30,
1665, but there was tumultous cheering
of the adoring followers who pushed their
way to the dock to see him off. The trip
was rough and stormy, as if the elements
of nature were disdainful of the distin-
guished passenger aboard. The sea was
lashed by gales and storms, while the King
Messiah lay squatting in a corner deep in
his dismal thoughts. A voyage that
should have taken no more than a few
days, lasted forty days. But that in itself
was a good omen, symbolic of the forty
years the Israelites had spent in the wilder-
ness when on their way to the Holy Land.
•
The reception of the King-Messiah by
the Turkish official was neither prophesied
nor expected — a resounding slap on the
cheek in the presence of the many Jews
who came to greet their Redeemer. There
were thunder and lightning, but nothing
happened to the man who administered
the blow. Sabbatai stood the test bril-
liantly. He simply offered the other
cheek to the smiter, thus vindicat-
ing the humility Scripture assigns to the
Suffering Messiah. But not so brilliant
was the part he played when he was
brought before the Deputy Grand Vizier.
For, when he was called upon to answer
who he was, whence he came, and what
had made him rouse the Jews to such
pitch of excitement, the mantle of the
Messiah suddenly dropped from Kim, and
his only stammered reply was that he
was a Palestine rabbi come to collect alms
and he could in no wise be held respon-
sible for the honors that were paid him.
The Turks saw through the trembling
little man's clumsy lie and did not even
deem him worthy a martyr's death. In-
stead, they packed him off in chains to
prison like a common thief. It was a
sorry spectacle, that of a shackled King-
Messiah. But sorrier still, infinitely more
pathetic, was the stubborn, fanatic faith
of his followers who, chains or no chains,
had not abandoned their trust in him.
Blindly they continued to worship him,
blindly they flocked to his cell from great
distances, bearing with them costly gifts
which made his prison look like a royal
reception hall. The jailers were patient,
tolerant, even generous, in their treatment
of him. Every opportunity of freedom
of movement and action was given him.
He was permitted to receive visitors, im-
part instruction, dictate letters and take
long walks surrounded by his admirers.
Princely gifts were sent by the followers
of the Prince Messiah, which helped to
make his forced confinement as painless
as possible.
Not long afterwards, the prisoner was
transferred to Abydos, a lonely fortress-
castle in Gallipoli, where the Turkish au-
thorities hoped to isolate him from his be-
sieging visitors. But they did not reckon
with the fanatical madness of his worship-
ers, for soon the isolated fortress became
a pilgrim's shrine, with streams of visitors
from almost everywhere. Its very name
was changed into Migdol Oz, signifying
a Tower of Strength. Samuel Primo, the
Messiah's secretary, was set to work as
feverishly as never before, writing letters,
dispatching messages, and issuing procla-
mations. Indeed, a whole world was set
in motion. Droves of pilgrims from al-
most every Jewish community stood
waiting at the prison gates. Cargoes of
furniture and tapestries came in with
every vessel. It was all too wonderful,
too magnificent. The Turkish officials
did not dare interfere. Their obscure
little town had suddenly become rich and
prosperous, almost a world capital.
•
Sabbatai Zevi played his part with
practiced skill. His old-time vanity had
not forsaken him. He was King-Messiah
again. A throne-room was set up where
he held court in royal style. He dispensed
counsel, bestowed blessings and, as before,
he succeeded in deluding the wise and the
simple, the ignorant and the subtle scholar
alike. Rabbis and talmudic scholars came
from almost all parts of the world, from
Asia, Africa, Italy, Poland, and Holland.
They engaged him in learned discussions
on the merits of his claims, and they went
away convinced. He waved aside many
practices of the Jewish ritual, abolished
the ninth of Ab and the seventeenth of
Tammuz, both commemorating the de-
struction of the Temple and the fall of
Jerusalem, as fast days, and proposed to
inaugurate a new religious code of his
own, yet there was not a murmur of
protest or disapproval from the learned.
There was only one man, Nehemiah
ha-Kohen from far-away Poland, himself
not without prophetic or messianic aspira-
tions, who shook the King-Messiah's
throne and, in the end, made it topple.
He was sent to investigate the Messiah of
Abydos. For several days the two men
locked metaphysical horns, with texts
THE BIBLE
NO ONE man could have made that
first standardized translation of the
Bible known as the St. James' Version.
No single generation of men could have
done it. It is not the labor of a single
century. It represents the work of hun-
dreds of translators, working through
hundreds of years, each succeeding gen-
eration improving upon the work of the
previous generation.
The 24 books of the Bible have inspired
poets and writers in all the literatures of
the world to such an extent, that one can
scarcely read a masterpiece in which there
is not some conscious or unconscious ref-
erence to these eternal books.
The Song of Songs, is the greatest of
lyric ballads. The book of Job is cer-
tainly not only the grandest book in the
Bible, but the most ancient drama of all,
and can be studied with enthusiasm in
our modern times. Another book of
philosophical importance is Ecclesiastes, in
which, in addition to much proverbial
wisdom there is admirable poetry.
We now have many other versions,
perhaps more scholarly than the King
James of 1611, and centuries hence there
will still be growing the number of poets,
scholars and translators who will be delv-
ing into the depths of the Bible, seeking
richer and deeper meaning and expressions
of its original.
— Dr. A. Asen.
raining like arrows on every side. After
the long kabbalistic duel was over, the
Polish emissary was plainly skeptical.
Sabbatai Zevi's enthusiasts would have
slain him, but Nehemiah outwitted them
by escaping to the Turks, to whom he
confided Sabbatai's sham messiahship and
his design against the Sultan and his king-
dom.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
What followed was quick and dra-
matic. Mahomet IV was an easy and
benevolent despot. He did not interfere
with the religious affairs of his subjects
so long as they brooked no danger to
himself or to his kingdom, but he was
harsh and unforgiving to rebels, and by
all rules, Sabbatai Zevi was a rebel against
the State whose penalty could be none
other than death. But Pasha Guidon, a
renegade Jew and the Sultan's trusted
physician, was of another mind. A rebel
against his former religion himself, he
knew best how to deal with other rebels.
He advised his master against executing
the pretender. That was too crude and
cruel and might not discourage his fol-
lowers from still be lieving in his messiah-
ship. His plan was to make Sabbatai look
ridiculous by prevailing upon him to be-
come a Moslem. The Sultan consented
and left it to his physician to attend to
the details.
For the first time Sabbatai Zevi was
unceremoniously treated. When the Turk-
ish soldiers burst into his magnificent
Abydos apartment to transfer him to
Adrianople, where the Sultan was to sit
in judgment over him, they showed him
neither the respect nor the deference due
to a King-Messiah. There was excite-
ment among the faithful; they sensed the
terrifying danger, and they were afraid.
Sabbatai alone remained composed.
He was not left long in suspense. No
sooner was he brought under guard to
Adrianople, than he was assigned to an
apartment in the seraglio. No report was
left of his talks with the Sultan's rene-
gade physician, but they must have been
long and exciting. Guidon Pasha pressed
his point with arguments to which there
was no answer. The Sultan, he said, was
a hard-headed realist who accepts nothing
on faith. Things to him had to be proven,
demonstrated, as clear-cut facts. The
only test of messiahship the king recog-
nized was for the man claiming the honor
to submit his flesh to the poisoned arrows
of skilled bowmen. If the Messiah sur-
vived the test, then, of course, the Sultan
would grant him his every wish. The
alternative was for Sabbatai to adopt the
Moslem faith.
•
Sabbatai Zevi was terrified. He had
no taste for martyrdom and he shrank
with equal horror from apostasy. He
was prepared for almost everything but
this. He was ready to surrender his lofty
pretensions, to sink into oblivion, but
these things they required of him, they
were too much. He hoped for a miracle,
for something to happen. Things always
did happen whenever he was in a des-
perate position. But nothing did happen,
except the long, interminable visits of his
tormentor which left him limp and ex-
hausted.
In the end, something did happen, and
it came from his own perverse and tor-
tured soul. What, he thought, if he
fooled the Sultan, fooled his tormentor,
fooled all the world? What if he became
a Moslem in name only, just as a matter
of form, by public declaration, and in his
heart of hearts he remained a Jew, even
the King-Messiah? Did not the Marranos
in the depth of their souls, remain Jews,
while openly, as a matter of form, pre-
tended to be Christians? The thought
no sooner flashed across his mind, than
he felt himself inwardly relieved. Yes,
he had found the answer to the insoluble
problem. There was a smile of profound
satisfaction on his wan lips. His misery
was at en end; his old-time gaiety re-
turned to him once more. He sent for
Guidon Pasha to hurry to the Sultan that
he was ready.
There was rejoicing at the seraglio, for
TWICE-TOLD TALES
THIS tale is ascribed to Dr. Weizmann.
Two brothers were engaged in differ-
ent industries. One was in woolen cloth-
ing and the other in the fur business.
The first was always hoping that the
weather would be mild and the second
that the weather would be freezing.
The mother was in a quandary. If she
prayed for mild weather, her furrier son
would lose and if she prayed for freezing
weather, her woolens son would suffer.
Finally she solved, the problem by pray-
ing, "Dear God, let us bs favored with
a season of warm frost."
In the old days, when the Jewish
pioneers were asked, "Is it worthwhile to
undergo all of these hardships?" they re-
plied: "We may not live to see the fruits
of our labors, but our children will."
Today when young men fight for Israel
and are asked about their sacrifices they
say: "We may not live to see the fruits
of our labors, but our parents will."
Sabbatai was not indeed an ordinary con-
vert. The ceremony was brief, but im-
pressive. All the dignitaries of the court
were assembled when, as a sign of his con-
version, the King-Messiah donned the
Moslem fez. The Sultan was not nig-
gardly. Sabbatai was arrayed in a white
silk uniform and appointed as seraglio
chamberlain with a generous stipend for
his support. His name, too, was changed.
He was proclaimed as Mehmed Effendi, a
favorite of the king, a nobleman among
the notables of the Sublime Porte. It was
thus that Sabbatai Zevi, the embodied
hope and prayer of his people, entered
upon the final role of his tragi-comic
career.
Among the Jews the news created the
deepest consternation. They were jeered
and laughed at wherever they went, many
not trusting themselves to leave their
homes for shame. Those were days of
mourning and bitterness for the Jews.
Hundreds were impoverished, and hun-
dreds others were excommunicated for
their blind trust and folly. In all Jewry
there was hardly a town or village with-
out victims of the spurious King-Messiah.
But the end was not yet. For full ten
years after his conversion, Sabbatai Zevi
carried on his messianic pretensions, try-
ing to rekindle the old flame in the hearts
of his scattered followers. To his brothers
in Smyrna he wrote: "God has made me
an Ishmaelite. He commanded and it
was done." The deception he practiced
for nearly a generation was renewed once
more. Samuel Primo and Nathan Ghazati
emerged from their hiding and carried on
the agitation. "He is the Messiah, and
we expect none other," they wrote to
their deluded followers. For the first
time in Jewish history was a imn who
committed the two sins most repugnant
to Jews — betrayal and apostasy — hailed
as Messiah.
•
Sabbatai Zevi himself tried to make
good the lie as best he could. He mingled
with Jews, sang psalms, and carried out
certain synagogue rituals. He held him-
self out as Messiah in disguise. Occa-
sionally he received letters from men as
mad as himself who assured him of their
belief and confidence in him. But they
lacked the flavor such messages once had
for him. His power and influence were
[Continued on page 22]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
i I
This is a sermon preached on Rosh
Hashanah by Rabbi Let in thai at The
Brooklyn Jewish Center.
THIS is indeed a New Year in Jew-
ish history in more than a literal
sense. It is altogether a new Rosh
Hashanah, different from all the other
Rosh Hashanahs of the last nineteen cen-
turies. It marks not only the usual
change in the Jewish calendar — 5709 in-
stead of 5708 — but is year one of a new
epoch in the annals of Jewish life.
The miracle has happened. For the
first time in 1878 years we are a free
people again, a nation on its own historic
soil. The dawn of Jewish freedom has
entered our national life.
There is a very interesting historic note
given by the Rabbis in the Talmud with
reference to Rosh Hashanah. They try
to recall what great and important events
occurred on this holiday, and one of the
Sages tells us: "It was on Rosh Hashanah
that Joseph was freed from the dungeon
in Egypt" (R. H. 11a). Joseph the
dreamer, who suffered so much because
of his dreams — sold as a slave, thrown
into pit, languishing in dungeon of
Egypt, finally saw his freedom on a Rosh
Hashanah. This outcast among men now
stood before the ruler Pharaoh, interpret-
ing his dreams, and saving a people from
starvation.
"What happened to Joseph happened
also to Zion," says a Rabbi in the Midrash.
Joseph is a symbol of all that happened
to Zion and to the people of Zion. Like
Joseph, the Jew of Zion languished in
countless dungeons in many Egypts
throughout all these centuries. In our
own day we saw millions of these Jews,
with the image of Zion engraved upon
their minds and hearts, slaughtered merci-
lessly, and the remnant veritably lan-
guishing in the dungeons of Europe.
Thank God, this Rosh Hashanah marks
the Jews' exit from their prison, a free
people standing before the nations of the
world with strength, with dignity and
with self-respect.
It is interesting to note how the
Rabbis associate Joseph's freedom with
Rosh Hashanah. They quote the verse
from the Psalms (81, 4-6): "Blow the
horn at the new moon, at the full moon
for our feast-day ... He appointed it
in Joseph for a testimony, when he went
forth over the land of Egypt; a language
THE LANGUAGE
which I did not know I heard." There
is a connection here between the com-
memoration of Rosh Hashanah and the
statement that Joseph went out over the
land of Egypt, learning a language which
he did not know, which was a sufficient
warrant for the Rabbis to conclude that
it was on Rosh Hashanah that he became
a free man, entering a new epoch in his
life of usefulness and achievement.
But the Rabbis go deeper in the analy-
sis of this statement of the Psalmist.
What could he have meant by the words:
"A language which I did not know, I
heard, I understood"? And why is the
name of Joseph spelled here so strangely,
so differently from the usual way, with
the added letter "H" inserted within it?
And so they tell us a beautiful legend.
When Joseph appeared before Pharaoh,
the king's advisors and ministers laughed
and mocked. "What!" said they, "Will
you permit this slave, this outcast to be
a ruler among our people? One who
aspires to be a ruler must know the lan-
guages of the seventy nations of the
world. Examine him and see how ignor-
ant and unfit he is to sit in our councils!"
Just then, says the Talmud, the angel
Gabriel appeared and tried to teach
Joseph all the seventy languages. But
somehow Joseph could not learn them.
Gabriel then took one letter from God
Himself — the letter "H" — and added it
to Joseph's name — Be'ychosef — and in-
stantly he mastered all the languages, so
that in whatever language Pharaoh or his
ministers spoke to him, Joseph under-
stood, and answered in that very tongue,
Yea, in very truth he could say: "A
language which I did not know, I sud-
denly learned!"
How well this tale applies to Zion and
to the new Jew of Israel! Take the very
art of defending oneself — that is a lan-
guage which the Jew did not know. He
bent his back before every oppressor. He
cringed before every tyrant. He knew
only the language of silence and submis-
sion to every taunt, to every kick, to
every beating. Suddenly we see the mir-
acle of the Haganab, of the learning a
language over-night which for almost
1900 years they did not know. And
OF STATEHOOD
By DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL
what a mastery of that language the Jew
displayed! The Jew who never knew the
intricacies of army organization or disci-
pline, who knew nothing about arms or
weapons, suddenly became master of that
language, and held back and almost de-
feated seven nations and their standing
armies — one even supported by mighty
Britain itself and led by British officers.
What a remarkable story this miracle of
Haganah tells. Nations thought — and
some even hoped — that the Israeli forces
would be crushed within a few weeks.
But the miracle of the angel Gabriel oc-
curred, and this new Joseph mastered the
language which he did not know.
Or take the language of government,
and see how here, too, the new Jew of
Zion learned the language he did not
know. For 1900 years he had no ex-
perience in the art of government or
diplomacy. He had no relationship,
politically, with the nations of the world.
They commanded and he obeyed. Never
did he dare to speak to them as an equal.
Suddenly, over-night, this new Jew of
Israel mastered this language. Even the
most enthusiastic Zionist among us
thought that there would have to be a
transition period of months or years be-
fore the Jews of Israel could learn the
intricacies of government and political
life. Take, for example, the simplest
needs of a country — running a post office
or minting money. Where did the Jew
learn this? Yet — see — instantly as it
were, on the very day that Britain left
the country, the government of Israel
functioned in every way, within the land,
and in diplomatic relationship with the
nations of the world. Again "a language
which I did not know, I learned!"
And we, too, the Jews of the Diaspora,
we Jews of America, have also suddenly
learned a language which we did not
know before this modern Joseph became
free. We learned the language of self-
respect, a new esteem for the very name
of Jew. We walk now with head erect,
no longer feeling that we are the pariahs
of mankind. The world has been forced
[Continued on page 22]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
WHAT I SAW IN THE D. P. CAMPS
MANY of us have seen pictures of
Nazi concentration camps, and
I, like others, have associated
them with the camps for displaced per-
sons in Europe. But as a member of the
Central Board of the World Ort Union
I visited this summer a number of D.P.
camps in Italy, Germany and Austria, and
I can report there is no similarity between
the two types. The D.P.'s live in military
barracks but they are not walled in to
prevent escape. The guards at the en-
trance are Jewish, and they are stationed
there merely to keep out intruders. The
internees have absolute freedom. They
come and go as they please, do what they
please and leave the camp whenever they
wish. (Many D.P.'s do leave daily, espe-
cially those between the ages of 17 to 3 5,
who join the Haganah.)
While the D.P. camps are a paradise
compared with the Nazi camps they are
hellish by comparison with normal living.
The D.P.'s get the equivalent of 1500 cal-
ories from the International Refugee Or-
ganization, and a supplementary ration of
500 calories from the Joint Distribution
Committee. They have enough % to keep
them from absolute malnutrition but not
enough to live healthfully. And the food
is unpalatable and not the kind they
would choose voluntarily. The living
quarters are, at best, one-room apartments
for three or more people. Many live in
dormitories which consist of large rooms
filled with cots.
•
I can best illustrate life in a D.P. camp
by describing conditions in three camps
in Northern Italy.
First I went to Cremona, about 80
miles from Milan. I was taken there by
Dr. Jaffe, director of ORT activities in
northern Italy, and we called on the IRO
officer in charge, Major O'Shaunessey, of
the British Army. In his office hung a
blackboard with statistical information
indicating that the number of inmates the
previous day was 1115 as against a pres-
ent figure of 1099. I asked what became
of the other 16. "They just disappeared,"
the Major replied. "They join the Haga-
nah." He then compared the Israel situ-
ation with the Irish rebellions against the
British, and went on: "You've got to ex-
pect that the able-bodied will leave to
fight." When I asked him how the
people in the camps got along he said,
"Those who want to go to Palestine or
elsewhere to start a new life, and pre-
serve a hope for the future are in the
ORT school."
Living conditions in this camp were
primitive, or worse — really shocking in
some aspects. Yet many babies were born
there — 70 up to the time I was there.
Many of the D.P.'s lived in dormitories.
At the back of the cots the internees
stored their few belongings. When they
went to bed a blanket was drawn around
the cot, and this was all the privacy the
married couples could get. Some had
"apartments" with walls made of card-
board papered with newspapers. In place
of a door was a curtain. When I ex-
pressed my shock at these conditions for
family living the officer said that after
existing for some time in this manner,
the internees practically lost all sense
of shame. The private rooms contained
cots, home-made tables and cook-stoves.
There were no chairs, the cots being used
for sitting. Some of the stoves were
outside the rooms. The appearance of
the rooms depended on the occupants
— some were as neat and clean as was
possible, others sloppy, the beds unmade
and things lying around.
Although the schools maintained by
ORT are free, and the courses taught ex-
cellent and adaptable for work in any
country, only about 10'/ of the internees
took advantage of them. They expected
that soon after their liberation they would
be taken to Palestine, or whatever land
By MAX HERZFELD
they wished to go, and since courses take
at least six months they believed they
would interfere with their leaving, or
that their training would be incomplete.
Other internees have become so dispirited
that they would rather sit around and do
nothing. ORT, of course demands a de-
gree of aptitude on the part of the stu-
dents and this cuts down some prospec-
tive attendance. To encourage ORT
study and to enable students to expend
the additional energy the work requires,
an' extra dole of the precious calories is
provided, and because this prize attracts
the poor, hungry inmates, a keen watch is
required to admit only those qualified for
ORT training.
•
At the Cremona camp I had a talk
with the head instructor, who told me
that he and his wife and two children
are alive today only through the kindness
of a priest. He was a native of Austria,
and when Hitler took over, he and his
family fled and finally landed in Italy.
One day the police came to him and said
there would be a round-up of Jews and
advised him to hide in the woods. For
two weeks the police brought food to this
family, and when it was deemed safe a
Catholic priest arrived, escorted them to
the Swiss border, and got them across.
The instructor said that many thousands
of Jews were rescued by the church, often
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
at the risk of the priests' or nuns' lives.
These humane deeds were characteristic
only of the church in Italy and France.
In Poland, this refugee said, the church
was no better than the people it served.
The next camp I visited was near
Turin, called Camp Rivoli. The director
of the ORT school there was anxious to
display the good work of his pupils, and
he had a good deal to boast about. He
was particularly proud of the courses in
building construction. The men were
learning bricklaying, plastering, plumb-
ing, tinsmithing, carpentering and almost
every craft that enters into building.
These students were being prepared for
emigration to Israel.
In this camp there were, officially, 1700
internees, but actually there were only
1400. 300 had joined the Haganah, but
because the food rationing was so pitifully
short the reduction of the population had
not been reported so that additional food
would be obtained by those remaining.
Vhen I first entered Camp Rivoli I
saw two signs over doors. One read:
Haganah, the other: Court. The chair-
man of the camp committee explained
to me the meaning of these signs, and
gave me a description of the manner in
which the camp was run. It was gov-
erned like a city. The population was
divided into as many political parties as
there are in Israel, and in addition, a
non-Zionist group. Each group held an
election and chose its leader. These
leaders selected from among themselves a
chairman, who was the head of the camp
government. The various leaders were
appointed heads of departments and
formed a cabinet. Under them were
committees to carry out the work as-
signed.
The Haganah committee was particu-
larly active when I was there. It was
after all the single men and the married
men without children. Those who re-
fused to enlist were dubbed traitors. One
of the excuses given for not enlisting was
attendance at the ORT school. The
Haganah committee then asked ORT to
bar such men. ORT took the position
that while it would not urge anyone eli-
gible to join Haganah to enter a class it
would not bar a man from attendance
once he had started a course. Everyone,
however, had made a contribution to
Haganah. Two months of supplemental
rations had been given up T sold, and the
proceeds turned over to the camp Haga-
nah committee.
There was a good deal of trading with-
in the camp, some persons selling soda,
cigarettes and postcards. There was even
a cafe where liquor and food were sold.
I was told the proceeds were donated to
the Haganah. The "stock" came from
THE MEANING OF ORT
^^RT (Organization for Reha-
^^bilitation Through Training),
is an organization, started in 1880
to help Jews wishing to escape from
a restricted existence in modern
ghettoes by teaching them trades
and agriculture and so enable them
to make, through their productive
efforts, a contribution to the econ-
omy of the country to which they
might emigrate.
ORT has the greatest potential
for the survival of Jewry. In the
D.P. camps, the internees are being
prepared to make a material contri-
bution to the development of Israel
through the skills they are taught
in the Ort schools, all of which are
peculiarly adapted for Palestine. In
Shanghai, Morocco, in North and
South America and in the countries
of Europe, ORT schools are train-
ing future leaders in industry and
commerce whose efforts will help
rehabilitate Jewry on a world-wide
scale. ,
In periods of greatest tragedy,
ORT has brought hope to the ref-
ugees from Nazi persecution in D.P.
camps. It has lifted the victims
from the depths of despair and has
opened for them vistas of a new
life in a new land where a skill ac-
quired in an ORT school brings a
visa and a welcome. In the new
home such skills make finding a job
easy and integrate the settler into
the economy of his new home.
— M. H.
packages sent from abroad. Inmates who
have no outside help at all are assigned
by a committee to work for the IRO at
a salary of 100 liras a day, approximately
18 cents.
Camp Rivoli has the highest birthrate,
averaging one baby ever}' 36 hours. There
were 300 children there, and wherever
you turned you saw baby carriages and
clotheslines with babv wash. The young-
sters looked well-fed and beautiful and
seemed bright. Many of the mothers
bartered food for things their babies
needed. The older children didn't look
too well. I saw a group of seven-year-
olds who appeared much younger because
they were under-nourished. They told
me they went to school, learned ivra,
arithemtic and other subjects. They were
old-young children, serious and resigned.
Another camp I went through was
Grugliasco. It was by far the best camp
I visited, a former military hospital. Un-
fortunately this camp had to be vacated
by the Jews, as were most of the North-
ern Italian camps. They were all being
converted into transitory depots mainly
for non-Jews selected for emigration.
The new camps, together with the ORT
schools, are moved to barracks farther
south, around Bari. The Italian govern-
ment has been extremely friendly and
cooperative.
Not all D. P.'s live in camps. There
are D. P.'s training at ORT schools in
Rome, for example. In one of them
there is a class for plane piloting. The
D.P.'s taking this course live in a beau-
tiful villa. These D.P.'s are an unusual
exception, for they are well fed and
clothed. Nothing is too good for them.
But the work they are learning is of
paramount importance. At Tivoli, not
far from Rome, ORT maintains an agri-
cultural school on a fair-sized farm.
The D.P. camps in Germany and
Austria are not much different from those
in Italy except that they are generally
larger and the physical conditions are
somewhat better. But the food, govern-
ment of the camp, occupations of the
internees and the Ort schools are similar
in character. The camps being larger,
the internees greater in number and Ort
operations having started sooner, the work
has progressed to a somewhat greater de-
gree.
All displaced persons, without excep-
tion, ask how soon they will be able to
leave. Many are demoralized through
their long stay and the frustration of
their hope of early departure, but the
hope of all is kept alive by the events in
Israel.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
SECUNDA'S COLORFUL CAREER
THERE was a time when Sholom
Secunda, the eminent music maker
and director of the Brooklyn Jewish
Center's music activities, was adventur-
ing in vaudeville and in the scarlet fields
of burlesque.
This enterprise was a rather odd pro-
gression for Secunda, for he began his
musical career as a cantorial prodigy. But
life has a way with us.
Some forty years ago the New York
Jewish community was startled by the
appearance of a young boy who had a
golden voice which he applied with skill
and unusually fine effect to synagogual
music. This was Sholom Secunda. He
was brought to this country from his
native Ukraine by Herman Wohl, the
choral leader, who intended him to be a
soloist with his choirs. But his voice was
far too good to waste on small matters,
so the boy was developed into a concert
artist, and toured American-Jewish com-
munities for three years. Then nature
asserted itself and put a stop to child ex-
ploitation by changing Sholom's voice.
Mr. Secunda says that he was very
happy when this happened, for he had
grown weary with commercialization and
wanted to lead a normal existence. So
beginning at 15 he settled down to a
home life, went to school, played with
the boys, and studied music seriously. His
ambition was to compose and conduct,
and he studied piano and theory at what
is now the Juilliard School of Music
and at Columbia University. He gradu-
ated a finished musician, but faced with
the problems of making a living he drifted
into vaudeville, and under the name of
Sam Secunda worked with various acts.
It was in this way that he got involved
with burlesque.
But the muse on high always haunted
Secunda, and while he was accompanying
vaudevillians in Philadelphia, the oppor-
tunity came to conduct a Salmaggi-like
opera troupe, calling itself the Philadel-
phia Opera Company. Secunda happily
left the variety stages and threw him-
self zealously into opera. He conducted
"Carmen," "II Travatore," "Traviata"
and "Rigoletto." How he missed "Pagli-
acci" and "Cavaleria Rusticana," he
doesn't know.
In Philadelphia, nostalgia led him to the
Arch Street Theatre, popular home of
Yiddish drama. There he met Anschell
Schorr, the theatre's manager, and Schorr
offered him a job at a higher salary than
the Italians paid him. A growing man,
he needed money, so he regretfully de-
tached himself from Verdi and Bizet.
Like all music masters, associated with
the Yiddish theatre, Secunda had to write
songs for the shows produced there as
well as conduct. His very first song for
Schorr was a hit — "Das Yiddishe Lied."
The second song was a hit too, "Yukel,"
which brought him $2,000 the first three
months via Jewish records.
At no time in his life had Secunda seen
so much money, so drunk with wealth he
went to Europe on a holiday. When he
returned his gains were in Continental
pockets and he had to return to his job.
Thus serious art had to be sidetracked
again.
But it was in the Yiddish threatre that
Sholom Secunda really found himself. He
turned out show after show with facility
and grace. Practically all the famous
Yiddish players have tapped his melodic
inspiration.
Of course, every one knows about "Bei
Mir Bist du Schein." In case everyone
doesn't, here is the true history of this
classic. In 1932 Secunda wrote the song
for a show produced in the Parkway
Theatre called "I Would If I Could," the
stars being Aaron Lebedeff and Leon
Blank. The song was prompted by a line
popular in the Secunda home. For some
By JOSEPH KAYE
reason not understandable to Secunda, his
wife had a habit of disparaging herself.
When this happened, her husband would
say, "Don't worry, kid — " (or some such
term) " — bei mir bist du schein 7"
The song became popular in Yiddish,
so much so that an obscure trio of Gen-
tile girls who sang around at Jewish af-
fairs learned to sing it in the mother
tongue and thereby increased their popu-
larity. Later they sang it in an English
version and so made it and themselves
famous. The girls were the Andrews
Sisters.
However, Secunda's profits from the
song were considerably curtailed because
he had sold it several years previously for
thirty dollars. No one would give him
more.
During one of his tours following this
emergence as a Broadway composer, Se-
cunda played in Philadelphia. An
elderly woman came to his dressing room
to pay her respects and told him she had
heard how little his song had earned for
him. "But through you I made more
than you did on 'Bei Mir Bist du Schein,' "
she said, and this was her story: A de-
partment store announced it had received
a shipment of "Bei Mir" records. There
was a rush to buy them, and in the crowd
was the elderly lady. Somebody knocked
her down, she hurt her leg, sued the store
and got a hundred dollars.
Today the Yiddish show business is
behind Sholom Secunda. Having achieved
all the distinction that that field can yield
him, he has returned to his first great love
— serious music. But this has now been
harmonized with all that he has learned
about Jewishness, and the result is a pro-
lific production of music based on liturg-
ical and folk themes. He has written a
Suite which has been performed over the
C.B.S. network and published by a lead-
ing house; a string quartet and symphony
have been performed, and the quartet re-
corded. He has also composed an opera.
Aside from his composing, Secunda lec-
tures extensively on Jewish music and
conducts choruses. He is a happy man
now, being able to truly serve himself
and at the same time serve his people.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
15
NEWS OF ISRAEL
THE Egyptian army in Palestine
seemed on the verge of being
knocked out as the Israeli soldiers
captured Beershcba and cut the Egyptian
supply lines. Only the roads held by King
Abdullah's Trans Jordan troops were open
to Egypt for communications, and Ad-
dullah is not on good terms with Egypt.
At this writing a truce was imposed by
the United Nations and Israel accepted it
conditional upon receiving official notifi-
cation that Egypt had ordered its army,
including irregulars, to cease fire.
The new outbreak of hostilities began
when Egypt broke the former truce (on
October 1 5 ) by attacking Israeli convoys
which were moving in the Negev in ac-
cordance with the U. N. decision opening
the roads to the Jews for 6 hours.
David Ben Gurian, Prime Minister and
Minister of War, congratulated the Israeli
commander of the Negev front for what
the world generally considers a remark-
able victory. The Israeli air force blasted
the Egyptian concentrations on a round-
the-clock schedule.
Meanwhile Israeli leaders expressed in-
dignation over Mediator Dr. Ralph
Bunche's report to the U. N. Council
which tended to place the responsibility
for the new hostilities on the Jews. In
New York, Representative Emanuel
Celler, on arriving after a month's trip
to Israel, accused Dr. Bunche of taking
"orders veiled as suggestions" from the
U. S. State Department. He also charged
John McDonald, U. S. Consul General at
Jerusalem, with an anti-Jewish bias, and
demanded he be recalled because of mis-
use of his office.
ft
It was learned here that the latest de-
velopment in the Negev is alarming
Egyptian Government leaders and has re-
sulted in consultations between Egyptian
delegation to the U. N. and the American
and British delegations. Egypt has ex-
pended in the five-month war and the
armed truce a total of 80 million pounds
($320,000,000), or four-fifths of its
scheduled revenue for this year.
The Cairo Government's first estimate
was that the war would cost 30 million
pounds ($120,000,000), and this was the
amount which Premier Nokrashi Pasha
asked in a secret meeting of the Egyptian
Senate on May 14, on the eve of the war
against Israel. The money was to be
drawn from Egypt's budgetary reserves.
At that session of the Senate the Premier
told the Senators that the war against
Israel would be over in two weeks, and
that he received assurances that neither
Britain nor the Security Council would
intervene during that period.
The Chief Engineer for the Jewish
Agency, Jacob Resier, recently arrived in
New York, revealed that plans have been
made to build 37,000 housing units in
Israel to accommodate the 120,000 im-
migrants expected in the next twelve
months. The cost has been estimated at
$64,000,000. Already there is a desper-
ate shortage of housing in Israel because
of immigrants already there. In Tel Aviv
an average of three persons live in one
room under present conditions.
ft
The Jewish National Fund's budget for
this year is 26,000,000 Israeli pounds
($104,000,000). Eighty percent of the
budget has been set aside for land re-
demption and 20 percent will be utilized
towards land recalmation.
ft
A military court investigating the
Sternist jailbreak in Jaffa this week found
a number of Military Police officers and
N. C. O.'s guilty of dereliction of duty
and ordered them dishonorably discharged
from the Israeli Army. The N. P.'s will
stand trial before a court martial. Ac-
cording to unofficial reports, the number
of persons involved in the court martial
will be 76.
The Communist newspaper Kol Haam
(Voice of the People) reported that the
Jewish Communist Party of Palestine and
the Arab League for National Liberation
had merged. In a joint declaration, the
paper reported, the two groups said that
the merged movement supports the U. N.
partition resolution, providing for the
establishment of two separate states in
Palestine bound together by economic
union.
ft
Representatives of the Chief Rabbinate,
the Jewish National Council and a num-
ber of religious organizations met in Jeru-
salem to discuss the "position of religion
in the framework of the State of Israel."
A number of the speakers complained that
the influence of the Jewish religion was
not yet being felt in the government ma-
chinery, the proposed constitution or ex-
isting legislation. A committee of three,
headed by Rabbi Meir Berlin, Mizrachi
leader, was appointed to work out pro-
posals for changing the situation.
A Cabinet committee, dealing with
preparations for the first parliamentary
elections to be held in Israel, has sub-
mitted a recommendation to the Cabinet
ISRAEL'S FLAG
A special committee of experts, desig-
nated to recommend an official Israeli flag,
announced that it had decided on the fol-
lowing pattern for the Jewish state's em-
blem: A white background with two
blue stripes on both the right and left
sides and with the Shield of David in the
center.
The Israeli crest would be a gray Chan-
ukah lamp with seven branches against
a blue background and containing seven
Herzl stars. At the bottom right would
be a Shofar while at the bottom left
would be the traditional Esrog (citron)
and palm branch. The committee of ex-
perts is headed by Prof. Eliezier Sukenik.
to set December 15 as the date of the
elections. The proposal must be approved
by the State Council.
ft
The intention of the State of Israel to
claim Western Galilee, Jerusalem and a
territorial link between Tel Aviv and
Jerusalem was reiterated in Paris by Israeli
Foreign Minister Moshe Shertok, speaking
at a reception tendered him by the French
Zionist Federation.
Shertok asserted that the Israeli Gov-
ernment will also make every effort to re-
tain the Negev. He stressed the import
ance of Israel's establishing a definite
settlement with the Middle East states.
"We have representatives in Moscow,
Prague, Washington, etc.," he stated,
"and we must have representatives in
Cairo, Damascus and Bagdad — and we
will have them."
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
— NEWS OF THE CENTER
Late Friday Night Lecture Services
To Begin Next Friday Evening
Members are reminded that our late
Friday Night Lecture Services will be re-
sumed for this season next Friday evening,
November 5th at 8:30 o'clock. Rabbi
Levinthal will preach the opening ser-
mon and will discuss "The Problem of
the Dissident Groups in the New State
of Israel."
Cantor Sauler will lead in the congre-
gational singing and render a vocal selec-
tion. Members and friends are cordially
invited.
Institute of Jewish Studies
For Adults Now Open
The opening assembly of the Institute
of Jewish Studies for Adults was held on
Thursday evening, October 28th at 8:30
o'clock. Rabbi Levinthal, Rabbi Saltz-
man and Dr. Reuben Finkelstein, who is
chairman of the committee on Adult
Jewish Education, greeted the assembly.
The courses being given this season are
Conversational Hebrew, Bible, Prayer
Book, Religion, Jewish History, Talmud
and Yiddish. Courses are given on Tues-
day and Wednesday evenings as well as on
Wednesday mornings. Those who are in-
terested and who have not as yet regis-
tered are asked to do so at once.
Sisterhood Board Meeting Nov. 9th
The next meeting of the Executive
Board of the Sisterhood will be held on
Monday afternoon, November 8th at 1
o'clock. Members of the Board are urged
to attend and to come early.
Federation Dinner Nov. 18th
The annual Brooklyn Jewish Center
dinner on behalf of the Federation of
Jewish Philanthropies will be held on
Thursday evening, November 18th at
6:30 o'clock. Federation's goal in this
year's campaign is $16,5 00,000.00 and
we hope that Center members will do
their share in helping to make the cam-
paign a huge success. Please make your
reservations immediately at the office of
the Center. Subscription is $6.50 per
person.
S. O. S. Campaign
For Canned Goods
The record-breaking community S.O.S.
campaigns have enabled the JDC, for the
time being, to catch up on its used cloth-
ing requirements. The facilities of the
S. O. S. national warehouse will be stream-
lined to concentrate on the processing of
canned foods, infant layettes, and new
clothing. Please bring these articles to
the Center.
Junior Club Activities
The Junior clubs of the Center began
their activities on Saturday night, Octo-
ber 16th. The clubs are directly affili-
ated with National Young Judea and are
being led by a very competent and able
staff of leaders under the supervision of
Rabbi Manuel Saltzman in a program
of cultural, social and gymnasium activi-
ties. The following is a list of the groups
and their respective leaders; Shomrim —
Joseph Aaron; Tzofim — Judah Adelson;
Maccabees — William Rosenthal; Viialefs
— Lila Cohen; Candle-Li tcs — Ruth Gal ad.
Alvin Goldberg is in charge of the ath-
letic activities and I. Adolph is in charge
of swimming. Mr. Leo Shpall is advisor
of the Junior club division.
Children of Center members, pupils in
our Hebrew School, Sunday School and
Center Academy are cordially invited to
join a club.
Girl Scout Troops
Brooklyn Jewish Center Girl Scout
Troops No. 128 and 159 have been meet-
ing since early in September. They are
being led by Mrs. J. Stenzler, Mrs. E.
Wiles, Miss Betty Marlin and Mrs. Berger.
These troops will celebrate Girl Scout
Week by joining the Junior Congregation
Services on Saturday, October 30th which
has been designated as Girl Scout Sabbath.
Members of the troops are urged to at-
tend this important assembly of the Girl
Scouts.
Congratulations
Hearty congratulations and best
wishes are extended to Mr. and Mrs. Alex
Bernstein of 1503 President Street on the
Bar Mitzvah of their grandson, Richard
Bernstein, on October 16, 1948.
Junior Congregation and
Hebrew School Notes
The Junior Congregation held impres-
sive services in the Beth Ha-Midrash dur-
ing the Rosh Ha-Shonah and Yom Kippur
holidays. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes
officiated. The Chazanim were Herbert
Kummel and Buddy Lowenfeld. The
Shofar was blown by Mr. Irwin Rubin
and Arthur Viders. The Torah was read
by Lloyd Altman. Robert Kritz assisted
as Chazan. Bernard Epworth, Jerry Mach-
lis and Daniel Klinghoffer served as Ga-
baim. Summaries of the Law were given
by Julia Heimowitz, Jeanette Flamm,
Helen Aronow, Ruth Klinghoffer and
Toby Brown. Prayers for the Govern-
ment were read by Frieda Cohen and
Shirley Aronow.
The Hebrew and Religious Schools
now have the largest registration in the
history of the Brooklyn Jewish Center.
317 Students are enrolled in the 3-day-a-
week department of the Hebrew School;
296 students are enrolled in the Religious
School.
The faculty of the Hebrew School for
the current year consists of the following:
Principal, Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes.
Teachers, Jean Serbin Beder, Samuel
Edelheit, George Epstein, Irving
Gabel, Rebecca Rosenstein, Paula
Weinreb, Leo Shpall, Evelyn Zus-
man, Nechama Cohen, Selma Man-
dell.
Registrar, Mrs. E. N. Rabinowitz. Sec-
retary, Mrs. F. K. Eisenberg.
The following are members of the Re-
ligious School faculty:
Judith Abelson, A. Alter, Jacob Gru-
met, Lila Cohen, Mildred Mogilensky,
Dora Muhlbauer, Rebecca Rosenstein,
Irwin Rubin, Laura Sorscher, Hannah
Wiedman, Bertha Wiener, Mrs. Laura
Rubin, Seymour Wadler.
Musical Director — Sholom Secunda.
A new class, called the Senior Group,
has been added to the High School depart-
ment. This class, under the direction of
Mr. Irwin Rubin, is made up of students
enrolled in the 3rd or 4th year of public
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
high school who would like an opportu-
nity to continue their study of Jewish
history and literature. Students to be eli-
gible must have completed one of the
preliminary departments of our School.
Other classes in the High School depart-
ment are the Post-Graduate Hebrew class
for graduates of the Hebrew School and
Center Academy; the Consecration class
for graduates of the Religious School and
the Post-Bar Mitzvah class for boys who
have been confirmed and who wish to
continue their study of Bible and Jewish
history. ^
Junior Congregation
The Junior Congregation will cele-
brate Girl Scout Sabbath on Saturday,
October 30th by dedicating their services
to the Girl Scouts of America and to the
pupils of the Brooklyn Jewish Center
schools. A kiddush has been arranged by
Mr. and Mrs. Leo Kaufmann in honor of
the marriage of their daughter.
Acknowledgment of Gifts
We acknowledge with thanks receipt
of donations for the purchase of Prayer
Books and Taleisim from the following:
Mr. and Mrs. Charles S. Feinberg in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their son,
Bernard Melvin.
Mr. and Mrs. Harry A. Freedman in
honor of the birth of a grandson, Andrew
Jonathan Branower.
Additions to Library
The following books have been added
to our library and are in circulation:
"Trial of the Major War Criminals Be-
fore International Military Tribunal,"
Vol. I - XXVI— Nuremberg.
"Under the Fig Tree" — Yitzhak Schen-
berg.
"The Young Lions" — Irwin Shaw
"The Gangster Isaac Babel" — Benya Krik.
"Chekov and His Russia" — W. H. Bin-
ford.
"Days of Awe" — S. Y. Agnon.
"Destination Palestine" — Ruth Gruber.
"Germany: What Now?" — Joachim
Joestin.
"I Learn From Children" — Caroline Pratt.
"Intruder in the Dust" — Herbert Faulk-
ner.
"I Was a Doctor in Auschwitz — Gisella
Peil.
"The Maccabees" — Elias Bickerman.
"Science Advances" — J. B. S. Haldane.
"The Birth of Israel" — Jorges Garcia
Granados.
"The Tower of Terzel" — Pierre Van Pas-
sen.
"The Crusaders" — Stefan Heym.
"Russian Literature Since the Revolution"
— Edited — Jushua Kunitz.
"Lost Stage Galley" — Frank Bonham.
"The Masquerade in Spain" — Charles
Folty, Jr.
"Nobody's Fool" — Charles Yale Harrison.
"The Old Beauty and Others" — Willa
Cather.
"One Clear Call" — Upton Sinclair.
"Palestine, Land of Israel" — Herbert Son-
nenfeld.
"Peony" — Pearl S. Buck.
"Roads to Zion" — Kurt Wilhelm.
"Sex Laws and Customs in Judaism" —
Louis M. Epstein.
"My Glorious Brother" — Howard Fast.
Young Folks League
Election Night Social
The Young Folks League of the Center
is planning a social for its members On
Tuesday evening, November 2nd (Flec-
tion Night). A very enjoyable evening
is in store and members are cordially in-
vited. This affair is open strictly to
members — no guests or friends will be
admitted.
Young Folks League Lecture Series
The Young Folks League is sponsoring
a series of six lectures which will be given
in two phases of three each. The first
lecture of series A will be given on Tues-
day evening, November 9th and the sec-
ond lecture will be delivered on Novem-
ber 16th. More detailed information re-
garding this series will be announced at
a later date. Open only to members, no
exception will be made for friends or
guests.
Sabbath Services
Friday evening services at 5:00.
Kindling of candles at 4:37 p.m.
Sabbath services, Parsha "Bereshit" —
Genesis 1.1-6.8, Prophets Isaiah 42.5-
43.11 will commence at 8:45 a.m.
Mincha services at 5:00.
Rabbi Levinthal will preach on the
weekly portion of the law.
Rabbi Saltzman will deliver the lec-
ture in Yiddish this Saturday afternoon
at 4:00 p.m.
Daily Services
Morning services at 8:00 o'clock.
Mixcha services at 5:00 P.M.
Personal Request From
Rabbi Levinthal
Rabbi Levinthal, who has accepted an
appointment this year as Visiting Profes-
sor of Homiletics at the Jewish Theolog-
ical Seminary in New York, will give his
lectures to the students on Thursday
mornings from 11 A.M. to 1 P.M. The
rabbi therefore requests members who
may desire appointments with him, or
may require his services on Thursdays, to
please arrange such appointments on
Thursday afternoons and not in the morn-
ing.
Junior League
The next meeting of the Junior League
scheduled for Thursday evening, Novem-
ber 4th will be in the form of an Qpen
Meeting. Members of the League and
their friends are invited.
Inta-League Boys and Girls
Clubs Start Season
The Inta-League Boys and Girls Clubs
have opened this season with two very
fine programs. Election of officers will
take place shortly. Plans for future
meetings will include programs outlined
by the Inta-Leaguers themselves under
the guidance of the leaders, Mrs. Laura
Rubin, Mr. Herbert Kummel and Mr.
Irvin I. Rubin, Director of the Senior
Youth Groups. Cultural, social and ath-
letic activities are part of the Inta-League
program. All children of Center mem-
bers and students in our Religious Schools
and Center Academy who are in the last
two years of High School are cordially
invited to attend the meetings which are
held every Saturday night at 8:15 o'clock.
Unveiling of Levy Monument
The unveiling of a monument in mem-
ory of Harry Levy will be held on Sun-
day afternoon, November 7th at 2 o'clock
at the Mt. Judah Cemetery, Block 2, Sec-
tion 6 (Moskowitz Plot).
Night of Stars Performance
To Aid U. J. A.
Tickets for the "Night of Stars"
which will be held on November 15 th at
the Madison Square Garden, may be ob-
tained from Mrs. K. I. Ostow, 5 23 Crown
Street. SL 6 2842.
Congratulations
Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Shevlowitz of 12
Crown Street on the engagement of their
daughter, Seena Sheldon, to Mr. Ira Solo-
mon.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Aaron, Joseph H.
Res. 916 Carroll Sc.
Bus. Teacher, P. S. 175
Married
Proposed by Irvin I. Rubin,
Dr. Samuel T. Markoff
Alterman, Montague T.
Res. 789 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Attorney, 160-16 Jamaica Ave.
Married, Proposed by Joseph Richman,
Frank Schaeffer
Ba&ashick., Miss Florence
Res. 42a Hampton Place
Proposed by Samuel Kamenetzky,
Louis J. Roth
Beckenstein, Norman
Res. 1592 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. 1592 St. Marks Ave.
Single
Bernstein, Miss Lillian
Res. 1574 Union St.
Chalef, Jerome
Res. 303 E. 94th St.
Bus. Acct., 303 E. 94th St.
Single
Proposed by Hyman Rosen,
Sol Rosen
Chalef, Morton M.
Res. 303 E. 94th St.
Bus. Chemist, 127th St. & 3rd Ave.
College Pt.
Single
Proposed by Hyman Rosen,
Sol Rosen
Cohen, Miss Bernice
Res. 1054 Eastern Parkway
Cohen, Miss Elinore
Res. 8305 — 21st Ave.
Proposed by Hyman Bloomgarden,
Marilyn Kobre
Cohen, Irving
Res. 1571 Lincoln Place
Bus. Auto Carburetors, 86-50 Queens
Boulevard
Married
Proposed by Sam Schoenfeld,
William Mintz
Cohen, Saris
Res. 3 5 Hampton Place
Bus. Asst. Principal, J.H.S. No. 49
Married
Proposed by Morris C. Finkcl
Cohn, Harry
Res. 919 Park Place
Bus. Telephone Serv., 45 Snyder Ave.
Single
Proposed by Dr. Irving Horowitz
Dr. Felix Horowitz
Deutsch, Miss Elaine M.
Res. 1602 W. 10th St.
Ehrenpreis, Rudolph
Res. 302 Eastern Parkway
Bus. Bindery, 61 Beekman St.
Married
Ehrlich, Miss Muriel
Res. 763 Greene Ave.
Elliot, Miss Lily
Res. 2067 E. 1st St.
Proposed by Pearl Person,
Minnie S. Cutler
Feldman, David
Res. 760 Montgomery St.
Bus. 481 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Hyman Zimmerman,
Helen Wiener
Fishkoff, Miss Evelyn
Res. 5110— 19th Ave.
Proposed by Pearl Person,
Minnie S. Cutler
Fine, Dr. Isidor
Res. 683 Montgomery St.
Bus. Physician, 683 Montgomery St.
Married
Folander, Miss Jean
Res. 25 3 Stockton St.
Proposed by Celayne Lane,
Helen Feldman
Friedman, Miss Doris
Res. 1563 St. Johns Place
Proposed by Judith Ziman,
Dr. Alexander LefT
Friedman, Miss Jessie
Res. 329a Crown St.
Galmitz, Aaron
Res. 1025 St. Johns Place
Bus. Pharmacy, 780 Gates Ave.
Married
Proposed by Harry B. Weseley,
Louis J. Weseley
Gartenberg, Samuel B.
Res. 474 Brooklyn Ave.
Bus. Tax Assessor, Municipal Bldg.,
Brooklyn
Married
Proposed by Louis Weiss,
Charles Rubenstein
Gelles, Miss Lucy
Res. 936 St. Marks Ave.
Gerson, Jules
Res. 934 Carroll St.
Bus. Jeweler, 126 W. 46th St.
Married
Proposed by Judge Emanuel Greenberg
Goldberg, Miss Sylvia
Res. 409 Georgia Ave.
Proposed by Florence Gallant,
Minnie S. Cutler
Goldman, Miss Ruth E.
Res. 1690 Union St.
Goldstein, Samuel A.
Res. 270 Crown St.
Bus. Teacher, Bryant H. S.
Married
Proposed by Joseph Levy, Jr.,
Nathaniel H. Jackson
Gottfried, Miss Celia
Res. 133 Penn St.
Proposed by Marilyn Kobre,
Abe Mann
Groman, Miss Blanche
Res. 496 Hinsdale St.
Proposed by Samuel Babbitt,
Samuel Margolis
Haas, Charles
Res. 2375 Ocean Ave.
Bus. New York Daily Mirror
Single
Proposed by Gerald Jacobs,
Philip Jacobs
Hobish, Harry
Res. 705 Avenue L
Bus. Electrical Com., 424 Foster Ave.
Married
Proposed by Hyman Aaron,
Joseph Goldberg
Horowitz, Albert
Res. 750 LefTerts Ave.
Bus. Paper, 74 Bushwick Ave.
Married
Proposed by Sol Horowitz,
Irving S. Horowitz
Hurwitz, Bernard
Res. 1409 Carroll St.
Bus. Dress Mfg., 530 — 7th Ave.
Married
Proposed by
Irving Chalkin
Jaffe, Daniel
Res. 12 5 5 E. 27th St.
Bus. Adv. Mgr., 68 Cortlandt St.
Single
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
19
Proposed by Samuel Shapiro,
Joel Sugar
Jefffr, Alvin M.
Res. 437 E. 56th St.
Bus. Jeffer Funeral Parlor
Married
Proposed by Louis J. Gribetz,
Abe Feldman
Kahn, Dr. Julius J.
Res. 4 E. 56th St.
Bus. Dentist, 1045 Eastern Parkway
Married
Proposed by Dr. Irvin Sparer,
Louis Kotimsky
Karch, Dr. Morris
Res. S618 Beverly Road
Bus. Dentist, 620 Osborn St.
Married
Proposed by Bernard Gartner
Katz, Bernard H.
Res. 1 5 5 5 Lincoln Place
Single
Kaufman, Alfred
Res. P.O.B. #31, Mitchel Field, N. Y.
Bus. Air Force Officer
Single
Kimmel, Dr. Philip R.
Res. 30 E. 91st St.
Bus. Dentist
Single
Proposed by Abraham Kimmel
Kosofsky, Miss Harriet
Res. 591 Dumont Ave.
Proposed by Pearl Jablin,
Clair Sorotsky
Lapayower, Miss Pearl
Res. 1030 Park Place
Proposed by Harold Sobelman
Leifer, Miss Evelyn
Res. 1420 E. 4th St.
Proposed by Irving Lerner,
Henry Lee Poyta
Lemberger, Jacob
Res. 1040 Carroll St.
Bus. J. N. F., 41 E. 42nd St.
Married
Levine, Aaron
Res. 1367 Sterling Place
Bus. Fluor. Mfg., 40 W. 2 5th St.
Single
Proposed by Seymour Glass,
Murray Segal
Levine, Miss Tessie
Res. 1134 Blake Ave.
Proposed by Hyman Rosen,
Sam Schiffman
Lipman, Isidore
Res. 751 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Trucking, 307 W. 3 8th St.
Married
Proposed by William Doblin
Lobel, Miss Carol
Res. 526 Williams Ave.
Proposed by Samuel Babbit,
Samuel Margolis
Lobll, Miss Florence
Res. 526 Williams Ave.
Proposed by Samuel Babbit,
Samuel Margolis
Lustig, Gerald I.
Res. 22 5 Buffalo Ave.
Bus. Acct., 20 Exchange Place
Single
Meister, J.
Res. 632 Montgomery St.
Bus. Fur Mcht., 151 W. 29th St.
Married
Proposed by Harry A. Klein
Mushin, Mrs. Della
Res. 1015 Washington Ave.
Widow
Proposed by Alter B. Belfer,
Isidore Fein
Nash, Samuel S.
Res. 80 New York Ave.
Bus. Steel, 1722 Linden Blvd.
Married
NUSSENBLATT, MlSS PHYLLIS
Res. 743 Empire Blvd.
Proposed by Philip Ginsberg,
Aaron Dershowitz
Orent, Herman
Res. 3 50 Lincoln Place
Bus. Mfg., 36 W. 42nd St.
Married
Proposed by Leo Kaufmann,
Aaron Dershowitz
Pollard, Joseph
Res. 297 Lenox Road
Bus. Paper Dist., 110 Classon Ave.
Married
Proposed by Isaac Schrier
Raistacher, Miss Arlene
Res. 518 Montgomery St.
Ratner, Miss Mildred
2153a Bay Ridge Parkway
Robinson, Mrs. Sadie
Res. 712 Crown St.
Widow
Rosenberg, Miss Rita
Res. 487 Vermont St.
Proposed by Clair Sorotsky,
Pearl Jablin
ROSENBLUM, ABNER
Res. 780 St. Marks \ve.
Bus. Teacher, L. I. H. S.
Married
Proposed by Mildred G. Zwerdling,
Israel I. Cohen
Rothman, Herbert L.
Res. 770 Empire Blvd.
Bus. Restaurant, 110 W. 42nd St.
Single
Proposed by Jerome J. Weiner,
David Gold
Rothstein, Stanley K.
Res. 2 53 Montgomery St.
Bus. Mfg., 433 Broadway
Single
Proposed by Samuel Shapiro,
Joel Sugar
Schachter, Miss Renee
Res. 1245 Eastern Parkway
SCHECHTER, MlSS LlNDA
Res. 1986 Strauss St.
Proposed by Gerald Jacobs,
Muriel Oginz
Scharf, Miss Florence C.
Res. 43 2 Stone Ave.
Schmilowitz, Miss Ruth
Res. 191a Utica Ave.
Proposed by Philip Ginsberg,
Aaron Dershowitz
Schwartz, Miss Anne
Res. 3109 Brighton 7th St.
Schwartz, Harold
Res. 240 Crown St.
Bus. Textiles, 5 6 Worth St.
Married
Proposed by Sidney H. Brown,
L. H. Berman
Scfiwartz, Seymour
Res. 776 Crown St.
Bus. Zippers, 32 W. 2 3 rd St.
Single
Proposed by Gerald Jacobs,
Harold Jacobs
ScHWIMMER, ALDEN
Res. 186 Crown St.
Bus. Announcer, 117 W. 46th St.
Single
Proposed by Samuel Shapiro,
Joel Sugar
Silverman, Abner
Res. 168 Pulaski St.
Bus. Lawyer, 132 Nassau St.
Single
Proposed by Bernard Meyerowitz,
Leo Chizner
[Continued on page 21]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
AGING
ISTERHOOD
As your President, I am glail to inaugurate a Sisterlwod page in the
Reviext which will, report items of interest to our women. We feel that
this medium will publicize Sisterhood's achievements and its activities and
that our women will he stimulated to greater cooperation. Make Sister-
l>ood a habit. All wives of Center members are automatically Sisterhood
members ami as such are eligible to attend our meetings. Watch the
Review and the Weekly Bulletins for announcements.
— Mrs. Morton Klinghoffer.
Our General Meeting:
AFTER a beautiful opening prayer
by Sarah Epstein, Ethel Pashenz
sang the National Anthem and
Hatikvah, Bea Schaeffer, Recording Sec-
retary, read the minutes of the previous
meeting and our President, Sarah Kling-
hoffer, gave a summary of the business at
hand. A fine message by Rabbi Levin-
thai opened the path for a year of note-
worthy programs and accomplishments by
Sisterhood. Our Cultural Chairman, Mrs.
Mildred Levine, then introduced Mr.
Richard Harvey, singing star of the late
Broadway success, "Ballet Ballads." His
songs were an unusual treat and we wish
more of you could have enjoyed them
with us.
Rabbi Manuel Saltzman delivered a re-
view of "Peony," Pearl Buck's provoca-
tive novel of Jewish life in China. His
enlightening and dramatic portrayal car-
ried us right into the setting of the story,
which left all of us highly stimulated and
thoughtful.
The evening closed with a pleasant so-
cial hour, and our usual delicious refresh-
ments. We would like to have all our
women attend and enjoy these monthly
meetings.
The Board Meeting:
Mrs. Abrams, representative of Federa-
tion of Jewish Philanthropies, outlines the
urgency of raising funds and lending as-
sistance to its drive.
The following women will represent us
as delegates to the Eastern Parkway Com-
munity Council: Mrs. Ruth Bernhardt,
Mrs. Sarah Klinghoffer, Mrs. Shirley
Gluckstein, Mrs. Nathan Dvorkin, Mrs.
Lillie Zakhem, Mrs. Etta Goldstein.
Our Women in the News:
Mrs. Dorothy Marvin, daughter of Mr.
and Mrs. Isaac Wiener, has been appointed
President of Sisterhood of the new Amity-
ville Jewish Center. Best wishes to her
for a term of office that will be fruitful
to both Mrs. Marvin and our Jewish way
of life.
At this writing, our Mrs. Sophie Gin-
guld is in Israel. We know her trip will
be most educational and satisfying.
Mrs. Anna Witty, former Sisterhood
President, is equally active in the affairs
of the Lynbrook Jewish Center.
Mrs. Shirley Gluckstein, our SOS
Chairman, has been doing a tremendous
job in this capacity and it has been due
to her tenacity and drive that our Center
leads the country in this fine work.
Won't you take a hint and pitch in to
help her in this most necessary job?
The following women will represent
Sisterhood at the annual convention of
Women's League at Atlantic City: Sarah
Klinghoffer, Ruth Bernhardt, Lilian
Lowenfeld, Rose Weiner and Kate Salit.
Cheer Fund Donor List
In memory of Aunt .. Mrs. Molly Meyers
In memory of Parents Morris Brukenfeld
In memory of Louis Teitlebaum
Mrs. Harriet Roth
In memory of Mother Mrs. Bea Schaeffer
In honor of Daughter's marriage
Mrs. Ruth Bernhardt
In honor of Son's marriage . . Mrs. Harriet Roth
In honor of Daughter's marriage
Mrs. Sadie Kaufmann
In honor of Grandson . Mrs. Gertrude Ostow
In honor of Grandchild .. Mrs. A. L. Goldman
For Mrs. Simon's speedy recovery
Mrs. Kate Salit
For Mrs. Simon's speedy recovery
Mrs. David Halpern
For General Good Cheer Mrs. Shirley Gluckstein
Committee Reports:
MOTHER - DAUGHTER LUNCH-
EON: A report of this event will appear
next month.
SOS-OVERSEAS AID: Shirley Gluck-
stein tells us to hold off on clothing but
to contribute canned food and baby lay-
ettes. Also — Mrs. Gluckstein sends out
an SOS for "assistants" and "assistance."
President
Vice-President
Vice-President
Vice-President
Treasurer
Recording Secretary
FEDERATION: Mrs. Lillie Levy,
Chairman. Luncheon at the Hotel St.
George on December 7th. Sisterhood will
cooperate.
NIGHT OF STARS: Mrs. Gertrude
Ostow, Chairman. Most of her tickets
have been sold. Those wishing to attend
the United Jewish Appeal Annual Night
of Stars Show at Madison Square Garden
on November 15th, should call her im-
mediately. (SL 6-2842.)
Meet Our ISeiv Officers
Mrs. Morton Klinghoffer
Mrs. Morris B. Levine
Mrs. M. Robert Epstein
Mrs. Joseph Levy, Jr.
Mrs. Hyman Rachmil
Mrs. Frank Schaeffer .
Mrs. Benjamin H. Wisner Corresponding Secretary
Mrs. Harry Zakhem Social Secretary
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Mrs. Saul Abelov Mrs. Joseph Horowitz
Mrs. George Altman Mrs. Samuel Katz
Mrs. Maurice Bernhardt Mrs. Leo Kaufmann
Mrs. Alex Bernstein Mrs. Harry Klaristenfeld
Mrs. Paul Barnett Mrs. Julius Kushner
Mrs. Elias Bernstein Mrs. Sidney Leonard
Mrs. Fanny Buchman Mrs. Benjamin Levitt
Mrs. Harry Berman Mrs. Isador Lowenfeld
Mrs. Charles Dilbert Mrs. Benjamin Markowe
Mrs. Nathan Dvorkin Mrs. Lawrence Meyer
Mrs. Isidor Fine Mrs. Solomon H. Mitrani
Mrs. David Fishman Mrs. Kalman I. Ostow
Mrs. Ida Fried Mrs. Herman J. Pashenz
Mrs. Samuel Fleishman Mrs. Louis J. Roth
Mrs. Simon Goldstein Mrs. Harris Salit
Mrs. Ira Gluckstein Mrs. William I. Siegel
Mrs. Irene Goodman Mrs. Louis Simon
Mrs. Emanuel Greenberg Mrs. Samuel Stark
Mrs. Alfred Greenblatt Mrs. Isaac Wiener
Mrs. Joseph Heimowitz Mrs. Albert Witty
Mrs. Irving S. Horowitz Mrs. Louis Zankel
Mrs. Abraham H. Zirn
Honorary Presidents
Mrs. Joseph Horowitz Mrs. Albert Witty
Mrs. Phillip Brenner Mrs. Isador Lowenfeld
Mrs. Maurice Bernhardt
Honorary Directors
Mrs. Maurice Bernhardt Mrs. Louis J. Levinson
Mrs. Phillip Brenner Mrs. Israel H. Levinthal
Mrs. Hannah Greenblatt Mrs. Isador Lowenfeld
Mrs. David Halpern Mrs. Samuel Rottenberg
Mrs. Joseph Horowitz Mrs. Albert Witty
Calendar of Events
October 30: Kiddush to the Junior
Congregation by Mrs. Leo Kaufmann in
honor of her daughter's marriage.
November 8: Sisterhood Board meeting
at 1:00 P. M.
November 22: General membership
meeting at 1:00 P. M. Jane Miller, noted
soprano, will be heard in an original opera-
logue of Gian-Menotti's "Medium and
the Telephone."
Suggestion Box
Sisterhood encourages its members to
submit any recommendations, suggestions,
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
21
advice and criticism. It would be nice
to get ideas from all our ladies.
The following have been appointed to
these committees:
Publication — Mrs. Shirley Gluckstcin, Mrs. Mary
Kaplan, Mrs. Sarah Klinghoffer.
Program — Mrs. Sarah Epstein, Mrs. Lila Leonard,
Mrs. Mildred Lcvinc.
Current Events — Mrs. Eleanor Horowitz, Mrs. Bea-
trice Schaeflfer, Mrs. Bertha Zirn.
Social Staff — Mrs. Ethel Abclow, Mrs. Mary Kap-
lan, Mrs. Sadie Kaufmann, Mrs. Jenny Levine,
Mrs. Ethel Pashenz, Mrs. Irene Perlin, Mrs.
Lillie Zakhcm.
Cheer Fund — Mrs. Lillie Zakhem.
S O S— Mrs. Shirley Gluckstein.
Fed. Jewish Phil— Mrs. Lillie Levy.
U. }. A.— Mrs. Ruth Bernhardt, Mrs. Gcrt Heimo-
witz, Mrs. Lilian Lowcnfeld.
Women's League — Mrs. Ruth Bernhardt, Mrs.
Sarah Epstein, Mrs. Sarah Klinghoffer, Mrs.
Lilian Lowenfeld, Mrs. Mollie Markowe, Mrs.
Rose Weincr.
Mother-Daughter Luncheon — Mrs. Sarah Epstein,
Mrs. Lillie Levy, Mrs. Dorothy Wisner.
Fed. Jewish Women's Org. — Mrs. Rose Horowitz,
Mrs. Beatrice SchacrTcr, Mrs. Rose Weincr.
Religious — Mrs. Fanny Buchman, Mrs. Sarah Ep-
stein, Mrs. Sadie Kaufmann, Mrs. Sarah Kush-
ncr, Mrs. Mildred Levine, Mrs. Lillian Lowen-
feld, Mrs. Hattie Roth.
Night of Stars — Mrs. Gertrude Ostow.
Zeiger, David
Res. 104 St. iMarks Avenue
Bus. Education, New Utrecht H. S.
Single
Additional Reinstatements:
Gottlieb, Saul
Res. 481 Schenectady Ave.
Bus. Paper, 470 Osborn St.
Married
Proposed by Morton Klinghoffer,
Joseph Goldberg
Shapiro, Alexander
Res. 603 Lcffcrts Ave.
Bus. Plbs. Spec, 68 Jay St.
Married
Proposed by Abe Mann
Samuel H. Goldberg,
Chairman, Membership Committee.
Congregational Singing Group
Last year the Center launched a
unique project, the Congregational Sing-
ing Group, whose function was to assist
our worshipers in the singing of Sabbath
and Holiday prayers.
The Group, now under the leadership
of Mr. Sholom Secunda, will participate
in the services on Saturday morning, Oc-
tober 30th and will continue throughout
the season.
A MODEL HOME
LIBRARY
RABBI LOUIS HAMMER, well-known
in our community, has developed the
idea of interesting people in the impor-
tance of establishing the beginnings of
a model Jewish library, in their homes.
He has compiled a list of about 2 5 vol-
umes, the most important in the fields
of Jewish history, religion, Bible, liturgy,
Talmud, Zionism, folk-lore and other
volumes.
These are well chosen and represent im-
portant contributions in their respective
fields. They certainly will help to make
the home an abode of Jewish culture, and
will give all members of the family a
knowledge of the fundamentals of Jewish
life and thought. Rabbi Hammer's selec-
tion includes alternate choices, so that
the works may conform to special tastes
and interests in Jewish literature.
—I. H. L.
APPLICATIONS
[Continued
Spieliogel, Morris J.
Res. 1621 St. Johns Place
Bus. Student
Single
Steiner, Miss Pauline
Res. 5 52 Pennsylvania Ave.
Proposed by Hyman Rosen,
Herbert Altneu
Wallerstein, Mrs. Irene
Res. 204 E. 52nd St.
Widow
Proposed by Dr. Max Goldstein
Weissberger, Miss Ruth
Res. 777 Eastern Parkway
Proposed by Samuel Kamenetzky,
Louis J. Roth
Willen, Michael J.
Res. 1647 Union St.
Bus. Real Estate, 13 5 Broadway
Married
Proposed by Milton J. Goell,
Selig J. Harrison
Winkler, Miss Rhea
Res. 1054 Park Place
Zwicher, Miss Minna
Res. 1030 Park Place
Proposed by Harold Sobelman
The following have applied for rein-
statement:
Albert, Joseph
Res. 57 Lincoln Road
Bus. Chain Stores, 15 5-26 Jamaica
Ave.
Married
Naidich, Miss Rose
Res. 418 Georgia Ave.
Proposed by Hyman Rosen,
Sam Schiffman
SCH VPARTZM AN, CHARLES H.
Res. 13 5 Eastern Parkway
FOR MEMBERSHIP
from page 19]
Bus. Atty., 186 Joralemon St.
Married
Proposed by Albert A. Weinstcin
Late Applications
Abrahams, Miss Joan
Res. 92 5 Prospect Place
Proposed by Gladys Fishman,
Mrs. Ida Perlman
Benin, Dr. Harry
Res. 951 Carroll St.
Bus. Physician, 899 Franklin Ave.
Married
Proposed by Benj. Kaplan,
Harold H. Reintz
Evans, Barnett
Res. 620 Saratoga Ave.
Bus. Drug Mfg., 30 Rockefeller Plaza
Single
Proposed by Aaron Levine,
Dr. Abraham Weisman
Mond, Dr. Stanley L.
Res. 696 Lefferts Ave.
Bus. Dentist, 774 Flatbush Ave.
Single
Proposed by Sally Jaffe,
Jerome J. Weincr
Passales, Harry
Res. 464 East 94th St.
Bus. Blouses, 22 5 West 34th St.
Single
Proposed by Al Cohen
Pincus, Miss Harriette
Res. 415 East 54th St.
Turk, Miss Frances E.
Res. 114 Rogers Ave.
Proposed by Jules W. Gold,
Sidney A. Gold
Winkler, Miss Rhea
Res. 1054 Park Place
Proposed by Morris Grodcn
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
THE LANGUAGE OF STATEHOOD
(Continued from page II]
to look upon the Jew in Israel in a new
light, and we too share in that trans-
formation.
Ah, how much the new freed Jew
could achieve if the nations of the world
would but realize the justice of this his-
toric force that marked the Jew's eman-
cipation. Alas, however, all this happened
not with their aid or encouragement,
but despite the attitude of the nations
of the world. It was by his own
efforts, his own heroism and martyrdom
that this miracle occurred. And we know
that the task is not yet completed. To
quote our own immortal Bialik: "The
road is yet long; great is yet the battle."
There will yet be attempts made to
strangle the new country, and a mighty
nation like Britain will yet do all in its
power to stifle the growth of Israel. We
will have to gird ourselves for new sac-
rifices, for new heroism. But we are con-
fident that the State of Israel will live,
and the Jew is out of the dungeons of
the modern Egypts for all time.
With the triumph of Israel the cause
of justice itself will be vindicated. Who
knows, perhaps that little land that once
gave to the world the first message of
universal peace and brotherhood may
again be the instrument to help the world
to find its Soul.
I told you the legend that the Talmud
tells, how the angel Gabriel taught
Joseph to speak a language he did not
know. But you recall that the Talmud
says that Joseph could not learn these
languages. It was only when the angel
Gabriel took the letter of God and placed
it within his name — his inner self — that
the miracle happened and he became mas-
ter of a new speech. It isn't just the
usual language of the nations that Joseph
learned; indeed, he refused to learn that
type of language. He learned the lan-
guage which reflected godliness, the lan-
guage of holiness, of righteousness and of
truth.
That is the language which we hope,
and which we are assured, the new Jew
of Israel has learned to speak. Israel does
not want to be just another nation like
unto most of the nations of today. He
does not want to learn the language of
hidden diplomacy, of deceit, of falsehood,
of duplicity, that is so often spoken by
so many of the seventy nations of our
day. He aspires to speak a language
which the world has not yet learned, but
which it needs to master if the world is
not to end in self-annihilation. The hand
of peace which Israel has been extending
to the Arabs is part of that new, that
Godly language that he has learned. The
ideals incorporated in the proposed Con-
stitution of Israel is again evidence of
that new language of holiness and God-
liness which the Jew in Israel wants to
speak.
The acts of a small handful in the new
Israel, who have not yet learned this
godly language, is not typical of the new
Jew nor of the new Zion. The murder
of a Bernadotte, or some of the other
ghastly acts that have been perpetrated
by members of the dissident groups, are
the result of minds turned insane through
the murder of six million of their
brethren in cold blood. This is a lan-
guage which they have learned from the
other nations — the language which Joseph
of old and the new Josephs in Zion have
11
of
refused to learn. These are acts that have
been denounced and repudiated by the
entire Yishuv. The very name Israel
which they gave to their nation and their
country is the most eloquent testimony
that, like the angel Gabriel, they have
taken the name of God and incorporated
the Divine letters within their own, to
make certain that godliness shall at
times mark all their thoughts and
their deeds.
Joseph interpreted the dream
Pharaoh and helped to save a nation from
approaching catastrophe. It is our hope
and our prayer that the Jew of Israel,
standing before the rulers of the world,
will once again interpret the dreams of a
weary humanity, and bring to mankind
the sustaining bread of life in this world
of spiritual hunger.
Like Joseph of old, the new Jew of
Zion will yet be able to say to us and
to all the peoples of the world, "God hath
sent me before you to be a source of life"
— the source of a new life of hope and
peace and dignity for the Jew and for
the world!
THE AMAZING SABBATAI ZEVI
[Continued from page 10]
spent and gone. Mehmed Effendi had not
the charm and magic once exercised by
Sabbatai Zevi. His gestures were empty,
his voice hollow, his commands lacked
their old time fear and awe. He was a
broken, strutting old man who knew
that the game was up.
The Turks suspected him. He was
closely watched. Then his pension was re-
voked. He was a problem on their hands.
When he was roused from his depression,
he dreamt of making a fresh start. To
obviate any such complications, he was
banished in 1673 to a remote village on
the coast of Albania, near Scuttari. That
was the final curtain on his strange and
fantastic life. When he felt that his end
was near, he begged not to be interred in
a Moslem cemetery but in proximity to
the people who, in better times, had never
wavered in their love and devotion to
him. Sabbatai Zevi died and was buried
on the Day of Atonement in the year
1675, his grave remaining unmarked and
unvisited, except, occasionally, by Mo-
hammedans who offer up prayers to him
as a saint.
Sabbatai Zevi was the last of Messiahs.
With him the Messianic Movement came
to an end. Jacob Frank, a Podolian Jew
of slight education who laid claims to
messiahship, was too crude, vulgar, and
blasphemous an individual to be seriously
regarded as Sabbatai's successor, although
he pretended to be his reincarnation. At
the height of his power and influence, he
commanded a following of 15,000, but
his "doctrine" was not so much messian-
ism as the complete absorption of the
Jews and Judaism, under certain condi-
tions, into the Catholic Church. His
place in history is therefore a completely
void one of total darkness without a
single bright spot.
But what, in retrospect, must be one's
opinion of Sabbatai Zevi? There is noth-
ing to show that in his long, rich, and
glamorous career he ever gave up his
pleasure, his comfort, for the sake of the
ideal he claimed. He chose to parade
before the world as a Messiah without the
least mental and spiritual preparation for
the task. He was a prophet without a
call, a messenger without a mission, a
Messiah without a divine summons. When
the call came to Jeremiah, it was in his
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
heart as a burning fire; he would feign
suppress it, but he could not. But what
was the transforming effect of the pre-
tended messiahship on Sabbatai Zevi? The
only "burning fire" one apprehends in
Sabbatai, is his burning self-love, burning
ambition, and the burning incense of the
flattery and adulation of his deluded ad-
mirers.
There was no love in his heart. There
is no indication that he ever loved any-
body sincerely. He used men, but he
did not love them. And one who lacks
the quality of love, can have no sympa-
thy, no understanding, no deep feeling
in his heart. Indeed, one wonders whether
he really knew the people who adored him,
and crowded about him. He was a lonely,
solitary man even when thousands bom-
barded him with their acclaim. He
mingled with men, but he never associ-
ated with them, he faced great multi-
tudes, but he had few, if any, intimates.
This is why, although there is a great lit-
erature about Sabbatai Zevi and his move-
ment, there are few authentic documents
from those who stood near him, for he
revealed himself to no one.
He was as incompetent in the prac-
tical execution of his "mission" as he was
in almost everything else. He lacked po-
litical astuteness. Sabbatai Zevi thought he
could end the galut, bring redemption to
his people, and lead them into the Holy
Land by impressive shows and grandiose
displays. Had he possessed political vi-
sion and wisdom and not childishly toyed
with his people's national hopes and aspi-
rations he might have shortened the Jew-
ish exile by three hundred years and saved
millions of lives. There was a time when
nearly the whole world was on its knees
before him. Christians and Moslems alike
paid him their respect, and the restora-
tion of the Jewish nationhood was not
regarded as an impossible dream. Menas-
seh ben Israel, a much smaller man than
himself in the sense of popular acclaim,
secured for the Jews their return to
England, while Sabbatai Zevi, the hope
and idol of thousands, with the eyes of
all the world turned upon him, only suc-
ceeded in making the abyss of Jewish pain
and suffering all the deeper. Therein lay
the tragedy of Sabbatai Zevi, the failure
of the man who might have done so much
yet accomplished so little. His end was
not a simple fall or an ordinary abdica-
tion, but the collapse of a whole people
at a time of its greatest need.
ABBOT -FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES— SERVICE
JESSE J. FINE
JACK ABBOT
507 Flatbush Avenue
Brooklyn, New York
Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
FLOWERS • WEDDING DECORATIONS
HYMAN SPITZ, Inc.
1685 Pitkin Avenue, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Dickens 2-4000 OUR ONLY STORE
• FRUIT BASKETS •
-RIVERSIDE-
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2 - 6600
Far Rockaway, L. I.
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE
FAr Rockaway 7-7100
Miami Beach, Florida
1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
Miami 5-7777
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle,
we have arranged to serve your Community. We have at our
disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn.
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
FOR A SERENE WINTER VACATION
-AND DIVERSION WHEN YOU CHOOSE
CONSIDER PALM BEACH
Enjoy the comforts of a Hotel ... in the tranquil
privacy of the Beaux Arts Apartments, Bradley Place
and Seminole Avenue, Palm Beach, Florida. A square
block of modern apartments conveniently located two
blocks from the ocean, theatres and shopping.
Set amidst tropical gardens directly on Lake
Worth, you are assured superb vistas and restful sur-
roundings.
One- two- three-room heated units, each with its
own patio. Furnished to the last detail for house-
keeping. Maid service by arrangement.
Season and Monthly Rates.
For brochure and information, write or call New York Office, 250 Montgomery Street,
Brooklyn 25, N. Y. Phone: BU 7-1 1 14 — or call Beaux Arts Apartments directly.
Phone: Palm Beach 6225.
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed
Sec. 562, P. L. & R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
Aloaemi&i, 1948
THE "OLIVER TWIST"
CONTROVERSY
By JACOB KAPLAN
THE PASSING OF JUDAH MAGNES
By DR. I. H. LEVINTHAL
A DECADE OF THE N. Y. U.
JEWISH CULTURE FOUNDATION
By DR. A. I. KATSCH
THE ANCESTOR
By SYLVAN KARCHMER
MY BROTHER'S KIDS
By MORRIS MANDEL
NEWS OF THE MONTH
• CENTER BULLETIN BOARD •
J? ORUM J^ ECTURES and J} lSCUSSIONS
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER, 667 EASTERN PARKWAY
SECOND AND FOURTH MONDAY EVENINGS AT 8:15 P.M.
December 13th:
DR. JORGE GARCIA GRANADOS
Former Ambassador from Guatamala to the U. S.; Member of the
United Nations Special Commission on Palestine; Acting Chairman
of the Guatamalan Delegation to the General Assembly of the
United Nations.
Dr. Granados is the author of "The Birth of Israel," a brilliant re-
view of the work of UNSCOP and the fight for the adoption of
Partition by the UN General Assembly. He is a statesman whose
name will go down in Jewish history as a great benefactor of the
Jewish people.
Subject:
"THE UNITED NATIONS AT WORK — A BEHIND
THE SCENE REPORT"
Admission: Center members free; Non-members 40$ (inch tax)
December 27th:
ROUND TABLE DISCUSSION
GROUP
Debate on
"SHOULD THE FEDERAL GOVERN-
MENT OUTLAW ANTI-SEMITIC
LIBELS?"
Affirmative:
WILL MASLOW, ESQ.
Director of Commission on Law and Social Action,
American Jewish Congress; Lecturer at New School
for Social Research.
Negative:
HON. WILLIAM I. SIEGEL
Assistant District Attorney, Kings County
and Zionist Leader.
Admission free to all.
January I Oth:
DEBATE
PROF. J. RAYMOND WALSH
Noted Radio Commentator and Economist
GEORGE HAMILTON COMBS
News Analyst and Former Member of Congress.
Subject:
"OUR FOREIGN POLICY— WHERE IS
IT LEADING TO?"
Admission: Center members free; Non-members 40$
(incl. tax)
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Vol. xxx
NOVEMBER, 1948 — HESHVAN, 5709
No. II
CHRISTMAS AND CHANUKAH
ALTHOUGH this period of the
year signifies to the businessman
the beginning of the Christmas
rush to many Jews it is the forerunner
of a period of confusion, conflict and
perplexity. The Yuletide is so much a
part of the American way of life that
many American Jews have adopted the
trimmings of Christmas, especially the
Christmas tree. These Jews rationalize
their assimilation of the Christmas ritual
by saying that they have only been at-
tracted by its spirit of good-will. They
fail to realize that Christmas is not merely
an American secular festival, but a Chris-
tian religious holiday symbolizing the be-
lief in the divinity of the founder of
Christianity. A Christmas tree in a Jew-
ish home does not denote the greater
Americanism but slavish imitation of a
religious festival that is not Jewish.
Many of our Christian neighbors consider
such celebrations in Jewish homes a dese-
cration. They expect us to respect their
religious customs, but they do not want
us to go through the motions of a mean-
ingless imitation and vulgarization of
their sancta.
The introduction of the Christmas tree
in Jewish homes can very often be traced
to the void left in the hearts of many
Jews who are unfortunately unaware of
the customs and ceremonies of their own
people. They are literally starved for re-
ligious experiences. They miss the
pageantry and beauty of our rituals which
alone can enrich and give greater meaning
and significance to their lives as Jews.
The Chanukah holiday, with its message
of the victory of light over the forces of
darkness, the triumph of freedom and the
defeat of tyranny, is rich with meaning
and abounds with opportunities for elabo-
rate and beautiful pageantry. It should
be celebrated with great eclat. Several
apartment houses in neighborhoods where
the tenants are predominantly Jewish have
set up large Menorahs in their lobbies;
this is a practice that should be encour-
aged by all Jewish tenants. Impressive
parties should be arranged for Chanukah
and gifts exchanged. Our children will
surely be inspired and moved by the
beauty of the Chanukah ceremonies if
parents would but take the time and the
initiative to plan family celebrations in
their home.
American democracy demands of us
not blind imitation of our surroundings
and environment but the development
of our particular way of life. Only as
self-respecting Jews will we be able to
contribute to American culture and repay
our country for the opportunities of civil
and religious freedom that it has granted
us.
— E. Z. and M. H. L.
A CULTURAL DYNAMO FOR JUDAISM
THE struggle for the establishment of
the State of Israel and its defense has
served as a great spiritual boon for Amer-
ican Jews. It has stimulated our Jewish
consciousness and given a sense of dignity
to Jews who were far removed from Jews
and Judaism. However, we must not be
deluded into believing that with the im-
minent solution of the problems confront-
ing the newly created state, and with the
strengthening of the Jewish spirit, the
religious and cultural problems which
face us in America will automatically be
solved. Prof. Salo Baron, Professor of
Jewish History, Literature and Institu-
tions at Columbia University, was right
when in a recent address he emphasized
"the danger of altogether delegating our
religious and cultural responsibilities to
our co-religionists in Palestine." Ameri-
can Jews are confronted with problems
uniquely American. We will continue to
be a religious minority subject to the pres-
sure and influence of the majority culture
and way of life — while in Israel.
American Jews must also understand
that Judaism in America cannot and will
not survive vicariously — by virtue of the
sacrifice and devotion of the Jews in
Israel to their people and their God.
American Jews must create and support
their own cultural dynamos from which
will flow the power to energize and vita-
lize our Jewish lives and which will re-
direct and channelize the spiritual
strength that will emanate from the New
Zion into the life-stream of American
Jewry.
Aware of the great challenge and op-
portunity that await us, a committee of
men and women of the Brooklyn Jewish
Center, who have been the vanguard to
raise and collect unprecedented sums of
money for the United Jewish Appeal and
Federation of Jewish Philanthropies have
again organized this year in support of
one of our leading cultural and religious
institutions, the Jewish Theological Semi-
nary of America.
Ever since its founding, the Seminary
[Continued on page 17]
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway. Brooklyn, N. Y
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and wi!! be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Greenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Soodstein. Treasurer Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthai, D.D., D.H.L, Rabbi Manuel Saltiman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
Ail contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
4
"JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES"
"irar; ynb
An Intimate Chat Between Rabbi and Reader
THE PASSING OF JUDAH MAGNES
THE recent death of Dr. Judah Leon
Magnes came as a shock and brought
great sorrow to the thousands of
men and women who knew him, both
here in America and in Israel. And the
strange fact to be noted is that though
the great majority of these people were
in utter disagreement with his political
views regarding the future of Palestine,
all had the highest regard for him per-
sonally. All sensed the absolute sincer-
ity of the man, his lofty idealism, his
passion for peace, and his unbounded love
for his people and for all mankind.
He was the dreamer in the noblest
sense of the term. And that explains
his greatness and also his failure to win
the approval of those to whom he made
his frequent pleas. "Lo, the dreamer
Cometh!" was not only the attitude of
the brothers to Joseph, but that of most
men and women towards those who, like
Dr. Magnes, refuse to be swayed by the
realities of life and who persist in living
in the realm of their ideals, no matter
how impractical these ideals may be.
•
We have an interesting Rabbinic com-
ment, which, I believe, best describes the
personality of men like Judah Magnes.
I interpreted this comment when I paid
tribute to him from our pulpit, and I
shall permit myself to repeat it here.
There is a discussion between the school
of Shammai and the school of Hillel as
to which was created first — heaven or
earth. The disciples of Shammai insisted
that the heavens were created first, while
the disciples of Hillel claimed that the
earth came first. Each of course quoted
Biblical verses to prove his case. The con-
clusion to which the later Rabbis came
was that both were created together.
This would appear to the superficial
reader as a naive, almost childish, dis-
cussion. And yet, looking deeper into
these words, one finds a penetrating char-
acterization of the leaders of these two
schools of thought.
Shammai was the strict teacher, who
never compromised with situations. When
the heathen came to him and asked to
be taught the whole Jewish law while
standing on one foot, Shammai drove him
from his presence. That was not the
way to learn the Torah. His mind and
his thoughts were in the heights of the
heavens; heaven came first and was the
all important.
•
Hillel was the mild teacher, the realist
who understood that we must often com-
promise with life. When the same
heathen approached Hillel with the iden-
tical request, Hillel did not drive him
away. He told him the golden rule and
added: "This is the Torah, all else is com-
mentary. Go now and learn the rest."
Hillel believed that earth came first, and
that in facing life we must take into ac-
count conditions of earth if we want to
reach out into the heavens.
The Jewish people knew how to solve
this dilemma — both heaven and earth
were fashioned at the same time; both
must be considered simultaneously.
Dr. Magnes, in this sense, belonged to
the school of Shammai. To him, heavenly
ideals not only came first, but were the
all-in-all of life. He never would nor
could compromise.
In the disputes between the two classic
Jewish schools I have described, the law
in nearly every case is according to the
view of the school of Hillel. "But," says
an interesting cabbalistic tradition, "when
the Messiah will come the law will then
be according to the views of the school
of Shammai."
•
That indeed explains the apparent fail-
ure of Dr. Magnes's ideals. They were
not for the Jew, as the earth presents
itself now. They were too far in the
heavens. But they do fit in with the
Messianic dream. When that glorious
day will appear, when a new earth will
be fashioned to reflect a new heaven,
when justice will flow like a river and
righteousness like a mighty stream, then
indeed the visions of Dr. Magnes will be-
come living realities.
The life of Judah Leon Magnes was
the most eloquent proof that though we
no longer have prophets, we are still the
B'ne Ha'nei'iim, children of the prophets,
capable of producing men like Magnes,
whose thoughts and actions are in the
noblest prophetic tradition.
INSIDE CZECHOSLOVAKIA
AT LEAST 1,000 Czech Jews have
fled Czechoslovakia since the recent
change of government, Gisela Tauber, a
Jewish journalist, declared upon her ar-
rival in Vienna from Prague. She crossed
the border illegally.
Miss Tauber said that the membership
of the Jewish Community Council of
Prague and the Federation of Jewish Com-
munities has been cleared of most per-
sons who "refuse to bow to the Commu-
nists." She added that most of the posi-
tions on both bodies have been filled by
Communists as a majority of the former
leaders of the groups fled the country,
mostly to Paris.
Administrative barriers have virtually
halted emigration to all countries except
Israel, Miss Tauber asserted, adding that
as a result many Jews in Prague have ap-
plied for Israeli visas. The Jewish com-
munities of many provincial centers, such
as Teplitz and Reichenberg, have been
depleted by legal and illegal emigration,
she said. The transfer of valuable prop-
erty such as jewels, silverware, furs and
rugs is frequently prevented by officials,
in the absence of regulations governing
their export, Miss Tauber reported.
She also said that many Jewish refugees
from other Eastern European nations ar-
riving in Prague are "not permitted to
receive" relief assistance on orders of Egon
Kohn, whom Miss Tauber identifies as a
leading member of the Prague Jewish
Community and the Communist Party.
She also confirmed that Oscar Krasnansky,
head of the Czech Zionist movement, has
been arrested.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
Dickens' Novel Continued an Ancient Slander
That Is Now Revived in a New Hritish Movie
THE "OLIVER TWIST"
CONTROVERSY
SHOCKED indeed are those of us
who have read the recent news re-
port from Germany that J. Arthur
Rank's "Oliver Twist," the controversial
film version of Dickens' novel, is to be
exhibited in the U. S. zone of Germany.
German dialogue is already being dubbed
into the movie, which is scheduled for a
preview in the American zone in Janu-
ary and a showing in the British and
French zones at the same time or shortly
after. The man responsible for permis-
sion to show the film is Col. Gordon
Textor, head of the U. S. Information
Services; the latter is reported to have said
he saw nothing in the film which might
stir up anti-Semitic feeling.
Apparently, the protests which fol-
lowed the announcement that the film
was to be displayed in the United States
have not been completely effective. True,
of course, columnists like Albert Deutsch
and Walter Winchell, official Jewish
groups like the New York Board of
Rabbis, raised their voices with enough
power to cause the picture's showing in
the United States to be shelved tempo-
rarily. Manifestly, more and more vigi-
lance is necessary to destroy the cultural
poison which i^ in this vicious, anti-
Semitic film, "Oliver Twist."
For, make no mistake about it, the
Rank "Oliver Twist" deserves condemna-
tion from all democratic mankind. It
deserves condemnation because it intro-
duces that outstanding example of anti-
Jewish stereotypes in English literature,
Fagin. Published shots of the film show
Fagin as a horribly-caricatured, viciously-
slanderous composite of the classic Jew-
ish stereotype. Sinister and ugly does he
look, with a scraggly beard, a tremen-
dous hooknose, greedy fish-eyes. He
speaks, we are told, with a thick gutteral
accent. He lisps and he wheedles. He
seduces the children of the film like
Dawkins, the Artful Dodger, and Oliver
Twist into a life of crime. He is a fiend-
ish, sadistic criminal who clubs Oliver
and murders Nancy Sikes with a mini-
mum of provocation. In a world still
suffering from the misinformation of
racist demagogues, this anti-Semitic cari-
cature can hardly serve to combat the
subtle evil of anti-Jewish prejudice.
There are some misguided liberals in
our midst who have hastened to the de-
fense of "Oliver Twist" on the ground
that art should never be censored. Thus,
Elmer Rice, distinguished American play-
wright, recently voiced his objection to
the protest of American Jewish groups
against "Oliver Twist" on the basis that
it violated artistic integrity. Art, he im-
plied, is above censorship of any type.
It is time that we came of age, cul-
turally speaking, on this whole issue of
literary or dramatic caricatures of the
Jew. It is time that we began to learn
the exact nature of a vicious tradition
extant in the literature of England, Ger-
many and America. It is the bane of
English, German and American literature
that they have perpetuated the tradition
about the Jew as a usurer, criminal, rogue,
evil-doer. We may label this the Shylock-
Fagin tradition, which has passed on from
century to century and has done irrepar-
able harm to the Jewish people. So im-
bedded has this Shylock-Fagin tradition
become in our mores that it has led many
a movie producer to introduce the stereo-
type of the avaricious Jew. Rank's
"Oliver Twist" is thus no innocent
accident.
•
When and how did this Shylock-Fagin
tradition begin? The very origin of dra-
matic literature brought with it the pil-
lorying of the Jew. The drama in Eng-
land was religious in origin and consisted
of miracles, mysteries or moralities pre-
sented to church and guild audiences.
These plays took over the spirit of the
medieval "Hymn of Hate" in respect to
the Jew. Usually they gave some story
of a Jew who tried to dupe a Christian,
only to be outwitted himself, much to
the amusement and delight of the audi-
ence. When religion and drama were di-
vorced, secular dramatists found that the
stage Jew was a convention in the drama
too popular to be cast aside. They pro-
ceeded to make him a ridiculous figure.
Usually he had red hair, a red beard and
a huge nose. With Shakespeare and
By JACOB KAPLAN
Christopher Marlowe showing the way,
the Jew was usually a moneylender. Nine
times out of ten he was a Shylock who
insisted upon his pound of flesh from the
Christian in his clutches. He spoke a
barbarous language with an inflection and
lisp which made him more ridiculous than
ever. When not a usurer, the Jew was a
fence or receiver of stolen goods, a rogue
or a parvenu. He was the progenitor of
Fagin.
The noteworthy point is that this
usurer-rogue stage Jew was based on the
fact that the Christian usurer for several
centuries used the Jew as a scapegoat —
a most familiar practice, as the modern
world may testify. "I suspect," said our
own Oliver Wendell Holmes, "the story
of sweating gold was one of the many
fables got up to make the Jews odious
and afford a pretext for plundering
them." Holmes' suspicion is borne out
by history. There were no Jews in Eng-
land from 1290, the year they were ex-
pelled, to 165 5, when they were permit-
ted to return. Only crypto-Jews, very
few in number, remained in the country
at the time of Shakespeare — the end of
the 16th century. Nevertheless, Stephen
Gosse, in 1 579, wrote an essay called
"The School of Abuse," in which he
refers to "The Jew" shown at the Bull
(a tavern playhouse in Bishopsgate) as
representing the bloody minds of usurers.
Here is the first Jewish usurer in Eng-
land, appearing at a time when not a
single Jew was known to England.
Why he appeared is no mystery.
R. H. Tawney, the famous English so-
cial scientist, informs us that Parliament
had to pass one bit of legislation after
another in attempts to stamp out the
usury evil. In 1341 and 1487, for ex-
ample, legislation was enacted by Parlia-
ment laying down severe penalties for
the crime of usury. As late as the period
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
6
of Bacon, whose essay 'Of Usurie" ap-
peared in 1623, it was quite plain that
usury was a widespread evil in Christian
England. All this is indicative of but
one all-important point: usury was prac-
tised widely in England both before and
after the expulsion of the Jews by the
non- Jewish world. Precisely because of
this very fact, the Christian usurers used
the Jew as a scapegoat to divert the re-
sentment of the aroused public from
themselves. They began to prate propa-
gandistically about the Jew as being
usurer by instinct and tradition. The
gullible dramatist unfortunately accepted
this characterization. Most Elizabethan
playwrights at one time or another took
occasion to depict the usurer Jew.
•
Shakespeare and Christopher Marlowe's
creations set examples for centuries.
Shakespeare's Shylock, desiring his pound
of flesh, and Barrabas, the Jew of Malta,
seeking "infinite riches in a little room,"
are the ancestors of a nauseating lineage
of Jewish stereotypes. The Shylock-
Fagin tradition has come down to our
own times. Such dramatists as Arthur
Wing Pinero in "The Mind of the Painted
Girl," Edmond Knoblock in "The Pawn,"
Somerset Maugham in "Lady Frederick"
have in recent years introduced Shylock-
Fagin stage Jews in their plays. Ameri-
can literature borrowed the stage Jew
stereotype and used it considerably. Not
before 1875 was a Jew portrayed on the
American stage who was not a usurer or
a villain. German literature introduced
the Shylock-Fagin pattern and used it
widely. Goebbcls found much to work
with in the German literary past.
Now there is but little question that
Charles Dickens' Fagin is a perpetuation
of the mendacious tradition of the Jew-
ish stereotype. His very description tes-
tifies to this: Fagin is "a very old shriv-
elled Jew whose villainous-looking and
repulsive face was obscured by a quantity
of matted red hair." He even has the
lisp of the stereotype. Contrast this de-
scription with Dickens' Jewish character,
Mr. Riah, in his "Our Mutual Friend,"
as "an old Jewish man in an ancient coat,
long of skirt and wide of pocket; a ven-
erable man . . . ." There is evidence that
Dickens regretted his Fagin characteriza-
tion and tried to make amends by his
creation of Mr. Riah. But Mr. Riah does
not quite blot out Fagin. In creating
Fagin, Dickens gave us one of the most
unfortunate types of literature. In a
bigoted moment he created a character
who should be relegated to the limbo of
literature. The world's culture would
have lost nothing if this figure had never
been born. Any form of art — novel,
movie, drama — which revives him should
be condemned.
It does not speak too well for Britain
that "Oliver Twist" has been exhibited
to adult audiences in it. Likewise, it
will be a definite reflection on the United
States if the American Military Govern-
ment officials are permitted to sponsor
this film. Consider! This film is to be
shown to the land of Buchenwald and
Auschwitz, to the land in whose soil six
million murdered Jews lie interred — six
million people who are, in a sense, the
victims of the falsehoods about the Jew
which "Oliver Twist" perpetuates,
o
It is interesting to call the roll of the
non-Jews who have attempted to cor-
rect the abominable usurer-rogue tradi-
tion. In English literature dramatists
like Cumberland and Galsworthy, novel-
ists like George Eliot have come forward
to write intelligently about the Jew and
his cultural traditions. George Eliot's
"Daniel Deronda" gives us a tale of a
Jewish boy, Daniel Deronda, whose social
idealism contrasted sharply with the mere
THE Board of Deputies of British Jews
set aside this month as "Defense
Month" in view of increasing anti-Semi-
tism in the British Isles.
A meeting of the Board heard Dr. Selig
Brodetsky, president of the organization,
assert that there are "indications of large-
scale preparations for all-out-attacks
against the Jews in Britain."
A resolution adopted by the Board pro-
vides that during "Defense Month," the
Jewish community in Britain will concen-
trate on raising $800,000 for the purpose
of combatting anti-Jewish propaganda.
Several speakers at the meeting warned
that anti-Semitic elements in Britain are
attempting to exploit the "present inter-
national situation by arousing mass sen-
timent against Jews."
individualism of his gentile girl friend,
Gwendolyn Harleth. In an inspiring
manner, Eliot traces this moral and social
idealism to the real traditions of the Jew-
ish people. In German literature Gott-
fried Ephraim Lessing, inspired by his
knowledge of Spinoza's life and his
friendship with Moses Mendelsohn, the
great Jewish philosophical and poetic
mind, wrote "Die Juden" and "Nathan
Der Weise." In our own literature, im-
mortals like Washington Irving, Long-
fellow, Emerson, James Russell Lowell,
Mark Twain, and Lafcadio Hearn have
written understandingly about the Jew
as a correction of the infamous picture
of him perpetuated by the Shylock-Fagin
stereotype.
Unfortunately, the salutary effect of
their works has had considerably less in-
fluence than Dickens' Fagin. The film
"Oliver Twist" will continue this unfor-
tunate vogue. It will fan the flames of
anti-Semitism in a land where its scourge
has done more harm than in any other
period of history. The democratic West-
ern world cannot afford to take a schizo-
phrenic approach to the Jew, permitting
him his national independence and mis-
representing him in its cultural media.
"Oliver Twist" is a slander upon the Jew.
In this view he is joined by all fair-
minded people.
Warning against the theory that anti-
Semitism can be removed by "a clever
trick," Prof. Brodetsky declared that "it
is a constant danger threatening Jews
throughout history." He urged Zionists
not to believe that Zionism is the "panacea
against this evil" and called on them to
participate fully in defense activities,
"since not only British Jewry but the
State of Israel is threatened by anti-Semit-
ism abroad."
The House of Commons will soon be
petitioned by the Committee for Slaughter
Reform to adopt legislation outlawing
Jewish ritual slaughter. Headed by Lord
Dowding, the group maintains that there
is no anti-Jewish intent in such legisla-
tion.
British Jews Organize Defense Against Increasing
Anti-Semitism
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
7
The Value of Jewish Culture and of the Jeuish
Heritage is Being Made Kuoicn at JV. Y, University
A DECADE OF N.Y.U. JEWISH
CULTURE FOUNDATION
THE New York University Jewish
Culture Foundation was conceived
and projected by Dr. E. George
Payne, the former Dean of the School of
Education of New York University, to-
gether with the writer, then an instructor
in Hebrew in the Division of General
Education of New York University. In
1937, they called together a group of
several leading faculty members, some
prominent persons in the general Jewish
community and several Jewish student
leaders, whom they invited to join in the
establishment of the New York Univer-
sity Jewish Culture Foundation, as the
all-embracing Jewish student organiza-
tion on the campus. The Foundation
was to be an intra-school rather than an
inter-collegiate association without for-
mal ties to outside groups or ideologies,
although, of course, cooperating with all
agencies sympathetic to its purposes. New
York University was thus the first in-
stitution to establish a Jewish student
organization woven into the very fabric
of its curricular and extra-curricular life,
for which the University would feel a
direct interest and responsibility.
The purposes of the Jewish Culture
Foundation as outlined by Dean Payne,
the Chairman of the Board of Directors,
at the inception of the organization are:
1. To make the Jews among our stu-
dents conscious of their cultural
background and its importance to
America.
2. To provide non-Jews with a back-
ground of understanding with ref-
erence to the vital contribution of
Jews to our national and social life.
3. To bring about a comity especially
between Jews and Gentiles, and to
curb incipient totalitarianism which
cannot exist in our democratic
country without doing violence to
our ideals and to our democratic
life.
The Jewish educational as well as the
inter-faith aspects of the Jewish Culture
Foundation are implied in these objec-
tives. The Jewish student is given an
opportunity to acquaint himself with,
and to develop an appreciation of his
heritage both through formal instruction
and through informal activities. The
Gentile student is also in a position to
increase his knowledge and understand-
ing of the Jew and his heritage. This
cultural and inter-cultural platform is of
especial significance to New York Uni-
versity, a large metropolitan and cosmo-
politan institution, national in scope,
spread over several campuses, with the
greatest Catholic, Jewish and Protestant
student population in the world. The
program is projected on a simple educa-
tional level, and is made an integral
rather than merely an incidental phase
of a liberal democratic education.
The program of the Jewish Culture
Foundation is composed of three inter-
related elements: the students' organiza-
tion, the Library of Judaica and Hcbraica,
and the Chair of Hebrew Culture and
Education. The Chair of Hebrew Cul-
ture and Education was established at
New York University in 1944. Students
may now major in Hebrew Culture or
Education, and receive full credit towards
a Bachelor's, Master's or Doctor's degree
in the University's School of Education.
Early in the career of the Foundation, the
compelling need of a library became ap-
parent as indispensable to students writ-
ing term papers, preparing assignments
or doing research in the field of Hebrew
or Jewish culture. To establish this li-
brary, the writer appealed to the Jewish
Publication Society for assistance and that
organization responded with a donation
of several hundred books of its own
publications.
On a subsequent occasion, the late Dr.
Mitchell M. Kaplan, poet and bibliophile,
contributed his unique private collection
of some 4,000 manuscripts, incunabula,
and other rare editions as well as current
Judaica. At about the same time, Mr.
William Rosenthal presented his father's
collection, dealing with Hebrew educa-
tion, to the Jewish Culture Foundation
Library. From the storage stacks of the
University Heights Library, the Founda-
tion secured the Judaica and Hebraica
collection of the famous Semitic scholar,
By DR. A. I. KATSCH
Paul Lagarde (1827-1891), a German
anti-Semite who distinguished himself
with his critical reconstruction of the
text of the Septuagint. The library has
since been further augmented by addi-
tional gifts; among them, a Zionist book
shelf presented by the Zionist Organiza-
tion of America, a number of diction-
aries presented by the Jewish Education
Committee of New York. The N. Y. U.
Jewish Culture Foundation Library, now
consisting of thousands of volumes,
though founded and maintained by the
Foundation, is under the direction of the
University Director of Libraries and the
J. C. F. director, and is included in the
main Uni* r ersity catalogue as a part of
the Unive-sity collection. It is conducted
as a refe-"nce library, open to all stu-
dents, and supervised by student li-
brarians, provided by the University. The
Jewish Library is an impressive symbol
to the Jewish student of the recognition
of his heritage, on a part with the cul-
tures of other peoples.
The Jewish Culture Foundation is gov-
erned by a Board of Directors consisting
of a number of leading faculty members.
It is maintained by a Board of Sponsors
composed of leaders in the community,
as well as representatives of a recently
organized Women's Division. The stu-
dents, however, have full run of their
own affairs. The activities of the Foun-
dation are guided by the Director who
is a regular member of the faculty and
by two associates, one for the Washing-
ton Square Center and the other for the
University Heights Campus. Both the
students and the faculty regard the Di-
rector as their liaison with the Jewish
community and consult him on various
questions affecting Jewish life and the
Jewish student body. Membership in the
Jewish Culture Foundation carries with
it voting rights in the students' organiza-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
8
tion as well as the privilege of joining
one or more of the many sub-groups of
the Foundation; the Zionist Circle, the
Hebrew Circle, dramatic, dancing, or
choral groups or the Graduate Society.
It includes also a subscription to the
Mcnorab Journal. The general activities
and functions of the Jewish Culture
Foundation are open to the entire student
body.
The University has concretized its con-
cern and interest in the inter-faith and
inter-cultural program, by acquiring re-
cently, on its own initiative, a special
building to house all its religious activ-
ities: the Christian Association, the New-
man Club, the Jewish Culture Founda-
tion and the J. C. F. Library. The Re-
ligious Activities Building is now being
outfitted to suit the needs of each of the
three groups, and when opened, it will
no doubt make it possible for the Jewish
Culture Foundation to broaden and in-
tensify its program.
On the plane of cultural activities, the
Jewish Culture Foundation begins its pro-
gram each semester with the annual
Freshman Reception, which attracts hun-
dreds of entering students, who come to
hear addresses by major administrative
officers of the University. This serves as
a means of inducting and orienting the
new students into the Jewish Culture
Foundation program. At least two reg-
ular weekly forums, one for the day stu-
dents and another for the evening stu-
dents, are arranged, and these are devoted
to a discussion of current problems on
religion, Palestine, Jewish history, litera-
ture, philosophy and art. The lectures
are arranged in a unit series running
through a semester, designed to give the
students a general picture of Jewish cul-
ture and life, contemporary and histori-
cal, and to acquaint them with the under-
lying currents and patterns of Jewish life
and thought. The discussions are led by
guest lecturers from within and without
the University. The weekly attendance
at the regular meetings of the Foundation
circles runs into several hundred. The
Foundation also fosters a number of an-
nually recurrent events, including the
Succoth Festival, Jewish Book Month
celebrations, Chanukah Chagigoth, Purim
masquerades, and the model Passover
Seders, all of which have become popular
functions, which attract Jews and non-
Jews on the campus. The Jewish Cul-
ture Foundation arranges the usual social
events, teas, dances, and the like.
To stimulate student interest, and also
as a means cf attracting students of spe-
cial merit or ability to the courses in
Hebrew Culture and Education, the
Foundation offers some ten scholarships
and prizes ranging from $2 5 to $450.
The University has recently accepted the
prize of an annual gift of a Lexicon of
the Hebrew Language in 16 volumes to
be given annually by the Benyehuda
Foundation to a student who excels in
Hebrew and writes on the Work of
Eliezer Benyehuda. Recently a teaching
fellowship, amounting to $1,5 00. per
annum and known as the Sidney Motz
Fellowship, was established in connection
with the Chair of Hebrew Culture and
Education.
The Jewish Culture Foundation has
now functioned for almost ten years, and
we are therefore in a position to evaluate
its pattern of organization as well as its
achievement. Its three component ele-
ments, united into one body, have not
only functioned harmoniously, but have
supplemented and served each other. The
library, for example, is to the Chair what
a laboratory is to the science classroom.
The student organization and Jewish Cul-
ture Foundation circles afford the stu-
dents in the Hebrew classes experience in
leadership, as a preparation for active par-
ticipation in Jewish communal enterprise.
Reciprocally, the students' activities and
circles of the Foundation are a reservoir
attracting students for the courses.
There is no competition between the three
arms of the Foundation, as is not infre-
quently the case in institutions where the
curricular studies are apart from rather
than a part of a single organization.
Moreover, since the Jewish Culture Foun-
dation is an integral part of the institu-
tion which it serves, there is maximum
cooperation between it and the Uni-
versity.
The fine spirit of understanding and
good-will which reigns among faculty
and students at New York University is
a manifestation of the basic philosophy
underlying the Jewish Culture Founda-
tion and its activities. By working on a
cultural and educational level we have
been able to make great strides toward
establishing understanding and healthy
human relationships on campus. The de-
gree of our success is indicated by the
fact that the Foundation's Faculty Board
of Directors is composed of Jews and
non-Jews, all of whom are interested, and
actively concerned, in furthering a
knowledge of Jewish culture on campus.
BRANDEIS UNIVERSITY
OPENS
Brandeis University, of Waltham, Mass.,
the first Jewish-sponsored non-sectarian
institution of higher learning in the
United States, was inaugurated at impres-
sive ceremonies in Symphony Hall in Bos-
ton here during which Dr. Abram Leon
Sachar was installed as the first president
of the University.
A letter of tribute from President Tru-
man was made public at the conclusion
of the three-day inaugural ceremonies.
Addressed to Dr. Sachar, it read in part:
"In behalf of the Nation, the ultimate
beneficiary of the creative contributions
Brandeis University will make, I welcome
you into the realm of free institutions."
More than 3,000 guests and delegates
from 166 American and 18 foreign col-
leges and universities attended the aca-
demic ceremonies. Dr. Sachar was in-
ducted by George Alpert, president of
the Board of Trustees of the university.
The inaugural address was delivered by
Dr. Arthur H. Compton, chancellor of
Washington University. Eliahu Epstein,
Israeli envoy to the United States, ex-
pressed the hope that many future grad-
uates of Brandeis University would bring
their knowledge to Israel.
In his address, Dr. Sachar said that
Brandeis University would never choose
its students or faculty on quotas of
genetic, ethnic or economic distribution.
"The truth is, " he declared, "that Amer-
ica is not a melting pot at all. It is a
symphony. The precious groups that
have come to these shores must not dis-
appear into an assimilative cauldron."
The academic year got under way on
October 14 when the 120 members of the
pilot freshman class registered. Classes
began October 20. Twenty-five percent
of the freshmen are receiving scholarships
from the university. The tuition charge
is $5 00 a year.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
How Margie Learned That Her Family's Great
Department Store Started in a Peddler's Paek
THE ANCESTOR
ELEVEN-YEAR-OLD Margie was
having trouble with history again.
"We've got seven questions and
I don't know the answers to a single one
of them," she fretted.
"Now stop worrying so much about
school," said Frances, "and let me talk
to your daddy."
How blond they both were, Mark
thought, idly glancing from one to the
other. They had long, narrow heads and
pale, luminous eyes. Margie's hair, like
her mother's, was the color of golden-
brown autumn apples.
"I've got all kinds of troubles," said
Margie, with a serious, preoccupied air.
"And nobody pays me any attention."
Frances pushed back her dish of des-
sert. "I didn't have a chance to tell you,
Mark," she said, "the agent for the
Crest Park addition was here today; he
drove me out to see the place we were
talking about."
Her eyes opened wide with excitement
as she talked. "Mark, you ought to see
the inside."
They had noticed the ad in Sunday's
paper, but when Mark saw the address
he had grown dubious about it. "Not
for us," he said. Crest Park was politely
called a restricted residential area. Mark
remembered that before the war Uncle
Sam Runawitz had tried to build out
there and had been unable to purchase
a lot.
"The agent was so nice," Frances went
out, slowly, "and when he phoned back
this afternoon, he said we could pick up
the key any time we liked and go through
the house again."
"But," Mark said, "I don't under-
stand . . ."
Frances interrupted, hurrying on be-
fore he had a chance to say anything else,
"It's got the loveliest downstairs den —
done in rough pine, and Mark-, I just love
the master bedroom. You must see it,
dear."
Mark looked at her with an odd ex-
pression in his eyes. "You mean they
don't know . . ."
But Frances interrupted him again
with a swift shrug of her shoulders.
"Why should they know?" she demanded
and tossed her golden hair back defiantly.
"Wouldn't it save us a lot of trouble,
I mean, later on? They're bound to find
out . . ."
"That's so utterly tiresome," Frances
said. "You don't have to advertise it,
do you? Why, I'm never taken for . . ."
She paused, her words trailed away, as
she arose from the table and walked
towards the French doors that opened in-
to the sitting room. "Come on, Alice,
get the dishes," she called, then she turned
to Mark, and now a sly little smile
hovered around the corners of her dainty,
well-formed lips. "Wouldn't Uncle Sam
and Aunt Laura just die! I mean if we
got a house in that exclusive district. It
would be worth it . . . just to see the
expression on their faces."
"I don't like it," Mark said. He had
followed her into the sitting room. I
just don't like it at all," he grumbled.
He slid into the green soft chair under
the lamp and picked up the paper. Fran-
ces came over, adjusted the light over
his shoulder, and leaned over so that her
chin touched his forehead. "Darling,"
she said, "half the congregation would
give anything they owned to move out
there."
"I wonder," he said. "I think you are
completely wrong."
They were interrupted by Margie, who
came in with her school books. She sat
down on the sofa and pushed some of
Frances' glass ornaments to one side of
the coffee table, where she deposited her
books.
Frances watched her disapprovingly.
"You can't study in here — not while your
daddy and I are talking. Why don't you
go up to your room?"
"I need Daddy's help," Margie cried.
"You know I just hate history. It's my
worst subject. It's not only that. We've
got to write a theme on our ancestors."
"Your ancestors?" Mark asked, curious.
"Miss Leak spent the whole period talk-
ing about it. She says her grandfather
was a colonel in a Texas Regiment dur-
ing the Civil War. She showed us a
letter Robert E. Lee had written him
after he was wounded in a battle."
"How interesting."
By SYLVAN KARCHMER
"And you know Martha Crow — she
spoke up in class and said that was noth-
ing, her folks had been living in the
South since Colonial days. They came
from Virginia."
"Is that Dr. Crow's daughter?" asked
Frances. She touched Mark's shoulder
knowingly. "They live out in Crest
Park addition."
"That's not all," Margie cried from the
sofa. "Ernestine Medford said they have
a family chart that shows all their rela-
tives. She said her mother paid twenty-
five dollars to have it made. And
Leonora Segrist said her people came from
France. She said they were French noble-
men. And you wouldn't think so, either,
Daddy . . . because she wears the tackiest
clothes."
Mark watched her soft grey eyes cloud
as she talked. "Miss Leak said it was all
so illuminating. That's the word she
used — then she went down the row and
asked each girl where her folks were from.
She didn't get to me before the bell
rang."
Mark put the paper down, and for a
second time his breath seemed caught in
his throat. What would Margie have
told them, he wondered.
Frances said, "I'm surprised that they
even discuss things like that at a fine
girls' school like Miss Carrothers' ... I
think it is perfectly silly."
"Why should it be silly?" asked Mark.
"Pride in one's forbears and that sort of
thing."
But he did not feel easy in his own
mind. There was a curious feeling in-
side him that he had been doing Margie
a grave injustice.
"Wouldn't it have been lovely," sighed
Margie, "if grandfather had fought in the
Civil War."
Mark gave a short little laugh. "He
hardly could have done that. He was
only six when the war started."
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
Then acting on a whim as he saw her
strangely troubled face, he arose from the
soft chair. "Let me sit here," he said,
and eased himself down to the sofa be-
side her. "Now," he said, and put his
arm around Margie's soft, round little
shoulders.
Frances sat down in his chair. Ab-
sently she picked up the paper. "They
don't have any right to embarrass girls
like that," she said petulantly. "I'm sure
Miss Carrothers wouldn't approve."
"Do you know where I work?" Mark
asked Margie.
"Of course," Margie said proudly.
"You're Vice-President at Runawitz's —
the biggest department store in the whole
city."
Mark's laugh was rueful, half-bitter.
"Thanks for the boost," he said. "But,
Margie, what I wanted to tell you was
that Runawitz's wasn't always the largest
department store in town, and it wasn't
always housed in that twelve-story build-
ing of white Austin chalk. Once — a
long time ago — it was only a twenty-
foot front down by the courthouse, near
the viaduct. And before that — a long
time ago — it was only a pack, a peddler's
pack, on a young man's shoulders."
For a second he tried to remember him
as he must have been in his prime, when
he was very young — when he stood erect
— but all that Mark could remember of
his grandfather was the small, spritely
man, slightly stooped, with the white
chin whiskers, who used to annoy Mark's
father and uncles because he was always
fussing around in the ladies ready-to-wear
buyers' offices, haggling about prices and
styles. Oddly enough, his judgment was
often better than the uncles who had
gone to expensive foreign schools to learn
their trade.
"He was your great-grandfather," he
said to Margie, "my own grandfather,
and when he came to America he was
only sixteen."
Frances creased the newspaper so that
it made a noise. "I thought you had so
many lessons to do," she said to Margie.
Margie ignored her. "Daddy's never
told me," she said. "And was his name
Runnan, like ours?"
"No," said Mark, softly now, and al-
most apologetically. "His name was not
Runnan, but nonetheless, he was your
ancestor."
There were so few stories he remem-
bered of the frail old man. Even now
he seemed fragmentary in Mark's mind,
like a book only half-read. And yet,
In the News
By BORIS SMOLAR
k| OW that the controversy within the
■ ^ United Palestine Appeal has become
public, it can be revealed that the leaders
of the U.P.A. in New York were amazed
by the attitude of the Jewish Agency in
Jerusalem. Immediately after the conflict
broke out, American members of the
Jewish Agency executive asked the exec-
utive in Jerusalem for a declaration con-
demning the dissidents within the U.P.A.
But this demand remained unanswered
and no clear statement has been received
from Israel even as this is being written.
On the other hand, Henry Montor, leader
of the dissident group, was apparently
expecting open support from Eliezer Kap-
lan, Israeli Finance Minister, but did not
get it.
The U.P.A. leaders here fear that other
dissident groups may be formed within
the Zionist movement in this country for
the purpose of securing funds from the
Jewish Federations and Welfare Funds, if
the pro-Montor group is not censured by
Israeli sources. They, therefore, cabled
the Jewish Agency in Jerusalem for a
second time stating that if no definite
declaration against the dissidents is forth-
coming, the U.P.A. may be whittled down
to the detriment of the entire Zionist
movement.
Meanwhile the pro-Montor group held
a secret conference at the Dixie Hotel in
New York to map its future campaign.
It is understood that the group intends
to organize, before the end of this year,
a national agency under the name of
"American Israel Fund" to compete with
the United Palestine Appeal.
Matters may change after the expected
arrival here of a Jewish Agency delegation
from Israel which will confer with mem-
bers of the American branch of the Jew-
ish Agency. The attitude of the Ameri-
can members is that the Jewish Agency
must make it known that it will not en-
dorse any new groups competing with the
U.P.A.
Mark wondered, what it must have been
like for him, a stranger in a new land,
unable to speak its language or to under-
stand its customs. Unlike Miss Leak's
grandfather, who had ridden trium-
phantly into battle, wielding his sword,
he had carried only a pack. That was
his only weapon in a fiercely hostile
world.
Suddenly, sitting on the sofa beside his
daughter, Mark felt a wave of sympathy
for the delicate old man, with the white
chin whiskers. And there was one story
he remembered . . .
"It was in the 70s when he came here.
This was only a village — where our main
street is today was a cotton patch. I
heard him tell, when I was a little boy
, . . how he rode up in his wagon — for
by then he had a team — to the bank of
the river. It was Friday night . . . what
he called Erev Shabbos — the eve of the
Sabbath. And though he saw the village
ahead, he knew he would not have time
to reach it before dark, so he stopped
here."
"What did he do?" asked Margie, eager
to hear a story.
Mark drew her closer to him. He
smiled, a feeling of warmth enveloped
him as he remembered his grandfather.
"Why, there in the fields, under a tree,
he put up his tent — and made prepara-
tions for his Shabbos. The next morning
he arose early and carefully recited his
prayers. And then all day he sat and
rested in the shade of the tree and studied
the plains and the small town before him.
It was going to be a great city, he knew,
because the river flowed to the sea, and
around the village were great fertile
plains, where the soil was black and rich.
He was tired of roaming the country.
Here he would settle down. And that
night at twilight, when the first star
twinkled in the sky, he broke camp and
made his way into town."
"But where did he stay that night?"
Margie asked.
That too was another story, and un-
fortunately, Mark did not know it. He
had never taken the time to ask his grand-
father, and now it was too late. These
girls in Miss Carrothers' School talked
of grandfathers who had killed Indians
and had cleared the forests . . . who had
marched away to fight in internecine
[Continued on page 15]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
A Sad Tale for Parents of Babies
MY BROTHER'S KIDS
Since the Review is always ready
to espouse causes it is happy to pub-
licize herewith the complaint con-
tained in the article below. Its
author is a high school youth liiing
in Cleveland, and he ivrites out of his
own bitter experience. What hap-
pened to him has doubtless happened
to many a youngster in the Center.
I HAD just come home from work, my
mind being troubled with all the
homework I had for school for the
following day. It was about seven
o'clock when I sat down to eat. I had
just begun when the phone rang. This
happened every day, and it was getting
on my nerves. Someone would always
call when I was trying to eat.
It seemed as if the phone would never
stop ringing. As I picked up the receiver
I could hear a small voice laughing at the
other end of the line. Already I under-
stood the meaning of this call. My
brother, Abe, wanted me to watch his
two little brats. In more refined lan-
guage, my nephew and niece.
I answered the phone with a timid hello.
My brother, not to be outdone, gave out
a mighty blast. "Hi buddy!"
"Yeah, — buddy!" I replied.
"Old Pal!" again boomed my brother.
"Yeah, — Old Pal!" I again replied.
This time I was going to have my way.
Sure, don't I always?
"No, I'm sorry Abe, but I've so much
homework, I don't even have a chance to
eat."
The line was silent for a few seconds,
and then it happened. Yes! My nephew
took the phone.
"Hello uncle Morrie." My brother was
trying to use psychology on me, but I
knew better. I had a strong will-power,
or did I?
"Hi there Uncle Billie," I replied, for
that is what I called him, Uncle! It made
him feel like a man.
The next few words my nephew said
started me burning. "Are you going to
watch me tonight, Uncle Morrie?"
"I'm sorry Billie, but I can't tonight.
I'm too busy," I said.
"Oh, please do," my dear nephew
seemed to say (plead).
"Where is daddy?" I asked, becoming
very irritated at my brother.
"Daddy doesn't want to talk to you,
so hurry and come over."
I could hear the telephone click and
as it did, I slammed the telephone down,
causing a short ring which seemed to re-
sound throughout the house. Although
I was speechless, I assure you that my
mind had nothing but words flowing
through it, but not one of them seemed
to be bad enough. Why? Because I
knew my brother had told my nephew
what to say. Yes, he dictated every
word. My Buddy!
In about an hour I arrived at my
brother's house. To my dismay, I saw
that my nephew was still awake, but at
least my niece was asleep. On one wall
there hung a cuckoo-clock which had
just chirped eight times, telling my
nephew it was time for him to go to bed.
Soon, my brother and sister-in-law left
the house, telling me they would be back
from the neighborhood movie by 11:30.
Naturally, my nephew didn't want to go
to bed, and as I tried to do some home-
work, he kept disturbing me. In about
an hour I had finished my trigonometry
paper, but I still had much more to do.
I got up to get a glass of water. As I
turned to return to my homework, I saw
my nephew laughing and jumping up and
down, and over the floor was an hour's
piece of work. My trigonometry paper
was torn to shreds. That did it! I im-
mediately picked up my nephew, threw
off his clothes and thrust him into his
bed. I no sooner sat down to continue
my homework when the little brat began
to whine as loud as he could. I walked
into his room, took off my belt, and
slapped it against the door as hard as I
could. This quieted him down until I
resumed my seat. Then, he began all over
again. This time I shut his door, but
he immediately opened it, and hopped
back into bed. He was quiet for about
a minute and then my niece started up.
I got up once more to see what was
wrong. She had just thrown up. I
changed her bed, bathed her and put her
to sleep. Once more my nephew com-
manded my attention. This time it was
By MORRIS MANDEL
legal. He had to go to the bathroom.
Since he was too small to reach the basin,
I had to lift him up. He couldn't wait
and I got pretty damp.
My nerves were on edge, and I still had
a test to study for. I should have known
I'd never be able to study for it, but I
had to try my best. I put the little brat
back into his bed, took a refreshing
shower and sat down to do some study-
ing. My nerves were becoming more en-
tangled. One more word from my
nephew, and I would have beat his brains
out. He was sleeping this time, so I
thought my worries were over. They
were, like heck. In the middle of a sen-
tence, the cuckoo-clock started up.
Eleven times. Enough to let me know
my brother and sister-in-law were due
back in half-an-hour, although I knew
they wouldn't be back 'till at least 1:00,
from past experiences.
About a half -hour later the man from
next door came home from work, and
couldn't fall asleep without the radio on.
He did everyone in the apartment build-
ing a favor. Yes! He turned the radio
on full blast so we could all hear the
world news. Luckily, this went on for
a little while only, for another tenant
helped him lower the radio.
The radio was no sooner turned down,
when I made a great discovery. Another
tenant also had a child, and he started
bawling. I felt like grabbing a frying
pan and going to work on the little darl-
ing. But he shut-up.
I tramped across the floor for about
fifteen minutes. This cooled me down a
little. I opened my book to do some
reading when who should pop up, but my
brother Abe and his wife.
"Hi buddy!" said my brother. Now
I was ready to let the words fly, but I
kept my temper. We all sat down to
a glass of tea and cookies and my wounds
were soon mended.
There is a moral to this story. What
is it? Well, you can't do anything about
it, but just be thankful if you are not
the youngest one in your family.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
NEWS
OF THE
MONTH
THE first national election in Israel
will be held between Jan. 10 and 15,
according to present plans of the
government as outlined by Nahum
Rafalkes-Nir, vice-chairman of the State
Council. The State Council decided that
the chairman of the election supervisory
committee will be a High Court judge
who will be elected by his colleagues.
Leaders of the Mizrachi, Hapoel Miz-
rachi, Agudath Israel, Poale Agudath
Israel and the independent Religious
Union decided at a joint meeting to form
a united Orthodox bloc at the forthcom-
ing general elections to the Constituent
Assembly. The two Mizrachi groups will
represent 60 percent of the bloc while the
Agudah organizations will make up the
remaining 40 percent.
Executive committees of all five of the
Orthodox groups participating in the
meeting must confirm the agreement.
The present estimates are that the Ortho-
dox bloc could poll between 20 and 25
percent of the total popular vote.
Members of the Stern Group plastered
Tel Aviv walls with posters demanding
the immediate release of - all Sternists.
"We will not tolerate their continued de-
tention," the posters read. Members of
the Stern Group have been under deten-
tion without trial since they were rounded
up by Israeli police and soldiers soon after
Count Bernadotte was assassinated.
•et
The bombing in Cairo of the Jewish-
owned building housing the Egyptian
Gazette, in which six persons were re-
ported killed and 70 injured, will be
brought by the Israeli Government to the
attention of the United Nations as "an
instance of the persecution of Jews in an
Arab state," an official spokesman an-
nounced.
it
Fritz Bernstein, Minister for Trade and
Industry, visiting Haifa, announced that
the government does not intend to na-
tionalize the refineries in the port city.
He expressed the hope that the plants
would re-open soon.
Petach Tikvah, known throughout
Israel as the "Mother of Jewish Settle-
ments," celebrated the 70th anniversary
of its establishment. Premier David Ben
Gurion was among the many distin-
guished guests participating in the cere-
monies.
A foundation stone was laid for the
erection of an orphan home which will
bear the name of Rabbi Eliezer Silver, of
Cincinnati, Orthodox leader in the United
States. One hundred children will reside
in the home, which will be built at a
cost of $100,000.
Peace in Israel will be achieved in two
months, Nathan Straus, president of radio
station WMCA, predicted upon his re-
turn from a month's visit to the Jewish
state. He declared that he expected peace
to come to Palestine "through the good
offices of Dr. Bunche and particularly
through the victories of the Israeli
Army."
A total of 70,000 Arabs and other non-
Jews are living in Israel and in 320 Israel-
occupied Arab villages, it was announced
by Minister for Minorities, Behor Shitreet.
The figure includes some 15,000 Bedouins
living in the Negev, but does not take
into account the Arabs living in Israeli-
held Lebanese territory.
Construction of a new railroad stretch-
ing from Hadera to Tel Aviv is presently
under consideration. Hadera is midway
between Haifa and Tel Aviv. The new
line would link up numerous coastal set-
tlements. Present plans call for the
Boneh Company to build the line at a
cost of $800,000.
•to
American special representative to
Israel, James G. MacDonald, declared that
he "forsees and prays" for an Israel which
is "not a copy of either the West or the
East but a free Israel — free to be itself."
Addressing a meeting of the Journalists'
Association of Tel Aviv, MacDonald de-
clared that mutual respect and sympathy
is essential for sound American-Israeli re-
lations. He also predicted Israel in the
future will cooperate with its Arab neigh-
bors, utilize its resources to settle the op-
THE WAR IN ISRAEL
Al S THE Review goes to press the gen-
eral feeling is that peace will come
to Israel within a reasonable time. Egypt
has been badly defeated, King Abdullah,
of Trans- Jordan, though still belligerent,
has advised a quick peaceful settlement
between Israel and the Arab world, and
outside military authorities have told the
Arabs their position, militarily, is hopeless.
In reply to the Security Council's de-
mand that Israel withdraw from the
Negev areas won recently and make the
territory a non-man's land, the Israeli
government replied that it would with-
draw all the extra forces sent into the
Negev for the campaign but retain its
troops in Beersheba and other areas or-
dered by the U.N. to be turned over to
Egyptj because they were necessary to
protect the entire Negev and Jerusalem.
In effect this was a diplomatic meeting
of the Council's demand.
Israel also informed the U.N. that it
was ready to negotiate an armistice as re-
quested by the Council, and had ap-
pointed representatives for this purpose.
It asked to be informed of the time and
place for a meeting with accredited Arab
representatives.
Meanwhile, Britain introduced a reso-
lution in the Political Committee of the
U.N. General Assembly calling for a set-
tlement on the basis of the Bernadotte
report. The United States and other
countries refused to join Britain in this
act, although Secretary Marshall had en-
dorsed the report in September and urged
its acceptance. Now, however, it was
said that America could not support the
report without some important changes
to make it acceptable to Israel. Ameri-
can sources said the American position
would be in accord with the statement
made by President Truman recently that
he would not favor boundary changes in
Palestine unless acceptable to Israel.
It was noted that Britain, in the reso-
lution, referred to the "Jewish State,"
thus implying recognition of Israel.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
pressed Jews of other lands and serve as
a model of economic and social develop-
ment.
ft
Circassians living on both sides of the
Palestine-Lebanon frontier are flocking to
Israeli Army positions in Galilee to join
up with the Jews, it was reported by the
Hebrew press in Tel Aviv. The develop-
ment is credited to the fine showing made
by Circassian and Druze troops, which
recently fought their first engagement as
units of the Israeli Army in Galilee,
ft
The British Government has decreed its
first economic sanction against Israel.
Israeli banking authorities in London
have been notified that the current re-
lease of a million pounds sterling — about
four million dollars — from Palestine's
frozen sterling balance has not been au-
thorized by the Treasury.
This sterling release was being used
mainly for the payment for Israel's food
purchases abroad. No official reason has
been given for the Treasury's action, but
a connection with events at the U.N.
session and in southern Palestine is not
denied.
ft
At a General Zionist reception in Paris,
Jorge Garcia Granados, Guatemalan dele-
gate to the U.N. and former member of
the United Nations Special Committee on
Palestine, bitterly criticized British policy
in Palestine and said that there would
have been no fighting in Palestine except
that "a government forgot its own
pledges." The White Paper is a "shame
not only for Britain, but for humanity,"
he said.
ft
United Nations' intervention is ham-
pering the establishment of permanent
peace in Palestine, Isaac Ben Zvi, presi-
dent of the Jewish National Council in
Israel, declared upon his arrival in New
York. Mr. Ben Zvi is in the United
States to aid the $10,000,000 campaign
currently under way in behalf of the
Histadruth.
Asserting that "it is one thing to order
the demilitarization of the Negev and an-
other thing to enforce it," Ben Zvi stated
that "if we could be sure that real con-
trol would be maintained in the demili-
tarization of the Negev by the United
Nations, we would take this demilitariza-
tion proposal more seriously.
"Insofar as giving up the Negev is con-
cerned," he added, "our answer is defi-
nitely 'no.' " The Israeli leader charged
that "arms are being delivered to the
Arabs from the outside" and that there
are "British, Yugoslavs and Germans
fighting with the Arabs." Hailing the
role of the Histadruth, Israel's general
federation of labor, in the development
of the Jewish state, Mr. Ben Zvi declared
that all of the Histadruth 's facilities have
been made available to the Israeli Gov-
ernment during the war period.
•Ct
Pledges totaling approximately
$3,000,000 in shares of the Israeli Cor-
poration of America, recently organized
by Zionist leaders to foster the economic
upbuilding of Israel, were subscribed at
the first national ZOA Economic Confer-
ence on Israel of the Zionist Organization
of America, which convened in New
York. As its first business project, the
ICA has entered into a partnership agree-
ment with the Jewish Agency for the
first large-scale housing projects to be
built in the Jewish state.
Dr. Emanuel Neumann, president of
the Z.O.A., told the conference that the
Zionist movement is now witnessing the
closing of its political phase. "Commis-
sions and committees in Paris might de-
cide this and that," he said, "but the au-
thentic decision is being given in Israel
itself." The present flow of Jewish im-
migration, said Dr. Neumann, was "over-
whelming." He predicted that the total
of immigration into Israel for the months
of November and December might come
to 50,000. The economic upbuilding of
the country which will follow this
growth will open a rich field for Ameri-
can investment, the Z.O.A. head said.
Dr. Israel Goldstein, Jewish Agency
treasurer, told the conference that 3 0,000
housing units are required to provide ade-
quately for newcomers to Israel. This,
he said, would entail an expenditure of
S64,000,000. "This is more than the
Jewish Agency treasury can bear," he
said. "The Agency is therefore glad to
enter into arrangements with corporation
investment groups which are ready to
provide a portion of the capital needed
for this purpose."
Otto Gass, economic adviser to Israel,
said that the Jewish state will require a
minimum of a billion dollars in private
investment in the next four years in order
to integrate the immigrants in the na-
tion's economy. He urged that American
Jews, in making investments, divest
themselves of a philanthropic approach.
The investors, he said, must give not
merely their money, but the benefit of
their commercial experience and thinking.
NEWS OF JERUSALEM
I ERUSALEM was subjected to heavy
J Arab shelling. Six Jewish casualties
were reported. A house situated in "no-
man's land" was also blown up.
Air raid sirens sounded in Haifa and
Rehovoth and anti-aircraft guns went
into action.
The Consular Truce Commission pro-
fessed to have no knowledge of the pres-
ence of British troops on Jerusalem's
Mount of Olives, as charged by Israeli au-
thorities.
Rene Neuville, French Consul-General
and chairman of the commission, added:
"France firmly supports the international-
ization of Jerusalem which is the sole so-
lution for safeguarding the Holy Places
of three great religions."
Plans for the revival of Jerusalem were
outlined here by Rabbi Zeev Gold, head
of the Jewish Agency's department for
developing this city. Rabbi Gold based
his program on bringing new immigrants
into Jerusalem, on restoring old indus-
tries and establishing new ones. He ad-
vocated the promotion of the city's fa-
mous stone-cutting industry and the en-
couragement of use of the product abroad
as cornerstones for Jewish buildings and
as tombstones.
The first unofficial figures on the Israeli
Government's population census for Jeru-
salem became known. The poll reports
that there are more than 80,000 Jews liv-
ing in the Jewish-held part of the city
as compared with 1,5 00 non-Jews, includ-
ing members of the consular corps and
the United Nations observers and their
staffs.
Jewish welfare funds in key cities in
the United States were invited by the
United Palestine Appeal to send two rep-
resentatives each to a conference at which
the question of implementing the U.P.A.
decision for expanding its governing
bodies through inclusion of one-third
representation of Jewish communities will
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
be discussed, it was announced by Her-
man L. Veisman, acting national chair-
man of the U.P.A.
The 103 welfare funds which received
this invitation were also the recipients of
a memorandum from Mr. Wcisman assur-
ing them that "the United Palestine Ap-
peal is equal to bringing about the most
effective and representative organization
which will ensure a completely unified
effort enabling the American Jewish com-
munity to rise to the unprecedented op-
portunity for Jewish settlement in Israel
and for the relief to our brethren over-
seas."
Noting that the United Palestine Ap-
peal is "cognizant of the necessity of
promptly organizing the United Jewish
Appeal effort for 1949," Mr. Weisman
said in his memorandum that while dis-
cussions of a precise formula for repre-
sentation are not yet completed, "the
executive bodies of the U.P.A. and Joint
Distribution Committee are getting ready
to re-establish the United Jewish Appeal
for 1949."
A national conference of fund-raising
leaders of Jewish communities who sup-
port the opposition within the United
Palestine Appeal will be held in Atlantic
City on December 11 and 12, it was an-
nounced by the newly-formed "Commit-
tee of Contributors and Workers."
The new group, which advocates the
launching of a drive for Israel separate
from the United Palestine Appeal, has ad-
vised the Jewish Agency in Jerusalem of
the convocation of the national confer-
ence. It informed the Agency that
"prompt action will be taken to provide
immediate funds for the expanded immi-
gration, resettlement, upbuilding and re-
construction program contemplated for
1949."
A statement issued by Abraham Fein-
berg, chairman of the new group, out-
lined its objectives as follows:
"1. All American Jews shall share in
the responsibility for raising funds for
Israel in 1949; 2. All funds raised in the
United States for Israel shall be remitted
directly to Israel; 3. Final authority for
allocations and disbursements of funds re-
mitted to Israel from the Jews of Amer-
ica shall rest with the executive of the
Jewish Agency in Israel."
Meanwhile, Berl Locker, chairman of
the Jewish Agency executive in Jerusa-
lem, arrived in New York to consult with
the American members of the executive
on the conflict which has developed with-
in the United Palestine Appeal leading to
the recent resignation of Henry Montor
from his post as U.P.A. executive
director.
Calling for a continuation of unified
fund raising in 1949, more than 200 dele-
gates to the 15 th annual conference of
the New England Region of the Council
of Jewish Federations and Welfare Funds,
passed a resolution urging communities
not to take independent action in matters
affecting the current differences between
the United Palestine Appeal and the
Committee of Contributors and Workers,
until a full report has been submitted by
the C.J.F.W.F. Conciliation Committee.
Establishment of the C.J.F.W.F. Con-
ciliation Committee was commended by
the delegates as "representative of the in-
terests of communities in working toward
unity in fund raising."
Rabbi Immanuel Jakobovits, spiritual
leader of the Great Synagogue of London,
has been appointed Chief Rabbi of Eire.
The new chief rabbi will assume his du-
ties toward the end of January, 1949, and
will be formally inducted by Chief Rabbi
SOME 450,000 dunams (112,500 acres)
of land, abandoned by Arabs fleeing
Palestine, have already been turned over
to Jews for cultivation, Agriculture Min-
ister Aaron Zisling told a press confer-
ence. Flalf the land has been sown in
winter crops and half in summer crops.
The cultivation of so much new land
was made possible by the Treasury's guar-
antee to the Anglo-Palestine Bank, on the
strength of which the bank lent some
$1,600,000 to farmers and settlement
groups. Plans were under discussion to
establish a $4,000,000 fund to aid farm-
ers.
Zisling also revealed that two shipping
experts have been sent abroad to purchase
fishing trawlers. There are plans in ex-
istence to build a major fishing port at
the town of Caesaria, south of Haifa, he
stated. The output of the fishing indus-
try on Lake Tiberias is being increased
Lamed Prize-Winners
Four prizes of $400 each for the best
books in Yiddish and Hebrew published
in the United States during 1947 were
won by two Yiddish and two Hebrew
writers. The prizes are awarded annually
by the Louis Lamed Fund, which seeks
to promote literary standards among Jews
in the United States. The jury was com-
posed of H. Lcivick, Kadie Molodowsky
and Dr. Aaron Steinberg.
The Yiddish winners are: Aaron Glanz-
Leyeless, for his book of poems, "A Jew
at Sea," and David Opatoshu, for a book
of short stories, "Between Sea and
Desert." The Hebrew winners are:
Ephraim Lisitzky, for his volume, "Man
on Earth," and Isiah Rabinowitz for his
book of essays, "Literature During the
Crisis of a Generation."
Israel Brodie, of Great Britain. Rabbi
Jakobovits, who is 27 years old, will prob-
ably be the youngest chief rabbi in the
world. A native of Koenigsberg, he came
to England in 1936 from Berlin. He was
educated at Jews College in London and
was ordained at the Yeshiva of Etz
Chaim in England last year. The post
of Chief Rabbi of Eire has been vacant
for ten years.
by the stocking of the lakes with 5 0,000
young carp.
The exportable citrus crop this year
will amount to about 6,000,000 cases,
Zisling estimated. Sales contracts have
already been signed with Britain, Sweden,
Czechslovakia, Ireland and Norway, while
negotiations are in progress with Holland,
France and Poland.
C. Halperin, director of the Ministry,
disclosed a decision of the Ministry to
allocate 9 5 percent of the country's arable
lands to agricultural settlements. He es-
timated that the country's water resources
were sufficient to water 8,000,000 dunams
(2,000,000 acres), which could provide
food for 15,000,000 people. At present,
he pointed out, only 200,000 dunams arc
irrigated and there is an immediate need
for 1,000,000 more in order to supply the
present population with food without
having to import any of it.
Industrial and Agricultural Progress in Israel
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
IS
Letter to the ''Review'*
CONCERNING OUR CHILDREN'S EDUCATION
IT WAS Joseph's first day of school.
He came home bringing back with him
a great, big surprise, as he put it, which
he refused to divulge to any one. He was
keeping it for his daddy. Finally dad
arrived. Joseph rushed to greet him with
more than his usual glee. "Dad, I have
a surprise for you," he shouted. "But
you'll never, never guess what it is!
Shalom, daddy, Shalom! That's the first
word we learned in Hebrew!"
I could not help thinking of the power
of some words — mysterious, profound,
searching. Take the word Shalom — a
word for which men "hnve from the be-
ginning of the world starved more than
for bread." And then I thought of Dr.
George N. Shuster's very touching and
timely essay, "The Word and the World:
A Challenge," in which he says, "I am
old-fashioned enough to think that edu-
cation is worthwhile if at some time, per-
haps when one is least expecting it, some
word is spoken, which lights up the earth
and the heaven of life."
•
This thought comes to my mind as I
contemplate the purpose and the achieve-
ment of one of the schools of our Brook-
lyn Jewish Center, the Center Academy.
No doubt we are aware of the changes
that were made in the Curriculum of the
Center Academy and the subsequent
changes that followed in the set-up of
the school. The attitude on the part of
some of the parents seemed to me rather
incxcusabfe. That is the reason for this
letter.
Here we are, a more or less select group
of parents willing and obviously able to
pay for a particular kind of education for
our children. What do we want? Tak-
ing into account that we cannot with
any precision foretell what will or will
not be of most value in later life, par-
ticularly for a child of a minority group
who may be faced with racial prejudice,
I do know that I want the following for
my son:
First: Facility in handling, what some
educators call the "tool subjects," namely,
reading, writing and 'rithmetic.
Secondly: Knowledge and acquain-
tance with what are known as, "appre-
ciation subjects or intangibles," namely,
literature, history, art, music, nature, and
with that, as he grows older, an aware-
ness that "man is more than his religious
sect, more than a supporter of a particu-
lar economic system, more than a nation-
alist."
•
I am old-fushioned enough to believe
that what counts most in the learning
process of normal children is a patient,
sympathetic, understanding teacher ac-
companied by a demand for hard, earnest
work and a maximum of effort and at-
tention on the part of the pupil, and not
so much the newest fads and frills of
so-called progressive schools.
Were I merely interested in the aims
and objectives as set forth above, our
Public School System, its shortcomings
notwithstanding (and there arc many of
them), would be good enough for my
boy. It so happens that I want some-
thing more. I am, therefore, sending my
son to a Jewish Center Academy pri-
marily because this particular school also
provides an additional tangible tool — the
power and use of another spoken and
written word and also an additional rich
source of intangibles in the form of
Hebrew literature, Hebrew tradition,
Hebrew music and art. To me, these are
as essential for Joseph's well being, as are
the prerequisites already mentioned.
As for the argument that an increased
Hebrew schedule interferes with the
learning of English and that it tends to
narrow the child's scope, it need not be
necessarily so. As a matter of fact I find
that Joseph has become more word-
conscious and more sound-conscious even
where English is concerned, and there
is a deepened awareness and a feel-
ing for differences and similarities in
sounds and meanings of words. More-
over, the introduction to the rich lore
of Bible stories and Hebrew festivals
has helped materially to enlarge his con-
cepts, his experiences, his outlook.
In conclusion, then, I want this inten-
sive Hebrew training for my child be-
cause I believe it will help him grow in
wisdom and understanding not merely as
a Jew but also as an American and as a
human being. And if, as a result of trm
training, he is a little more sensitive to
injustices and "hurt," it is just as well,
even if within the next decade or two the
world docs grow less callous, more hu-
mane, more considerate, more respectful
of the rights and dignity of man.
— Marcia C. R. Borowsky.
THE ANCESTOR
[Continued from page 10)
wars. But his grandfather's stories, too,
Mark knew, were part of the folklore of
the land — the man who was the first of
his race to come into the village . . . and
whose store grew with the teeming city.
"At first," said Mark, "the villagers
were not friendly. He was a stranger
and they were suspicious of him. But
one night there was a fire in the village.
It threatened the whole town. The men
had to fight it with buckets of water
and their own swift legs. The wind was
strong and their homes were in danger
of being destroyed, but all night they
fought with their pails of water, and in
the morning, when the danger was past
and they rubbed away the grime and
srnoot from their faces to see who had
stayed the long night, they found grand-
father in their midst He too had helped
save the village."
"And what did they do?." asked
Margie.
"I will tell you," Mark said. "The
mayor was big enough to admit to grand-
father they had misjudged him. 'We
thought you were like the rest, but now
we see you are a brave man,' he said.
But grandfather shook his head. 'No,'
he replied, 'do not separate me from my
people. If you knew them, you would
find they too are like me.' "
"Just think," cried Margie, "I can tell
my grandchildren about him. They'll
really be proud of him. He'll be their
ancestor too. Let me sec ... a great-
great-great . . ."
Frances put down her paper. Unwel-
come thoughts seemed to. press harder in
her mind. An ironic smile played over
Mark's lips. He had suddenly realized
that Crest Park, over by the river, must
have been the spot where grandfather
camped the night he rested over the
S/Mos!
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
NEWS OF THE CENTER-
Rabbi Saltzman to Preach
Thanksgiving Sermon at Late
Friday Night Services
This Friday night, November 26th,
at our late Friday evening services Rabbi
Saltzman will speak on the subject "Mir-
acles Do Happen — A Thanksgiving Day
Sermon." November 29th marks the
first anniversary of the very fateful day
in Jewish history when the United Na-
tions passed the partition plan. Rabbi
Saltzman will discuss the miracles that
have taken place in Jewish life in Israel
and in the Diaspora during the past year
as well as in the lives of the American
people. He will treat his theme with the
background of the Thanksgiving holiday
and will dwell on the import and sig-
nificance of these miracles to our reli-
gious thinking.
Cantor Sauler will lead in the congre-
gational singing and render a vocal selec-
tion. Members, their families and friends
are cordially invited to attend.
Advance Notice
Next Friday evening, December 3rd,
at our late Friday night services, Rabbi
Levinthal will preach on the subject
"The Problem of the Dissident Groups in
the New State of Israel."
Isidor Fine to be Honored
At Testimonial Dinner
The seventieth birthday anniversary
of Mr. Isidor Fine, former President of
the Brooklyn Jewish Center, will be cele-
brated at a Testimonial Dinner to be
given at the Center on Thursday evening,
December 16th. The dinner is arranged
under the auspices of the Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center committee on behalf of the
Jewish Theol-Seminary and the United
Synagogue of America. Reservations at
$7. SO may be made at the office of the
Center.
Sisterhood Executive Board
Meeting December 6th
The next Executive Board meeting of
the Sisterhood will be held on Monday
afternoon, December 6th, at 1 o'clock
promptly. Members of the Board are
urged to attend.
Junior League
The next regular meeting of the
Junior League scheduled for Thursday
evening, December 2nd, will feature a
Solemn Service Marks Unveilins of Tablet in Memory
of Center War Martyrs
A congregation that filled our Syna-
gogue to overflowing attended the ser-
vices on Shemini Atzeres, October 2 5 th,
when a special and solemn service, in
addition to the regular Yizkor prayers,
was conducted by Rabbi Levinthal in
loving memory of the sons and grand-
sons of Center members who gave their
lives in defense of our country during
the recent second world war. The tab-
let, which adorns the front wall of the
Synagogue, was unveiled by Mr. Max N.
Koven, the chairman of the special com-
mittee to arrange for this tribute.
Rabbi Levinthal, in his sermon that
morning, spoke of the deeper meaning of
their heroic sacrifice, and the message
their death has for our day. The tablet
bears . the following inscription: "The
Brooklyn Jewish Center dedicates this
tablet in fond memory of its beloved
sons who in defense of their country and
the ideals of humanity made the supreme
sacrifice in World War II."
Antell, Charles Nov. 27, 1941
Brimberg, Isaac Nov. 27, 1943
Goell, Julian T. Oct. 7,1944
Green, Marvin Apr. 12,1945
Karron, Murray Jan. 9, 1945
Price, George F. Jan. 15,1945
Schnell, Sidney Oct. 11, 1944
Sovatkin, Stanley B. Nov. 13, 1942
"May their sacrifice be precious in Thy
Sight."
Forum on the future development of the
Jewish State. The subject of discussion
will be "Whither Israel?" The usual so-
cial hour will follow the meeting and all
Junior Leaguers are cordially invited to
attend.
Junior Clubs
Rabbi Saltzman is very happy to an-
nounce that although there has been a
very fine registration in our Junior Clubs,
registration is still open to children of
Center members and to children of our
Hebrew and Religious Schools who are
ten years of age and older. Parents are
urged to advise their children to partici-
pate in the very fine program of social,
athletic and Young Judean activities con-
ducted in our clubs which meet on Sat-
urday evenings at 7 o'clock. Since the
inception of our club program on Octo-
ber 16th, the following subjects have
been the themes of the club meetings:
"The Balfour Declaration" in celebration
of Balfour Day; "The Jewish Ideals of
Peace" in celebration of Armistice Day;
"The Jew in the World Wars." The re-
lationship between Jews and Arabs were
discussed and portrayed. Plans are being
made for the celebration of Jewish Book
Month and the Chanukah Holiday.
Junior Congregation News
A kiddusi i will be given to the Junior
Congregation this Sabbath morning, No-
vember 27th, by Mr. and Mrs. Morris
Brukenfeld.
Acknowledgment of Gifts
We acknowledge with thanks re-
ceipt of the following donations for the
purchase of Prayer Books, Talcisim and
Books for our Library:
Mr. and Mrs. Alex Bernstein in honor
of the Bar Mitzvah of their grandson,
Richard.
Mr. and Mrs. Louis Halperin.
Mr. and Mrs. Julius Kushner, in honor
of the Bar Mitzvah of their son, Harold.
Mr. and Mrs. Herman Rothstein, in
honor of the Bar Mitzvah of their son,
David.
Dr. and Mrs. Isaac Salevitz, in honor
of the Bar Mitzvah of their son, Bernard.
Congratulations
Hearty congratulations and best
wishes are extended to:
Dr. and Mrs. Samuel Lubin of 847
Park Place on the marriage of their
daughter, Loretta, to Mr. Monroe Fink
at the Center on November 2 5th.
Mrs. Hannah O. Jaffe of 1 33 5 Carroll
Street on the marriage of her son, Albert
Samuel, to Miss Phyllis Jadwin of Chi-
cago, on November 21st.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
Open Meeting of the Nominating
Committee, Monday Evening
The Nominating Committee will have
an open meeting on Monday evening, No-
vember 29th, at 8:00 o'clock. Members
of the Center who may wish to make
suggestions for nominations of officers,
members of the Board of Trustees or
Governing Board arc urged to come that
evening and present their recommenda-
tions.
Testimonial Dinner to
Dr. Michael Higger
The faculty of the Jewish Theological
Seminary of America and the Rabbinical
Assembly of America tendered a Testi-
monial Luncheon to Dr. Michael Higger,
who is a lecturer at our own Institute of
Jewish Studies for Adults, on Wednesday,
November 17th. The tribute was in
honor of the appearance of the tenth vol-
ume of Dr. Higger's monumental work
"Otzar Ha-Beraytot." Dr. Levinthal was
one of the many distinguished speakers
who paid tribute to Dr. Higger's scholar-
ship and devotion to Jewish learning on
that occasion.
Young Folks League
The Young Folks League meeting on
Tuesday evening, November 30th, will be
devoted to the celebration of "Jewish
Book Month." A review of a current
book will be presented. The usual social
hour will follow the meeting. Admission
will be limited only to members present-
ing their membership cards.
Personals
Mrs. Murray Rosen, daughter of Mr.
and Mrs. Morris B. Levine, has been
awarded by Columbia University the de-
gree of Doctor of Philosophy in the field
of Semitic language.
Mr. Harry Blickstein, Chairman of our
Forum and Education Committee, de-
livered an address on "Your Synagogue
and Mine — Its Scope and Its Task," at
the annual meeting of the Metropolitan
Council of the United Synagogue of
America. Mr. Benjamin Markowe was
elected Secretary-Treasurer of the council.
Boy Scout News
Boy Scouts of America, Troop 12 5,
meets every Monday night at 7:30
o'clock at the Center. Swimming ses-
sions are held every third Monday and
hikes are held every other week. Sons
of Center members, 12 years and over,
are eligible and are invited with their
friends to join.
Inta-League News
The Inta-League opened its season
with several exceptional programs. On
November 6th a debate was held on the
subject "Resolved that the Young Amer-
ican Jew Should Emigrate to Israel." The
affirmative was taken by Tobia Brown,
Stanley Green and Thomas Kraner. The
negative was taken by Ann Joy Levitt,
Shirley Aranow and Paul Kozinn. Mrs.
Laura Rubin, co-leader of the Inta-League
Girls group was moderator in the dy-
namic discussion which followed. On
November 13 th the Eternal Light Script
"Certificate Entry" was presented. The
direction, music and production was com-
pletely in the hands of the members of
the club. It was very enthusiastically
received by the audience. At the meet-
ing on October 30th, Mr. Herbert Kum-
mel, leader of the Inta-League Boys,
presided at the election of officers, which
are listed as follows: President — Thomas
Kraner; 1st Vice President — Ann Joy
Levitt; 2nd Vice President — Stanley
Green; Secretary — Tobia Brown; Chair-
man of Executive Committee — Arthur
Viders. This group meets Saturday eve-
nings at 8:30 o'clock.
A CULTURAL DYNAMO
FOR JUDAISM
[Continued from page 3]
has had an almost intuitive, even pro-
phetic insight in the work of uniting the
best in Jewish tradition with the finest
in our American heritage. From its por-
tals have gone forth the most prominent
American rabbis, including our own be-
loved Rabbi Levinthal. The Teachers In-
stitute of the Seminary has trained the
foremost Jewish educators, and its teach-
ers arc serving in every important Jewish
community in our country.
Through its "Eternal Light" program
every Sunday morning on the N.B.C.
net-work, it has brought the message of
Judaism into the homes of millions of
Americans, Jews and non-Jews. It has
been beamed to Europe and has been
translated into many languages. The
Jewish Museum of the Seminary, the first
of its kind in the United States and prob-
ably the largest in the world, besides its
extraordinary exhibits of Jewish art, an-
IN THE HEBREW SCHOOL
Our annual Simchat Torah celebra-
tion proved to be a great success. 700
children and parents crowded into the
auditorium to view the spectacle.
A Simchat Torah play, written and di-
rected by Mrs. E. Zusman, was presented
with the following cast of students: Ed-
ward Bressman, Isaac Dressner, Allan En-
tin, Reuben Epstein, Lawrence Glassberg,
Robert Granovsky, Herbert Jacobson,
Barry Lipson, Judith Liebowitz, Edward
Nelson, Naomi Raphael, Martin Sloate,
Charles Stein, Mitchel Streger, Joseph Zcl-
vin, Edward Klein, Madeline Meerbaum,
Charles Monto, Ellen Gofscyeff, Lila
Berger, Paula Spinrad and Larry Levy.
An address was given by Rabbi Lewit-
tes and Rabbi Saltzman inducted new
members.
Fruits were distributed to the children
by a P.T.A. committee headed by Mrs. J.
Kushner.
The celebration attracted the attention
of the Yiddish press.
A new banner to encourage Junior
Congregation attendance has been pre-
sented to the Hebrew School by Mr. J.
Heimowitz. The first class to win the
banner for excellent attendance was Mrs.
Weinrib's 4A' class.
cicnt and modern, conducts a wide and
varied program of service for the public.
The Seminary possesses the largest collec-
tion of books and manuscripts in the
world.
The campaign to raise $50,000 in the
Brooklyn Jewish Center on behalf of the
Seminary will culminate in a testimonial
dinner to Mr. Isidor Fine on the occasion
of his seventieth birthday, December 16,
1948. Mr. Fine, a former President of
our Center, has, for many years been a
pillar of strength to our institution and
our community. Long a friend of the
Seminary, he has chosen to join his own
Simcha with its cause. With great humil-
ity he prefers that we honor him by
doing honor to the Seminary.
It is the heartfelt hope of his friends
that by reason of strength gained from
association with the cause of God, Torah,
and Israel, we will gather again ten years
hence to honor Isidor Fine after another
decade of service.
— Manuel Saltzman.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Abelman, Jack
Res. 5 52 Parksidc Ave.
Bus. Electric, -477 — 7th Ave.
Single
Proposed by Herbert N. Altneu,
Morris Swerlin
Ackerman, Jack
Res. 201 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Furs, 841— 6th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Herman Lambert,
Judge J. Schwartzwald
Bariban, Miss Lillian
Res. 79 Legion St.
Bassin, Miltox G.
Res. 56 5 Crown St.
Bus. Engr. Instructor, 300 Pearl St.
Single
Proposed by Herbert Altneu,
Martin Bruckner
Bauer. Miss Shirley
Res. 320 Eastern Pkwy.
Proposed by Harry Passales,
Edna Malatzky
Bernhaut, Miss Claire
Res. 71 Morton St.
Birnbach, Miss Edna
Res. 367 E. 45th St.
Blumberg, Abraham
Res. 422 Saratoga Ave.
Bus. Consulting Engr., 60 E. 23rd St.
Single
Brozell, Miss Sally
Res. 680 Rivcrdale Ave.
Brown, Harold M.
Res. 187 Sullivan Pi.
Bus. Attorney, 70 Pine St.
Married
Proposed by Joseph Levy, Jr.,
Sidney H. Brown
Boyar, Louis
Res. 2110 Union St.
Bus. Locksmith, 1259 E. N. Y. Ave.
Married
Probosed by Geo. Fcldman,
Charney, Miss Eileen
Res. 281 Crown St.
Proposed by Lillian Schlusscl,
Mrs. I. Lowcnfeld
Coblrt, Maxwell
Res. 4S9 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Dresses, 13 5 0 Bway.
Single
Proposed by Morris Hecht
Cortin, Miss Dlbbil
Res. 241 E. 96th St.
Proposed by Abe Mann,
Abraham Pindek
Donenson, Miss Rose
Res. 1 593 Prospect Pi.
Dressler, Miss Lucille
Res. 308 Sterling St.
Proposed by Betty Lusthaus
Druckerman, Ben
Res. 315 E. 94th St.
Bus. Linens, 401 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Herbert J. O'Koskin
Elkin, Miss Sari
Res. Ill Watkins St.
Proposed by Samuel Kaye
Fuder, Miss Mildred
Res. 5 1 Legion St.
Proposed by Samuel Kaye
Feinstein, Alfred Z.
Res. 93 0 E. 89th St.
Bus. Acct., 3 3 W. 42nd St.
Single
Fine, Albert W.
Res. 2990 Brighton 12th St.
Bus. Insurance, 217 Bway.
Single
Proposed by Emanuel Berlin,
S. Stevens
Fine, Jerome
Res. 739 Sheffield Ave.
Bus. Underwear, 72 Spring St.
Single
Proposed by Nat Horowitz
Galperin, Leon
Res. 763 Eastern Pkwy.
Israel Kaplan
Buck, Bernard L.
Res. 3 24 New York Ave.
Bus. Real Estate, 22 5 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Samuel Lcmberg,
Joseph Goldberg
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Bus. Auto Repairs, 1078 Bedford Ave.
Married
Proposed by Joseph Goldstein
Gl LLFR, MlSS CLAIRI
Res. 293 5 Ocean Pkwy.
Proposed by Samuel Kaye,
Sam Florowitz
Ginsbi rg, Harold A.
Res. 312 E. 21st St.
Bus. Candy, 942 Flatbush Ave.
Single
Proposed by Abraham Goldsmith,
Sam Schoenfeld
Gnaizda, Samuel
Res. 61 E. 96th St.
Bus. Drugs, 8 53 E. N. Y. Ave.
Married
Goldmlier, Larry
Res. 291 Lincoln Rd.
Bus. Bicycles, 594 Glenmore Ave.
Single
Goldsmith, Miss Muriel
Res. 289 Empire Blvd.
Proposed by Ben Berke,
David Gold
Goldstein, Albert H.
Res. 1115 Union St.
Bus. Acct., 225 W. 34th St.
Married
Gurvitch, Nathan
Res. 742 Montgomery St.
Bus. Furs, 224 W. 30th St.
Single
Proposed by Gerald and Harold Jacobs
Herskowitz, Joshua P.
Res. 5 5 E. 57th St.
Bus. C. P. A., 501— 5th Ave.
Single
Hochberg, Sol
Res. 9027 Kings Hway.
Bus. Clothing, 13 E. 16th St.
Single
Hoffman, Dr. Sidney
Res. 360 Ocean Pkwy.
Bus. Physician, Same
Single
Proposed by Dr. Irvin J. Sparer,
Rubin Gralla
Holtz, Miss Pearl
Res. 1384 Carroll St.
Proposed by William Sells,
Philip Rossow
Isaacson, Abraham
Res. 3 68 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Stationers, 10 Hanover St.
Married
Kaplan, Miss Shirley H.
Res. 1154 St. Marks Ave.
Karon, Miss Shirley F.
Res. 1551 Carroll St.
Proposed by Dr. Milo M. Bcrkowitz,
Marvin Blickstcin
Kfmpner, Miss Shirlee
Res. 424 Amboy St.
19
Kraiman, Miss Annl
Res. 1 5 Lloyd St.
Proposed by Abe Mann,
Abraham Pindek
Kri i rzr r, Miss Br. at rick
Res. 367 E. 45th St.
Kl'RSS, MURRY
Res. 2044 Pacific St.
Bus. Engineering, 22 5 E. 144th St.
Single
I.i.powitz, Miss Plorfnce
Res. 133 Rivcrdalc Ave.
Laxgsam, Lfo
Res. 28 5 Albany Ave.
Bus. Boilers, 19 Rector St.
Single
Proposed by Dr. Alexander Left,
Morris LefT
Malick, Gfrson
Res. 658 Crown St.
Bus. Wool, 23 5 Mercer St.
Married
Maron, Miss Jean
Res. 420 Eastern Pkwy.
Novins, Miss Pauline
Res. 428 Neptune Ave.
Proposed by Howard Levenson,
Stanley Levenson
Orland, Maxwell W.
Res. 570 LcfFerts Ave.
Bus. Resident Buyer
Married
Proposed by Jack Silverman
Peltz, Julius
Res. 1051 Carroll St.
Bus. Acct., 307— 5th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Dr. Frank G. Bass
Person, Miss Frances
Res. 4132 Bedford Ave.
Polishook, Philip
Res. 143 Linden Blvd.
Bus. Jewelry, 31 W. 47th St.
Married
Proposed by Mrs. R. Davis,
• Dr. M. Goldberger
Roberts, A. H.
Res. 1028 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Engineer
Single
Proposed by Abraham B. Kazdan
Rosi nberg, Miss Frances
Res. 114 E. 5 3rd St.
Proposed by Harry Passales,
Hy Rosen
Rothbaum, Theodore
Res. 465 Sheffield Ave.
Bus. Springs, 168 Sanford St.
Single
Proposed by Mr. and Mrs. Isador
Lowenfeld
Rubin, FIerman M.
Res. 567 Sheffield Ave.
Bus. Dry Goods, 275 Grand St.
Single
Proposed by Louis Weber,
Herbert Baskin
S( hreer, William
Res. 1966— 72nd St.
Bus. Iron and Steel, 5 54 Metropolitan
Ave.
Single
Proposed by Sol Palley,
Nat Bern hard
Seidler, Miss Rosalyn T.
Res. 88 8 Montgomery St.
Proposed by Dr. Alexander LefF,
Morris LefF
Si.atin, Miss Phyllis
Res. 732 Essex St.
Proposed by Jules W. and Sidney A.
Gold
Stein, Miss Judith
Res. 721 Empire Blvd.
Proposed by Leah Zimmerman,
Ruth Schmulowitz
Stein, Sidney
Res. 314 Park Pi.
Bus. Furniture, 79 Clifton Pi.
Single
Proposed by Solomon Sorscher,
Michael Kahn
Steingut, Stanley
Res. 706 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Vending, 27 Moore St.
Married
Proposed by Hon. Irwin Steingut,
Hon. Wm. I. Siegel
Stern, Miss Muriel
Res. 5 3 East 43rd St.
Srii.LMAN, Miss Rose
Res. 520 Crown St.
Sw'arzman, Ira
Res. 919 Park Pi.
./ o I V
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
CONGREGATIONAL
SINGING GROUP
and
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
CHORAL GROUP
under the Uatlrrship of
SHOLOM SECUNDA
The Choral Group, consisting of men
and women, meets on the 1st, 3rd and
5th Monday evenings and on the 2nd
and 1th Wednesday evenings at S:1.5
o'clock.
Members of the Center and their
friends who wish to join one or both
of these groups are asked to please
leave their names at the information
de.sk.
Next meeting — Monday, Nov. 29
at 8 p.m.
BASKETBALL GAME
This
SUNDAY EVENING, NOV. 28th
Brock'yn Jewish Center
Pelham Parkw'y Community Center
DEC. 5th
B.J.C. vs. Union Temple
•
DEC. 12th
B.J.C. vs. Hebrew Educational
Society
Admission: Center Members 75c
Non-members $1.20
(incl. tax)
VILLA CLAIR
PALM BEACH, FLORIDA
Moderate in Size Home-Like Atmosphere
Dietary Laws Excellent Cuisine
Inquire
LOUIS COHN
223 Seminole Avenue Palm Beach, Florida
(One Block from the Ocean)
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
Bus. Specialty Shops, 42 Amboy St.
Married
Proposed by Herman Swarzman,
Jesse J. Fine
Tallering, Leo A.
Res. 184 E. 59th St.
Bus. Acct., 401 Bway.
Married
Proposed by Herbert J. O'Koskin
Thun, Bernard
Res. 5101 — 13 th Ave.
Bus. Sheet Metal, 76 Forsythe St.
Married
Proposed by Harry Mandler,
Dr. Aaron Leifer
Tvtell, Abraham
Res. 763 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Health Inspector, 125 Worth St.
Married
Proposed by Irwin Karen,
Joseph Goldstein
Wegbreit, Miss Belle
Res. 5614 — 15th Ave.
Proposed by Harry Mandler
Weinberger, Morton
Res. 349 Crown St.
Bus. Drugs, 146 Wyona St.
Single
Proposed by Gerald and Harold Jacobs
Weiss, Marvin
Res. 265 Rochester Ave.
Bus. Bicycles, 594 Glenmore Ave.
Single
Zimmerman, Philip L.
Res. 686 E. 98th St.
Bus. Electronics, R. C. A.
Single
Proposed by Solomon Sorschcr,
Michael Kahn
Zinn, Miss Nan
Res. 1 3 33 St. Johns Pi.
Proposed by Ira Brodsky,
Dr. M. M. Sherman
Zwirn, Miss Beatrice
Res. 1427 Remsen Ave.
Proposed by Shirley Zwirn
The following has applied for rein-
statement:
Cohen, Jack
Res. 583 E. 91st St.
Bus. 53 Chambers St.
Married
Additional Applications:
Bf.rchuck, Miss Mildred
Res. 98 Legion St.
Bernstein, Miss Irene
Res. 13 3 5 Eastern Parkway
Proposed by Nat Hofspiegel,
Bernie Braverman
Daniels, Sol B.
Res. 131 East 93rd St.
Bus. Teacher
Married
Proposed by Jos. D. Smallberg
Fauer, Miss Edith
Res. 2114 Mermaid Ave.
Proposed by Hy Rosen,
Richard Nepon
Katz, Miss Jeanette
Res. 147 Lincoln PI.
Proposed by Frances Marcus
Kleiman, Bernard C.
Res. 1412 Carroll St.
Single
Proposed by Louis Kleiman
Newman, Miss Frances
Res. 1006 Hopkinson Ave.
Noll, Harvey B.
Res. 789 St. Marks Ave.
Bus. Buyer, Bloomingdale's
Married
Proposed by David Halpern
Oppenheim, Miss Janet
Res. 1942 — 50th St.
Proposed by Hy Rosen
Oremland, Joseph
Res. 481 Crown St.
Rampell, Edward
Res. 2301 Avenue S
Bus. Truck Distr., 3rd Ave & 21st St.
Single
Proposed by Paul Siskind,
Seymour Glass
Rosenthal, Harry
Res. 9206 Avenue L
Bus. Dep't. Store
Married
Proposed by Milton Manheim,
Reuben Lubetski
Schwalberg, Miss Sylvia R.
Res. 1617 President St.
Proposed by David Gold,
Jerome Friedman
Schwartz, Nathaniel E.
Res. 206 Flatbush Ave.
Bus. Engineer, 51 Broadway
Single
Proposed by Herbert Altneu,
Eleanor Trager
Shner, Miss Gertrude T.
Res. 84 Blake Ave.
Struhl, Joseph
Res. 1 520 Carroll St.
Bus. Rest., 144 E. 14th St.
Married
Proposed by Irving L. Weishar,
Bernard Fink
Sabbath Services
Friday evening services at 4:15.
Kindling of candles at 4:11 p.m.
Sabbath services, Parsha "Haye Sarah"
— Genesis 23.1-25.18, Prophets — Isaiah
I Kings 1.1-31 will commence at 8:45
a.m.
Mincha Services at 4:15.
Rabbi Levinthal will preach on the
weekly portion of the law.
Cantor Sauler will officiate assisted by
the Congregational Singing Group under
the leadership of Mr. Sholom Secunda.
Rabbi Abelson will continue the lec-
ture in Yiddish this Saturday afternoon
at 3:30 p.m.
Daily Services
Morning services at 8:00 o'clock.
Mincha services at 4:15 o'clock.
Why make
funeral plans
NOW?
Here is the Answer . . .
The BOULEVARD PLAN
• Spares your loved ones the
bitter anguish of making
funeral arrangements in
the hour of bereavement.
• Provides pre-arranged in-
structions covering your
wishes.
• (lives you peaee of mind
in knowing that this im-
portant problem has been
solved.
• Protects against emotional
overspending because ex-
pense has already been de-
termined.
For free booklet describint)
plan in detail, write or call
un today. There in no cost
or obligation.
374 EMPIRE BOULfVARD
PhoTf Slo«in 6-7300 BSCCKIVN 25, N. Y.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
21
AGING CISTERHOOD
SISTERHOOD'S CREDO
/ shall pass t/jrough this world but once.
Any good, therefore, that I can do
Or any kindness that I can slxw
To any human being
Let me show it now. Let me
Not defer it or ne gleet it, for
I shall not pass this way again.
Anon.
General Meeting:
WE OPENED our October meeting
with an innovation. Refreshments
and the social hour preceded the business
and cultural parts of the program. An
appropriate Succoth prayer, read by Sarah
Kushner, was followed by the singing of
the National Anthem and Hatikvoh by
Ethel Pashenz, accompanied at the piano
by Ruth Bernhardt — our "anthem two-
some." Our president, Sarah Klinghoffer,
proceeded with current business. Project
chairmen Sarah Epstein (for our Annual
Mother - Daughter Luncheon), Shirley
Gluckstein (for SOS) and Lil Levy (for
Federation of Jewish Philanthropies) each
enlisted the co-operation of our women
in their forthcoming functions and
drives.
Substituting for Program Chairman
Mildred Levine, our past President, Ruth
Bernhardt, graciously presented Miss
Shirley Levine, young concert singer,
whose lyric soprano voice charmed us
with Hebrew, Yiddish and operatic songs
and arias. Mrs. Paula Packer, a repre-
sentative from the League of Women
Voters, talked on "Pre-Election Signifi-
cance." Her keynote was, "Vote as you
please, but vote!" Between lively ques-
tions and answers, our women received a
clearer picture of election issues.
Interesting programs of this kind we
know will attract greater attendance.
Hoard Meeting Report:
Sisterhood members have made reserva-
tions for the Chanukah Festival and
Luncheon to be given by Women's League
of the United Synagogue at the Hotel
Commodore on Monday, December 27th.
Reservations have also been made for
the All-Day Conference and Luncheon
sponsored by the Federation of Jewish
Women's Organizations to be held at the
Waldorf Astoria on Wednesday, January
12, 1949. Call Mrs. Amelia Rachmil,
NEvins 8-4864, for further reservations
on both events. A Jewish Book Exhibit
has been planned for the December "Wel-
come to New Members" meeting.
The Torah Fund Luncheon, to provide
scholarships for needy students at the
Seminary, is tentatively set for March
9th.
SOS Chairman Shirley Gluckstein, her
co-chairman, Jeannette Richman and
her committee are making plans for a
"Layette Party."
Federation Chairman Lillie Levy has
the active co-operation of the entire
Board in her campaign plans.
Delegates to the Eastern Parkway Jew-
ish Community Council reported on plans
to purchase sets of the Jewish Encyclo-
pedia for all Brooklyn Libraries and High
Schools.
As members of the National Confer-
ence of Christians and Jews, we are urged
to attend a professional football game at
Ebbets Field, Sunday, November 28th,
the proceeds of which will go to the
Conference.
Sisterhood is actively supporting Boy
Scout and Girl Scout drives. Center
Scout troops were the guests of the
Junior Congregation at a Kiddush last
Saturday.
Results of the Mother - Daughter
Luncheon were reported.
Onr Women in the News:
Beatrice Shaeffer has been appointed
Chairman for our Torah Fund Luncheon
to be held in March. Her co-chairmen
arc Sarah Kushner and Ruth Klaristen-
feld. Watch for details of another Sis-
terhood gala event.
At a joint meeting of the Board of
Trustees and the Governing Board, Sarah
Klinghoffer, our President, was elected a
member of the Center Governing Board.
At our Board meeting, Sisterhood elect-
ed the following women to serve on our
Executive Board: Dorothy Gottlieb, Mary
Kaplan, Jeannette Richman.
We regret having omitted in last
month's Paging Sisterhood the name of
Bertha Greenblatt from our list of Board
Directors.
We are pleased to., announce the ap-
pointment of Shirley Gluckstein and
Esther Greenblatt as delegates to the
Federation of Jewish Women's Organiza-
tions.
Many of our women are enjoying the
courses in all phases of Hebrew and Jew-
ish subjects given by our Institute of
Jewish Studies, held at the Center. In
these eventful days, every Jewish woman
should familiarize herself with her Jew-
ish heritage.
Fanny Jackson still "tags" after her
big sister, Lil Levy. She is her co-
chairman in the drive for Federation.
Committee Reports:
On behalf of the Luncheon Committee,
Chairman Sarah Epstein and her co-
chairmen, Dorothy Wisner and Lillie
Levy, wish to express their gratitude to
the hundreds of women who attended
our Mother - Daughter Luncheon and
Fashion Show, and those who helped make
it the success it was. We appreciate
especially the generous contribution of
Martin's Fashion Show, the lovely floral
arrangements by Hyman Spitz, the deli-
cious mints provided by Barton's Choco-
lates, and lastly, but equally important,
the co-operation of our own Kotimsky
and Tuchman in serving such a splendid
repast.
Our SOS Committee Chairman, Shir-
ley Gluckstein, urges you to bring to the
Center contributions of canned food and
baby layettes each time you come. Call
her and offer your assistance. You will
earn a mitzvah, and the unfortunates
overseas will benefit by your efforts. The
following women have volunteered their
help: Mmes. Eva Grabisch, L. Saffer,
Claire Cohen, Anne Goldberg, B. Schorr,
Irene Perlin, Dorothy Gottlieb, Esther
Greenblatt, Sylvia Dilbert, Dorothy Wis-
ner, Lila Leonard. Won't you add your
name to this list of "Assistants and
Assistance"?
Sisterhood's campaign for the Federa-
tion of Jewish Charities expects great re-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
suits, according to Chairman Lillie Levy,
who reminds us: Please call your pros-
pects at once. Make your own contribu-
tions and be exceptionally generous this
year. Call Lil Levy, SLocum 6-805 3,
and volunteer your aid. Make a date to
attend the Dessert Luncheon given by
Ruth Bernhardt at her home, 1368 Car-
roll Street, on Thursday, December 2nd,
// you can contribute $36 or more. Make
another date to be present at Hotel St.
George on Tuesday, December 7th, at the
Federation Day Luncheon, // you can
contribute $10 or more. Tickets are
$2.75 each.
Plans for the Torah Fund Luncheon
are now being made, and will be an-
nounced in this department next month.
Cheer Fund Donor List:
In honor of daughter's engagement —
Mrs. Lena Christenfeld.
In honor of son's Bar Mitzvah — Mr.
and Mrs. H. Rothstein.
In honor of grandson's Bar Mitzvah —
Mr. and Mrs. Louis Simon.
We hope we will find sponsors among
our members for the March and April
Kiddush for the Junior Congregation.
This is an excellent way to celebrate a
simcha.
Welcome to -Sew Members:
Sisterhood welcomes our new members,
and extends to them a hearty invitation
to attend our meetings and become one
of us in deed as well as in name. Be-
sides meeting friends, they will spend an
enjoyable and illuminating afternoon.
Calendar of Events:
November 27: Kiddush to the Junior
Congregation by Mr.' Brukenfeld in
memory of his parents.
December 2: Dessert Luncheon at
home of Ruth Bernhardt for Federation
contributors of $36 and over.
December 6: Sisterhood Board meet-
ing at 1:00 p.m.
December 7: Federation Day and
Luncheon at Hotel St. George.
December 20: General membership
meeting. Welcome party to our new
members. A brilliant review by Henri-
etta Shapiro of the novel, "The Jewish
Pope." Musical program being arranged.
December 27: Women's League Chanu-
kah Festival and Luncheon.
Suggestion Box:
Sisterhood continues to solicit your
recommendations and suggestions for the
betterment of our programs and meet-
ings. Write or phone us items which
you think should appear on this page. It
is your letterbox. Tell us what you
think.
Members wishing to serve on Standing
Committees are most welcome. Call our
Recording Secretary, Bea Schaeffer,
PR. 3-2744.
William I. Siegel, Newly Elected
President of Eastern Parkway
Zionist District
At the last annual meeting of the East-
AFEW years ago the Brooklyn Jewish
Center donated three Sifre Torah to
the Jews in the displaced persons camps
through the American Jewish Joint Dis-
tribution Committee. We are glad to
publish the following letters of acknowl-
edgment:
December 30, 1947
"To Rabbi Israel H. Levinthal and to
the officers of the Brooklyn Jewish Cen-
ter. We should like to express our
heartiest thanks for the wonderful pres-
ent that you sent to us through the Joint
Distribution Committee. The Sefer Torah
has reached its destination and is at pres-
ent in the Beth Ha-Midrash of the ref-
ugee camp. We use this Sefer Torah,
which is the only scroll in our possession
on Sabbath and weekdays. When the
Sefer Torah was dedicated we held a pub-
lic celebration in which representatives of
all parties participated and which was at-
tended by a large number of refugees.
Your present is indeed an invaluable one
and it is difficult to tell you how much
we appreciate your kindness. We raise
our eyes to heaven and pray that all of
us might soon succeed in reaching our
Holy Land where we can joyfully devote
ourselves to our Torah."
Religious Committee, Camp Exodus,
Sengwarden, British Zone, Germany.
By Jacob Roth.
10th of Sivan 5708
"To the members of the Brooklyn Jew-
ish Center! Shalom and blessings!
In the name of the 8,000 Jews, sur-
vivors of the catastrophe and terrible de-
em Parkway Zionist District No. 14,
Hon. William I. Siegel was elected Presi-
dent for the coming year. The other of-
ficers are: Chairman of the Board —
Maurice Bernhardt; Vice Presidents —
Joseph Goldberg, Dr. Samuel T. Markoff,
Lawrence Meyer, Charles Rubenstein,
Joseph L. Scheinberg, David Spiegel and
Dr. H. A. S. Tanenbaum; Treasurer —
Leo Kaufman; Recording Secretary —
Louis J. Finkelstein; Financial Secretary
— Bernard L. Buck.
The Honorary Presidents of the district
are: Dr. Israel H. Levinthal, Hon. Eman-
uel Greenberg, Maurice Bernhardt and
Dr. Samuel T. Markorf.
struction, who now live in the Ulm
camps in the German Golus, I should like
to express our sincere thanks for the
beautiful scroll which we have received
from you through the Joint Distribution
Committee.
I need not tell you how important this
precious gift is. The day on which we
received the Sefer was for us a day of
rejoicing. We shall always remember
your generosity. The name of your con-
gregation will head the list of those whom
we delight to honor on the day when we
install the scroll in our synagogue.
The heart of every member of our
community overflows with gratitude to
those who helped carry out this great
Mitzvah.
May God shower his blessings upon
you, and may He bless your homes and
the work of your hands. May you be
blessed with health and prosperity, and
may you be privileged to see the return
of Israel to our homeland and the re-
establishment of our ancient Temple in
Zion.
Cordially yours and with the Torah 's
blessings,
Judah Leib, Aussubel, Chief Rabbi,
Ulm, Germany.
To the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Recently we celebrated the arrival of
the Sefer Torah, which was presented to
our synagogue by the Congregation
"Hamerkaz Hayehudi Shel Brooklyn"
(Brooklyn Jewish Center) headed by
Rabbi Israel H. Levinthal. It was trans-
CENTER SIFRE TORAH PRIZED IN D. P. CAMPS
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
mitted to us by the "Joint" through the
efforts of the well-known Agudah leader,
Mr. Ezekiel Kelman.
The celebration started with a large
assembly at the camp Beth Ba-Midrash
which was opened by the Chairman of
the Poale Eretz Israel at the camp, the
indefatigable communal worker Mr.
Jacob Rot. Mr. David Lindenfeld, rep-
resentative of the Poale Eretz Israel, Mr.
Pesach Mlinek of Mizrachi, Mr. David
Goldberg of the Kibbutz Chofez Chaim,
Zev Chayes the deputy from Eretz Is-
rael, Joseph Dorman of the Home for
the Youth of Poale Eretz Israel, and rep-
resentatives of the Joint Relief, etc., were
invited to participate in the program.
Mr. Jacob Rot spoke about the signifi-
cance of the celebration and thanked the
American Jews for their spiritual and fi-
nancial support. Finally he referred to
the two victims of the "Exodus," who
were honored by everyone present by two
minutes of silence.
When the formal program was con-
cluded, the Sefer Torah was brought in-
to the school to the sound of music, the
procession being illuminated by candles
and fireworks.
Short speeches followed by the repre-
sentative of the Poale Eretz Israel, Mr.
David Lindenfeld, and the instructor of
the Talmud Torah, Mr. Shloimele, who
interspersed his remarks with suitable
Biblical quotations. The people stayed
at the banquet tables until a late hour,
enjoying the fine food, which was pre-
pared by the women and young girls of
the "Ohel Sarah."
Joseph Dorman, Camp Exodus, Seng-
warden, Germany, British Zone.
Bar Mifzvahs
A hearty Mazel Tov is extended to
Mr. and Mrs. Harry Spevack on the Bar
Mitzvah of their son, Robert M., which
will be celebrated at the Center this Sab-
bath morning, November 27th.
Congratulations are also extended to
Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin Karten of 1191
Carroll Street on the celebration of the
Bar Mitzvah of their son, Arthur, at the
Center this Saturday morning, Novem-
ber 27th.
ABBOT-FINE MOTORS
NASH SALES— SERVICE
507 Flatbush Avenue
JESSE J. FINE Brooklyn, New York
JACK ABBOT Phone: BUckminster 4-7800
FLOWERS • WEDDING DECORATIONS
HYMAN SPITZ, Inc.
1685 Pitkin Avenue, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Dickens 2-4000 OUR ONLY STORE
• FRUIT BASKETS •
FOR BROOKLYN
a new riverside
II Memorial Chapel
ONE OCEAN PARKWAY
Representing the FINEST in Modern Funeral Homes
Ample Parking Facilities
76th St. AND AMSTERDAM AVE., N. Y. 1250 CENTRAL AVE., FAR ROCKAWAY
ENDICOTT 2-6600 FAR ROCKAWAY 7-7100
WESTCHESTER MIAMI MIAMI BEACH
Director Charles Rosenthal
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
r "-^5^^'
Li^*L YOU 0 * 8 *
Enjoy the Comforts of a Hotel
in the Tranquil Privacy of,..
The
APARTMENTS
PALM BEACH
FLORIDA
A sheltered block of modern apart*
ments conveniently located two
blocks from the Ocean, Theatres
and Shopping. Set amidst tropical
gardens directly on beautiful Lake
Worth, you are assured superb
vistas and restful surroundings.
One, two, and three room units,
each with its own patio. Furnished
to the last detail for housekeeping.
Maid service.
Season and Monthly Rates
For Brochure & Information Write:
The BEAUX ARTS APARTMENTS
Bradley Place and Seminole Avenue
PALM BEACH. FLORIDA
Phone: Palm Beach 6225
New York Office:
250 Montgomery Street
Brooklyn 25. N. Y.
Phone: BU 7-1114
>.,,*'*
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed
Sec. 562, P. L. ft R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U. S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622
J&LWdA Center
^becemb&i, 1948
THE CONSTITUTION OF ISRAEL
A COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS
LIFE IN DUBLIN
JEWS OF YEMEN
By WILLIAM I. SIEGEL
By JACQUELINE SAYERS
By HARRY E. WEDECK
NEWS OF THE MONTH
• CENTER BULLETIN BOARD •
Jp QRUM J^ ECTURES and J^ ISCUSSIONS
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER, 667 EASTERN PARKWAY
SECOND AND FOURTH MONDAY EVENINGS AT 8:15 P.M.
December 27th:
ROUND TABLE DISCUSSION
GROUP
Debate on
"SHOULD THE FEDERAL GOVERN-
MENT OUTLAW ANTI-SEMITIC
LIBELS?"
Affirmative:
WILL MASLOW, ESQ.
Director of Commission on Law and Social Action,
American Jewish Congress; Lecturer at New School
for Social Research.
Negative:
HON. WILLIAM I. SIEGEL
Assistant District Attorney, Kings County
and Zionist Leader.
Admission free to all.
January 24:
ROUND TABLE DISCUSSION GROUP
Subject and Speakers to be announced.
January 10th:
DEBATE
PROF. J. RAYMOND WALSH
Noted Radio Commentator and Economist
GEORGE HAMILTON COMBS
News Analyst and Former Member of Congress.
Subject :
"OUR FOREIGN POLICY — WHERE IS
IT LEADING TO?"
Admission: Center members free; Non-members 40$
(incl. tax)
February 14th:
GEORGE FIELDING ELIOT
Distinguished News Analyst, Correspondent and Author
Subject:
"MUST WE FIGHT RUSSIA?"
Don't fail to Reserve this Date to hear a Stimu-
lating and Informative Discussion on a vital topic.
NEXT MEMBERSHIP A program of entertainment in keeping with the spirit of
SOCIAL MEETING tne Chanukah celebration will be rendered on that evening.
Wednesday Evening, December 29th at 8:15 o'clock
IRVING DAVIDSON Center Choral Group Cantor WILLIAM SAULER
Well-known Jewish Humorist under the leadership of in a Special Chanukah program
Mr. Sholom Secunda
Admission will be limited to members of the Center and their wives. Please present your 1948 membership cards at the door.
Refreshments
BASKETBALL GAMES
This Sunday Evening, December 26th at 8:30
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER vs. GRAND STREET BOYS
Admission: Center Members 75^; Non-members $1.20 (incl. tax)
January 2nd: B. J. C. vs. E. N. Y. "Y"
Brooklyn Jewish Center Revie
w
Vol. XXX
DECEMBER, 1948 — KISLEV, 5709
No. 15
THE MIRACLE OF DEDICATION
DR. JORGE GRANADOS, Chief
of the Guatemalan delegation to
the United Nations, in a recent
address delivered at the Forum of the
Brooklyn Jewish Center, stated that na-
tional greatness is not determined by
physical strength or geographical size,
and he was confident that the newly-
established State of Israel would be a
great nation despite its limited area.
That small nations are not necessarily
condemned to subservience or defeat is
the basic theme of the Chanukah holiday.
On Chanukah we celebrate the rout of
the great and mighty armies of the Syrian
Empire by the small and weak Maccabean
forces. We kindle candles for eight days
to commemorate the miracle of the small
flask containing only enough oil to light
the Menorah in the Temple for one day
and which lasted miraculously for eight
days. In our day Israel, like the small
cruse of oil, has been able to rally enough
spiritual strength and energy to keep the
lights of victor)' burning and to over-
come the mighty forces of hate and re-
action that were arrayed against it. De-
spite overwhelming odds this miracle may
indeed be described as the miracle of
Chanukah, the miracle of dedication. We
have emerged victorious against the ene-
mies of the new State because the Jewish
State has not only been established, but
because it has been dedicated to a pur-
pose high and noble, it has fired the hearts
and the imagination of its citizens. This
spirit will transform it, even though its
territory is small, into a first-rate power.
Israel has never accepted the limita-
tions of smallness. The fact of Jewish
renaissance, Chaim Nachman Bialik said,
Al Tomar Kotnit, "We must not say we
are too small." In Israel the Jews solved
the problem of absorptive capacity be-*
cause of their creative and spiritual ca-
pacity. Since there are no limits in the
realm of the spirit, no limits may be set
to Israel's greatness in the family of na-
tions.
— Manuel Saltzman.
FIFTY YEARS OF BENEFICENT SERVICE
THE Hebrew Educational Society of
Brownsville is about to celebrate the
50th anniversary of its existence. Those
who are familiar with the Brownsville
community in the years when the H.E.S.
was founded will appreciate how impor-
tant and necessary this institution was for
the development of that community. It
served as the social and educational
Center for young and old; it helped in
the process of Americanization of thou-
sands of immigrants, who learned, with-
in its walls, the English language and
American ideals of freedom and democ-
racy. Many of America's prominent citi-
zens in all professions today owe much
to the training and inspiration they re-
ceived in this fine institution.
Though the community has changed
in many ways, the H.E.S. is still func-
tioning at full capacity and rendering a
most beneficial service. It has the great
advantage of having had Rabbi Alter
Landesman as its guiding spirit for the
last several decades. He is one of the
most capable educators and spiritual lead-
ers that we have in this country, and he
has had, and is having, a splendid influ-
ence upon all who come in contact with
him.
We offer our sincere congratulations to
Rabbi Landesman, to the officers and to
all who guide the H.E.S. and hope that
it may continue its beneficent service
for many years to come.
— Israel H. Levinthal.
The Weizmann Autobiography
THE Herald-Tribune has announced the
serial publication of Chaim Weiz-
mann's autobiography (beginning Janu-
ary 5 ) . This is an imaginative enterprise,
and the newspaper deserves our congratu-
lations. The circulation manager of the
Herald-Tribune, wishing, understand-
ably enough, to attract the widest atten-
tion to this series, describes the autobiog-
raphy as "the story of one man's brilliant
contributions to science and humanity,
reflecting the contributions of a whole
race to our civilization." It's a good
blurb, and so much the better because it
is true.
One may consider it a journalistic
event when a big newspaper serializes a
work that used to be considered of Jew-
ish interest only. And it is an event
that is undoubtedly an initial result
of the Jews' rise to the dignity of pos-
sessing a national homeland.
EDITORIAL BOARD
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
Louis J. Gribetz, Chairman
Joseph Goldberg M. H. Lewittes
Joseph Kaye Manuel Saltzman
I. H. Levinthal William I. Siecel
The Brooklyn Jewish Center Review is published monthly by the Brooklyn Jewish Center at 667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn, N. Y.
Manuscripts should be sent to this address and will be carefully considered by the editors. Subscription $1.00 per year.
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is affiliated with the United Synagogue of America and the National Jewish Welfare Board.
Emanuel Greenberg, President Dr. Moses Spatt and Hyman Aaron, Vice-Presidents David Soodstein, Treasurer Frank Schaeffer, Secretary
Israel H. Levinthal, D.D.. D.H.L. Rabbi Manuel Salhman, Asst. Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes, Asst. Rabbi, Hebrew Schools
Joseph Goldberg, Administrative Director
All contents of the Brooklyn Jewish Center Review are copyrighted
"JUST BETWEEN OURSELVES"
An Intimate Chat Betiveen Rabbi and Reader
THE SAD PLIGHT OF THE JEWISH BOOK
READERS of the Review have read
and heard a great deal in the past
few weeks about Jewish Book
Month, which is now being observed
throughout the land. In our own Center
the theme was discussed from pulpit and
platform.
The very fact that it was found neces-
sary to dedicate a certain month in the
year to the Jewish Book is in itself a sad
commentary on the cultural status of the
American Jew. And yet it is axiomatic
that if we are to develop a healthy Jewish
life in this country there must be a re-
vival of interest in Jewish books. We
cannot hope to develop Jewish scholars
or thinkers or writers unless we give them
the encouragement of at least of showing
an interest in what they create. Jewish lit-
erature flourished in the old communities
in Europe because there was hardly a
home that did not take pride in owning
a Jewish library. How tragic it is to ob-
serve in the average home today, even
among the most affluent, the absence of
FULL settlement of the differences be-
tween the United Palestine Appeal and
the Committee of Contributors and
Workers was announced this week, assur-
ing national united fund-raising in 1949
for Jewish needs in Europe, Israel and
immigration to America.
The announcement was made by Edwin
Rosenberg, chairman of the conciliation
committee of the Council of Jewish Fed-
erations and Welfare Funds, which con-
ducted negotiations between the two
groups on behalf of its 800 organized
Jewish member communities in the
United States.
The accord covered the powers and
functions of the U.P.A., clarified proce-
dures for disbursement and allocation of
funds, composition of governing bodies,
any Jewish book. And there have been
so many worth-while works published
that should interest all our people. The
Jewish Publication Society of America,
the Shocken Books, and the many other
publishing houses have issued fine volumes
on every phase of literature, but few have
been their readers. You will find in our
homes the popular best sellers, the latest
publications of the Book Clubs; it is only
the book of Jewish interest that is a
stranger in the Jewish home.
Let us hope that the Jewish Book
Month this year will succeed in awaken-
ing the American Jew to an appreciation
of the value and importance of the Jew-
ish Book, so that our people may once
again become what we were in the past —
the Am Ha-Sefer, the People of the Book.
procedures for re-constituting the U.J.A.,
voting by mail or telegraph in certain
circumstances, and provided for cancel-
lation of the December 11-12 conference
called by the Committee of Contributors.
Concerning representation on the gov-
erning bodies of the U.P.A., it has been
agreed that 60 per cent would be desig-
nated by the Palestine Foundation Fund
and the Jewish National Fund, benefi-
ciaries of the U.P.A., and 40 per cent
representation would be from the Amer-
ican Jewish communities. The procedure
for designation of community represen-
tatives will be determined by the U.P.A.
in consultation with the Council. A
small sub-committee of the committee
will be available to the Council for con-
sultation regarding these procedures.
Subject to the above provisions, the
U.P.A. will elect its own officers, will de-
termine the organization's administrative
budget and all matters of staff personnel,
and will establish all rules of procedure
required for the functions of the U.P.A.
The income of the U.P.A. will be made
available with the greatest promptitude
to the principal beneficiaries, namely the
treasury of the Jewish Agency for Pal-
estine and the head offices of the Pales-
tine Foundation Fund and Jewish Na-
tional Fund in Israel. The U.P.A. will
disburse such funds through agencies and
procedures authorized by these benefi-
ciaries.
•
The U.P.A. will also be empowered to
make its own recommendations regarding
special allocations or grants for agencies
other than the principal beneficiaries.
Recommendations made by the American
Palestine Foundation Fund and the Jew-
ish National Fund will go to the U.P.A.
for consideration and action by it before
they are transmitted to Israel. (Minor-
ity as well as majority reports may be
transmitted.) Final decision on all grants
and allocations rests with the head offices
of the Palestine Foundation Fund and
the Jewish National Fund in Israel, and
the executive of the Jewish Agency. The
U.P.A. will negotiate an agreement with
the J.D.C. for setting up the U.J.A. and
for the conduct of the joint campaign.
New York First In
Racial Bias Protection
New York was listed as the most ad-
vanced state in the Union insofar as pro-
tecting its residents from religious and
racial discrimination is concerned. In a
survey made by the American Jewish
Congress evaluating the degree of pro-
tection offered citizens in all 48 states,
New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts
and Illinois follow New York in that
order.
The Congress survey digested more
than 200 laws in the fields of public
accommodation, employment, education,
housing and group defamation which are
presently carried on the statute books of
all 48 states. A majority of the states
fall short of a minimum program re-
quired to assure protection of their citi-
zens' civil rights, the survey revealed.
THE SETTLEMENT OF THE U.P.A. CONTROVERSY
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
5
An Analysis of the Basic
Laws of the New State
THE CONSTITUTION OF ISRAEL
As a service to its readers, and be-
cause of the universal interest in the
proposed Constitution of the State of
Israel, the Review publishes this
comprehensive and critical analysis
of the historic document by a noted
legal student and Zionist leader.
— The Editors
THE proposed Israeli Constitution
commands admiration for the basic
liberalism in which it is conceived.
At the same time, and especially because
of its liberal quality, surprise is occasioned
because of the omission of fundamental
civil rights. Again, serious questions are
raised as to the successful implementation
of the democratic purpose of the Consti-
tution. It is proposed in this article to
comment on these points in the hope that
a public discussion of the Constitution
may focus attention on these lacks and
omissions, to some useful end.
The Constitution consists of seventy-
eight articles which may, for convenience,
be divided into four main groupings.
These divisions are concerned with (1.)
fundamental rights of the citizen; (2.)
the legislature and its powers; (3.) the
Executive and its powers; (4.) the courts
and their jurisdiction. It is not a mere ac-
cident of arrangement that the Constitu-
tion addresses itself first to the subject
of fundamental rights. The long history
of oppression suffered by the Jewish
people makes it natural and right that in
their first opportunity to enact a basic
governing law they should concern them-
selves with the protection of the rights
of the individual against the arbitrary
and despotic acts of government, even
though it be their own government.
Fundamental Rights
In the main, this portion of the Consti-
tution responds to the finest conception of
the rights of the individual. Citizenship
within the State and the right to hold
public office is open to all inhabitants
without regard to race, color or creed.
This is true, not only of Jews, but of
non-Jews who may choose to avail them-
selves of the opportunity. Freedom of
worship is assured to all. Private prop-
erty is protected against expropriation,
except in the case of public use, and in
such cases full compensation is guaran-
teed. The death penalty is banned, as is
cruel and humiliating physical punish-
ment. Police brutality is prohibited and
the citizen is protected against the admis-
sion in court of evidence procured by
the police in contravention of this rule.
All persons charged with crime are
guaranteed a speedy arraignment and
notice of the charges against them and
are further guaranteed a trial not later
than two days from the date of arrest.
(It is to be hoped that the incidence of
crime in Israel will remain at such low
point as to enable the courts to deal with
their calendars so expeditiously. This is
rarely the case in our American procedure.
This provision, while clearly grounded in
a commendable zeal for the protection of
the individual, is nevertheless practically
unworkable. It gives the prosecution no
time, or at most inadequate time and op-
portunity for the preparation of its case.
This will very likely result in injustice
to the People as a whole. Moreover, being
part of a Constitution it may cast serious
doubt on the legality of a conviction
where the trial is held more than two
days after arrest. The better rule to ex-
press would guarantee the defendant a
speedy trial, without specific limitation of
time.) The writ of habeas corpus is af-
forded as a protection against unlawful
detention or punishment. The vivid rec-
ollection of the injustices practised by
British military tribunals is undoubtedly
the cause of the provision that only mem-
bers of the armed forces on active service
shall at any time be subjected to the jur-
isdiction of military courts. There is a
proper prohibition against ex post facto
laws or retroactive alterations of the rules
of evidence and subsequent increases in
penalty. An unusual and salutary pro-
vision is the one granting the subject an
enforceable claim for compensation
against the State in the case of an unjust
or illegal arrest, conviction or punish-
ment.
The dwellings of all persons are ren-
dered inviolable and there is a strict pro-
hibition against unlawful search and sei-
zure. Also, the right of privacy as to
correspondence and telegraphic and tele-
By WILLIAM I. SIEGEL
phonic communications is preserved. In
thus requiring search warrants and pro-
tecting communications, the Israeli Con-
stitution follows the pattern set down by
our Federal law. It might have been
better to have banned explicitly the in-
troduction in evidence of the fruits of
violation of these rights rather than to
leave the interpretation of this provision
to the courts. There arc, for instance,
similar provisions in the basic laws of
New York and yet the courts have so
construed these provisions as to permit
the receipt of the evidence. The sole
relief to the defendant is an action for
damages against the police or a prosecu-
tion of the police officials — which is
hardly a compensation to the defendant.
A similar provision under Article 18 of
the Israeli Constitution for the prosecu-
tion of officers acting contrary to the
provisions of the Constitution may indi-
cate that the Israeli courts will construe
the Constitution in the manner adopted
by the courts of New York (People v.
Defore) . It is suggested that the alter-
native Federal law which completely pro-
hibits the reception of evidence illegally
obtained is the better view.
The Israeli Constitution provides for
the right of political refuge within its
borders and reserves to the government
the absolute discretion to refuse "to de-
liver up any of its subjects to a foreign
government for prosecution or punish-
ment." This is a right enjoyed by all
sovereign states and it is one which, at
least for some time to come, is especially
necessary in view of the arbitrary, ca-
pricious, and hostile attitude of certain
governments toward the people and State
of Israel.
•
As we have said and as this analysis
shows, the animating spirit of the Con-
stitution, in so far as it deals with the
rights of the citizen, is liberal. It is,
therefore, all the more noticeable that
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
6
the Constitution fails to make other pro-
visions which are in themselves important
safeguards, and which the experience of
democratic countries has shown to be of
primary and inestimable value. Thus,
there is no provision against double jeop-
ardy, so that it would appear that there
is, at the present time, no limit to the
number of prosecutions for the same
crime. There is also no guarantee against
self-incrimination. The right to be free
from compulsion to testify against one-
self has long been held to be a basic right
and one of the chief protections of the
individual against the despotism of gov-
ernment. It may be that the failure to
provide such guarantee in the Constitu-
tion is the result only of an oversight, or
it may also be possible that it is intended
to create such right by later statute. Both
these protections, however — against
double jeopardy and against self-incrimi-
nation — are too important to be made the
subject of statutory enactment. They
properly belong in the basic organic law
and it is to be hoped that at the first
opportunity of amendment they will be
included in the Israeli Constitution.
•
Another example of at least possibly
dangerous unclarity relates to the guar-
antees of free speech and free press.
Article 16 of the Constitution says that
"freedom of speech and the free expres-
sion of opinion in writing, or any other
form are guaranteed." This categorical
protection is, however, immediately
whittled down by the following provision
that "this Constitutional guarantee shall
not extend to utterances or publications
which are libelous, slanderous or obscene,
or which are designed to stir up racial or
religious hatred or to incite to violence
or crime, or which advocate the suppres-
sion of human rights, or of the demo-
cratic system of government or which re-
veal secrets of national defense." The
feeling underlying some of these excep-
tions to the right of free speech and
press is thoroughly understandable, for
the Jews have everywhere and always,
particularly in late years, been the vic-
tims of this despicable type of slander
and libel. Nevertheless, it is dangerous
to give to the government power so to
characterize speech and writing as to ban
such expressed thought from the opera-
tion of Constitutional guarantees. This
is especially true of the right of the gov-
ernment to determine that an expression
of thought is contrary to "the democratic
system of government." Under such an
exception to the general rule of freedom
any particular administration has the
power, whenever it has the will, to jail
its opponents in any numbers and for
any period necessary to its almost perpet-
ual retention of office.
It is obvious, of course, that in this
point is contained the entire debate
(which is constant in every democracy)
as to the limits of liberty and the begin-
ning of license. Nevertheless, it is sub-
mitted that at least in the form in which
this dilemma is resolved in the Israeli
Constitution, it goes far too far in the
direction of suppression. It would ap-
pear to be much better to trust first to
the loyalty of the citizen and, second, to
a careful process of trial and error, than
to give to the government such wide and
dangerous power.
From the Constitution's Preamble
"WE, THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL,
HUMBLY giving thanks to Almighty
God for having delivered us from the
burden of exile and brought us back to
our ancient land;
"Resolved to rebuild our Commonwealth
in accordance with the ideals of peace and
righteousness of the Prophets of Israel, to
welcome home every Jew who seeks entry,
and to promote the security and well-
being of all who dwell within our
gates.* . . ."
The same criticism must regretfully be
made of the provision for the right of
assembly. While there is a general guar-
antee of the right of assembly and asso-
ciation which is granted without regard
to race, religion, language or political be-
lief, there is a specific provision that "this
Constitution guarantee shall not extend to
assemblies or associations aiming at the
suppression of human rights or of the
democratic form of government." Here
again the power of proscription by gov-
ernment is far too wide and may, in the
hands of an unscrupulous administration,
be misused to the detriment of the coun-
try. The argument of necessity is, of
course, apparent. There will for some time
to come (and perhaps forever) be a large
Arab minority within the borders of the
State of Israel, and perhaps, it is because
of this fact that the constitutional excep-
tion is provided. It must also be recog-
nized, however, that there are sharp divi-
sions of economic and political opinion
among the Israelis themselves The mere
possibility that the government may at
any time hamper or destroy the rights of
its opponents by invocation of this article
is sufficient to render the entire provision
suspect. As in almost every other in-
stance of human relations in organized
society, it appears to be far better to trust
to reasonable argument, education and
the* powers of peaceful persuasion.
The Interrelation Between the Legislative
and Executive Powers.
The Constitution provides for a uni-
cameral legislature, to be known as the
Chamber of Deputies. The minimum age-
eligibility for election is twenty-five years.
Members of the Chamber are to be elected
by universal secret ballot on the basis of
proportional representation. This con-
troversial method of balloting is not a
matter of choice with the State of Israel.
Its adoption was one of the conditions of
the creation of the State laid down by the
United Nations. (Later experience may
show that it is adapted to the needs of
the country. The experience of American
communities, notably in the City of New
York, has been to the contrary.) There
is to be one deputy for approximately
10,000 residents, and the term of office
shall be four years, subject to an exten-
sion in case of war or emergency. The
Chamber of Deputies may, however, even
during its term, be dissolved where it con-
tains no stable majority. Deputies enjoy
the usual right of privilege for their offi-
cial acts. They also are granted immunity
against criminal proceedings except where
in cases flagrante delicto the Chamber it-
self approves of prosecution.
The Chamber of Deputies has the im-
portant power of electing the President
of the Republic for a term of five years.
The President may be reelected for only
one additional term of office. The inter-
relation of power between the Chamber
of Deputies and the President is one pat-
terned after the French rather than the
American system. The President thus
elected by the Chamber of Deputies is
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
7
empowered to appoint the Prime Min-
ister and the other members of the Exec-
utive Council. The Council consists of
the Prime Minister and Ministerial heads
of departments to a number not to ex-
ceed fifteen. The ministers themselves
must be members of the Chamber of Dep-
uties. The Council is collectively respon-
sible to the Chamber of Deputies. If the
Council fails to retain the support of the
majority of deputies, it, with the Prime
Minister, must resign.
This is not a system which recom-
mends itself to anyone believing in really
representative government. It will have
been noted, undoubtedly, that the Cham-
ber of Deputies, enjoying a term of four
years, elects the President for a term of
five years. There is, therefore, at least
one year in which the President, not
elected by the people, serves beyond the
term of office of the Chamber of Depu-
ties, which was elected by the people.
While it may be said that the people, in
voting for the Chamber of Deputies, has
agreed in advance to that Chamber's
choice of the President, it does, neverthe-
less, follow that for the period of one
year, at least, there has been no popular
participation in the choice of the Presi-
dent. Moreover, it is doubtful whether
there is, under such a system, any pop-
ular control of the Executive at all. The
election of a representative or deputy
may, and usually does, involve questions
removed from the identity, personality
and point of view of a prospective Presi-
dent. Therefore the choice of such an
Executive should not be confused by this
once-removed form of selection. This is
particularly true in the case of a system
such as is provided in this Constitution,
where the Executive directly and indi-
rectly has powers greater than the Cham-
ber of Deputies.
One notable instance of this dispropor-
tion of power is the provision (Article
42) that "the initiative in introducing
legislation shall rest with the Executive
Council." Deputies may propose legis-
lative measures, but such proposals shall
be referred to a Select Committee of the
Chamber. They shall be introduced by
the Executive Council if recommended
by a majority of the Select Committee
and in the form recommended by that
Committee." This sets up two methods
for the introduction of legislation. One
gives the power to the Executive Council
directly, and the other gives the power to
the Executive Council upon the recom-
mendation of a portion of the Chamber
of Deputies. That Select Committee,
however, is very likely in practice to be
no more than the voice of the Executive
Council. The Ministers of State will owe
their position in the government to their
power in the parties making up the gov-
ernment. The Select Committee will un-
doubtedly be appointed from and in pro-
portion to the strength of the various
parties in the Chamber of Deputies.
While there is in theory a difference in
functioning between the Ministers form-
ing the Council of State and the Depu-
ties, actually, and in practice, their polit-
ical philosophies will be identical. The
Minister, however, will party-wise be of
superior importance. The Select Com-
mittee will undoubtedly in all important
and crucial matters of legislation follow
the will of the Council of Ministers. The
net result is that the power of the legis-
lative branch of government to legislate
will be subject to the imprimatur of the
Executive branch of the government, no
member of which is either elected by or
responsible to the people directly. This
is not democratic, at least within the
American concept.
There is another criticism which must
be levelled at the set-up. The direction
for the dissolution of the Chamber of
Deputies in case there be no stable ma-
jority provides, in theory, for an im-
mediate responsiveness to the will of the
people — one which seems to be even closer
in contact with the electorate than is pro-
vided for in the American system of
stated terms of office. It must be borne
in mind, however, that in Israel (at least
today) there are a large number of par-
ties, particularly in proportion to the
small population. Moreover, there is an
intense division of policy and point of
view among these parties: differences
which seem at this distance to be much
more acute than the differences between
Republicans and Democrats in America.
It is possible, certainly, and perhaps even
probable, that this ideological conflict
may on frequent occasions be impossible
of solution and compromise, with the con-
sequent result that government after gov-
ernment will fall within too short a
period of time. This has been the history
of the French, for instance, who have a
long apprenticeship in self-government.
It is much more likely to be the case in
a new state, such as Israel, whose popula-
tion comes from many different kinds of
political climates. The personal experi-
ences of Israeli citizens also makes it
likely that their interest in the working
of government will be much more in-
tense, polemic and uncompromising than
is the case of citizens whose interest in
government has been dulled by their per-
sonal security.
Excerpts From the Constitution
"The State shall insure the sanctity of
human life and uphold the dignity of
man. . . ."
"The liberty of the person is inviol-
able. . . ."
"Freedom of conscience and the exer-
cise of all forms of worship, subject only
to the maintenance of public order and
morals, shall be insured to all. . . ."
"Everyone has the right to work. The
State of Israel shall endeavor to insure to
all its citizens without distinction a de-
cent standard of living and a fair and
equal opportunity of earning a liveli-
hood. . . ."
"Care for the health of our population
is a primary duty of the State. . . ."
Now, it is, of course, possible that this
form of administration has been rendered
necessary as a compromise by the very
existence of the many parties of Israel
and the sharpness of their divisions. An
observer from the outside cannot be cer-
tain about this. It is to be hoped, how-
ever, that if the present form does not
make for stability of administration, then
the parties at the proper time will waive
their insistence on the protection of their
own specific powers in favor of the gen-
eral good of the country. If a choice
must be made between the comparative
rigidity of the American system, and the
enervating fluidity of the French system,
then experience clearly proves the prefer-
ability of the former.
American experience has shown the
wisdom of the separation of function and
power as among the Executive, the Legis-
lative and the Judicial branches of the
government. Based on this experience
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
8
there is a provision in the Israeli Constitu-
tion which appears to be of questionable
wisdom. The President, as we have seen,
is elected for a term of five years. He is
removable on impeachment by a vote of
two-thirds of the members of the Cham-
ber of Deputies, or on conviction by the
Supreme Court of high treason, or bribery,
or of culpable violation of the Constitu-
tion. This is a proper and necessary pro-
vision. Since power of this kind must
reside somewhere, it is best that it rest
with the elected representatives of the
people. There is, however, a further pro-
vision that the President may be removed
from office on a finding of permanent
incapacity by the Supreme Court. It is
not very likely, one must concede, that
Equal Rights
"All persons within the jurisdiction of
the State of Israel shall be entitled in
equal measure to the protection of the
law. No discrimination of any kind shall
be made by the State between the inhabi-
tants of the State on the grounds of race,
religion or sex.
"All citizens of the State shall enjoy
equal civic and political rights."
— From the Israeli Constitution.
the Supreme Court of Israel will ever be
either venal or in any other respect false
to its trust. Nevertheless, we are dealing
with a Constitution which, as the basic
and organic law of the country, should
be, as far as humanly possible, removed
from the influence of, or dependence on,
the personal factor. This being so, it
does not appear to be wise for the Su-
preme Court to be given this power. In-
capacity is not a fact so capable of exact
determination as high treason or bribery
or even culpable violation of the Consti-
tution. It may relate to physical dis-
ability or mental condition, and each of
these may be a condition resting more in
conjecture than upon fact. The wide
powers vested in the presidency, as for
instance the treaty-mr.king power, the
power of pardon, the appointment of of-
ficers of the Armed forces, the selection
of Ministers and the appointment of
judges, are such as to make his office one
which should be free from even the
vaguest threat of usurpation by another
branch of the government.
In the last decade or two there has
grown up in the American system a large
body of what is known as administrative
law as distinguished from legislative law.
This has been the subject of wide con-
troversy, and although administrative law
has tended to become constantly more
firmly imbedded in the American system,
there is still grave doubt as to the wisdom
of permitting non-elected officials to
promulgate binding law. The Israeli
Constitution seems to have no such fears.
Article 68 provides that not only the
Executive Council but any of its indi-
vidual members shall have the power to
make orders and regulations. The only
check on such power is the requirement
that these orders and regulations shall
be tabled in the Chamber of Deputies and
shall become inoperative if the Chamber,
within two weeks therefrom, so decides.
This would seem to call for a too-hasty
consideration by the Chamber of regu-
lations which, certainly in the formative
stages of the Republic, are likely to be
many in number and diverse in their
cumulative purposes and effects. We be-
lieve that it would be better to make
haste slowly and that in the long run the
country would be better off if the Cham-
ber of Deputies would, after careful con-
sideration, legislate specifically upon the
problems to be dealt with within the
province of each minister.
The Judiciary
The Israeli Constitution provides for
an appointive system of judges. In this
respect it follows the English and Fed-
eral procedure as against, for instance, the
New York elective system. Both systems
have their proponents and both systems
have their virtues and defects. However,
this Constitution is notable for one omis-
sion with respect to the rights of a de-
fendant in the Criminal Courts. There
is no provision for trial by piry. This is
an extraordinary omission. The Jews in
Israel within recent years have been so
oppressed by the judicial system imposed
upon the country by the English that
one would have thought the first require-
ment in the constitutional law of a free
Israel would be trial by jury. Whether
the omission is one of inadvertance only
or whether it is deliberate we do not
know. It is the writer's belief, however,
based upon long experience, that the jury
system, although subject to many faults
and defects, is one of the chief guaran-
tees of the citizen against oppression by
the government. It is certainly to be
hoped that the omission to provide it
will be cured immediately, by an amend-
ment to the Constitution. It is too im-
portant a right to rest on statute alone.
The civil and criminal courts have,
in the main, jurisdiction over most of the
matters relating to organized social liv-
ing. There is an exception in the case of
"matters of personal status and of re-
ligious foundation and endowments,"
which are left by Article 70 to the re-
ligious courts of the Jewish, Moslem and
Christian communities. In this connec-
tion it is interesting to note that the tra-
ditional Jewish law finds a place — indeed
two places — in the functioning of the
courts. The very fact that the religious
courts retain jurisdiction in the matters
indicated means that they will continue
in the future to apply traditional law as
they have in the past. There is the fur-
ther provision that "future legislation in
Israel shall be guided by the basic prin-
ciples of Jewish Law. Wherever the ex-
isting law does not provide adequate
guidance, the Courts-of-Law shall have
recourse to these basic principles." It is
interesting (although at this time futile)
to speculate on the degree to which the
courts, functioning in a modern state,
will find it either practicable or useful to
incorporate the provisions of the ancient
law. Certainly the process will require
judicial ingenuity in relating ancient law
to modern conditions, and in accomodat-
ing, within the framework of decision, the
varying concepts not only of the binding
quality of the law itself but of its adapt-
ability to modern conditions.
The Public Weal
We have left to the last a considera-
tion of certain fascinating possibilities
within the Constitution. Thus, Article
8 provides that "all natural resources
within the jurisdiction of the State of
Israel shall belong to the State subject to
any rights therein vested in any person or
body. . . . Article 21 provides, among
other things, "that every citizen shall
have an equitable share in the national
income and a right to social security. The
State shall encourage and aid every form
[Continued cn page 20]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
9
AMONG the oldest Jewish com-
munities that have unbrokenly
retained their ethnic and reli-
gious identity, the Yemenites of South
Arabia claim major recognition. Some
say that they even antedate the Falashas,
the Jews of Ethiopia discovered late last
century. In any case, the mores and tra-
ditions of the Yemenites stem, according
to numerous legends, from the period of
persecution that followed the Destruction
of the Temple at Jerusalem in 70 A.D.
The Yemenites, cut off from the main
body of Jewry, fled southward, finally
reaching Yemen, in southwest Arabia.
There are indigenous folk tales too that
tell how the Yemeni Jews came from
Palestine forty-two years before the De-
struction of the First Temple, that is, in
586 B.C., among them slaves, priests
and proselytes. The association between
Yemen and Jews has been marked, his-
torically, on many occasions. There is
evidence of a new Jewish settlement in
the second century A.D. In the fifth
century, again, the royal house of Yemen
adopted Judaism. More familiar than the
name of Yemen is the old name of Sheba,
or Saba, linked biblically with the Queen
who came to King Solomon. It is said
that possibly the Yemen colonies of Jews
originated in the naval and commercial
activities of King Solomon and Hiram,
King of Tyre, one of his allies, in the
tenth century B.C. Even the present
currency is stamped with Hebrew char-
acters. Strangely enough, the Yemen
Arabs venerate as the tomb of Job a
whitewashed shrine perched on the sum-
mit of Jebel Hesha; but the local Jews
themselves have no regard for it.
Like most Jewish history, the history
of the Jews of Yemen has been seared
by persecution, indifference, interludes of
quietness. Until the twelfth century
their lives were fairly placid, disrupted
only by occasional Moslem attacks. But
the Yemeni Jews, gathering their scant
tunics around their spare bodies, inten-
sified their absorption in Talmudic lore.
In the twelfth century, to build up their
morale, Maimonides sent them his famous
epistle, exhorting them to hold to their
faith. From the twelfth to the nine-
teenth century, scarred almost continu-
ously by Arab hostilities and later by
Arab and Turkish warfare, the Jews were
the scapegoats, victims of both sides. As
a minority, they had little redress, and
THE JEWS
their essential helplessness resulted in the
deprivation, or rather non-fulfillment, of
their civil rights. In the eighties of last
century, however, they began to migrate
to Palestine. It was hazardous, however,
for Jews to leave the Yemen. The Imam
Yahya, who recently died and who had
been an autocrat for over four decades,
permitted Jews, caught leaving the coun-
try for Palestine, to be killed off-hand.
There are at present some twenty Pales-
tinian settlements of Yemeni, complete
with their ancient customs and crafts.
In Yemen itself, out of an estimated pop-
ulation of about three and a half mil-
lion, about 60,000 are Jews.
Yemeni Jews live in many villages and
smaller towns throughout the Arab ter-
ritory; but they always cling to their
Hebrew and to the Pentateuch, even in
the midst of Arab surroundings. They
form, as it were, little oases of rigidly
preserved patterns of ancient culture, ad-
hering to Talmudic literature and the
mystical Kabbalah. That is one main-
spring of their existence, possibly the only
one. In the town of Lodar, about one
hundred miles northeast of Aden, there
were in 1939 some thirteen Jewish fam-
ilies, living in a confined Jewish quarter.
The men wear ringlets of hair at the
ears, while skull caps and knee-long
tunics readily accentuate their identity.
They assiduously study, in addition to the
Talmud, a body of scrupulously trans-
mitted apocrypha, legends and anecdotes
of various kinds. Intermarriage is shunned
and occurs rarely. The women do not
work in the fields, like the Arab women,
but devote their time to keeping neat,
clean, though humble homes. They even
do their hair into a semblance of fashion,
and occasionally paint their cheeks a yel-
low color. The men are artisans, potters,
embroiderers, sellers of clothes, leather-
tanners and, very largely, silversmiths,
making earrings, filigree work, girdles,
bangles, jambiyat and similar articles for
Arab adornment. They also make axe-
heads for chopping wood, wooden keys
and wooden locks for house doors. Some-
The Colorful History of
An Ancient Community
OF YEMEN
By HARRY E. WEDECK
times these craftsmen wander among
Arab villages like gypsy tinkers. In a
civic sense, they are compelled also to
accept the most menial work, cleaning
cesspools and digging ditches, like the
mehtars of India.
The houses of the Yemeni Jews are
primitive, following the type of Arab
house; sometimes held together by dried
branches. But in the towns there are
rugs on the floor, a few pieces of basic
furniture, a narghileh (water smoking
pipe) and a coffee set. The dances of
the Yemeni Jews are picturesque. The
men, tall, bearded, with shaven heads and
coiffed with skull caps, dance slowly in
pairs. Rabbis in red kerchiefs open a
text and lead wailing tremulous choruses
as the dancers pound out their rhythms.
The dance ended, the men depart into
the darkness, making their way home-
ward by means of primitive lanterns.
In Al Jof, there are Jews living among
the Arabs but easily identifiable by their
earlocks. These Jews do not carry arms,
the Arab explanation being that the Jews
are too weak. But the taxes imposed on
them are heavy. They are forbidden to
ride donkeys or camels. In public, they
must walk to the right of a Moslem,
while a more sinister ordinance compels
Jewish orphans under thirteen to become
Moslems. In law, furthermore, the tes-
timony of Yemeni Jews is void.
In northern Yemen the Jews are known
as Haidans. Other Jews are in the vil-
lages of Al Quibeli and Mas'am, eking
out an austere living by practicing their
craft as silversmiths. East of the city
of Dhamar is a "Jew" town. In south
Yemen, east of the chief city of Ta'Izz,
there is a tomb of a Jewish saint — Weli
Shebazi — engraved with a Hebrew in-
scription. It is a small, one-roomed stone
building, whitewashed in the usual
Yemeni manner. The tomb is an object
of veneration and pilgrimage to many
pious Yemeni Jews, including women.
[Continued on page 20]
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
10
An Intimate Picture of the Jeivish
Colony in the Irish Metropolis
IT IS Friday afternoon, in Dublin.
Rubenstein's the butcher is crowded.
Outside on Clanbrassil Street, the
Delancey of Dublin, the curbs are lined
with the crowded stalls of the Dublin
(non- Jewish) fishwives, who set up their
herrings, whiting, mackerel or salmon, in
season, every Friday. Occasionally, above
the conversation and friendly wrangling
in the butcher shop, you hear their
piercing cry of "Fresh fish" or "Fresh
herrings."
After getting her meat from Ruben-
stein's the Yiddish housewife buys her
groceries at Ordman's or at one of the
other groceries which line Clanbrassil
Street (about 90% of the food, clothing,
book and other shops there are owned by
Jews). Then she gets her fish from the
fishwomen at the stalls. Wrapped in
black shawls, these women have the ready
wit and biting sarcasm of the Irish and
drive a hard bargain. But once they get
to know you they are your friends for
life. They live in the Coombe and on
Fridays come to sell their fish to the
Jews for Friday dinner and to their own
people, who reluctantly eat it on Fast
days. Many a delicious gefulte fish
started on their stalls, and Howth her-
rings from Dublin Bay are delicious
sweet and sour, baked, or laid to salt or
pickle.
•
The south side of Dublin is where the
Jews congregated from the beginning.
It has become like the Lower East Side
in New York. You can get lox and
baigels and other delicacies in all the gro-
ceries here, and on Pesach they all are
completely Pesachdig. Goldberg's, the
bakers, supplies the chalath on Fridays,
and I remember often waiting for him
to take them from the oven. No bread
ever tasted or smelled so good. There
was also a special delicious brown bread
baked only by Mr. Goldberg and the one
or two other Jewish bakers who later
supplemented him. I have never seen it
anywhere else, London, New York and
Paris included. It was a pinky brown
inside, the upper crust was a shiny choco-
late brown, and the under, floury oat-
meal colored. But we imported our
matzoth from London or Manchester.
All the Dublin Jews were strictly
orthodox, the second generation may have
become more lax but there are no such
things as a liberal or reform school. We
LIFE IN
even had special sugar and milk on
Pesach, and when at one period our fam-
ily lived too far from the Jewish com-
munity to get our milk from the kosher
dairy, we went to the cow shed every day
with our own cans to see that the cow
was milked directly into our own pail.
We probably had the most Pesachdig
milk in the world.
Pesach was indeed one of the high-
lights of the year. There was the mat-
zoth, which we enjoyed and distributed
to all our neighbors, just as we sampled
a hundred Christmas cakes and puddings
at Christmas. Sometimes my mother
would make her own wine, as many other
people did, though I think making Mehd,
honey wine, was illegal without a license.
We always had new clothes to go to
shul in, more so than the gentile kids
had for Easter.
Though the other children shared the
goodies of Pesach with us they never
participated in the religious ceremonies.
But there were times when we would ac-
company them to Mass, though I must
say we did not pay much attention to it.
We were excused from religious instruc-
tion. We went to cheder three times a
week and the other children went to Sun-
day School and were busy with com-
munion and confirmation. We were
strangely uncurious about each other's
religion, though we were always delighted
when our holidays fell on school days,
and tried to explain their significance.
We had a Chanukah party at the school,
when we all got bags of sweets and cakes,
and loved rattling our noise-makers.
•
The Catholic priests never tried to con-
vert us or our families, though we were
frequently visited by Protestant mission-
aries — missionark.es we called them. There
was always a polite though, on my par-
ents' side, somewhat triumphant discus-
sion about religion. The missionaries
continued to be good friends of ours over
the years, occasionally leaving tracts or
the New Testaments, and regularly every
Christmas they sent a huge box of
candies.
DUBLIN
By JACQUELINE SAYERS
My first personal contact with a Cath-
olic priest was when I went to college.
Many of the Jewish girls and boys, espe-
cially the intelligent ones, went to col-
lege. Most of them took medicine, law
or dentistry. Very few boys took arts,
and those that did studied Oriental lan-
guages, Hebrew and kindred subjects, at
which they had a head start. The few I
know personally who took arts are now
lecturers or professors in Hebrew at Trin-
ity College. My sister took Hebrew and
Semitic languages. She was coached by
the headmaster of the cheder and Jewish
students. But my college was the Cath-
olic University, or rather the National
University of Ireland, which was Cath-
olic. I was interested in Hebrew, and
to my surprise found that I was the only
one who was. The Hebrew professor was
a charming, kindly parish priest who took
a friendly interest in me. He corrected
my Ashkenazi pronunciation, learned
from my cheder days, to the Sephardic.
My sister and I used to come to tea with
him at his lovely home in one of the sea-
side suburbs of Dublin. His library,
where he entertained us, overlooked the
Dublin Bay, and while I sat admiring the
view and drinking tea and eating the de-
licious home-made cakes his housekeeper
served us on a gleaming and ornate sil-
ver service, we discussed Palestine and
Jerusalem, and even politics. He was
widely travelled but a scholar at heart,
so I don't think we had much in com-
mon. On the surface we were a widely
travelled family, as were most of the
Dublin community. You would bump
into Dublin people on the continent and
in England and over here, too. Dr. and
Mrs. Isaac Herzog, the Chief Rabbi of
Palestine and his wife, are Dubliners.
There is a group of Irish Jews who meet
regularly in Chicago, and every letter I
get from home tells me of this person
or that who is spending her vacation or
honeymoon in America.
When Irish became compulsory in the
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
II
schools, the Jewish children were often
the most fluent if not the best speakers
of the language. One difficulty they did
not have was the pronunciation of the
gutteral sounds, with which Hebrew and
Yiddish had made them familiar. -The
gentile children did not like the harsh
gutterals, and they often spoiled their ac-
cents by refusing to pronounce it prop-
erly. But we delighted in a third lan-
guage and found similarities between
Yiddish and Irish.
There is a thriving Jewish community
in Cork, and that is where I and most
of my family were born. We came to
Dublin shortly after, in time it turned
out for the "troubles" — with the Eng-
lish. And we were, hardly, an enthusi-
astic part of it. s My parent's first anxiety
was to earn a living, for there were quite
a number of mouths to feed. But I sup-
pose it was impossible not to take a vio-
lent interest in the politics at the time.
To this day the Black and Tans, which
was the nickname given the British sol-
diers because of the colors of their uni-
forms, conjures up something of the
most obnoxious nature. Many of the
Jewish people were involved in the plan-
ning and fighting. A tragic reminder
of this was to occur some years later.
On the night a cousin who fought with
the Irish was married, his best man was
shot and killed. It was believed that he
was taken for my cousin.
•
Many a story I heard of the men on
the run from the British who slept in our
kitchen, or who were given a good meal
or that Irish cure-all, a cup of tea. And
many the policeman who was put off
with another cup of tea or a bottle of
Guinness ale, or a sharp answer, which
saved the life of a hero. An uncle of
mine is fond of telling how De Valera
often slept in his kitchen during those
days. I remember vaguely my mother
not letting us play in the yard, and
worrying about my eldest sister coming
home from school by the Portobello
Barracks, later named the Griffith Bar-
racks after the Irish hero. And the nights
we brought our mattresses downstairs and
slept on the floor seemed more like play
to us. One of my earliest recollections
is that of attending the funeral of
Michael Collins. My father brought me
in his arms to see the funeral procession
of the hero of the troubles who fought
valiantly against the English. He and
Arthur Griffith were close friends until
the signing of treaty with England which
split Ireland into North and South.
It was about this time that my grand-
mother came to Ireland from Russia.
Like most of the other immigrants before
and after, she brought her feather bed,
prrririe, and her candlesticks and her
stassel. She made us taglecb, something
my mother would never take the time
to do, and lokshen. She came from Tcls
and there were many Tellser in Dublin.
They worked hard. At first the first
generation did not mingle with the Irish
except in business, but later there was
very little difference between them ex-
cept religion.
•
The Dublin Jewry had its aristocracy
— doctors and even one stockbroker — but
soon education and money became cri-
teria. Now Dublin Jews are in every
trade and profession. There are several
fine artists and actors. People here are
often surprised at the number of women
doctors and lawyers among the Dublin
Jews. One Dublin woman married an
American and about ten years later re-
turned from her home in the United
States with her four daughters to give
them an Irish education. They went to
University and studied professions, teach-
ing, medicine, dentistry and architecture.
All but one has returned to America, but
all now have good Irish accents, and are
the product of the Irish educational
system.
The Dublin Jew is a respected indi-
vidual. He keeps the law, works hard
and rarely gets into trouble. But in our
childhood there was one character who
was not so respectable. He is dead these
few years and he wanted it to be quicker.
He was "Poor Old Joe" to the police,
to whom he was a well known character,
and they treated him with affectionate
despair. Joe was an alcoholic, but dur-
ing his good periods a clever wit and the
chronicler of the Jewish holidays in the
Irish papers. He would contribute a long
and scholarly account of the various holi-
days to the press whose editors knew him
and his weaknesses. He even wrote a
book about Dublin Jews which did not
please them a bit, but it became some-
what of a classic and was reprinted every
once in a while.
All the Dublin Jewish families had
their own houses, large or small accord-
ing to their needs, the size of their fam-
ilies or their income, but for years Joe,
a bachelor, lived in lodgings, and his land-
lady kept him in immaculate condition
except during his periodic binges. Dur-
ing these he was completely out of his
mind. However, after a rest cure in a
nursing home he was always cheerful
again, well groomed, handsome and full
of witticisms, especially about his sojourn
in the courts and in hospital.
•
Towards the end Joe became more and
more subject to his spells and the lucid
moments became less frequent. He was
finally killed in a street accident. Joe
was well liked in Dublin when he was
himself. He was the subject of all kinds
of stories, and the originator of many
funny ones. He it was who was sup-
posed to have nicknamed a certain Mr.
Bernstein, a lawyer, "Necessity Bern-
stein" because necessity knows no law.
But not all his jokes were at someone's
expense. I remember him coming to
spend an evening with us and telling
anecdote after anecdote. He kept my
mother and father laughing long after
we were sent to bed.
As the time passed things changed.
After De Valera became premier new
taxes were imposed on imports. Many
Jews came to Dublin from England,
Scotland and Wales to start business. A
new group sprang up. The Dublin com-
munity was no longer the closely-knit one
it was. Instead of the exclusively Irish
accent of the Yiddish people, you heard
the strong Scottish burrs, or the Cock-
ney twang, or the soft Welsh accent. The
Jews may move away from the South side
and the Circular Road (which is circu-
lar) but they always come back to do
their shopping in the same place, for
where else can you get the same food?
The women still line the curb with their
fish stalls on Fridays, though the cob-
blestones have been replaced by a con-
crete road. Rubenstein's is larger and has
the most modern equipment available,
as have Ordman's the grocers, and the
other shops. There is still the cheder on
weekend mornings but in the new com-
bined school and synagogue, both well
equipped and large. Many things have
changed as everywhere, but the essentials
remain.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
12
NEW BOOKS
Reviewed by DR. ISRAEL H. LEVINTHAL,
JACOB KAPLAN and LAZAR E. LEVINTHAL
"Sex Laws and Customs in Judaism," by
Louis M. Epstein, L.H.D., D.D.
IT IS indeed a rare privilege to see such
an important subject treated in so
scholarly and yet popular fashion as is this
work by Dr. Epstein. The author has
already enriched Jewish literature by his
classic studies in analogous fields. His
previously published books on "The Jew-
ish Marriage Contract," "Marriage Laws
in the Bible and the Talmud," have won
for him world-wide recognition as one
of the leading authorities on these mat-
ters. His latest book will add to his de-
served fame.
The report of the sexual behavior of
the American male of our day, as revealed
in the Kinsey report, makes it even more
important to study the Jewish teachings
and the norms of Jewish behavior in this
phase of life. The very fact that in the
Kinsey survey the conduct of the observ-
ing Jew rates high according to accepted
standards of chastity and purity is suf-
ficient recommendation for our sup-
posedly antiquated code with all its
shortcomings.
Dr. Epstein starts with an historical
study of sex morality in the early Bibli-
cal period, then traces the social and cul-
tural influences in the post-exilic period,
its development in the Talmudic and
post-Talmudic periods, down through the
middle ages and up to quite recent times.
Every phase of life which is even indi-
rectly connected with the subject is
treated by the author with a thorough-
ness and scholarly background that wins
the admiration of the reader.
Space permits only the briefest men-
tion of some of the subjects discussed in
this interesting volume: Nudity, exposure
of parts of body, the covering of the face
of women, the covering of the hair, the
peruque, ornaments and cosmetics, wear-
ing garments of the opposite sex; sex
segregation in synagogue or Temple, in
schools, at weddings and funerals, at
feasts and public celebrations; private re-
lations between sexes, flirtation and love-
making; natural and unnatural sex con-
duct; rape and seduction, adultery.
The discussion of all of these and the
other themes is based upon thorough
research and great erudition, as attested
by the vast amount of our ancient litera-
ture quoted in the scholarly notes.
In reading these teachings of our sages,
one must agree with the author when he
says: "On the whole, that rabbinic tra-
dition which fashioned Jewish life for
twenty centuries is the result of the com-
mon sense, the level-headedness, the close
contact with life, and the practical piety
of the talmudic sages. These qualities
also characterized their approach to prob-
lems of sex morality."
Modern civilization, in which emanci-
pated Jewry has shared to the full, has
no doubt made Jewish life broader and
richer in many ways. But, after reading
this volume, you must come to the con-
clusion of Dr. Epstein that "it is ques-
tionable whether it has given the Jew a
better code of sex morality than the one
depicted here, which grew out of his
native moral reactions and bore the stamp
of religious authority."
Dr. Epstein deserves a hearty Y'yasher
Ko'ach for a work that will do much to
enlighten Jew and non-Jew in the matter
of sex ideals and behavior among our
people throughout the ages.
"Hammer on the Rock" — A Short Mid-
rash Reader, edited by Nahum N. Glatzer.
The Midrash represents a number of
collections of rabbinic interpretations of
the Biblical text, which deal not with
legal decisions or discussions, but rather
with moral, philosophical, ethical and
mystical phases of life. Here, too, one
finds legends and folk-tales woven by the
ancient preachers and the masses of peo-
ple themselves around their Biblical
heroes and the events that the Bible
relates.
Our great national poet, Bialik, cor-
rectly characterized the influence of these
spheres of thought in the moulding of
Jewish life. "The Halakah" (the legal
literature), fed by a world of reality, is
concerned with that which is, with life
that is already established, and shows us
the actual substance of the life of the
people. But as we read the Haggadah
(the Midrashic, or legendary and folk-
tale literature), we know what the soul
of che people meditated, what it yearned
for, and to what it aspired."
This material represents a vast litera-
ture, and there are, fortunately, a few
works in the English language, for the
student who desires to become acquainted
with this rich storehouse of the Jew. The
Soncino translation of Midrash Rabbah
and Professor Louis Ginzberg's "The
Legends of the Jews" are two noteworthy
examples.
This little volume, edited by Dr.
Glatzer, is one of the very few popular
collections of Midrashic, teachings, trans-
lated into beautiful English, that gives
the reader a true insight into the wisdom
inherent in these ancient teachings. There
are only about 200 of these gems in the
book, but the editor has shown great skill
in selecting choice morsels of sayings and
interpretations.
The title of this work is significant,
for it tells in striking fashion what the
Midrash really is. Quoting the verse
from Jeremiah 23:29, "Is not My word
like ... a hammer that breaketh the rock
in pieces?" the Rabbis in the Talmud add:
"As the hammer splits the rock into many
splinters, so will a scriptural verse yield
many meanings." The passages collected
in this Midrash Reader show how these
great teachers of the past found the in-
spiration and support for all their ideas
revealed in the eternal word of the Bible.
"Hammer on the Rock" will do much
to awaken in American Jews a new in-
terest in the beautiful, quaint and pro-
found teachings of the ancient Rabbis,
many of which have a vital message even
for our ultra modern age.
— Dr. Israel H. Levinthal.
•
"My Glorious Brothers," by Howard Fast.
With the rebirth of the State of Israel
many writers of Jewish origin the world
over are beginning to probe deeply into
Jewish history, traditions and folklore in
order to reveal the many-sided richness of
the Jewish cultural past. Just as the ad-
vent of Irish independence inspired writers
like Joyce, George Moore and Lord Dun-
sany to turn to the Celtic past, so the ren-
ascense of Israel is motivating writers like
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
13
Nathan Ansubel, Ari Ibn-Zahav and
Howard Fast to dip into the Jewish past.
Those of us who have followed How-
ard Fast's creative work recall a poem he
wrote about two years ago in consecra-
tion to the martyrs of the Warsaw ghetto.
The poem evinced a deep Jewish con-
sciousness on Fast's part. Out of this
consciousness comes this novel of the
Maccabees. Today the men of the Pal-
mach and the Haganah are the lineal
descendants of those ancient Jewish
heroes. Their fight for a modern Israel
had its counterpart more than two thou-
sand years ago in the struggle of Judea
against the attempt of Antiochus Epi-
phanes to Hellenize and enslave it. Fast
fashioned this novel from the legends of
the Bible and other historical accounts
to show the organic unity of the Mac-
cabees with their present day prototypes.
The historic framework of the novel
should be familiar to us all. In the sec-
ond century before Christ, Antiochus
Epiphanes, King of the Greek Empire, set
about compelling Judea to adopt his false,
idol-worshipping brand of Hellenism.
His mercenaries pillaged the country,
murdered its people and desecrated the
temples. Destiny called for men to lead
the people of Judea against their oppres-
sors, and destiny answered by producing
Mattathias, a Jewish priest, and his five
sons. It was they who rallied Judea to
fight the phalanxes of the oppressors in
guerrila-style warfare. It was they who
led this comparatively small nation in a
successful fight for three decades against
the numerically superior foe. It was they
who redeemed the temples from the vio-
lations of the idol-worshipping Greek-
Syrian oppressors. It is their story the
Jews of the world celebrate as Ghanuka.
* * *
The search by man for freedom has
been the predominant note of all of Fast's
novels. This book is no exception. In
it the Jews have a veritable passion for
freedom. They are believers in the
Brotherhood of Man. The Greek Empire
of the second century B.C. was a slave-
holding world. Not so the world of the
Jews. They followed the Mosaic law that
a slave could not be held enthralled for
more than seven years and was to be
freed if mistreated. Behind this attitude
was the memory of Jewish oppression.
"For we were ourselves slaves in Egypt,"
is the constant refrain of these Jews. Re-
membering this, they permitted slaves to
marry and become one with them. The
fighters under the Maccabees had one slo-
gan: "Resistance to tyranny is the truest
obedience to God." Judas the Maccabee
inspires the Jews to battle with the ques-
tion, "Is it better to die on your feet —
or to live on your knees?" Here was
a classic pattern for freedom that many
other peoples were to emulate in their
own struggles for freedom through the
centuries.
» * *
The creative artist in Fast gives us
excellent characterizations of the Macca-
bees. The father, Mattathias, is a priestly
militant who convinces his sons it is their
mission to lead their people against the
enemy. Judas emerges from Fast's pen
as a man of destiny, a great guerrilla
chief, an able military strategist; Eleazer
is a good-natured, noble figure of Gar-
gantuan strength; Simon is the sagacious
inheritor of the mantle of his father on
the latter's death; John is a gentle, pas-
sive, almost saintly man; and Jonathan is
a mere youth dedicated to his brothers
and his people. Between Judas and Simon
there is rivalry. Both love the same
woman, Ruth. Simon, at times, is envi-
ous of his brother's leadership qualities,
his way with people, his handsomeness of
person. But the death of Ruth and the
common cause against the oppressor, re-
solve the problem. In the end Simon's
love for his brother is far greater than
his rivalry.
Fast's craftsmanship is noteworthy.
Apparently he turned to Graetz, Josephus
and the Bible for source material. He
has succeeded in producing a fast-moving,
easily read narrative, of which the climax
is the death of Judas.
Fast has used an interesting technique
to tell the Maccabean history — Roman
legate summarizes it in a report to his su-
perior. Fast's dexterity as a writer is
also shown in his successful capturing of
Biblical rhythms, which brings to the
work a lyrical, emotional quality.
There is a serious omission in the novel.
Graetz shows that the Jews who fought
with the Maccabees were inspired to mili-
tancy by the writings known to us today
as the Book of Daniel, created by the
Chassidim of the day to remind the Jews
of their ideals. In his "Citizen Tom
Paine" Fast saw fit to emphasize Tom
Paine's writings as a unifying force in
the American Revolution. Had he in-
dicated how the Book of Daniel shaped
Jewish morale in the days of the Mac-
cabees he would have added an authentic
note.
•
"S/r>7oc£'s Daughter," by Art Ibu-Zabav.
In writing "The Merchant of Venice"
Shakespeare fell in with one of the lit-
erary vogues of the day. Some of his
Elizabethan contemporaries penned plays
about the usurious Jew, of which the best
known besides Shakespeare's drama is
Marlowe's "Jew of Malta." Sir Sidney
Lee, veteran Shakespearean scholar, has
argued that the famous state trial of Dr.
Roderigo Lopez, Elizabethan court physi-
cian, prompted the bard's writing of the
play. Lopez was alleged to be a crypto-
Jew who intrigued against a Portuguese
nobleman called Antonio, the same name
as Shylock's adversary. Lee's theory has
gained some plausibility because "The
Merchant of Venice" was staged two
months after the trial.
It is an historical fact that no Jews
were in Elizabethan England. It is there-
fore true that the picture of the usurious
Jew represented on the stage was based
on a spurious conception, as has been
pointed out by Tawney, the English so-
cial scientist, our own Oliver Wendell
Holmes, and others. The Elizabethan
stage Jew was a distorted, mendacious
caricature which had no relation to real-
ity. But Shakespeare, profound psychol-
ogist that he was, transcended his theme.
He reveals Shylock as a human being mo-
tivated in his desire for vengeance by the
fact that his daughter Jessica has eloped
with a Christian. As those great Shakes-
pearean actors, Edmund Kean and Sir
Henry Irving, played Shylock they inter-
preted him as an abject figure who is
more deserving of our pity than our
scorn. It was this fact that led Heinrich
Heine to deny that Shakespeare's Shylock
put the bard among the Jew-baiters of
literature.
Thus it is that the figure of Shylock
has been a controversial figure among our
men of letters. But in the popular mind
Shylock has passed into the language as
a symbol of opprobrium for unscrupulous
usuriousness. Shylock set the pattern for
hundreds of literary caricatures in Amer-
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
14
ican, English and German literature
which slandered the Jew. The pattern
has done irreparable harm to the Jewish
people, culturally and socially. It ob-
scured the great contributions to civil-
ization of the Jewish people to religion,
social thinking and culture.
In "Shylock's Daughter," lately pro-
duced as a play by Maurice Schwartz, we
have a novel written specifically to refute
and correct the Shylock legend. Ari
Ibn-Zahav has turned to Renaissance
documents, thereby giving his work the
authentic touch. His book gives us an
adequate picture of the social conditions
of the Jews of the time; Shakespeare gives
us practically none. Those were the days
of the Inquisition. Paul IV was on the
papal throne and proved an unmitigated
tyrant whose Roman laws resembled the
Nuremberg laws of the modern Hitler.
The threat of the Inquisition over-
shadowed the ghettos where Jews are im-
mured. Hebrew books were proscribed
and burned. Jews turned to the Talmud
in covert study. Impossible taxes were
extorted from the Jewish community.
Many Jews, like Rabbi Schlomo Yehya,
martyred themselves for the Law of
Moses. An ugly red hat and a badge
of identification were worn by the Jew.
He was subjected to indignities and
persecutions.
* * *
Ari Ibn-Zahav's Shylock emerges
clearly as a victim of this persecution.
He is far more benevolent than his
Shakespearean prototype. He is devoted
to the cause of world Jewry and his fel-
low Venetian Jews. As treasurer and
elder of the Jewish community he is one
of its rulers who contribute money, and
person to lighten the sufferings of his co-
religionists. His is a profound, under-
standable bitterness against the Chris-
tians because of their persecutions. He
reacts strongly against the humiliations
which Christians heap upon him, such
as spitting in his face and reviling him
with the epithets "dog" and "leech." He
hates with fierce bitterness the apostate
Jews won over by the Inquisition. But
Shylock is not all hatred. He loves the
faith of his fathers. He loves his daugh-
ter, Jessica, dearly. He chooses Don
Samuel Morro, a crypto- Jew who has es-
caped from the persecution of the In-
quisition for her husband. He prevails
upon Morro to teach her the lore of
Judaism as a preliminary to marriage.
But Jessica frustrates her father's plans.
Her nature shows considerable dualism of
spirit. Not too schooled in Judaism, she
is attracted to the Renaissance gayety of
Venice. She does not share her father's
bitterness against the gentile world. She
vacillates between Morro, symbolizing the
Jewish world, and Lorenzo, a Venetian
nobleman, symbolizing the Renaissance
world. Finally she elopes with Lorenzo
and accepts baptism. Where Shylock has
been bitter he now becomes fanatical in
his hatred. He swears vengeance on
Antonio who has aided Lorenzo in win-
ning Jessica.
* * *
Apparently, the novelist considers the
trial scene of importance, and he thus
devotes a great deal of attention to it.
The trial in Shakespeare's play has Portia
succeed in resolving it by obtaining a
judgment that obliges not to shed any
of Antonio's blood or be punished by
death. The Doge remits the sentence on
condition that Shylock become a Chris-
tian and surrender half his fortune to
Antonio. In this novel Don Samuel is
Shylock's lawyer. He refutes Portia's
argument that blood must not be drawn
by pointing out the lash is permitted in
Venice even if it draw blood. When
Portia argues that Shylock is permitted
to take one pound, no more, no less, he
refutes her by indicating that Shylock
make take up to one pound with im-
punity, and could certainly take half a
pound. He thus satisfies the Doge that
Shylock may collect his fine in terms of
Venetian law.
The climax of the book is reached in
Shylock's debate with himself regarding
the exaction of the fine. The Jewish
community pleads with him to forfeit
the fine but he is adamant. But he re-
cants at the last moment. He cannot
shed Antonio's blood. "I cannot, I can-
not — I cannot do it. I am a Jew."
Thus Ari Ibn-Zahav has written a
novel which is a penetrating corrective
of the Shylock legend. He has succeeded
in giving Shylock a great deal more
human dignity and credibility than did
Shakespeare's play. The work is also a
good historical novel with authoritative
touches, such as discussions of Michael
Angelo, Aretino and other Renaissance
figures. It is a novel which deserves a
place in all our schools and libraries, and
should be read with Shakespeare's play.
The book suffers from a somewhat heavy
style on occasions, but this heaviness is
lost in the absorbing importance of the
theme.
— Jacob Kaplan.
•
"The Jew in American Sports" by Harold
U. Ribalow. With a Preface by Barney
Ross.
Some of my friends who saw this book
on my desk strongly disapproved of its
title on the theory that classifying Amer-
icans into sub-divisions such as Jewish-
Americans is, in and of itself, un-
American. Others, perhaps less sensitive,
realizing that Americans are sub-divided
every day into various categories, look
upon this title as impersonally as if the
book had dealt with the New Englander,
the Left-Handers, or even Women in
American Sports.
This book is a series of thumb-nail
sketches and profiles of twenty-five
American-Jewish athletes who have
gained prominence in their respective
fields. It is a book about Jews, and it
is refreshing to note that the author
sticks to his subject without dragging in
anti-Semitism. Neither does Ribalow
bask in the reflected glory which these
athletes have brought to their race.
Because baseball is our national game
the author has included more Jewish base-
ball players than their measure of suc-
cess in this sport would warrant. Boxers,
football and basketball players make up
the bulk of the remaining profiles, which
are every bit as interesting. The work
is not intended to be encyclopedic, and
therefore Mr. Ribalow can be readily for-
given for having omitted some particular
favorite of the reader. He deserves much
credit for the amazing coverage he has
cramped into 288 pages. Golf, chess,
bull-fighting, hockey, tennis, bowling,
horse-racing and fencing are a few of
the sports discussed. It must be presumed
that swimming, ping-pong and archery
were not included only because the line
must be drawn somewhere.
The book will prove of particular in-
terest to many of our young people, who
will experience a surge of pride in seeing
how well represented the Jews are in
sports.
— Lazar E. Levinthal.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
IS
NEWS
ISRAEL has issued the text of a pro-
posed Constitution. A comprehensive
analysis of this document is given in
the article by William I. Siegel beginning
on page 5 of this issue of the Review.
The United Nations General Assembly
adjourned its Paris session following the
formation of a Palestine conciliation com-
mission composed of the United States,
France and Turkey with the powers and
functions formerly held by the U.N. Pal-
estine mediator and the Security Council
truce commission.
A resolution adopted by the Assembly
instructs the commission to assist the
governments concerned to achieve a final
settlement on all outstanding questions
with regard to Palestine. At the same
time, the Assembly resolution called on
the Palestine disputants to seek agreement
by negotiation either through the com-
mission or directly. The Assembly also
reaffirmed the decision of a year ago to
place Jerusalem under an international
regime.
The Assembly decision to set up the
commission was adopted by a vote of 3 5
to 15, with eight abstentions. Voting
against the resolution were: Afghanistan,
Byelorussia, Czechoslovakia, Cuba, Egypt,
Iraq, Lebanon, Pakistan, Poland, Saudi
Arabia, Syria, the Ukraine, the Soviet
Union, Yemen and Yugoslavia.
Commenting on the Assembly resolu-
tion, an Israeli delegation spokesman said:
"Israel views with satisfaction that the
resolution contains no vestige of endorse-
ment of the late mediator's report which
the delegation declared from the outset
to be unacceptable even as a basis for
discussion. Moreover, there is nothing
in the resolution which invalidates in any
way the basic principles of the Palestine
partition resolution of November 29,
1947."
Asserting that Israel has consistently
advocated a settlement through negotia-
tion — which the Assembly now provides
— the spokesman reaffirmed Israel's will-
ingness to enter into negotiations with-
out delay. The negotiations, he added,
should aim at a solution of the problem
by agreement on all problems between
the Arabs and Jews, taking full account
of "existing realities."
The proposed conciliation in Palestine
will cost the United Nations $4,092,000
for the next ten months — $6. for each
adult Israeli and Arab to be conciliated
in Palestine.
At the start, the projected U.N. con-
ciliation commission would have 500
military observers, 107 internationally re-
cruited officials and 72 technical per-
sonnel. Altogether, the proposed three
grand conciliators will have a staff of
679.
The whole ten months of conciliation
will cost less than three days' war in Pal-
estine cost the combatants. It will cost
less than one week's additional expendi-
ture by Israel for defense against Egypt
alone.
The British Government, in the per-
son of Foreign Under Secretary Christo-
pher Mayhew, served notice that it is
not prepared to recognize Israel, while
wartime Prime Minister Winston Church-
ill demanded that Britain recognize the
Jewish state. Both statements were made
in the course of the second day of a for-
eign policy debate in the House of
Commons.
Describing the establishment of Israel
as an "event in world history," Churchill
insisted that the Israeli Government can-
not be ignored. Calling for an end to
the Labor Government's "sulky boycott"
of the Jewish state, the Conservative
leader asked that British representatives
be sent to Tel Aviv immediately.
"A settlement of the Palestine ques-
tion would certainly have been attempted
in the closest possible association with the
United States and in personal contact
with the President by any government of
which I happened to have been the head,"
Churchill stated. Summing up the
achievements of the Jews in establishing
their state, he said: "The Jews have
driven out the Arabs from a larger area
than contemplated under the partition
decision; they have established a govern-
ment which functions efficiently; they
have a victorious army at their disposal;
and, they have the support of both the
Soviets and the United States."
He also claimed that once the war ends,
it will be easy to establish an Arab fed-
eration consisting of several Arab states
and one Jewish nation. Addressing him-
self to Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin,
Churchill reminded him that he had
staked his reputation on solving the Pal-
estine problem. Referring to the Trans-
jordan issue raised by the British delegate
at the United Nations, Churchill warned
against aiding Transjordan in its present
conflict.
"If Transjordan is attacked and we are
brought in," he pointed out, "it might
bring us into dispute with the United
States. After all the good work we have
done in Palestine it would be tragic if
the only result we carried away was a
deep divergence between ourselves and
the United States."
Mayhew, in his statement, insisted that
Britain has no intention of permanently
ostracizing the Jewish state. Asserting
that the British Government looks for-
ward to friendly relations with Israel, he
revealed that the British Consul General
at Haifa was returning to Palestine for
consultations following a visit to Lon-
don. "The question of establishing bet-
ter contacts with the Jewish authorities,
without prejudice to the question of rec-
ognition, is being closely studied by the
government."
The pro-Israel attitude adopted by
Anthony Eden and Winston Churchill,
opposition leaders, in the foreign affairs
debate in the House of Commons brings
recognition of Israel by Britain "appre-
ciably closer," in the view of official cir-
cles and also in the opinion of Israeli ob-
servers in London. The keenest Foreign
Office observers are anxiously watching
the forthcoming elections in Israel. In
their view, Britain and the United States
must make an important, magnanimous
gesture toward Israel, if only to give
those elements in Israel which are pro-
Anglo-American the necessary electoral
appeal against other elements which look
to Russia. Many Britishers are sorely
worried over defence problems and they
see Israel as the only militarily powerful
unit in the Middle East. They view the
Jewish state as the natural ally of Britain
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
16
and the United States in the effort to
maintain strategic control over the vastly
important cross-roads where Europe and
Asia meet.
ft
Against opposition of the other Arab
states, King Abdullah, of Transjordan,
announced himself king of Arab Pales-
tine as well.
ft
Egyptian units, supported by about 1 5
tanks, launched a heavy attack against
the Jewish settlement of Nirim, south of
Gaza, in the Negev. The government
revealed that in a recent clash in the
Negev, the Egyptians lost a battalion,
with the number of dead alone above 100.
ft
Yehezkel Sahar, Inspector General of
the Israeli police, will come to the United
States to study new police investigation
and organization methods.
Minister of Trade Dr. Fritz Bernstein,
addressing a meeting of the General
Zionist executive in Tel Aviv, announced
that a new law on industrial development
in Israel will soon be promulgated.
A total of 5,600 Jewish immigrants
arrived in Haifa. At the same time, two
Israeli freighters laden with citrous prod-
ucts left Haifa for Sweden, England and
Norway with a combined cargo of
130,000 cases of oranges and other fruits.
3 5,000 new immigrants have already
been settled in areas occupied by Israeli
troops. In the past three months 3,000
barracks have been erected and 5,000 are
to be constructed in the coming months.
The Jewish Agency and other Jewish in-
stitutions have established a financing
corporation with a capital of $20,000,000
for this purpose.
ft
The Histadruth Council conference in
Tel Aviv ratified by a vote of 69 to 38
the dissolution of the separate headquar-
ters of Palmach, the striking force of
the former Haganah. The 69 votes were
cast by members of Hapai, the right-
wing labor group within Histadruth, and
the minority ballot was cast by members
of Mapam, the left-wing segment of the
Israeli Labor Federation. The General
Zionists within the Histadruth — Haoved
Hazioni — abstained from voting.
Twenty countries signed the genocide
convention adopted by the United Na-
tions outlawing the mass extermination
of religious and racial groups. Twenty
signatures were needed for the conven-
tion to acquire binding legal force. The
last requirement to be fulfilled is ratifi-
cation by the legislative bodies of the 20
countries whose delegates signed the
document.
A number of Russian amendments
which sought to link the declaration to
the Marxist conception of a state or of
society was defeated before the final vote
was taken.
ft
President Truman indicated that he
will propose to the 81st Congress liber-
alization of the present law for the ad-
mission of displaced persons to the United
States, which he termed anti-Jewish after
it was passed by the 80th Congress.
Rep. Francis E. Walter of Pennsylvania
said that he will introduce a new dis-
placed persons bill on January 3 that will
guarantee against all racial, religious or
nationality discrimination in the dis-
placed persons program. Walter said his
bill will raise the number admissible
under the present law from 205,000 to
J. D. C. Estimates European
Europe's 1,300,000 Jews have reached
the point where their essential recovery
can be completed within three years bar-
ring unforeseen circumstances, Edward
M. M. Warburg, chairman of the Joint
Distribution Committee, declared follow-
ing his return from Europe, where he de-
livered the keynote address at the first
International Conference on Jewish Re-
lief and Rehabilitation.
Warburg warned, however, that while
the end of the emergency period in
Europe is in sight, "a new emergency has
arisen in North Africa and other Moslem
countries." Here, he said, "hundreds of
thousands of Jewish men, women and
children are living under conditions as
miserable and wretched as any on the
face of the earth." In the "mellah"
(ghetto) of Casablanca, he pointed out,
one out of every four Jewish children
die before the age of one year, and tuber-
culosis, typhoid and rickets rage on an
epidemic scale. Some 20,000 homeless
Jewish children, hundreds of them blind
with trachoma, roam the streets, he
stated.
The deteriorating situation in North
Africa and the Arab lands of the Middle
400,000 and will give the refugees four
years instead of two to apply for admis-
sion. The measure would also declare a
DP eligible for consideration if he entered
Germany, Austria or Italy on or after
September 1, 1939, and on or before
April 21, 1947. The present law sets the
date as December 22, 1945, making thou-
sands of East European Jewish refugees
ineligible for admission. Walter's bill
would also remove priority listings for
agriculture workers and would give pref-
erence instead to "farm, household, con-
struction, clothing and garment workers,
and other workers needed in the locality
in the U. S. in which such persons pro-
pose to reside."
A member of the House Judiciary
Committee which handles all displaced
persons and immigration legislation, Wal-
ter said he believes his bill will eliminate
all the discriminatory features in the
present law that President Truman has
repeatedly objected to. Rep Emanuel
Celler is slated to become chairman of
the Judiciary Committee.
Jews Recovery in 3 Years
East, is one of the chief problems which
the J.D.C. must face in the next twelve
months, Warburg said. A second major
responsibility, he added, will be the
emptying of the DP camps through a
speeded-up emigration program. He dis-
closed that the J.D.C. visualizes expendi-
tures amounting to $18,000,000 for emi-
gration activities along next year, adding
that "by next October we hope that
everyone who wants to leave the camps
for Israel will have found a home there"
and that several thousand Jews eligible
for admission to the U. S. under the DP
Act will have been resettled in this
country.
The third major aspect of J.D.C. op-
erations next year will cover increased
efforts aimed at economic reconstruction.
Included under this heading will be in-
tensive, short-term training courses for
at least 75,000 Jews in Eastern Europe,
now "economically displaced" because of
the nationalization of industry and com-
merce there. Another phase of J.D.C.
work on the continent next year is
planned to help local Jewish communities
become strong enough to meet their own
needs.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
17
NEWS OF THE CENTER
Annual Youth Service This Friday
Night, December 24
Our annual youth service which we
hold in our Synagogue every year during
the winter vacation from college and uni-
versity will be held this coming Friday
night, December 24th, at 8:30 o'clock.
Three of our young people who are ac-
tively identified in Jewish communal
work will speak on various phases of Jew-
ish activities which should interest the
youth of our community. Miss Zelda
Funk will speak on "The Challenge
of the State of Israel to the American
Jewish Youth." Mr. Leroy Lowenfeld,
one of the leaders of our Junior Con-
gregation, will speak on "The Challenge
of the Synagogue of Our Youth" and Mr.
Herbert Kummel will speak on "The
American Jewish Youth and Our Jewish
Culture." We hope that all of the
younger people of our Center will attend
this very important service which we are
confident will inspire and enlighten them
on the role that the Jewish youth must
play in these days. Dr. Levinthal and
Rabbi Saltzman will lead the services.
Cantor Sauler will lead in the congre-
gational singing and render a vocal selec-
tion. Members and friends are cordially
invited.
Advance Notice
Next Friday night, December 31st, at
our Late Friday Night Lecture Services,
Rabbi Saltzman will preach the sermon
on the subject "The Challenge of a Re-
dedicated Israel" — a Chanukah sermon.
Junior League Sponsors Chanukah
Social for Keren Ami Fund
The meeting of the Junior League
scheduled for Thursday evening, Decem-
ber 30th, will be in the form of a Cha-
nukah Entertainment and Social for the
benefit of the Junior League Keren Ami
Fund. All members of the Junior League
are cordially invited.
235 Students Registered at Institute of
Jewish Studies for Adults
This year, our Institute of Jewish
Studies for Adults enjoys the largest reg-
istration of men and women students
since its inception sixteen years ago. 23 J
men and women have already enrolled
and the large majority of these students
have registered for more than one course
— some even for three or four courses.
It is interesting to note the number of
students in each of the classes:
Evening Classes
Course
Instructor
Register
Hebrew A-l
Mr. Shpall
31
Hebrew A-2
Mrs. Beder
20
Hebrew B
Mrs. Zusman
24
Hebrew C
Mrs. ^C'einreb
28
Advanced Hebrew
Mrs. N. Cohen
24
Bible in Hebrew
Mrs. N. Cohen
24
Yiddish A
Mr. Pasner
18
Yiddish B
Mr. Edelheit
16
Religion
Rabbi Saltzman
66
Jewish History
Mr. Shpall
32
Talmud A
Dr. Higger
14
Talmud B
Dr. Higger (A
seminar
course for
students
in Talmudic
textual
study)
Morning Classes
Hebrew A-3
Mr. Shpall
29
Bible
Dr. Burnstein
31
Jewish Philosophy
Dr. Burnstein
31
Samuel Pasner Added to Faculty of
Institute of Jewish Studies for Adults
Mr. Pasner has joined the faculty of
our Institute of Jewish Studies and will
be in charge of Yiddish A, which is a
class interested in speaking, reading and
writing Yiddish.
Mr. Pasner is a graduate of Columbia
College, M.A. Teachers College. He is
the author of numerous published syndi-
cated articles printed all through the
United States and Canada; a speaker on
numerous occasions in Yiddish and in
English on the radio. Author of some
articles that were published in the Brook-
lyn Jeichb Center Reiicu'. Teacher at
Tilden High School, formerly educational
director of Tilden P. T. A., formerly
principal of Sunday School at Petach
Tikvah Temple.
Shomrim Club Activities
The Shomrim is the Center Junior
Group for boys between the ages of 13
and 14 which meets Saturday evenings
throughout the school year. It boasts of
25 active members and engages in a pro-
gram of cultural, social and athletic ac-
tivities. Following is a summary of
events of the past month.
The meeting of November 27, 1948,
was devoted to a program appropriate to
the approaching anniversary of the U.N.
Partition Plan. The Balfour Declaration,
Palestine under the British Mandate, and
Arab Jewish relationships were reported
on by the members of the group. Finally,
the significance of the U.N. decision was
the subject of general discussion.
At the meeting of December 4th, the
Shomrim initiated a project of writing
an original play connected with Chanu-
kah. Highlights of the Chanukah story
were discussed, and the general outline of
the play was developed. The meeting of
December 11th was devoted to Jewish
Book Month. "The Wise Men of Chelm,"
the Van Passen picture book on Palestine
and Howard Fast's "Our Glorious
Brothers" were reviewed by the Shomrim.
December 18th was spent revising and
rehearsing the play on the Maccabees.
Appropriate Chanukah games were intro-
duced and played.
Saturday evening, December 2 5th, will
find the Shomrim joining with other Cen-
ter Junior groups in presenting the Cha-
nukah entertainment.
Mr. Joseph Aaron is leader of the
Shomrim group.
Junior Clubs
A gala Chanukah rally of all our
Junior Clubs will take place Saturday
evening, December 2 5th, at 8 o'clock in
the Prayer Room of the Center. The
evening will feature original dramatic
presentations of each group with the
Chanukah holiday and the newly estab-
lished Jewish State as the central themes.
Members of our Junior Clubs are urged
to attend this very important event. The
significance of the Jewish Book has been
prominently used as the basis of Junior
Club programs in celebration of Jewish
Book Month.
There will be no club activities on Sat-
urday evening, January 1, 1949.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
18
Employees' New Year's Gift Fund
In view of the fact that the employees
of the Center are prevented by rules of
the institution from accepting gratuities
throughout the year, the Center has es-
tablished an annual New Year's Gift
Fund.
Chanukah In the Center Academy
The boys and girls of the Center
Academy were very busy before Cha-
nukah. Each of them had an important
job to do and they wanted to do it well.
In keeping with school tradition the
pupils of the eighth grade lighted the
Chanukah candles and led the school in
the chanting of the prayers. The sixth
grade presented their original Hebrew
play "Chanukah Beuthid — Chanukah in
the Future" which they had themselves
written for the occasion. In it they por-
trayed a Chanukah festival in the land
of Israel a thousand years hence. The
fourth grade contributed two orchestral
numbers and the first grade dramatized
a Hebrew song. Parents and friends
joined the children in the celebration and
heartily applauded the fine performance.
Chanukah gifts were not forgotten.
Every child in the school made with his
own hands a Chanukah gift for mother,
dad and other members of the family.
Among the gifts were embroidered aprons
and towels, tiles on which they painted
ceremonial designs, leather change purses,
cigarette cases, doilies, etc. The mem-
bers of the graduating class knitted
woolen socks and scarves for the Israeli
soldiers and tiny booties for the Israeli
babies.
Also busy were the members of our
P.T.A. Executive Board. According to
an old established school tradition they
provided a Palestinian made Chanukah
gift for every child in the school. The
gifts ranged from a camel-shaped pen
holder for the younger child to a beau-
tifully illustrated Haggadah bound in
leather or in olive wood for the gradu-
ating class. Thus Chanukah was a
source of joy to all.
Inta-League News
In celebration of Jewish Book
Month, the Inta-League held a very in-
teresting program on November 20th at
which slides related to Jewish Books,
were shown. On November 13th, Pales-
tinian dancing was held. Havdalah ser-
vices were conducted by Mr. Herbert
Kummel, Inta-League Boys' Club Leader,
on November 27th. It was decided after
much discussion, to apply for member-
ship in the Young People's League. On
December 11th a discussion of the Israeli
Constitution was given. Members of the
club who have given news reports on cur-
rent Jewish topics are Stuart Oelbaum,
Ann Joy Levitt, Stanley Green, Ruth
Klinghoffcr and Tom Kraner. Plans for
the near future consist of a gala Chanu-
kah party to be held on December 2 5th,
a basketball game and dance and a theatre
party. A newspaper staff was formed.
This newspaper will cover all club activ-
ities. Paul Kozinn is editor.
Young Fo'ks League
The meeting of the Young Folks
League on Tuesday evening, December
2 8th, will be in the form of a Chanukah
Entertainment and Program befitting the
celebration of Chanukah. Members pre-
senting their 1948 membership cards are
cordially invited.
Junior League
The meeting on Thursday evening Jan-
uary 6th, will feature a Rhumba Lesson
by our own Al Leifer. Members who
are interested in learning the Rhumba are
cordially invited to join the class.
S.O.S. Campaign
Canned food and infant layettes are
urgently needed for displaced persons
overseas. These items may be brought
directly to the Center.
We appeal to the women to volunteer
their services in the collection of such
items to the Campaign Chairman, Mrs.
Ira Gluckstein, PR. 3-5412.
Congratulations
Our heartiest congratulations and best
wishes are extended to:
Miss Eleanor Ginsberg of 1281 Eastern
Parkway who announces her marriage to
Mr. Irving Dubman at the Center on De-
cember 19th.
Mr. and Mrs. Herman Salomon of 374
Eastern Parkway on the marriage of their
daughter, Harriet, to Mr. Morris Liebson
on December 12th.
Mr. and Mrs. Sigmund Schwartz of
615 Empire Boulevard on the marriage
cf their daughter, Diana, to Mr. Harold
M. Jasscm at the Center on December
22nd.
Mr. and Mrs. Ralph SokolofT of 13 5
Eastern Parkway on the marriage of their
daughter, Patricia, to Mr. Emanuel Gantz
on December 19th.
Mr. Morris Weinberg, Honorary Trus-
tee of the Center and publisher of The
Day, on the occasion of his 70th birthday
anniversary.
Bar Mitzvah
A hearty Mazel Tov is extended to
Mr. and Mrs. Milton Manheim, 283
Kingston Avenue on the Bar Mitzvah of
their son, Robert, at the Center this Sab-
bath morning, December 2 5 th.
Best Wishes
Best wishes for a speedy and complete
recovery are extended to Mr. Albert A.
Weinstein of 1475 Carroll Street and to
Dr. Elias N. Rabinowitz, Librarian of the
Center.
Personals
Dr. Charles Windwer has been
elected President and Dr. Harry Block,
Vice-President, of the East New York
Medical Society.
Mrs. Charles Windwer has been elected
President and Mrs. Milton D. Goldfein,
Vice-President, of the Physicians' Wives
Group of the Brooklyn Women's Hos-
pital.
Condolence
Our most heartfelt expressions of sym-
pathy and condolence are extended to
Mrs. Bernard L. Buck of 324 New York
Avenue on the loss of her beloved
brother, Mr. Irving Sussman of East
Orange, N. J.
JO I is
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
CONGREGATIONAL
SINGING GROUP
and
BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER
CHORAL GROUP
under the leadership of
SHOLOM SECUNDA
Members of the Center and their
friends who wish to join one or both
of these groups are asked to please
leave their names at the information
desk.
•
The Choral Group, consisting of men
and women, meets on the 1st, 3rd and
5th Monday evenings and on the 2nd
and tth Wednesday evenings at 8:15
o'clock.
Next meeting — Monday, Jan. 3rd
at 8 p.m.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
19
MEMBERSHIP APPLICATIONS
The following have applied for mem-
bership in the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Ain, Stuart L.
Res. 1 193 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Law Student, same
Single
Proposed by Benjamin Ain
Aronstein, Miss Gloria
Res. 1045 St. Johns Pi.
Proposed by Dr. M. Rappaport,
Mr. E. Rudin
Bonder, Benjamin L.
Res. 760 Montgomery St.
Bus. Insurance, 20 Broad St.
Married
Proposed by Samuel Nicoll,
Samuel H. Goldberg
Brasner, Miss Helen
Res. 658 Crown St.
Proposed by Gladys Fishman,
Toby Drogin
Bresler, Miss Helen
Res. 784 Eastern Pkwy.
Proposed by Milton Bassin,
Nat Gurvitch
Cohen, Monroe
Res. 451 Kingston Ave.
Bus. Jobber
Married
Cutler, Samuel C.
Res. 990 President St.
Bus. C. P. A., 331 Madison Ave.
Married
Proposed by Milton Reiner
Finkel, Miss Marilyn C.
Res. 1621 Union St.
Proposed by Dr. Milo M. Berkowitz,
Marvin Blickstein
Fogelman, Edward A.
Res. 699 Lefferts Ave.
Bus. Traffic Control
Married
Proposed by Allen J. Gilbert
Solomon Ginsburg
Freedman, Miss Irene L.
Res. 620 Vermont St.
Friedman, Miss Evelyn
Res. 1040 Carroll St.
Proposed by Sol Rosen,
. Hy Rosen
Gaslow, Abraham
Res. 1004 Montgomery St.
Bus. Office Furniture, 100 Pine St.
Married
Proposed by Irving L. Green,
George Altman
Glrshowitz, Miss Ruth
Res. 2965 Ocean Pkwy.
Proposed by Pauline Novins,
Claire Geller
Ginsberg, Jacob
Res. 2129— 71st St.
Bus. Manufacturer, 708 Bway.
Married
Gleicher, Leo P.
Res. 934 Schenectady Ave.
Bus. Coat Mfg., 214 \V. 39th St.
Single
Proposed by Alan Kaufman
Goldman, Samuel
Res. 696 Bristol St.
Bus. Wholesale Meats, 67 Ganscvoort
St.
Married
Proposed by Irving L. Green,
George Altman
Goldstein, Miss Esther
Res. 3 53 E. 5 6th St.
Golub, Irving B.
Res. 32 Legion St.
Bus. Govt., 3 5 Ryerson St.
Single
Proposed by Maurice Levin,
Isador Lowenfeld
Hantman, Miss Sophia
Res. 56 Norwood Ave.
Proposed by Milton Reiner,
Rosalie Isaacson
Hinitz, Miss Judith
Res. 784 Eastern Pkwy.
Proposed by Milton Bassin,
Herbert Altman
Holzschlag, Miss Estelle
Res. 6206 Fifth Ave.
Kahn, Joseph
Res. 1422 Lincoln Pi.
Bus. Geologist
Single
Proposed by Joel Sugar,
Joseph H. Aaron
Leventhal, Miss Sylvia
Res. 2 59 Throop Ave.
Proposed by Max Jacobs,
Harold Jacobs
Lubar, Miss Estelle
Res. 680 E. 48th St.
Proposed by Samuel Nicoll
Lurye, Arthur A.
Res. 590 Lafayette Ave.
Bus. Candy Store, 292 Nostrand Ave.
Single
Maginot, Geoffrey
Res. 631 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Govt.
Married
Marker, Miss Frances
Res. 217 Hart St.
Proposed by Harold Jacobs,
Max Jacobs
Miller, Lawrence
Res. 1619 Lincoln PI.
Bus. Army Surplus, 221 Division St.
Single
Proposed by George Shulruf,
Morris Hecht
Moses, Miss Bertha
Res. 314 Powell St.
Proposed by Henry L. Coyta,
Ben R. Berke
Namzoff, Aaron L.
Res. 439 Remsen Ave.
Bus. Blind Mfg., 4816 — 16th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Irving L. Green,
George Altman
Oberter, Miss Esther
Res. 1870 Pitkin Ave.
Proposed by Mr. S. Levenson,
Ben R. Berke
Pagowitz, Miss Shirley
Res. 1082 Eastern Pkwy.
Plck, Harold
Res. 198 5 Ocean Ave.
Bus. Bus. Machines, 444 Fourth Ave.
Married
Proposed by Mr. and Mrs. Isador
Lowenfeld
Pick, Dr. Sidney J.
Res. 1299 Ocean Ave.
Bus. M.D.
Married
Proposed by Mr. and Mrs. Isador
Lowenfeld
Pfstreich, Murray
Res. 8 52 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Coat Mfg., 4112— 1st Ave.
Single
Proposed by Rita Kotkes
ROSFNBERG, IsRAEL
Res. 961 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Bakery, 311 Rogers Ave.
Married
Proposed by Isador Lowenfeld
Rouchwager, Sheldon
Res. 135 Clarkson Ave.
Bus. Women's Wear, 1441 Bway.
Single
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
20
Proposed by Alan Kaufman
Scherr, Miss Gladys
Res. 39 Legion St.
Schreer, William
Res. 1966— 72nd St.
Bus. Iron and Steel, 5 54 Metropolitan
Ave.
Married
Proposed by Sol Palley,
Nat Bernhard
Schiffer, Miss Irene
Res. 1232 Carroll St.
Schwartz, Miss Gloria
Res. 83 E. 51st St.
Proposed by Hy Rosen,
Ben R. Burke
Schwartz, Miss Ruth
Res. 12 54 Union St.
Proposed by Mrs. Akiba Margolin,
Natalie Levine
Tuchfeld, Murray
Res. 395 Ocean Ave.
Bus. Dresses, 5 30 — 7th Ave.
Married
Proposed by Mitchell Siegel,
Albert Glickman
TURKELTAUB, MlSS MlLDRED
Res. 175 8 Sterling PI.
Proposed by Al Rosoff
Weisbein, Stanley
Res. 15 20 Carroll St.
Bus. Scarfs, 12 W. 37th St.
Single
Wrubel, Miss Edna
Res. 771 Hopkinson Ave.
Zamore, Miss Harriet
Res. 2 59 Legion St.
Proposed by Al Rosoff
Additional Applications
Abrams, Miss Elaine
Res. 543 Autumn Ave.
Proposed by Joan Abrahams,
Louis Weber
Bicker, Henry
Res. 250 Adelphi St.
Bus. Teacher, Bklyn. Tech. H. S.
Single
Proposed by Joan Abrahams,
Joe Kahn
Chasin, Jack
Res. 296 E. 92nd St.
Proposed by Hy Rosen,
Ben R. Berke
Efirenberg, Miss Laura Constance
Res. 1073 Sutter Ave.
Proposed by Joan Abraham,
Louis Weber
Gerchick, Abe
Res. 436 Eastern Pkwy.
Bus. Men's Wear, 5 5 E. 8th St.
Married
Proposed by Jerome J. Weiner,
Jos. Shuter
Liebowitz, Jack
Res. 166-05— 89th Ave.
Single
Proposed by Ben R. Berke,
David Gold
Reckson, Miss Bette
Res. 877 Empire Blvd.
Proposed by Sol and Hy Rosen
Schneider, Albert N.
Res. 25 0 Montgomery St.
Bus. Brushes, 905 Nostrand Ave.
Married
Proposed by Harry L. Berter,
Harry Sperling
THE ISRAELI CONSTITUTION
[Continued from page 8]
of cooperative effort." Article 22 pro-
vides that "everyone has the right to
work. The State of Israel shall endeavor
to insure to all its citizens without di-
stinction a decent standard of living and
a fair and equal opportunity of earning
a livelihood." These provisions have been
characterized in the public press of
America as "socialistic." The reception
of the Constitution in this respect has in
turn been colored by the individual com-
mentator's conception of socialism and
his attitude toward it.
We do not believe that there can be
any reasonable adverse criticism of these
broad principles. In the last analysis they
are not laws at all. They are guideposts
along the road of future law-making.
How they will be implemented will de-
pend on the many factors of public
wealth, peace or war, budgetary necessi-
ties, internal and even external relations
and other considerations not now deter-
minable. It is good to know, however,
that the State of Israel begins its career
with a determination to realize in the ac-
tual living of its citizens the principles
of decent and dignified Jewish life for
which the Republic was founded. The
Jews may very well paraphrase a famous
challenge in history and say to their
critics: "If this be socialism, then make
the most of it." We have long passed
the stage in history where that is a
stigma. Israel is a State which has been
born in travail and war, following upon
the greatest cataclysm in its or any other
people's history. In some matters it has
no time to experiment, and is wise in its
acceptance of the experiments of others.
The freedom and security of the citizen
are the paramount considerations of gov-
ernment, and where security can be had
without the sacrifice of freedom, security
ranks on a par with freedom.
•
What has been written here by way of
criticism has, nevertheless, been written
with love and pride. It is a beautiful
occasion for a shehechiyanu that we Jews
may in our day and at long last see real-
ized the fact of a State of Israel and its
Constitution. Years ago, Prime Minister
Gladstone said of the American Consti-
tution that it is "the most wonderful
work ever struck off at a given time by
the brain and purpose of man." In some
such fashion future historians, when re-
viewing the miracle of an Israeli State and
Constitution following so closely upon
the debacle of Jewish rights in many
countries may be led to say of the Israeli
Constitution that despite any defects it
may now appear to have, it is neverthe-
less, in the long view of history, a re-
markably important and forward-looking
contribution to the science of government
and the history of mankind.
JEWS OF YEMEN
[Continued from page 9]
Another walled town that has a Jewish
quarter is Haz. Once the province of
Eastern Khaulan possessed a flourishing
Jewish city, now long abandoned. Some
fifty years ago an English artist, W. B.
Harris, traveling in the Yemen, reached
the capital, Sanaa, which, with an esti-
mated population of 5 0,000, had about
20,000 Jews. To the west of the city
lay Qa'al Yahud, the Jewish quarter, en-
closed by a wall. The Jews lived in a
ghetto, in low houses between narrow
lanes. Many had shops in the bazaars
and carried on various trades in the Arab
city, but at nightfall they returned to
their medieval quarters. They had more
than twenty synagogues, and enough
schools to care for about seven hundred
boys. During services, the boys sit on
shelves built against the walls. The
women are picturesquely garbed. They
wear a hood, with silver embroidery and
close-fitting trousers. In public, they
cover themselves with a large shawl, but
do not veil the face.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
21
g ISTERHOOD!
AGING
THE new State of Israel is now one year
old.
The rebirth of Israel is a twentieth cen-
tury miracle. It has been an amazing
year since November 29, 1947, when the
United Nations, in voting for Partition,
decreed that Israel must rise again as a
sovereign nation. Am Isroel Chat! —
Israel lives again, reborn after 1800 years
of persecution, and Jews the world over
can now come home to Eretz Israel.
Sisterhood shares alike with every Jew
in the Diaspora the joy of achievement,
the proud ecstasy of a national home, a
haven for those who escaped the Nazi
holocaust. Our zeal, our hopes, our ef-
forts were duly rewarded by God, who
favors the righteous. All hail to the new
State of Israel, may she grow from
strength to strength!
— Sarah Klinghoffer,
President.
General Meeting:
Our general meeting on November
22nd was appropriately opened with a
prayer read by Dora Gaba, ushering in
the Thanksgiving holiday. In the ab-
sence of our President, Sarah Klinghoffer,
who was attending the Atlantic City
Convention of Women's League, Vice-
President Levine presided. She proceeded
with the order of business which included
an appeal to members to help serve the
Incurables at the Hospital for Chronic
Diseases at the annual Chanukah party
given by Sisterhood.
A very entertaining and stimulating
program, introduced by Sarah Epstein,
included a short movie and talk on the
vital work of the Federation of Jewish
Philanthropies, a brief analysis of the cur-
rent Jewish scene by our own Mrs.
Bertha Zirn, and, for a lyric diversion,
Jane Miller, mezzo-soprano, and Neal
Van Rees, pianist, presented Menotti's
"The Medium" and "The Telephone," in
operalogue form. Incidentally, our idea
of serving refreshments before the meet-
ing was a huge success.
Board Meeting Report:
Reservations may still be made for the
Women's League Chanukah Luncheon,
on Monday, December 27th, at the Hotel
Commodore.
The Federation of Jewish Women's
Organizations urges all those who have
not yet made their reservations for the
Annual Convention and Luncheon pro-
gram to be held at the Waldorf-Astoria,
on Wednesday, January 12th, to do so.
The guest speaker will be the publisher
of The Star, Bartley Crum.
Funds Vere voted Girl Scout Troop
2-159, for expenses entailed in making
stuffed toys for the children in Kings
County Hospital. A similar allocation
was made toward the Chanukah party
tendered to the Llome for Incurables.
Federation Chairman Lillie Levy, Jr.,
reported an overwhelming response on
the part of our members, reminding those
who had not yet pledged to make their
contributions. A most charming hostess
was Ruth Bernhardt at a Dessert Tea
which she gave at her home in behalf of
the Federation drive. The response of
her guests was exceedingly generous.
■£r
Contributions for the Mother-Daughter
Luncheon continue to come in.
The Board voted to send a message of
congratulations to Young Israel of East-
ern Parkway on the occasion of their
twenty-fifth anniversary.
■2r
SOS is making tremendous strides.
Our women are collecting such large
quantities of canned food and layettes
that we are quite sure that the Center
will again lead the country in its aid to
the JDC for displaced survivors overseas.
However, our quota has not yet been
reached and we trust that our members
will continue their excellent efforts.
SOS contributions include a complete
layette donated by Mrs. S. Katz, and
other items by Mesdames Louis Simon,
Kate Salit, Lil Lowenfeld and D. Belfer.
*
Jewish Book Month will be observed
with an attractive display at Sisterhood's
December meeting. Make it your aim to
read a Jewish book and to buy a Jewish
book — they make excellent Chanukah
gifts.
Brooklyn Jewish Community Council
aims to have a Jewish Encyclopedia do-
nated to every Brooklyn High School for
reference work in the libraries. It was
noted, with great pride, that because of
the Council's efforts in that direction,
very few incidents of anti-Semitism had
been reported in the borough. Members
are advised that religious ceremonial ob-
jects may be viewed at the Main Library,
Eastern Parkway and Flatbush Avenue.
Torah Fund Luncheon: Chairman Bea
Schaeffer announced that our function
this year would be held on March 9, 1949.
Plans are now being formulated to assure
us a most delightful and lucrative after-
noon. The proceeds provide scholarships
for student rabbis at the Jewish Theo-
logical Seminary. Watch this department
for further details.
Cheer Fund Donor List:
In memory of her father, Mrs. S.
Klinghoffer; in memory of S. Kling-
hoffer's father, Mr. and Mrs. I. Lowen-
feld; in memory of S. Klinghoffer 's
father, Mr. and Mrs. Jos. Levy, Jr.; in
memory of S. Klinghoffer's father, Mr.
and Mrs. M. Bernhardt; in memory of
S. Klinghoffer's father, Mr. and Mrs. I.
Kaplan; in memory of S. Klinghoffer's
father, Mr. and Mrs. I. Gluckstein; in
memory of S. Klinghoffer's father, Mr.
and Mrs. H. Rachmil; in memory of S.
Klinghoffer's father, Mr. and Mrs. J.
Heimowitz; in memory of S. Kling-
hoffer's father, Mr. and Mrs. S. Rey; in
honor of son's new dental office, Mrs. D.
Green.
The following women have donated
Torah Covers (perochot) for our syna-
gogue: Mesdames Dora Brenner, D. Good-
stein, Sarah Klinghoffer, Mildred Levine
and Lillie Lowenfeld.
Sisterhood extends congratulations to
Mr. Isidor Fine, past President of the
Center, on his seventieth birthday, and
prays that his cheerful presence will be
with us for many, many years to come.
Women and (Little Women )
In the Neivs:
Shirley Gluckstein was elected to the
National Board of the Joint Distribution
Committee in recognition of her out-
standing efforts on behalf of SOS.
■A-
Miss Joyce Bernhardt was appointed
Borough-wide Fund-Raising Chairman of
Senior Young Judea.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
22
IN THE HEBREW SCHOOL
Miss Ruth Klinghoffer was appointed
Associate Editor of the Inta-League news-
paper.
-it
A sincere vote of thanks is due Lillie
Levy, chairman of our Federation drive,
for her untiring work in this direction.
Almost single-handed, except for the aid
of little sister, Fan Jackson, she rallied
tremendous support to the cause and was
instrumental in turning over to the fund
large sums of money. Thank you, Lillie.
You know how "blessed it is to give (ser-
vice) and receive ($$$)!"
Calendar of Coming Events:
December 27 — Women's League Chanu-
kah Luncheon.
January 1 — Kiddush to the Junior Con-
gregation by Mr. and Mrs. Henry
Gross, in honor of their thirty-fifth
wedding anniversary. Encourage your
children to come to the synagogue on
this and every Sabbath.
January 10 — Sisterhood Board meeting at
1:00 p.m.
January 12 — Federation of Jewish
Women's Organization Luncheon.
January 17 — General membership meet-
ing at 1:00 p.m.
Suggestion Box:
We continue to solicit your suggestions
and recommendations toward the better-
ment of this page, as well as any im-
provements you may desire in our meet-
ings. This is your letterbox. Write or
phone us your ideas.
Invitation:
Members wishing to serve on any com-
mittee will please call our Recording Sec-
retary, Bea Shaeffer, PResident 3-2744.
Sponsors may still reserve a Kiddush
for the Junior Congregation for Febru-
ary, March or April.
Young Married Group
Being Organized
The Brooklyn Jewish Center is very
happy to announce that a new affiliate,
the Young Married Group, is in the proc-
ess of being organized at our Center.
This group will be open to all young
married members and will participate in
a program of social and cultural activ-
ities. A very interesting and entertain-
ing program has been arranged for the
opening meeting which will take place on
Thursday evening, January 13th, at 8:30
o'clock. Young married members who
are interested in joining this newly organ-
ized group notify Rabbi Saltzman.
AN ACCOUNT of our Simchat Torah
celebration which appeared in the
"Jewish Day" is of special interest. Rabbi
Nisan Gordon who conducts a weekly
column called "In the Orthodox Jewish
World" wrote, in part, as follows:
"The weather on the 8 th day of
Sukkot, as you may recall, was in
no sense 'Yomtovdig.' The skies
were cloudy and a slight rain fell,
but on Eastern Parkway, hundreds
of Jewish children of various ages
made their way toward the Brook-
lyn Jewish Center. Some were alone,
others accompanied by their parents,
but all were dressed in holiday ap-
parel and were in joyous spirits. The
large auditorium in the Brooklyn
Jewish Center was crowded with
hundreds of students and parents.
Several mothers distributed Ameri-
can and Jewish flags to the children,
while their parents sat alongside,
enjoying 'nacbas.* The program be-
gan with the American and Hebrew
anthems, followed by appropriate
recitations and songs led by Mr.
Secunda.
"The climax of the program was
the Hakafot procession which the
students carried out in a most im-
pressive fashion. Several of the
older boys marched with Sefer
Torahs in tune to the traditional
Hakafot melodies. They were fol-
lowed in the procession by many
boys and girls waving their flags. I
was deeply impressed by all that I
saw." #
The Hebrew School Chanukah celebra-
tion will take place on Sunday, Decem-
ber 26, 1948, in the auditorium. The
program will feature a Chanukah play by
the Hebrew Dramatic Club under the di-
rection of Mrs. E. Zusman, Palestinian
songs and dances and a Chanukah magi-
cian.
A second performance for the religious
school will be held on Sunday, January
2, 1949. Guests are cordially invited to
attend.
ft
Recent assemblies featured a Jewish
Music quiz emphasizing Palestinian and
synagogue melodies, a story about refu-
gees in Israel by Mr. Irvin Rubin, a
Thanksgiving playlet by the Hebrew
Dramatic Club and a story about Chelm
by Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes.
ft
A book by Mr. George Epstein, mem-
ber of the Hebrew School faculty, and
Mr. Mordecai Zeldner has just been pub-
lished by the Hebrew Publishing Com-
pany. The book called "Modern Hebrew
Literature" includes Hebrew selections
from Bialik, Peretz, Tchernichovsky and
other noted modern authors.
The P.T.A. held a most impressive
Meet the Faculty evening on Thursday,
December 2, 1948. Mrs. J. Kushner,
president of the P.T.A., presided. Rabbi
Israel H. Levinthal installed the officers.
Rabbi Mordecai H. Lewittes then in-
troduced all members of the Hebrew and
Religious school faculties. Mrs. Evelyn
Zusman, Mr. George Epstein and Mr.
Irvin Rubin gave brief talks.
ft
The following G. O. officers were
elected by the Hebrew school:
President — Conrad Lefkowitz.
Vice-President — Paul Kushner.
Treasurer — Larry Levy.
Secretary — Allan Gottdenker.
Editor — Helen Wein.
Assistant Editor — Helene Wolfe.
In the religious school, these students
were elected to office:
President — Sheila Weinstein.
Vice-President — Ruth Bakstansky.
Secretary — Rhoda Friedman.
Treasurer — Barbara Frankel.
ft
Sabbath Services
Friday evening services at 4:15.
Kindling of candles at 4:14 p.m.
Sabbath services, Parsha "Vayeshet" —
Genesis 37.1-40.23, Prophets-Amos 2.6-
3.8, will commence at 8:45 a.m.
Mincha services at 4:15.
Rabbi Saltzman will preach on the
weekly portion of the law.
Cantor Sauler will officiate assisted by
the Congregational Singing Group under
the leadership of Mr. Sholom Secunda.
Mr. Abelson will continue his lecture
in Yiddish this Saturday afternoon at
3:30.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
23
ANNUAL MEETING — JANUARY 27th
In accordance with the requirements of Section 5, Article X of the Con
stitution and By-Laws of the Brooklyn Jewish Center, notice is hereby given that
the Annual Meeting of the Center will be held on Thursday evening, January
27, 1949, at 8:15 o'clock.
Election and installation of officers, members of the Board of Trustees and
Governing Board will take place.
A detailed report of the past year's activities will be rendered.
Frank Schaeffer, Secretary.
List of members pieced in nomination as officers, members of the Board of Trustees
and Governing Board of the Brooklyn Jewish Center:
Officers
President Emanuel Greenberg 2nd Vice-President Hyman Aaron
1st Vice-President Dr. Moses Spatt Treasurer David Goodstein
Secretary Frank Schaeffer
lsidor Fine
Jacob A. Fortunoff
Aaron, Bernard J.
Abelov, Saul S.
Albert, Louis
Beldock, George
Belfer, Rubin
Benjamin, A. David
Bernhardt, Mrs. M.
Bernstein, Alex
Blacher, Chas.
Brenner, Mrs. Ph.
Burros, Elias
Cohen, Dr. Irv. L.
Cooper, Harry
Daum, Louis
Dilbert, Chas.
Doner, Jacob S.
Fine, Chas.
Fine, Jesse J.
Finkelstein, Dr. R.
Frieman, Reuben
Ginsburg, Abraham
Gluckstein, Ira I.
Gold, David
Goldberg, Max
Rubin Belfer
Elias Burros
Dr. Irving L. Cohen
Members of the Board of Trustees
(For a term of three years, 1949, 1950, 195
Judge Emanuel Greenberg
Jacob L. Holtzmann
Members of the Governing Board
Goldberg Saml. H. Levenson, Dr. S. M.
Goldsmith, Herman Leventhal, Julius
Goldstein, Joseph Levine, Morris B.
Goldstein, Nathaniel Levine, Mrs. M. B.
Gottlieb, Aaron Levy, Mrs. Margaret
Gottlieb, Irv. J. Lowenf eld, Isador
Gottlieb, lsidor Lowenfeld, Mrs. I.
Greenblatt, Samuel
Greene, Harry Markoff , Dr. S. T.
Greenfield, Louis Markowe, Benj.
Gribetz, Louis J. Martz, Benj.
Gross, Henry H. Melker, Abr. R.
Meyer, Lawrence
Halperin, Louis Miller, Dr. Solomon
Halpern, David Mitrani, Solomon
Heimowitz, Jos.
Horowitz, Irv. S.
Horowitz, Mrs. Jos.
Jacobs, Gerald
Jaffe, Benj.
Joley, Albert
Neinken, Morris
Palevsky, Philip
Parnes, Louis
Pomerantz, S. L.
Kamenetzky, Saml. Racn ™il, Hyman
Kaminsky, David B. R^man, Jos.
Karlin, Irv. P. Rivkin, Louis
Kauf mann, Leo Rosen, Meyer A.
Klinghoffer, Morton Robbins, Samuel
Klinghoffer, Mrs. M. Rubin, Irvin I.
Nominating Committee
Harry Blickstein, Chairman
Max Herzfeld
Samuel Lemberg
I)
Morris Miller
Nathan D. Shapiro
Safier, Chas.
Schiff , Lawrence
Schneider, S. A.
Schrier, Isaac
Schwartz, Nathan T.
Siegel, fm. I.
Siegmeister, Isaac
Silberberg, I.
Simon, Louis
Spiegel, David
Stark, Abe
Stark, Joseph
Stark, Samuel
Stelzer, Abr. J.
Sterman, Jack
Turner, Herbert
Weinstein, A. A.
Weinstock, Louis
Wender, M. D.
Wiener, Mrs. I.
Wisner, Benj. H.
Zeitz, Harry
Zimmerman, Mort.
Zirn, Abr. H.
Zucker, Harry
Zwerdling, Tobias
Solomon Mitrani
Samuel Robbins
Jack Sterman
PRAYERS FOR LIGHTING
CHANUKAH CANDLES
LIGHT the first candle Sunday evening,
December 26th, 1948.
One of the household kindles the lights
with the Shammes light; one on the first
evening, two on the second, etc., until
on the eighth night of Chanukah eight
candles are lit. As the lights are lit, the
following blessings are sung:
1 . Boruch atoh A-do-noy E-lo-he-nu Me-
lech ho-o-lom, Asher kid-d'sho-nu
b'mits-vo-sov v'tsi-vonu L'had-lik ner
shal Cha-nu-kah.
Blessed art Thou, O Lord our God,
Ruler of the Universe, who has sanc-
tified us by Thy commandments and
commanded us to kindle the light of
Chanukah.
2. Boruch atoh A-do-noy E-lo-he-nu Me-
lech ho-o-lom She-o-soh nis-sim la-
avo-se-nu bay-yomim ho-haim baz-
z'man ha-zeh.
Blessed art Thou, O Lord our God,
Ruler of the Universe, who wrought-
est miracles for our fathers in days of
old, at this season.
3. The following is said only on the first
evening:
Boruch atoh A-do-noy, E-lo-he-nu Me-
lech ho-o-lom She-hech'yo-nu, v'k-
y'mo-nu v'hig-gi-o-nu la-z'man haz-
zeh.
Blessed are Thou, O Lord our God,
Ruler of the Universe, who has kept
us in life and has preserved us, and
enabled us to reach this season.
For the Chanukah
Gift
This present will be appreciated
by Jew or N on- Jew:
"Judaism — An Analysis
and An Interpretation"
By RABBI LEVINTHAL
Ludwig Lewisohn says:
"This volume seems to me the
best and most lucid brief and
popular exposition of Judaism
that I know in any language."
Other book's by Dr. Levinthal:
"Steering or Drifting — Which?"
"A New World Is Born"
Copies at $2.50 each may
be secured or ordered at the
Center office.
Brooklyn Jewish Center Review
RIVERSIDE
MEMORIAL CHAPEL
Fifty Years of Fine Funeral Service
WITHIN THE REACH OF ALL
76th STREET & AMSTERDAM AVENUE
ENDICOTT 2-6600
Far Roclcaway, L. I. Miami Beach, Florida
1250 CENTRAL AVENUE 1236 WASHINGTON AVENUE
FAr Roclcaway 7-7100 Miami 5-7777
Pending the opening of our Brooklyn Funeral Home at Park Circle, we have arranged to
serve your Community. We have at our disposal Chapel facilities in all parts of Brooklyn
CHARLES ROSENTHAL, Director
FLOWERS • WEDDING DECORATIONS
HYMAN SPITZ, Inc.
1685 Pitkin Avenue, Brooklyn, Ni Y.
Dickens 2-4000 OUR ONLY STORE
• FRUIT BASKETS •
VILLA CLAIR
PALM BEACH, FLORIDA
Moderate in Size — Home-Like Atmosphere
Dietary Laws — Excellent Cuisine
Inquire
LOUIS COHN
223 Seminole Avenue Palm Beach, Florida
{One Block from the Ocean)
THE BROOKLYN JEWISH CENTER REVIEW
667 Eastern Parkway, Brooklyn 13, N. Y.
Return Postage Guaranteed
Sec. 562, P. L. & R.
Paid
Brooklyn, N. Y.
U.S. POSTAGE
Permit No. 1622